Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC. Moreover section 155(4)
  • sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC State
  • sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC.P.S
  • section 226 Cr. P.C and section 227
  • sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC
  • section 2-D of Cr. P.C
  • section 227 Cr. P.C
  • section 207 Cr. P.C
  • section 482 Cr. P.C
  • section 226 Cr. P.C
  • section 209 Cr. P.C
  • section 302 I.P.C
  • section 2(D)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC. Moreover section 155(4)
  • sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC State
  • sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC.P.S
  • section 226 Cr. P.C and section 227
  • sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC
  • section 2-D of Cr. P.C
  • section 227 Cr. P.C
  • section 207 Cr. P.C
  • section 482 Cr. P.C
  • section 226 Cr. P.C
  • section 209 Cr. P.C
  • section 302 I.P.C
  • section 2(D)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from an application under section 482 Cr. P.C. seeking quashing of the order dated 1.9.2007 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge/FTC No. 3, Basti in S.T. No. 207 of 2007 (State v. Ram Vijai), in which the Sessions Judge framed charge against the accused-applicant under section 302 IPC.

On 5.2.2006 Mahendra Prasad Tiwari (the complainant) lodged an FIR (registered as Crime No. 84 of 2006 at P.S. Mahuli, District Sant Kabir Nagar) naming Dinesh Tiwari (the applicant), Sadhu Saran and Ram Vijai Yadav for offences under sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC. The FIR alleged that the applicant and others had attacked the complainant's family while they were filling a pit for an electric pole; Arvind Kumar Tiwari (son of the complainant) was alleged to have been shot dead on the spot.

Investigation was initially by local police but later transferred to the CBCID by Government order. CBCID first submitted a charge sheet against Sadhu Saran Yadav for sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC; cognizance was taken on 8.5.2006 and Sadhu Saran was committed to the Sessions Court (S.T. No. 149 of 2006). Investigation against the other accused was kept pending at that time.

CBCID subsequently submitted a common charge sheet on 11.1.2007 in Crime No. 84 of 2006 against Ram Vijai Yadav and Dinesh Tiwari. That charge sheet indicated section 302 IPC was made out against Ram Vijai Yadav, while against Dinesh Tiwari the charge sheet mentioned offences under sections 323, 504 and 506 IPC (no charge-sheeted offence of 302 IPC against Dinesh Tiwari). Cognizance on that charge-sheet was taken by the Chief Judicial Magistrate (CJM) on 23.1.2007; bail was granted to the applicant in respect of the offences under sections 323, 504 and 506 IPC. The case (or cases) were later before the Sessions Court where the Sessions Judge framed, after committal, a charge under section 302 IPC against the applicant as well.

The applicant challenged the framing of the section 302 IPC charge via the present section 482 Cr. P.C. application. The Sessions Judge also passed an order dated 5.10.2007 directing custody be taken of the applicant for the offence under section 302 IPC (the complainant had applied for custody, asserting bail earlier related only to the minor offences).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Sessions Judge was justified in framing a charge under section 302 IPC against the applicant despite no separate charge-sheet having been submitted against him for section 302 IPC.
  2. Whether the committal by the Magistrate and subsequent framing of charge by the Sessions Judge involved any procedural illegality or defect (including whether the committal should have been limited to only the offences specified against the applicant in the charge-sheet).
  3. Whether the applicant was deprived of the protections under section 227 Cr. P.C. (i.e., the opportunity to be heard before framing of charge) when the Sessions Judge framed the section 302 charge without affording an opportunity to the applicant.
  4. Whether the Sessions Judge was justified in ordering that the applicant be taken into custody after framing the section 302 charge despite earlier grant of bail in respect of minor offences.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments (as advanced by learned Counsel Sri Satish Trivedi)

  • No charge-sheet was submitted against the applicant for the offence under section 302 IPC; the charge-sheet against the applicant listed only sections 323, 504 and 506 IPC.
  • Because the charge-sheet against the applicant was for non-cognizable offences, proceedings against him should have proceeded as a complaint case under the explanation to section 2-D of the Cr. P.C., and not by committal to Sessions for trial on a capital charge.
  • The Sessions Judge framed the section 302 charge without affording the applicant an opportunity to be heard under section 227 Cr. P.C., thereby depriving him of valuable rights and resulting in prejudice.
  • There was procedural non-compliance with provisions such as section 207 Cr. P.C. and related requirements for offences triable by the Sessions Court; framing of the more serious charge surprised and prejudiced the applicant.
  • The earlier grant of bail in relation to minor offences should have prevented the Sessions Judge from ordering custody for the accused once a more serious charge was framed.

