AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was a candidate at the February 1978 Maharashtra State Legislative Assembly election from Barsi Constituency. Nominations were required by 1-2-1978 and the petitioner filed his nomination on that date. Under Section 34(1)(b) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, the deposit for a legislative assembly candidate was Rs. 250, but members of Scheduled Castes/Tribes were required to deposit Rs. 125. The petitioner deposited Rs. 125 claiming to belong to a Scheduled Caste (Khatik community) and relied on a Taluka Magistrate's certificate dated 23-3-1968 describing his caste as "Hindu Dhangar." On scrutiny (2-2-1978) the Returning Officer (Respondent No. 2) rejected the petitioner's nomination for failure to prove Scheduled Caste status and for not depositing Rs. 250. The petitioner then filed the present election petition seeking, among other reliefs, a declaration that the returned candidate (Respondent No. 1)'s election was void.

Respondent No. 1 raised preliminary objections under Section 81 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. By consent, certain preliminary issues (primarily Issues Nos. 1 and 1-A, and also Issues Nos. 2 and 3 though the latter two were not pressed) were tried first. The petition was filed on 13-4-1978 (the last date for filing). At presentation the Master and Assistant Prothonotary endorsed that the petition lacked four copies required by Section 81(3) (the High Court's Election Rules required two copies per respondent, hence four copies for two respondents). The petitioner later produced evidence that the required attested copies had been put into the Board Department on 13-4-1978 by the Advocate's clerk and were handed over to the Master and Assistant Prothonotary on 14-4-1978 when objections were being removed. The court examined the facts and evidence on the preliminary issues and made findings on compliance with Section 81(3) and related procedural rules.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petition is liable to be dismissed for non-compliance with the provisions of Section 81(3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, as asserted in Para 1(a) of the written statement? (Issue No. 1)
  2. Whether the High Court Rules can confer on the Prothonotary and Senior Master or the Master and Assistant Prothonotary any power to permit the petitioner to correct or remove defects under S. 81(3) or Section 83 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 beyond the period of limitation? (Issue No. 1-A)
  3. Whether the petition is signed in the manner laid down in the Code of Civil Procedure? If not, whether the same is liable to be dismissed for non-compliance with Section 83(1)(c) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951? (Issue No. 2) — this issue was not pressed by Respondent No. 1.
  4. Whether the annexure to the petition is signed and verified in the manner laid down in the Code of Civil Procedure? If not, whether the petition is liable to be dismissed for non-compliance with Section 83(2) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951? (Issue No. 3) — this issue was not pressed by Respondent No. 1.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petition was presented on the last permissible date (13-4-1978) to an officer appointed for presenting election petitions (the Master and Assistant Prothonotary).
  • Although the petition at the time of presentation lacked the requisite number of attested copies, those copies were placed in the Board Department on the same day (13-4-1978) by the Advocate's clerk (Acharya), and were thereafter handed over to the Master and Assistant Prothonotary on 14-4-1978 when objections were being removed. This, the petitioner argued, amounts to substantial compliance with Section 81(3).
  • Counsel for the petitioner (Mr. Paranjpe) relied on Supreme Court authorities that allowed election petitions to stand where there was substantial compliance with Section 81(3) (i.e., where procedural defects did not frustrate the statutory purpose of prompt service and early hearing).

