AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as the Act),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as the Act),
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Kantawala, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners filed this petition under sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act, 1956, with an alternative prayer that the company be wound up under the court's direction. Respondent No. 1 is Engineers' Enterprises Pvt. Ltd., a private limited company with issued, subscribed and paid-up capital of Rs. 2,04,000 divided into 2,040 ordinary shares of Rs. 100 each. The petitioners held 1,000 shares (about 49.02%); respondents Nos. 2–5 held the remaining 1,040 shares (a little over 50%).

Procedurally: the petition was accepted by the court in April 1968. On March 20, 1969 the petition was admitted in respect of prayers except those relating to winding up (prayers (g) and (j)); at that time petitioners' counsel stated they were not pressing winding-up relief. On August 10, 1970 petitioners indicated they would not press sections 397 and 398 and intended to proceed as if the petition were for winding up only. The petition was adjourned on numerous occasions, often by consent, and has now come up finally for admission on the winding-up prayers.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the company should be wound up on the ground that it is unable to pay its debts (reference to section 433 of the Companies Act, 1956).
  2. Whether it is just and equitable to wind up the company because the petitioners have lost confidence in the management and cannot carry on the business with respondents Nos. 2–5 (application of the "just and equitable" ground for winding up as applied to a private company).
  3. Whether the petition should be admitted despite the delay between presentation and hearing, and whether such delay requires dismissal in limine.
  4. Whether, having admitted the petition, the court should direct advertisement of the petition or suspend advertisement (considering the company's contention of hardship from advertisement and the rule in National Conduits (P) Ltd. v. S.S. Arora).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The company is unable to pay its debts; the last audited balance-sheet (year ending 30 June 1970) and the audited trial balance-sheet for period ending 30 June 1971 show accumulated losses that have substantially eaten into the subscribed and paid-up capital and reserves.
  • It is just and equitable to wind up the company because petitioners have entirely lost confidence in the management (respondents Nos. 2–5) and it is impossible for them to carry on business with those respondents; significant disputes and conduct described (board resolution increasing remuneration of interested director, termination of employment of petitioner No. 1, notice to purchase petitioner shares under article 20, etc.) support this position.

Respondent No. 1 (Company)'s Arguments

  • There has been considerable delay between presentation of the petition and its hearing/admission; delay should preclude admission or justify dismissal in limine.
  • If the petition is advertised after admission it will cause considerable hardship to the company's interests; the court has power (per Supreme Court authority) to suspend advertisement of a petition for winding up and should consider exercising it in the company's favour.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
National Conduits (P) Ltd. v. S.S. Arora, [1967] 37 Comp Cas 786 (SC) Establishes that once a petition for compulsory winding up is admitted the court is not bound to advertise the petition immediately; the court may suspend advertisement pending disposal of an application to revoke admission and may, in the interest of justice or to prevent abuse, decide not to advertise. The court acknowledged and applied the principle that it has discretion not to advertise after admission and must take all facts into account. Having considered the company's financial position and the interests of creditors, the court declined to suspend advertisement and ordered the petition to be advertised so that creditors may be informed and can appear.
Palmer's Company Law (21st ed.), p. 739 (secondary source cited) Cited for the proposition that in considering winding up of private limited companies, principles applicable to dissolution of partnerships (just and equitable dissolution where participants are excluded from participation) are relevant. The court relied on this principle when treating the private company as akin to a partnership-like concern for the purpose of applying the "just and equitable" ground for winding up, supporting the view that disputes and exclusionary conduct between small-company members may justify winding up.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in stages, addressing the two primary grounds relied upon by the petitioners and the procedural objections raised by the company.

1. Inability to pay debts (section 433): the court examined the audited balance-sheet for the year ending 30 June 1970 and the audited trial balance-sheet for the period ending 30 June 1971. Key financial facts drawn from those documents (as stated in the opinion) include:

  • Paid-up capital: Rs. 2,04,000; reserves and surplus (including share premium and development rebate) approximately Rs. 36,693–38,693.
  • Secured loans and unsecured liabilities aggregated (per the 1970 balance-sheet) to approximately Rs. 4,96,375 (secured) and Rs. 5,83,000 (unsecured), with total liabilities shown about Rs. 13,32,115.
  • Assets included fixed assets of about Rs. 2,23,228 and current assets, loans and advances of about Rs. 8,71,005.18.
  • Accumulated losses as at 30 June 1970 and as at 30 June 1971 (trial balance-sheet) were sufficient to substantially wipe out the subscribed and paid-up capital and reserves (figures given: carried-forward losses around Rs. 2,27,682 for 1970 and around Rs. 2,23,240 for 1971 as cited). The court noted the business was effectively being carried on from borrowed money and that future losses would primarily affect creditors.

