Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 3 of the Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhans, Up-Pradhans and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1997 (hereinafter referred to as 1997 Rules).
  • Rule 4 of the Enquiry Rules. Similar expression used in Rule 5 of the Enquiry Rules
  • Section 95(l)(g) of UP. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as the Act)
  • Rule 3, sub-rule (6), the procedure prescribed in Rule 3
  • sub-clause (c) of Rule 2 of 1997 Rules
  • Section 21 of the Indian Penal Code.
  • Sub-rule (6) of Rule 3 of 1997 Rules
  • sub-rule (2) of Rule 3 of 1997 Rules.
  • Rule 4(1) of the Enquiry Rules
  • Rule 3 of 1997 Rules. Rules 3
  • Rule 3 of the Enquiry Rules
  • Rule 2(c) of 1997 Rules
  • sub-rule (6) of Rule 3
  • Rule 3 to sub-rule (1)
  • Rule 4 of 1997 Rules
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 4
  • Rule 3(6)
  • Rule 4(2)
  • Rule 2(c)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 3 of the Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhans, Up-Pradhans and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1997 (hereinafter referred to as 1997 Rules).
  • Rule 4 of the Enquiry Rules. Similar expression used in Rule 5 of the Enquiry Rules
  • Section 95(l)(g) of UP. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as the Act)
  • Rule 3, sub-rule (6), the procedure prescribed in Rule 3
  • sub-clause (c) of Rule 2 of 1997 Rules
  • Section 21 of the Indian Penal Code.
  • Sub-rule (6) of Rule 3 of 1997 Rules
  • sub-rule (2) of Rule 3 of 1997 Rules.
  • Rule 4(1) of the Enquiry Rules
  • Rule 3 of 1997 Rules. Rules 3
  • Rule 3 of the Enquiry Rules
  • Rule 2(c) of 1997 Rules
  • sub-rule (6) of Rule 3
  • Rule 3 to sub-rule (1)
  • Rule 4 of 1997 Rules
  • sub-rule (1) of Rule 4
  • Rule 3(6)
  • Rule 4(2)
  • Rule 2(c)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant is an elected Pradhan of Gram Panchayat Kalyanapura, Block Virdha, Tehsil and District Lalitpur. The Up-Pradhan, Mangal Singh, along with several other villagers, made a complaint against the appellant. A preliminary enquiry was directed and conducted, producing a preliminary enquiry report dated 13.10.2002. A show cause notice was issued to the appellant by the District Magistrate on 25.10.2002, and the appellant submitted a reply. On 27.11.2002 the District Magistrate passed two orders: one rejecting the appellant's reply/explanation and another ceasing the appellant's financial and administrative powers and constituting a three-member committee. The appellant challenged the Single Judge's dismissal of his writ petition (Writ Petition No. 54394 of 2002; Moti Lal v. District Magistrate, Lalitpur and Ors.) by way of this special appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the complaint filed by the Up-Pradhan and signed by villagers complied with Rule 3 of the Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhans, Up-Pradhans and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1997, particularly the requirement of an affidavit verified before a notary, or whether the exception for complaints by public servants (sub-rule (6) of Rule 3) applied.
  2. Whether the preliminary enquiry was validly conducted by officers other than the District Panchayat Raj Officer—specifically by the Land Conservation Officer and Project Officer—or whether only the District Panchayat Raj Officer was competent to conduct the preliminary enquiry.
  3. Whether the preliminary enquiry was vitiated because the appellant was not informed of the preliminary enquiry and the enquiry was not conducted in the presence of the appellant, i.e., whether opportunity to the appellant was required at the preliminary enquiry stage under the Rules.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (as raised by his counsel)

  • The complaint was not in accordance with Rule 3 of the 1997 Rules because it was not supported by an affidavit duly sworn before a public notary; consequently the District Magistrate's order should be invalidated.
  • Under the 1997 Rules the preliminary enquiry must be conducted by the District Panchayat Raj Officer; in this case the preliminary enquiry was conducted by the Land Conservation Officer and Project Officer who were not competent to do so.
  • The appellant was not informed about the preliminary enquiry nor was the enquiry conducted in his presence, which vitiates the proceedings.

