1. Accused No. 5 in Sessions Case No. 20/1994 on the file of the III Addl. Metropolitan Sessions Judge, Hyderabad, is the petitioner-herein. This petition under Section 482 Cr. P.C is filed by the petitioner/A- 5 to grant stay of the proceedings against him till the final adjudication against A-1 to A-4 for charges under Sections 302 and 392 IPC in Sessions Case No. 20/1994, on the file of the III Metropolitan Sessions Judge, Hyderabad.
2. The substance of accusation against A-1 to A-5 is that A-1 to A-4, on 23-2-1993, at about 7.45 p.m, killed one Haji Mohammed Yakub, at Red Hills, Hyderabad, a businessman and took away cash of Rs. 1,60,000/- from his possession. A-5, the petitioner-herein, harboured A-1 to A-4 in his house at Bodabanda, Hyderabad, and shared the booty along with A-1 to A-4. A-1 to A-4 are charged with offences of robbery and murder punishable under Sections 392 and 302 IPC and A-5 is charged with the offence of harbouring the offenders and for dishonestly receiving the stolen property, punishable under Sections 212 IPC and 411 IPC. The petitioner contends that in order to convict him for an offence under Section 212 IPC, first of all there must be an offender who has to be harboured; that unless and until A-1 to A-4 are convicted for the offences under Sections 392 and 302 IPC, “they (A1 to A4) will not become offenders”; the petitioner who is charged with the offence of harbouring under section 212 IPC cannot be tried along with A-1 to A-4 in Sessions Case No. 20/94; therefore, the trial as against the petitioner A-5 must be stayed. In support of his contention, the learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the decision in Chacko v. State (1) AIR (38) 1951 Trawancore-Cochin-90.
3. The learned Public Prosecuto contends that as per Section 223 Cr. P.C, all persons accused of different offences committed in the course of the same transaction can be charged and tried together and therefore the question of staying the trial as against A-5 for the offence under section 212 IPC cannot be ordered.
4. It is necessary to note the ingredients which are to be established by the prosecution to bring home the guilt of an accused for an offence under Sec. 212 IPC. Section 212 IPC reads as follows:
“Wherever an offence has been committed, who ever harbours or conceals a person whom he knows or has reason to believe to be the offender, with the intention of screening him from legal punishment,
shall, if the offence is punishable with death, be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to five years, and shall also be liable to fine:
and if the offence is punishable with imprisonment for life, or with imprisonment which may extend to ten years, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to three years, and shall also be liable to fine,
and if the offence is punishable with imprisonment which may extend to one year, and not to ten years, shall be punished with imprisonment of the description provided for the offence for a term which may extend to one-fourth part of the longest term of imprisonment provided for the offence, or with fine, or with both……”
5. A reading of this Section 212 IPC will disclose that 3 things have to be proved by the prosecution, viz., (i) there must be an offender, and (ii) the offender should have already committed an offence and (iii) the person accused of under this Section should have harboured the offender knowing that he is an offender.
6. The learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that unless and until A-1 to A-4 are found guilty of committing the offences under Sections 392 and 302 IPC, they cannot be called as offenders. Therefore, he submits that the petitioner cannot be tried for an offence under section 212 IPC simultaneously along with A-1 to A-4 in the same sessions case, in which A-1 to A-4 are facing trial for offence under Sections 392 and 302 IPC. He submits that the trial against the petitioner/A-5 for the offence under Sec. 212 IPC has to be put off until the disposal of the case as against A-1 to A-4
7. This contention, ex-facie, sounds impressive, but, on a thorough examination of the facts of the case and on consideration of the provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code, this contention deserves to be rejected.
8. The learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon two decisions — Ram Raj Chaudhury v. Emperor (2) AIR 33 (1946) Patna 74 and Chacko v. State (1 supra). In Ram Raj's Case (2 supra), it was held thus:
“Sec. 212 applies to the harbouring of persons who have actually committed an offence. It does not apply to the harbouring of persons not being criminals, who merely abscond to avoid or delay a judicial investigation. Therefore, where there is no evidence showing that the accused knew or had reason to believe that the person harboured had committed any offence, he cannot be convicted under Sec. 212”.
9. In Chacko v. State (1 supra), trial of the case against the petitioner-therein for an offence under Sec. 212 IPC was stayed until after the disposal of atleast one of the cases against the concerned offenders on the ground that “until the ‘offender’ has been convicted of the offence he is alleged to have committed, no prosecution can be launched under Sec. 212, Penal Code for harbouring him”.
10. In both the above decisions, the accused were charged only with the offence under section 212 IPC and not with any other offences.
