Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • clause (g) of sub-section (1) of Section 95. Rule 2(c), Rule 4 and Rule 5 of U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947
  • Section 2(c) of U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan; Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1997.
  • Rule 2(c) of U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947
  • Section 95(1)[g) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947. Proviso to Section 95(1)(g)
  • Rule 5 with proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947
  • sub-section (2) of Section 11-A or sub-section (5) of Section 12,
  • Section 95(1)(g) proviso of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947
  • Section 95(1)(g) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947
  • clause (g) of sub-section (1) of Section 95
  • Clauses (a) to (m) of Section 5-A:(Provided
  • Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947. Rule 2(c)
  • Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947
  • sub-rule (2) of Rule 4
  • Section 95(1)(g)
  • Rule 4. Rule 5
  • Rule 4(2).
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • clause (g) of sub-section (1) of Section 95. Rule 2(c), Rule 4 and Rule 5 of U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947
  • Section 2(c) of U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan; Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1997.
  • Rule 2(c) of U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947
  • Section 95(1)[g) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947. Proviso to Section 95(1)(g)
  • Rule 5 with proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947
  • sub-section (2) of Section 11-A or sub-section (5) of Section 12,
  • Section 95(1)(g) proviso of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947
  • Section 95(1)(g) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947
  • clause (g) of sub-section (1) of Section 95
  • Clauses (a) to (m) of Section 5-A:(Provided
  • Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947. Rule 2(c)
  • Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947
  • sub-rule (2) of Rule 4
  • Section 95(1)(g)
  • Rule 4. Rule 5
  • Rule 4(2).
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed this writ petition seeking quashing of the District Magistrate, Kanpur Nagar's order dated 16 August 2004, by which the District Magistrate ceased the petitioner’s financial and administrative powers under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 and appointed a three-member committee.

The material facts, as set out in the opinion, are:

  • Several members of the Gaon Sabha filed a complaint against the petitioner.
  • The Commissioner of the Division passed an order directing the District Director (Panchayat) to conduct an enquiry.
  • The Deputy Director (Panchayat) conducted an enquiry and submitted a report dated 20 February 2004 to the Commissioner.
  • On the basis of that enquiry report, the District Magistrate issued a show cause notice to the petitioner (dated 21 July 2004) asking why action under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) should not be taken.
  • The petitioner submitted a reply to the show cause notice; thereafter the District Magistrate passed the impugned order on 16 August 2004.
  • The District Magistrate recorded that he was satisfied, on the material before him, that the petitioner was prima facie guilty of irregularities, justifying cessation of financial and administrative powers.
  • The impugned order also appointed an officer (Assistant Engineer, District Rule Development Agency, Kanpur) as the final enquiry officer.

The writ petition impugns the lawfulness of the District Magistrate's order dated 16 August 2004. The Court heard senior counsel for the parties and standing counsel before delivering the judgment quashing the impugned order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned order dated 16 August 2004 was passed in accordance with the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 and the U.P. Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules (as referred to in the opinion).
  2. Whether the Deputy Director (Panchayat) was a valid "Enquiry Officer" within the meaning of Rule 2(c) of the U.P. Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules (as cited in the opinion), given that he was not nominated by the District Magistrate and was not a district-level officer.
  3. Whether the District Magistrate could exercise the power to cease the financial and administrative powers under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) in the absence of a preliminary enquiry report under Rule 4(2) or a final enquiry report under the procedure prescribed in Rule 6.
  4. Whether issuance of a show cause notice by the District Magistrate (and consideration of the petitioner's reply) equates to the District Magistrate having conducted the preliminary enquiry required by the Rules.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The enquiry report dated 20 February 2004 was not an enquiry report as envisaged by the U.P. Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules (the opinion references the Rules with years variously noted in the text).
  • The Deputy Director (Panchayat) was not an enquiry officer within the meaning of Rule 2(c) because he was not nominated by the District Magistrate and, according to the Rules as interpreted by the petitioner, is not a district-level officer.
  • There was no allegation of financial irregularity specifically against the petitioner; therefore the cessation of financial and administrative powers could not be validly ordered under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g).

