AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 5 Chapter VIII of the Rules of Court, 1952,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 5 Chapter VIII of the Rules of Court, 1952,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion — D.S. Sinha, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This Special Appeal under Rule 5, Chapter VIII of the Rules of Court, 1952, challenges a judgment and order dated 28 May 1997 (Markande Katju, J.) in Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 40495 of 1996, Ravindra Nath Rai v. State of U.P., which directed the preparation of a waiting list and appointment from that list to the extent of vacancies caused by selected candidates not joining.

Relevant facts (as stated in the opinion):

  • An advertisement for recruiting 525 Sub-Inspectors in Civil Police was issued on 4 October 1991; revised on 26 October 1991 to increase vacancies to 630.
  • Various stages of the selection process occurred between June 1992 and October 1993 (preliminary, physical, written tests and interviews). Remaining interviews were postponed in October/November 1993, and on 9 June 1994 the entire selection process was cancelled.
  • The cancellation was challenged in Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 21994 of 1994 (Ram Das Rai v. State of U.P.); a single judge allowed that petition on 23 May 1995 directing declaration of result. That judgment was modified in special appeal on 19 November 1996 to alter the OBC reservation percentage from 27% to 15%.
  • On 2 December 1996 a list of candidates chosen to fill 630 vacancies was declared and a communique stated no waiting list had been prepared; training commenced on 7 January 1997.
  • On 16 January 1997 authorities decided to fill 86 newly created posts from the same recruitment process, resulting in 716 candidates being taken for training (630 + 86).
  • Out of the 716, 123 did not join and 13 dropped out, producing 136 vacancies.
  • Respondents (candidates) filed Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 40495 of 1996 seeking quashing of the 2 December 1996 communique and a mandamus directing preparation of a waiting list and consideration of candidates from it to fill the remaining vacancies. The single judge allowed that petition and directed preparation and consideration of a waiting list; this Special Appeal challenges that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners (respondents in this appeal) had the locus (right/standing) to maintain the writ petition challenging the communique and seeking preparation and consideration from a waiting list.
  2. Whether there exists any statutory or other provision obliging the authorities to prepare a waiting list or to consider candidates from such a list for filling vacancies arising from selected candidates not joining.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The petitioners (candidates) have no right to maintain the writ petition because successful candidates do not possess an indefeasible right to appointment (relying on Shankarsan Dash v. Union of India).
  • There is no statutory or other provision requiring preparation of a waiting list or requiring that candidates on a so-called waiting list be considered for appointment.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents sought only consideration of their candidature for appointment; they relied on the constitutional right to equality under Article 14 read with Articles 16(1) and 16(4) as a basis for a legally cognizable and judicially enforceable right to be considered.
  • They relied on judicial authority (as cited in the opinion) for the proposition that while inclusion on a select panel may not create a vested right to appointment, it does create a right to be considered and the appointing authority cannot ignore the select panel or decline appointments arbitrarily.
  • Practices and past decisions where waiting lists were prepared (and a Supreme Court directive to fill vacancies from comparative merit lists in analogous circumstances) were relied upon to support the relief sought.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shankarsan Dash v. Union of India Holds that successful candidates have no indefeasible right to be appointed. The appellants relied on it to contend petitioners had no right to maintain the writ; the single judge and this court observed that even if there is no indefeasible right, the State cannot act arbitrarily and the principle does not oust a candidate's right to be considered.
Jai Narain Ram v. State of U.P. Right to seek appointment is a facet of the constitutional guarantee of equality under Article 14 read with Articles 16(1) and 16(4). The court invoked this authority to recognise that the respondents possess a constitutional right to equality that encompasses a right to seek consideration for appointment.
R.S. Mittal v. Union of India Although a person on a select panel has no vested right to appointment, he has a right to be considered; the appointing authority cannot ignore the select panel or decline to make appointments on whims. The court applied this principle to hold that respondents have a legally cognizable and judicially enforceable right to be considered for appointment from the comparative merit list.
Ram Das Rai v. State of U.P. (C.M.W.P. No. 21994 of 1994) The single judge had allowed the petition and directed declaration of result (procedural history of the selection process). Used as part of the factual and procedural history leading to declaration of the list and subsequent events; it led to the declaration of candidates for the 630 vacancies.
Ravindra Nath Rai v. State of U.P. (C.M.W.P. No. 40495 of 1996) The judgment and order dated 28 May 1997 (impugned in this appeal) directing preparation of a waiting list and appointment from it to the extent of vacancies caused by non-joining. This court upheld that impugned judgment as substantially sound and not in conflict with legal principle or precedent, and dismissed the Special Appeal.
Santosh Kumar Singh v. State of U.P. (Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 18930 of 1989) A waiting list was prepared pursuant to this court's order dated 15 March 1991; a special leave petition against that order was rejected by the Supreme Court. The court noted prior practice and judicial sanction for preparing waiting lists in earlier selections (1981, 1982 and 1987) and relied on that background to support fair play in the present case.
A.V. Bhogeshwarudu v. A.P. Public Service Commission Supreme Court directed that existing vacancies be filled up from the comparative merit list of candidates. The court invoked this case to support the proposition that vacancies should be filled from the comparative merit list when available.
Asha Kaul (Mrs.) v. State of Jammu & Kashmir Recognises that inclusion in a select list does not give an indefeasible right to appointment but emphasises the Government's obligation to act fairly; the selection exercise cannot be reduced to a farce. The court cited this authority to underline the requirement of fair treatment by the State and to conclude that the appellants' refusal to consider candidates from the comparative merit list was unfair.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's reasoning proceeds in two main strands corresponding to the appellants' twin submissions:

