Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision petition was filed challenging the judgment and order dated 17-9-1997 passed by the Additional Subordinate Judge, Eluru in E.A. No.217 of 1997 in E.P. No.82 of 1997 in OS No.74 of 1991. The impugned order rejected the decree-holder’s petition seeking attachment of the respondents’ pension, holding that the pension could not be attached. The Court below relied on judgments from the High Court of Sindh and the High Court of Madras. The petitioner contended that while pension is not attachable under Section 60 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC), the commuted pension is attachable. The respondents relied on a Supreme Court judgment and a Madras High Court judgment to contend that even the commuted pension cannot be attached as it is also a pension amount.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the commuted portion of a pension is liable to attachment under Section 60 of the CPC.
  2. Whether Section 11 of the Pensions Act, 1871, protects the commuted pension from attachment in execution of a decree.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • Under Section 60 of the CPC, pension is not attachable, but the commuted pension can be attached.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • Reliance on the Supreme Court judgment in Union of India v. Wing Commander R.R. Hingorani and a Madras High Court judgment to argue that the commuted pension also cannot be attached since it remains a pension amount.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
AIR (29) 1942 page 19 (High Court of Sindh) Protection of pension from attachment Relied upon by the court below to hold pension not attachable
1940 MWN page 1150 (High Court of Madras) Interpretation of Section 11, Pensions Act, 1871, protecting commuted pension from attachment Held that commuted pension cannot be attached; the court below relied on this
Union of India v. Wing Commander R.R. Hingorani, (1987) 2 SCJ 60 (Supreme Court) Section 11 of the Pensions Act includes commuted pension within protection from attachment Approved the Madras High Court’s interpretation and clarified that commuted pension is protected
C. Gopaiachariar v. Deepchand Sowear, AIR 1941 Mad.207 (Madras High Court) Protection of pension and commuted pension under Section 11, Pensions Act Supported the view that commuted pension is money "due on account of pension" and protected from attachment
58 Mad 469 ('35) 22 AIR 1935 Mad 249 Interpretation of commuted pension as money due on account of pension Applied to reject contention that commuted pension is not pension for attachment purposes

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the issue by referring to Section 11 of the Pensions Act, 1871, which protects pensions granted by the Government from attachment. The Court noted that the High Court of Madras had interpreted this provision to include the commuted portion of the pension as "money due or to become due on account of any such pension," thus extending the protection to commuted pensions as well. The Court examined the ordinary meaning of the phrase "on account of" and found that commuted pension payments are indeed money payable because of the pension, as commutation is considered a mode of payment of pension under the Civil Pensions (Commutation) Rules.

The Court further relied on the Supreme Court’s approval of the Madras High Court’s interpretation, which clarified that commuted pension falls within the scope of Section 11 and is protected from attachment. The Court also referred to a Government Circular reinforcing this interpretation. Consequently, the Court concluded that the commuted pension enjoys the same protection as the pension itself and cannot be attached under Section 60 CPC when read with Section 11 of the Pensions Act.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is dismissed.

The Court held that the commuted pension, like the pension itself, is protected from attachment under Section 11 of the Pensions Act, 1871, and Section 60 of the CPC. The decision of the Court below rejecting attachment of the commuted pension is upheld. The direct effect is that the commuted pension of the respondents cannot be attached in execution of a decree. The opinion does not establish any new precedent beyond affirming existing legal principles.

    T. Sakuntala v. B. Satya Murthy & Anr.

    1. This revision petition is filed being aggrieved by the judgment and order dated 17-9-1997 passed by the Additional Subordinate Judge, Eluru in E.A. No.217 of 1997 in E.P. No.82 of 1997 in OS No.74 of 1991. By the impugned order, the Court below rejected the petition filed by the decree-holder, on the ground that the pension of the respondents cannot be attached. The Court below relied upon a judgment of the High Court of Sindh reported in AIR (29) 1942 page 19 and also the judgment of the High Court of Madras reported in 1940 MWN page 1150. The learned Counsel for the petitioner strenuously contended that under section 60 of cpc, pension is not attachable, but the commuted pension can be attached. Whereas, on the side of the respondents, reliance is placed on the judgment of Supreme Court reported in Union of India v. Wing Commander, R.R. Hingorani, (1987) 2 SCJ 60, and also the judgment of the Madras High Court reported in C. Gopaiachariar v. Deepchand Sowear, AIR 1941 Mad.207, contending that the commuted pension also cannot be attached, since it is also a pension amount.

