Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Contempt Petition No. 820 of 2002)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion records proceedings concerning long-standing directions of the Supreme Court in D.K. Joshi v. State of U.P. (2000) requiring the State of Uttar Pradesh to identify, publicise and prosecute unauthorised/unregistered medical practitioners. A contempt petition (Contempt Petition No. 820 of 2002) was filed by the petitioner alleging non-compliance with those directions. Notices in this contempt petition were issued on 21.3.2002 to several State officers, and by orders dated 27.7.2002 and 5.8.2002 the Principal Secretary, Medical & Health, District Magistrates, Chief Medical Officers and other State authorities were directed to take action and were impleaded as parties.

During the hearings recorded here, a thirteenth supplementary affidavit dated 15.1.2004 of Sri Rakesh Kumar Mittal, Principal Secretary, Medical Health and Family Welfare, Government of U.P., was filed, annexing Government orders dated 1.12.2003, 8.1.2004 and 12.1.2004, and containing a district-wise list (except Sant Ravidas Nagar) showing that 18,856 persons had been identified as practising without valid registration, FIRs had been lodged against 4,381 persons and charge-sheets submitted in 440 cases. Inspections of community health centres were also conducted and reports filed. The Court has been monitoring compliance and heard parties, intervenors and the Medical Council of India (MCI).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the directions issued by the Supreme Court in D.K. Joshi's case (to identify, publicise and prosecute unauthorised/unregistered medical practitioners) have been complied with by the State authorities.
  2. What specific and enforceable measures the Court should direct to ensure effective compliance with those Supreme Court directions, including whether the burden of proving competence to practice can be shifted onto private medical practitioners and establishments by requiring compulsory registration.
  3. Whether the Court may invoke Article 142 of the Constitution to issue such directions as are necessary to do complete justice in the matter.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner

  • The petitioner initiated the contempt petition asserting that the State has not complied with Supreme Court directions to stop unauthorised medical practice despite earlier orders and government letters.
  • The petitioner highlighted inadequate follow-up action by District Magistrates and Chief Medical Officers, and emphasised the public-health hazards posed by unauthorised practitioners, including reports of deaths and harmful procedures.

Respondents / State Authorities

  • The State (as reflected in affidavits and submissions) produced a supplementary affidavit and Government orders and identified 18,856 persons in two years; FIRs were lodged against 4,381 and charge-sheets submitted in 440 cases.
  • The State put forward practical difficulties and an excuse of insufficient funds for not publishing all identified names, and reported limited capacity to carry out prosecutions and publicity.
  • Senior State officials (Sri R.K. Mittal and Dr. Amrendra Singh) participated in deliberations and indicated that they would accept and implement any effective method placing burden on unauthorised practitioners.

Intervenors

  • Intervenors (including D.K. Joshi, Shiba Jose and the Indian Association of Pathologists and Microbiologists, Varanasi Forums) emphasised that unauthorised/unregistered practitioners continue to flourish in large numbers in U.P. and pointed to systemic deficiencies in government medical services contributing to the problem.

Medical Council of India (MCI)

  • MCI filed an affidavit clarifying qualifications for running pathology laboratories and practice in pathology: minimum qualification for setting up a pathology lab and practising pathology is M.B.B.S.; specialists require postgraduate qualifications; B.A.M.S./B.H.M.S. degrees are not recognised under the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 for modern-medicine pathology practice.
  • MCI stated that any person may establish a pathology laboratory but must employ a modern medicine graduate to examine specimens and sign reports; MCI also stated it prescribes norms for medical colleges and teaching hospitals though no separate norms are prescribed only for pathology laboratories.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
D.K. Joshi v. State of U.P., 2000 (3) AWC 1845 (SC); 2000 (5) SCC 80 (decided 25.4.2000) The Supreme Court in D.K. Joshi recorded that the State had been apprised of the problem of unauthorised medical practice (including a 1991 letter from the Indian Medical Council) and directed the Secretary, Health and Family Welfare (U.P.) to identify unqualified/unregistered practitioners and take further steps (including monitoring and publicising names and prosecuting). The Court relied on the D.K. Joshi directions as the foundational mandate to be enforced. It concluded that those directions must be complied with and structured specific registration and enforcement orders to achieve the objectives set out in D.K. Joshi.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in the following steps, derived from the text of the opinion:

  1. Record of compliance data: The Court noted the thirteenth supplementary affidavit of the Principal Secretary (dated 15.1.2004) and accompanying government orders (1.12.2003; 8.1.2004; 12.1.2004) and a district-wise list showing identification and prosecution statistics (18,856 identified; 4,381 FIRs; 440 charge-sheets), and observed these figures represent only a partial identification of the problem.
  2. Assessment of past measures: The Court reviewed the Supreme Court's findings in D.K. Joshi that prior State directions (including a 1995 Secretary letter referring to statutory provisions such as Section 15 IMC Act 1956, Section 17 IMCC Act 1970, and Section 30 United Provinces Medical Act, 1971) had not been effectively implemented by District Magistrates and Chief Medical Officers, and reiterated the Supreme Court's earlier directions to identify, publicise and prosecute unauthorised practitioners.
  3. Empirical findings from inspections: Inspections of Community Health Centres (Koraon and Shankargarh, Allahabad) were relied upon to corroborate that government primary/secondary medical care was inadequate or absent, contributing to the growth of unauthorised practitioners and sometimes showing nexus between some government personnel and unauthorised practitioners.
  4. MCI's position and regulatory context: The Court took into account MCI's affidavit on qualifications and regulatory obligations (including MCI Regulations 2002 provisions on maintenance of medical records, display of registration numbers and evasion of legal restrictions), and noted these regulatory standards that bear on the issue.
  5. Evaluation of adequacy of measures taken: The Court found that limited identification and prosecution over two years were inadequate — the identified numbers were "a tip of the iceberg" — and that conventional methods (raids, one-time actions) had not produced sustained compliance; raids often produced only temporary closure or absence.
  6. Conclusion that an alternative, enforceable mechanism is required: Given practical difficulties and the scale of non-compliance, and with the consent of parties and senior State officials, the Court concluded that a compulsory registration regime for private medical establishments and practitioners (shifting the burden to prove competence to practice) would be an effective method to implement the Supreme Court directions and create a reliable data bank of authorised private medical facilities.
  7. Invocation of constitutional power: The Court invoked Article 142 as authority to pass such directions necessary for doing complete justice, noting that Article 141 binds courts to the law declared by the Supreme Court and Article 144 mandates aid to the Supreme Court; the Court explained Article 142 is a residuary power to supplement the statutory framework for complete justice when appropriate.
  8. Formulation of detailed, mandatory directions: On the basis described above, and having deliberated with officials and counsels, the Court issued specific, time-bound directions (registration proforma and deadline, publicity requirements, criminal enforcement measures from specified dates, restraints on advertisements, administrative personnel transfer rules, and personal responsibility for District Magistrates/Chief Medical Officers), concluding these directions must be strictly complied with and breaches treated as contempt.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core ruling): The Court directed compulsory registration of all private medical establishments and practitioners in the State of Uttar Pradesh and issued specific, time-bound measures to enforce the Supreme Court's directions; non-compliance with these orders will be treated as contempt of Court.

Immediate consequences and practical effect on the parties (as stated in the opinion):

  • All hospitals, nursing homes, maternity homes, clinics, private practitioners, pathology labs and diagnostic clinics (including those run by firms, societies, trusts, private/public limited companies) in U.P. must register with the Chief Medical Officer of the district with a prescribed proforma supported by affidavit on or before 30.4.2004.
  • The Principal Secretary, Medical Health & Family Welfare must publish the registration requirement and proforma in leading newspapers of the State at least three times in February 2004.
  • Registrations must be updated within 30 days of any change and renewed annually before 30 April; from 1.5.2004 non-registered persons/establishments shall be deemed unauthorised and reported to police for raids and sealing of premises. Authorised persons who fail to register may only apply to this Court for permission to continue practice.
  • Institutions awarding medical degrees in the State must register with the Principal Secretary by 30.4.2004 with particulars of authorization to confer degrees/certificates.
  • Newspapers and magazines in U.P. are restrained from carrying advertisements by unauthorised practitioners unless proof of qualifications and registration is produced; breaches may attract action under the Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisements) Act, 1954 and other laws.
  • Administrative measures for government personnel: no Government Medical Officer should be posted beyond three years in any district; para-medical staff posted longer than five years at the same centre shall be transferred; government doctors aiding unauthorised practitioners will face disciplinary action and prosecution.
  • District Magistrates and Chief Medical Officers are required to continue identifying, publicising and prosecuting unauthorised practitioners and will be held personally responsible for unauthorised practice in their areas; Director General of Prosecutions (U.P.) was directed to file a detailed affidavit within three weeks on prosecution delays/status.
  • Any breach of the directions will be treated as contempt and punished accordingly; the earlier directions in the matter remain unaffected.

