AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    The Public Prosecutor (A.P) v. Vaijnath And Another, Accused

    Narasimham, J.:— The question referred to us is whether the adoption by the trial Magistrate of summons procedure in a warrant case amounts to an illegality vitiating the entire trial or only an irregularity curable under Section 537 of the Cr PC.

    2. There has been a consensus of judicial opinion on this question referred ever since the decision of the Privy Council in Subramania Iyer v. Emperor, (1901) 28 Ind App 257 (PC). The question did not directly arise in that case but the principle was enunciated that the disobedience to an express provision as to a mode of trial could not be regarded as a mere irregularity. That was reiterated in Pulukuri Kotayya v. Emperor, AIR 1947 PC 67. The pronouncement in the later case was more clear that when a trial was conducted in a manner different from that prescribed by the Code, the trial was bad and no question of curing an irregularity arose.

    3. The question now referred to us has, however, been directly answered in a series of cases. It is sufficient to refer to Emperor v. Chinapayan, (1906) ILR 29 Mad 372 : (4 Cri LJ 231) and the cases thereafter. That was a case where a warrant case was tried as a summons case and the accused was convicted. The learned Judge set aside the conviction holding that that was something more than irregularity and that the accused might have possibly been prejudiced by the procedure adopted by the Magistrate. The other cases which have held the same view are Gaya Prasad v. Emperor, AIR 1932 Nag 11; Sufal Golai…Accused v. Emperor, AIR 1938 Cal 205 and Bandulal Balaprasad v. The State, AIR 1962 Bom 258. The decisions have held the view that the trial was not conducted as prescribed by the Code when a warrant case was tried as a summons case and the trial was therefore vitiated.

    4. A different view, however, came to be expressed by a Full Bench of the Allahabad High Court in Prem Das v. State, AIR 1961 All 590. While holding that an illegal procedure was adopted when a warrant case was tried as a summons case, the learned Judges, however, took the view that that was a curable irregularity as no prejudice was caused to the accused by the adoption of a wrong procedure.

    5. Mohanlal Nandlal Sharma v. State, AIR 1962 Guj 231 said in some what similar terms that the adoption of procedure prescribed for summons cases by the Magistrate in a warrant case was mere irregularity and did not vitiate the trial and was curable by the provisions of Section 537 of the Cr PC if it did not occasion any failure of justice.

    6. It is therefore clear that the two later decisions have struck a discordant note in conflict with the observations of the Privy Council in (1901) 28 Ind App 257 (PC), and AIR 1947 PC 67.

    7. The learned Judge of the Gujarat High Court appears to have relied on Gopal Das Sindhi v. State of Assam, AIR 1961 SC 986 at p. 989, which we may appropriately peruse in this context.

    “It is true that after the amendment of the Code of Criminal Procedure, an offence under Section 448 is triable as a summons case and Mr. Goswami adopted the procedure prescribed for a case triable as a warrant case. We are, however, of the opinion that this irregularity does not vitiate the proceedings and is curable by the provisions of Section 537 as no prejudice to the accused has been established in the case.”

    8. With great respect, we are unable to find support for the decision of the learned Judge that the converse follows.

    9. We cannot regard it as an authority for the position that when a warrant case is tried as a summons case, the trial is not vitiated but curable by the provisions of Section 537 and that the accused has to establish that prejudice was caused to him.

    10. In cases where the trial does not comply with the code, an indefeasible presumption of prejudice may be drawn. This Court has held in Criminal R.C 299 of 1959 (AP) that where a warrant case is tried as a summons case, the trial was vitiated and gave rise to an irrebuttable presumption of prejudice.

    11. Having regard to the preponderating view taken in the many decisions, which is consistent with the principle enunciated by the Privy Council, our opinion is that when a warrant case is tried as a summons case, it amounts to an illegality and not an irregularity curable under Section 537 of the Cr PC. The reference is answered accordingly and the case will be posted for hearing.

    12. Reference answered.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The Public Prosecutor (A.P) v. Vaijnath And Another, Accused
    (Nov 20, 1968)