Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 489-B and 489-C, I.P.C
  • Section 489-B and 489-C, I.P.C
  • Sections 489-B and 489-C
  • Sections 420/467, I.P.C
  • Section 489-C, I.P.C2.
  • Section 313, Cr. P.C
  • Section 489-B
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 489-B and 489-C, I.P.C
  • Section 489-B and 489-C, I.P.C
  • Sections 489-B and 489-C
  • Sections 420/467, I.P.C
  • Section 489-C, I.P.C2.
  • Section 313, Cr. P.C
  • Section 489-B
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal challenges the conviction and sentence dated 5-6-1980 by the I Additional Sessions Judge, Nainital, in Sessions Trial No. 293 of 1979. The accused-appellant purchased medicines and paid with a currency note which the shopkeeper Jagdish Kumar Agarwal (P.W.3) suspected to be counterfeit. He showed it to a neighbouring shop and another person (P.W.4) who also identified it as counterfeit. A crowd assembled and a constable (P.W.5) arrived and arrested the accused at the scene. An investigation followed; an expert (P.W.1) corroborated that the note was counterfeit — described as the upper half being part of a genuine Rs.50 note and the lower half a crudely drawn replica. Charge-sheet was submitted and charges under Sections 489-B and 489-C, I.P.C. were framed. The prosecution examined six witnesses including the expert, the informant, his brother (P.W.2), the constable and the investigating officer (P.W.6). In his Section 313 Cr.P.C. statement the accused admitted possession of the note but claimed innocence. The trial judge convicted the accused under Sections 489-B and 489-C, sentencing him to one year R.I. and a fine of Rs.200 for the offence under Section 489-B and one year R.I. for the offence under Section 489-C.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution proved that the accused had "knowledge" or "reason to believe" that the currency note was forged or counterfeit as required by Sections 489-B and 489-C, I.P.C.
  2. Whether mere possession of a counterfeit note (including a note made of two parts pasted together) is sufficient to infer knowledge or intention, or whether additional circumstances are required to establish guilt under Sections 489-B and 489-C.
  3. Whether the failure to put to the accused, in his Section 313 Cr.P.C. examination, a specific question about his knowledge of the forged character of the note constitutes an infirmity vitiating the conviction.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (as recorded)

  • It was submitted for the appellant that the learned trial Judge erred in finding that the accused had the requisite knowledge that the currency note was forged; the accused's conduct (remaining at the shop and not fleeing) indicated innocence rather than guilty knowledge.
  • The defence emphasized that P.W.3 (informant/shopkeeper) and his brother P.W.2 inspected the note and were in doubt about its genuineness, seeking confirmation from a third person (P.W.4). This showed suspicion rather than actual knowledge on the part of the accused.
  • Counsel relied on authorities (including Hamid Ali) to contend that suspicion or doubt is not sufficient to establish "reason to believe" under Sections 489-B and 489-C and that mere possession does not automatically shift the burden to the accused.
  • It was also submitted that no specific question was put to the accused in his Section 313 Cr.P.C. examination about his knowledge of the forged character of the note, and that omission was a vital flaw in the prosecution's case.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hamid Ali v. State, AIR 1961 Tripura 46 (1961 (2) Cri LJ 801) Held that under Sections 489-B and 489-C guilt is based on "knowledge" or "reason to believe" and that mere suspicion or doubt is not sufficient to fasten liability. Relied upon by the appellant and considered by the court to support the proposition that suspicion does not amount to reasonable cause to believe the note was forged.
M. Mammutti v. State of Karnataka, (1979) 4 SCC 723 : AIR 1979 SC 1705 (referred via 1980 SCC (Cri) 17) Held that presumption of knowledge from mere possession can be drawn only if the notes were apparently counterfeit. The court noted this authority to show that where counterfeit character is not plainly apparent, possession alone is insufficient to infer knowledge; it was applied to the facts where consultation by others showed ambiguity.
Madan Lal Sharma v. State, 1990 Cri LJ 215 Affirmed that the burden is on the prosecution to prove knowledge under Section 489-B and intention under Section 489-C; mere possession does not shift the burden to the accused. Quoted and relied upon to emphasize prosecution's burden and that knowledge/intent must be proved by circumstances leading irresistibly to that conclusion.
Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab, 1982 Cri LJ 32 Stated that prosecution must prove possession together with circumstances that clearly and irresistibly indicate intention to use forged notes on the public (e.g., prior palming off, possession of a large number of such notes). Invoked by the court to underline that absent such collateral circumstances (e.g., multiple notes or past conduct), guilt under Sections 489-B/C is not established.
Chatt Ram v. State of Haryana, (1980) 1 SCC 460 : AIR 1979 SC 1890 (1979 Cri LJ 1411) Held that mere possession or presentation of a forged instrument (lottery ticket in that case) does not necessarily show the possessor's knowledge of its forged character or participation in forging it. Applied to show that the accused's possession of a single forged note and presentation (or possession) did not by itself demonstrate knowledge or intent.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The appellate court reviewed the evidence and trial judge's findings. The trial judge had placed significance on a "special feature" of the note — that it was composed of two parts pasted together (upper half genuine, lower half a crude replica) — and held that this visible characteristic supported an inference that the accused knew the note was counterfeit.

