Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of Judicial Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a P.C.S. officer appointed in 1985 (Lokesh Kumar), challenged an order dated 24.6.1997 that transferred him from the post of General Manager (Executive Director), Kichha Sugar Company (a subsidiary of U.P. State Sugar Corporation Ltd.), Udham Singh Nagar, to the post of Additional District Magistrate (Project), Kanpur.

Prior to the impugned order the petitioner had undergone several transfers in early 1997: from General Manager Sugar Mill, Bijnor/Rampur area postings (dates and sequence set out in the record) to various administrative posts and was finally posted at Kichha Sugar Company on 6.3.1997 at his request because of frequent transfers. After approximately three months on that post the impugned transfer was issued on 24.6.1997.

The petitioner alleged political interference, mala fide action and absence of any administrative exigency; he relied on a complaint by Sri Isam Singh (MLC) and recommendations by Sri Ilam (MLA), and on a note/endorsement by the Chief Minister dated 22.6.1997 (annexed to the petition). Respondents filed counter-affidavits asserting the transfer was in public interest, pointing to complaints by public representatives and to the Chief Minister’s communications that referenced complaints about the petitioner’s alleged unsatisfactory conduct.

Procedurally: the writ petition was filed on 11.7.1997 (affidavit sworn 10.7.1997). The High Court initially passed an interim order on 14.7.1997 restraining that no incumbent be posted in petitioner’s place; subsequent directions kept the post vacant and the matter was listed for further hearing. An application under Article 215 (contempt) was filed on 12.8.1997 alleging continued occupation of the post by respondent No.4 (Jai Prakash Sagar). Show-cause notices were issued, explanations accepted, and contempt notices were later discharged. The court ultimately considered the merits of the challenge to the transfer order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned transfer order dated 24.6.1997 was tainted by political interference and mala fide exercise of power.
  2. Whether the transfer was justified by administrative exigency or in the public interest, as claimed by the respondents.
  3. Whether there was any material on record demonstrating unsatisfactory work or conduct by the petitioner sufficient to justify the transfer.
  4. Whether respondents wilfully disobeyed interim court orders (contempt allegations) by continuing to post or allow another officer to function in the petitioner’s post.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The impugned transfer was made as a result of political interference and extraneous/political considerations rather than administrative exigency or public interest.
  • The complaint relied upon (by Sri Isam Singh, M.L.C., and endorsed by M.L.A.) was false, concocted and frivolous; no proper enquiry was undertaken before the Chief Minister directed transfer to a non-sensitive post.
  • The petitioner asserted meritorious work and no prior adverse record; the transfer after only about three months on the post was arbitrary and mala fide.
  • The petitioner did not initially disclose in his petition that he had handed over charge of the post on 28.6.1997 and that an interim order had been obtained — respondents alleged concealment of this fact when seeking interim relief.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Respondent No.3 (U.P. State Sugar Corporation / deponent Shiv Raj) contended that the transfer was effected by the competent authority in public interest and the order expressly recited that it was made in public interest.
  • Respondents relied on complaints from public representatives (MLC/MLA) and the Chief Minister’s endorsements; they submitted complaints must be given due importance and do not automatically amount to political interference.
  • Respondent No.3 also stated the petitioner’s period in the post was too short for proper assessment of performance, but nonetheless argued the complaints justified transfer pending review.
  • Respondent No.1 stated services of the petitioner were withdrawn from the Sugar Corporation on administrative grounds and public interest, and clarified procedural positions regarding respondent No.4’s posting.
  • Respondents alleged procedural irregularity and concealment by the petitioner in failing to disclose that he had handed over charge on 28.6.1997 and that respondent No.4 had assumed charge; this was relied upon to criticise the manner of filing and the interim relief obtained.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pradeep Kumar Agrawal v. Director, Local Bodies, U.P. IVth, Lucknow, 1994 (1) UPLBEC 189 Principle that transfers must be made only for administrative exigency or public interest and that transfers made in response to political letters/representations (without due basis) are objectionable. The court relied on the authority to support its conclusion that transfers motivated by political interference (and not administrative exigency or public interest) are liable to be set aside. The decision was cited as an illustrative authority condemning transfers prompted by extraneous political letters.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by reference to the chronological facts, the documentary material annexed to the writ petition, and the respondents' affidavits. Key elements of its analysis were:

  1. Document review: The court examined the complaint letter by Sri Isam Singh (MLC) and its endorsements (including a note by the Chief Minister dated 22.6.1997 and another communication dated 26.5.1997) which requested that the petitioner be transferred to a non-sensitive post and referred to alleged oppression of Dalits and poor work.
  2. Lack of supporting material: The court noted that no independent enquiry, material, or evidentiary basis was placed on record to substantiate the complaints against the petitioner. The court emphasised that the Chief Minister had apparently acted on the complaint without further inquiry.
  3. Respondents' own admissions: The counter-affidavit of respondent No.3 expressly stated that the petitioner’s tenure at the Sugar Company was too short for his work to be properly evaluated. That admission undercut the respondents’ contention that the transfer was justified by a legitimate assessment of performance.
  4. Political provenance of the action: The sequence of the documented correspondence — complaint by a public representative, endorsements, and the Chief Minister’s note — led the court to conclude that the impugned order was based on extraneous political considerations rather than administrative exigency or objective public interest.
  5. Procedural/disciplinary matters addressed separately: The court criticised the petitioner for failing to place before the court the fact that he had handed over charge on 28.6.1997 and that respondent No.4 had taken over. The court treated that omission as improper for a responsible government officer and admonished the petitioner to be more circumspect. Separately, the court considered contempt show-cause proceedings: after service was proved and explanations furnished, the court found no wilful disobedience and discharged the notices.
  6. Reliance on precedent and policy considerations: The court reiterated administrative values — transparency, objectivity and non-politicisation of service — and referred to prior authority (Pradeep Kumar Agrawal) condemning transfers driven by political letters and not by administrative need.
  7. Conclusion from the record: On balance, given the absence of material supporting the respondents’ claim of unsatisfactory performance and the contemporaneous documentary trail showing political representations and ministerial endorsements, the court held the impugned order to be a colourable exercise of power motivated by political considerations.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The court allowed the petition and set aside the impugned transfer order dated 24.6.1997.

Direct consequences:

  • The petitioner was ordered to function on the post of General Manager/Executive Director, Kichha Sugar Company.
  • The respondents were permitted, however, to pass any future orders in accordance with law (i.e., they retain the power to make lawful transfers subject to adherence to proper procedure and objective justification).

Broader implications: The opinion reinforces the established principle (as illustrated by the cited authority) that transfers effected primarily on political considerations, absent administrative exigency or supporting material, are susceptible to judicial interference. The judgment emphasises administrative transparency and discourages politicisation of transfers. The opinion does not itself purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying established principles to the facts of this case.

    Lokesh Kumar, P.C.S v. State Of U.P And Others

    S.C Verma, J.:— The order of transfer dated 24.6.1997, transferring the petitioner from the post of General Manager, (Executive Director), Kichha Sugar Company (A subsidiary of U.P State Sugar Corporation, Ltd.), Udham Singh Nagar to Additional District Magistrate (Project), Kanpur, has been challenged in the present writ petition mainly on the ground of political interference and absence of any administrative exigency as also on account of mala fide actions of the respondents No. 1 to 3.

    2. The petitioner is a P.C.S Officer appointed in the year 1985 and while posted as General Manager, Sugar Mill, Bllaspur, District Rampur, he was transferred on 17.1.1997 as Additional District Magistrate, Sambhal, District Moradabad. The petitioner was then transferred as Deputy Director (Administration), Mandi, Moradabad on 5.2.1997 The petitioner was again transferred and relieved of the charge on 7.2.1-997 and was placed in the waiting list to await further posting. The petitioner was transferred on 10.2.1997 on the post of Deputy Director, Consolidation, Azamgarh. On the request of the petitioner considering the frequent transfers, he was posted on 6.3.1997 to Kichha Sugar Company, Kichha District Udham Singh Nagar as General Manager (Executive Director). The petitioner after completing about three months on the said post has again been transferred by the impugned order dated 24.6.1997 on the complaint made by one Sri Isam Singh, Member of Legislative Council and on the recommendations made by one Sri Ilam Singh, Member of the Legislative Assembly. The petitioner has alleged that on the basis of false, concocted and frivolous complaint made by the said persons to the Hon ble Chief Minister. Sushri Mayawati, she had directed the Appointment Secretary to transfer the petitioner to a non-sensitive post. The note dated 22.6.1997 issued by the Chief Minister is on the letter dated 8.6.1997 of Sri Isam Singh, M.L.C, Saharanpur. A copy of the letter and the endorsement of the Chief Minister are contained In Annexure No. 2 to the writ petition. The petitioner has further alleged that the Impugned action is neither for any administrative exigency nor in the public interest rather it has been passed on extraneous considerations and for political considerations. The work and conduct of the petitioner is meritorious and there was no complaint or adverse record. In the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of respondent No. 3, it has been stated that the order dated 24.6.1997 has been passed by the Competent Authority In public interest. In the order itself, it has been recited that the Officer mentioned in the order is being transferred In public interest. It has also been stated that a perusal of the letter contained in Annexure No. 2 would make it evident that there were complaints against the work and conduct of the petitioner. In the letter written by the Hon'ble Chief Minister dated 26.5.1997 to the Hon'ble Minister, it has been stated that in view of the complaint of Sri Isam Singh, Member Legislative Council, in which he has complained about one Sri Rudra Pratap Singh, Manager, Nanauta Sugar Mills, Sri Nikhil Shukla, Manager. Sarsawan Sugar Mills and Sri Lokesh Kumar, General Manager, Kichha Sugar Company, Udham Singh Nagar, that their work is extremely bad and they have Committed Oppression on the Dalits and they should be immediately transferred from their posts. Thus, the work and conduct of the petitioner was not found satisfactory.