Respondent No. 1's Arguments

  • The petition was not accompanied by the requisite attested copies at the time of presentation, contrary to the mandatory language of Section 81(3). Under Section 86 the court must dismiss petitions not complying with Section 81.
  • Copies placed in the Board Department do not constitute presentation to the High Court under Section 81(3), because the Board Department is not the designated office for presenting election petitions and filing in the wrong department can cause delay; the required copies must accompany the petition at presentation to the proper officer.
  • Even if copies were given subsequently on the same day or later, that would be non-compliance with Section 81(3) unless they were provided within the period of limitation and to the proper officer; the petitioner failed to comply within the period of limitation.
  • The respondent relied on the point that certain earlier decisions had held that spare copies filed beyond the period of limitation were not cured by subsequent filing; hence the petition should be dismissed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Murarka Radhey Shyam Ram Kumar v. Roop Singh Rathore, AIR 1964 SC 1545 Establishes that total non-compliance with Section 81 (inter alia) requires dismissal, but where there is substantial compliance the petition should not be dismissed. The court cited this case to frame the threshold between total non-compliance and substantial compliance when deciding whether the petition must be dismissed under Section 86.
Dr. Anup Singh v. Shri Abdul Ghani, 1965 SC 815 Considered whether copies of an election petition were true copies properly attested and held there can be substantial compliance with Section 81(3). The court relied on this decision to support the principle that substantial compliance with the attestation requirement may prevent dismissal of a petition.
Satya Narain v. Dhuja Ram, (1974) 4 SCC 237 : AIR 1974 SC 1185 Explains the purpose of Section 81(3): copies for all respondents enable quick despatch of notices so that there is no delay in the initial stage of trial. The court used this precedent to analyse the public policy underlying Section 81(3) and to conclude that filing copies in the wrong department frustrates the purpose of prompt service and may not amount to substantial compliance.
M. Kamalam v. Dr V.A. Syed Mohammed, (1978) 2 SCC 659 : AIR 1978 SC 840 Affirms considerations regarding substantial compliance with Section 81(3) in relation to attested copies. The court cited it as another authority showing that substantial compliance can be sufficient in some factual situations; used in the aggregate with other precedents to assess the present facts.
Shiv Chand v. Ujagar Singh, (1978) 4 SCC 152 : AIR 1978 SC 1583 Expresses the view (Krishna Iyer, J.) that hyper-technicality must not defeat public policy of investigation into the merits of an election petition when the statute's public policy is fulfilled. The court invoked these observations to balance procedural strictness against the public policy of permitting adjudication on the merits, and then to test whether the petitioner's conduct satisfied the statutory purpose of Section 81(3).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded stepwise and focused on the statutory requirement and its underlying purpose:

  1. Statutory requirement and purpose: Section 81(3) requires that every election petition be accompanied by as many attested copies as there are respondents, and the court highlighted the purpose explained in precedents — to enable prompt issuance of notices and avoid delay at the initial stage of trial.
  2. Presentation to proper officer: The court emphasized that "presented to the High Court" under Section 81 must mean presentation to the officer appointed for election petitions (the Prothonotary and Senior Master or an officer appointed by him). Presentation before other officers or merely leaving papers in another department does not satisfy the statutory requirement.
  3. Facts on evidence: The petition was presented on 13-4-1978 (last filing date) but lacked the requisite attested copies when presented to the Master and Assistant Prothonotary. The Advocate's clerk (Acharya) later placed four attested copies in a bundle in the Board Department on 13-4-1978; these copies were produced to the Master and Assistant Prothonotary on 14-4-1978. Testimony about these events came from the petitioner, his friend Handure, the clerk Acharya, the Advocate, the Master and Assistant Prothonotary, and the Board Department clerk. The Master and the Board clerk could not recollect the events beyond the endorsement on the petition docket; the court accepted parts of Handure's and Acharya's testimony but rejected the claimed directive by the Master authorizing deposit of copies in the Board Department.
  4. Legal effect of filing in wrong department: The court found that merely placing copies in the Board Department did not amount to presentation of the petition with requisite copies to the High Court under Section 81(3). The Board Department was not the designated department for presentation of election petitions, and such misplacement can defeat the purpose of prompt service and early hearing.
  5. Timing and limitation: Even where copies are furnished shortly after presentation, compliance must be within the statutory period of limitation. The petitioner's copies were not actually presented to the designated officer until after the period of limitation expired; therefore the mandatory dismissal provision (Section 86) applied.
  6. Balance between technicality and public policy: The court acknowledged precedents cautioning against hyper-technical rulings when the statute's public policy is fulfilled, and it considered whether the petitioner's conduct nevertheless achieved the statutory purpose. The court concluded it did not—because the copies were not filed with the officer responsible for presentation within the limitation period—and therefore the petition could not be saved as a case of substantial compliance.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The election petition is dismissed.

