AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 2(18) and S. 2(19) of Uttar Pradesh State Universities Act, 1973,
  • S. 31 of the Uttar Pradesh State Universities Act,
  • S. 21(3) of the State Universities Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 2(18) and S. 2(19) of Uttar Pradesh State Universities Act, 1973,
  • S. 31 of the Uttar Pradesh State Universities Act,
  • S. 21(3) of the State Universities Act.
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Aloke Chakrabarti, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, an incumbent Instructor in the Department of Fine Arts at Allahabad University, seeks a mandamus directing the redesignation of his post to Lecturer and payment of Lecturer's salary. The petitioner was originally appointed as Instructor by order dated January 19/20, 1987 and made permanent by order dated December 2, 1989. He performs duties that include teaching graduate and postgraduate classes.

The writ petition describes prior institutional attempts to obtain redesignation: the University's Executive Council passed resolutions (notably on March 19, 1974, and again in 1981) recommending that Instructors be redesignated as Lecturers and given Lecturer grade/pay, but the State Government did not act on those resolutions. Some other categories (demonstrators, cartographers, research assistants, etc.) obtained designation or pay parity with Lecturers, but the Instructors of Fine Arts allegedly remained deprived.

The petition was considered by a Division Bench and referred to a Full Bench (order dated July 30, 1997) because of inconsistent Division Bench decisions: Dr. Ashutosh Kumar Upadhyay v. Sampurnanand Sanskrit University (allowed parity) and Pankaj Kumar v. University of Allahabad (allowed parity) on one side, and Radhev Shyam Bhatt v. State of Uttar Pradesh (1996 A.L.J. 1624) (rejected parity) on the other.

The petitioner was permitted to amend the writ (order dated March 4, 1998) to challenge a State Government order dated March 15, 1982. Counter-affidavits were filed by the University and the State; rejoinder affidavit was filed by the petitioner. The matter was heard with counsel for all parties present.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the post of Instructor in the Department of Fine Arts at Allahabad University should be redesignated as Lecturer and whether the petitioner is entitled to be paid the Lecturer's scale of pay.
  2. Whether the principle of "equal pay for equal work" applies to the petitioner, given alleged parity of duties with Lecturers and the University/State's contention of differences in qualifications and mode of recruitment.
  3. Whether the University's resolution(s) in favour of redesignation could be implemented absent State Government approval under the State Universities Act (notably S. 21(3) as invoked by the parties).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The University accepted the claim at institution level (Executive Council and Academic Council) and recommended redesignation to Lecturer, but implementation was stalled because the State Government did not act; the State never positively refused the claim.
  • Other categories (demonstrators, research assistants, cartographers) in the University received parity or redesignation; Instructors of Fine Arts having similar treatment in other categories should not be deprived.
  • The petitioner performs functions similar to Lecturers (including teaching graduate and postgraduate classes) and thus claims parity under the principle of equal pay for equal work, relying on judgments such as Dr. Ashutosh Kumar Upadhyay and Pankaj Kumar.
  • The petitioner challenged a State Government order dated March 15, 1982 by amendment and relied on institutional approvals to support entitlement.

University's Arguments

  • The process of appointment for Lecturers differs from that for Instructors; recruitment modes and statutory provisions differ, so pay parity cannot be equated.
  • The University pointed out that the State Government had already rejected the proposal for parity in 1982 on grounds of parity, and thus the University's institutional approvals were subject to State approval and not self-executing.
  • Relied on prior Division Bench decision in Radhey Shyam Bhatt rejecting a similar claim and argued that there is no material to contradict that finding.