On this basis the court held that a prima facie case exists warranting enquiry and scrutiny as to whether the company is unable to pay its debts, observing that the balance-sheets, taken at face value, show accumulated losses sufficient to "eat away" substantially the whole subscribed capital and reserves.

2. Just and equitable ground: because the company is a private limited company, the court applied principles akin to dissolution of partnerships. The petitioners alleged complete loss of confidence in the management (respondents Nos. 2–5) and narrated a sequence of events evidencing serious disputes between the two groups: an October 1966 arrangement for share subscriptions and employment, subsequent disputes, an August 11, 1967 board resolution authorising increased remuneration for respondent No. 3 despite his interest and his vote, termination of petitioner No. 1's employment, and a notice to convene a board meeting to purchase petitioner No. 1's shares under article 20. The court treated these facts as prima facie showing serious disputes and exclusionary conduct that raise the question whether the company can be effectively carried on by the parties concerned.

3. Delay and adjournments: the court considered the company's contention about inordinate delay. It acknowledged that considerable time had elapsed and deplored the practice of indefinite postponements, but noted that some delay resulted from adjournments by consent of parties and that petitioners were not solely to blame. The court concluded that the delay, standing alone, was not sufficient to dismiss the petition in limine.

4. Advertisement after admission: the court considered the company's submission (relying on the Supreme Court decision) that advertisement could be suspended to protect the company. While acknowledging the authority that the court has discretion not to advertise, the court balanced that discretion against the interests of creditors and other persons vitally interested in the assets. Given the financial position disclosed by the balance-sheets and the likelihood that creditors would be affected by further losses, the court concluded that it was desirable in the interests of the company and creditors to have the petition advertised so that interested parties might appear.

Concluding from the combined financial prima facie evidence and the allegations of serious internal disputes in a small private company, the court found sufficient grounds for admission and further inquiry.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court directed that the petition be admitted and ordered that the petition be advertised in the Indian Express, Bombay Samachar and the Maharashtra Government Gazette. The court specified that the advertisements should appear on or before 20th January, 1972, and that the petition should be placed for hearing on board on the second Monday in February, 1972.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The petition is admitted and will proceed to further hearing; the specified advertisement will invite creditors and others with interests to appear and make submissions before the court. A hearing has been scheduled for the specified date.
  • Scope: The court's order is procedural and interlocutory — admission and advertisement for the purpose of enquiry and hearing. The opinion does not pronounce a final winding-up order at this stage.
  • Precedential effect: The decision applies established principles (including the court's discretion regarding advertisement after admission and the application of "just and equitable" principles to private companies akin to partnership dissolution) to the facts; the opinion does not state that it is establishing a new legal precedent beyond applying these principles to the case facts.

    Ramesh Premchand Shah And Another v. Engineers' Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. And Others

    Kantawala, J.:— Petitioners have filed this petition under sections 397 and 398 of the Companies Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”), with an alternative prayer that the company may be ordered to be wound up by and under the directions of this court.

    2. Respondent No. 1, Engineers' Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as “the company”), is a private limited company and its issued, subscribed and paid-up capital consists of Rs. 2,04,000 divided into 2,040 ordinary (equity) fully paid-up shares of Rs. 100 each. The petitioners held 1,000 ordinary shares of Rs. 100 each, i.e, about 49.02% of the total paid-up share capital of the company. Respondents Nos. 2 to 5 are the other shareholders of the company holding in all 1,040 ordinary shares of Rs. 100 each. Their holding comes to a little over 50% of the total paid up share capital of the company.

