Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 7(c) and (d) of the Family Courts Act, 1984,
  • Section 7(c) of the Family Courts Act,
  • Section 7(c)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 7(c) and (d) of the Family Courts Act, 1984,
  • Section 7(c) of the Family Courts Act,
  • Section 7(c)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are the wife and children of the respondent. They filed a suit designated O.S. (SR No. 12798/95) which was allotted to the II Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad. By an order dated 1-9-1995 the plaint was returned for presentation in the proper court because the Assistant Judge held that, in view of Section 7(c) and (d) of the Family Courts Act, 1984, the Civil Court could not entertain the suit. On appeal the Additional Chief Judge confirmed that order, holding that Section 7(c) applied and that the Family Court was the proper forum. The petitioners filed the present Criminal Revision Petition (C.R.P.) challenging the appellate order.

The underlying suit seeks a permanent injunction restraining the respondent from interfering with the petitioners' possession and enjoyment of certain premises known as "Bin Try Souk Shopping Complex", Charminar, Hyderabad. The petitioners allege that pursuant to a family arrangement dated 29-11-1993 certain "Mulgies" in the Complex were allotted to each of them, while the defendant was allotted only two. The petitioners state that they leased out their allotted Mulgies from about October 1994 and have been receiving rent. They allege that the defendant went to tenants and proclaimed an exclusive right over the suit property, and they apprehend dispossession; accordingly they filed the suit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the suit falls within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Family Court under Section 7(c) (and, as initially relied on below, Section 7(d)) of the Family Courts Act, 1984, so as to prevent the Civil Court from entertaining it.
  2. Whether the plaint should have been returned for presentation in the Family Court rather than being numbered and tried in the Civil Court.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court considered the statutory language of Section 7(c) of the Family Courts Act, 1984, which the opinion reproduces as applying to "a suit or proceeding between the parties to a marriage with respect to the property of the parties or either of them" and thereby conferring exclusive jurisdiction on the Family Court for such matters.

The court analyzed whether the present suit fell within that description. The court noted that the plaintiffs are the wife and the major children of the respondent and that they claim ownership of certain Mulgies by virtue of a family arrangement dated 29-11-1993. The plaintiffs (wife and major children) seek an injunction to protect their possession and enjoyment of those allotted Mulgies, and the case therefore involves claims by the children as well as the wife.

The court's central analytical point was that Section 7(c) applies to suits "between the parties to a marriage" in respect of property of the parties. The court concluded that the present suit is not confined to the wife and husband alone; it involves the wife's claim together with her major children. Consequently, the mere fact that the wife is one of the claimants does not transform the dispute into one "between the parties to a marriage" within the meaning of Section 7(c). On that basis the court held that Section 7(c) does not apply to the suit as characterized by the petitioners.

Given that conclusion, the court set aside the impugned orders of the lower courts which had returned the plaint and directed the trial Court to number the suit if it was otherwise in order. The court qualified that direction by permitting any objection by the defendant regarding the maintainability of the suit insofar as it related to the 1st plaintiff.

The court expressly stated it was not addressing the merits of the suit or whether a suit of this nature might otherwise fall within Section 7(c); its conclusion was limited to the jurisdictional question based on the parties and the characterization of the dispute in the pleadings.

Holding and Implications

The C.R.P. is allowed. The impugned orders of the lower courts returning the plaint for presentation in the Family Court are set aside. The trial Court is directed to number the suit if it is otherwise in order, subject to any objection the defendant may raise about the maintainability of the suit insofar as the 1st plaintiff is concerned.

Direct effect: the suit may proceed in the Civil Court unless the defendant successfully raises a permissible maintainability objection as to the 1st plaintiff; the plaintiffs are not compelled, on the basis of the lower courts' rulings, to re-present the suit in a Family Court.

Broader implication: the opinion resolves the jurisdictional question in this case narrowly and does not purport to establish a broader precedent beyond the facts and the statutory interpretation applied here.

    Smt. Izzat Sultana & Ors. v. Sabir Bin Yasrab .

    1. The petitioners herein are the wife and children of the respondent. They filed a suit - O.S. (SR No. 12798/95) which was allotted to the II Asst. Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad. The plaint was returned for presentation in proper Court, by an order dated 1-9-1995. The learned Asst. Judge took the view that in view of Section 7(c) and (d) of the Family Courts Act, 1984, the suit cannot be entertained by the Civil Court. On appeal, the learned Addl. Chief Judge confirmed the said order. The appellate Court held that Section 7(c) applies to the instant case and therefore the Family Court is the proper forum in which the suit has to be filed. Questioning this order, the present CRP has been filed.

    2. Under Section 7(c),

    "a suit or proceeding between the parties to a marriage with respect to the property of the parties or either of them, falls within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Family Court"
    . The suit sought to be filed by the petitioners is a suit for permanent injunction restraining the Respondent-defendant from interfering in any manner with the possession and enjoyment of the plaintiffs' right in respect of a premises known as 'Bin Try Souk Shopping Complex' Charminar, Hyderabad. It is the case of the petitioners-plaintiffs that by virtue of a family arrangement dated 29-11-1993, certain Mulgies in the Complex were allotted to each one of them and the defendant was allotted only two Mulgies and pursuant to this arrangement, the plaintiffs leased out the Mulgies to various tenants ever-since October 1994 and they have been receiving rents. It is alleged that the defendant, having developed an animosity towards the plaintiffs, went to the tenants and proclaimed his exclusive right over the suit property. Apprehending that the plaintiffs or their tenants will be dispossessed by the defendant, the suit was filed. I am not concerned with the merits of the suit or the question whether a suit of this nature falls within the purview of Section 7(c) of the Family Courts Act, as held by the appellate Court. In my view, the answer to this question must be in the negative. It is not a suit confined to the wife and husband. The wife as well as the major children of the defendants are seeking an injunction on the footing that they have become owners of certain Mulgies pursuant to a family arrangement. The mere fact that the wife is also claiming exclusive rights over a part of the premises along with her children, does not bring the dispute within the fold of Section 7(c) of the Family Courts Act. The impugned orders of the Courts below are therefore set aside and the trial Court is directed to number the suit if it is otherwise in order, subject to any objection that may be taken by the defendant as regards the maintainability of, the suit in so far as the 1st plaintiff is concerned.

    3. The C.R.P. is accordingly allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Smt. Izzat Sultana & Ors. v. Sabir Bin Yasrab .
    (Sep 28, 1995)