Respondent's Arguments

  • When the District Magistrate issued the show cause notice (21 July 2004) and subsequently passed the order after considering the petitioner's reply, it should be treated as if the District Magistrate himself had conducted the enquiry; accordingly, the order is an order based on an enquiry by the District Magistrate.
  • There were allegations of financial irregularity against the petitioner in addition to other alleged irregularities; reliance was placed on the affidavit of Smt. Maya Devi filed before the Commissioner (a copy of which was placed on record with the counter-affidavit) to support the existence of allegations of financial irregularity.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a statutory and rules-based analysis focusing on the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 and the procedure prescribed by the corresponding Enquiry Rules. The analysis proceeded as follows:

  1. The Court noted that the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) permits cessation of financial and administrative powers only "where, in an enquiry held by such person and in such manner as may be prescribed, a Pradhan or Up-Pradhan is prima facie found to have committed financial and other irregularities." The Court emphasized that "such manner as may be prescribed" refers to the procedure laid down in the relevant Rules.
  2. The Rules in question (referred to in the opinion as U.P. Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules — the opinion quotes Rule 2(c), Rule 4 and Rule 5) define an "Enquiry Officer" and prescribe the procedure for preliminary enquiry (Rule 4), submission of reports, and constitution of the three-member committee (Rule 5).
  3. Rule 2(c), as extracted in the opinion, defines "Enquiry Officer" to mean "the District Panchayat Raj Officer or any other district level officer, to be nominated by the District Magistrate." Rule 4 prescribes the preliminary enquiry to be ordered by the State Government and requires the Enquiry Officer to submit a report within thirty days. Rule 5 contemplates constitution of the committee and the appointment of an Enquiry Officer other than the one who conducted the preliminary enquiry for the final enquiry.
  4. Applying those provisions to the facts, the Court found that the Deputy Director (Panchayat) who conducted the enquiry was not a district-level officer nominated by the District Magistrate; rather, he had been directed to conduct the enquiry by the Divisional Commissioner. Consequently, that enquiry could not be treated as the preliminary enquiry envisaged by Rule 4.
  5. The Court acknowledged that Rule 5 permits the District Magistrate to direct an enquiry on the basis of the preliminary enquiry report "or otherwise." However, after a harmonious reading of Rule 5 with the proviso to Section 95(1)(g), the Court held that the power to cease financial and administrative powers under the proviso can be exercised only when an enquiry has been held by the person and in the manner prescribed by the Rules — i.e., normally on the basis of a proper preliminary enquiry report or on a prima facie finding that arises in the final enquiry conducted according to the Rules (including Rule 6 procedure for final enquiry).
  6. In the present case, there was neither a preliminary enquiry report as required by Rule 4(2) nor a final enquiry report in which the Pradhan was found prima facie guilty. The final enquiry officer had been appointed by the impugned order itself (i.e., the final enquiry had not yet occurred when the impugned order was passed). Therefore, the statutory condition — an enquiry held in the prescribed manner resulting in a prima facie finding of financial and other irregularities — was not satisfied prior to cessation of powers.
  7. The Court rejected the submission that issuance of a show cause notice and consideration of the reply by the District Magistrate equated to the District Magistrate having conducted the preliminary enquiry. The Court held that mere issuance of a notice cannot be equated with conducting the enquiry contemplated by the Rules.

Based on the foregoing statutory construction and application of the Rules to the facts, the Court concluded that the District Magistrate had no jurisdiction to exercise the power under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) in the manner he did on 16 August 2004.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The impugned order of the District Magistrate dated 16 August 2004 is quashed and the writ petition is allowed.

Implications

  • Direct effect on the parties: The cessation of the petitioner's financial and administrative powers effected by the District Magistrate's order dated 16 August 2004 has been set aside (the impugned order quashed).
  • Further action permitted: The Court observed that this quashing does not prevent the District Magistrate from directing a preliminary enquiry in accordance with the U.P. Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules (as referred to in the opinion) and from taking action thereafter in accordance with law.
  • Precedential effect: The opinion does not announce any broader novel principle of law beyond its application of the statutory scheme and rules to the facts; it confines itself to the direct legal consequence that the statutory preconditions for exercising the power under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) were not met. The opinion does not state that it is laying down a new precedent beyond this ruling.

This summary is compiled exclusively from the content of the provided opinion. No information has been added beyond what appears in the opinion.

    Rajeshwari Kushwaha v. District Magistrate

    1. Heard Sri P.N Saxena, learned Senior Advocate, assisted by Sri. A.K Sachan, Sri Ravi Kiran Jain, Senior Advocate, assisted by Sri. L.M Singh for re: spondent No. 5 and learned standing counsel.

