AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1930. Rule 55 of the aforesaid Rules
  • U.P. Recruitment of Dependants of Government Servants (Dying-in-Harness) Rules, 1974.
  • Rule 55 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1930,
  • provisions of the Public Servant Inquiries Act, 1850,
  • Section 240(3) of the Government of India Act, 1935,
  • Rule 55 of the aforesaid Rules
  • Rule 55 Sub-rule (1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1930. Rule 55 of the aforesaid Rules
  • U.P. Recruitment of Dependants of Government Servants (Dying-in-Harness) Rules, 1974.
  • Rule 55 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1930,
  • provisions of the Public Servant Inquiries Act, 1850,
  • Section 240(3) of the Government of India Act, 1935,
  • Rule 55 of the aforesaid Rules
  • Rule 55 Sub-rule (1)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was appointed as a Labour Investigator on 26.7.1979 under the U.P. Recruitment of Dependants of Government Servants (Dying-in-Harness) Rules, 1974, was later promoted and was working as Housing Inspector in 1996. On 27.7.1996 he was transferred from Shastri Nagar to Zajmau, Kanpur Nagar but did not hand over charge. Multiple departmental letters were issued; a letter dated 3.10.1996 recorded non-compliance and indiscipline. On 15.10.1996 an almirah lock at Shastri Nagar was broken open and no cash or relevant receipts were found. The petitioner was placed under suspension by order dated 2.12.1996 and disciplinary proceedings commenced.

A charge-sheet dated 30.5.1997 was served and replied to on 27.6.1997. An additional charge-sheet (three more charges) was issued on 10.2.1999 and replied to. The petitioner appeared before the Enquiry Officer on 30.1.1999, 10.2.1999, 19.2.1999 and 25.2.1999; copies of documents (1–58 pages) were given on 30.1.1999. No oral witnesses were examined by either party in the enquiry. The Enquiry Officer submitted a detailed report dated 12.3.1999 finding seven out of ten charges fully proved. A show-cause notice dated 20.3.1999 was issued; the petitioner replied. The Labour Commissioner issued a removal order dated 23.4.1999 dismissing the petitioner from service. The petitioner filed the present writ petition seeking quashing of that order. The High Court directed production of the disciplinary record, perused it and heard counsel; ultimately the writ petition was dismissed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the disciplinary enquiry leading to the petitioner's removal complied with Rule 55 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1930 and principles of natural justice when the employer did not produce oral witnesses to prove documents relied upon in the charge-sheet.
  2. Whether non-payment of subsistence (suspension) allowance to the petitioner vitiated the disciplinary proceedings and the resulting order of removal.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The disciplinary enquiry was conducted in violation of Rule 55 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1930 and principles of natural justice because the employer did not prove charges by oral evidence and the Enquiry Officer did not hold a proper enquiry as contemplated under the Rules.
  • The petitioner was not paid suspension (subsistence) allowance during suspension, which vitiated the entire disciplinary proceedings.
  • The petitioner relied on several precedents of this Court and the Supreme Court in support of the above submissions (cases cited in the opinion).

Respondents' Arguments (Learned Standing Counsel)