  1. Maintainability / Locus: The court rejected the contention that the petitioners had no right to maintain the writ simply because successful candidates lack an indefeasible right to appointment. The court relied on precedent emphasising that absence of a vested right to appointment does not license arbitrary State action. The court held that candidates possess a constitutionally protected right to equality and to be considered for appointment (Article 14 read with Article 16), and that R.S. Mittal establishes a right to consideration even where no vested appointment right exists. On this basis the court concluded the respondents had locus standi and the single judge correctly rejected the maintainability objection.
  2. Waiting list / Obligation to Consider: The court accepted that there was no statutory provision explicitly mandating a "waiting list" under that label. However, the court noted these undisputed facts: (a) a comparative merit list of all eligible candidates was prepared; (b) there is no statutory rule or executive instruction limiting the life of that list; (c) the comparative merit list had not been nullified; and (d) the appellants themselves treated that comparative merit list as operative by picking 86 candidates from it to fill newly created posts. Given these circumstances, the court found it inconsistent and arbitrary for the appellants to refuse consideration of the next candidates on the comparative merit list to fill 136 vacancies arising from non-joining and drop-outs.

The court additionally relied on precedents and past practice (including earlier selections where waiting lists were prepared and a Supreme Court authority directing filling vacancies from comparative merit lists) and on the equitable principle that the Government must act fairly. Noting a communication from the Deputy Inspector General suggesting compliance with the single judge's direction, the court found no justifiable reason for the discriminatory approach adopted by the appellants.

Having applied these legal principles to the facts, the court concluded that the impugned judgment was not in conflict with statute or precedent and required no interference in intra-court appellate jurisdiction.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

DISMISSED — The Special Appeal fails and is dismissed.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The court upheld the single judge's direction that the authorities prepare a waiting list (or otherwise consider the comparative merit list) and consider and appoint eligible candidates in accordance with merit to the extent of the number of candidates in the main select list who had not joined — i.e., to fill the identified vacancies (136 vacancies resulted from non-joins and drop-outs as set out in the facts).
  • No costs were ordered ("There is no order as to costs").
  • The court observed that the impugned judgment does not conflict with legal principle, statute or precedent and is substantially sound; the decision represents an application of existing principles (Article 14/16 and the right to be considered) rather than the creation of a novel precedent. Accordingly, the practical effect is limited to enforcing consideration/appointment from the comparative merit list in this selection exercise rather than announcing a new broad legal rule.

Note: This summary is confined to the statements, facts, legal arguments and holdings contained in the provided opinion and does not add information beyond that text.

    State Of U.P And Others v. Ravindra Nath Rai And Others

    D.S Sinha, J.:— Heard Sri Sabha Jeet Yadav, learned counsel representing the appellants and Sri Ashok Khare, learned counsel appearing for the respondents, at length and in detail.

    2. Instant Special Appeal, under Rule 5 Chapter VIII of the Rules of Court, 1952, is directed against the judgment and order dated 28th May, 1997, rendered by his Lordship Hon'ble Markande Katju, J. in Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 40495 of 1996, Ravindra Nath Rai v. State of U.P, allowing the writ petition and giving to the appellants the following direction:

    “The respondents are directed to prepare a waiting list in the said examination and consider and appoint the persons in the waiting list in accordance with merit to the extent of the number of candidates in the main select list who had not joined.”

