AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This group of writ petitions (with Writ Petition No. 56505 of 2005 taken as the lead matter) arises from transactions in which the petitioner, a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956, purchased agricultural land in village Todarpur, Saharanpur district, for the purpose of setting up a sugar factory.

Key factual and procedural milestones, as set out in the opinion, are:

  • The petitioner executed a sale deed dated 22-7-1994 for agricultural land and paid stamp duty in accordance with the circle rate issued by the District Magistrate.
  • On 13-2-1995 the Additional District Magistrate (Finance) issued a notice under Section 47-A read with Section 33(4) of the Stamp Act alleging deficiency of stamp duty on the basis that the land had been purchased for industrial purposes and that market value for industrial purpose should be taken; the notice relied on a District Magistrate circular dated 12-3-1994 which stated that agricultural land purchased for business or industrial purposes would attract stamp duty at three times the prescribed agricultural rate.
  • The petitioner filed objections; the Assistant Commissioner (Stamps) by order dated 8-1-1996 discharged the notice finding no deficiency and that adequate stamp duty had been paid.
  • In May 2000 (over four years later) the State filed a revision under Section 56(2) of the Stamp Act. The revisional authority condoned the delay (order dated 6-6-2000) and, by order dated 20-7-2005, allowed the revision, relying on the District Magistrate's circular and holding that the petitioner was liable to pay the deficiency (three times the agricultural rate), quantified at Rs. 29,062.50.
  • The petitioner challenged the revisional order and the circular dated 12-3-1994 by filing the present writ petition. The matter was heard with counsel for both parties appearing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the market value of land for the purpose of stamp duty can be determined with reference to the use to which a buyer intends to put the land (i.e., whether intended future use or potential value can be taken into account).
  2. Whether the District Magistrate's circular (note (b) dated 12-3-1994) — providing that agricultural land purchased for business or industrial purposes should attract stamp duty at three times the agricultural rate — is permissible under the Stamp Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner paid stamp duty at the time of execution of the sale deed according to the circle rate prescribed by the District Magistrate; there was no deficiency.
  • Market value must be determined on the character of the land as on the date of execution and cannot be based on the buyer's intended future use or potential future value of the land.
  • The District Magistrate's circular demanding three times the agricultural rate for land purchased for industrial purposes is illegal and contrary to the Stamp Act.
  • The State's revision was filed after more than four years and the Revisional Authority erred in condoning such delay without an explanation; the revision should have been dismissed on grounds of laches.

