AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 32 (1) of the A.P. Civil Rules of Practice & Circular Orders, 1980 (for short "Civil Rules of Practice"),
  • provisions of Sections 32 and 33 of the Advocates Act.
  • provisions of Rules 32 and 33 of the Civil Rules
  • SECTION 32 ADVOCATES ACT 1961
  • Rules 32 and 33 of the Civil Rules
  • Order III Rule 2 of the Code
  • Rule 32 of the Civil Rules
  • Order 3, Rule 1, C.P.C.
  • Order 3 Rule 1
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 32 (1) of the A.P. Civil Rules of Practice & Circular Orders, 1980 (for short "Civil Rules of Practice"),
  • provisions of Sections 32 and 33 of the Advocates Act.
  • provisions of Rules 32 and 33 of the Civil Rules
  • SECTION 32 ADVOCATES ACT 1961
  • Rules 32 and 33 of the Civil Rules
  • Order III Rule 2 of the Code
  • Rule 32 of the Civil Rules
  • Order 3, Rule 1, C.P.C.
  • Order 3 Rule 1
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

A suit was filed for declaration of title and delivery of possession of the suit schedule property, along with rectification of entries in the revenue records. The suit was instituted by a General Power of Attorney (GPA) holder without obtaining prior court permission as required under Rule 32(1) of the Andhra Pradesh Civil Rules of Practice and Circular Orders, 1980 ("Civil Rules of Practice"). It was contended that such suit was non-est in law due to this procedural defect. The lower court dismissed an application related to this issue, which was challenged. A learned single Judge referred the matter to address whether the procedure under Rules 32 and 33 of the Civil Rules of Practice is mandatory or curable by subsequent application and whether the Court can rectify non-compliance depending on facts and circumstances.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the procedure contemplated under Rules 32 and 33 of the Civil Rules of Practice is mandatory or a curable irregularity that can be remedied by moving an appropriate application.
  2. Whether the Court can, depending on facts and circumstances, rectify non-compliance with these procedural rules.
  3. Whether a suit filed by a General Power of Attorney holder without prior court permission is maintainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The provisions of Rules 32 and 33 of the Civil Rules of Practice are mandatory and not curable by subsequent application.
  • Since the GPA holder filed the suit without court permission under Rule 32(1), the suit is non-est in law.
  • The plaint registration itself is without jurisdiction due to non-compliance.
  • Subsequent applications cannot cure the defect.
  • Relied on various precedents to support the mandatory nature of these rules.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Relied on judgments holding that presentation of plaint by a GPA holder coupled with the power of attorney and appearance by an advocate does not require prior court permission.
  • Absence of affidavit under Rule 33 does not invalidate the suit or warrant dismissal.
  • Objections not raised at earlier stages should be deemed waived.
  • Non-compliance is a curable irregularity, not going to the root of the case.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mohd Hasnuddin and Anr. v. Dontagari Sathamma, 2002 Suppl. (2) ALD 867 Presentation of plaint by GPA holder does not require court permission if advocate appears; absence of affidavit under Rule 33 is not fatal. Supported the view that non-compliance with affidavit requirement is curable and does not invalidate suit.
G.M. Uruj v. Anwar Hussain, 1990 (1) AWR 256 Agent other than advocate must file power of attorney and affidavit before acting; court must permit agent's appearance. Clarified procedure and emphasized court's permission requirement but also recognized curability of defects.
Indira Devi and Janab Sayeed Kazim Saheb v. Janab Sayeed Bakaran Saheb Judge must record in writing permission for GPA holder to appear; GPA holder enters party's shoes for evidence except personal knowledge. Confirmed procedural requirements and scope of GPA holder's capacity to depose on documentary evidence.
Hari Om Rajender Kumar v. Chief Rationing Officer of Civil Supplies, A.P. Distinguished right to appear and plead from other acts by GPA; GPA cannot plead unless court grants authority under Advocates Act. Emphasized that appearing/pleading is subject to Advocates Act provisions, limiting GPA's role without court permission.
Janab Sayeed Kazim Saheb's case Failure to raise objection on GPA holder's authority at trial stage amounts to waiver; defect is curable and does not invalidate plaint. Supported that procedural defects in GPA authority can be waived if not timely objected to.
Md. Munawar Hussain v. Usha Kiran Chit Funds, Sathupalli Irregularity in proceeding without following Rule 32 does not go to root of case; judgment and decree upheld. Rejected argument that non-compliance with Rule 32 invalidates proceedings.
Ismath Ahmedizade Mahmoodi Abidi v. Kurshidunnisa Begum GPA holder cannot represent party or depose on party's behalf but may appear as witness on personal knowledge. Clarified limits of GPA holder's role in litigation.
Kamal Silk Mills v. Kuncham Mohana Rao Judgment debtor cannot raise new objections in execution stage without prior permission to GPA holder; no evidence of discharge of decretal amount. Reinforced procedural safeguards and limits on raising GPA-related objections in execution.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the language and intent of Rules 32 and 33 of the Civil Rules of Practice, which regulate the authority and permission required for agents, other than advocates, to represent parties in court proceedings. It recognized that these rules were introduced to discourage parties from appointing non-advocate agents to represent them, emphasizing the importance of legal expertise in court appearances and pleadings.