State's Arguments (as advanced by learned Additional Government Advocate)

  • There was no illegality, apparent irregularity or procedural error in the Sessions Judge framing the charge under section 302 IPC.
  • The Sessions Judge framed the charge after receipt of the file in the Sessions Court and on the basis of the material on record; the Judge was satisfied that prima facie allegations of section 302 existed against the applicant.
  • The Sessions Judge properly considered the evidence available on the file, including the complainant's recorded statement and evidence from the earlier trial/committal proceedings against co-accused (Sadhu Saran Yadav).
  • Because the co-accused's case had already been committed to the Sessions Court and evidence existed on file, it was appropriate and convenient to try all accused together; the Magistrate was justified in committing the entire case to the Sessions Court.
  • The Sessions Judge's order for custody after framing the section 302 charge was justified given the seriousness of the offence; the prosecution relied on relevant statutory provisions and case-law (not specifically named in the order) to support the custody direction.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court confined itself to examining whether the procedure adopted by the Sessions Judge was defective or faulty; it expressly stated that it was not the function of the present section 482 Cr. P.C. petition to assess whether there was sufficient evidence to frame a charge under section 302 IPC.

The court noted the following points from the record and analyzed them:

  • The FIR contained a direct allegation naming the applicant in the murder of Arvind Kumar Tiwari; the complainant was an eyewitness according to the FIR.
  • Investigation was transferred to CBCID; CBCID initially submitted a charge-sheet against Sadhu Saran Yadav (for section 302 and other offences) while investigation against other accused remained pending. Later, CBCID submitted a common charge-sheet (dated 11.1.2007) against Ram Vijai Yadav and Dinesh Tiwari. In that common charge-sheet section 302 was alleged against Ram Vijai, while Dinesh Tiwari was charge-sheeted for sections 323, 504 and 506 IPC.
  • Because a common charge-sheet was submitted in the same crime and some accused faced sessionable offences, the CJM was justified in committing the entire case to the Sessions Court rather than separating the accused for separate proceedings. The court referred to established practice/authority (generally described in the judgment) that co-accused involved in the same crime ought to be tried together even if allegations against them differ in character (sessionable vs. non-sessionable offences).
  • The court rejected the applicant's reliance on the explanation to section 2-D Cr. P.C. (that non-cognizable allegations should proceed as complaint matter), reasoning that explanation would apply only if allegations were exclusively of non-cognizable offences; because allegations of section 302 IPC were made against at least some accused and police had investigated the murder allegation, committal and common charge-sheet were proper.
  • The court observed section 155(4) Cr. P.C. as relevant to investigation of non-cognizable offences and noted that, given the murder allegation, the police investigation and submission of a common charge-sheet was proper on the facts presented.
  • As to framing of charge by the Sessions Judge, the court noted that a Sessions Judge, when framing charge, is required to peruse the entire material on record (relying on scheme of Chapter XVII, including sections 211, 226 and related provisions). Because the Sessions Judge considered material including evidence/statements recorded in the co-accused's file, framing the section 302 charge against the applicant could not be faulted.
  • The court rejected the submission that the applicant was deprived of the protections of section 227 Cr. P.C. It reasoned that section 226 Cr. P.C. requires the prosecutor, after committal and when the accused are produced, to open the case by describing the charge and stating what evidence he proposes to rely on; if section 226 procedure was followed, then section 227 (which provides for discharge where charge is not to be framed) would not be triggered. The court concluded the Sessions Judge framed the charge in the manner envisaged by section 226 Cr. P.C., and therefore there was no deprivation of the applicant's rights under section 227.
  • Regarding the Sessions Judge's order to take the applicant into custody after framing the section 302 charge (despite earlier bail in relation to minor offences), the court accepted the Sessions Judge's reasoning: the earlier bail related only to minor offences triable by a Magistrate, whereas section 302 IPC is a major offence; the Sessions Judge had passed a detailed, speaking order and placed reliance on higher court precedents (not named in the text). The court considered it neither a mockery nor improper for the Sessions Judge to require custody and for the applicant to seek fresh bail for the serious offence.