Respondent's Arguments (as presented by the learned Standing Counsel)

  • The complaint was not contrary to the 1997 Rules because it was filed by the Up-Pradhan, who is a public servant; therefore sub-rule (6) of Rule 3 excludes the necessity of following the detailed procedure in Rule 3(1)-(5).
  • The District Magistrate rightly relied on the preliminary enquiry report and was entitled to act under the proviso to Section 95(1)(g) of the UP Panchayat Raj Act, 1947, having found a prima facie case of financial and other irregularities.
  • Rule 4 empowers the State Government (and by delegation the District Magistrate) to direct a preliminary enquiry on receipt of a complaint or report referred to in Rule 3 "or otherwise", hence there was no lack of power in directing the preliminary enquiry.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
1998(3) AWC 1892; Chunmun v. District Magistrate, Sonbhadra and Anr. Interpretation of the words "or otherwise" in Rule 4(1) of the Enquiry Rules; held that "or otherwise" is ejusdem generis with "complaint or report" and permits ordering a preliminary enquiry on the basis of reports or information other than a complaint under Rule 3; a complaint by a public servant may partake the nature of a report received "otherwise". The court relied on this authority to construe Rule 4(1) and held that the expression "or otherwise" permits the District Magistrate to order a preliminary enquiry even when the material originates other than a formal complaint under Rule 3; the court found that the earlier observations were applicable and no exception was taken to them in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court systematically considered the appellant's submissions against the statutory framework (the 1997 Rules) and the record.

  1. On the challenge to the validity of the complaint under Rule 3:
    • The complaint filed by the Up-Pradhan (Mangal Singh) was supported by an affidavit (Annexure-2) and thus complied with sub-rule (2) of Rule 3 where relevant.
    • Even more decisively, sub-rule (6) of Rule 3 provides that the detailed procedure in sub-rules (1)–(5) is not necessary where a complaint is made by a public servant. The court relied on Section 28 of the UP Panchayat Raj Act to classify the Up-Pradhan as a public servant (deemed to be so within the meaning of Section 21 IPC), and therefore concluded that the procedural requirements of Rule 3(1)–(5) were not attracted here.
    • Consequently, the court held there was no fault in the complaint as the Up-Pradhan was a public servant and the exception applied.
  2. On the power to order a preliminary enquiry under Rule 4:
    • Rule 4(1) permits the State Government to order a preliminary enquiry "on the receipt of a complaint or report referred to in Rule 3 or otherwise." The court emphasized the wide import of the words "or otherwise" and agreed with the Standing Counsel that Rule 4 is an enabling provision.
    • The court cited and followed the earlier decision in Chunmun v. District Magistrate (1998(3) AWC 1892) which interpreted "or otherwise" ejusdem generis with "complaint or report" and endorsed that a complaint by a public servant may constitute a report received "otherwise". The court found these observations applicable and did not take exception to them.
    • The court further noted examples (from the judgment) illustrating that information from other official channels or personal knowledge of a District Magistrate may legitimately form the basis for ordering a preliminary enquiry.
  3. On the competence of the Enquiry Officer:
    • The court relied on the amended definition of "Enquiry Officer" in Rule 2(c) (by notification dated 5.10.2002), which defines "Enquiry Officer" as "the District Panchayat Raj Officer or any other district level officer, to be nominated by the District Magistrate."
    • The record showed the preliminary enquiry was conducted by the Land Conservation Officer and Project Officer, both district-level officers. The appellant himself stated this in his affidavit. Thus, under the amended Rule 2(c) these officers were within the definition of Enquiry Officer and authorized to conduct the preliminary enquiry.
    • The court rejected the appellant's contention that only the District Panchayat Raj Officer could conduct the enquiry.
  4. On whether the appellant needed to be informed or present at the preliminary enquiry:
    • The court observed that while Rule 4 directs a preliminary enquiry to ascertain if there is a prima facie case for a formal enquiry, neither Rule 4 nor the Rules generally obliges the Enquiry Officer to give opportunity to the appellant at the preliminary enquiry stage, nor requires the enquiry to be conducted in the presence of the appellant.
  5. Final evaluative step:
    • Having found the complaint valid (or in any event squarely within the exception for complaints by public servants), the preliminary enquiry properly authorized, and no rule-obligation breached by not informing or conducting the preliminary enquiry in the presence of the appellant, the court found no error in the Single Judge's dismissal of the writ petition.
    • The court further accepted the District Magistrate's prima facie satisfaction that the appellant had misused funds in development works, and that it was appropriate for the District Magistrate to cease the appellant's financial and administrative powers pending further proceedings.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The special appeal has no merit and is DISMISSED.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The judgment of the learned Single Judge dated 19.12.2002 dismissing the writ petition is affirmed.
  • The District Magistrate's orders of 27.11.2002 (rejecting the appellant's reply and ceasing his financial and administrative powers, and constituting a three-member committee) stand upheld.
  • The court directed that the formal enquiry against the appellant be expeditiously held by the District Magistrate.

