AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — B. Prakash Rao, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant (petitioner below) appealed under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 against an order dated 05.04.2007 in IA No. 850 of 2007 in OP No. 338 of 2007 of the Court of First Additional District Judge at Khammam. The impugned order dismissed an interim injunction application filed under Section 9(ii)(d) of the Act, in which the appellant sought an ad interim injunction restraining the respondents from deducting any amount from the appellant's running bills in respect of Purchase Order No. KC-60 & ROC 1030 dated 30.06.2006, pending disposal of the main OP.

The appellant manufactures industrial explosives and alleges that the respondent (M/s. Singareni Collieries Company Limited) placed a purchase order dated 30.06.2006 after floating a tender. Supplies and payments were made, but differences arose over survey volumes and an alleged unilateral reduction in the power factor by the respondents, which the appellant disputes. Clause 18 of the contract provides for arbitration; the appellant addressed a letter dated 27.03.2007 seeking reference to arbitration and filed the main OP on 29.03.2007. Alongside the main OP, the appellant filed IA No. 850/2007 under Section 9(ii)(d) seeking an ad interim injunction against deductions from running bills.

The respondents filed a counter-affidavit in the interim application denying wrongful recoveries and stating that survey work was for determining appropriate volume calculations. The court below heard both sides, admitted documentary evidence, and dismissed the interim application primarily on the grounds that (i) the interim relief sought (prohibiting deductions) was not consonant with the main relief (recording post-excavation measurements in the presence of representatives), and (ii) no material was placed to show alteration of actual excavation measurements.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and circumstances of the case, the appellant is entitled to the interim relief sought (an injunction restraining deductions from running bills) pending disposal of the main application under Section 9 of the Act.
  2. Whether further or varied interim applications (filed in addition to a main application under Section 9) seeking additional interim reliefs are maintainable and/or ought to be entertained by the court.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended that unless deductions from running bills are stopped, it would suffer great loss and be denied entitlements for supplies already made.
  • The appellant argued that the court below erred in refusing the interim relief pending the main application.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents submitted by counter-affidavit that no wrongful recoveries were being made and that the survey exercise was intended only to arrive at correct volume calculations.
  • The respondents' counsel supported the lower court's findings and contended that, given the nature of the proceedings, the appellant was not entitled to the interim indulgence sought.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sundaram Finance Ltd. v. Nepc India Ltd., (1999) 2 SCC 479; AIR 1999 SC 565; 1999 (1) Arb. LR 305 (SC) Establishes that interim orders under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act can be passed even before commencement of arbitration and need not be preceded by issuance of notice invoking the arbitration clause; courts have power to pass ad interim, ex parte orders or orders after notice as circumstances warrant. The court relied on this authority to explain the broad, interim nature of remedies under Section 9, to emphasize that such orders are remedial/interim (akin to injunctions) and to frame the correct approach to applications under Section 9 (i.e., they are interim in character and should be disposed of expeditiously).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court identified the single question for consideration as whether the appellant was entitled to the interim relief pending disposal of the main application. It observed an "erroneous approach" by parties and courts in appreciating the scope of Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and set out the text of Section 9 in full to anchor its analysis.

Key elements of the court's reasoning:

  • Section 9 is designed to provide interim measures (preservation, custody, securing amounts, inspection, interim injunction, appointment of receiver, and other such interim protective measures) and is remedial in nature — not a substitute for substantive relief or for arbitration itself.
  • The court treated the remedies under Section 9 as analogous to interim remedies under the Code of Civil Procedure (e.g., injunctions), emphasizing that they are temporary, protective measures to be invoked before, during, or after arbitral proceedings (and before enforcement of any award).
  • The court cited Sundaram Finance to stress that courts have ample power to pass interim orders even before arbitration proceedings commence and that such orders need not follow prior invocation of arbitration through notice.
  • The court criticized the practice of filing successive or additional interim interlocutory applications while a main application under Section 9 is pending, describing that practice as duplicative, causing delays and contrary to the scope and object of Section 9. The court held that such further interim applications are neither contemplated by the Act nor maintainable.
  • Given that the interim relief sought in IA No. 850/2007 (an injunction against deductions) was not consonant with the main relief in OP No. 338/2007 (directions to record post-excavation measurements and prevent unilateral alteration), the court below had declined the interim relief on that ground and for lack of material showing alteration. The appellate court refrained from expressing any opinion on the merits of the factual disputes.
  • To remedy delay and multiplicity of interlocutory applications, the court directed that the main application under Section 9 should be taken up and disposed of expeditiously after the respondent's appearance, and in no case later than three months from appearance.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The civil miscellaneous appeal is dismissed.