    3. On March 20, 1969, this petition was admitted in respect of prayers except those relating to winding up, namely, prayers (g) and (j). At that stage, the counsel for the petitioners stated that for the time being he was not pressing the petition in so far as it related to winding up and that the petition was kept pending for winding-up order. On August 10, 1970, counsel for the petitioners stated in the court that the petitioners did not press for reliefs under sections 397 and 398 of the Act and have decided to proceed with the petition as if it was a petition for winding up only. After that date, this petition came up on board for admission for almost nearly a dozen occasions but on most of the occasions, for one reason or the other, by consent of the parties, it was adjourned from time to time. Today it has come up finally for admission so far as it relates to prayers for winding up.

    4. It is unnecessary at this stage to refer in detail to the various allegations that are made in the petition and in the affidavits filed in reply. It is sufficient, for the present purposes, if two grounds are referred to at the present stage, in order to consider whether the court should admit the petition and issue consequential directions. One of the grounds pleaded in the petition is that the company is unable to pay its debts and, therefore, it should be wound up. Secondly, it is submitted that it is just and equitable to wind up the company because the petitioners have entirely lost confidence in the management of the company by respondents Nos. 2 to 5 and it is impossible for them to carry on the business of the company with respondents Nos. 2 to 5.

    5. So far as the first ground is concerned, under section 433 of the Act, a company may be wound up by the court, inter alia, if the company is unable to par its debts. My attention has been drawn not only to the last audited balance-sheet of the company for the year ending June 30, 1970, which has been duly passed by the company, but also to the trial balance-sheet of the company duly audited by the chartered accountants of the company for the period ending June 30, 1971.

    6. The financial position of the company as disclosed by the balance-sheet for the period ending June 30, 1970, is as under: The issued, subscribed and paid-up capital of the company is Rs. 2,04,000; in addition thereto, at the time when the petitioners were allotted shares they have paid a premium of Rs. 20 per share and this amount of Rs. 20,000 is shown under the heading “reserves and surplus” for share premium account. About Rs. 18,700 is the amount set apart for development rebate reserves. The company has borrowed large amounts by way of secured loans as well as unsecured loans. The aggregate liability in respect of the secured loans is about Rs. 4,96,375 while the aggregate liability in respect of unsecured loans including the current liabilities come to about Rs. 5,83,000. Thus, on the liabilities side, the total amount aggregates to Rs. 13,32,115, out of which Rs. 2,04,000 represents the amount of paid-up capital and the sum of Rs. 36,693 represents the amounts of reserves and surplus including the amount of share premium. The assets side in the balance-sheet of the company shows that the company owns fixed assets of the value of about Rs. 2,23,228. The current assets, loans and advances total up to about Rs. 8,71,005.18. Thus, even if the picture presented by the balance-sheet is taken at its face value, it is quite clear that the entire amount of share capital subscribed by the shareholders has been eaten away by accumulated losses. Thus, the balance-sheet shows that the company is carrying on the business only on borrowed loans by reason of carried forward losses. If, hereafter, further losses are incurred, the persons to suffer as a result of these losses will be the creditors of the company. The position will be worse if any of the assets shown on the assets side are either over-valued or unrealisable. One thing, however, is clear, that the aggregate carried forward losses for the period ending 30th June, 1970, are sufficient to wipe out substantially the whole of the capital subscribed and paid up by the shareholders and the amounts of reserves.

    7. As the entire share capital is eaten away by the accumulated losses, the risk in further carrying on the business is only on those who advanced loans to the company.