  • There was no violation of principles of natural justice. The petitioner was provided copies of the documents relied upon in the charge-sheet and was given oral hearings on multiple dates; the petitioner signed the enquiry proceedings and participated in the enquiry.
  • The charges were established from documents on record; it was not obligatory for the Department to produce oral witnesses where the allegations could be proved from documents and their genuineness was not challenged.
  • The petitioner did not request production of any witnesses nor seek cross-examination; hence there was no denial of opportunity to lead evidence.
  • Non-payment of subsistence allowance did not vitiate the proceedings because the petitioner participated in the enquiry and did not show prejudice resulting from non-payment.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Khem Chand v. Union of India and Ors., AIR 1958 SC 800 Defines "reasonable opportunity" in disciplinary proceedings (opportunity to know charges, cross-examine, lead defence, and representation on proposed punishment); links statutory rules to Article 311(2). The Court applied the principle to hold that the petitioner was given opportunity to defend and that opportunity requirements were met in this case.
Jagdish Prasad Saxena v. State of Madhya Bharat, AIR 1961 SC 1070 Requires that a proper disciplinary enquiry be held after supplying a charge-sheet and affording reasonable opportunity to meet allegations. The Court acknowledged this rule and treated it as supporting the need for reasonable opportunity; found that such opportunity was afforded here.
Town Area Committee, Jalalabad v. Jagdish Prasad and Ors., 1978 AWC 647; AIR 1978 SC 1407 Reasonable opportunity includes right to cross-examine witnesses and to lead defence. The Court cited the principle but distinguished the present facts because the documents relied upon were not challenged and no witnesses were produced by the employer to be cross-examined.
Kulwant Singh Gill v. State of Punjab, 1991 SCC (L & S) 998 Stresses that a pretend enquiry without reasonable opportunity to adduce and rebut evidence and to cross-examine is no enquiry in law. The Court accepted the general proposition but noted that the cited cases do not hold that employer must always prove documents by oral evidence when genuineness is not disputed; therefore the case did not require interference under these facts.
Subhash Chandra Sharma v. Managing Director, U.P. Co-operative Spinning Mills Federation Ltd., 1999 (4) AWC 3227 Held dismissal illegal where no regular enquiry was held and evidence should have been led with opportunity to cross-examine. The Court observed the decision supports petitioner's contention in principle but found it distinguishable on facts because in the present case documents were not denied and the petitioner participated.
Smt. Ram Pyari (Ram Pyart) v. State of U.P. and Anr., 2000 (2) AWC 1711 (LB) Affirms requirement of leading evidence and cross-examination in a proper enquiry. The Court noted the decision but found it factually distinguishable for the same reasons as Subhash Chandra Sharma.
State of Haryana and Anr. v. Rattan Singh, (1982) 1 LLJ 46 (SC) Domestic enquiries need not follow strict rules of evidence; admissible material is that which is logically probative; hearsay may be admissible with proper evaluation. The Court relied on this principle to support that strict evidentiary rules do not apply and that documents may constitute sufficient material where appropriate.
Employees of Fire Stone Tyre and Rubber Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Workmen, AIR 1968 SC 236 Where accusation is based on a matter of record or admitted facts, it may be permissible to draw attention to evidence on record and in certain cases examine the delinquent first; procedure is a question of justice and fair play. The Court used this to support the view that when allegations rest on records or admitted facts, it may be proper to rely on documents rather than oral witnesses.
Tata Oil Mills Co. Ltd. v. Its Workmen, 1963 [2] Lab LJ 78 (SC) Case law cited for the principle that ordinarily all evidence against a delinquent must be led before questioning him; part of the corpus of authorities on enquiry procedure. The Court referenced this line of authorities to explain the ordinary procedure but observed exceptions where facts are admitted or based on records.
Sur Enamel and Stamping Works Ltd. v. Their Workmen, AIR 1963 SC 1914 One of the authorities stating that evidence against a delinquent should generally be led before questioning him. Used with other authorities to frame the ordinary procedural rule; the Court noted exceptions in clear cases based on record.
Meenglas Tea Estate v. Workmen, AIR 1963 SC 1719 Cited among precedents about the ordinary sequence of enquiry and evidence leading. Referred to as part of the judicial backdrop; the Court noted that deviation from ordinary sequence is permissible in clear cases where it is fair to the delinquent.
Associated Cement Co. Ltd. v. Their Workmen, 1963 (2) LLJ 396 (SC) Cited along with other cases discussing enquiry procedure and order of leading evidence. Referenced as part of the authorities that establish the ordinary procedural approach; Court recognized flexibility in particular cases.
Orissa Mining Corporation and Anr. v. Ananda Chandra Prusty, (1998) 3 LLJ (Suppl) 1207 Explains that there is no absolute burden of proof always lying on the department; burden may shift depending on nature of charges and explanation. The Court applied this to find that when charges are based on departmental records and the delinquent's own explanation, the burden may shift to the delinquent to prove innocence.
Capt. M. Paul Anthony v. Bharat Cold Mines Ltd. and another, 1999 (2) AWC 1579 (SC); 1999 (82) FLR 627 (SC) Held that non-payment of subsistence allowance that prevents participation in enquiry may vitiate proceedings; ex parte proceedings caused by non-payment can amount to denial of natural justice. The Court distinguished this authority: here the petitioner participated in the enquiry and did not show he was prevented from attending due to non-payment, so Capt. M. Paul Anthony did not warrant interference.
P.C. Chaturvedi v. U.P. State Textile Corporation Ltd., Kanpur and Ors., (2002) 1 UPLBEC 84 Division Bench quashed dismissal where non-payment of subsistence allowance reasons could not be substantiated and respondent could not prove entitlement rules relied upon by employer. The Court found this case factually distinguishable because in the present record the petitioner had not submitted requisite certificate and facts did not match; thus it did not assist the petitioner.
Municipal Board, Amroha and Anr. v. V.P., Public Service Tribunal No. 1 and Anr., 2001 (3) AWC 1831 Held that mere non-payment of subsistence allowance will not ipso facto render removal invalid; actual prejudice must be shown (e.g., inability to attend enquiry). The Court applied this principle to conclude that because the petitioner attended the enquiry and did not show prejudice, non-payment did not vitiate proceedings.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began with the statutory framework: Rule 55 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1930, which requires that a person subject to dismissal, removal or reduction must be informed of the grounds, supplied with definite charges, given reasonable time to put in a written statement and be given an opportunity to be heard; if an oral inquiry is directed, oral evidence deemed necessary shall be heard and the charged person shall be entitled to cross-examine witnesses and call witnesses of his own.

The central analytical questions were whether (a) the absence of oral witnesses produced by the employer vitiated the enquiry and (b) non-payment of subsistence allowance vitiated the proceedings.

On the first question, the Court analyzed Rule 55's language and concluded that the Rule does not make it obligatory for the employer to produce oral evidence in every case. The Court explained that whether oral evidence is required depends on the nature of the allegation: if allegations can properly be proved from documents and the genuineness and veracity of those documents are not challenged by the delinquent, it is not incumbent on the employer to produce oral witnesses to prove those documents. The Court emphasised that disciplinary enquiries are not governed by the strict rules of evidence applicable to regular courts.

The Court applied these principles to the facts: many of the charges were based on departmental records (rent receipts, receipt register, vouchers, cash book). The petitioner himself had lodged receipts and documents and in his reply admitted realisation of amounts and claimed deposits to the bank (for example, he admitted receipt totals and later deposit dates for a substantial sum). The petitioner did not challenge the genuineness of the departmental receipt book, cash book or treasury challans; he participated in the enquiry on multiple dates, signed the proceedings and did not request the production of witnesses or seek cross-examination. The enquiry proceedings recorded that the petitioner had given written answers and did not ask for witnesses. On these facts the Court concluded there was no violation of natural justice arising from the absence of oral witnesses.

The Court also addressed the burden of proof: relying on cited authorities, it observed there is no immutable rule that the department must always discharge the entire burden by oral evidence; the burden may shift to the delinquent depending on the nature of charges and his explanation. Given the petitioner's own admissions and the documentary record, the burden shifted to him to demonstrate innocence and he did not do so.