Direct, case-specific consequences:

  • The appeal against the order dismissing IA No. 850/2007 failed; the interim injunction sought by the appellant was not granted by this Court.
  • The Court directed the lower court to take up the main OP No. 338 of 2007 itself for expeditious disposal not later than three (3) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order, after the respondent's appearance.
  • No costs were awarded.

Broader implications articulated by the Court:

  • The Court held that applications under Section 9 are exclusively interim remedies and should be treated and disposed of as interim applications rather than as substantive proceedings equivalent to main suits.
  • The Court held that further or varied interlocutory interim applications filed in addition to a main application under Section 9 (i.e., successive or duplicative interim applications) are not maintainable and ought not to be entertained, because they frustrate the objective of summary and protective reliefs under Section 9 and cause undue delay.
  • The Court mandated an expeditious procedure: main Section 9 applications should be disposed of as soon as possible after the respondent appears and, in the circumstances of this case, within three months of appearance.

Note: The Court expressly refrained from expressing any opinion on the substantive merits of the underlying factual disputes between the parties.

    Gulf Oil Corporation Limited v. Singareni Collieries Company Limited And Anr.

    B. Prakash Rao, J.:— The appellant herein, who is the petitioner in the court below, by way of this appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (for brevity ‘the Act’), seeks to assail the order dated 05.04.2007 in IA No. 850 of 2007 in OP No. 338 of 2007 on the file of the Court of First Additional District Judge at Khammam, dismissing an interim injunction application purported to be filed under Section 9(ii)(d) of the Act, whereunder the appellant sought an ad interim injunction restraining the respondents from deducting any amount from the running bills of the appellant in respect of Purchase Order No. KC-60 & ROC 1030 dated 30.06.2006 unilaterally pending disposal of the main OP.

    2. Heard Sri S. Ravi, learned counsel appearing for the appellant and Sri J. Prabhakar, learned counsel appearing for the respondents and at their request, the main appeal itself is taken up for disposal.

    3. The appellant herein filed the main application in OP No. 338 of 2007 against the respondents herein with the following reliefs:

    (a) to direct the respondents, their employees or anybody claiming through the respondents to record the post-excavated measurements in the presence of representatives of both the petitioner and respondents;

    (b) further, the respondents, their employees or anybody claiming through them be directed not to alter the said measurements unilaterally;

    (c) to pass an order of injunction restraining the respondents from deducting any amounts from the running bills of the petitioner unilaterally in respect of Purchase Order No. KC-60 & ROC 1030 dated 30.06.2006 during the pendency of the main OP;

    (d) to award costs of this petition;

    (e) to grant any other relief or reliefs as the hon'ble court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances.

    4. The case of the appellant, in brief, is that the appellant is engaged in manufacture and sale of industrial explosives and accessories and the respondent-M/s. Singareni Collieries Company Limited, which is a government company, floated a tender for supply of SMS/SME explosives and accessories for removal of overburden by the respondents for the period from 01.07.2007 to 30.06.2008 Accordingly, after negotiations, the respondents placed a purchase order dated 30.06.2006 for supply of specified quantity of the said explosives which contains certain terms and conditions. Later, there had been further negotiations and the appellant started supplying the explosives and the respondents had been making payments. However, later, there had been certain minor differences which arose due to the alleged survey volume, which resulted into varied correspondences between them. According to the appellant, the respondents have unilaterally and arbitrarily started reducing the power factor on the basis of the said survey. This action on the part of the respondents is being disputed by the appellant. Since the contract provides settlement of disputes through arbitration as per Clause 18 of the tender document, i.e Annexure P-1, the appellant has initiated the process of arbitration proceedings by addressing a letter dated 27.03.2007 to the first respondent to refer the matter for arbitration. However, pending disposal thereof, the appellant has filed this application for protecting the interests and thus, sought the aforesaid reliefs in the main application. The main case was filed on 29.03.2007 Along with the said application, the appellant has filed the interim injunction application in IA No. 850 of 2007 by trying to invoke subclause (ii)(d) of Section 9 of the Act and sought ad interim injunction restraining the respondent from making any such deductions from the running bills unilaterally. This application was virtually filed on the same day of filing the aforesaid application under Section 9 of the Act. According to the appellant, the affidavit, which has been filed in support of this application, reiterates the self-same allegations and complains that any such action would impair their rights and cause irreparable loss and they would be put to damages and injuries. Therefore, having regard to prima facie case in their favour, they sought for such interim order.