The opinion does not purport to announce any new, broader principle of law beyond the application of the Rules and existing authority cited; it addresses the correctness of the actions taken by the District Magistrate in the circumstances and the validity of procedural steps under the 1997 Rules and the UP Panchayat Raj Act.

    Moti Lal v. District Magistrate

    JUDGMENT Ashok Bhushan, J.

    1. Heard Sri R.N. Upadliaya, the learned Counsel for the appellant as well as the learned Standing Counsel appearing for the respondents.

    2. By this special appeal, the appellant has challenged the judgment of learned Single Judge dated 19.12.2002 passed in Writ Petition No. 54394 of 2002 (Moti Lal v. District Magistrate, Lalitpur and Ors.) dismissing the writ petition.

    3. Brief facts giving rise to this appeal are; the appellant is an elected Pradhan of Gram Panchayat Kalyanapura, Block Virdha, Tahsil and District Lalitpur. Up- Pradhan made a complaint against the appellant. On the complaint a preliminary enquiry was directed. The complaint was signed by several other villagers along with Mangal Singh, Up-Pradhan. An affidavit was also filed by Mangal Singh sworn by Oath Commissioner, Land Conservation Officer and Project Officer conducted preliminary enquiry and submitted preliminary enquiry report dated 13.10.2002. A show cause notice was issued to the appellant by the District Magistrate dated 25.10.2002. The appellant submitted a reply to the show cause notice. The District Magistrate passed two orders on 27.11.2002 filed as Annexures-6 and 7 to the affidavit filed in support of the stay application. By first order dated 27.11.2002, the reply/explanation of the appellant was rejected and by second order passed on the same day the financial and administrative powers of the appellant were ceased and three members committee was constituted.

    4. The learned Counsel for the appellant raised following submissions in support of the appeal:-

    (i) The complaint filed by Up-Pradhan and signed by several villagers was not in accordance with Rule 3 of the Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Raj (Removal of Pradhans, Up-Pradhans and Members) Enquiry Rules, 1997 (hereinafter referred to as 1997 Rules). Complaint ought to have been supported by an affidavit duly sworn by public notary. The complaint being not in accordance with Rules, 1997, the order of the District Magistrate falls on the ground.

    (ii) According to 1997 Rules, the preliminary enquiry is to be conducted by District Panchayat Raj Officer and in the present case the preliminary enquiry has been conducted by Land Conservation Officer and Project Officer who are not competent to conduct the preliminary enquiry.

    (iii) The appellant was not informed about the preliminary enquiry nor the said enquiry was conducted in presence of the appellant, hence the whole proceedings are vitiated in law.