State Respondents' Arguments

  • The recruitment process for Lecturers and Instructors is different; classification on the basis of qualification and responsibility is permissible in law, and where such differences exist the principle of equal pay for equal work does not apply.
  • Pointed to a prior refusal by the State (1982) to approve redesignation/parity, supporting non-implementation of executive-level resolutions without State sanction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dr. Ashutosh Kumar Upadhyay v. Sampurnanand Sanskrit University Held by a Division Bench to allow a similar writ directing Instructor be treated as Lecturer (an instance of permitting redesignation/pay parity). The Court treated this decision as confined to its facts and held that the circumstances there were different; therefore it could not be applied to the present case as an automatic precedent for parity.
Pankaj Kumar v. University of Allahabad Granted pay parity to a Research Assistant in Allahabad University with Lecturer(s) in that case. The Court held that Pankaj Kumar is confined to its facts and that nothing was shown to establish parity between the present Instructor and the research assistants in that earlier case; hence it was not applicable here.
Radhev Shyam Bhatt v. State of Uttar Pradesh [1996 A.L.J. 1624] Division Bench dismissed claim of Instructors (Department of Fine Arts) for pay parity with Lecturers. The Court approved the reasoning and findings of that Division Bench decision, observed that the present petitioner produced no material contradicting those findings, and relied on that precedent to deny relief.
Secretary, Finance Department v. West Bengal Registration Service Association [1992 (2) L.L.N 386] Establishes that determination of pay-scales/ job evaluation is normally an executive function; courts will not ordinarily perform job evaluation but retain jurisdiction if arbitrary state action/inaction is shown. The Court cited this principle to emphasize judicial restraint on matters of pay-scale determination while noting judicial jurisdiction remains in cases of arbitrary treatment; it used this to frame deference to executive classification of posts.
State of Tamil Nadu v. M.R. Alagappan (Civil Appeals Nos. 4684-4685 of 1994) Observation that a person claiming parity must show that his qualifications, duties and functions are similar to the person with whom parity is sought. The Court cited this principle to place the burden on the petitioner to demonstrate parity of qualifications, duties and recruitment; held that the petitioner did not discharge that burden.
Sita Devi v. State of Haryana [1996 (2) L.L.N 476] Cited as authority referred to in Alagappan on the burden/requirements for establishing parity. The Court noted that Alagappan relied upon Sita Devi; the reference supported the general position about the claimant's burden to prove parity.
Chandigarh Administration v. Smt Anita Sood [1995 Supp (3) SCC 613] Explains that qualitative differences (e.g., between a Professor and a Lecturer) justify different pay-scales; teaching quality/standard can justify classification. The Court relied on this principle to support the view that differences in qualification and expected quality of work can justify different pay-scales and that parity is not automatic despite some similarity in duties.
Dr. Bajrang Bahadur Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh [1997 (3) A.W.C 1476] Summarises that to claim equal pay a petitioner must establish similarity in mode of recruitment, eligibility qualifications, nature of duties/responsibilities and applicable service rules. The Court quoted and applied this exposition as consistent law, using it to require the petitioner to prove parity in all relevant respects — which was not done.
V. Markendeya v. State of Andhra Pradesh [1989 (1) L.L.N 815] Upheld reasonableness of classification between graduate and non-graduate supervisors. Used to support that classification based on qualifications can be reasonable and justify different pay-scales.
Shyam Babu Verma v. Union of India [1994 (2) L.L.N 465] Holds that nature of work may be similar but pay may vary due to academic qualification or experience, justifying classification. Cited to bolster the Court's view that academic qualification or experience can justify differential pay even when duties overlap.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court approached the petition by applying the principle that claims of parity must be examined on the basis of relevant factual matrices and established legal principles. The Court's analysis proceeded in the following steps, as recorded in the opinion:

  1. Identification of the legal test: the Court emphasized that a claimant seeking "equal pay for equal work" must demonstrate parity across several objective factors — notably qualifications, mode of recruitment, nature of duties and responsibilities, and applicable service rules — rather than relying solely on similarity of some duties performed.
  2. Comparison of prescribed qualifications: the Court compared the statutory qualifications contained in the First Statute, 1976 of Allahabad University. For Lecturers in Fine Arts, the University requires either a master’s degree (with at least 55% marks or equivalent grade) or a recognizably high professional achievement as a traditional/professional artist. For Instructors, the requirement is a degree/diploma in painting from a recognized institution. The Court concluded the qualifications are substantially different.
  3. Comparison of modes of recruitment: the Court examined recruitment provisions. Lecturers are appointed by a selection committee constituted under S. 31 of the Uttar Pradesh State Universities Act (including external experts nominated by the Chancellor) and require Executive Council approval. Instructors are appointed on the recommendation of a different selection committee (Vice-Chancellor, Dean and Head of Department) and under different statutory/ordinance provisions (Para 10.04 / Chap. X). The Court found the recruitment processes to be substantially different.
  4. Distinction in status and role: relying on statutory definitions (S. 2(18) and S. 2(19) of the Uttar Pradesh State Universities Act, 1973), the Court drew a distinction between a "teacher" and a "teacher of University," observing that the latter typically also guides or conducts research while the former may primarily assist in imparting instruction — reinforcing the qualitative distinction between Lecturers and Instructors.
  5. Analysis of precedents: the Court reviewed conflicting authorities. It held that decisions allowing parity in other contexts (e.g., Ashutosh Kumar Upadhyay; Pankaj Kumar) are fact-specific and confined to those circumstances. The Court approved the reasoning in Radhey Shyam Bhatt (which dismissed a similar claim by Instructors in the same department) and found no material before it to displace the findings in that case.
  6. Deference to executive classification: the Court cited authority that job classification and pay-scale determination are primarily executive functions (Secretary, Finance Department v. West Bengal Registration Service Association) and noted that courts normally will not substitute their judgment for the executive absent arbitrariness; this informed the Court's cautious approach.
  7. Consideration of late-produced Government order: after conclusion of hearing the petitioner filed an affidavit attaching a Government order dated October 17, 1998. The Court observed that this document was not before it during the hearing, had not been the subject of argument, and therefore could not be taken into account at that stage. The Court expressly stated its decision was based on the pleadings and documents before it at hearing and that its judgment would not, in any way, affect the Government order (the opinion also refers to a Government order dated October 17, 1988 in the same context).
  8. Conclusion on facts and law: applying the legal principles to the factual record, the Court concluded the petitioner had not established parity in qualifications or recruitment and therefore failed to establish entitlement to redesignation or pay parity.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition was DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the petitioner remains in the post of Instructor and is not entitled, on the material before the Court at hearing, to be redesignated as Lecturer or to receive the Lecturer's scale of pay.
  • Precedential effect: the Court treated prior decisions that allowed parity as confined to their facts and approved the Division Bench decision in Radhey Shyam Bhatt rejecting parity for Instructors in the Department of Fine Arts. The opinion emphasizes that no general rule of automatic parity is established — entitlement depends on establishing similarity across multiple objective factors.
  • Government order(s): the Court recorded that a Government order dated October 17, 1998 was produced after hearing and not considered; the Court stated its judgment would not affect the Government order (the opinion also references a Government order dated October 17, 1988 in the same passage). The Court therefore limited its ruling to the materials before it and did not adjudicate the effect of the subsequently-produced government document.
  • No new general principle was declared; the decision applies the existing principles requiring claimants to establish parity in qualifications, recruitment and responsibilities rather than relying solely on similarity of tasks.

Note: This summary is prepared exclusively from the contents of the provided opinion and does not add information beyond the opinion's text.

    Ajay Kumar Jaitly v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Another

    Aloke Chakrabarti, J.:— The petitioner filed the present petition for issuance of mandamus to redesignate the post of Instructor in the Department of Fine Arts of Allahabad University to the post of Lecturer and to pay salary or Lecturer to the petitioner who presently is holding the post of Instructor.

    2. The facts stated in the writ petition relevant for the purpose, are that the petitioner was appointed as Instructor in the Department of Fine Arts of Allahabad University by order, dated January 19/20, 1987. He was appointed on permanent basis by order, dated 2 December, 1989. Such appointment, it has been stated, was upon successful selection by a selection committee considering several candidates including the petitioner. The petitioner is performing functions of Lecturer in the department concerned including teaching graduate as also postgraduate classes.

    3. It has been further stated in the writ petition that on considering representation made by the Instructors from time to time, the Executive Council of Allahabad University on March 19, 1974 passed a resolution that the post of Instructors should be redesignated as Lecturers and all the confirmed incumbents working against these posts be given Lecturer's grade. The State, Government did not take any action in the matter and, therefore, the said resolution could not be implemented. The Executive Council as well as Academic Council of University again resolved that the Instructors be given the scale of Lecturers and posts of Instructors may be redesignated as Lecturers. The said resolution, though was submitted before the State Government on February 7, 1981 and again on March 14, 1981 no action was taken by the State Government. The Instructors continued to agitate their claims and approaches were being made to the appropriate authorities.

    4. Contention has further been made that some posts of demonstrators, cartographers, Instructors in Physical Education Department, and Research Assistant in the University have been given designation as well as scale of pay of Lecturers. The present Instructors though were getting the same scale as of demonstrators, cartographers, etc, they are still being deprived. In such circumstances, the present writ petition has been filed for die relief already stated herein above.

