AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923.13.
  • Section 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923,
  • Section 3(1) of the Workmen's Compensation Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923.13.
  • Section 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923,
  • Section 3(1) of the Workmen's Compensation Act,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Sk. Abdulla was a jeep driver employed by the Managing Director, Maharashtra State Land Development Bank Ltd., Bombay (respondent No. 2) and was working with respondent No. 1, the District Branch Manager, Land Development Bank Ltd., Beed. On 21 March 1980 he took bank officers to the village Renapur in the bank's jeep in connection with recovery proceedings. After resting the jeep at the Rest House and going to the market at Renapur, he was assaulted by some unknown persons in the crowd and was found dead; his body was taken to the Police Station and handed over to the bank officers the same day.

The widow and minor children (the appellants) claimed compensation under Section 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, contending that the death was caused by an accident arising out of and in the course of employment. They served notice for Rs. 24,000 on 9-2-1981. Respondent No. 2 did not participate; respondent No. 1 filed a written statement and opposed the claim. Evidence was adduced by both sides and was not in dispute as to the recorded facts. The learned Civil Judge (Commissioner) found that the death did not result from an accident arising out of and in the course of employment, accepted that the assault in the market was not shown to be caused by a tense situation created by the bank's recovery staff, and relied on earlier authority (AIR 1960 Bom. 387) to distinguish or reject the claim. The appellants appealed against that decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the death of Sk. Abdulla arose out of and in the course of his employment with the respondents (i.e., whether there was a causal connection, casual or otherwise, between the death and his employment).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The death of Sk. Abdulla was an accident arising out of and in the course of his employment under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923.
  • There was an incidental connection between the employment and the death because Abdulla was on duty for the Bank in the jeep at Renapur on that day, and but for performing that duty he would not have been at the bazar and would not have suffered the fatal assault.
  • The claim sought Rs. 24,000 as compensation (with interest and penalty) and a notice had been given; the claim was therefore properly before the Commissioner.

Respondents' Arguments (as reflected in the record and the Commissioner’s findings)

  • The learned Commissioner accepted contentions that the assault in the market was not shown to have been caused by a tense situation created by the bank's recovery staff, noting that the appellants did not plead that the assault was committed for that reason.
  • The Commissioner found that, even if a tense situation existed, there was no reason to commit the assault on the jeep driver (a poor driver) rather than on the bank officers, and therefore the death could not be held incidental to employment on the facts before him.
  • The respondents relied on evidence (including several defence witnesses) which, in the Commissioner's view, did not establish a connection between the assault and the employment; the alleged assailants were later prosecuted and acquitted, but no prosecution record or judgment had been produced despite opportunity to do so.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR 1966 Madhya Pradesh 297 — Public Works Department through Chief Engineer, P.W.D., Bhopal v. Smt. Kausa ‘Accident’ in Section 3(1) of the Workmen's Compensation Act is used in the popular/ordinary sense — a mishap or untoward event not expected or designed by the workman; unexpected death/injury qualifies as an accident. The court treated the facts of that case as similar and used the principle to hold that Sk. Abdulla's death was an 'accident' within the Act because it was neither expected nor designed by him.
AIR 1959 Madhya Pradesh 281 Cited in support of the ordinary meaning of 'accident' under Section 3(1) (as relied upon in the Public Works Dept. case). Referenced by the court via the Public Works Department authority as part of the reasoning that the death qualifies as an 'accident' under the Act.
AIR 1952 Bombay 382 The words “arising out of his employment” are wide enough to cover cases where there may not be a direct connection between the injury and the employment; the expression suggests both time and place and some sort of connection is required but it can be broad. The court relied on this Division Bench decision to support the finding that death may arise out of employment even without a strict/direct causal link, applying that broader test to the instant facts.
AIR 1943 Madras 353 — K. Ramabrahmam v. Traffic Manager, Vizagapatnam Port Risk incidental to employment can make an accident arise out of and in the course of employment even where the risk (e.g., crossing railway lines) is shared with the public; what matters is that the risk was incidental to the employment. The court drew an analogy: the risk Abdulla faced by going to the bazar after resting the jeep was incidental to his employment of taking the jeep to Renapur, distinguishing it from a risk faced by all members of the public.
AIR 1960 Bombay 387 — Mohanlal Prabhuram v. Fine Knitting Mills Co. Ltd. (Ahmedabad) When an employee, while engaged in duties, is a helpless victim of an assault initiated by another employee assisted by outsiders, with no contribution by the victim, the injuries are incidental to employment and there is causal connection between the accident and employment. The learned Commissioner below had relied on and distinguished this authority. The court in the present opinion described the Mohanlal principle and applied it analogously to hold that where a workman is a helpless victim while on duty, the injuries are incidental to employment.
AIR 1955 Bombay 105 — Bhagubai v. General Manager, Central Railway, V.T., Bombay Observation (Justice Chagla, C.J.): If an employee must be at a particular place in the course of employment and by reason of being there must face a peril incidental to employment, then a causal connection is established even if the peril is shared with the public; employer must show the peril was personal to the employee or brought about by him. The court quoted and relied on these observations to conclude that Abdulla, by being at Renapur on duty, faced a peril incidental to his employment and that the respondents had not shown the peril was personal to him or self-created.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in these steps, based on the evidence and legal authorities:

  1. Fact-finding: The court accepted that Abdulla went to Renapur on duty with bank officers on a weekly bazar day, rested the jeep at the Rest House with permission, went into the market, and was assaulted and killed by persons in a mob. Witness evidence from both sides did not establish how the quarrel started or identify the motive or initiators; defence witnesses were unable to provide details about the origin of the quarrel.
  2. Course of employment: The court found there was no dispute that the death occurred while Abdulla was on duty (i.e., during the course of employment).
  3. Definition of ‘accident’: Relying on authority (notably AIR 1966 MP 297 and the articulation of Section 3(1) of the Workmen's Compensation Act), the court reiterated that an 'accident' is an unexpected or untoward event not designed or expected by the workman; Abdulla's death met that description.
  4. Causal connection / “arising out of” employment: The court examined whether the death “arose out of” the employment and concluded that the words are to be given a broad meaning — they may cover cases without a strict direct connection between employment and the injury (citing AIR 1952 Bom. 382). The court considered whether there was at least a casual connection between the employment and the fatal assault.
  5. Peril incidental to employment: Applying the principle in Bhagubai v. General Manager, Central Railway and the Madras decision (K. Ramabrahmam), the court reasoned that if an employee is required by employment to be at a particular place and faces a peril by reason of being there, a causal connection is established; sharing the peril with the public does not make it irrelevant if the peril is incidental to employment.
  6. Application to the facts: The court accepted the appellants' contention that but for Abdulla performing his duty by taking the officers to Renapur he would not have been in the bazar and would not have suffered the fatal assault. The court noted admissions suggesting a tense situation (for example, the District Recovery Officer's evidence that he apprehended assault) and held there was a casual connection between the accident and the employment.
  7. Rejection of contrary inferences: The respondents did not establish that the peril was brought about by Abdulla himself, nor that he had added to or extended the peril; the record was silent on the motive and on how the quarrel started, and the respondents failed to produce prosecution records despite opportunity.
  8. Conclusion on liability: On this basis and in view of the authorities cited, the court concluded that the death was an accident arising out of and in the course of Abdulla's employment, making the respondents liable to pay compensation to the appellants under the Workmen's Compensation Act.

Holding and Implications

Holding: APPEAL ALLOWED.

Direct consequences (as ordered by the court):

  • The appellants' application before the Commissioner — Civil Judge, Senior Division, Beed is allowed.
  • The respondents are directed to pay to the appellants Rs. 24,000/- as compensation.
  • Interest is awarded at the rate of 6% from the date of the application, with an additional sum not exceeding fifty percent of such amount of interest because there was no justification for denying and delaying the claim until recovery of salary arrears.
  • The appeal is allowed with costs.

Broader implications: The opinion applies and reiterates existing principles governing when an injury or death “arises out of and in the course of employment,” emphasizing that a causal connection may be satisfied by a peril incidental to employment even if shared with the public. The judgment does not state that it establishes a new legal precedent beyond applying and distinguishing prior authority; its effect is to find liability in the specific facts of this case and to award the stated compensation and interest.

This summary is based exclusively on the provided opinion and does not introduce information not contained in that opinion.