    3. It has also been stated by the respondents in the counter-affidavit that the deponent (Shiv Raj. Law Officer, U.P State Sugar Corporation Ltd., Lucknow) was advised to State that M.L As and M.L Cs. hold public office and complaints of such persons cannot be treated always as borne of political interference. The respondent No. 3 has also stated that time had not arisen and the stay of the petitioner In the Factory of the Corporation was so short that the work of the petitioner could not be evaluated properly. However, complaints from the public representatives have to be given due importance. The competent authority has transferred the petitioner in public interests.

    4. In the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of respondent No. 1, it has been stated that the services of the petitioner have been withdrawn from Sugar Corporation on administrative grounds and public interest. It was further stated that the Government had only placed the services of Sri J.P Sagar, respondent No. 4 at the disposal of Sugar Corporation and the Government has not posted Sri J.P Sagar as General Manager, Kichha Sugar Mills.

    5. Apart from the above averments in the counter-affidavit, there is no other material to establish any shortcoming or irregularity committed by the petitioner which was taken into account for taking the decision to transfer the petitioner after three months.

    6. The respondents have taken serious objection in the manner the writ petition was filed and the concealment of the facts made by the petitioner. The respondents have alleged that after the petitioner was transferred by order dated 24.6.1997, he was relieved of the charge on 28.6.1997 by the respondent No. 4 who joined as Executive Director. They have brought on record the charge-certificate in which the petitioner under his signature had handed over charge of the post General Manager/Executive Director, Kichha Sugar Mills in favour of respondent No. 4 on 28.6.1997 The petitioner without placing this fact on record filed the present writ petition on 11.7.1997 and without disclosing the correct and complete facts obtained interim order dated 14.7.1997 from the Hon'ble High Court.

    7. The writ petition challenging the order dated 24.6.1997 was presented before Hon'ble High Court on 11.7.1997 and the affidavit was sworn by the petitioner Lokesh Kumar on 10.7.1997 At the time when the petition was taken up for hearing on 14.7.1997, a copy of the writ petition was served on Sri P.P Sinha at 11.00 a.m In order to obtain the version of the respondents, the learned standing counsel was directed to file counter-affidavit by 28.7.1997 and in the meantime by order dated 14.7.1997 it was provided that no incumbent shall be posted in place of the petitioner. It was further provided that in case any officer has been posted and has already taken over charge prior to the date of passing of the order, the order shall not be operative on 28.7.1997, as no counter-affidavit it was filed and the learned standing counsel had prayed for two weeks further time and in view of the averments contained in the supplementay affidavit as also the letter dated 26.5.1997 of the Chief Minister, it was directed that the post of General Manager, Kichha Sugar Company should be kept vacant till further orders and the posting of the Officer be kept in abeyance. The case was thereafter directed to be listed on 12.8.1997

    8. By an application under Article 215 of the Constitution, filed on 12.8.1997, which was directed to be listed on 13.8.1997, it was brought to our notice that despite the order dated 28.7.1997 the respondent No. 4 Sri Jai Prakash Sagar, is still performing the duties on the post of General Manager.

    9. By our order dated 13.8.1997, we directed the respondent No. 2 Sri B.K Singh, respondent No. 3 Sri Devendra Chaudhary and respondent No. 4 Sri Jai Prakash Sagar to show-cause why action for contempt be not taken against them. The counter-affidavit on behalf of respondents was thereafter filed on 28.7.1997 and the explanation had also been furnished by the respondents No. 2 and 3 in compliance to the order dated 13.8.1997 requiring them to show-cause. On considering the explanation furnished by the respondents, we were satisfied that the order dated 28.7.1997 was served on them by registered post on 1.8.1997 and there was no wilful disobedience. We accordingly discharge the notices by our order dated 27.8.1997

    10. At the outset, we may indicate that the petitioner was bound to place correct and complete facts relating to his handing over of the charge of the post on 28.6.1997 He is a responsible Government Officer and was supposed to be more circumspect. We understand and appreciate his anxiety but in narrating his tale of woes, he should not have lost the sense of fairly detailing complete facts before the court. We expect him to be more discreet even in cases of acute diversity.