On the basis of this analysis, the court concluded that there was no procedural illegality, irregularity or error in the Sessions Judge's order framing a section 302 charge and directing custody; therefore, the section 482 petition could not be allowed at this stage.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The application under section 482 Cr. P.C. is dismissed.

Implications (direct effect on the parties):

  • The Sessions Court's framing of charge under section 302 IPC against the applicant stands; the applicant will be tried on that charge along with co-accused as per the Sessions Court proceedings.
  • The Sessions Judge's order directing that the applicant be taken into custody in respect of the section 302 charge is upheld by this court; the applicant must seek fresh bail for the serious offence (the prior bail granted for minor offences does not carry over to the more serious charge without fresh consideration).
  • No broader precedent or change in law is declared by this opinion; the decision confines itself to concluding there was no procedural defect in the course adopted by the Magistrate and Sessions Judge on the facts and record before the court.

Order: Application under section 482 Cr. P.C. dismissed.

    Dinesh Tiwari v. State Of U.P.

    Shiv Charan, J.:— The present application has been moved under section 482 Cr. P.C for quashing the order dated 1.9.2007 passed by Addl. Sessions Judge/FTC No. 3 Basti in S.T No. 207 of 2007 under sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC State v. Ram Vijai. By this order learned Sessions Judge framed the charge against the accused-applicant for the offence under section 302 IPC.

    2. The perusal of the file shows that on 5.2.2006 Mahendra Prasad Tiwari complainant lodged a FIR against the applicants Dinesh Tiwari, Sadhu Saran and Ram Vijai Yadav for the offence under sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC.P.S Mahuli Dis trict Sant Kabir Nagar. It was registered at Crime No. 84 of 2006. It was alleged in the FIR that the applicant along with Sadhu Saran committed murder of Arvind Kumar Tiwari son of the complainant. It has also been alleged in the FIR that about two and half years earlier applicant Dinesh Tiwari kidnapped and enticed his daughter Seema. But nothing was done in this matter and the applicant Dinesh Tiwari had been living with his daughter and he had been pressurizing him to accept him as his son in law. But complainant refused from doing it and hence he was inimical from him. For electrification of the village electric poles were fixed for last several days'. On 5.2.2006 at about 12 O'Clock Dinesh Tiwari and his companion Sadhu Saran arrived at the field of the complainant. The complainant with the consent of electric department filled up the pit dug for the electric pole. Dinesh Tiwari and his companions started abusing him for doing so. Ravi Shankar son of the complainant told them not to abuse them. On it both the accused persons took out country made pistol and Dinesh Tiwari caused injuries on his head by the butt of country made pistol and he sustained head injury. Ravi Shankar escaped from the spot and reached at his house. These accused persons chased him up to the house and the complainant with folded hand told to them not to beat him. On it Dinesh Tiwari threw the JANEOO (sacred thread) and declared that he will not bear it till he will not eliminate all of them. Then these accused persons rushed towards the house of the complainant. The another son Arvind Kumar Tiwari was standing in the verandah both the accused persons opened fire on Arvind Kumar Tiwari and as a result of firing he died on the spot and after committing the murder, the accused persons escaped from the spot on motorcycle. The accused persons were seen by the wit nesses escaping from the spot. No witness is ready to give evidence due to fear.

