AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 5 of 1974 Rules. Relaxation
  • Rule 5 of recruitment Rule 1974,
  • Government Service Rule 5
  • omittedEd.)6. Rule 5
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 5 of 1974 Rules. Relaxation
  • Rule 5 of recruitment Rule 1974,
  • Government Service Rule 5
  • omittedEd.)6. Rule 5
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitions concern a challenge to an order dated 24-3-2003 issued by the Deputy Director General (Establishment), U.P. Police Headquarters, Allahabad, which called the petitioner to appear for interview for appointment as a Constable (Civil Police) in the pay scale of Rs. 3050-4590 on compassionate grounds. The petitioner contends that he was entitled to compassionate appointment as a Sub-Inspector (Civil Police) and not as a Constable.

Facts as recorded in the opinion: the petitioner's father, who was employed in the U.P. Police Department as a follower, died in harness on 19-7-1986 while the petitioner was a minor. After the petitioner graduated, he submitted application papers for compassionate appointment under the U.P. (Recruitment of Dependents of Government Servants Dying in Harness) Rules, 1974. An inquiry report appears to have been submitted on 31-8-2002.

The petitioner asserted that the process for appointment as Sub-Inspector had been completed and even approved, except for interview and appointment letter, but that the criteria for Sub-Inspector appointment were changed by respondent No. 2 in the meantime. Consequently he was directed to appear for interview for the post of Constable and filed the present writ petition challenging that direction.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner, as a dependent of a government servant who died in harness, was entitled to compassionate appointment to the post of Sub-Inspector (Civil Police) rather than to the post of Constable.
  2. Whether the department acted lawfully in calling the petitioner for interview for the post of Constable given (a) that the petitioner's application was filed beyond the five-year period specified in Rule 5, (b) that the State Government had granted a relaxation, and (c) that the petitioner allegedly did not meet the physical/medical standards required for Sub-Inspector.
  3. Whether the phrase "to be given a suitable employment in Government Service" in Rule 5 of the 1974 Rules includes consideration of physical standards and other suitability criteria beyond mere educational qualification.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner submitted that he fulfilled the eligibility prescribed for the post of Sub-Inspector (Civil Police) and that all necessary formalities for his appointment as Sub-Inspector had been completed except the interview and issuance of the appointment letter.
  • He relied on an earlier government order (dated 21-12-1973, appended as Annexure 10) and on Rule 5 of the 1974 Rules, arguing that the phrase "to be given a suitable employment in Government Service" confers a legal right to be appointed on a post fitting his qualifications — in his case, Sub-Inspector.
  • He contended that calling him for interview for the post of Constable was arbitrary and contrary to law, especially when, according to him, many vacancies for Sub-Inspector posts existed in U.P., and it was unprecedented to call a candidate suitable for Sub-Inspector to face interview only for Constable.
  • The petitioner asserted that he should not be deprived of a better post and pay scale by being offered the lower post of Constable.

Department's (Respondents') Arguments

  • The department explained that compassionate appointment cases are considered by a departmental committee chaired by the Deputy Inspector General of Police, and that the deceased's family had not applied for compassionate appointment within five years of the death of the government servant; the petitioner applied only after he became a major (after an 11-year lapse).
  • Although the immediate family members who were eligible did not apply within five years, the department, adopting a humanitarian approach, sought and obtained relaxation under Rule 5 so as to consider the petitioner's case.
  • Despite the relaxation, the petitioner was found not to meet the physical standard (specifically chest measurement) required for appointment as Sub-Inspector; therefore he was offered the lower post of Constable.
  • The department alleged that the petitioner did not provide complete information in a 26-point checklist, and that incomplete or delayed information was used to gain time to overcome the physical shortfall; otherwise the petitioner could have been appointed as Constable in the year 2000 itself for which he was eligible according to the records.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by considering the record and hearing learned counsel for the parties. It examined Rule 5 of the U.P. (Recruitment of Dependents of Government Servants Dying in Harness) Rules, 1974, which the opinion quotes and addresses: the Rule provides that a dependent of a government servant dying in harness shall be "given a suitable employment in Government Service" provided certain conditions (educational qualifications, other qualifications, and timely application within five years) are satisfied, subject to the State Government's power to relax the time limit in appropriate cases.

The court accepted the department's factual account that the petitioner had filed the compassionate appointment application well beyond the five-year period and that other eligible family members had not applied within time. It noted the department nevertheless obtained relaxation from the State Government to consider the petitioner's appointment.