Implications and direct consequences as stated by the court:

  • The court answered Issue No. 1 in the affirmative (i.e., the petition was liable to be dismissed for non-compliance with Section 81(3)) and Issue No. 1-A in the negative (i.e., the High Court Rules cannot permit correction of S.81(3) non-compliance beyond the limitation period in the circumstances described).
  • The petitioner was ordered to pay costs to Respondent No. 1, quantified at Rs. 750 (taking into account the petitioner's poverty). The Prothonotary and Senior Master was given liberty to allow Respondent No. 1 to withdraw Rs. 750 from the petitioner's security deposit; the petitioner was given liberty to withdraw any remaining balance after that payment.
  • There was no order as to costs in favour of Respondent No. 2 because Respondent No. 2 had submitted to the court's orders on the preliminary issues.
  • The Prothonotary and Senior Master was directed to intimate the substance of the decision to the Election Commission and to the Speaker, Maharashtra Legislative Assembly, and to send a copy of the decision to the Election Commission as provided under Section 103 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951.
  • Administrative directions: the Prothonotary and Senior Master was to act on certified Minutes and the petitioner's advocate undertook to draw up the order within eight weeks.

Broader legal implications: The opinion applies existing Supreme Court authorities regarding substantial compliance and the purpose of Section 81(3), but the court's decision turns on the facts that the required copies were not presented to the designated officer within the statutory period. The opinion does not purport to establish a new precedent beyond applying those principles to the facts before it.

    Ashok Shankar Gholap v. Krishnarao H. Deshmukh And Another

    1. The petitioner in this election petition was a candidate for the election to the Maharashtra State Legislative Assembly from Barsi Constituency. The election was to be held in the month of Feb. 1978. The nominations were required to be filed by the candidates on or before 1-2-1978. Accordingly the Petitioner filed his nomination paper on 1-2-1978. Under S. 34(1)(b) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, in the case of an election to the Legislative Assembly a candidate is required to deposit a sum of Rs. 250/-. However, if the candidate is a member of a Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe, he is required to deposit a sum of Rs. 125/- only. The petitioner deposited the sum of Rs. 125/- on the ground that he belonged to a Scheduled Caste, namely Khatik community. When the nomination papers were scrutinised on 2-2-1978 the nomination of the petitioner was rejected by the Returning Officer, Barsi Constituency, who is the Respondent No. 2 herein, on the ground that the petitioner had not proved that he belonged to a Scheduled Caste and that as he had not deposited Rs. 250/- his nomination paper was bad. It is the petitioner's case that the people of Khatik community describe themselves as ‘Hindu Dhangar’ and that he had produced a Certificate dated 23-3-1968 signed by the Taluka Magistrate, Barsi in which the petitioner's caste was described as ‘Hindu Dhangar’. According to the petitioner, on the basis of this Certificate his nomination paper should have been accepted by the Respondent No. 2-He has, therefore, filed the present election petition, inter alia, for a declaration that the election of the returned candidate the Respondent No. 1 is void and should be set aside.

    2. In reply the Respondent No. 1 has, inter alia, raised certain preliminary issues, which by consent of the parties are being tried as preliminary issues. These issues relate to the presentation of petition as required under Section 81 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. These issues are Issues Nos. 1 and 1-A, which are as follows:

    (1) Whether the petition is liable to be dismissed for non-compliance with provisions of Section 81(3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 as stated in Para 1 (a) of the written statement?

