AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 5 of the A.P Excise (Arrack and Toddy Licenses General Conditions) Rules, 1969 (hereinafter referred
  • Section 3 of the A.P Excise Act (for short the Act)
  • Rule 5 of the Rules,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 5 of the A.P Excise (Arrack and Toddy Licenses General Conditions) Rules, 1969 (hereinafter referred
  • Section 3 of the A.P Excise Act (for short the Act)
  • Rule 5 of the Rules,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Court's Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

These two writ petitions arise from contestation over a toddy shop allegedly located at Survey No. 10/2 (Habsiguda revenue village / part of Uppal Municipality) in or adjacent to the Osmania University campus. Osmania University, founded by H.E.H. Nizam, grew into a large campus containing multiple colleges. Over time the Excise Department granted licences to establish toddy shops and bars in and around the campus, prompting protests from the University administration, alumni and students.

The licensee (the 5th respondent in W.P. No. 7602/2003 and petitioner in W.P. No. 25979/2003) was granted a licence to run a toddy shop at the location in dispute. The University objected on the grounds that the shop was on University land and within the prohibited distance from educational institutions and a place of worship. Prolonged correspondence followed.

On 2-2-1999 the Prohibition and Excise Superintendent (third respondent) issued proceedings directing the licensee to choose another location. The licensee filed W.P. No. 3526/1999 and obtained interim protection; that writ was ultimately allowed on 5-7-2001 on the sole ground that the third respondent lacked jurisdiction, leaving open the power of the Commissioner of Excise (second respondent) to pass appropriate orders.

Despite the 1999 proceedings, the Excise Department later renewed the license (the licence was renewed up to 31-3-2007), prompting the University to file W.P. No. 7602/2003 challenging the renewal. The licensee filed W.P. No. 25979/2003 challenging subsequent proceedings dated 17-11-2003 (by the second respondent) and 19-11-2003 (by the third respondent) directing shifting of the shop.

The Court directed the Assistant Director of Survey and Land Records (Ranga Reddy District) to survey the site. The Assistant Director surveyed on 6-1-2004 and produced a sketch and report indicating that the shop is inside a wall separating Survey Nos. 10/2 and 11/2 and that Survey No. 10/2 (admeasuring Ac. 16.326 guntas) appears registered in the name of the University. The Court found on the sketch and report that the shop is within the campus and within the prohibited distance from a temple and staff quarters.

The Court reached final dispositions: W.P. No. 7602 of 2003 was allowed; W.P. No. 25979 of 2003 was dismissed. The Court directed respondents to ensure no excise shop functions within the prohibited distance measured from the outer limit of the University campus and to shift any such shops within two months of receipt of the order. The Court clarified it was not pronouncing on title to the land.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the toddy shop in Survey No. 10/2 is located within the Osmania University campus and therefore within the prohibited distance from an educational institution and a place of worship under Rule 5 of the A.P. Excise (Arrack and Toddy Licenses General Conditions) Rules, 1969.
  2. Whether the grant and subsequent renewal of the licence to the licensee were in conformity with Rule 5 and, if not, whether the Excise authorities (particularly the third respondent) acted within their jurisdiction in issuing and renewing the licence.
  3. Whether the Commissioner of Excise (second respondent) had the power to require shifting of the shop under Section 3 of the A.P. Excise Act, and whether the consequential action taken by the third respondent (ordering selection of alternative premises) was valid.

Arguments of the Parties

University (Standing Counsel)

  • Submitted that the shop was established within the University campus and caused nuisance to staff and students.
  • Relied on Rule 5 of the A.P. Excise (Arrack and Toddy Licenses General Conditions) Rules, 1969, to argue that the entire campus must be treated as an "educational institution" and licences are prohibited within 50 metres measured from the campus boundary.
  • Contended that granting renewal of the licence was a mala fide exercise of power to benefit the licensee.
  • Pointed out that the Court in W.P. No. 3526/1999 left open the possibility for the Commissioner of Excise to require shifting, and that the second respondent subsequently issued such a direction.

Licensee (Sri Raghuveer Reddy)

  • Asserted the toddy shop had existed for more than a decade and was established on private land purchased under sale deed dated 3-11-1966.
  • Maintained there were no specific complaints of disturbance or nuisance and that the action was motivated by personal animus of certain individuals.
  • Contended the third respondent lacked jurisdiction to require selection of alternative premises.

Government Pleader for Prohibition and Excise

  • Explained that, given objections from the University administration and students, the Commissioner of Excise (second respondent) issued proceedings dated 17-11-2003 and the third respondent's order dated 19-11-2003 was consequential.
  • Relied on Section 3 of the A.P. Excise Act to submit that the second respondent has the power of regulation and superintendence enabling issuance of the impugned proceedings.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by first identifying the statutory rule and its definition. It quoted Rule 5 of the A.P. Excise (Arrack and Toddy Licenses General Conditions) Rules, 1969 which prohibits the establishment of excise shops within 50 metres from places of worship or educational institutions, and reproduced explanation (ii):

"'Educational Institution' means any Primary School, Middle School and High School recognized by the State Government or Central Government or any college affiliated to any University establishing by law."