The court interpreted the word "suitable" in Rule 5 to mean more than mere educational qualification: suitability also encompasses compliance with physical standards and other norms required for the post by the department. Applying that interpretation to the petitioner's case, the court observed the record showed the petitioner lacked the physical standard (chest measurement) required for the post of Sub-Inspector; on that basis he could not be held entitled to appointment as Sub-Inspector.

The court also relied on the department's explanation that the petitioner had not provided complete information in the prescribed checklist and that further information was required; the opinion records that these factors contributed to the timeline and that, but for these matters, the petitioner might have been appointed to the post of Constable earlier.

Concluding its analysis, the court found no mala fide action by the respondents in offering the petitioner the lower post of Constable after determining he did not meet the physical standards for Sub-Inspector. Given these findings, the court held that the impugned order directing the petitioner to appear for interview for the post of Constable did not warrant interference under Article 226 of the Constitution.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is dismissed.

Implications and immediate effects:

  • The court refused to grant the relief prayed for by the petitioner to be appointed as Sub-Inspector on compassionate grounds, concluding that he was not eligible for that post because he did not meet the required physical standard and because his application was filed beyond the five-year period (though relaxation had been granted).
  • The departmental decision to call the petitioner for interview for the post of Constable was upheld and found not to require interference under Article 226.
  • The opinion notes that the petitioner had earlier been permitted by the court to join as a Constable by an interim order dated 23-5-2003; the final dismissal means no further relief is granted and no costs were ordered ("No order as to costs").
  • The court's decision concerns the specific facts and statutory interpretation of "suitable employment" under Rule 5 in this case; the opinion does not purport to set out any broader precedent beyond its conclusion that suitability includes required physical standards. If no broader implications were argued in the opinion, the practical consequence is limited to the parties: the petitioner's claim to Sub-Inspector status on compassionate grounds was rejected and the offer/appointment process for Constable stands.

This summary is strictly limited to the information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts or authorities that are not present in the text.

    Rakesh Kumar Tiwari v. Secretary, Home Department, Government Of U.P And Others

    1. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. The controversy involved in the aforesaid petitions pertains to grant of compassionate appointment. The petitioner has challenged the validity of correctness of the order dated 24-3-2003 issued by Deputy Director General (Establishment), U.P Police Head Quarters Allahabad, offering compassionate appointment to the petitioner as Constable in Civil Police in the pay scale of Rs. 3050-4590. The petitioners claim that he is entitled for compassionate appointment on the post of Sub-Inspector in Civil Police and not as Constable.

    2. The father of the petitioner was in service in U.P Police Department as follower. He expired on 19-7-1986 in harness. The petitioner was minor at that time. After graduating, the petitioner submitted the papers for appointment on compassionate ground under the U.P (Recruitment of Dependents of Government Servants) Dying in Harness Rules 1974. The Government granted age relaxation for appointment of the petitioner after inter departmental correspondence. The inquiry report in respect of the petitioner appears to have been submitted on 31st August, 2002.

    3. The petitioner claims that he was eligible for the post of Sub-Inspector (Civil Police). It is submitted that the process for appointment of the petitioner for the post of Sub-Inspector (Civil Police) was completed and approval was also accorded for his appointment to the post of Sub-Inspector (Civil Police) except interview and issuance of appointment letter for the said post. In the mean time it appears that criteria for the appointment of Sub-Inspector (Civil Police) were changed by respondent No. 2.

    4. The petitioner was thereafter directed to appear for interview for the post of Constable (Civil Police) in the pay scale of Rs. 3050-75-3950-80-4590 at Police Headquarter Allahabad. Aggrieved by the order dated 24-3-2003 whereby he was directed to appear for interview against the post of Constable (Civil Police) this petition has been filed.

    5. The contention of the counsel for the petitioner is that before the enforcement of U.P (Recruitment of Dependants of Government Servants. Dying in Harness Rules 1974, a Government order dated 21-12-1973 had been issued providing that the dependants of employees who have died in the harness may be appointed as per their qualification. The copy of the Government Order has to be appended as (Annexure 10 to the writ petition) and is as under:

    (Vernacular matter omitted………Ed.)