    Salamabegum v. Maharashtra State Co-Operative Land Development Bank

    1. This is an appeal by the wife and minor children of a Jeep Driver Sk. Abdulla, who was employed by the Managing Director, Maharashtra State Land Development Bank Ltd., Bombay — the respondent No. 2 and was at the relevant time working with the respondent No. 1, the District Branch Manager, Land Development Bank Ltd., Beed. While he the driver had taken the Officers of the Bank at Beed to the village Renapur in the jeep of the Bank on 21st March, 1980 in connection with the recovery proceedings, conducted by the Bank and while he had rested the jeep in the Rest House and had gone to the market at Renapur, was assaulted by some unknown persons in the crowd in the market, and was found dead. He was taken to the Police Station. The appeal is for compensation under Section 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, on account of the death of the jeep driver Sk. Abdulla, on the ground that the death was caused, of Sk. Abdulla, a workman by accident arising out of and in the course of his employment on 21st March, 1980.

    2. The appellants have served the respondents with a notice on 9-2-1981 for compensation of Rs. 24,000/-, but in vain. The respondent No. 2 did not participate in the proceedings. The respondent No. 1 — District Branch Manager filed his written statement and opposed the claim. Both the sides adduced the evidence and the sum of the total evidence, marshalled by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Beed is not in dispute. The pleas raised by the respondents found favour with the learned Judge — Commissioner. It was held that the death of Sk. Abdulla was not the result of an accident arising out of and during the course of his employment. The learned Judge accepted the contention that the assault on Sk. Abdulla in the market place was not committed due to a tense situation created in the village by recovery staff of the Bank on the ground that there was no such plea taken by the appellants. Even assuming that the death of Sk. Abdulla was the result of such a tense situation, the learned Judge observed, that there was no reason to commit the assault on the jeep driver. The target should have been the Officers of the Bank rather than a poor Jeep Driver. The learned Judge relying on AIR 1960 Bom. 387, Mohanlal Prabhuram…Applicant; v. Fine Knitting Mills Co. Ltd., Ahmedabad…Opponent., Ahmedabad, came to the conclusion that the facts of that case were different from the facts of the instant case and it cannot, therefore, be held that the death was incidental to the employment of Sk. Abdulla. It was observed by the Judge that the record in the instant case regarding the cause of assault vis-a-vis the motive is silent, and that the record does not show that as to how the quarrel had started in the market and by whom.

    3. The position of the facts in the present case, therefore, is that a jeep driver in the employment of the respondents Nos. 1 and 2 while he had gone on duty to village Renapur and had taken the Bank Officers to that village on 21st March 1980, which was a weekly bazar day of village Renapur, had rested his jeep at the Rest House with permission of the officers and had possibly wandered in the market, and was murdered by some persons in the mob and his dead body was handed over to the Bank Officers by the Police Station on that day. The alleged assailants of Sk. Abdulla, it appears, were later on prosecuted and were acquitted. No record of the said prosecution nor even the judgment of the case has been placed on record in spite of an opportunity given to the respondents to produce at least the judgment.

    4. The sole question for consideration in this appeal is whether the death of Sk. Abdulla arose out of and during the course of employment with the respondent. An accident means a mishap or untoward event not expected or designed by a workman. It is pertinent to observe in this connection that the mishap of the accident which occurred in a weekly bazar, where the workman had gone after resting his jeep in the Rest House, and where he had to lose his life at the hands of a unruly mob. The evidence recorded in this case does not show as to who started the quarrel and what was the reason of the assault on Sk. Abdulla. The respondents did not show by any evidence as to how the quarrel started and whether the assault was invited by the workman. The evidence of Pandharinath s/o Tulshiram Shirsat, DW 1 (Ex. 38) and Sudam Vishwanath Kolekar, DW 2 (Ex. 39) does not throw any light on this fact. They stated that while they were going to the Rest House after completing their work they learnt from the villagers that Sk. Abdulla and the assailants were taken to the Police Station and they saw that a huge mob had gathered. They are ignorant of the circumstances in which the quarrel had ensued. The respondents also examined two witnesses i.e Hanumant s/o Genba Akhangire DW 3 (Ex. 47) and Gachkumar s/o Dattatraya Apsingekar DW 4 (Ex. 48), who showed that the incident had taken place in the weekly bazar at Renapur. Hanumant is a banana seller, who in his evidence stated that some wordy quarrel had taken place between some assailants and Sk. Abdulla, which resulted in the assault on him. What the wordy quarrel was, he could not tell. The other witness is a Proprietor of a Cycle Mart. He also could not say as to how the quarrel had started. The witness at Ex. 38 examined by appellants deposed about the incident in the market, but without any further details.

    5. There is no doubt, therefore, that the accident had taken place resulting in the death of Sk. Abdulla in the bazar at Renapur, when he had gone there in the jeep with the Officers of the Bank on official duty. There is no gainsaying of the fact that the accident had taken place during the course of employment.