    (1-A) Whether the High Court Rules can confer on the Prothonotary and Senior Master or the Master and Assistant Prothonotary any power to permit the petitioner to correct or remove defects under S. 81(3) or Section 83 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 beyond the period of limitation?

    The Respondent No. 1 had also raised two other preliminary issues being Issues Nos. 2 and 3 which are as follows:

    (2) Whether the petition is signed in the manner laid down in the Code of Civil Procedure? If not, whether the same is liable to be dismissed for non-compliance with the provisions of S. 83(1)(c) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951?

    (3) Whether the annexure to the petition is signed and verified in the manner laid down in the Code of Civil Procedure? If not, whether the petition is liable to be dismissed for non-compliance with S. 83

    (2) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951?

    These two issues are however not pressed by the Respondent No. 1.

    3. The last date for presenting an election petition in connection with the election in question was admittedly 13th Apr. 1978. The present petition was presented on 13-4-1978. There is an endorsement dated 14-4-1978 at the back of the petition made by the Master and Assistant Prothonotary, who is an Officer authorised under the Election Rules framed by this High Court for accepting election petitions. According to this endorsement the petition was not accompanied by four copies of the election petition. This objection appears to have been complied with on 14-4-1978, because there is an endorsement of the petitioner's Advocate to that effect on the back of the petition immediately after the endorsement of the Master and Assistant Prothonotary, Section 81, Sub-sec. (3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 is as follows:

    “Every election petition shall be accompanied by as many copies thereof as there are respondents mentioned in the petition and every such copy shall be attested by the petitioner under his own signature to be a true copy of the Petition. Under Section 86 of the Representation of the People Act the High Court is required to dismiss an election petition which does not comply with the provisions of S. 81. The Respondent No. 1 has, therefore, urged that this election petition should be dismissed because the petitioner has not complied with the provisions of S. 81, sub-section (3). There are two respondents to the election petition. According to the 1st Respondent, the election petition should have been accompanied by two copies thereof in compliance with the provisions of Section 81(3). Under the Election Rules framed by the Bombay High Court, two copies are required to be submitted per respondent. Hence four copies should have accompanied the petition at the time of its presentation.

    4. Evidence has been led by the Petitioner in order to show that the petitioner has substantially complied with the provisions of Section 81, sub-section (3). The case of the petitioner is that on 13-4-1978, which was the last date for filing an election petition, the Advocate of the petitioner had given to his clerk the petition along with four copies of the petition which were attested by the petitioner under his own signature to be true copies of the petition. There was some difficulty about making the deposit of Rs. 2000/-. But ultimately the petitioner was permitted to make the deposit of Rs. 2000/- and thereafter the petition was presented to the Master and Assistant Prothonotary, or the afternoon of 13-4-1978. Under Rule 4 of the Election Rules framed by the High Court in regard to election petitions under the Representation of the People Act, 1951 an election petition arising from “the rest of the areas of the State of Maharashtra” shall be presented to the Prothonotary and Senior Master, High Court, Bombay, or such other officer as the said Prothonotary and Senior Master, may, by special or general orders passed from time to time, appoint in this behalf. Admittedly the Master and Assistant Prothonotary is an Officer so appointed by the Prothonotary and Senior Master before whom an election petition can be presented. In the present case the petition was presented to him on 13-4-1978. Sometime thereafter on the same day, according to the Petitioner, the clerk of the Advocate realised that he had not given four duly attested copies of the election petition to the Master and Assistant Prothonotary. According to the Petitioner's version, the clerk accompanied by the petitioner and the petitioner's friend Handure went first to the Office of the Master and Assistant Prothonotary for handing over 4 copies of the election petition to him. The clerk however found the Office crowded and therefore he went to the Board Department of the High Court which adjoins the Office of the Assistant Prothonotary and put the four copies of the election petition duly attested by the Petitioner in the bundle of papers kept in the Board Department. On the next day, that is to say, on 14-4-1978 the Advocate of the Petitioner, who was presumably unaware of what had been done by the clerk, went to the Office of the Master and Assistant Prothonotary for removing the Office objections, if any. He found that the first objection pertained to not filing four copies of the petition. At that time, his clerk who had accompanied him told him that he had filed 4 copies of the election petition with the Board Department and the clerk immediately went to the Board Department and brought the copies which were then handed over to the Master and Assistant Prothonotary. Thereafter the Advocate for the Petitioner made an endorsement inter alia that Objection No. 1 had been complied with. The question is, whether the Petitioner has, under these circumstances, substantially complied with the requirements of S. 81, sub-sec. (3), relating to the presentation of the election petition. If there is no substantial compliance with these provisions, then, however hard the case may be, the petition is required to be dismissed under the mandatory provision of S. 86. The Petitioner's case taken at its highest is that on 13-4-1978 the election petition was presented to an Officer so appointed for the purpose by the High Court. Although the petition was not ac companied by the requisite number of copies. Nevertheless on the same day, requisite number of copies were filed by the petitioner in the High Court in a different department, namely the Board Department. The Petitioner has, therefore, substantially complied with the requirements of S. 81, sub-sec. (3), of the Representation of the People Act, which lays down that every election petition shall be accompanied by as many copies thereof as there are respondents mentioned in the petition. There is no dispute relating to the second half of S. 81, sub-sec. (3) of the Act, which lays down that the copies must be attested by the Petitioner under his own signature to be true copies.