    3. Investigation was started by the police of the offence. But afterwards the investigation was transferred to CBCID by the order of the Government. CBCID submitted charge sheet against Sadhu Saran Yadav co-accused for the offence under sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC. And the CJM took the cognizance of the offence vide order dated 8.5.2006, and it was men tioned in the charge sheet that investigation shall continue against rest of the accused persons. The case was committed to the Court of Sessions of Sadhu Saran Yadav registered at S.T No. 149 of 2006 State v. Sadhu Saran Yadav and Mahendra Prasad Tiwari was examined by Trial Court as P.W 1 against Sadhu Saran Yadav. Afterwards CBCID submitted the charge sheet against Ram Vijai Yadav for the offence under sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC. But the charge sheet was submitted against the applicant for the offence under sections 323, 504 and 506 IPC. The charge sheet was not submitted against the applicant for the offence under section 302 IPC. The cognizance was taken by CJM on charge sheet No. 5-A of 2006 on 23.1.2007 Bail was granted to the applicant for the offence un der sections 323, 504, 506 IPC. The case was committed to the Court of Sessions by the CJM after taking cognizance and the charge was framed against the applicant also along with Ram Vijai Yadav without af fording any opportunity to hear for the offence under section 302 IPC according to applicant and ort the application of the complainant order was passed for taking the applicant into custody for the offence under section 302 IPC. I have heard learned Counsel for the applicant, learned AGA for the State and perused the entire material on record.

    4. It has been argued by learned Counsel for the applicant Sri Satish Trivedi that no charge sheet was submitted against the applicant for the offence under section 302 IPC. And no cognizance was taken by the Magistrate for the offence under section 302 IPC against the applicant. But learned Sessions Judge after committal framed the charge under section 302 IPC also. It was specifically mentioned in the charge sheet that against the applicant charge sheet is submitted for the offence under sections 323, 504, 506 IPC. He argued that as the charge sheet against the applicant was submitted for non-cognizable offence hence it must have proceeded as a complaint case as provided in explanation of section 2-D of Cr. P.C That all of a sudden learned Sessions Judge framed the charge under section 302 IPC and this is most unjustified on the part of the Sessions Judge. That the applicant has been deprived off from his valuable rights as has been provided under section 227 Cr. P.C That entire procedure adopted by the Sessions Judge is faulty. The applicant was assured that he will be tried for the offence under sections 323, 504, 506 IPC. That for offence triable by Sessions Judge there should be proper compliance of section 207 Cr. P.C That as prejudice has been caused to the applicant by the order of Sessions Judge by framing charge under section 302 IPC hence deserves to be set aside.

    5. Learned AGA opposed the argument of learned Counsel for the applicant and it has been argued that there is no illegality or apparent irregularity or procedural error in the order of the Sessions Judge of framing the charge under section 302 IPC. In the present case as the charge was framed after receipt of the file in the Sessions Court and the charge was not amended and on the basis of the material available on record the Sessions Judge was convinced that there are prima facie allegation against the applicant also for framing the charge for offence under section 302 I.P.C He also argued that as the case of co-accused Sadhu Saran Yadav was commit ted to the Court of Sessions earlier and statement of complainant was recorded in the case and when the case of co-accused Dinesh Tiwari and Ram Vijai Yadav was committed to the Court of Sessions, hence learned Sessions Judge perused the entire evidence including the statement of complainant recorded in the case of Sadhu Saran Yadav and after perusing the evidence the charge was framed.