    11. In the above conspectus of facts, the validity of the impugned order dated 24.6.1997 has now to be considered. As regards the merit of the action of the respondents to transfer the petitioner, we are of the opinion that series of events and the material on record establish that the respondents in colourable exercise of their power on extraneous considerations, have passed the impugned order of transfer only for political reasons. In the letter written by Sri Isam Singh, M.L.C contained in the Annexure No. 2 to the writ petition, it has been stated that the petitioner is very close to Sri Mulayam Singh and Sri Azam Khan and in his prior posting at Rampur Sugar Mill he had exploited the Sugar Mill and he should be immediately transferred to some other place, Le., to a non-sensitive post. On this letter, there is an endorsement of recommendation by Sri Dam Singh, M.L.A, Nagal, Saharanpur. On this letter itself, there is a note addressed to the Secretary appointment, signed by the Chief Minister dated 22.6.1997 requiring immediate transfer of the petitioner to some non-sensitive post. There is another letter of the Chief Minister addressed to Hon'ble Minister dated 26.5.1997, in which a copy of the letter of Sri Isam Singh, M.L.C was enclosed and in which the work of the petitioner and few others have been stated to be bad. It was also stated that they have committed oppression on Dalits and as such they should be immediately transferred from their post.

    12. Relevant extract of the letter 1s quoted below:

    Hon'ble the Chief Minister, on the request of the Member Legislative Council, required that the petitioner be transferred from his post. Although in the counter-affidavit, it has been stated that the impugned action of transfer has been taken in public interest and on the subjective satisfaction of the appointing authority in view of the complaints received against the petitioner from responsible persons holding public office which has also been taken note of by Hon'ble the Chief Minister but no material whatsoever has been brought on record which may reflect the unsatisfactory work and conduct of the petitioner. On the other hand, the respondent No. 3 in the counter-affidavit has clearly stated that the tenure of the petitioner was too short for any assessment being made of his work on the post held by him and the same has not been evaluated so far. It is thus clear that the impugned action is based only on the complaint of Sri Isam Singh, M.L.C which has been taken cognizance by the Chief Minister without any further enquiry. It is surprising to note that in the letter of the Chief Minister dated 22.6.1997, it has been stated that the complaint has been made by Sri Isam Singh. M.L.C with regard to oppression committed by the petitioner on Dalits, yet no enquiry or complaint or material has been placed on record. In the letter of Sri Isam Singh, it has also been stated that the petitioner has association with Sri Mulayam Singh and Sri Azam Khan belonging to his group and as such he should be transferred.

    13. It is really unfortunate that the administrative actions are taken in such manner which has resulted in untold sufferings and financial expenditure on the administrative side. Transparency and objectivity reflecting the set norms and rules should be the criteria of administration and executive rather than whimsical labelling of the officers with the tags of any shade.

    14. Public interest is not abstract to be found in the Dictionaries but must be obvious and visible. Politicising services would be unproductive and detrimental against the interest of the country.

    15. On many occasions, judicial note has been taken against such actions and they have been deprecated and strongly condemned but it seems that the directions have not been properly understood. The learned counsel for the petitioner placed reliance on the numerous decisions of this Court in which the order of transfer passed on political interference without there being any administrative exigency or in the public interest have been set aside.

    16. It would suffice to refer to one of the decisions of the Division Bench in Pradeep Kumar Agrawal v. Director, Local Bodies, U.P IVth, Lucknow, 1994 (1) UPLBEC 189, in which it has been held:

    “It would be appropriate to observe here that in a democratic set up like ours, bureaucrats are expected to act and discharge their executive functions impartially and strictly in accordance with the Rules and Regulations. No doubt, as of right no Government servant can claim to be posted either on a particular station or post, therefore, the transfers are to be done only in administrative exigencies and in public interest, but in the instant case the letter written by the aforesaid M.P addressed to Minister for Urban Development bearing endorsement of the Officers of the State Government, indicated that instant transfer has neither been made in administrative exigency nor in public interest. It is not only a matter of surprise but highly objectionable that bureaucrats are dancing at the tunes of such letters ignoring the well settled norms meant for transfer.”

    17. In view of the above facts and circumstances of the case, we are satisfied, that the impugned action was taken by the respondents in colourable exercise of their power without there being any administrative exigency or public interest on the other hand mainly for political reasons.

    18. We allow the petition and set aside the impugned order dated 24.6.1997 The petitioner would function on the post of General Manager/Executive Director, Kichha Sugar Company, but it would be open to the respondents to pass orders in accordance with law.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Lokesh Kumar, P.C.S v. State Of U.P And Others
    (Sep 5, 1997)