    5. This writ petition, when was considered by a Division Bench, two sets of judgments were considered and the writ petition was referred to a Full Bench by order, dated July 30, 1997 The reason for the same was on contention of parties that one Division Bench in Civil Miscellaneous Writ Petition No. 5328 of 1992, Dr. Ashutosh Kumar Upadhyay v. Sampurnanand Sanskrit University, by judgment, dated May 22, 1992, allowed a similar writ petition issuing mandamus directing the concerned University to treat Instructor as Lecturer and following the same by judgment, dated November 4, 1992, Civil Miscellaneous Writ Petition No. 21709 of 1988, Pankaj Kumar v. University of Allahabad was allowed whereby research assistant in Allahabad University was granted pay parity with the Lecturer of the University. On the other hand, another Division Bench deciding Civil Miscellaneous Writ Petition No. 5327 of 1982, Radhev Shyam Bhatt v. State of Uttar Pradesh, [1996 A.L J. 1624], dismissed the same refusing the claim of the Instructors in the Department of Fine Arts for pay parity with the Lecturers.

    6. The petitioner filed an application for amendment of the writ petition which was allowed by order, dated March 4, 1998. The order of the State Government, dated March 15, 1982 was challenged.

    7. Counter-affidavit was filed on behalf of State of Uttar Pradesh as also by the University, rejoinder affidavit was also filed.

    8. Heard Sri RN. Singh, learned counsel for the petitioner, Sri Ashok Bhushan, learned counsel for the University and Sri Yatindra Singh, learned Additional Advocate-General representing the State respondents.

    9. Contention of the petitioner is that the only defence of the University to the claim of the petitioner is that the said claim cannot be allowed by the University authorities without prior approval of the State Government in view of S. 21(3) of the State Universities Act. It has been stated that the State Government never refused the claim and only because no decision was taken by the State Government, even the decision in favour of the petitioner taken by the University could not be implemented. The further contention of the petitioner is that other designation holders belonging to the same category of the petitioner, namely demonstrators, research assistant and cartographers having been already given the benefit, the claim of the petitioner cannot be kept withheld. It is contended further that the claim of the petitioner having been accepted by the Executive Council and Academic Council of the University, petitioner is entitled to relief before this Court. With regard to the judgment in the case of Radhey Shyam Bhatt (vide supra), it has been stated that the said case has not been decided correctly applying the correct legal principles and, therefore, has no binding effect. Reliance has been placed on the judgment in the case of Dr. Ashutosh Kumar Upadhyay (vide supra).

    10. The learned counsel for the University authorities relied on the contentions made in the counter-affidavit of the University and stated that process of appointment for Instructors is different from the process of appointment of the Lecturers and, therefore, no parity can be drawn between the two categories. Moreover in the year 1982, the State Government already rejected the proposal for benefits in favour of the Instructors on the ground of parity and, therefore, it cannot be contended that the proposal of the University having been not disposed of by the State Government, there stands a decision of the University.

    11. On behalf of the State respondents also, contention has been made that process of recruitment in the post of Lecturer and for the post of Instructor is different. It is also contended that classification on the basis of qualification or responsibility is permissible in law and in case of such difference in any of the said aspects, the principles of equal pay for equal work does not apply.

    12. Learned counsel for both the said respondents referred to case law in support of their contention. Specific reliance was placed to the findings in the case of Radhey Shyam Bhatt (vide supra), which was a case filed by Instructors in the Department of Fine Arts of Allahabad University and their claim for similar benefits having been already rejected and there being no material produced by the petitioners to contradict the findings therein, the present petitioner is not entitled to any relief before this Court.

    13. After considering the respective contentions of parties, it appears that in the case of Radhey Shyam Bhatt (vide supra), at the instance of Instructors of the same department of Allahabad University, same claim was refused by the Division Bench of this Court in a contested proceeding. Similar claim on the basis of the same Facts was rejected by giving detailed reasons and upon arriving at a specific finding and upon consideration of the law in this connection. On behalf of the petitioner, nothing has been shown that any of the findings arrived at by the Division Bench in the case of Radhey Shyam Bhatt (vide supra), is wrong and contrary to materials on record.