Broader legal implications: The Court invoked Article 142 of the Constitution to issue the directions as necessary to do complete justice and to implement Supreme Court orders in D.K. Joshi. The opinion does not explicitly assert the creation of a binding new precedent; rather it frames the directions as an effective method to secure compliance with existing Supreme Court directions and statutory/regulatory standards cited in the record (including MCI Regulations, 2002).

Administrative follow-up: The matter was listed for further orders and hearing on 16.2.2004 (including issues related to Unauthorised Pathology Laboratories at Varanasi and contempt proceedings against Dr. A. K. Dubey). A copy of the order was directed to be supplied to Chief Standing Counsel for compliance.

    Rajesh Kumar Srivastava v. A.P Verma And Others

    1. Heard counsel for petitioner and Sri R.B. Pradhan, learned standing counsel, Sri Pankaj Naqvi, Sri Dinesh Kackker for interveners, Sri Rakesh Kumar Mittal, Principal Secretary, Medical Health and Family Welfare Government of U.P., Lucknow and Dr. Amrendra Singh, Director, Medical Care, Government of U.P., Lucknow are present in Court.

    2. A XIIIth supplementary-affidavit of Sri Rakesh Kumar Mittal, Principal Secretary, Medical Health and Family Welfare Department, Government of U.P. dated 15.1.2004, has been filed today, annexing Government orders dated 1.12.2003, 8.1.2004 and 12.1.2004 issued by him directing all the District Magistrates, the Superintendent and Senior Superintendents of Police, and the Chief Medical Officers in U.P. to take action in pursuance of order of Supreme Court in D.K. Joshi's case dated 25.9.2000 and in this Contempt Petition No. 820 of 2002, between Rajesh Kumar Srivastava v. A.P. Verma, the then Chief Secretary, U.P. and Ors. ; to identify the unauthorised and unregistered medical practitioners and to submit fresh list of such persons to the State Government, to Initiate prosecution and to take effective steps to stop unauthorised medical practice by such persons. A letter dated 12.1.2004 of Shri Rakesh Kumar Mittal requires Principal Secretary, Home Government of U.P. to issue directions to all Superintendent of Police/Senior Superintendent of Police to effectively represent the State Government in Contempt Petition No. 820 of 2002. Annexure-5 is a list of number of unauthorized medical practitioners identified so far in State ; the number of F.I.Rs. lodged, and number of cases in which the charge-sheets has been submitted in Court. This list provides information from all the 70 districts in the State of U.P. except District Sant Ravidas Nagar. The respondents have so far, in last two years since these proceedings were initiated, identified 18,856 persons practicing without any valid registration in the State of U.P. First information reports have been lodged against 4,381 such persons and charges-sheets have been submitted in 440 cases.

    3. In D.K. Joshi v. State of U.P., 2000 (3) AWC 1845 (SC) : 2000 (5) SCC 80, decided on 25th April, 2000, it was found by Supreme Court that the Indian Medical Council in its letter dated 3.5.1991 apprised the Secretary Medical Health, U.P. of the problem of unauthorised medical practice in the State. The Secretary was requested that the

    "public may be relieved by taking strict action against unqualified/ unregistered practitioners, and institutions which are providing Illegal degrees in the Indian System of Medicine."
    The State Government was also concerned and that as far back as on 2.12.1995, the Secretary, Health and Welfare Department, U.P., addressed a letter to all the District Magistrates and Chief Medical Officers of the State, drawing their attention to the legal provisions for taking appropriate action against such persons. In this letter attention was drawn to Section 15 of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956, Section 17 of the Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970, and Section 30 of the United Provinces Medical Act, 1971. The District Magistrates and Chief Medical Officers were also advised how to initiate action against these unauthorised persons. The Supreme Court observed in para 4 of the report as follows :

    "It is distressing to note that in spite of the above direction of the State Government, the District Magistrates and the Chief Medical Officers did not take effective steps to stop this menace which is hazardous to human life. As indicated above, the Chief Medical Officers only forwarded the names of such unauthorised medical practitioners to the District Magistrates and no follow up action was taken."