    8. My attention has also been drawn by Mr. Shah on behalf of the company to the trial balance-sheet of the company for the period ending June 30, 1971, which has been duly audited by the chartered accountants, but which has not been put before the shareholders. The financial position disclosed even by this trial balance-sheet does not present a different picture. The accumulated losses as shown by this balance-sheet comes to about Rs. 2,23,240. This figure primarily shows that the entire capital subscribed by the shareholders and the reserves are substantially eaten away by these carried forward losses. A comparison of the balance-sheet for the period ending June 30, 1970, and June 30, 1971, shows that some of the secured and unsecured creditors are asking for repayment of the amount. Under the balance-sheet for the period ending June 30, 1970, the secured loans due by the company aggregated to about Rs. 4,96,375 while under the trial balance-sheet for the period ending June 30, 1970, they aggregate to about Rs. 2,41,207. Even so far as unsecured loans are concerned, under the balance-sheet for the period ending June 30, 1970, they aggregate to about Rs. 5,83,000 while under the balance-sheet for the period ending June 30, 1971, they aggregate to about Rs. 5,09,014. Even this balance-sheet, therefore, clearly shows that the intention of the company is to carry on the ??? business of the company at the risk only of the creditors who have advanced loans to the company as the accumulated losses which are carried forward are sufficient to eat away practically the whole of the subscribed and paid-up capital and the amount of reserves and surplus. This position will become whose if upon an investigation it is found that the assets shown in the balance-sheet are over-valued or are unrealisable or any of the debts could not be recovered. Thus, a prima facie analysis of the balance-sheet for the period ending June 30, 1970, and the balance-sheet for the period ending June 30, 1971, is sufficient to come to a conclusion that this is a case for enquiry with a view to consider whether the company is unable to pay the debts.

    9. The company is a private limited company and for consideration of a petition for winding up of a private limited company, principles normally applied to the dissolution of partnership-firms are not overlooked. It is well settled that under the just and equitable clause a winding-up order has been made when the petitioner has been excluded from all participation in the business or that in the case of a small private company, the company was in substance a partnership and the facts would justify the dissolution of a partnership. See Palmer's Company Law, 21st edition, page 739.

    10. It is one of the contentions of the petitioners in this petition that the petitioners have entirely lost confidence in the management of the company by respondents Nos. 2 to 5 and that it is impossible for them to carry on the business of the company with them. Prior to October 15, 1966, this company comprised of shareholders who belonged to the family of respondent No. 2. In or about October, 1966, an arrangement has been arrived at between the petitioners and respondent No. 2 and the members of his group under which each of the petitioners agreed to subscribe for 500 shares of the company at a premium of Rs. 20. There was also an understanding that petitioner No. 1 will be appointed as electrical engineer with a salary of about Rs. 1,100 and that petitioner No. 2 will be appointed as electrical engineer upon a salary of Rs. 900 per month. Besides this, each of the two petitioners also agreed to deposit a sum of Rs. 40,000 in the company which they have done. Within a short time, after the petitioners subscribed for the shares, differences and disputes have arisen between the two groups, namely, the petitioners' group and the group of respondents Nos. 2 to 5. It is alleged that at the meeting of the board of directors held on August 11, 1967, a resolution was passed by which the remuneration payable to respondent No. 3 was increased by Rs. 100. Even though respondent No. 3 was vitally interested in this resolution he himself voted in favour of the said resolution. Respondent No. 2, who is the father of respondent No. 3, also voted in favour of it and ultimately got the resolution passed by casting his vote as a chairman. It is further alleged that Miss Naina, daughter of respondent No. 2 and sister of respondent No. 3, who was working originally as receptionist-cum-operator was promoted to act as an accountant of the company, resigned (sic). On or about October 5, 1967, a notice is given to petitioner No. 1 by the attorneys of the company terminating his employment as an engineer. On the same day, a notice is also addressed for convening a meeting of the board of directors of the company on October 7, 1967, with a view to purchase the shares held by petitioner No. 1 in view of the powers conferred by article 20 of the articles of association of the company. Apart from this, several other allegations are made, which it is unnecessary to refer to at the present stage. These facts prima facie disclose that there are serious disputes and differences between the two groups, namely, the group of the petitioners and the group of respondents Nos. 2 to 5, and whether, in view of such differences and disputes, it will be possible to carry on the business of the company smoothly; that is the thing which is to be inquired into. Thus, a prima facie case whether it is just and equitable to wind up respondent No. 1-company, which is a private limited company, has been made out and the matter requires investigation and scrutiny by the court.

    11. It has, however, been strenuously urged by Mr. Shah on behalf of the company that this petition should not be admitted as considerable time has elapsed between the date of presentation of this petition and the date on which it is being heard for admission. Mr. Shah is right that considerable time has elapsed between these two dates. Unfortunately, an undesirable practice has cropped up in the proceedings of this court where matters relating to adjudication of persons as insolvents and petitions for winding up of limited companies are indefinitely postponed from time to time before they are even admitted or before even they are heard and finally disposed of. Undoubtedly, there was some delay on the part of the petitioners. This petition was accepted by this court in the month of April, 1968.