On the second question (subsistence allowance), the Court reviewed authorities holding that non-payment can vitiate an inquiry if it causes real prejudice (for example, inability to attend). The Court found the present case distinguishable from cases where non-payment prevented participation: the petitioner here attended the enquiry and did not plead that non-payment prevented him from attending or caused prejudice. The respondents' specific factual defence regarding non-payment (lack of a certificate that the petitioner was not engaged in other occupation) was noted and the petitioner had not shown prejudice attributable to non-payment. Accordingly, non-payment of subsistence allowance did not vitiate the proceedings.

Having found no procedural infirmity — i.e., the petitioner was given adequate opportunity under Rule 55, documents were properly relied upon where genuineness was not disputed, the burden appropriately shifted in light of the petitioner's own explanations, and no prejudice arose from non-payment of subsistence allowance — the Court concluded the disciplinary authority correctly considered the enquiry report, the explanations and the material on record and legitimately found the charges proved.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The writ petition challenging the removal order dated 23.4.1999 is DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • The removal order of 23.4.1999 (dismissal from service) stands upheld on the facts and record before the Court.
  • The Court reaffirmed that Rule 55 and principles of natural justice require reasonable opportunity, but do not rigidly require the employer to produce oral witnesses to prove documents whose genuineness has not been challenged; disciplinary enquiries are not governed by strict rules of evidence and the necessity of oral evidence depends on the facts of each case.
  • The Court held that non-payment of subsistence allowance will vitiate proceedings only if it causes real prejudice (such as inability to attend the enquiry); mere non-payment, without demonstrable prejudice, does not automatically invalidate the enquiry.
  • No broader or novel precedent beyond application of established principles was announced; the decision applies settled principles to the particular facts before the Court and results in upholding the disciplinary order on the record provided.

    Raj Babu Agnihotri v. Labour Commissioner, U.P, Kanpur And Others

    1. Heard Sri R.G. Padia, senior counsel assisted by Sri Prakash Padia for the petitioner and Sri Ajay Bhanot learned standing counsel appearing for the respondents. Affidavits have been exchanged between the parties. Both the parties have agreed that the writ petition itself be finally decided.

    2. By this writ petition, the petitioner has prayed for quashing of the impugned order dated 23.4.1999 Annexure-14 to the writ petition by which the petitioner has been dismissed from service. Facts of the case as emerge from the pleadings of the parties are :

    Petitioner was appointed as Labour Investigator vide order dated 26.7.1979 under the U.P. Recruitment of Dependants of Government Servants (Dying-in-Harness) Rules, 1974. Petitioner was promoted as Welfare Superintendent and was working as Housing Inspector in the year 1996. On 27.7.1996, the petitioner was transferred as Housing Inspector from Shastri Nagar to Zajmau, Kanpur Nagar. Petitioner did not hand over charge of Shastri Nagar and was issued several letters for handing over charge. A letter dated 3.10.1996 was issued by the Deputy Labour Commissioner that he has not complied the order of the departmental authorities which shows indiscipline in discharge of duties. On 15th October, 1996, the lock of the almirah of Shastri Nagar was broken open but neither any cash nor relevant receipts were found. Petitioner was placed under suspension by the order dated 2.12.1996 and disciplinary proceedings started. A charge-sheet dated 30.5.1997 was given to the petitioner of which reply was submitted by the petitioner on 27.6.1997. An additional charge-sheet containing three more charges was issued to the petitioner on 10.2.1999 which was also replied by the petitioner. In this writ petition, this Court vide its order dated 16.7.2001 passed an order directing the respondents to produce the entire record of the disciplinary enquiry. Learned standing counsel has produced the record of the disciplinary proceedings which was perused by the Court on 20.5.2002 and 22,5.2002. The petitioner appeared before the Enquiry Officer on 30.1.1999, 10.2.1999, 19.2.1999 and 25.2.1999. On 30.1.1999, petitioner was given copies of various documents running from 1 to 58 pages. In the enquiry proceedings, neither employer nor the petitioner produced any oral evidence. No witnesses were examined by either of the parties. The Enquiry Officer gave personal hearing to the petitioner on different dates and ultimately submitted detailed enquiry report dated 12.3.1999. In the enquiry report, out of ten charges, seven charges were found fully proved. A show cause notice dated 20.3.1999, was issued to the petitioner informing him that the Enquiry Officer has found seven charges proved out of ten charges. Petitioner was asked to show cause as to why he be not removed from the service. A copy of the enquiry report was also annexed along with the show cause notice. The petitioner also replied to show cause notice. The Labour Commissioner, U. P., after considering the reply to show cause notice of the petitioner and other material on record has passed the removal order dated 23.4.1999. The present writ petition has been filed challenging the aforesaid order dated 23.4.1999.

    3. Dr. R.G. Padia, counsel for the petitioner challenging the removal order has raised following submissions in support of the writ petition :

    (1) That the disciplinary enquiry against the petitioner has been conducted in violation of statutory rules, namely Rule 55 of the Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1930, since the employers did not prove the charges by any evidence and no enquiry was held by the Enquiry Officer as contemplated under the Rules. Counsel for the petitioner also relied on various authorities of this Court and the Apex Court in support of the above submission.

    (2) The petitioner was not paid suspension allowance during the suspension period which has vitiated the entire disciplinary proceedings. Several decisions have also been cited by the counsel for the petitioner in support of his submission.