    5. Sri Ranvijai Singh, learned Standing Counsel, refuting the submissions of Counsel for the appellant submitted that the complaint filed against the appellant was not contrary to 1997 Rules. He submitted that complaint was made by Up- Pradhan of the village who is a public servant and by virtue of Rule 3, sub-rule (6), the procedure prescribed in Rule 3 is not attracted and there was no error in the complaint and the preliminary enquiry report has rightly been relied by the District Magistrate. The learned Standing Counsel has further submitted that the District Magistrate has found that prima facie the appellant is guilty of financial and other irregularities and power under proviso of Section 95(l)(g) of UP. Panchayat Raj Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) has rightly been exercised. The learned Standing Counsel has also submitted that Rule 4 empowers the State Government to direct for preliminary enquiry on receipt of complaint or report referred to in Rule 3 or even "otherwise", hence there was no lack of power in the District Magistrate in directing the preliminary enquiry.

    6. We have considered the submissions of the Counsel for both the parties and perused the record.

    7. The first submission of Counsel for the appellant is based on Rule 3 of 1997 Rules. Rules 3 and 4 which are relevant for the present purpose are quoted below:

    "3. Procedure relating to complaints.-(1) Any person making a complaint against Pradhan or Up-Pradhan may send his complaint to the State government or any officer empowered in this behalf by the State Government.

    (2) Every complaint referred to in sub-rule (I) shall be accompanied by the complainant's own affidavit in support thereof and also affidavits of all persons from whom he claims to have received information of facts relating to the accusation, verified before a notary together with all documents in his possession or power pertaining to the accusation.

    (3) Every complaint and affidavit under this rule as well as any schedule or Annexure thereto shall be verified in the manner laid down in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 for the verification of pleadings and affidavits, respectively.

    (4) Not less than three copies of complaint as well as each of its Annexures shall be submitted by the complainant.

    (5) A complaint, which does comply with any of the foregoing provisions of these rules, shall not be entertained.

    (6) It shall not be necessary to follow the procedure laid down in the foregoing provisions of this rule if a complaint against a Pradhan or Up- Pradhan is made by a public servant.

    4. Preliminary Enquiry.-(1) The State Government may, on the receipt of a complaint or report referred to in Rule 3 or otherwise order the Enquiry Officer to conduct a preliminary enquiry with a view to finding out if there is a prima facie case for a formal enquiry in the matter.

    (2) The Enquiry Officer shall conduct the preliminary enquiry as expeditiously as possible and submit his report to the State Government within thirty days of his having been so ordered."

    8. The copy of the complaint on the basis of which preliminary enquiry has been ordered has been annexed by the appellant as Annexure-1 to the affidavit filed in support of the stay application. The complaint is also supported by an affidavit of Mangal Singh who is said to be Up-Pradhan. Affidavit of Mangal Singh has been filed as Annexure-2 to the affidavit filed in support of the stay application. The Up-Pradhan, Mangal Singh, is himself complainant along with several other villagers. The complaint being supported by an affidavit, there is a compliance with sub-rule (2) of Rule 3 of 1997 Rules. The reliance of learned Standing Counsel on sub-rule (6) of Rule 3 is wholly justified. sub-rule (6) of Rule 3 of 1997 Rules provides that if a complaint against a Pradhan is made by public servant, it shall not be necessary to follow the procedure laid down in the provisions of Rule 3. It is not disputed that complaint against appellant was by Up-Pradhan. Section 28 of the Act provides that every member or servant of a Nyaya Panchayat, Gram Panchayat, Joint Committee or any other committee constituted under this Act shall be deemed to be a public servant within the meaning of Section 21 of the Indian Penal Code. Up-Pradhan being member of Gram Panchayat is a public servant within the meaning of Section 28 of the Act. The complaint against the appellant being filed by Up-Pradhan, the procedure as prescribed in Rule 3 to sub-rule (1) to (5) was not attracted and no fault can be found with the complaint. The submission of learned Standing Counsel that preliminary enquiry can be ordered even without there being any complaint also has merit. Rule 4 of 1997 Rules is a enabling provision giving power to the State Government to order holding of a preliminary enquiry with a view to find out that there is a prima facie case for formal enquiry or not. The words "or otherwise" occurring in sub-rule (1) of Rule 4 are of wide import. Even if no complaint is filed as envisaged by Rule 3, the State Government does not lack of power to direct holding of preliminary enquiry. There may be cases in which the District Magistrate or other officials charged with looking the affairs of Gram Panchayat may receive information or may personally finds fact requiring holding of preliminary enquiry. For example, the Sub-Divisional Officer who is incharge of a sub-division if finds a Pradhan abusing his position and committing serious financial irregularities can report the matter to the District Magistrate who is authority competent to order of preliminary enquiry. The report of Sub-Divisional Officer may form basis for directing a preliminary enquiry. The District Magistrate may after personally coming to know some serious lapse on the part of the Pradlian may direct preliminary enquiry without there begin any complaint or report. In the present case the complaint submitted by the Up-Pradhan was valid material for directing preliminary enquiry, hence the submission of Counsel for the appellant has no substance.