The Court distinguished between different levels of authorization: signing pleadings alone versus full representation including adducing evidence and advancing arguments. For mere signing of pleadings, court permission by affidavit is not mandatory if the authorization is evident and the party is represented by an advocate. However, for full representation by an agent or GPA holder, prior court permission through an affidavit is necessary.

Further, the Court noted that non-compliance with these procedural rules, particularly the absence of prior permission, does not invariably render the suit invalid or non-est in law. It can be a curable irregularity, especially if objections were not raised timely. The Court relied on precedents holding that filing a subsequent application or affidavit can cure defects related to agent authorization.

Ultimately, the Court concluded that Rule 32 is not mandatory in all circumstances but serves as a procedural safeguard to ensure proper authorization and protect parties from unauthorized representation. The Court emphasized the need to balance procedural requirements with the interests of justice, allowing rectification depending on facts and circumstances.

Holding and Implications

The Court answered the reference by holding that Rule 32 of the Civil Rules of Practice is not mandatory in all cases but a procedural safeguard whose non-compliance can be curable depending on facts and circumstances.

The Court clarified that when a GPA holder is authorized only for limited purposes such as signing pleadings or giving evidence as a witness, prior court permission is not mandatory. However, if the GPA holder or agent is to represent the party fully by signing pleadings, adducing evidence, and advancing arguments, prior permission by filing an affidavit is necessary.

This decision directly affects the parties by permitting rectification of procedural defects related to agent authorization in appropriate cases and does not set a new precedent overriding existing legal principles but harmonizes procedural rigor with practical justice.

    Natubhai Chotabhai Patel v. Patnam Shakuntala And Another

    1. This is a reference made by a learned single Judge of this Court to answer the following questions:

    Whether the procedure contemplated under Rules 32 and 33 of the Civil Rules of Practice is mandatory or it is curable which can be cured by moving an appropriate application and whether the Court depending upon the facts and circumstances can rectify the same.

    2. A suit was filed for declaration of title and delivery of possession of the suit schedule property and also to rectify the entries in the revenue records etc. The suit was filed by the GPA holder, but they have not obtained the orders of the court permitting the GPA holder to represent on their behalf under rule 32 (1) of the a.p. civil rules of practice & circular orders, 1980 (for short "civil rules of practice"), therefore, it is contended that the said suit is non-est in the eye of law. Since the presentation itself is invalid presentation, the lower Court totally erred in dismissing the application instead of allowing the same as prayed for.

    3. After reference, the counsel representing both parties advanced arguments, therefore, the question whether the suit filed by the General Power of Attorney, without prior permission of the Court, is maintainable and whether Rules 32 and 33 of the Civil Rules of Practice are mandatory.

    4. Rules 32 and 33 read as follows:

    32. Party appearing by Agent:

    (1) When a party appears by any agent, other than an advocate, the agent shall, before making of or doing any appearance, application, or act, in or to the Court, file in court the power of attorney, or written authority, thereunto authorizing him or a properly authenticated copy thereof together with an affidavit that the said authority still subsisting, or, in the case of an agent carrying on a trade or business on behalf of a party, without a written authority, an affidavit stating the residence of his principal, the trade or business carried on by the agent on his behalf and the connection of the same with the subject matter of the suit, and that no other agent is expressly authorized to make or do such appearance, application, or act.

    (2) The Judge may thereupon record in writing that the agent is permitted to appear and act on behalf of the party; and unless and until the said permission is granted, no appearance, application, or act, of the agent shall be recognized by the Court.

    33. Signing or verification by Agent:

    If any proceeding, which under any provision of law or these rules, is required to be signed or verified by a party, is signed or verified by any person on his behalf, a written authority in this behalf signed by the party shall be filed in court, together with an affidavit verifying the signature of the party, and stating the reason of his inability to sign or verify the proceeding, and stating the means of knowledge or the facts set out in the proceeding of the person signing or verifying the same and that such person is a recognized agent of the party as defined by Order III Rule 2 of the Code and is duly authorized and competent so to do.