    5. Contesting the said application, the respondents herein filed a detailed counter-affidavit denying about the allegations and specifically pointing out that no such wrong recoveries are being made from the running bills of the appellant and the exercise of survey is only for arriving at a proper volume calculations and, therefore, there is absolutely no prima facie case and the appellant is not entitled to any indulgence. As evident from the record, the respondents have filed the counter only in this interim application pending the main application.

    6. The court below, after hearing the counsel on both the sides and marking the documents, which have been filed from both the sides as Exs. A.1 to A. 12 on behalf of the appellant and Exs. B.1 to B. 6 on behalf of the respondents, did not find favour with the appellant and dismissed the application mainly on the ground that the main relief is totally different since it only pertains to measure the excavation in the presence of the appellant's representative and not to change the measurements whereas the interim relief as now sought is not the one to achieve the main relief but is totally different one whereby the appellant seeks an interim injunction not to deduct any amounts from the running bills. Therefore, the interim relief as sought for is not in consonance with the main relief and as such, it cannot be granted. Even otherwise, it has been observed that nothing has been placed on behalf of the appellant or any material in support to show that there is any change or alteration of the actual excavation measurements.

    7. Sri S. Ravi, learned counsel appearing for the appellant strenuously contended that having regard to the nature of relief as sought and unless and until such deductions are not stopped, the appellant would be put to great loss and for no fault of him, he will be denied his due entitlement in regard to the supplies, which have been made. Therefore, the court below was not right in holding that no such relief would be granted pending the main application.

    8. Sri J. Prabhakar, learned counsel appearing for the respondents sought to sustain the findings of the court below and the reasons given in support and further stated that having regard to the very nature of proceedings, the appellant cannot seek any indulgence.

    9. Having heard the counsel on both the sides and on perusal of the material available on record, the only point which arises for consideration is as to whether on the facts and circumstances, the appellant is entitled to interim relief as sought for pending disposal of the main application ?

    10. At the first flash, it is curious to note that there has been a total erroneous approach from all sides in appreciating or keeping in view the scope and the principles as contemplated under the provisions of the Act and especially the very provision, i.e Section 9 of the Act, which needs to be quoted before venturing into the merits and it reads as follows:

    “9. Interim measures, etc. by court—A party may, before or during arbitral proceedings or at any time after the making of the arbitral award but before it is enforced in accordance with Section 36, apply to a court—

    (i) for the appointment of a guardian for a minor or a person of unsound mind for the purposes of arbitral proceedings; or

    (ii) for an interim measure of protection in respect of any of the following matters, namely:

    (a) the preservation, interim custody or sale of any goods which are the subject matter of the arbitration agreement;

    (b) securing the amount in dispute in the arbitration;

    (c) the detention, preservation or inspection of any property or thing which is the subject matter of the dispute in arbitration, or as to which any question may arise therein and authorizing for any of the aforesaid purposes any person to enter upon any land or building in the possession of any party, or authorizing any samples to be taken or any observation to be made, or experiment to be tried, which may be necessary or expedient for the purpose of obtaining full information or evidence;

    (d) interim injunction or the appointment of a receiver;

    (e) such other interim measure of protection as may appear to the court to be just and convenient,

    and the court shall have the same power for making orders as it has for the purpose of, and in relation to, any proceedings before it.”