Respondents' (State's) Arguments — as presented by the Standing Counsel

  • The Assistant Commissioner (Stamps) committed an error in discharging the show-cause notice under Section 47-A by not determining the market value of the land as required under that provision.
  • The Revisional Authority was justified in filing a revision because of the manifest error in the Assistant Commissioner's order; on complaint, inquiries were conducted and the matter was placed before the Board of Revenue which directed revision under Section 56; consequently, the delay in filing revision was to be condoned in the interest of justice, particularly because substantial revenue was said to be at stake.
  • The Revisional Authority relied on the District Magistrate's circular and determined that the land had been purchased for industrial/business purposes and thus attracted three times the agricultural rate for stamp duty.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R.C. Bansal v. District Magistrate, (1999) 5 SCC 62 : AIR 1999 SC 2126 (1999 All LJ 1547) Circle rates issued by District Magistrates are guidelines and at best prima facie indicia of land value. The Court relied on this authority to confirm that circle rates are only prima facie material and cannot be treated as definitive for market value determination.
State of Punjab v. Mahabir Singh, (1996) 1 SCC 609 : AIR 1996 SC 2994 Reinforces that circle rates are only guidelines and serve as prima facie material regarding land value. The Court cited this case to support the proposition that circle rates are not conclusive proof of market value.
Maya Foods and Vanaspati Ltd. v. Chief Controlling Revenue Authority (BR), Allahabad, 1998 (4) AWC 636 Market value cannot be determined with reference to the use to which a buyer intends to put the land; only the potential as on the date of sale can be considered, not distant-future potential. The Court relied on this single-judge decision for the legal proposition that buyer's intended use is immaterial for determining market value for stamp duty purposes.
Anirudhha Kumar & Ashwini Kumar v. Chief Controlling Revenue Authority, Uttar Pradesh, Allahabad, 2000 (3) AWC 2587 Future potential of land is not a factor in determining market value; market value is the value that would satisfy the vendor as on the date of transfer. The Court cited this authority to reinforce that valuation must reflect the utility and character of the land on the date of transfer and not speculative future uses.
Rakesh Chandra Mittal v. Additional District Magistrate (Finance and Revenue), Moradabad, 2004 (3) UPLBEC 2434 : (2004 All LJ 2802) Market value must be determined with reference to the date on which the document is executed; subsequent improvements or changes in use that enhance value are not to be taken into account. The Court relied on this Division Bench decision to underscore that only the value as on the date of execution is relevant for stamp duty assessment.
Shri Ramesh Chandra Srivastava v. State of U.P., 2007 UPTC 335 : (2007 (1) ALJ 90) (Full Bench) Full Bench authority that market value is to be determined with reference to the date of execution of the document. The Court cited this Full Bench decision as authoritative support for holding that market value must be fixed as on the date of execution and subsequent change in user/enhancement is irrelevant.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds in a sequence tied closely to precedent and statutory interpretation:

  1. The Court acknowledged that circle rates set by the District Magistrate are guidelines and prima facie indicators of value (citing R.C. Bansal and State of Punjab v. Mahabir Singh), but not conclusive proof of market value.
  2. The Court focused on the central legal question whether market value can be determined by reference to the intended use or future potential of land. It examined earlier decisions of this Court and other authorities which consistently hold that market value must be assessed with reference to the character and potential of the land as on the date of execution of the instrument and not by speculative or future uses the buyer may envisage (citing Maya Foods; Anirudhha Kumar; Rakesh Chandra Mittal; and the Full Bench in Shri Ramesh Chandra Srivastava).
  3. Drawing on these authorities, the Court concluded that intended future use or distant-future potential cannot be the basis for fixing market value for stamp duty purposes. The proper approach is to consider the utility, character and potential of the land as on the date the document was executed.
  4. Applying that principle to the facts, the Court held that the District Magistrate's circular note (b) dated 12-3-1994 — which mandated charging stamp duty at three times the agricultural rate when agricultural land is purchased for business or industrial purposes — is inconsistent with the Stamp Act and beyond the District Magistrate's jurisdiction. The Court described such a note as "against the provisions of the Stamp Act and ... without jurisdiction."
  5. Because the circular was held to be invalid, the Revisional Authority's reliance on that circular to hold the petitioner liable to pay three times the agricultural rate (and to demand the alleged deficiency) could not be sustained. The Court therefore quashed the Revisional Authority's order.
  6. The Court expressly noted that because the writ petition was being allowed on the substantive ground of illegality of the circular and incorrect basis for valuation, it was unnecessary to decide whether the Revisional Authority was justified in condoning the delay in filing the revision.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed; the impugned order of the Revisional Authority is quashed and note (b) of the circle rate dated 12-3-1994 issued by the Collector, Saharanpur is quashed.

Implications and direct consequences as stated in the opinion:

  • The petitioner is relieved of the Revisional Authority's finding that it was liable to pay the alleged deficiency of stamp duty calculated at three times the agricultural rate on the basis of the District Magistrate's circular.
  • The District Magistrate's circular note (b) (dated 12-3-1994) directing that agricultural land purchased for business or industrial purposes attract stamp duty at three times the agricultural rate is held to be illegal and without jurisdiction and is quashed.
  • Because relief was granted on this substantive ground, the Court did not decide the separate procedural question regarding the condonation of delay in filing the revision; that issue remains undetermined by this judgment.
  • There shall be no order as to costs in the circumstances of the case (as recorded by the Court).