The Court interpreted Rule 5 in context. It held that because the Osmania University campus comprises several colleges (Arts College, Science College, College of Engineering, College of Technology, Law College, College of Business Management etc.), the entire campus must be treated as an "educational institution" for the purposes of Rule 5 and the 50-metre prohibited distance must be measured from the outer boundary of the campus. The Court reasoned that a narrower interpretation could permit excise shops between colleges inside the campus, which could never have been the intention of the rule-making authority.

To resolve the factual dispute about the shop's precise location, the Court directed an official survey. The Assistant Director of Survey and Land Records surveyed on 6-1-2004 and produced a sketch and report indicating that the shop stood inside the wall separating Survey Nos. 10/2 and 11/2, and that Survey No. 10/2 (Ac. 16.326 guntas) was shown in the revenue records as registered in the name of the University. On perusal of that sketch and report, the Court found that the shop was within the campus and within the prohibited distances from a temple and staff quarters.

The Court reviewed the administrative chronology: proceedings dated 2-2-1999 by the third respondent had required shifting, but the third respondent was found, by earlier order in W.P. No. 3526/1999, to lack jurisdiction to issue that direction; the Court had left open the competence of the Commissioner of Excise to issue appropriate orders. Instead of prompt corrective action, the third respondent had renewed the licence on 11-4-2002, which the Court criticized as an irresponsible act that perpetuated the illegality.

The Court addressed jurisdictional and rights-contentions. It reiterated that nobody has a fundamental right to carry on trade in excise (noting this has been so held by the Supreme Court repeatedly — no specific cases were cited in this opinion). It held that the second respondent's power to issue necessary instructions is contained in Section 3 of the A.P. Excise Act; because the Court had earlier left the matter open for the second respondent to pass orders, the post-2003 directions issued by respondents 2 and 3 were held to be competent (though the Court noted they were belated). The Court therefore found no legal exception to the impugned proceedings directed at shifting the shop.

The Court directed that, following its interpretation of Rule 5 (treating the entire campus as an educational institution), the Respondents 2 and 3 must ensure that no excise shop of any category be permitted to function within the prohibited distance measured from the outer limit of the University campus and must take appropriate steps to shift any such shops within two months from receipt of a copy of the order. The Court expressly clarified that its observations were not to be treated as pronouncement on title to the land.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition: The Court ordered that W.P. No. 7602 of 2003 is allowed and W.P. No. 25979 of 2003 is dismissed.

Direct implications for the parties and administration:

  • The Court found the toddy shop to be within the Osmania University campus and within the prohibited distances under Rule 5; accordingly the grant and renewal of the licence at that location were in contravention of the Rules and the third respondent's acts in granting/renewing the licence were held to be illegal.
  • The Commissioner of Excise (second respondent) was held to possess power under Section 3 of the A.P. Excise Act to issue directions; the respondents were ordered to ensure that no excise shop functions within the prohibited distance measured from the outer limit of the campus.
  • The respondents 2 and 3 were directed to take steps to shift any excise shops within that prohibited distance within two months of receiving a copy of the order.
  • The Court emphasized that its findings on location and Rule 5's application do not constitute or decide questions of title to the land.

The opinion contains an interpretation of Rule 5 (treating the entire University campus as an "educational institution" for measuring the prohibited 50-metre distance) and directs administrative action; it did not cite or rely upon any specific reported precedents in the text supplied.