    5. The learned Counsel for the petitioner placed reliance on the following Judgments:

    Mohd Hasnuddin and Anr. v. Dontagari Sathamma 2002 Suppl. (2) ALD 867, G.M. Uruj v. Anwar Hussain , Secretary to Government of India, Ministry of Defence, New Delhi v. Indira Devi and Janab Sayeed Kazim Saheb v. Janab Sayeed Bakaran Saheb 1990 (1) AWR 256, wherein a learned single Judge of this Court held as follows:

    the presentation of the plaint signed and verified by the power of attorney holder coupled with the very power of attorney executed in his favour filed in the court, does not require any permission from the court, for an advocate duly appointed by the said power of attorney holder, duly authorizing him in this behalf, entered appearance in the court. The absence of an affidavit (under Rule 33) however does not invalidate the suit resulting in dismissal thereof.

    6. The learned Counsel for the petitioner contended that this view expressed by the learned single Judge cannot be sustained in view of the provisions of Rules 32 and 33 of the Civil Rules of Practice and the language employed therein is mandatory and is not a curable irregularity. He also contended that an application filed subsequently cannot cure the defect, therefore, the very registration of the plaint itself can be said to be without jurisdiction, therefore, it has to be considered whether the provisions are mandatory. The following decisions are helpful in resolving the issue in question:

    7. In Indira Devi's case (3 supra), a Division Bench of this High Court held as follows:

    The requirement is that when GPA-holder is representing the party, the Judge is required to record in writing that he is permitted to appear and act on behalf of the party. In the instant case, the procedure prescribed under Rule 32 of the Civil Rules of Practice has been followed. When once a person files a suit on behalf of the party, as a GPA holder he enters into the shoes of that party and except to the extent of personal knowledge, he is entitled to depose on other facts. In the instant case, what was relied upon by the plaintiffs is entirely documentary evidence, which are public documents and no personal knowledge was required to be pressed into service to establish the case of Plaintiff.

    8. In G.M. Uruj v. Anwar Hussain (2 Supra), a learned single Judge of this Court held that under Rule 32 of the Civil Rules of Practice if a party appears by any agent other than an Advocate, he should file before the Court the power of attorney authorizing him to act with authenticated document together with an affidavit that the said authority was still subsisting. Thereupon the Judge will permit the person to act on behalf of the party. The authenticated document together with an affidavit filed by the agent for permission of the Court to act on behalf of the party, certified copy of GPA properly notorised filed with application for permission, the objection raised by other side that they identified the person who is said to have executed the document is in doubt is not sustainable.

    9. In Hari Om Rajender Kumar v. Chief Rationing Officer of Civil Supplies, A.P. , a learned single Judge of this Court while dealing with the scope of Order 3 Rule 1 held that:

    It has to be noticed that Section 33 of the Act uses the word 'practice' while Section 32 uses the word 'to appear' in the Courts etc. The word 'practice' means appear, act, and plead, unless there is anything in the subject or context to limit its meaning. Therefore, the word 'appear' is only one aspect and does not take in the concept of 'pleading' without which, it cannot be equated to 'practising'. The right to appear in Court and plead for a principal as also the right to practise in Courts have to be distinguished from the other acts, which a power of attorney can perform under Order 3, Rule 1, C.P.C. So far as the signing or verifying or doing other acts are concerned, these could be done by the power of Attorney duly authorized therefore but so far as appearing or practicing in Court are concerned, they are subject to the provisions of Sections 32 and 33 of the Advocates Act. As such the power-of-attorney holder cannot plead or practise in Court for a principal unless special authority by the Courts in that behalf under Section 32 of the Advocates Act (1961).

    10. In Janab Sayeed Kazim Saheb's case (supra), it is seen that the objection has not been taken by the defendant in his written statement nor raised in the lower Court. What all has been averred in the written statement is that the GPA holder must apply to the court seeking permission from it, which is not done so; nor any such objection raised in the evidence. On the basis of this, the learned Counsel for the plaintiffs-respondents argued that the objection must be deemed to have been waived by the defendant, therefore, it will not be proper to allow the defendant to raise this plea at the appellate stage that the plaintiff failed to file an affidavit accompanying the plaint within the meaning of Rule 33, more so when such a defect is mere curable irregularity and does not invalidate the plaint resulting in dismissal.

    11. In Md. Munawar Hussain v. Usha Kiran Chit Funds, Sathupalli, Khammam District and Ors. , a learned Judge of Civil court did not follow the procedure contemplated under Rule 32 and only after numbering of the suit, he has decided the issue, that irregularity in proceeding with the suit was held not to go to the roots of the case. Under those circumstances, the High Court held that it is not inclined to accept the contention of the counsel for the petitioner that the Judgment and the decree in the above case are contrary to Rule 32.