    6. I have considered all the facts and circumstances of the case. I have only to see that whether the procedure adopted by the Sessions Judge was defective or faulty. I am not required for disposal of the application under section 482 Cr. P.C that whether there was sufficient evidence against the applicant or not for framing the charge under section 302 IPC Although according to the FIR there was direct allegation against the applicant for committing the murder of Arvind Kumar Tiwari. There is a specific allegation that applicant Dinesh Tiwari and Sadhu Saran Yadav opened fire on Arvind Kumar Tiwari with the intention of causing his death and both of them fired on him. It is not such a case in which the applicant was not named in the offence rather direct involvement of the applicant has been alleged in the FIR and the complainant was the eye-witness of the incident. But the investigation was entrusted to the CBCID by the orders of the State Government. It is not very material to ascertain that under what circumstances, the investigation of the case was transferred to CBCID from the civil police. But it is a fact that investigation of the case was entrusted to CBCID and it is also material that CBCID submitted charge sheet against Sadhu Saran Yadav for the offence under sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC and cognizance was taken by the Court in the month of May, 2006 and this case was also committed to the Court of Sessions. But at the time of the submitting the charge sheet against Sadhu Saran Yadav the investigation against the applicant and other co-accused was kept pending by the CBCID. At that time no final re port etc. was submitted by CBCID against the applicant. It is also a matter to be decided by the Trial Court whether this act of CBCID was justified or not.

    7. The perusal of the file shows that CBCID submitted a common charge sheet against Ram Vijai Yadav and Dinesh Ti wari in case crime No. 84 of 2006 on 11.1.2007 and the cognizance was taken by the CJM on 23.1.2007 and it was mentioned in the charge sheet that the offence under section 302 IPC is made out against the accused Ram Vijai Yadav whereas against the applicant Dinesh Tiwari under sections 323, 504, 506 IPC. As a common charge sheet was submitted by the I.O in Crime No. 84 of 2006 against Ram Vijai Yadav and Dinesh Tiwari hence the CJM was perfectly justified in committing the case to the Court of Sessions. The allegation against Dinesh Tiwari even of the offence under sections 323, 504, 506 IPC was in crime case No. 84 of 2006 and in view of several pronouncement of Hon'ble Apex Court if some persons are facing trial in one and same crime then all must be tried simultaneously in one case irrespective of the fact that against some of the persons there are allegations of a non-cognizable offence. If there are allegations of section 302 IPC against some of the accused and there are allegation under sections 323, 504, 506 IPC against rest of the accused then the trial will be the same against all and in my opinion, the CJM was fully justified in committing the entire case to the Court of Sessions. Learned Magistrate could have not been said justified in separating the case of the applicant for the offence under sections 323, 504, 506 IPC and retain the file. This might have been the most unjustified act on the part of the CJM. Hence when in the charge sheet offences were mentioned which is exclusively triable by the Court of Sessions and the case of one of the accused had already been committed to the Court of Sessions. Hence the case of the applicant was also to be committed to the Court of Sessions. I also disagree with the argument of learned Counsel for the applicant that as the charge sheet was submitted against the accused applicant for the of fences under sections 323, 504, 506 IPC hence in view of section 2(D) explanation it must have proceeded as complaint case. This was possible only if there were allegations of only of non-cognizable offence then the case should have been tried as com plaint case. But in the present case there were allegations of section 302 IPC against the applicant also and the matter was investigated by the police for the offence under section 302 IPC against the applicant also and the common charge sheet was submitted against the applicant and Ram Vijai Yaday and cognizance was also taken by the Magistrate on this charge sheet submitted against Ram Vijai Yadav and Dinesh Tiwari for the offence under sections 302, 323, 504 and 506 IPC. Moreover section 155(4) is also relevant for the purpose of investigation of a non-cognizable offence and there were allegations of murder against the applicant. Hence the police has rightly conducted the investigation and a common charge sheet was submitted. Hence the Magistrate also took the cognizance for the offence and he was also justified by committing the case to the Court of Sessions to face trial for the offence.