    6. The only question that calls for consideration is whether it can be said that the accident arose out of the employment or whether there was any connection, casual or otherwise, between the death and the employment of the workman and the employment. In this respect, the appellants' contention was that there was incidental connection by the very fact that the deceased Sk. Abdulla was on duty of the Bank and but for his performing the duty of taking the Bank Officers in the jeep at Renapur on that day, the accident could not have taken place. In other words, had he not been on duty of the Bank on that day and had he not taken the jeep anywhere, he would not have met with any accident, much less a fatal one like his death. This contention has much force. It cannot be lightly brushed aside.

    7. The learned Commissioner has obviously erred in not holding that there was a casual connection between the accident in question and the employment of Sk. Abdulla. The assault may have been perhaps due to tense situation in the village on account of recovery proceedings. DW 1, Mr. P.T Shirsat, the District Recovery Officer has admitted in his cross-examination that he was apprehending the assault on him also. There was, no doubt, a casual connection between the accident and the employment. As a matter of fact, the expression “accident arising out of and in the course of employment” rather denotes a point of time than a factual connection with the employment and the accident.

    8. A few cases on this point need be perused. In AIR 1966 Madhya Pradesh 297, Public Works Department through Chief Engineer, P.W.D, Bhopal v. Smt. Kausa, a workman/gang-jamadar from P.W.D had started from his place of work for collecting salaries of labourers from his office and was while on his way murdered by some unknown persons. The question arose as to whether the death of Gokul, the workman can be said to be the result of accident “arising out of and in the course of his employment”. Relying on AIR 1959 MP 281, it was observed that the word ‘accident’ in Section 3(1) of the Workmen's Compensation Act, has been used in the popular and ordinary sense; and all that it means is ‘mishap’ or ‘untoward event not expected or designed’. It was further observed that if the injury or death from the point of view of the workman, who dies or suffers the injury, is unexpected or without design, on his part, then the death or injury would be by accident although it was brought about by other causes. The death of Gokul in the aforesaid case was certainly neither expected nor designed by him. It would, therefore, amount to an ‘accident’ within the meaning of Section 3(1) of the Workmen's Compensation Act. The facts in the instant case are also similar as in the abovementioned case. In this case also a workman died while he was on duty at the hands of some other persons. The cause of assault and death is not known and it does not show that the workman Sk. Abdulla had expected or designed or invited the assault on him. The death of Sk. Abdulla was, therefore, certainly due to accident during the, course of his employment. Whether the death arose out of his employment, is a question, which can be answered by a reference to the decision of Division Bench of this Court, reported in AIR 1952 Bombay 382. This Court has held that, the words, “arising out of his employment” are wide enough so as to cover a case, where there may not necessarily be a direct connection between the injury caused as a result of an accident and the employment of the workman. There was a bomb explosion, as a result of which workman received injuries and died. It was not known as to who had placed the bomb. The workman was certainly not responsible. The bomb was exploded in the workshop. It was held that there was a circumstance attending to his employment because at the time and place at which he was employed, an explosion occurred. As such, it was an accident arising out of and during the course of his employment. Speaking for the Division Bench of Dixit and Bavdekar, JJ., Dixit, J. observed that:

    “The expression “arising out of his employment” suggests both the time as well as the place of employment. The expression “out of” conveys the idea that there must be some sort of connection between the employment and the injury caused to a workman as a result of the accident. That is the literal and strict construction of the section. But, the words “arising out of his employment” are wide enough so as to cover a case, where there may not necessarily be a direct connection between the injury caused as a result of an accident and the employment of the workman’. And there may be circumstances at ending the employment, which would go to show that the workman received personal injury as a result of the accident arising out of his employment.”

    (Emphasis supplied)

    9. The implications of the expression “out of and in the course of their employment” have also been extended to a case by Madras High Court in a case reported in AIR 1943 Madras 353, K. Ramabrahmam v. Traffic Manager, Vizagapatnam Port. A workman was employed by the contractor of the Port Authorities for loading manganese ore into ships at a dump within the harbour premises. While returning, he had to cross the railway lines. There was a notice prohibiting the persons from crossing the railway line, but it was usual practice for the workmen to cross the railway line in spite of the prohibition. The two workmen in that case while crossing the railway line were crushed by an engine. It was held that despite the prohibition and despite the fact that there was no necessary connection between the workmen and the crossing of the railway line, the accident had arisen out of and in the course of employment. The risk was incidental to that employment as distinguished from a risk to which all members of the public were alike exposed. Similarly, in the instant case, the risk incurred by Sk. Abdulla for going to the bazar after resting his jeep, was incidental to his employment of taking the jeep to Renapur as against the risk which all members of the public may have been exposed on account of the unruly mob in the market.