    11. From the above, it is quite apparent that the very provision and the procedure as contemplated under the aforesaid Section 9 of the Act is only to provide for an interim measure as the very heading reads. Though a substantive provision has been made in the main Act itself, the remedy as contemplated is not a substantive one as such either in regard to appointment of an arbitrator or assailing any awards either way. It only provides for the interim arrangement, protection or any directions, which may be warranted on the facts and circumstances and a party can invoke the said provision to seek any such reliefs as specified thereunder. Therefore, the relief enshrined thereunder can safely be put on par with a grant of injunction, ad interim injunction or appointment of a receiver, etc. as provided for under the regular procedure in the Code of Civil Procedure. It further reiterates that a party can invoke this provision even before or during the arbitral proceedings or at any time after the award but before it is enforced as contemplated thereunder, the reliefs, which are exclusively intended for, only as an interim measure, include like appointment of a guardian or any such measure for protection or preservation, custody or securing the amounts, detention or inspection including the appointment of a receiver, and further widens under clause (e) to take any further or wider measures as may be expedient in the circumstances, which the parties can seek for. Therefore, the relief as provided for or the application, which needs to be filed under the aforesaid provision is absolutely only an interim one but not an application for any substantive reliefs. In Sundaram Finance Ltd. v. Nepc India Ltd. limited, (1999) 2 SCC 479 : AIR 1999 SC 565 : 1999 (1) Arb. LR 305 (SC) it has been held that the interim orders under the aforesaid provision can be passed even before commencement of arbitration and even it need not be preceded by issuance of notice invoking the arbitration clause. Therefore, the court has ample power to pass appropriate orders even like ad interim, ex parte and also after notice and hearing the respondent, as the facts and circumstances warrant. Therefore, when disputes arise between the parties and where there is a provision for settlement of disputes by arbitration proceedings, the parties may have to approach for any such relief and necessarily it has to be treated only as an interim application and disposed of accordingly.

    12. In spite of such clear and categorical letter of the law under the aforesaid provision, it is brought to our notice that pending all such applications filed under Section 9 of the Act, seeking interim reliefs or measures or for any directions, once again further interim applications are being filed like the present one which is appealed against in this appeal, seeking further or varied interim reliefs by way of injunctions and directions which only amounts to duplication of the very enquiry and adds to the delays in disposal of main interim application and repetition of the exercise. Such action is not only not permissible and contemplated under the law but goes far beyond the scope of provision and objects intended under Section 9 of the Act. Therefore, it has to be seen that the very application filed under Section 9 of the Act itself should be treated as an interim application alone and shall accordingly be disposed of on the same procedure or approach as normally followed, This court is informed during the course of arguments that even the main applications filed under Section 9 of the said Act are being kept for quite long time for some or other reason including due to pendency of such further interlocutory applications and are being treated as a substantive application almost on par like a regular suit or other OP, touching upon the main lis. However, having regard to the very nature of the proceedings as provided for and as stated above, necessarily, wherever such applications are being filed by the parties, the court should take up the main application itself and dispose of in the same manner as an interim application but not to entertain any interim applications. In this case, no doubt, the court below has rejected the present interim application on the ground that it is in total variance with the main relief without taking up main application. We refrain from expressing any opinion on merits either way. Instead of entertaining applications of this nature, which may give scope to the parties to go on filing one application after the other pending the main application under Section 9 of the Act, the endeavour should be to take up the main application under Section 9 of the Act and dispose of the same as expeditiously as possible after appearance of the respondent. Therefore, we hold that having regard to the nature of proceedings as contemplated under Section 9 of the Act, further interim application as has been filed and framed is neither maintainable nor can require to be considered by the court. However, by taking into consideration the apprehensions expressed across the bar in regard to long pendency and delays in disposal of the applications filed under Section 9 of the Act, we hold that all such applications shall have an expeditious disposal as expeditiously as possible, immediately after the appearance of the respondent not later than three months from such appearance of the respondent. Such approach would be more apt and objectively meet the ends of justice.

    13. Having regard to the aforesaid reasons and facts and circumstances, we do not find any merits in the above appeal. The civil miscellaneous appeal is accordingly dismissed. However, the court below is directed to take up the main OP No. 338 of 2007 itself for an expeditious disposal not later than three (3) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gulf Oil Corporation Limited v. Singareni Collieries Company Limited And Anr.
    (Aug 20, 2007)