The appellate court examined the prosecution evidence: P.W.3 and P.W.2 inspected the note and were doubtful about its genuineness, and they sought confirmation from P.W.4. The expert (P.W.1) described the note's composition, but the evidence showed that even the shopkeeper and his brother were uncertain and required confirmation. The court treated this as consistent with a skilful counterfeiting exercise that might not make the note’s forged character manifestly obvious to a layperson.

The court considered authorities holding (i) that knowledge or reason to believe is an essential ingredient of Sections 489-B and 489-C and (ii) that mere possession will only give rise to a presumption of knowledge where the counterfeit character is apparent. It noted that there was no evidence of collateral circumstances (such as previous similar incidents, multiple forged notes, or prior palming off) that would irresistibly indicate an intention to use the note as genuine.

The appellate court also scrutinized the trial judge's treatment of the accused's failure to flee. The trial judge had suggested that the accused's not running away did not prove innocence since a crowd may have prevented escape. The appellate court found that the crowd assembled only after P.W.3 had consulted others and that the accused had an opportunity to escape; therefore, his remaining at the shop was a material circumstance that the trial judge failed to appreciate adequately.

Crucially, the court observed that no question was put to the accused in his Section 313 Cr.P.C. examination specifically asking whether he knew the currency note was forged. Because knowledge (or having reason to believe) is the prime factor in establishing guilt under Sections 489-B and 489-C, the omission of such a question was a vital infirmity in the trial process.

Weighing these points, the appellate court concluded that the essential ingredient of knowledge or reason to believe, required under Sections 489-B and 489-C, was not established on the material before the trial court.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeal is allowed. The conviction and sentence passed by the learned Judge under Sections 489-B and 489-C, I.P.C. are set aside and the accused is ACQUITTED of the charges under Sections 489-B and 489-C, I.P.C.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The accused, who was on bail, has his bail bond discharged.
  • The accused need not surrender in connection with this case.

Broader implications: The court relied on existing authorities emphasizing that knowledge or reason to believe is essential under Sections 489-B and 489-C, and that mere possession will not suffice unless the counterfeit character is manifest or other corroborative circumstances demonstrate intent to use such notes. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond reaffirming these points.

Disposition: Appeal allowed.

    Mohd. Yasin v. State Of U.P Opposite Party.