This summary is drawn exclusively from the provided opinion. No information has been added beyond what is contained in that opinion.

    Shakumbari Sugar And Allied Industries Ltd. v. State Of U.P & Ors.

    1. Heard Sri Yashvant Varma, the learned counsel for the petitioner and the learned Standing Counsel for the respondents. In this group of writ petitions, the petitioner has challenged the revisional order of the Chief Controlling Revisional Authority (CCRA) passed (under Section 56(2) of the Stamp Act, allowing the revision of the State and holding that the petitioner was liable to pay the deficiency of stamp duty. The petitioner has also prayed for the quashing of the circular dated 12-3-1994 issued by the District Magistrate which provided that in case the land was being purchased for industrial purposes, in that event, the stamp duty would be payable at three times the rate prescribed for agricultural land. For facility, the writ petition No. 56505 of 2005 is being made the leading case and the facts mentioned therein are being taken into consideration.

    2. Briefly stated, the facts leading to the filing of the writ petition is, that the petitioner is a company duly incorporated under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 and had purchased various pieces of land, in village Todarpur, in district Saharanpur, for the purpose of setting up a sugar factory.

    3. The petitioner purchased agricultural land by means of a sale deed Dated 22-7-94. Since the land was agricultural in nature, the petitioner paid the stamp duty in accordance with the circle rate issued by the District Magistrate. Or 13-2-1995, the Additional District Magistrate (Finance), issued a notice under Section 47-A read with Section 33(4) of the Stamp Act to the petitioner, to show cause, as to why the deficiency of stamp duty should not be levied. In the notice, it was alleged that the petitioner had purchased the land for industrial purposes and that the market value of the land for industrial purpose came to Rs. 1,51,312.50 per bigha on the basis of which a sum of Rs. 54,312.50 was payable as stamp duty, whereas, the petitioner had only paid a sum of Rs. 25,250/- It is alleged that the aforesaid notice was issued on the basis of a circular dated 12-3-1994 issued by the District Magistrate which provided that in case the land was being purchased for business or for industrial purposes, in that event, the stamp duty was payable at three times the rate prescribed for agricultural land.

    4. The petitioner, in response to the aforesaid show cause notice, filed a detailed objection denying the allegations made in the notice. The petitioner contended that there was no deficiency of stamp duty and that the stamp duty was paid in accordance with the market value of the land and in accordance with the circle rate issued by the District Magistrate.

    5. The Assistant Commissioner (stamps), by his order dated 8-1-96, discharged the notice and held that there was no deficiency of stamp duty on the conveyance in question and that the petitioner had paid the stamp duty in accordance with the market value which was more than the prescribed circle rate fixed by the District Magistrate. The Authority further found that there was no industrial unit in the vicinity and that the land purchased was agricultural land and that adequate stamp duty was paid by the petitioner.

    6. In May 2000, i.e after than 4 years, the State Government preferred a revision under Section 56(2) of the Act which contained no explanation of the inordinate delay in filing the Revision. The petitioner filed their objections contending that there was a huge delay in the filing of the revision and that no explanation had been given for condoning the delay. However, the Revisional Authority, by an order dated 6-6-2000, condoned the delay in the interest of justice. Subsequently, the Revisional Authority, by an order dated 20-7-2005, allowed the revision holding that there was a deficiency of stamp duty and that the petitioner was liable to pay three times the rates prescribed for agricultural land, since the petitioner had purchased the land for an industrial purpose. The Revisional Authority, based its order by relying upon the circular issued by the District Magistrate. The Revisional Authority further held that the petitioner was liable to make good the deficiency of Stamp Duty amounting to Rs. 29,062.50.