    4. The writ petition was disposed of by Supreme Court with following directions :

    "The Secretary, Health and Family Welfare Department, State of U.P. shall take such steps as may be necessary to stop carrying on medical profession in the State of U.P. by persons who are unqualified/unregistered and in addition shall take following steps :

    (i) All District Magistrates and the Chief Medical Officers of the State shall be directed to identify, within a time-limit to be fixed by the Secretary, all unqualified /unregistered medical practitioners and to initiate legal actions against these persons immediately ;

    (ii) Direct all the District Magistrates and the Chief Medical Officers to monitor all legal proceedings Initiated against such persons ;

    (iii) The Secretary, Health and Family Welfare Department shall give due publicity to the names of such unqualified/ unregistered medical practitioners so that people do not approach such persons for medical treatment;

    (iv) The Secretary, Health and Family Welfare Department shall monitor the actions taken by all District Magistrates and all Chief Medical Officers of the State and issue necessary directions from time to time to these officers so that such unauthorised persons cannot pursue their medical profession in the State."

    5. A Contempt Petition No. 292 of 2001 was filed by Rajesh Kumar Srivastava, Reporter of National Daily 'Rastriya Sahara' drawing the attention of the Apex Court that the directions passed by the Court have not been complied with by the officials of the State Government. By an order dated 8.10.2001, the contempt petition was dismissed with the following directions."

    "It is appropriate for the petitioner to move the High Court for the relief sought for. The contempt petition is dismissed accordingly."

    6. The petitioner thereafter filed this contempt petition which was registered as Contempt Petition No. 820 of 2002. Notices were issued by this Court on 21.3.2002 to the respondents namely, the Chief Secretary, Government of U.P., Secretary, Department of Health and Family Welfare, the District Magistrate, Meerut and Chief Medical Officer, Meerut. On 27.7.2002, directions were issued to the Principal Secretary, Medical and Health, Government of U.P. and to all the District Magistrates, Chief Medical Officers as well as Director General of Information and Public Relations Department, Director, Medical Care, Government of U.P. as well as Officiating Director General, Medical Health of U.P. On 5.8.2002, all the District Magistrates and Chief Medical Officers of the State were impleaded as parties and were required to take action.

    7. Since thereafter, the Court is monitoring the matter. The successive Principal Secretaries, Medical Health, Government of U.P. have filed supplementary-affidavits including the action taken on reports of the Chief Medical Officers. The Court by its order dated 5.8.2002 also directed the Director General of Police and Director General of Prosecution to submit their reports. Interventions were also made on behalf of D.K. Joshi, Shiba Jose and Indian Association of Pathologists and Microbiologists Varanasi Forums. These intervenors have also highlighted the reality that the unauthorised/unregistered medical practitioners in thousands are still nourishing in the State of U. P.

    8. During the pendency of contempt petition this Court also directed inspections of Community Health Centres at Koraon and Shankergarh at Allahabad as exemplars to verify the complaint alleging that the unauthorised practitioners are flourishing on account of wholly inadequate Primary and Secondary Medical care provided by the State Government, and that there is a close nexus between the State Government Health Machinery and the unauthorised practitioners. The report submitted by Dr. Ram Babu, Director, Medical Health, U. P., verified these assertions. It was found that the Community Health Centres are not providing adequate medical Care and the Government medical care in remote rural areas is almost absent ; the Doctors are not attending their duties, the medical equipment is either not available or is nonfunctional, the para-medical staff is wholly insensitive, and that apart from advertised Government medical and family welfare schemes, like Pulse Polio Programme, Family Welfare camps, Aids care, Blood donation camps the actual and much needed medical care is not available. Some doctors and Para Medics, managing long tenures at their postings have entered into a close nexus with unauthorised practitioners. The State Government assured the Court to make further inspections, but no follow up action was taken.