11. In the present case, admittedly, the petitioner/A-5 is charged with offence under section 212 IPC for harbouring A-1 to A-4, and also for an offence under section 411 IPC, for dishonestly receiving stolen property from A-1 to A-4, knowing it to be stolen.
12. In this context, it is necessary to note that Sec. 223 Cr. P.C prescribes the procedure as to when persons charged with different offences should be tried together. Sec. 223 Cr. P.C reads as follows:
“223. What persons may be charged jointly:—
The following persons may be charged and tried together, namely:—
(a) …..…..…..
(b) …..…..…..
(c) ………..…..
(d) persons accused of different offences committed in the course of the same transaction;
(e) persons accused of an offence which includes theft, extortion, cheating, or criminal misappropriation, and persons accused of receiving or retaining, or assisting in the disposal or concealment of property, possession of which is alleged to have been transferred by any such offence committed by the first-named persons, or of abetment of or attempting to commit any such last-named offence;
(f) …..…………
(g) …..…………”
13. In Kadiri Kunhahammad v. State Of Madras (3) AIR 1960 Supreme Court 661, interpreting the previsions of Section 239 Old Cr. P.C, which is same as Section 223 of the new Cr. P.C, the Supreme Court held thus:
“It is true that, in framing the charge against more persons than one and directing their joint trial, Courts should carefully examine the nature of the accusation; but if they are satisfied that prima facie the accusation made shows that several persons are charged of different offences and that the said offences prima facie appear to have been committed in the course of the same transaction, their joint trial can be ordered. The point of time in the proceedings at which it is to be determined whether the condition that the offences alleged had been committed in the course of the same transaction has been fulfilled or not is at the time when the accusation is made and not when the trial is concluded and the result known”.
14. In State of Andhra Pradesh v. Ganeswara Rao (4) AIR 1963 Supreme Court 1850, the Supreme Court held:
“The object of enacting Sec. 239 is to avoid multiplicity of trials and the only limitation which could properly be placed on the trial of several persons for the same kind of or different offences would be that which considerations of justice and fairness would require”.
15. The Supreme Court, in two decisions (3 and 4 supra), has made it clear that persons charged with different offences committed in the course of the same transaction should be tried together jointly, unless there are exceptional circumstances to avoid it.
16. In the present case, the petitioner, who is charged for offences under Sections 212 and 411 IPC, has to be necessarily tried along with A-1 to A-4, the other accused, for the offence under section 411 IPC as it forms part of the same transaction. Sub-section (e) or Sec. 223 Cr. P.C also mandates that, in such a situation a joint trial must be held. If the charge against the petitioner/A-5 is under section 212 IPC simpliciter, without any other charges, then undoubtedly the petitioner cannot he tried for the offence under section 212 IPC along with the other accused. The reason for doing so is, that A-1 to A-4 are not yet found to be ‘offenders’ as required under Sec. 212 IPC. That is not the position in this case. The petitioner/A-5 is charged with another offence, viz., under section 411 IPC also, in addition to the offence under section 212 IPC. In these circumstances, the petitioner/A-5 should not be allowed to undergo trial for the offence under section 411 IPC, along with others, viz., A-1 to A-4, and thereafter face the trial under section 212 IPC. This is not the intendment of the provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code. Therefore, the decisions in Chacko v. State (1 supra) and Ram Raj Chaudhary v. Emperor (2 supra) are distinguishable and cannot be made applicable to the facts of the case as in those cases the accused therein were charged only with the offence under section 212 IPC. Therefore, it follows, as laid down by the Supreme Court in Kadiri Kunhahammad v. State Of Madras (3 supra) and State of Andhra Pradesh v. Ganeswara Rao (4 supra), that to avoid multiplicity of trials and also as the offences alleged against all the accused including the petitioner-herein (A-5) are committed in the course of the same transaction, the charge for the offence under section 212 IPC against the petitioner must also be tried and decided in the same Sessions Case, without postponing the same for consideration by a separate case. By adopting this method, no prejudice is caused to petitioner. Further, if the petitioner/A-5 is found guilty of the offence under section 411 IPC for receiving stolen property from A-1 to A-4, it automatically follows that the ingredients for the offence under section 212 IPC are established against the petitioner for harbouring A-1 to A-4, who committed the offences of robbery, punishable under Sec. 392 IPC.
17. For the reasons stated above, there are absolutely no justifiable grounds for staying the proceedings against the petitioner/A-5 for the offence under section 212 IPC till the final adjudication against A-1 to A-4 for charges under Sections 392 and 302 IPC in Sessions Case No. 20 of 1994 on the file of the III Additional Metropolitan Sessions Judge's Court, Hyderabad.
18. This petition is, therefore, dismissed.