    7. Aggrieved, the petitioner has filed the present writ petition. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the stamp duty is attracted on the instrument at the time of the execution of the document and that the stamp duty, on the potential value or the nature of the land that would be put in use in future, is not required to be considered, while, determining the market value of the land.

    8. The learned Counsel submitted that the market value of the land is to be determined on the basis of the character of the land and cannot be determined on the basis of its future potential. The learned counsel, consequently submitted that the rates fixed by the District Magistrate demanding three times the rates fixed for agricultural and for such agricultural land purchased for industrial purpose was wholly illegal and against the provisions of the Stamp Act.

    9. The learned counsel further submitted that the revision was filed after more than 4 years of the passing of the order by the competent authority and submitted that the revision was highly belated and that no explanation whatsoever was given for condoning the delay in filing the revision. The learned counsel further submitted that the Revisional Authority had committed a manifest error in entertaining the revision on the ground of interest of justice without giving any reason for condoning the delay and that it should have dismissed the revision on the ground of laches.

    10. On the other hand, the learned standing counsel submitted that the Assistant Commissioner had committed a manifest error in discharging the notice under Section 47-A of the Stamp Act and that the authority had erred in holding that there was no deficiency of stamp duty without determining the market value of the land in question. The learned standing counsel submitted that the Assistant Commissioner discharged the notice on the basis of giving a finding that the stamp duty has been paid in accordance with the circle rate issued by the District Magistrate without determining the market value as required under Section 47-A of the Act. The learned standing counsel submitted that since there was an error in the order of the Assistant Commissioner, a revision was filed which has been allowed by the Revisional Authority after considering the impact of the circular of the District Magistrate and after determining that the rate of duty was required to be paid at three times the rate prescribed for agricultural land. This finding was based on the basis of the circular issued by the District Magistrate which contemplated that where the land was purchased for business or industrial purposes, in that event, the rate of stamp duty would be charged on the basis of three times the rate prescribed for the agricultural land. The learned standing counsel submitted that since a manifest error of law had crept in the order of the Assistant Commissioner and on the basis of a complaint, an enquiry was initiated by the Collector and thereafter, the I.G Registration, vide its letter dated 25-9-1998, directed the District Magistrate to send all the sale deeds executed in favour of the petitioner, which were then placed before the Board of Revenue, and after considering the matter, the Board of Revenue directed the District Magistrate, by its letter dated 4-4-2000, to file a revision under Section 56 of the Stamp Act and, on that basis, the revisions were filed. Consequently, the learned standing counsel submitted that the delay in filing the revision was liable to be condoned in the interest of justice as substantial revenue was being lost by the State Government.

    11. Admittedly, in the present case, stamp duty has been levied on the basis of the circular dated 12-3-1994 issued by the District Magistrate. This circular, is in fact, the circle rate issued by the District Magistrate prescribing the rates of land for different areas in the district of Saharanpur. At the end of the circular, a note has been placed which reads as under:

    “Where agricultural land is purchased for business or industrial purposes, in that case, the stamp duty would be payable @ of three times the rate prescribed for agricultural land.”

    12. The moot question which arises for consideration is, whether the market value of the land could be determined with reference to the use of the land to which a buyer intends to put it in use and whether the potential value of the land could be taken into consideration for determining the market value of the land in question.

    13. Admittedly, the circle rates issued by the District Magistrate are only guidelines and, at best, it prima facie indicates the value of the land in a particular area as held by the Supreme Court in R.C Bansal v. District Magistrate, (1999) 5 SCC 62 : AIR 1999 SC 2126: (1999 All LJ 1547). In State of Punjab v. Mahabir Singh, (1996) 1 SCC 609 : AIR 1996 SC 2994, the Supreme Court held that the circle rate was merely a guideline provided by the State which could only serve as prima facie material of the value of the land.