    9. The Medical Council of India was impleaded and is represented by Sri Vikram Nath. The council filed an affidavit of Shri Jagtar Singh, Assistant Secretary, Medical Council of India, New Delhi. In respect of qualifications for running pathological laboratories the council clarified in the affidavit as follows :

    "10. It is most respectfully submitted that the following are the submissions/answers to the queries set out in para 5 above :

    (i) The minimum qualification required by persons for setting up a pathological lab and practice pathology is M.B.B.S. However, in order for a physician to claim himself to be a specialist in pathology he has to have a special qualification in pathology, i.e., either post-graduate degree or diploma.

    (ii) Persons who hold degrees of B.A.M.S. or B.H.M.S. do not fall within the purview of holding recognised degrees under the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956, and would not be entitled to practice pathology being a part of modern medicine.

    (iii) Any person can establish a pathology laboratory. But, the said person would certainly be required and obliged to employ of a graduates of modern medicine to examine the pathological specimens and sign the certificates and reports.

    (iv) The council towards discharge of its statutory responsibilities for maintenance of highest standards of medical education have prescribed norms etc. for setting up of a medical college having a teaching hospital. The norms for hospitals, beds, wards, operation theatres, etc. laboratories have been laid down but no separate norms for pathology labs only have been prescribed by the Medical Council of India, i.e., for establishment of a pathological laboratory."

    10. In the last two years the respondents have only identified some of the unauthorised medical practitioners. It is only a tip of the ice berg. It is estimated that apart from 18,856 identified so far there are many more thousands unauthorised persons playing with the health of the population of the State. In two years the authorities have only been able to identify only 18,856 and at some places the names have been published in newspapers. Director of Information, Government of U.P. has expressed his inability to publish all the names. The State Government has put up an excuse that they do not have sufficient funds to comply with the order, and instead of publishing and prosecuting they have caused a few awkward and clumsy advertisements, warning public to visit such unauthorised persons. The effort made to initiate prosecution only against 4381 persons and charge-sheets only in 440 cases, proves the lack of will and inadequacy of efforts by the respondent.

    11. The orders passed by Supreme Court intended to curb the growing menace of unauthorised practitioners. The proceedings in this contempt in last two years petition have made it apparent that the menace cannot be effectively checked, unless and until all the establishment offering unauthorised medical care in the State of U.P. are compulsorily registered. This will exclude the black sheep and also provide a valuable data bank of the authorised private medical care in the State.

    12. In these two years, the Court has experienced, and that all the parties have suggested, that instead of chasing unauthorised persons, by process of inviting complaints and conducting raids (which was made a one time affair, with no follow up actions) the authorised medical practitioners must be identified to exclude the unauthorised persons. Whenever raids were conducted the unauthorised persons either closed their clinics or ran away. Most of them were found absent. A large number of letters have been received from the general public complaining their mischief and manner in which these persons are playing with public health. Almost every day there are reports of deaths, spoiled medical cases, blindings, etc. They are also engaged in carrying out hazardous medical procedures operation to remove cataracts, caesarians, and do not fear in prescribing scheduled drugs advertise magical remedies, of which they have no knowledge.

    13. Sri R.K. Mittal, and Dr. Amrendra Singh, participated in the deliberations, and assured the Court that any effective method, which may place burden upon such unauthorised practitioners, shall be accepted and implemented by the State Government.

    14. Article 142 of the Constitution of India provides that Supreme Court in exercise of its jurisdiction may pass such decree, or make such order as it is necessary for doing complete justice in any cause or matter pending before it. The law declared by Supreme Court of India is binding on all Courts under Article 141 of the Constitution of India and that all the authorities civil or judicial, in the territory of India, under Article 144 have been mandated to act in aid of Supreme Court. The power of the Supreme Court under this Article is meant to supplement the existing legal framework-to do complete Justice between the parties and not to supplant it. It is conceived to meet the situations which cannot be effectively and appropriately tackled by the existing provisions of law. The Article provides that the Supreme Court in exercise of its jurisdiction may pass such decree or make such order as is necessary for doing complete justice in any 'cause' or 'matter', which would include any proceeding pending in Court and would cover almost every kind of proceeding in Court. It is residuary power, supplementary and complementary to the powers specially conferred by the Statutes to do complete justice between the parties whenever it is just and equitable to do so. It is intended to prevent any obstruction to the stream of justice. It can grant relief even to a party who is not before the Supreme Court and has omitted to challenge the impugned order before the Supreme Court.