    9. The word "otherwise" as referred to in Rule 4 has also been considered in 1998(3) AWC 1892; Chunmun v. District Magistrate, Sonbhadra and Anr.. It was held by this Court in Paragraph 8 of the aforesaid judgment :-

    "8. The expressions 'or otherwise' used in Rule 4(1) of the Enquiry Rules has a meaning ejusdem generis with "complaint or report" and only enables the District Magistrate to order the District Panchayat Raj Officer to conduct preliminary enquiry with a view to finding out If there is prima facie case for a formal enquiry in he matter not only on the basis of a complaint received under Rule 3 of the Enquiry Rules but he may do so even on the basis of a report received 'otherwise' disclosing the cause for holding a preliminary enquiry in the matter. A complaint by a public servant under Rule 3(6) may partake the nature of a report received 'otherwise' within the meaning of Rule 4 of the Enquiry Rules. Similar expression used in Rule 5 of the Enquiry Rules enables the District Magistrate to direct the Enquiry Officer to hold a formal enquiry on the basis of the report or information other than the one contained in Rule 4(2) of the Enquiry Rules........................"

    10. In the present case, we are concerned with the expression 'or otherwise' as used in Rule 4 and no exception can be taken to the observations made in paragraph 8 of the aforesaid judgment while construing the word 'otherwise' in Rule 4.

    11. The next submission of Counsel for the appellant that in the present case enquiry has not been conducted by the District Panchayat Raj Officer, hence the whole proceeding is vitiated has also no substance. The definition of Enquiry Officer as contained in sub-clause (c) of Rule 2 of 1997 Rules has been amended by notification dated 5.10.2002. The amended Rule 2(c) is quoted as below :

    "2(c) 'Enquiry Officer' means the District Panchayat Raj Officer or any other district level officer, to be nominated by the District Magistrate."

    12. In the present case, the appellant himself has stated in Paragraph 5 of the affidavit filed in support of the stay application that enquiry has been conducted by the Land Conservation Officer and Project Officer. The Land Conservation Officer and Project Officer both are district level officers, hence were fully covered by definition of Rule 2(c) of 1997 Rules and it cannot be said that they were not authorised to hold the preliminary enquiry. The show cause notice dated 25th October, 2002 which has been filed as Annexure-3 to the affidavit filed in support of the stay application, refers the Enquiry Officer as Bhumi Sanrakshan Adhikari, Lalitpur and Pariyojana Nideshak, Zila Vikas Abhikaran, Lalitpur. The submission of the Counsel for the appellant that only District Panchayat Raj Officer can conduct the enquiry cannot be accepted.

    13. The third submission of Counsel for appellant has also no substance. While holding a preliminary enquiry under Rule 4 of 1997 Rules the Enquiry Officer is not obliged to give opportunity to appellant nor the Rules require holding of preliminary enquiry in the presence or appellant.

    14. We do not find any error in the judgment of learned Single Judge dismissing the writ petition. The District Magistrate on being prima facie satisfied that the appellant has misused the amount in various development works has rightly ceased the financial and administrative powers of the appellant. No error can be found in the order of the District Magistrate dated 27th November, 2002. It is, however, observed that the formal enquiry against the appellant be expeditiously held by the District Magistrate.

    15. The special appeal has no merit and is dismissed subject to observation that enquiry against the appellant be expeditiously held.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Moti Lal v. District Magistrate
    (Feb 5, 2003)