    14. In Maya Foods and Vanaspati Ltd., Allahabad v. Chief Controlling Revenue Authority (BR), Allahabad, 1998 (4) AWC 636, a single Judge of this Court held that the market value of the land cannot be determined with reference to the use of the land to which the buyer intends put it in use. The learned Judge held—

    “Learned Chief Controlling Revenue authority has observed that the land was purchased for an industrial purpose and the Collector is not arbitrary in deciding the price of the land on the basis of the proposed usage. This proposition is legally incorrect. The market value of the land cannot be determined with reference to the use of the land to which buyer intends to put it. One buyer may intend to establish an industrial undertaking thereon, another may intend to use it for agricultural purpose and a third person may intend to dedicate it for charitable purposes like leaving it open as pasture ground or a cremation ground or a playground. These different intentions may affect the price that each of them may be willing to pay for the property and such prices have wide variations but the market value is not what each such individual may offer for the property. The market value is what a general buyer may offer and what the owner may reasonably expect. In determining the market value, the potential of the land as on the date of sale alone can be taken into account and not what potential it may have in the distant future.”

    15. In Anirudhha Kumar and Ashwini Kumar v. Chief Controlling Revenue Authority, Uttar Pradesh, Allahabad, 2000 (3) AWC 2587, the learned single Judge held—

    “In the present case, the market value is to be determined on the basis of the value that would satisfy the vendor. Thus, the question of future potential cannot be a factor for determining the market value of such a land for the purpose of stamp duty payable under the Stamp Act. The vendee pays the price that satisfies the vendor and, therefore, it is the utility of the land as on the date of transfer by the vendor and as such, if the land was an agricultural land, it has to be treated as such and the valuation has to be done accordingly. Whether in future the purchaser puts the land into residential use or changes the character is immaterial for the purpose of payment of stamp duty.”

    16. Rakesh Chandra Mittal v. Additional District Magistrate (Finance and Revenue), Moradabad, 2004 (3) UPLBEC 2434 : (2004 All LJ 2802), a Division Bench of this Court held (Para 10)—

    “It is well settled that market value of the property has to be determined with reference to the date on which the document is executed. Market value as such keeps on varying and changing. Any subsequent improvement or change in the nature or user of the land, which may result into enhancement of the market value of the property, is not to be taken into account and it is only the value of the property on the date of execution of the document that is to be considered for the purpose of determination of proper stamp duty payable on the instrument.”

    17. Above all, a Full Bench of this Court in Shri Ramesh Chandra Srivastava, Kanpur v. State of U.P, 2007 UPTC 335 : (2007 (1) ALJ 90) held that the market value of the property has to be determined with reference to the date of which the document is executed.

    18. In view of the judgments of this Court, it is clear that the market value of the property has to be determined with reference to the date of which the document is executed. The market value of the property cannot be determined on the basis that the said property could be used for a different purpose nor could the market value be determined on the basis that it has a potential value in future. A Full Bench of this Court has clearly held that on the basis of the various provisions of the Stamp Act, the market value is to be determined with reference to the date of which the document was executed and that any subsequent change in the nature or use of the land which may result in the enhancement of the market value of the property was not to be taken into account.

    19. Consequently, the note (b) given by the District Magistrate in its circular dated 12-3-1994 is against the provisions of the Stamp Act and is without jurisdiction and cannot be sustained. Such type of determination of the market value cannot be envisaged. Since the writ petition is being allowed on this ground itself, it is not necessary for the Court to dwell on the question as to whether the revisional authority was justified in condoning the delay in the filing of the revision.

    20. For the reasons stated aforesaid, the impugned order of the Revisional Authority cannot be sustained and is quashed. The writ petition is allowed. Further, I also hold that note (b) of the circle rate dated 12-3-1994 issued by the Collector, Saharanpur is wholly illegal and against the provisions of the Stamp Act and is also quashed. In the circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to cost.

    21. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shakumbari Sugar And Allied Industries Ltd. v. State Of U.P & Ors.
    (Apr 12, 2007)