    2. By this writ petition, the petitioner has prayed for quashing the order dated 16th August, 2004 passed by District Mag istrate, Kanpur Nagar by which the District Magistrate has ceased the financial and ad ministrative powers of the petitioner under proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 and appointed three members committee. Brief facts, which emerge from pleading of the parties, are; a complaint was filed against the petitioner by several members of the Gaon Sabha on which the Commissioner of the Division passed an order to the District Director (Panchayat) to conduct an enquiry. The Deputy Director (Panchayat) conducted an enquiry and submitted report dated 20th February, 2004 to the Commissioner. The District Magistrate, Kanpur Nagar on the basis of the enquiry report dated 20th February, 2004 submitted by Deputy Director (Panchayat) issued a show cause notice to the petitioner asking him to show cause as to why action under Section 95(1)(g) proviso be not taken against the petitioner. The petitioner submitted reply to the said show cause notice. The District Magistrate after considering the reply of the petitioner passed order dated 16th August, 2004. The District Magistrate observed that on the basis of the material brought before him he is satisfied that petitioner has been found prima facie guilty of irregularities, hence his financial and administrative powers are liable to be ceased.

    3. Sri. P.N Saxena, learned Senior Advocate, appearing for the petitioner, contended that enquiry report dated 20th February, 2004 was not an enquiry report as contemplated in accordance with the provisions of U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and (Members) Enquiry Rules, 1997 and on the said basis the District Magistrate has no jurisdiction to pass an order ceasing the financial and administrative powers. Sri Saxena contended that neither the District Magistrate nominated the Deputy Director (Panchayat) to conduct the enquiry nor Deputy Director (Panchayat) can be enquiry officer under Section 2(c) of U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan; Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1997. Sri Saxena further contended that there was no allegation of financial irregularity against the petitioner, hence financial and administrative powers of the petitioner could not have been ceased.

    4. Sri Ravi Kiran Jain, replying the submission of counsel for the petitioner, contended that when the show cause notice has been issued by the District Magistrate dated 21st July, 2004 and the District Magistrate after considering the reply of the petitioner has passed the order, it should be treated that District Magistrate himself has conducted the enquiry and the order passed by District Magistrate is nothing but an order passed on the basis of enquiry conducted by the District Magistrate himself. He further contended that there was allegation of financial irregularity against the petitioner apart from other irregularity. Sri Jain relied on the affidavit of Smt. Maya Devi which was filed before the Commissioner, copy of which has been filed along with the counter affidavit in which allegation of financial irregularity against the Pradhan has been made.

    5. I have considered the submissions and perused the record.

    6. The first submission of counsel for the petitioner is that impugned order has not been passed in accordance with Section 95(1)(g) proviso of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 and U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) En quiry Rules, 1947, hence the order of Dis trict Magistrate is vitiated. The submission of the petitioner, as noted above, is that the Deputy Director (Panchayat) is not enquiry officer within the meaning of Rule 2(c) of U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947 nor his enquiry report can be said to be pre liminary enquiry report within the meaning of U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947. The reply of Sri Jain, as noted above, is that District Magistrate when issued show cause notice, it will be presumed that he held the enquiry and there was no impedi ment for the District Magistrate in passing the order. For appreciating the submission raised by counsel for the parties, it is relevant to note proviso to Section 95(1)[g) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947. Proviso to Section 95(1)(g) provides that where, in an enquiry held fay such person and in such manner as may be prescribed, a Pradhan or Up-Pradhan is prima facie found to have committed financial and other irregularities such Pradhan or Up-Pradhan shall cease to exercise and perform the financial and administrative powers and functions. Section 95(1)(g) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 is quoted below:—

    “95(1)(g) : (remove a Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members of a Gram Panchayat or a Joint Committee or Bhumi Prabandhak Samiti, or a Panch, Sahayak Sarpanch or Sarpanch of a Nyaya Panchayat if he)—

    (i) absents himself without sufficient cause for more than three consecutive meetings or sittings.

    (ii) Refuses to act or becomes incapable of acting for any reason whatsoever or if he is accused of or charges for an offence involving moral turpitude,

    (iii) has abused his position as such or has persistently failed to perform the duties imposed by this Act or Rules made thereunder or his continuance as such is not desirable in public interest, or

    (iii-a) has taken the benefit of reservation under sub-section (2) of Section 11-A or sub-section (5) of Section 12, as the case may be, on the basis of a false declaration subscribed by him stating that he is a member of Schedule Castes, the Scheduled Tribes or the backward classes, as the case maybe

    (iv) being a Sahayak Sarpanch or a Sarpanch of the Nyaya Panchayat takes active part in politics, or

    (v) suffers from any of the disqualifications mentioned in Clauses (a) to (m) of Section 5-A:

    (Provided that where, in an enquiry held by such person and in such manner as may be prescribed, a Pradhan or Up Pradhan is prima facie found to have committed financial and other irregularities such Pradhan or Up Pradhan shall cease to exercise and perform the financial and administrative powers and functions, which shall, until he exonerated of the charges in the final enquiry, be exercised and performed by a Committee consisting of three members of Gram Panchayat appointed by the State Government.)”

