Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C as specific provision
  • provision of Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C
  • Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C
  • Section 151 C.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C as specific provision
  • provision of Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C
  • Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C
  • Section 151 C.P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition challenges the order dated 6-5-2005 passed by the trial court and the order dated 19-12-2005 passed by the revisional court. The respondent No. 1 filed a suit for declaration against the petitioners-defendants and presented an application under Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C for discovery of certain documents. The initial application was dismissed on 4-4-2005 for lack of supporting affidavit and denial by the defendants of possession of the documents. Subsequently, a second application, stated to be under Section 151 C.P.C with the same prayer and supported by an affidavit, was allowed by the trial court. The revisional court dismissed the petitioners' revision petition, holding that it would not examine factual matters. The petitioners challenged this order on grounds including res judicata and incorrect invocation of Section 151 C.P.C instead of Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the earlier order dismissing the application for discovery of documents operates as res judicata against the second application.
  2. Whether an application for discovery of documents can be properly entertained if filed under Section 151 C.P.C instead of Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The earlier order rejecting the respondent-plaintiff’s application for discovery of documents should operate as res judicata.
  • The second application was incorrectly filed under Section 151 C.P.C instead of the specific provision Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C, and therefore should not have been entertained.
  • Cited case law: All Khan v. Ram Prasad (1981 AWC 17 : 1981 All LJ 271) and N.I.M.H & Neuro Sciences v. C. Parameshwara (2005 (2) AWC 1865 (SC) : (2005) 2 SCC 256 : AIR 2005 SC 242).

Respondents' Arguments

  • The earlier order was not passed on merits but was a summary dismissal for want of affidavit; hence it does not operate as res judicata.
  • The merits of whether the documents are in possession of petitioners-defendants were never examined in the earlier order.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
All Khan v. Ram Prasad (1981 AWC 17 : 1981 All LJ 271) Principle of res judicata The court held that this precedent was not applicable because the earlier order was not decided on merits and thus did not operate as res judicata.
N.I.M.H & Neuro Sciences v. C. Parameshwara (2005 (2) AWC 1865 (SC) : (2005) 2 SCC 256 : AIR 2005 SC 242) Improper invocation of Section 151 C.P.C instead of specific provisions The court found this precedent inapplicable to the present facts, emphasizing that the mere incorrect mention of Section 151 C.P.C in the application heading does not warrant rejection if the prayer falls under another specific provision.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the two main points raised by the petitioners. First, it found that the earlier order dismissing the application for discovery was a summary order not decided on merits but for want of a supporting affidavit, which the court noted was not procedurally required. Therefore, the earlier order cannot operate as res judicata because the factual question of possession of documents was never examined. Second, regarding the classification of the application under Section 151 C.P.C instead of Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C, the court held that the mere heading or mention of a provision does not invalidate the application. The court must consider the substance and merits of the prayer. Since the application sought discovery of documents, it was rightly considered under Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C despite the heading. The court also rejected the applicability of the cited precedent concerning improper invocation of Section 151 C.P.C, emphasizing the trial court’s detailed consideration of the matter and the correctness of its order directing the petitioners, as representatives of the society, to produce documents.

Holding and Implications

The petition is dismissed.

The court upheld the trial court’s order allowing discovery of documents despite the procedural irregularity in the application’s heading and rejected the plea of res judicata based on the earlier summary dismissal. The decision directly affects the parties by confirming the trial court’s direction to the petitioners to produce the documents. No broader precedent or new legal principle was established beyond the application of existing procedural rules and principles regarding interlocutory orders and the substance-over-form approach to procedural filings.