    Osmania University, Hyderabad v. Government Of A.P And Others

    COMMON JUDGMENT

    1. The subject-matter of these two writ petitions is common. Hence they are disposed of through a common judgment.

    2. H.E.H Nizam, a Dynastic Ruler thought it appropriate to bring about an excellent place of learning and education and had constructed beautiful edifices in a sprawling campus. He named it as Osmania University. It has grownup as an excellent place of learning shortly after it was established. After independence, it was flanked with important institution like the R.R Labs (now ACT), N.G.R.I, Survey of India C.C.M.B etc. The priorities of the successive Governments appear to have changed, particularly in the context of maintenance of serene and congenial atmosphere in the educational institutions. It is a different thing that several residential localities have come up all-round the campus. However, in pursuit of its object of earning as much revenue as possible through sale of intoxicants, it started granting licenses to establish Toddy shops and Bars right inside or just around the campus. The Alumni and the administration of the University had to record their protest and raise voices against such disturbing developments. Their voice is subdued or was rendered inaudible by the powerful liquor lobbies or the Excise Department. The 5th respondent in W.P No. 7602 of 2003, who is the petitioner in W.P No. 25979 of 2003 (hereinafter referred to as the licencee) was granted licence to establish and run a toddy shop in the land in Survey No. 10/2 of Habsiguda revenue village and part of Uppal Municipality, Osmania University, the Petitioner in W.P No. 7602 of 2003 went on objecting to the very establishment of the shop. According to it, the shop was established on the land belongjhg to the University and at any rate within the prohibited distance from educational institution and a place of worship. Prolonged correspondence ensued between the University on the one hand and the Excise department on the other. After such long drawn battle, the Prohibition and Excise Superintendent, Hyderabad (hereinafter referred to as the third respondent) issued proceedings dated 2-2-1999 directing the licensee to choose another location for establishment of their shop. The licencee filed W.P No. 3526 of 1999 in this Court and an interim order was obtained. The writ petition was ultimately allowed on 5-7-2001 on the sole ground that the third respondent did not have the jurisdiction to issue the order impugned therein. It was, however, left open to the Commissioner of Excise, (hereinafter referred to as the second respondent) to pass appropriate orders Nobody disputed the power of the Commissioner to require shifting of the shop.

    3. The allegation of the University that the proceedings dated 2-2-1999 were issued only as an eye-wash gains strength with the conduct of the Excise Department subsequent to the orders in W.P No. 3526 of 1999. The licence of the licensee was to expire on 1-10-2001. This Court, through its order dated 25-1-2001 directed that it shall be competent for the second respondent to pass appropriate orders for shifting. They have not chosen to do so. On the other hand the department had favoured the licensee by granting renewal up to 31-3-2007. The University became helpless. Therefore, it had filed W.P No. 7602 of 2003 challenging the orders granting renewal of the licence of the 5th respondent and sought for directions to set aside the same.

    4. This Court granted an interim order on 28-4-2003 in W.P No. 25979 of 2003. The same was, however, vacated by a learned Single Judge, through orders dated 13-5-2003 in W.V.M.P 1774 of 2003 and it was affirmed in a writ appeal. The students and administration of the University have also stepped up their protest. It was in this context, that the second respondent had issued proceedings dated 17-11-2003 directing the shifting of the shop. Consequently, the third respondent issued proceedings dated 19-11-2003 directing the licensee to select alternative suitable premises for location of the Toddy shop. W.P No. 25979 of 2003 is filed by the licencee challenging the said proceedings.

    5. Learned Standing Counsel for the University submits that the licensee had established the Toddy shop right in the University campus and is causing nuisance to the staff and students. Placing reliance on Rule 5 of the A.P Excise (Arrack and Toddy Licenses General Conditions) Rules, 1969 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules’) learned Counsel submits that it was impermissible for the Excise Authorities to grant licence to the 5th respondent to establish the shop in question. According to him, the entire campus of the University has to be treated as an educational institution and grant of licenses within 50 metres from the boundary of the campus, not to speak of any place within the campus was contrary to rules. He also submits that the grant of renewal in favour of the licensee was nothing but mala fide exercise of power, to confer benefit upon the licencee. Supporting the order, which is impugned in W.P No. 25979 of 2003, he submits that this Court in its order in W.P No. 3526 of 2002 had taken the view that it is competent for the second respondent to require shifting of the shop. He submits that on a direction issued by the second respondent, the order of the 3rd respondent dated 19-11-2003 was issued and that no exception can be taken to the same.

    6. Learned Counsel for the licensee Sri Raghuveer Reddy on the other hand submits the shop in question was in existence since more than a decade and it was established in a private land purchased under sale deed dated 3-11-1966. According to him, there were no specific complaints of any disturbance or nuisance and it was only to satisfy the ego of some selected individuals, the impugned action was taken. It is also his case that the third respondent has no jurisdiction to require the petitioner to select alternative premises.

    7. The learned Government Pleader for Prohibition and Excise submits that taking into account the objections raised by the University administration and the students, the second respondent has issued instructions in his proceedings dated 17-11-2003 and the order passed by the third respondent on 19-11-2003 is only a consequential step. Placing reliance upon Section 3 of the A.P Excise Act (for short ‘the Act’) he submits that the second respondent is vested with the power of regulation and superintendence and the impugned proceedings are initiated in exercise of such power.

    8. As observed in the preceding paragraphs, the students and the administration of the University have been recording their protest since last several years against the existence of a toddy shop established by the licensee. Their objection was two fold viz., that the shop is established in the land belonging to the University and that it is within the prohibited distance from the University campus and a temple. The first aspect of the matter is outside the scope of these two writ petitions. It has to be seen as to whether the shop of the licensee is established in contravention of any provisions of the Act and Rules.