    3. The acts and events constituting undisputed facts of the case, briefly stated, are as below—

    (i) For the purposes of recruiting 525 Sub-Inspectors in Civil Police of the State, the Deputy Inspector General of Police (Karmik), Police Headquarters, Allahabad, the appellant No. 5, issued an advertisement on 4th October, 1991. Later on, by means of another advertisement dated 26th October, 1991 number of vacancies to be filled in by the recruitment was modified, increasing number of vacancies from 525 to 630.

    (ii) On 28th June, 1992 a preliminary test was held. Physical test was held on 4th, 5th and 6th January, 1993. The result of the physical test was announced on 7th January, 1993. Written examination was conducted on 8th/9th January, 1993, and result was declared on 19th October, 1993. Thereupon, dates for the interview were fixed from 24th September, 1993 to 19th October, 1993 and some interviews took place. On 2nd October, 1993 a press-note was issued notifying that the remaining interviews were postponed and would commence from 1st December, 1993. On 29th November, 1993 Government issued notification notifying its decision to postpone the remaining selection process. Eventually on 9th June, 1994 entire selection process was cancelled.

    (iii) The validity of the order cancelling the entire selection process was challenged in this court through Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 21994 of 1994, Ram Das Rai v. State of U.P. The petition was considered by a learned single judge who by means of his judgment and order dated 23rd May, 1995 allowed the petition and commanded the concerned authorities to declare the result.

    (iv) The above judgment and order of the learned single Judge was challenged in special appeal which was decided on 19th November, 1996. In special appeal the judgment of the learned single judge was modified to the extent that reservation for the O.B.C candidates should be 15% instead of 27% as directed by the learned single Judge.

    (v) Finally, after lapse of interminable period of more than five years from the initiation of selection process, on 2nd December, 1996 a list of candidates chosen to fill up 630 vacancies was declared. On the same date, a communique was issued from the Police Headquarters under the signature of the Deputy Inspector General of Police (Karmik), Uttar Pradesh notifying that no waiting list had been prepared and it would not be possible to send any candidate for training from the waiting list. This order was duly notified by a separate press-note of the same date. The training course for the new recruits commenced on 7th January, 1997.

    4. On 16th January, 1997, the authorities decided to fill up 86 newly created posts of Sub-Inspectors in Civil Police from the candidates who had participated in the recruitment process in pursuance to the advertisements dated 4th October, 1991, as modified by notification dated 16th November, 1991 and found eligible and qualified therefor. Thus, the total number of candidates selected for training leading to appointment on the post of Sub-Inspectors were 716 (630 for vacancies advertised and 86 for newly created posts).

    5. Out of 716 candidates 123 did not join and 13 dropped out of training course resulting in 136 vacancies. The respondents who had participated in the recruitment approached this court through Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 40495 of 1996, praying for issuance of a writ of certiorari quashing the order dated 2nd December, 1996 and the communique notifying the order dated 2nd December, 1996 whereby it was notified that no waiting list had been prepared. Further prayer of the respondents was that by means of a writ of mandamus the Deputy Inspector General of Police (Karmik), Police Headquarters, Allahabad, the Respondent No. 5 in the writ petition, be directed to prepare a waiting list of selected candidates and if their names figured in the waiting list, they may be allowed to join the training for the purposes of filling up the remaining posts falling vacant on account of the candidates either not joining or dropping out. The learned single Judge allowed the writ petition and issued directions, extracted earlier. Hence, this special appeal.

    6. Twin submissions made by the learned Standing Counsel, appearing for the appellants, before the learned Single Judge as well as before this court are:

    (i) that the petitioners have no right to maintain petition; and

    (ii) that there is no provision, either statutory or otherwise, to prepare waiting list, and consider the candidature of candidates who figure therein.

    7. First submission of the learned Standing Counsel regarding the maintainability of the writ petition, based on decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Shankarsan Dash v. Union Of India. of India,1 holding that the successful candidates have no indefeasible right to be appointed, was rejected by the learned single judge by observing that the said decision itself states that although a person may not have indefeasible right to be appointed yet this does not mean that the State has the licence for acting in an arbitrary manner. In support of instant appeal also, the learned Standing Counsel submits that as the petitioners have no indefeasible right to appointment they could not maintain the writ petition.