    Learned standing counsel Sri Ajay Bhanot refuting the submission of the counsel for the petitioner contended that there is no violation of principles of natural justice in conducting the disciplinary enquiry against the petitioner. He has submitted that the petitioner was given copies of documents relied in the charge-sheet and the petitioner was also given oral hearing in the disciplinary enquiry. Learned standing counsel submitted that the charges against the petitioner were established from the documents on record and it was not obligatory for the Department to bring oral evidence on record in support of the charges. Learned standing counsel produced original record of the disciplinary proceedings and has pointed out that the petitioner has appeared before the Enquiry Officer on several dates and had signed the enquiry proceedings. Learned standing counsel submitted that the petitioner did not ask for producing any witness or to cross-examine any witness. Learned standing counsel placed reliance on several decisions in support of his submission. Replying the second submission of the counsel for the petitioner, learned standing counsel contended that since the petitioner participated in the disciplinary enquiry, non-receiving of suspension allowance was no Impediment in participating in the enquiry, the proceedings are not vitiated on that account.

    4. I have heard counsel for both the parties and have considered the pleadings of the parties. I have also examined the original record of the disciplinary enquiry. The first submission of the counsel for the petitioner is with regard to violation of principles of natural justice in conduct of the disciplinary enquiry. According to the submissions of the counsel for the petitioner no enquiry has actually been held. The submission of the counsel for the petitioner is that it was obligatory for the employer to prove the charges by producing witnesses who could prove the facts and charges. The counsel submitted that since the employer did not produce any witnesses none of the charges have been proved and the disciplinary authority committed error in holding the charges proved. He has submitted that the documents which have been referred to by the Enquiry Officer in the enquiry report has not been proved by any witnesses in the enquiry. The submission is that the correctness and veracity of the documents is to be proved in the enquiry by competent witnesses. It has been submitted that the petitioner was not allowed to cross-examine any witness.

    5. Counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance on several judgments of the Apex Court and this Court, i.e., Khem Chand v. Union of India and Ors., AIR 1958 SC 8OO ; Jagdish Prasad Saxena v. State of Madhya Bharat, AIR 1961 SC 1070 ; Town Area Committee, Jalalabad v. Jagdish Prasad and Ors., 1978 AWC 647 ; AIR 1978 SC 1407 ; Kulwant Singh Gill v. State Of Punjab, 1991 SCC (L & S) 998 ; Subhash Chandra Sharma v. Managing Director, U. P. Co-operative Spinning Mills Federation Ltd., Kanpur and another, 1999 (4) AWC 3227 and Smt. Ram Pyart v. State of U. P. and another. 2000 (2) AWC 1711 (LB).

    6. The disciplinary enquiry against the Government servant is governed by the Rules, namely, Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1930. Rule 55 of the aforesaid Rules lays down the procedure for conduct of the enquiry. Rule 55 of the aforesaid Rules is quoted below ;

    "55. (1) Without prejudice to the provisions of the Public Servant Inquiries Act, 1850, an order (other than an order based on facts which had led to his conviction in a criminal court or by a court martial) of dismissal, removal or reduction in rank (which includes reduction to a lower post or time scale, or to a lower stage in a time scale but excludes the reversion to a lower post of a person who is officiating in a higher post) shall be passed on a person who is a member of a civil service, or holds a civil post under the State unless he has been informed in writing of the grounds on which it is proposed to take action and has been afforded an adequate opportunity of defending himself. The grounds on which it is proposed to take action shall be reduced in the form of a definite charge or charges which shall be communicated to the person charged and which be so clear and precise as to give sufficient indication to the charged Government servant of the facts and circumstances against him. He shall be required, within a reasonable time to put in a written statement of his defence and to state whether he desires to be heard in person. If he so desires, or if the authority concerned so directs, an oral Inquiry shall be held in respect of such of the allegation as are not admitted. At that inquiry such oral evidence will be heard as the inquiring officer considers necessary. The person charged shall be entitled to cross-examine the witnesses, to give evidence in person and to have such witnesses called as he may wish, provided that the officer conducting the Inquiry may for sufficient reason to be recorded in writing refuse to call a witness. The proceedings shall contain a sufficient record of the evidence and statement of the findings and the grounds thereof. The officer conducting the inquiry may also separately from these proceedings make his own recommendation regarding the punishment to be Imposed on the charged Government servant."

    7. From perusal of the Rules it is clear that no order of dismissal, removal or reduction in rank can be passed against a person unless he has been informed in writing of the grounds on which it is proposed to take action and has been afforded an adequate opportunity of defending himself. Definite charges shall be communicated to the person and he shall be required to put in a written statement of his defence and to state whether he desires to be heard in person. If he so desires, or if the authority concerned so directs, an inquiry shall be held in respect of such of the allegations as are not admitted. At that enquiry such oral evidence will be heard as the inquiring officer considers necessary. The person charged shall be entitled to cross-examine the witnesses, to give evidence in person and to have such witnesses called as he may wish. The proceedings shall contain a sufficient record of the evidence and statement of the findings and the grounds thereof.

    8. Rule 55 contains the provisions, which are nothing but various facet of principles of natural justice. In the present case, admittedly the charge-sheet was given to which has also been replied. The Enquiry Officer was appointed to conduct the enquiry and the oral enquiry has also been conducted on various dates, namely, 30.1.1999, 10.2.1999, 19.2.1999 and 25.2.1999. The submission which requires to be examined is as to whether in the oral enquiry, the employer must necessarily bring oral evidence to prove the documents relied in the charge-sheet and to prove the charges. The counsel for the petitioner has much emphasised that unless the documents and charges are proved in the enquiry, it cannot be held that there is enquiry held. The reading of Rule 55 Sub-rule (1) expressly do not provide that it is obligatory on the employer to bring oral evidence to prove the charges. The Rule does not indicate that in case oral evidence is not brought by the employer, the charges must fail. There is no doubt that oral enquiry is held to enquire the veracity of the charges and to examine the allegations made against the delinquent. The words used under Rule 55 are "an oral enquiry shall be held in respect of such of the allegation as are not admitted". Thus, the enquiry, has to be confined to the allegations which are not admitted. The question is that if in the charge-sheet, certain documents are referred, does the employers have necessarily to bring the witnesses to prove the correctness of the documents or unless the documents are proved, they cannot be relied upon. In the oral enquiry, what evidence is required to prove the charges is a fact which may differ from case to case. If the allegations in the charges are such which can be proved by oral evidence, it is necessary for the employer to bring oral evidence to prove the charges but if the allegations in an enquiry are such which can be proved from the documents, it is not obligatory for the employer to bring oral evidence. Moreover, even in cases where the charges are based on documents, employer may be required to prove the documents in an event when the genuineness or veracity of the documents has been denied by the delinquent. In a case where the genuineness or veracity of the documents has not been denied by the delinquent, the employer may not fail on the ground that no witness has come forward to prove the document. The disciplinary enquiry is not governed by strict rules of evidence.