    5. The Petitioner has led his own evi dence as well as the evidence of his friend Handure who is supposed to have accompanied the Petitioner at the time of the filing of the petition. He has also led the evidence of his Advocate and of Acharya, the clerk of the Advocate. In ad dition he has also examined the Master and Assistant Prothonotary and the clerk in the Board Department. The Petitioner, Handure and Acharya have all deposed to the effect that after presenting the election petition to the Master and Assistant Prothonotary they went to the canteen to have tea when Acharya remembered that he had forgotten to give 4 copies of the election petition to the Master and Assist ant Prothonotary. There are some minor variations in their testimony but taken by and large they all say that all of them immediately went to the Office of the Master and Assistant Prothonotary. The Office was crowded. Therefore, at the suggestion of Acharya they went to the Board Department and Acharya put the four copies of the election petition in a bundle in the Board Department. The rest of the testimony is not really material for the purpose of considering the preliminary issues. The testimony of the Advocate does not carry the matter much further because admittedly he was not present on the occasion when the copies of the election petition were put in the bundle of papers in the Board Department by Acharya. He has however deposed that on the next day when he went to remove the objections in the Office of the Master and Assistant Prothonotary, Acharya told him that he had kept the copies of the election petition in the Board Department and that Acharya thereafter went to the Board Department and brought the copies to him which he then gave to the Master and Assistant Prothonotary. The two independent material witnesses who have been examined by the Petitioner are the Master and Assistant Prothonotary and the clerk in the Board Department in whose presence Acharya put the four copies of the election petition in a bundle of papers in the Board Department. Unfortunately neither of them is able to recollect what happened either on 13-4-1978 or on 14-4-1978. The Master and Assistant Prothonotary has relied upon the endorsement put by him on the docket of the petition at the back. He is not able to recollect anything beyond what is endorsed at the back of the petition. The clerk in the Board Department, who was admittedly a new clerk in that department at the material time, also says that he can-not remember anything about the incident in question. Therefore the only witnesses whose evidence can throw any light on the question are the Petitioner, his friend Handure and Acharya and Advocate Mr. Hargolkar. The Petitioners testimony is obviously interested and it cannot be relied upon per se. However, his statement have been confined by Handure and Acharya in their testimony. It is true that Handure's name has not been mentioned in any of the affidavits filed by the Petitioner when an application was made for amendment of the Chamber Summons or in the Petition itself. Mr. Bhandare, who appears for the Respondent No. 1, has, therefore, urged that his alleged presence at the time of the filing of the election petition is an afterthought and he was in fact not present at the material time. But in this connection I am inclined to accept the evidence given by the Advocate to the effect that Handure had accompanied the Petitioner when he came to file the election petition. Hence Handure's testimony cannot be rejected out-right. It has also been urged by Mr. Bhandare that Handure is also an interested witness. He has come to the Court on a number of occasions at his own eixpense in connection with this election petition and admittedly he is inte-rested in the outcome of the election petition. He is also a close friend of the Petitioner. His evidence therefore should not be relied upon. In my view, this is not a ground for rejecting Handure's testimony outright. As a friend of the Petitioner he is bound to have an interest in the Petition. Nevertheless there is no reason to believe that he would deliberately give false evidence in a case like this. He has stated that he and the Petitioner had accompanied Acharya when he went to the Board Department to put the copies of the election petition in the bundle of papers in the Board Department and I am inclined to accept this part of his testimony. Acharya himself has also deposed to the same effect. His testimony further reveals that he seemed to carry an impression that copies could be put in the Board Department because, on a previous occasion, he had managed to obtain a precedent of an election petition from that department. He has however tried to justify his conduct by going a step further and saying that on another occasion he had been directed by the Master and Assistant Prothonotary to give the copies of the election petition in the Board Department. This part of his testimony cannot be believed at all. In fact, the Master and Assistant Prothonotary has categorically denied that he had directed any clerk to give copies of an election petition in the Board Department. It is, therefore, clear that Acharya, on his own, had deposited the copies of the election petition in the Board Department on 13-4-1978. The question is whether this constitute sufficient compliance with the provisions of Section 81, sub-Section (3), of the Representation of the People Act, 1951.