    15. The Medical Council of India has notified the Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics), Regulations, 2002 (Part III, Section 4, Gazette of India dated 6th April, 2002). These Regulations made under Section 20A read with Section 33(m) of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956, with previous approval of Central Government, provides a Code of Conduct, etiquette and ethics. Chapter I (B) 1.1.3, 1.3. Maintenance of Medical Records, 1.4 Display of registration numbers and 1.9 Evasion of Legal Restrictions (relevant for the matter) are quoted as below :

    "1.3. Maintenance of Medical Records :

    1.3.1. Every physician shall maintain the medical records pertaining to his/her indoor patients for a period of 3 years from the date of commencement of the treatment in a standard proforma laid down by the Medical Council of India and attached as Appendix-3.

    1.3.2. If any request is made for medical records either by the patients/authorised attendant or legal authorities involved, the same may be duly acknowledged and documents shall be issued within the period of 72 hours.

    1.3.3. A registered medical practitioner shall maintain a Register of Medical Certificates giving full details of certificates issued. When issuing a medical certificate he/she shall always enter the identification marks of the patient and keep a copy of the certificate. He/she shall not omit to record the signature and/or thumb mark, address and atleast one identification mark of the patient on the medical certificates or report. The medical certificate shall be prepared as in Appendix-2.

    1.3.4. Efforts shall be made to computerize medical records for quick retrieval.

    1.4. Display of registration numbers :

    1.4.1. Every Physician shall display the registration number accorded to him by the State Medical Council/Medical Council of India in his clinic and in all his prescriptions, certificates, money receipts given to this patients.

    1.4.2. Physicians shall display as suffix to their names only recognised medical degrees or such certificates/diplomas and memberships/ honours which confer professional knowledge of recognizes any exemplary qualification / achievements.

    1.9. Evasion of Legal Restrictions.--The physician shall observe the laws of the country in regulating the practice of medicine and shall also not assist others to evade such laws. He should be co-operative in observance and enforcement of sanitary laws and regulations in the interest of public health. A physician should observe the provisions of the State Acts like Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 ; Pharmacy Act, 1948 ; Narcotic Drug and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 ; Medical Termination of. Pregnancy Act, 1971 ; Transplantation of Human Organ Act, 1994 ; Mental Health Act, 1987 ; Environmental Protection Act, 1994 ; Drug and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisement) Act, 1954 ; Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities and Full Participation) Act, 1995 and Biomedical Waste (Management and Handling Rules, 1998 and such other Acts. Rules and Regulations made by the Central/ State Government or local Administrative Bodies or any other relevant Act relating to the protection and promotion of public health."

    16. The directions issued by Supreme Court in D.K. Joshi's case must be complied. The object and purpose of the order is to identify, unauthorised persons, publish their names and to prosecute them. The magnitude of the problem, the practical difficulties put forward by the respondents, and the expediency requires to adopt same innovative method. The suggestions made by the parties were deliberated and readily accepted by Shri R. K. Mittal and Dr. Amrendra Singh. They made valuable suggestions. The Regulations, 2002 of Medical Council of India, also require maintenance of records.

    17. Having the considered deliberated, and discussed the matter in detail with the officials and the counsels appearing from either side, I find that the orders passed by the Apex Court can be effectively complied, if the burden of proving the competence to practice be shifted upon all such persons engaged in private medical practice, and offering private medical care/services in the State.