    9. The facts of the present case reveal that most of the charges against the petitioner were based on documents, i.e., the rent receipts, receipt register, the vouchers, cash book and vouchers submitted by the petitioner. In the present case, petitioner himself has deposited various receipts and has submitted documents to prove the deposit of the amount in the State Bank of India before the Department. For example charge No. 3 against the petitioner was to the effect that the petitioner has not deposited the amount of rent of Rs. 60,319 in the Government Treasury and has embezzled the said amount which was amount of rent realised by the petitioner from the tenants. The petitioner in his reply himself has come out with the explanation that he received various rent from the different receipts giving different dates and has also submitted that he has deposited the aforesaid amount in the State Bank of India on different dates. Thus, the realisation of the amount and the deposit of the amount on different dates in the State Bank of India was himself claimed by the petitioner. These facts were apparent from the documents including the receipt book, cash book, and the statement containing deposit in the bank. The reply of the petitioner to the charge-sheet dated 30.5.1997, has been filed by the petitioner as Annexure-3 to the writ petition. In reply to charge No. 3 the petitioner has ; given himself the details of the amount of rent realised by him and deposited a sum of Rs. 59,216 on different dates. From perusal of reply of the petitioner to charge No. 3 it is clear that he himself has admitted that he realised various amounts in August and September, 1996, amounting to Rs. 59,216 and an amount of Rs. 59,216 is claimed to be deposited by the petitioner on 25.1.1997. Thus, it is relevant to note that the petitioner made deposit of aforesaid amount after initiation of disciplinary proceedings and after his suspension on 6.12.1996. Thus, the charge of temporary embezzlement of the amount is proved even on the own explanation given by the petitioner. The receipt book and cash book of the department which were in possession of the petitioner were subsequently handed over by him to the department. The cash book maintained by the petitioner himself and the details of deposit of various amounts in the Bank has never been denied by the petitioner in his reply. There being no challenge to the genuineness of the receipts, registers and the documents, there was no occasion for the employer to bring oral evidence to prove the documents. If the genuineness of the documents relied by the employer is not challenged, there is no illegality in relying on the aforesaid documents in the disciplinary enquiry by the Enquiry Officer. In the facts of the present case, there being no challenge to the genuineness of the documents, it was not obligatory for the employer to bring any oral evidence to prove the documents. Thus, in the present case, no illegality was committed by the Enquiry Officer in referring and relying the documents which were relied in the charge-sheet and were not denied by the delinquent. In a case where the genuineness of the documents referred to in the charge-sheet are denied by the delinquent saying that the documents have been manufactured/fabricated and are not genuine documents. It may be necessary for the employer to bring oral evidence to prove the said document but each case will depend on facts of the particular case. The original record shows that the petitioner participated in the disciplinary enquiry and has signed the proceedings. The proceedings of the enquiry dated 25.2.1999 are very relevant. The proceeding of 25.2.1999 reads as under :

    ‘‘25.2.1999 श्री आर. बी. अग्निहोत्री, गृह निरीक्षक निलम्बित जांच कार्यवाही में भाग लेने हेतु आज दिनांक 25.2.1999 को उपस्थित हुए । श्री अग्निहोत्री द्वारा पत्र दिनांक 10.2.1999 द्वारा लगाये गये आरोपों का उार भी प्रस्तुत किया गया । आरोपों के सम्बनध में श्री अग्निहोत्री के कतिपय

    बिन्दुओं पर स्पष्टीकरण एवं मौखिक पूछताछ भी की गई । श्री अग्निहोत्री के अनुसार उनके द्वारा आरोपों के अम्बन्ध में लिखित विस्तृत उार दिया गया है तथा पूछताछ के दौरान भी वस्तुस्थिति स्पष्ट की गई है । श्री अग्निहोत्री द्वारा प्रश्नगत मामले में किसी अन्य

    व्यक्ति/कर्मचारी / अधिकारी से साक्ष्य कराने अथवा जिरह करने का अनुरोध/अपेक्षा नहीं की गई । प्रस्तुत मामले में आरोपी से सुनवाई कार्यवाही की गई । मामले में सुनवाई कार्यवाही समाप्त की जाती है ।’’

    10. Petitioner did not ask for cross-examination of any witness nor produced any witnesses in his defence. It cannot be said that he was not given opportunity to lead his evidence. No witness having been produced by the employer, there was no occasion of cross-examination. Further, the petitioner neither in his written reply nor even in the oral enquiry has prayed for summoning any witness. This clearly shows that there was no violation of principles of natural justice in the enquiry.