    President, Shri Chaturbhuj Sharma Sikshan Sansthan Mahavidyalaya Samiti, Orai & Ors. v. Awadh Bihari Tiwari & Ors

    1. Heard learned counsel for the g parties.

    2. This petition challenges the order dated 6-5-2005 passed by the trial court and order dated 19-12-2005 passed by the revisional court. The respondent No. 1 filed a suit for declaration against the petitioners-defendants in which the plaintiff presented an application under Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C for discovery of certain documents. Initially the said application was dismissed vide order dated 4-4-2005 (Annexure-6) stating that the application was not supported with affidavit and the defendants petitioners had denied possession of those documents sought to be discovered. Thereafter, a second application stated to be under Section 151 C.P.C was moved with the same prayer, which has been allowed by the impugned order. This application was supported with affidavit. The revisional court has dismissed the revision of the petitioners stating that the revisional court would not go into the factual matters and thus, the revision was not found having merits. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners has tried to emphasise that the earlier order rejecting the application of the respondent-plaintiff will operate as res judi cata and has also cited the case law of All Khan v. Ram Prasad, 1981 AWC 17 : (1981 All LJ 271). The second argument of the learned counsel is that the present application, which has been allowed by the impugned order, is stated to be an application under Section 151 C.P.C whereas it should be an application under Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C as specific provision for granting such prayer is provided under the Code. Therefore, if the application has been given the title of being a petition under Section 151 C.P.C the same is not to be entertained in view of case law of N.I.M.H & Neuro Sciences v. C. Parameshwara, 2005 (2) AWC 1865 (SC) : ((2005) 2 SCC 256 : AIR 2005 SC 242).

    3. As regards the first point of argument raised in the present case, the reply, which has been given from the side of the respondents, is that the order, which was passed earlier in Annexure-6, was not an order passed on merits and the application was summarily rejected for waht of supporting affidavit. The merits of the matter whether the documents sought to be discovered are possessed by the petitioners-defendants are not gone into by the trial court in the earlier order, therefore, the said order would not operate as res judicata.

    4. I find force in the reply argument given from the side of respondents. Any order whether interlocutory or not, if has not been passed on merit, it will definitely not operate as res judicata. The aforesaid case law of Division Bench of this court in the present facts and circumstances would not be applicable. The application was summarily rejected for want of supporting affidavit though, the affidavit in support of such application is not required under the procedure. So-far-as the availability of those documents with the respondents defendants is concerned, the mere observation in the earlier order is that the defendants had denied possession of the same. This point is also not discussed on merit. The second order passed by the court below is a full-fledged order passed after discussing the entire aspects of the matter and in the present context any bar of res judicata would not be applicable for the purposes to challenge this order.

    5. As regards the second point of argument that such application should not be allowed with a heading of Section 151 C.P.C, it also does not appear to be very sound. The mere mention of provision on the heading of the application will not render the application liable for rejection. On the contrary the prayer made in the application if found to be sound and covered under some other provision of the Code, it will not be treated as one made under Section 151 C.P.C Such application should usually be considered in the light of its otherwise merits by the court. In the present case, the application with the prayer, appears to be pure and simple under the provision of Order XI, Rule 12 C.P.C for discovery of document. It is definitely an order passed under that provision only and the application is not liable to be rejected summarily because it wrongly mentions Section 151 C.P.C in its heading.

    6. The aforesaid case law of N.I.M.H & Neuro Sciences (supra) is not applicable with the facts of this case. The trial court has given its serious thoughts to the prayer made in the application of the respondents plaintiffs and has found that the documents, which were sought to be discovered, would, definitely be in possession of the petitioners, who are President and Secretary of the society and who alone represent the society. Therefore, if a direction has been given to them for presenting those documents, the said order cannot be said to be erroneous. The possession of the documents may be with the Treasurer but since the President and Secretary of the society represent the society itself, the direction of the court will be issued only to the President and Secretary and not to the Treasurer.

    7. In the aforesaid view of the matter, I do not find any error whatsoever in the order of the court below and as such the petition having no force is hereby dismissed.

    8. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    President, Shri Chat... v. Awadh Bihari Tiwari ...
    (Mar 6, 2006)