    12. In G.M. Uruj v. Anwar Hussain (2 supra), in execution proceedings, a lengthy counter affidavit was filed by the defendant contending that the plaintiff has failed to mention categorically that the GPA in question was bogus or fabricated and the averments in the said counter showed that the defendant was absconding and avoiding summons issued by the court below. The High Court held that the GPA holder was not permitted to act and appear on his behalf of the defendant.

    13. In Ismath Ahmedizade Mahmoodi Abidi v. Kurshidunnisa Begum , the A.P. High Court held that a General Power of Attorney holder cannot be permitted to represent the party in the suit and to depose on his/her behalf, but it is always open to the General Power of Attorney holder to appear as a witness in his/her personal capacity to speak about the facts which are in his/her personal knowledge about the case.

    14. In Kamal Silk Mills v. Kuncham Mohana Rao , an order has been passed by the Court below showing that specific contention was raised by the judgment debtor claiming that the decretal amount was already discharged and he need not pay any amount towards the decree, but he failed to place before the Court as proof any receipt to that effect issued by the petitioner, and that no permission was obtained from the original Court under Rule 32 of the Civil Rules of Practice authorizing the General power of Attorney holder to present on behalf of the original decree holder as long as the General Power of Attorney was in force, and that the Court below failed to notice that no such contention was ever raised in the suit, therefore, the High Court held that the Judgment debtor was not to raise such a plea at the stage of execution of the decree.

    15. A party generally represented by an Advocate. This provision enables an agent to represent the party. This provision has been introduced to discourage the parties to appoint the agents to represent them in the Courts than the legal practitioners. The wording "when a party appears by any agent other than an Advocate" used in Rule 32 clearly indicates that the authorization is for all purposes including the filing of the pleadings, examination of the witnesses, marking of the documents and advancing of the arguments, which is generally expected to be performed by an Advocate who is a legal expert in the field. If an agent represents the party, he may not know the implications and complications of the issues involved in the matter, thereby it is likely to cause injustice to the party. If the party prepares to take the risk of authorizing an agent, it is an indication that the party is prepared to reap the consequences by appointing an agent. In order to make sure that the party authorized the agent to represent him in the matter, an affidavit is necessary. But in cases of authorizing an agent to sign the pleadings while authorizing a legal practitioner to appear on his behalf, it is sufficient if the court is satisfied that he was authorized to sign and in such a case, the filing of an affidavit is not mandatory, therefore, the defect can be cured at a later stage also by convincing the court that the agent was duly authorized by the respective party in that matter. But if an agent is authorized to undertake the signing of pleadings, adducing of evidence and advancing of arguments, the agent shall be permitted in writing and the party has to file an affidavit that he has duly authorized the agent to represent him instead of an Advocate. In case of a party executing a General Power of Attorney in favour of another person, the General Power of Attorney holder also cannot be permitted to represent the party in the suit for all purposes namely to sign the pleadings, to adduce evidence and to advance arguments unless an affidavit is filed by the party affirming that he has authorized his General Power of Attorney holder to represent his case for the above purposes. But for mere signing of the pleadings on behalf of the party duly represented by an Advocate, permission from the court is not necessary by way of filing an affidavit to that effect. It is sufficient if the court is satisfied that the agent or power of attorney holder is duly authorized to sign the pleadings, after perusal of such authorization, which was filed along with the pleadings.

    16. In the light of the decisions rendered by this Court, it is made clear that Rule 32 is not mandatory.

    17. In the light of the foregoing discussion, it is made clear that Rule 32 of the Civil Rules of Practice was introduced to discourage the parties to authorize their agents to represent their cases by way of signing the pleadings, adducing evidence and advancing arguments instead of authorizing a legal practitioner. If an agent or a General Power of Attorney holder is authorized to perform the above duties on behalf of the party, the obtaining of permission from the court by filing an affidavit by the party is necessary. If the agent or GPA holder is authorized only to sign the pleadings or to give evidence as a witness, in such circumstances, Rule 32 is not mandatory. The Rule was introduced to discourage the parties to authorize their agents and to engage the legal practitioners to represent their cases and in case of the agent or general power of attorney holder is authorized by the party to sign the pleadings or to give evidence, it is sufficient if the Court is satisfied on verification of such authorization that he is duly authorized by the party for those limited purposes.

    18. The Reference is, accordingly, answered.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Natubhai Chotabhai Patel v. Patnam Shakuntala And Another
    (Jul 28, 2006)