    10. In yet another case, in which a workman's hand was fractured on account of an assault initiated by one of the employees of a Mill and assaulted by three outsiders, was granted compensation by this Court in a case reported in AIR 1960 Bom. 387, Mohanlal Prabhuram…Applicant; v. Fine Knitting Mills Co. Ltd., Ahmedabad…Opponent., Ahmedabad. It was observed in this case that:

    “If the evidence of Deoshankar is accepted, then, it is clear that the petitioner did not contribute by his own action or conduct to the peril. It is equally clear that the petitioner was a helpless victim of the assault which was initiated by one of the employees of the Mill, who was assisted by three outsiders. It is also clear that the attack took place upon the petitioner while he was engaged in carrying out his day to day duties. That being the case, it must be held that the injuries suffered by the petitioner were incidental to his employment. There was also a causal connection between the accident and the employment, and, therefore, accident must be taken to have arisen out of employment of the petitioner.”

    11. The facts of the instant case are also the same and it shows that the accident having been taken place without the fault of workman and while he was on duty at Renapur must be taken to be during the course of his employment and also arising out of the employment on account of risk which was incidental to his duty of taking the Bank officials to Renapur. The observations made by Justice Chagla, C.J in this connection, relied upon in AIR 1955 Bom. 105, Bhagubai v. General Manager, Central Railway, V.T, Bombay are pertinent, which are as follows:

    “If the employee in the course of his employment has to be in a particular place and by reason of his being in that particular place he has to face a peril and the accident is caused by reason of that peril which he has to face, then a casual connection is established between the accident and the employment. The fact that the employee shares that peril with other members of the public is an irrelevant consideration. The peril which he faces must not be something personal to him; the peril must be incidental to his employment. He must not by his own act add to the peril or extend the peril. Once the peril is established, it is for the employer then to establish either that the peril was brought about by the employee himself, that he added or extended the peril, or that the peril was not a general peril but a peril personal to the employee.”

    12. In the instant case, the respondents have not adduced any evidence to show that the peril of death in which Sk. Abdulla succumbed was brought about either by Sk. Abdulla or that he added or extended the peril. But for Sk. Abdulla going to Renapur by driving a jeep, on a weekly bazar day, as a part of his duty, he would not have been exposed to the peril of facing a deadly assault. The respondents having despite notice and having been given an opportunity, have not shown that the peril was brought about by Sk. Abdulla himself or that he added or extended the peril. In view of this factual situation, it must be said that the death caused to Sk. Abdulla was a result of an accident out of and during the course of his employment, and as such, the respondents were liable to pay the compensation to the appellants i.e wife and her minor children of Sk. Abdulla, in accordance with the provisions of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923.

    13. The salary of Sk. Abdulla was Rs. 726.50 ps. per month at the time of his death, as per the evidence of DW 1. The District Recovery Officer, Mr. Shirsat, D.W 1 stated in his evidence that an amount of Rs. 5767.14 ps. was paid to Sk. Abdulla, which was the amount of the salary of Sk. Abdulla, after deducting the amount of Rs. 970.24 ps., which was recoverable from Sk. Abudlla. Obviously, this amount was on account of arrears of salary due to Sk. Abdulla and cannot, therefore, be taken into consideration in the amount of compensation payable to the widow and children of Sk. Abdulla. The claim was made for Rs. 24,000/- by the appellants as compensation with interest and penalty, which should have been accepted by the learned Commissioner — Civil Judge, Senior Division, Beed. The appeal, therefore, has to be allowed. In the result the application made by the appellants before the Commissioner — Civil Judge, Senior Division, Beed, is allowed and it is hereby directed that the respondents shall pay to the appellants Rs. 24,000/- with interest at the rate of 6 per cent from the date of application with a further sum not exceeding fifty per cent of such amount of interest, as there was no justification for denying and delaying the claim of compensation, till recovery of the amount. The appeal is thus allowed with costs.

    Appeal allowed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Salamabegum v. Maharashtra State Co-Operative Land Development Bank
    (Sep 1, 1988)