    11. The counsel for the petitioner has cited several judgments of the Apex Court and this Court in support of his submission which are required to be considered. The first decision relied by the petitioner is Khem Chand v. Union of India and Ors., AIR 1958 SC 800. In paragraph 19 of the aforesaid judgment, the Apex Court laid down as under :

    " 19. To summarise, the reasonable opportunity envisaged by the provision under consideration includes :

    (a) An opportunity to deny his guilt and establish his innocence, which he can only do if he is told what the charges levelled against him are and the allegations on which such charges are based ;

    (b) An opportunity to defend himself by cross-examining the witnesses produced against him and by examining himself or any other witnesses in support of his defence ; and finally

    (c) An opportunity to make his representation as to why the proposed punishment should not be inflicted on him, which he can only do if the competent authority, after the enquiry is over and after applying his mind to the gravity or otherwise of the charges proved against the Government servant, tentatively proposes to inflict one of the three punishments and communicates the same to the Government servant.

    In short the substance of the protection provided by rules, like Rule 55 referred to above, was bodily lifted out of the rules and together with an additional opportunity embodied in Section 240(3) of the Government of India Act, 1935, so as to give a statutory protection to the Government servants and has now been incorporated in Article 311(2) so as to convert the protection into a constitutional safeguard."

    The principles laid down by the Apex Court in the aforesaid judgment have been applied in the present case. Opportunity to defend was duly given to the petitioner in the present case.

    12. The next judgment relied upon by the counsel of the petitioner is Jagdish Prasad Saxena v. State of Madhya Bharat, AIR 1961 SC 1070. In the aforesaid judgment the Apex Court held that in taking disciplinary action against the public servant ; a proper disciplinary enquiry must be held against him after supplying him with the charge-sheet, and he must be allowed reasonable opportunity to meet the allegations contained in the charge-sheet. To the same effect is the judgment of the Apex Court in Town Area Committee, Jalalabad v. Jagdish Prasad and Ors. (supra), in which it was held that

    "a reasonable opportunity is a term of well known legal significance and includes an opportunity given to the employee to cross-examine the witnesses examined against him ; and to lead defence in support of his version"
    .

    13. Much emphasis has been given by the counsel for the petitioner on paragraph 5 of the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Kulwant Singh Gill v. State Of Punjab, 1991 SCC (L & S) 998. The Apex Court in paragraph 5 has held as under :

    "5. The further contention of Shri Nayar that the procedure under Rule 8 was followed by issuance of the show cause notice and consideration of the explanation given by the appellant would meet the test of rules 8 and 9 of the rules is devoid of any substance. Conducting an enquiry, de hors the rules, is no enquiry in the eye of law. It cannot be countenanced that the pretence of an enquiry without reasonable opportunity of adducing evidence both by the department as well as by the appellant in rebuttal, examination and cross-examination of the witnesses, if examined, to be an enquiry within the meaning of rules 8 and 9 of the rules. Those rules admittedly envisage, on denial of the charge by the delinquent officer, to conduct an enquiry giving reasonable opportunity to the presenting officer as well as the delinquent officer to lead evidence in support of the charge and in rebuttal thereof, giving adequate opportunity to the delinquent officer to cross-examine the witnesses produced by the department and to examine witnesses if intended on his behalf and to place his version : consideration thereof by the enquiry officer, if the disciplinary authority himself is not the Enquiry Officer. A report of the enquiry in that behalf is to be placed before the disciplinary authority who then is to consider it in the manner prescribed and to pass an appropriate order as for the procedure in vogue under the rules."

    In the aforesaid case, the Apex Court held that without reasonable opportunity of adducing evidence both by the department as well as by the appellant in rebuttal, examination and cross-examination of the witnesses, it cannot be said to be valid enquiry under the Rules. As observed above, there cannot be any dispute that opportunity is required to both the delinquent and the employer. In none of the casts cited by the counsel for the petitioner, it was held that if the documents relied by the employer are not disputed, i.e., if the genuineness of the documents relied by the department in the charge-sheet are not disputed, it is obligatory for the employer to bring oral evidence to prove the documents. The Division Bench of this Court in the case of Subhash Chandra Sharma (supra) held that the dismissal is illegal since no regular enquiry was held in that case. It was held by the Division Bench that the evidence should have been led against the delinquent in his presence and he should have been given opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses. To the same effect is another Division Bench's judgment in the case of Smt. Ram Pyari v. State of U. P. and Anr., 2000 (2) AWC 1711 (LB).

    14. The above mentioned judgments do support the contention of the counsel for the petitioner that the disciplinary enquiry is required to be held in consonance of principles of natural justice by giving opportunity to the petitioner to lead evidence and cross-examine the witnesses. However, in none of the aforesaid Judgments, it has been held that it is necessary for the employer to prove all documents relied by them whether their genuineness are denied or not. As observed above, since in the present case genuineness of document was not denied, there was no necessity to prove the documents by leading oral evidence by the employer. The denial of charges by delinquent is entirely different from denial of documents on the basis of which charges are levelled. In the present case, the charges were denied by the petitioner but there was no allegation that the documents are ungenuine, forged or fabricated. The proceedings of the enquiry clearly show that the copies of documents were given to the petitioner in the course of enquiry on 3.1.1999, which clearly suggests that the original documents which, were referred and relied in the charge-sheet were before the Enquiry Officer. The enquiry proceedings dated 9.2.1999, further reveals that the petitioner himself has submitted receipt books, cash book and treasury challans. Thus, the Enquiry Officer having referred to and relied aforesaid receipt books, cash book and treasury challan, it cannot be said that any error has been committed by the Enquiry Officer in relying the aforesaid documents.