    8. In its decision rendered in the case of Jai Narain Ram v. State of U.P,2 the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that right to seek appointment to a post under Article 14 read with Articles 16(1) and (4) is a constitutional right to equality. In another decision rendered in the case of R.S Mittal v. Union Of India. of India,3 the Hon'ble Supreme Curt pointed out that it is “no doubt correct that a person on the select panel has no vested right to be appointed to the post for which he has been selected. He has a right to be considered for appointment. But at the same time, the appointing authority cannot ignore the select panel or decline to make the appointment on its whims.” The respondents seek nothing more than consideration of their candidature for appointment. They have legally cognizable and judicially enforceable right therefor.

    9. Thus, it cannot be held that the respondents had no locus standi at all to maintain the petition. The learned single Judge rightly rejected the contention of the appellants that the petitioners had no right to maintain the petition.

    10. Second submission of the learned Standing Counsel that there is no provision, either statutory or otherwise, to preparer waiting list is correct. It may also be correct that no waiting list was prepared in terms of the expression ‘waiting list’. But, neither has it been nor can it be disputed that a comparative merit list of all the candidates found eligible and qualified for appointment was prepared; that there is no statutory rule or executive instruction limiting the life of the said comparative merit list; that the comparative merit list has not been nullified; and that the comparative merit list was treated to be surviving by the appellants themselves which is evident from the fact that for filling up 86 newly created posts candidates were picked up from that very list from which the candidates for filling 630 advertised vacancies were selected, and out of 630 so selected candidates 123 did not join and 13 dropped out which resulted in creation of 136 vacancies qua 630 advertised posts.

    11. On one hand for filling unadvertised new posts the appellants have picked up 86 candidates from the comparative merit list of all the candidates found eligible and qualified for appointment prepared during the selection process initiated for filling the 630 advertised posts and on the other for filling 136 advertised posts they have denied even the consideration of the candidature of those candidates who figure in the comparative merit list immediately next to those who have been appointed against 494 advertised posts. The appellants have not disclosed any justifiable reason for adopting such discriminatory and wholly arbitrary course resulting in gross violation of the inalienable guarantee enshrined in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. It cannot be countenanced. The candidates whose names figure in the comparative merit list prepared for a particular selection held for the advertised posts do not have any right of consideration for future vacancies. But, certainly they have a right to be considered for appointment against the advertised vacant posts, and such right is a legally cognizable and judicially enforceable constitutional right.

    12. It may be noticed that the Deputy Inspector General of Police (Karmik), Police Headquarters, Allahabad addressed a letter dated 21st June, 1997 to Special Secretary, State of Uttar Pradesh (Home), Police Department-10 suggesting that direction given by the learned single judge in the impugned judgment may be complied with keeping in view the past precedent in that regard and seeking necessary direction in that regard.

    13. Prior to selection in question the selections had taken place in the years 1981 and 1982 also, and in those selections waiting lists had been prepared. In the year 1987 also a waiting list was prepared, of course this time the waiting list was prepared in pursuance of the judgment and order of this court dated 15th March, 1991 rendered in Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 18930 of 1989, Santosh Kumar Singh v. State of U.P against which a special leave petition was filed before the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, and it is not disputed, it was rejected.

    14. In similar circumstances, in the case of A.V Bhogeshwarudu v. A.P Public Service Commission, the Hon'ble Supreme Court directed that existing vacancies be filled up from the comparative merit list of the candidates.

    15. Approving the dictum that mere inclusion in the select list does not confer upon the candidates included therein an indefeasible right to be appointed, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in its decision rendered in Asha Kaul (Mrs.) v. State of Jammu and Kashmir, observed that the “other aspect is the obligation of the Government to act fairly. The whole exercise cannot be reduced to a farce.” The course adopted by the appellants in the instant case is not fair. There being no statutory rule or executive instruction limiting life of the comparative merit list, the list having not been treated by the appellants as exhausted, and 136 vacancies against the advertised posts being available, and there being no justifiable reason for not considering the candidature of the candidates figuring in the comparative merit list next below the last candidate absorbed, the appellants must consider the candidature of such candidates for filling up 136 advertised vacant posts. Rule of fair play, which has to be reflected in all actions of the State, demands so.

    16. In the back-drop of what has been said above, the impugned judgment and order does not suffer from dissonance with any legal principle, Statute or judicial precedent. It is, substantially, sound and warrants no interference in exercise of intra-court appellate jurisdiction.

    17. Thus, the Special Appeal fails and is dismissed. There is no order as to costs.

    18. Appeal Dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of U.P And Others v. Ravindra Nath Rai And Others
    (Feb 3, 1999)