    9. Rule 5 of the Rules prohibits the establishment of excise shops within 50 metres from the places of worship or educational institutions. The term ‘educational institution’ is defined in explanation (ii) of Rule 5 which reads as under:

    “‘Educational Institution’ means any Primary School, Middle School and High School recognized by the State Government or Central Government or any college affiliated to any University establishing by law.”

    10. The University campus comprises of various colleges. In the Osmania University, several colleges such as Arts College, Science College, College of Engineering, College of Technology, Law College, College of Business Management etc., are within the campus. The entire campus has to be treated as educational institution for the purpose of Rule 5. Any other interpretation may even enable the grant of licenses in between colleges within the campus. Having regard to the clamor of the Government, particularly the Excise Department for earning as much revenue as possible by granting licenses, a situation may even arise when excise shops can be established within the campus duly maintaining 50 metres distance from the Colleges, if there is a pliable head of the administration of the University. That can never be said to have been the intention of the rule making authority. Therefore, there is no escape from the conclusion that in the context of Rule 5, the entire campus has to be treated as educational institution and the distance has to be measured from the outer boundary of the campus.

    11. The parties to the proceedings have made contradictory claims as to the location of the shop. While the University contended that it is within its campus, the licensee contended that it is outside the same. To have a definite information about the matter, this Court directed the Assistant Director of Survey and Land Records, Ranga Reddy District to undertake a survey of the concerned place and to submit a report as well as sketch to indicate as to whether the shop in question is within the campus of the University. The Assistant Director, in turn, had conducted survey on 6-1-2004 and prepared a sketch. The sketch discloses that the shop is in Survey No. 10/2. The report as well as the sketch indicate that the University Campus is separated by a wall constructed between the Survey numbers 10/2 and 11/2 and that the shop is inside the wall. The Assistant Director has also referred to the revenue records whereunder Survey No. 10/2 admeasuring Ac. 16.326 guntas is said to be registered in the name of the University. Though the title dispute is not the subject-matter of this writ petition, on a perusal of the sketch furnished by the Assistant Director of Survey and Land Records, this Court finds that the shop is right within the campus and within the prohibited distances from the temple in Survey No. 11/1 and staff quarters etc. Hence, the grant and renewal of licence by the Excise authorities in favour of the licensee was in contravention of the provisions of the rules and the 3rd respondent has committed illegality in granting and renewing the licence at the said place.

    12. Through proceedings dated 2-2-1999, the third respondent required the licensee to select alternative premises. That was challenged in W.P No. 3526 of 1999. This Court had set aside the same on the sole ground that the third respondent did not have the jurisdiction to issue the said orders. It was specifically contended before this Court that it was competent for the second respondent to issue such directions. It was left open for the second respondent to pass appropriate orders. Instead of taking proper steps to rectify the illegality committed by them and to ensure proper atmosphere in the University Campus, the third respondent had chosen to renew the licence through his proceedings dated 11-4-2002. To say the least, it was irresponsible on the part of the third respondent to have granted such a renewal. If at all anything, it only shows the type of education, he has received or the regard he has for educational institutions. He appears to have kept his thirst for funds, be it for himself or for the State, above the interests of the students in particular and the campus in general. Though the licensee was successful in getting the interim stay vacated, the second respondent has seen to reason atleast at a belated stage. He issued proceedings dated 17-11-2003 requiring shifting of the shop. The third respondent issued consequential proceedings dated 19-11-2003.

    13. Several contentions have been raised in challenge to these proceedings. Firstly, it has to be noticed that no individual has any fundamental right to carry on trade in Excise. It has been so held by the Honorable Supreme Court time and again. Secondly, the power of the second respondent to issue necessary instructions is contained in Section 3 of the Act. Further, this Court made it clear that it shall be competent for him to pass appropriate orders in the context of the licensee itself. Therefore, no exception can be taken to the impugned proceedings. The exception if at all is only to the undue delay after which they have been issued. At least at a belated stage, the Respondents 2 and 3 have chosen to spare the one prominent educational institution from the purview of their wide net to earn as much revenue as possible through sale of intoxicants. Learned Counsel for the licensee submits that his client has been singled out in the matter of shifting and states that several shops are existing within the prohibited distance. Since this Court recorded a finding that the entire University Campus has to be treated as an educational institution for the purpose of Rule 5 of the Rules, it is directed that the Respondents 2 and 3 shall ensure that no excise shop of any category whatever is permitted to function within the prohibited distance measured from the outer limit of the Campus of the University and take appropriate steps to shift them within two months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. It is, however, made clear that any observation made herein shall not be treated as pronouncement of the title of the parties to the land in question.

    14. Accordingly, W.P No. 7602 of 2003 is allowed and W.P No. 25979 of 2003 is dismissed in terms indicated above.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Osmania University, Hyderabad v. Government Of A.P And Others
    (Jan 27, 2004)