    1. This appeal has been preferred against the conviction and sentence dated 5-6-1980 passed by learned I Additional Sessions Judge, Nainital in Sessions Trial No. 293 of 1979. The accused-appellant went to the medical store Of Jagdish Kumar Agarwal P.W 3 to purchase medicines. After purchasing one tube he made over one fifty rupees currency note (Ext. 1) to the shopkeeper. The said Jagdish Kumar suspected as regards the genuineness of the said note and he went to the neighbouring shop M/s. Tula Ram Raja Ram and showed it to one Ganeshji of that shop who also confirmed that it was a counterfeit note. Crowd assembled there and thereafter a constable arrived. The accused was found standing there and he wass arrested. A case under Sections 420/467, I.P.C was started and during investigation the case having been established, according to the prosecution, charge-sheet was submitted. Charge under Section 489-B and 489-C, I.P.C was framed. Accused pleaded not guilty and trial started. During trial the prosecution has examined six witnesses, out of which P.W 1 is the expert. He corroborated his report to the effect that it was a counterfeit note. The Upper half is a part of genuine currency note of Rs. 50/- denomination while lower half comprises of a crudely drawn replica of the complementary part of the said note. P.W 2 Virendra Kumar Agarwal is the brother of the informant, who has corroborated the prosecution story stating that his brother Jagdish Kumar Agarwal went to him and asked if the currency note which was with him was genuine. He was not sure and then he and Jagdish Kumar Agarwal went to the shop of Tula Ram Raja Ram. In cross-examination he has stated that after both the brothers inspected the note Jagdish Kumar Agarwal went to the shop of Raja Ram and when he also went there and at that time he found the accused standing in his shop. P.W 3 Jagdish Kumar has corroborated the story depicted in the first information report. P.W 4 Ganeshi Lal also corroborated the statement of P.W 2 and P.W 3 that they brought the note to him to verify whether it was genuine or not. P.W 5 is the Constable, who went to the place of the occurrence after seeing the crowd. He seized the currency note and took the accused to the police station. P.W 6 is the Investigating Officer. In his statement under Section 313, Cr. P.C the accused admitted the possession of the note but expressed innocence. After considering the evidence on record the learned Judge convicted that accused under Sections 489-B and 489-C and sentenced him to suffer, R.I for one year and a fine of Rs. 200/- for the offence under Section 489-B and one year for the offence under Section 489-C, I.P.C

    2. Sri Kamal Krishna appearing for the appellant has submitted that the learned Judge has erredi in holding that the accused appellant had knowledge tha the said currency note was forged… he has stated that the conduct of the accused shows that he was innocent and had no knowledge that, the said note was forged. In the first information report it was stated that he was arrested from the spot P.W 5 constable has also stated thathe took the accused to the police station after preparing recovery nieino pf the counter-feit note. P.W 3 Jagdish Kumar Agarwal has stated when was in doubt about the genuineness of the currency note and hewent to the contiguous shop of his brother P.W 2, who was a medical practitioner to yarify whether the, said currency note was genuine. He has also stated that when his brother expressed doubt he went tp the shop of M/s. Tula Ram Raja Ram to get confirmation. In cross-examination he has stated that during the period the accused was standing in the shop. Learned counsel has submitted that if the accused had any knowledge that the said; note was not genuine he would have tried to flee away from the spot. This very conduct of the accused shows that he was innocent.

    3. Learned counsel in this connection has referred the case of Hamid Ali v. State, AIR 1961 Tripura 46 : (1961 (2) Cri LJ 801) whereinit has been held that under Sections 489-B and 489-C guilt is fastened on the ground of ‘knowledge’ or ‘reasons to believe’. But suspicion of doubt is not sufficient for fastening the liability under those sections.

    4. Learned Judge has held that in view of special feature that the currency note which was made of two parts completely pasted together and which was visible it cannot be said that the accused had no knowledge that the said currency note was counterfeit one.

    5. From the evidence, of Jagdish Kumar Agarwal P.W 3, and Dr. Virendra Kumar P.W 2, it appears that they suspected about the genuineness of the said note after inspecting it and in order to get confirmation they consulted with P.W 4. In both sections, namely, Sections 489-B and 489-C I.P.C words “knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit note” have been cornmonly used. Referring that portion the learned counsel has submitted that in Hamid Ali's case (supra) it was held that in case of suspicion whether notes were genuine will not amount to “reasonable” cause to believe. In another decision reported in 1980 SCC (Cri) 17 : ((1979) 4 SCC 723 : AIR 1979 SC 1705)(M. Mammutti v. State Of Karnataka.), it was held that presumption of knowledge from mere possession can only be drawn if the notes were apparently counterfeit. In the instant case it was not so. After receiving the counterfeit note P.W 3 had suspicion. He went to P.W 2 for confirmation and to get further confirmation they visited the shop of P.W 4. From these facts it is apparent that the counterfeiting exercise was skilful that P.W 3 could not be sure of it and had to run to two persons to get confirmation.