    18. Having regard to the facts and circumstances, and with the consent of all the parties including the senior State officials present and, including their valuable suggestions, following directions are issued, for strict compliance by all those who are concerned ;

    (1) All the Hospitals, Nursing Homes, Maternity Homes, Medical Clinics, Private Practitioners, practicing medicine and offering medical and health care services. Pathology Labs, Diagnostic Clinics ; whether run privately or by Firms, Societies. Trusts, Private limited or Public limited companies, in the State, shall register themselves with Chief Medical Officer of the district where these establishments are situate, giving full details of the medical facilities offered at these establishments, the names of the registered and authorised medical personnel practicing, employed or engaged by them, their qualifications with proof of their registrations ; the Para Medical staff employed or engaged and their qualifications, on a form (for each category) prescribed by the Principal Secretary, Medical Health and Family Welfare, Government of U.P. The prescribed proforma with true and accurate information shall be submitted, supported by an affidavit of the person providing such medical services or the person incharge of such establishment, sworn before Notary Public. The required information shall be submitted for registration, by all these persons, on or before 30.4.2004.

    (2) The Principal Secretary, Medical Health and Family Welfare, U.P., shall publish the information requiring all these persons to obtain registrations, along with the directions given in this order, and the prescribed proforma, in all leading newspapers of the State, at least three times, in the month of February, 2004.

    (3) Any change or addition in the particulars submitted shall be notified within thirty days and that the registrations shall be renewed every year before 30th April of the year.

    (4) On and from 1.5.2004, all those persons who have not furnished the information and obtained registration with the Chief Medical Officers of the district, shall be taken to be practicing unauthorisedly and that the Chief Medical Officers, shall scrutinize and forthwith report the matter to the Superintendent/Senior Superintendent of Police of the district with information to this Court, to conduct raids and to seal the unauthorised premises/establishments. All the authorised persons/ establishments, who fail to obtain registration will have liberty to apply only to this Court to explain the delay and to seek permission to continue with their medical practice/ profession.

    (5) All those medical practitioners who desire to offer medical services in the State, in future, shall be required to submit the details in the aforesaid proforma for registration as above with the Chief Medical Officer of the district before they start medical practice.

    (6) All the institutions/ establishments/ colleges awarding medical degrees in the State shall apply and get themselves registered with the Principal Secretary Medical Health and Family Welfare, U.P. with full particulars of their authorization to confer such degrees/certificates, on or before 30.4.2004.

    (7) The news papers and magazines, published in Uttar Pradesh, are restrained from publishing advertisements by and from unauthorised medical practitioners, publishing their claims of quick and magical remedies.

    They shall require these persons to give proof of their qualifications and registrations. The breach shall be taken to aid and abet illegal activities violative of Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisement) Act, 1954, and other relevant legislation's.

    (8) The Principal Secretary, Medical Health and Family Welfare, it is directed to ensure that no Medical Officer in the Government service is posted beyond three years in any district, and that all para medical staff serving in the Primary Health Centre/ Community Health Centre/ District Hospitals and other hospitals run by Government of U.P. for more than five years, shall be transferred from that centre/hospital. Any doctor in employment of State Government offering their services to the unauthorised medical practitioners shall face immediate disciplinary action by the State Government and shall be prosecuted for aiding and abetting such unauthorised practice.

    19. These orders shall be strictly complied with. Any breach of these orders shall be treated to be contempt of the Court, and shall be punished accordingly.

    20. These directions shall not affect the earlier directions issued in this matter. The respondents shall continue to identify and prosecute unauthorised medical practitioners. There is a large gap between the identified unauthorised practitioners so far, and the prosecutions launched against them. A request has been made by standing counsel on behalf of Director General, Prosecutions, U.P. to file a reply with regard to the delay and status of the prosecutions. Let a detailed affidavit be filed by him within three weeks. All the District Magistrates and Chief Medical Officers shall comply with the order of the Apex Court and the Government Orders dated 1.12.2003, 8.1.2004 and 12.1.2004 issued by the Principal Secretary, Medical Health and Family Welfare, U.P. Government, Lucknow. They shall continue to identify, advertise and prosecute the unauthorised practitioners. They shall be held personally responsible for unauthorised practitioners practicing in their areas.

    21. List on 16.2.2004 for further orders and hearing in the matter of Unauthorised Pathology Laboratories at Varanasi, and the contempt proceedings drawn against Dr. A. K. Dubey. A copy of the order shall be supplied to chief standing counsel for compliance.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajesh Kumar Srivastava v. A.P Verma And Others
    (Jan 28, 2004)