    6. Rule 5 of Recruitment of Dependents of Govt. Servants, 1977 Dying In Harness Rules, provides recruitment of a member of the family of the deceased is as under:—

    “In case a Government servant dies in harness after the commencement of these rules, one member of his family who is not already employed under the Central Government or a State Government or a Corporation owned or controlled by the Central Government or a State Government shall on making an application for the purposes, be given a suitable employment in Government Service which is not within the purview of the State Public Service Commission in relaxation of the normal recruitment rules, if such person,

    (i) Fulfils the educational qualifications prescribed for the post.

    (ii) Is otherwise qualified for Government service, and

    (iii) Makes the application for employment, within five years of the date of death of the Government Servant.

    Provided that where the State Government is satisfied that the time limit fixed for making the application for employment causes undue hardship in any particular case, it may dispense with or relax the recruitment as it may consider necessary for dealing with the case in a just and equitable manner.

    (2) As far as possible, such an employment should be given in the same department which the deceased Government Servant was employed prior to his death.”

    7. It is urged by the counsel for the petitioner that the word “to be given a suitable employment in Government Service” Rule 5 vests the petitioner with a legal right the petitioner with a legal right to get appointment on compassionate ground against the post of Sub-Inspector (Civil Police), as he fulfils the eligibility prescribed for the post and as all the necessary formalities had been completed for his appointment of the petitioner on compassionate grounds, except interview and issuance of appointment letter. It is submitted that calling him for interview for the post of constable was arbitrary and contrary to law, and there are thousands of vacancies for the post of Sub-Inspector Police (Civil Police) lying vacant in U.P but it is for the first time that a candidate suitable for the post of Sub-Inspector (Civil Police) is being called for facing interview for the post of Constable. It is further submitted that the person's who are eligible to get a better chance in better scale in (Civil Police) cannot be deprived of a better life by offering him the posts of Constable and that the conduct of respondents is, therefore, not in accordance with law.

    8. The case of the department is that for considering the cases of compassionate appointment of dependants of the Government Servant a committee is constituted on departmental basis under the Chairmanship of the Deputy Inspector General of Police. The case of the deceased family was not considered by the Committee as the family had not applied for compassionate appointment within 5 years. The details of the family members of the deceased at the relevant time has been given in a para 4 of the counter-affidavit as under.

    (Vernacular matter omitted………Ed.)

    9. On the basis of these details it is urged that the application for compassionate appointment was not moved according to the spirit of the objects of the rules and even though the mother and two elder brothers of the petitioner who were eligible, did not apply for appointment on compassionate ground within 5 years. Rather the application was made by the petitioner after 11 years when he became major. However, taking a humanitarian approach, a proposal was sent to the State Government to relax the recruitment of the petitioner under Rule 5 of 1974 Rules. Relaxation was accorded by the State Govt. for appointment on the post of Sub-Inspector (Civil Police), but he was not found eligible as he lacked physical standard/norms of chest required for the post, and, therefore, was offered a lower post of Constable. It is also submitted that in order to gain time to over come his physically in handicap of minimum requirement of chest measurement, the petitioner did not give complete information under 26 point check list and as such further information was required to be submitted by him. The information was not directly communicated to the competent authority sent through respondent No. 3 in order to gain time, otherwise he would have been appointed on the post of constable in the year 2000 itself for which he was eligible according to the records.

    10. Under Rule 5 the appointment is to be given by the department to the dependant of the deceased who dies in harness, “On a suitable post”. The word suitable not only means and includes not only educational qualification, but also encompasses within it the standard of its physical norms for the post required in the department. In the instant case the application filed by the petitioner was beyond five years period as provided under Rule 5 of recruitment Rule 1974, there is no explanation by the petitioner why the other member of the family, who were eligible for compassionate appointment at the time of the death of his father. The Department made efforts for grant of relaxation for the appointment of the petitioner in spite of the fact that the eligible family members did not apply within time prescribed under the Rules for the appointment on compassionate ground. If the petitioner was not up to mark in physical standard prescribed for the recruitment of Sub-Inspector (Civil Police). No mala fides he can be pleaded if he was offered appointment for the post of Constable. However, he was permitted by the Court to join as constable vide interim order dated 23-5-2003. For these reasons the petitioner was not eligible for the post of Sub-Inspector and he had rightly been offered appointment, on the post of constable in the circumstances stated above. The impugned order does not require any interference under Art. 226 of the Constitution. This petition is, therefore, dismissed. No order as to costs.

    11. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rakesh Kumar Tiwari v. Secretary, Home Department, Government Of U.P And Others
    (Jan 9, 2004)