    6. There are other circumstances top. Learned counsel has pointed out the conduct of the accused which, is most relevant to assertion if he had knowledge of it or not. Mere possession, of the counterfeit note is not punishable under the law. It must be conscipus possession. The accused must have possessed it knowingly that it was forged or counterfeit note. If the accused Appellate had knowledge of the same he would have tried to flee away from the place. But the evidence is that he was all along standing at the medical'store till he was apprehended by P.W 5-the constable. Reliance has been placed in the case of Madan Lal Sharma v. State, 1990 Cri LJ 215, wherein if has been held at page 216:

    “Under S. 489-B, I.P.C the burden is on the prosecution to prove that at the time when the accused was passing the note he knew thatit was a forged one. The mere possession of it by him does not shift the burden to the accusedto prove his innocent possession of the forged note. Similarly, under S. 489-C it is to be proved that the accused intended to use the forged or counterfeit currency note as genuine or it might be used as genuine. It is for the prosecution to prove the circumstances which would irresistibly lead to the conclusion that the accused had the intention to introduce surreptitiously the note on the public. Thus knowledge or reason to believe that the note was forged has to be proved to fix the liability under Ss. 489-B and 489-C.”

    7. In that case also one hundred rupee note was found from the possession of the accused. It was made of two parts neatly pasted together. Its lower part was genuine while the upper part was hand drawn replica of the 100 rupee note. But the Division Bench of Calcutta High Court did not consider it as a special feature, as the learned Judge did, to burden the accused with conscious possession.

    8. In the case of Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab, 1982 Cri LJ 32, wherein it was held at page 35:

    “The prosecution has not only to prove that the accused had possession of counterfeit note ensuring it or having reason to believe it as such but further to prove circumstances which lead clearly, indubitably and irresistibly to his/her intention to use the notes on the public. Such intention could be proved by a collateral circumstance that the accused had palmed off such notes before, or that he/she was in possession of such notes in such large number, that her possession for any other purpose was inexplicable.”

    9. It is an admitted fact that no such evidence is forthcoming that suchoccasion ever arose before where the accused was found in possession of such type of currency notes. It is also the prosecution case that he was found with a single note and therefore, there was no questions of having with any other similar notes in his possession.

    10. In the case of Chatt Ram v. State Of Haryana, (1980) 1 SCC 460 : AIR 1979 SC 1890 : (1979 Cri LJ 1411) certain forged lottery tickets were found from the possession of the accused. It was held at page 1416; of Cri LJ:

    “Even if it is assumed for the sake of argument that the number on Ex. P-3 had been forged, that by itself would not show that Chatt Ram, appellant forged it or participated in the forgery. Nor would be mere fact that Chatt Rain presented this ticket before the officers concerned and claimed Special Prize on its basis, necessarily stamp him with the knowledge or belief of its forged character.”

    11. So in this case it was held that the accused must have knowledge or belief about the forged character of the Lottery tickets which were found from his possession.

    12. The learned Judge has considered the circumstances about the arrest of the accused from the spot but has stated that the mere fact that the accused did not run away does not mean that he had no knowledge. It might be that large number of crowd assembled there and he could not get any opportunity to escape. The latter part of his finding is against the weight of evidence on record. The evidence is that the crowd assembled after P.W 3 visited the shop of P.W 4. It was done after he consulted his brother P.W 2 at his chamber. So it is not correct to say that the accused had no chance to escape. Moreover, he did not run away is certainly an important feature that should have been considered while judging whether the accused had knowledge about the counterfeit note. I do find that the learned Judge was unable to appreciate the said circumstance properly.

    13. Sri Kamal Krishna has also submitted that in cross-examination under Section 313, Cr. P.C no question was put to the accused if he had knowledge about the forged currency notes found from his possession. He has submitted that knowledge being prime factor in establishing the guilt of the accused under Sections 489-B and 489-C it should be put to him in his examination under Section 313, Cr. P.C and when not done learned Judge was not right in drawing conclusion that he had such knowledge. No doubt, the said question is vital one and should have been put to the accused and without it this case also suffers from the said infirmity.

    14. Considering the above circumstances I find that the essential ingredient of Sections 489-B and 489-C since missing it cannot be held to be sufficient to prove the charge. The appeal is, therefore, allowed. Conviction and sentence passed by the learned Judge are hereby set aside. The accused is acquitted to the charge under Sections 489-B and 489-C, I.P.C He is on bail. His bail bond is discharged. He need not surrender in connection with this case.

    15. Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mohd. Yasin v. State Of U.P Opposite Party.
    (Jan 17, 1997)