    8. It has been argued by learned Counsel for the applicant that as charge sheet was submitted against the applicant for the offence under sections 323, 504, 506 IPC and learned Sessions Judge was not justified in framing the charge out right for the offence under section 302 IPC. In view of section 211 and other provision in this connection of Chapter XVII and section 226 at the time of framing the charge the Court is required to peruse the entire material on record. As I have stated that charge sheet against one of the accused namely, Sadhu Saran Yadav was submitted earlier and the case of this accused was committed to the Court of Sessions and this accused was facing trial before the Sessions Judge. The statement of the complainant was also re corded in the case against Sadhu Saran Yadav. When there were two cases out come of the same offence then as a matter of convenience both are to be consolidated. And for framing the charge the entire evidence on the file including on the file of Sadhu Saran Yadav was also to be considered by the Sessions Judge for framing the charge and as there was sufficient oral evidence against the applicant, hence the charge was framed under section 302 IPC also. If the Sessions Judge has framed the charge against the applicant for the offence under section 302 IPC also then the Sessions Judge cannot be said to be unjustified. Because the learned Sessions Judge shall consider the entire evidence and allegations against each of the accused for framing of the charge. And in the present case also the learned Sessions Judge framed the charge after considering the entire evidence. Learned Counsel for the applicant has not argued that the charge framed under section 302 IPC against the applicant is not substantiated by any evidence present in the file. But learned Advocate only raised the technical objection that as the applicant was convinced that he will face trial for the offence under sections 323, 504 and 506 IPC hence by the order of learned Sessions Judge the applicant was surprised and prejudiced. In the present case it can not be said that the applicant was prejudiced in any respect because the trial will have to commence and statement of the witnesses were to be recorded and there is no reason for prejudice to the applicant if charge has been framed under section 302 IPC.

    9. Much has been argued by learned Counsel for the applicant that the applicant has been deprived from the benefit of section 227 Cr. P.C Under this section the applicant is entitled for discharge from the offence and as the Sessions Judge framed the charge without affording any opportunity to be heard then the applicant has been deprived from the benefit of section 227 Cr. P.C I disagree with the argument of learned Counsel for the applicant. It is been provided by section 226 Cr. P.C that when accused appeared or brought before the Court in pursuance of the commitment of the case under section 209 Cr. P.C the prosecutor shall open the case by describing the charge brought against the accused and stating by what evidence he proposes the guilt of the accused. It cannot be said that in the present case learned Sessions Judge has not framed the charge by following section 226 Cr. P.C and section 227 shall come into force if the charge is not to be framed as provided under section 226 Cr. P.C But in the present case the charge was framed in the manner as provided under section 226 Cr. P.C and a detailed order is not required to be passed by the Sessions Judge in framing the charge.

    10. Learned Counsel for the applicant also argued that learned Sessions Judge after framing the charge under section 302 IPC has gone beyond that. Application of the complainant was allowed. The complainant moved an application that a charge has been framed against the applicant for the offence under section 302 IPC then he must be taken into custody as he was granted bail only for the offence under sections 323, 504 and 506 IPC. Learned Counsel for the applicant argued at length that as the applicant was granted bail earlier in this crime hence there was no justification for the Sessions Judge for passing the order for taking him into custody for the offence under section 302 IPC. I have perused the order of learned Sessions Judge dated 5.10.2007 and learned Sessions Judge has passed the detailed and speaking order in this connection and in passing the order he placed reliance on the judgement of Hon'ble Apex Court and also this Court. It has been alleged by the Sessions Judge that as the charge was framed for the of fence under section 302 IPC hence the applicant must be taken into custody for the offence because he was granted bail earlier in a very minor offence under sections 323, 504 and 506 IPC. The offence under section 302 IPC is a major offence whereas the of fence under sections 323, 506 and 504 IPC is a very minor offence and triable by Magistrate only and this order of Sessions Judge is perfectly justified after framing the charge under section 302 IPC Applicant must be taken into custody and he must seek bail. In the circumstances of the case applicant also cannot be permitted to re main on the already furnished bail bonds or require the applicant to furnish fresh bail bonds for the offence under section 302 IPC without taking him into custody. This will be a mockery of the system. There are serious allegations against the applicant of the offence under section 302 IPC and for this offence he must be taken into custody and he must move for fresh bail for the offence. For the aforesaid reason I have arrived at the definite conclusion that the order of learned Sessions Judge is perfectly justified. There appears no illegality or irregularity or procedural error in the order of Sessions Judge and the application under section 482 Cr. P.C deserves to be dismissed at this stage.

    11. The application under section 482 Cr. P.C is dismissed accordingly.

    12. Application Dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dinesh Tiwari v. State Of U.P.
    (Dec 11, 2007)