    15. Learned standing counsel has placed reliance on the Apex Court's judgment in State of Haryana and Anr. v. Rattan Singh, (1982) 1 LLJ 46 (SC). It was held in paragraph 4 by the Apex Court :

    "4. It is well-settled that in a domestic enquiry the strict and sophisticated rules of evidence under the indian evidence act may not apply. All materials which are logically probative for a prudent mind are permissible. There is no allergy to hearsay evidence provided it has reasonable nexus and creditability. It is true that departmental authorities and administrative Tribunals must be careful in evaluating such material and should not glibly swallow what is strictly speaking not relevant under the indian evidence act. For this proposition it is not necessary to cite decisions nor text books, although we have been taken through case law and other authorities by counsel on both sides. The essence of a judicial approach is objectively, exclusion of extraneous materials or considerations and observance of rules of natural justice. Of course, fair play is basis and if perversity or arbitrariness, bias or surrender of independence of judgment vitiate the conclusion reached, such finding, even though of a domestic Tribunal, cannot be held good. However, the courts below misdirected themselves, perhaps, in insisting that passengers who had come in and gone out should be chased and brought before the Tribunal before the valid finding could be recorded. The "residium" Rule to which counsel for the respondent referred, based upon certain passages from the American jurisprudence does not go to that extent nor does the passage from the Halsbury insist on such rigid requirement. The simple point is, was there some evidence or was there no evidence not in the sense of the technical sides governing regular Court proceedings but in a fair common sense way as men of understanding and worldly wisdom will accept."

    16. Further reliance has been placed on Employees of Fire Stone Tyre and Rubber Co. (P.) Ltd. v. Workmen, AIR 1968 SC 236, in which it was held by the Apex Court in paragraph 9 :

    " 9. This leaves over the contention that before examining the witnesses Subramaniam was subject to a cross-examination. This was said to offend the principles of natural justice and reliance was placed on, Tata Oil Mills Co. Ltd. v. Its Workmen, 1963 [2] Lab LJ 78 (SC) ; Sur Enamel and Stamping Works Ltd. v. Their Workmen, 1963 (2) LLJ 367 : AIR 1963 SC 1914 ; Meenglas Tea Estate v. Workmen, 1963 (2) LLJ 392 : AIR 1963 SC 1719 and Associated Cement Co. Ltd. u. Their Workmen. 1963 (2) LLJ 396 (SC). These cases no doubt lay down that before a delinquent is asked anything, all the evidence against him must be led. This cannot be an invariable Rule in all cases. The situation is different where the accusation is based on a matter of record or the facts are admitted. In such a case it may be permissible to draw the attention of the delinquent to the evidence on the record which goes against him and which if he cannot satisfactorily explain must lead to a conclusion of guilt. In certain cases it may even be fair to the delinquent to take his version first so that the enquiry may cover the point of difference and the witnesses may be questioned properly on the aspect of the case suggested by him. It is all a question of justice and fair play. If the second procedure leads to a just decision of the disputed points and is fairer to the delinquent than the ordinary procedure of examining evidence against him first, no exception can be taken to it. It is, however, wise to ask the delinquent whether he would like to make a statement first or wait till the evidence is over but the failure to question him in this way does not ipso facto vitiate the enquiry unless prejudice is caused. It is only when the person enquired against seems to have been held at a disadvantage or has objected to such a course that the enquiry may be said to be vitiated. It must, however, be emphasised that in all cases in which the facts in controversy are disputed, the procedure ordinarily to be followed is the one laid down by this Court in the cited cases.

    The procedure of examining the delinquer.t first may be adopted in a clear case only."

    17. From the aforesaid two decisions, it is clear that the strict proof of evidence are not attracted in the disciplinary enquiry. Further in certain cases, the charges can be based only on the documents. It was held by the Apex Court where the question is based c n the matter of record, in such cases, it may be permissible to draw attention of the delinquent to evidence on record. Learned counsel has also submitted that the burden of proof in disciplinary enquiry depends on nature of charges and nature of explanation. It was held in paragraph 5 by the Apex Court in the case of Orissa Mining Corporation and Anr. v. Ananda C(sic)andra Prusty, (1998) 3 LLJ (Suppl) 1207 :

    "5, On a consideration of the totality of the facts and circumstances of the case including the nature of charges we are not inclined to interfere in the matter. The position with respect to burden of proof is as clarified by us herein above viz., that there is no such thing as an absolute burden of proof, always lying upon the department in a disciplinary enquiry. The burden of proof depends upon the nature of explanation and the nature of charges. In a given case the burden may be shifted to the delinquent officer, depending upon his explanation. For example take the first charge in this case. The charge was that he made certain false notings on account of which loans were disbursed to certain ineligible persons. The respondent's case was that those notings were based upon certain documents produced and certain records maintained by other employees in the office. In such a situation it is for the respondent to establish his case. The department is not expected to examine those other employees in the office to show that their acts or records could not have formed the basis cf wrong notings made by the respondent."

    18. Thus, in facts of the present case when the charges against the petitioner were based on records, namely, receipt book, cash book, treasury challan and on the said documents, allegation of embezzlement of the amount was made, it can be observed that the burden shifted to the delinquent to prove his innocence. More so, when he himself admitted that the realised the amount of Rs. 59,216 as rent from the tenant and the said amount was not immediately deposited in the treasury and was deposited only after disciplinary enquiry was initiated and he was placed under suspension.

    19. From the above discussion, it is clear that there was no violation of principles of natural justice in conducting the disciplinary enquiry against the petitioner. The petitioner was given ample opportunity to give defence. The enquiry was not vitiated on account of the fact that no witness was examined on behalf of the employer to prove the documents referred and relied in the charge-sheet, since at no point of time, the genuineness of document was denied by the delinquent.