    14. The claim of the petitioner is required to be considered on facts involved upon application of principles of law in respect of equal pay for equal work. Admittedly, the petitioner was appointed as Instructor m the Department of Fine Arts and the posts of Lecturer and Instructors are different having different pay-scales.

    15. Qualifications of Lecturer as contained in Para. 11.01 of the First Statute, 1976 of Allahabad University are as follows:

    “(4) In the case of Department of Fine Arts in Faculty of Arts, the following shall be the minimum qualifications for the post of a Lecturer in the University, viz.:

    Either

    Master's degree or the equivalent degree or diploma recognised by the University in the relevant subject with at least 55 per cent marks or its equivalent grade and consistently good academic record.

    A traditional or professional artist with highly commendable professional achievement in the subject concerned”.

    The qualification required for the Instructor is as follows:

    “Instructor.— The applicant must possess a degree/diploma in painting from a recognized University/Institution”.

    A comparison of the aforesaid makes it clear that qualifications required for the said two categories of posts are substantially different.

    16. On the question of mode of recruitment, it appears that the Lecturers are appointed by selection committee as constituted under S. 31 of the Uttar Pradesh State Universities Act, consisting of two experts nominated by the Chancellor but the recommendation of selection committee has to be approved by the Executive Council.

    17. With regard to Instructors, it appears that appointment can be made by the Executive Council on such, terms and conditions as provided in Para. 10.04 of the First Statute. According to the provisions contained in Chap. X of the Ordinances, Instructors are appointed on the recommendation of selection committee consisting of Vice-Chancellor, Dean of Faculty and Head of Department. Therefore, the process of recruitment of the two categories is also substantially different.

    18. A distinction has been drawn between “teacher” and “teacher of University” with reference to S. 2(18) and S. 2(19) of Uttar Pradesh State Universities Act, 1973, in support of the contention that a teacher of University not only imparts instructions but also guides or conducts research whereas Instructor is employed for helping imparting instructions only and he does not guide or conduct research.

    19. On behalf of the petitioner, claim has been made relying on the judgment in the case of Dr. Ashutosh Kumar Upadhyay (vide supra), claiming similarity of cases of Instructors appointed in the Sampurnanand Sanskrit University at Varanasi and those appointed in Allahabad University. Claim has also been made drawing parity between the Instructor of Allahabad University and the research assistant of Allahabad University as decided in the case of Pankaj Kumar (vide supra). But on behalf of the petitioner, nothing has been shown in support of drawing such parity in respect of present Instructor of Allahabad University with either the research assistants in Allahabad University or Instructors of Sampurnanand Sanskrit University. In absence of these materials, no parity can be drawn as sought for by the petitioner and the judgment in the case of Dr. Ashutosh Kumar Upadhyay and Pankaj Kumar (vide supra), cannot be held applicable. Moreover the judgment in the case of Dr. Ashutosh Kumar Upadhyay shows clearly that the circumstances prevailing there were different and the law decided in those facts cannot be made applicable in the present proceeding.

    20. Law has been referred to on behalf of respondents as decided in various cases. Observation in the case of Secretary, Finance Department v. West Bengal Registration Service Association, [1992 (2) L.L.N 386], settles the general position and the relevant portion thereof is as follows, in Para 12, at page 394:

    “ . . It is well-settled that equation of posts and determination of pay-scales is the primary function of the executive and not the judiciary and, therefore, ordinarily Courts will not enter upon the task or job evaluation which is generally left to expert bodies like the Pay Commissions, etc. But that is not to say that the Court has no jurisdiction and the aggrieved employees have no remedy if they are unjustly treated by arbitrary State action or inaction …”

    21. As regards responsibility for showing the parity observation has been made in the case of State of Tamil Nadu v. M.R Alagappan [Civil Appeals Nos. 4684-4685 of 1994], decided on 18 April, 1997] (reported infra), as follows:

    “… .that person claiming parity in pay on the work must show that his qualification, duties and functions are similar to person with whom he claims parity”.

    This observation was made while referring to the case of Sita Devi v. State of Haryana, [1996 (2) L.L.N 476].