    6. Mr. Paranjpe drew my attention to a number of decisions of the Supreme Court which lay down the proposition that a total non-compliance with the provisions of section 81, inter alia, of the Act would result in a dismissalof an election petition. But in a case where the provisions of this section were substantially complied with, the election petition should not be dismissed. In this connection he relied upon the observations of the Supreme Court in AIR 1964 SC 1545 (Murarka Radhey Shyam Ram Kumar v. Roop Singh Rathore). This is a case where there was a dispute as to whether, inter alia, the copies of the election petition, which are required to accompany an election petition, were attested as provided under Section 81 sub-section (3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, and the Court came to the conclusion” that the petitioner had substantially complied with the provisions relating to attestation of copies. This decision was followed by the Supreme Court in 1965 SC 815 (Dr. Anup Singh v. Shri Abdul Ghani) where also in considering whether the copies of an election petition were true copies properly attested, the Court came to the conclusion that there was subtantial compliance with Section 81 sub-section (3) of the Act and the petition should not be dismissed. The other decisions of the Supreme Court cited before me in this connection are (1974) 4 SCC 237 : AIR 1974 SC 1185 (Satya Narain v. Dhuja Ram) and (1978) 2 SCC 659 : AIR 1978 SC 840 (M. Kamalam v. Dr V.A Syed Mohammed.). Reliance has also been placed on the observations of Krishna Iyer, J. in the judgment reported in (1978) 4 SCC 152 : AIR 1978 SC 1583 (Shiv Chand v. Ujagar Singh) where he has stated that “hyper-tecnnicality, when the public policy of the statute is fulfilled, cannot be permitted to play the procedural tyrant to defeat a vital judicial process, namely, investigation into the merits of the election petition. It is necessiary therefore to examine what is the “public policy” underlying S. 81(3). In the decision reported in (1974) 4 SCC 237 : AIR 1974 SC 1185 (Supra) the Supreme Court itself has explained the principle underlying S. 81 sub-sec (3). It has stated: “The purpose of enclosing the copies of the election petition for all the respondents is to enable quick despatch of the notice with the contents of the allegations for service on the respondent or respondents so that there is no delay in the trial at this very initial stage when the election petition is presented/’ In view of this purpose, it requires to be examined whethei the filing of copies of the election petition in a wrong department of the High Court can be considered as a substantial compliance with the provisions of S. 81, sub-sec. (3). The High Court is a very complex entity consisting of a large number of departments which deal with diffe-rent, matters pertaining to the administration of the High Court. Filing of papers in the wrong department can easily result in considerable delay before papers can be traced and properly filed. The adminis-tration of the High Court is regulated under various rules which are framed by the High Court for this purpose. Under the Election Rules which have been framed by this High Court concerning petitions filed under the Representation of the People Act, 1951, it is very clearly provided that in cases of election;petitions arising from areas other than Akola, Amravati, Bhandaira, Buldana, Chanrapur, Nagpur, Wardha and. Yeotmal., they must be presented to the Protho-notary and Senior Master, High Court, Bombay, or such other officer as may be appointed by him in this behalf. The Master and Assistant Prothonotary is such an officer appointed by the Prothonotary and Senior Master to whom election petitions are required to be presented. If the petitioner presents his election petition to somebody else in the High Court— a clerk in the High Court instead, for example, it cannot be said that he has I presented the election petition to the High Court under S. 81. When S. 81 talks about presentation of petitions to the High Court, it must be taken to mean presenting such a petition to such an officer of the High Court as may be appointed for the purpose. It would be a mockery of the rules framed for proper administration of a High Court and for a proper conduct of litigation in the High Court if a petitioner can be permitted to disobey the rules framed by the High Court for this purpose. It would make it impossible fori the High Court to deal with election petitions which may be filed anywhere before any officer of the High Court. What is more important, it would defeat the basic purpose underlying S. 81, particularly sub-sec. (3) thereof, namely that there should not be any delay in proceeding with the election petition and that all the respondents must be immediately intimated about the filing of the petition. For this purpose it is essential that the petition accompanied by the requisite number of copies is presented to an officer, whose duty it is to see that the petition is properly presented and to see that all procedure in connection with such an election petition is properly complied with. It can-i not, therefore, be said that by giving copies of the election petition to the Board Department, the Petitioner has pre-sented the election petition with the requisite number of copies to the High Court under Section 81, sub-section (% of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. The Petitioner has not even filed his copies, although they may be with the wrong department. The clerk of the Advocate merely kept the copies of the election petition in a bundle of papers in the Board Department. Therefore, in the present case it cannot even be said that copies were filed in the wrong department though on, the same day. The Petitioner merely put his copies in the wrong department, of the High Court. It has been argued that this department was also under the jurisdiction of the Master and Assistant Prothono-tary. But that cannot help the Petitioner in any way because the Board Department has nothing to do with the presentation of election petitions. Admittedly the copies were presented to the Master and Assistant Prothonotary on the next day after the time specified for filing an election petition had expired. Such a filing Icannot save the election petition.