    12. However, it was only in the month of March, 1969, that it was admitted in so far as it related to the prayers germane to sections 397 and 398 of the Act, while it was kept pending in respect of prayers (g) and (j), which related to proceedings for winding up of the company. In the month of August, 1970, the petitioner made it very clear that they did not want to proceed with the petition in so far as it related to reliefs under sections 397 and 398 of the Act and they have decided to proceed with the petition as if it is a petition only for winding up of respondent No. 1-company. It is unfortunate that even though such a decision was taken as early as August, 1970, parties got this petition adjourned from time to time on numerous occasions and on most of the occasions it was adjourned by consent of the parties. The petitioners are, therefore, not solely to be blamed for the delay that has taken place before this petition is finally considered for admission. In my opinion, the practice of adjourning the winding-up petition from time to time before it comes up for admission is not to be encouraged as, under the law relating to winding-up of the limited companies, if, ultimately, a petition is allowed and the company is ordered to be wound up, the order for winding up will relate back to an earlier date. The delay in the present case is not by itself sufficient to dismiss this petition in limine.

    13. It was then urged by Mr. Shah on behalf of respondent No. 1-company that if this petition is advertised after admission, it will cause considerable hardship to the interests of respondent No. 1-company. Reliance was placed by Mr. Shah on the decision of the Supreme Court in National Conduits (P) Ltd. v. S.S Arora, [1967] 37 Comp Cas 786 (SC). The Supreme Court has therein laid down that once a petition for the compulsory winding up of a company is admitted, the court is not bound forthwith to advertise the petition. In an appropriate case the court has the power to suspend advertisement of a petition for winding up, pending disposal of an application for revoking the order of admission of the petition. If the petition is admitted it is still open to the company to move the court that in the interest of justice or to prevent abuse of the process of the Court, the petition be not advertised. It cannot be disputed that such a power exists in this court not to issue an advertisement of the petition for winding up even though a petition for winding up is admitted. For exercise of such power it is obligatory upon the court to take into account all the facts. So far as respondent No. 1-company is concerned, the balance-sheet for the period ending June 30, 1970, and the trial balance-sheet for the period ending June 30, 1971, show that the accumulated losses are such that the entire subscribed and paid-up capital of the shareholders is eaten away thereby. Further, during the last few years, the company has incurred losses from year to year. For the year 1965–1966 carried-forward losses incurred during that year were about Rs. 69,493. For the year 1966–1967 the company has made a further loss of Rs. 25,970. In the year 1967–1968 the company has made a profit of about Rs. 28,583. For the year 1968–1969 the company has made a loss of about Rs. 93,763. During the year 1969–1970 the company has incurred a loss of about Rs. 48,667. Thus, the carried-forward losses as at June 30, 1970, come to about Rs. 2,27,682, while the carried-forward losses as shown by the trial balance-sheet as at June 30, 1971, come to about Rs. 2,23,240. The subscribed and paid-up capital of the shareholders consists only of Rs. 2,04,000. The reserves and surplus including the share premium amount and the development rebate is about Rs. 38,693. These figures, therefore, prima facie show that by reason of the carried-forward losses, the entire capital subscribed by the shareholders has been eaten away and the business of the company has to be carried on from the borrowed money. When such is the financial position disclosed by the balance-sheet of the company it is eminently desirable in the interests of the company and more so of the creditors of the company that they should know the real position qua their dealings with the company. In considering whether the petition should be directed to be advertised it is not only the interests of the company that have to be looked at. The interests of all the persons, who are vitally interested in the assets of the company, has not to be ignored. When creditors of the company are likely to suffer if future losses are incurred, then they are the fit persons who would be entitled to appear before the court and make their submission in relation to proceedings for winding up of the company.

    14. In my opinion, a prima facie case is made out for admission of this petition. I, therefore, direct that the petition be admitted and it should be advertised in the Indian Express, Bombay Samachar and the Maharashtra Government Gazette. Such advertisements should appear on or before 20th January, 1972, and the petition should be placed for hearing on board on second Monday in February, 1972.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ramesh Premchand Shah And Another v. Engineers' Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. And Others
    (Dec 22, 1971)