    7. In the proviso enquiry is contemplated by such person and in such manner as may be prescribed. The word prescribed obviously means prescribed by the rules. Rules have been framed, namely, U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947. Rule 2(c) defines enquiry officer. Rule 4 provides with regard to preliminary enquiry and Rule 5 is with regard to constitution of three members committee as envisaged under proviso to clause (g) of sub-section (1) of Section 95. Rule 2(c), Rule 4 and Rule 5 of U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947 is extracted below:—

    “2(c). ‘Enquiry Officer’ means the District Panchayat Raj Officer or any other district level officer, to be nominated by fne District Magistrate.

    8. Preliminary Enquiry.— (1) The State Government may, on the receipt of a com plaint or report referred to in Rule 3, or oth erwise order the Enquiry Officer to conduct a preliminary enquiry with a view to finding out if there is a prima facie case for a formal enquiry in the matter.

    (2) The Enquiry Officer shall conduct the preliminary enquiry as expeditiously as possible and submit his report to the State Government within thirty days of his having been so ordered.

    9. Where the State Government is of the opinion, on the basis of the report referred to in sub-rule (2) of Rule 4 or otherwise that an enquiry should be held against a Pradhan or Up-Pradhan or Member under the pro viso to clause (g) of sub-section (1) of Section 95 it shall forthwith constitute a com mittee envisaged by proviso to clause (g) of sub-section (1) of Section 95, of the Act and by an order ask an Enquiry Officer, other than the Enquiry Officer nominated under sub-rule (2) of Rule (4), to hold the enquiry.

    10. The preliminary enquiry as contemplated under U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947 has to be by an enquiry officer nominated by the District Magistrate. Admittedly, the Deputy Director (Panchayat) was an enquiry officer not nominated by the District Magistrate but he was directed to conduct the enquiry by Divisional Commissioner. According to provisions of U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947, the Deputy Director (Panchayat) being not a district level officer cannot be an enquiry officer. The enquiry conducted by Deputy Director (Panchayat) cannot be said to be an enquiry under Rule 4. Rule 5 gives power to the State Government/District Magistrate to direct for holding an enquiry against the Pradhan under proviso to clause (g) of sub-section (1) of Section 95 on the basis of report referred to in sub-rule (2) of Rule 4 or otherwise. The action of the District Magistrate is not based on any preliminary enquiry report as referred to in Rule 4(2). The question, however, is that as to whether without there being any preliminary enquiry report the District Magistrate himself could have passed the impugned order. Reading of Rule 5 clearly provides that District Magistrate can take a decision otherwise than the preliminary enquiry report also to hold an enquiry against the Pradhan. However, harmonious reading of Rule 5 with proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 makes it clear that the power to cease financial and administrative powers under proviso to Section 95(1)(g) can be made only when in an enquiry held by such person in such manner as prescribed, a Pradhan is found to have committed financial and other irregularities. Under Rule 5, the District Magistrate can direct for enquiry which enquiry shall take place in accordance with the procedure prescribed in Rule 6. The power under 95(1)(g) proviso can thus be exercised on the basis of preliminary enquiry report or on the basis of prima facie finding which comes even in an final enquiry as prescribed under Rule 6. In the present case, admittedly, final enquiry has not yet been held since the final enquiry officer has been appointed in the order impugned dated 16th August, 2004 itself i.e Assistant Engineer, District Rule Development Agency, Kanpur. The enquiry officer to conduct the final enquiry having been appointed by the impugned order itself, there is no question of any final enquiry’ report before the District Magistrate. There being no final enquiry report in which Pradhan has been found prima facie guilty of financial and other irregularities nor there being any preliminary enquiry report, the power under proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of U.P Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 cannot be exercised by the District Magistrate.

    11. The submission of Sri Jain that District Magistrate himself has conducted the preliminary enquiry cannot be accepted. After receiving the preliminary enquiry report, the District Magistrate has to issue show cause notice for taking action under Section 95(1)(g). Mere issuance of notice by the District Magistrate cannot tantamount conducting of enquiry by the District Magistrate.

    12. In view of the foregoing discussions, the order of the District Magistrate impugned in the writ petition dated 16th August, 2004 cannot be sustained and is hereby quashed. It is, however, observed that this order shall not prevent the District Magistrate in directing for holding preliminary enquiry in accordance with U.P Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhan, Up-Pradhan and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1947 and take action in accordance with law. The writ petition is allowed accordingly.

    13. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajeshwari Kushwaha v. District Magistrate
    (Oct 28, 2004)