    7. Mr. Bhandare has also argued that even assuming that the election petition is presented and thereafter on the same day the copies of the election petition are subsequently presented, that itself will amount to non-compliance with S. 81, sub-sec (3) because the section provides that the election petition should be accompanied by the requisite number of copies of the election petition. Hence the election petition must be presented along with the copies. If the copies are filed subsequently, it will amount to non-compliance with tne section. He has pointed out that in the case reported in (1974) 4 SCC 237 : AIR 1974 SC 1185 (Satya Narain v. Dhuja Ram), which was a case in appeal from the judgment of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, the Punjab and Haryana High Court had held that if the requisite number of spare copies of the election petition were not filed along with the petition in the High Court, the defect would not be cured subsequently even within the period of limitation prescribed for filing an election petition. On the facts of that case the High Court had held that such spare copies were filed beyond the period of limitation. I have not had the benefit of looking at the judgment of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in question. The Supreme Court has not considered this aspect of the question at ail-Hence the decision of the Supreme Court does not throw any light on this aspect of the matter. Looking, however, merely to the language of S. 81(3) would not be conclusive on a matter like this. It is true that the words used in the section are (petition shall be accompanied by copies”. Therefore, prima facie it would appear that what Mr. Bhandare contends is correct, namely that the copies must accompany the election petition at the time when it is presented. However, the section need not be construed so literally. The purpose of the section is to ensure that copies are immediately available for service on the respondents so that the hearing of the (election petition is not unnecessarily delayed at the initial stage. Bearing this pur-pose in mind, if the copies are given by the Petitioner on the same day or soon after the presentation of the election petition at the time of removal of objections, it cannot be said that the Petitioner has violated Section 81(3) of the Act because the copies are supplied in such a case by the Petitioner within a reasonable time for service on the Respondents and his conduct does not cause any unreasonable delay in proceeding with the hearing of the election petition at the initial stage, provided, of course, the copies are given by the Petitioner within the period of limitation prescribed under the Representation of the People Act, 1951. Hence it cannot be said that simply because copies are furnished subsequently by the Petitioner though on the same day his petition is liable to be dismissed for non-compliance with Section 81(3) of the Act. Compliance with the provisions of Section 81(3) of the Act, however, after the expiry of the period of limitation, is not permissible. The petition must be presented as prescribed under S. 81(3) within the period of limitation.