    20. The second submission of the counsel for the petitioner is to the effect that since the petitioner was not given subsistence allowance the whole enquiry is vitiated. Reliance is placed on Capt. M. Paul Anthony v. Bharat Cold Mines Ltd. and another, 1999 (2) AWC 1579 (SC) : 1999 (82) FLR 627 (SC) ; P.C. Chaturvedi v. U. P. State Textile Corporation Limited, Kanpur and Ors., (2002) 1 UPLBEC 84. In the case of Capt. M, Paul Anthony (supra), the Apex Court held the whole enquiry vitiated on the ground that the appellant was unable to go to Kolar Gold Fields to participate in the enquiry due to nonpayment of subsistence allowance. In the aforesaid case the adjournment sought by delinquent was refused and the enquiry proceeded ex parte. Paragraphs 30 and 31 of the judgment of the Apex Court in the aforesaid case are being reproduced below :

    "30. The question whether the appellant was unable to go to Kolar Gold Fields to participate in the inquiry proceedings on account of non-payment of subsistence allowance may not have been raised before the Inquiry Officer, but it was positively raised before the High Court and has also been raised before us. Since it is not disputed that the subsistence allowance was not paid to the appellant during the pendency of the disciplinary proceedings, we have to take strong notice of it, particularly as it is not suggested by the respondents that the appellant had any other source of income.

    31. Since in the instant case the appellant was not provided any subsistence allowance during the period of suspension and the adjournment prayed for by him on account of his illness, duly supported by medical certificate, was refused resulting in ex parte proceedings against him, we are of the opinion that the appellant has been punished in total violation of the principles of natural justice and he was literally not afforded any opportunity of hearing. Moreover, as pleaded by the appellant before the High Court as also before us that on account of his penury occasioned by nonpayment of subsistence allowance, he could not undertake a journey to attend the disciplinary proceedings, the findings recorded by the Enquiry Officer at such proceedings, which were held ex parte, stand vitiated."

    21. In P.C. Chaturvedi's case (supra), the Division Bench held the dismissal is liable to be quashed since the reason for non-payment of subsistence allowance could not be substantiated. The Court did not accept the case of the employer that since the delinquent did not mark the attendance register whereas he was required to report for duty daily he was not entitled for allowance. The Court observed that no register was produced by the respondent showing that it was that register which was required to be signed by the petitioner and that due to his non-attending the office he was marked absent. Thus, the adverse inference was drawn against the respondent. In the present case, the respondents have taken the plea in supplementary counter-affidavit that the petitioner has not filed the requisite certificate to the effect that he is not engaged in any other occupation, hence due to that reason allowance could not be paid. The aforesaid paragraph 5 of the supplementary counter-affidavit has been replied in paragraph 5 of the supplementary rejoinder-affidavit dated 18.2.2002, but no specific reply has been given. It has not been submitted that the petitioner has submitted necessary certificate to the effect that he is not engaged in any occupation. Thus, the Division Bench's judgment in P.C. Chaturvedi's case depends on facts of that case and does not help the petitioner in any manner. Learned standing counsel has also relied on the Division Bench's judgment of this Court in Municipal Board, Amroha and Anr. v. V.P. Public Service Tribunal No. 1 and Anr., 2001 (3) AWC 1831. The Division Bench in the aforesaid judgment has held that mere non-payment of subsistence allowance during the period of suspension will not ipso facto render the order of removal invalid. It must be coupled with real prejudice. Relevant paragraphs 13 and 15 of the aforesaid judgment are extracted below :

    "13. The proposition that is culled out from the aforesaid judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court is that apart from the violation of the principles of natural justice because of nonpayment of subsistence allowance, some prejudice must be shown to have been caused to the employee. Prejudice may be the inability of the employee to attend the enquiry proceedings for want of funds because of non-payment of subsistence allowance.

    Therefore, it is clear that mere non-payment of subsistence allowance during the period of suspension will not ipso facto render the order of removal invalid. It must be coupled with real prejudice.

    15. In the instant case respondent No. 2 has not pleaded that he was prevented from attending the inquiry proceedings because of non-payment of subsistence allowance. No material has been placed by him before the Court to show that any prejudice was caused to him on account of non-payment of subsistence allowance. It is not in dispute that he attended the inquiry proceedings throughout and was afforded full opportunity. Under these circumstances, the Tribunal was not justified in allowing the review application and in setting aside the order of removal dated 27.8.1974 and the order of dismissal of appeal dated 11.5.1977. Therefore, the impugned judgment of the Tribunal is liable to be quashed."

    22. In the present case, it has come on the record that the petitioner has participated in the enquiry. There is no such case of the petitioner that on account of non-payment of subsistence allowance, he suffered any prejudice in participating in the enquiry. In view of the facts of the present case and the reasons given above, the dismissal order is not vitiated due to non-payment of subsistence allowance to the petitioner. The second submission of the petitioner also cannot be accepted.

    23. It is also relevant to note here that the disciplinary authority in its order has considered all the charges, explanation given by the petitioner and the enquiry report and found the charges proved. Charge Nos. 3, 8 and 9 of the charge-sheet relate to financial Irregularity and embezzlement of Government money and the aforesaid charges were found proved. There being serious charges of financial irregularity and embezzlement, which is proved from the records of the case, no error has been committed by the disciplinary authority in passing the order of removal. Apart from the aforesaid three charges, four other charges were found proved which Included disobedience of the order of the authorities, not handing over charge of the office after transfer, making manipulations and alterations in the Government records, not making entries of rent receipts in receipt book and in the relevant registers. From the own explanation of the petitioner submitted in reply to the charge-sheet, the charge of temporary embezzlement is fully proved. Further more, the amount which was misappropriated and embezzled by the petitioner, was deposited by him after initiation of disciplinary enquiry and after he was placed under suspension. In view of the aforesaid, the charges were fully proved and the order of dismissal has been passed on material on record.

    24. In view of the aforesaid discussion, none of the submissions raised by the counsel for the petitioner have any merit. No good ground has been made out for Interfering with the order of removal in this writ petition. The writ petition lacks merit and is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Raj Babu Agnihotri v. Labour Commissioner, U.P, Kanpur And Others
    (Jul 17, 2002)