    2. From the reading of the judgment of the High Court of Madras, (supra), I find that the High Court of Madras interpreting Section 11 of the Pensions Act, 1871, held that even the commuted pension cannot be attached in pursuance of an execution of a decree. I think it appropriate to extract the relevant portion of the said judgment as under:

    "In the present case it was urged in the Courts below, and the same contention is repeated in this Court, that the commuted portion of the pension is not attachable by reason of the provisions of Section 11, Pensions Act, which runs as follows:

    No pension granted or continued by Government on political considerations, or on account of past services or present infirmities or as a compassionate allowance, and no money due or to become due on account of any such pension or allowance, shall be liable to seizure, attached or sequestration by process of any Court in British India, at the instance of a creditor, for any demand against the pensioner, or in satisfaction of a decree or order of any such Court.

    Reliance is specially placed on the clause "and no money due or to become due on account of any such pension or allowance" because in view of the Bench decision in 58 Mad 469 ('35) 22 AIR 1935 Mad 249, it is not really possible for the petitioner to contend successfully that the commuted portion of the pension is still pension so as to bring these cases under the first portion of the Section. The question therefore is whether the commuted portion of the pension - I am using these words; "commuted portion of the pension" as they are the words employed in the rule relating to this subject which defines the legal effect of an order of commutation, namely Rule 6(2) of Civil Pensions (Commutation) Rules - is "money due or to become due on account of pension."

    The point is not covered by any authority; in any case no authority bearing on it has been quoted before me and no judicial interpretation of the words "on account of " has been brought to my notice. The phrase is a phrase used in ordinary parlance and it is certainly not a term ofart which has acquired a definite or precise meaning in law. The ordinary dictionary meaning of the phrase has to be ascertained and applied to the facts of the present case. The meaning given in the New English Dictionary as well as in Websters Dictionary is 'for the sake of 'by reason of' or 'because of. Now can it be said that the commuted portion of the pension is not money due on account of the pension? Though the pension has been commuted, still can it be said that money due because of, or by reason of such commutation is not money due on account of the pension? It is brought to my notice by the learned Advocate for the petitioner that Section 10 which relates to commutation of pension is part of Chapter III which is headed "Mode of Payment". In other words, the commutation of pension is regarded as a mode of payment of pension. If so, can it be reasonably urged that payment of the commutation amount is not payment on account of the pension, though not of the pension itself, because after commutation it ceases to be pension? I see no good reason why it should be deemed to be otherwise. No doubt money is due immediately under the commutation order, but the commutation order itself is on account of a pension which was commuted or a portion of the pension which was commuted. The intention behind the provisions of Section 11, Pensions Act, is applicable to the commuted portion as well as to the uncommuted portion of the pension and the language of Section 11 does not appear to exclude from its protection, the money that is due under a commutation order commuting a part of the pension, I am therefore of opinion that in these cases that attachments were contrary to the provisions of Section 11, Pensions Act, and it follows therefore, that these petitions must be allowed and the attachments must be set aside with costs in all the Courts."

    From the other judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court cited (supra), I find that the judgment of the High Court of Madras cited (supra) has been approved by the Supreme Court. By interpreting the said Section 11 of the Pensions Act and also the Circular No.F7(28) E.V/53 dated August, 25, 1985, the Hon'ble Supreme Court ruled as under:

    "It bears out the construction that the words "money due or to become due on account of pension" occurring in Section 11 of the Pensions Act, 1871 includes the commuted portion of the pension payable to an employee after his retirement. It must accordingly be held that the Government had no authority or power to unilaterally deduct the amount of Rs.20,482.78 p. from the commuted pension payable to the respondent, contrary to Section 11 of the Pensions Act, 1871.

    13. For these reasons, the appeal partly succeeds and is allowed. The judgment and order of the High Court are set aside."

    In view of the above law declared by the Supreme Court, it is clear that even the commuted pension in the hands of the pensioner also has the same protection as the pension. In this view of the matter, the commuted pension also cannot be attached in terms of Section 60 CPC, since it has to be read with Section 11 of the Pensions Act, 1871. It is not in dispute that Pensions Act, 1871 is still in force. Having regard to these circumstances, the conclusions of the Court below that the commuted pension at the hands of the judgment-debtors is not liable for attachment do not call for interference.

    3. For the above reasons, I do not find any merits in this revision petition and it is accordingly dismissed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    T. Sakuntala v. B. Satya Murthy & Anr.
    (Oct 30, 1998)