    22. With regard to the effect of difference of qualifications, in respect of two different categories, law has been explained by the Apex Court in the case of Chandigarh Administration v. Smt Anita Sood, [1995 Supp (3) SCC 613], and relevant portion thereof runs as follows:

    “The quality and standard of teaching by a Professor is bound to be of much higher standard than that of a lecturer. Keeping in view the qualitative difference of standard of teaching between the two teachers with different designations it cannot be claimed that they are entitled to the same pay-scales”.

    23. The requirement of law in respect of the present aspect was also considered by the Division Bench of this Court in the case of Dr. Bajrang Bahadur Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh, [1997 (3) A.W.C 1476], and the relevant portion thereof is quoted below:

    “12. From the conspectus of views taken in the aforementioned decided cases, the position is clear that to substantiate a claim of higher scale of pay/salary on the basis of the principle ‘equal pay for equal work’ the petitioner appellants will have to establish that they are equally placed in all respects with the person or persons whose scale of pay/salary they claim. They must allege and prove that the mode of recruitment, eligibility qualifications prescribed, the nature of duties/responsibilities discharged/shouldered, and the service rule if any applicable to the two posts are similar. They cannot succeed in the case merely by showing that they have been discharging same duties which are being discharged by persons holding the other class posts”.

    24. In the case of V. Markendeya v. State of Andhra Pradesh, [1989 (1) L.L.N 815], the Apex Court has observed that the classification made between the graduate supervisor and non-graduate supervisor is reasonable. Similarly, in the case of Shyam Babu Verma v. Union of India, [1994 (2) L.L.N 465]. It has been held that nature of work may be more or less same, but scale of pay may vary based on academic qualification or experience which justifies classification.

    25. Designation of a post and the scale of pay admissible for the same are matters for consideration by the employer. While taking a decision relating to these matters, several factors like eligibility qualifications for the post, nature of duty assigned for the post, the manner of recruitment to the post and the quality of work expected from the incumbent, etc., are to be taken into consideration. No general principle of universal application and no straight jacket formula can be laid down for determination of the questions. In case a dispute is raised relating to the matter, it has to be decided on the basis of the facts and circumstances emerging from the materials on record bearing in mind certain principles laid down by the Supreme Court and High Courts in their decisions. Tested on the above observations, we find that the decisions of this Court in the cases of Dr. Ashutosh Kumar Upadhyaya v. Sampurnanand Sanskrit University (vide supra), and Pankaj Kumar v. University of Allahabad (vide supra), must be taken to be confined to the facts of those cases. They should not be read as laying down a general principle of law applicable to all cases. It may be stated here that when a person holding a post approaches the Court claiming parity of salary/emoluments with another post, he has to establish that the post in question are similar in all respects. He is not entitled to succeed by merely showing that the nature of duty discharged by him is similar to the nature of duty discharged by the holder of the other post.

    26. Coming to the case of Radhey Shyam v. State of Uttar Pradesh, [1996 A.L.J 1624] (vide supra), we may state that the principles of law stated in the judgment and the findings recorded therein, in our considered view, are correct. The said judgment has our approval.

    27. The further contention that the Executive Council and the academic council held in favour of the petitioner also does not help the petitioner as the same was subject to approval by the State Government and admittedly the State Government refused approval. Such approval has been referred to in the case of Radhey Shyam Bhatt (vide supra), and from the judgment thereof, it is apparent that the said rejection order was available on record before the Division Bench concerned. Nothing has been shown on behalf of the petitioner justifying interference with the said decision of the State Government.

    28. After hearing of case was concluded, Sri R.N Singh, learned senior advocate appearing for the petitioner, filed an affidavit of the petitioner attaching thereto a Government order, dated October 17, 1998. On perusal of the Government order, it appears to us that the State has acceded to the demand of the Instructors working in State Universities and has decided to designate the post as Lecturer and grant me scale of pay of the Lecturer of the University to persons holding the post of Instructors. This document was not before us when the case was heard. We have not heard counsel for the parties on the document. As such this document cannot be taken into consideration at this stage. However, we make it clear that our decision based on the pleadings of the parties and the documents filed by them when the case was heard. Our judgment will not, in any way, affect the Government order, dated October 17, 1988.

    29. In view of the aforesaid legal position and in view of the findings that the qualification and mode of recruitment in the case of the Instructors and lecturers are different, the claim of the petitioner does not appear to substantiated. Therefore, the present writ petition is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ajay Kumar Jaitly v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Another
    (Dec 1, 1998)