    8. In the present case the Petitioner did not give copies of the election petition to the Officer of the High Court designated for the purpose until after the period of limitation for filing an election petition had expired. In such a case the mandatory provisions of Section 86 of the Act must come into operation and the petition must be dismissed because within the period pre scribed under the Act the Petitioner had not presented the petition accompanied’ by the requisite number of copies as provided under Section 81 sub-section (3) of the Act.

    9. It is also not open to the Petitioner to argue that under the Election Rules framed by the High Court the Officer concerned has a right to ask the parties or Advocate to attend the Office on the third day from the date of presentation of petition to remove the objections and the Advocate or the party is entitled to remove such objections within two days there after.

    10. From these rules it cannot be de duced that even in a case where an election petition is filed on the last date of limitation, the petitioner would get an additional 5 days for removing objections. Before the expiry of the period of limitation the petition must be Tbefore the High Court without any objections relating to non-compliance with S. 81(3). In other words, all such objections must be removed by the Petitioner before the period of limitation expires. This is the view expressed by the Supreme Court in the easel reported in (1974) 4 SCC 237 : AIR 1974 SC 1185, and the Petitioner has not seriously argued to the contrary. He has attempted to show that copies were in fact filed before the expiry of the period of limitation. For the reasons stated by me earlier I am not inclined to accept this argument of the Petitioner.

    11. Under the circumstances issue No. 1 is answered in the affirmative and issue No. 1A is answered in the negative.

    12. In the result the election petition is dismissed. Petitioner to pay the costs of Respondent No. 1.

    13. Considering that the Petitioner is a poor person the costs are quantified at Rs. 750/-.

    14. There will be no order as to costs in favour of Respondent No. 2 for the same reasons and also because the Respondent No. 2 has submitted to the orders of the Court as far as preliminary issues are concerned.

    15. The Prothonotary and Senior Master to intimate the substance of the decision in this petition to the Election Commission and to the Speaker, Maharashtra Legislative Assembly as provided under Section 103 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 and send to the Election Commission a copy of the decision.

    16. Liberty to the 1st Respondent to withdraw the sum of Rs. 750/- from out of the security deposit made by the Petitioner in the present election petition. Liberty to the Petitioner to withdraw the balance amount lying with the Prothonotary after payment of costs to the 1st Respondent.

    17. Prothonotary and Senior Master to act on the certified copy of the Minutes of Order on the undertaking given by the Advocate of the Petitioner to draw up the Order within eight weeks from today.

    18. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ashok Shankar Gholap v. Krishnarao H. Deshmukh And Another
    (Sep 6, 1979)