AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Common Judgment by S.R. Misra, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

These writ petitions raise common questions of fact and law and have been disposed of by a single, common judgment. The petitioners in all matters are the Zila Contractors Workers Union, Sonbhadra (with Writ Petition No. 29990 of 1991 treated as the leading case).

Annexure 1 to the writ petitions lists 140 workers who are said to be members of the Union and to have been working with Respondent No. 1 (U.P. State Electricity Board) in the "Marry Go Round and Track Hopper Workshops and Maintenance Department" performing maintenance of diesel engines, railway lines, coal wagons and related works. The Union seeks a writ of mandamus directing respondents not to discontinue or deny duty to these workers on change of contractors and seeks regularisation/permanency and related reliefs.

Procedurally, counter and rejoinder affidavits have been filed. With consent, the writ petitions were finally disposed of at the admission stage under the High Court Rules. Some members of the Union had already approached a labour forum (Labour Court), and the Union registered a grievance before the Deputy Labour Commissioner (Pipri) as G.B. Case No. 19 of 1991; another dispute was raised before the Labour Commissioner, Kanpur, under Rule 25(2)(v)(a)(b).

The respondents include the U.P. State Electricity Board, a State corporation responsible for generation and supply of electricity (Annapara unit capacity noted as 630 MW per day). The petitions invoke the Contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970 and its Rules, and also refer to the Trade Unions Act, 1926.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the persons named in Annexure 1 are contract labour (employed by contractors) or are in fact workmen of the principal employer (U.P. State Electricity Board) entitled to regularisation/ permanency and attendant benefits.
  2. Whether the work performed by those persons is of an intermittent or casual nature (excluded by Section 1(5) of the Contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970) or whether the work is continuous/essential and therefore not amenable to engagement as contract labour.
  3. Whether licences under the Contract Labour Act are valid when used to engage labour for work that is continuous/permanent in nature and whether such licensing and contractor-renaming practices constitute unfair labour practice intended to deny regularisation.
  4. Whether the High Court should exercise jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution in the face of an alternative remedy via the labour/industrial forums (given that industrial law is a self-contained code and disputed questions of fact may be determined by the industrial tribunal).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners (Union and its members) contend that the work they perform (supply of coal from colliery, maintenance of railway lines, diesel engines, wagons, Marry Go Round and Track Hopper systems) is continuous, essential and integral to power generation and is not intermittent or casual.
  • They assert that engagement of such workers through contractors, issuance of licences and year-to-year change of contractors is being used to deny regularisation/permanency and to reduce pay and other benefits (allegation of unfair labour practice and victimisation).
  • The Union seeks a writ of mandamus restraining respondents from discontinuing or denying work to the listed workers on account of change of contractors and seeks regularisation/other reliefs.
  • The petitioners argued that certain case law relied upon by respondents (including Dena Nath v. National Fertilizers Ltd., 1992 FLR 39) overlooked Section 1(5) of the Contract Labour Act and therefore would not apply to the facts of the present case.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents denied that the petitioners perform permanent jobs and stated that contractors, not the principal employer, engage the labourers for specified periods.
  • They asserted that the principal employer's role is limited, except in circumstances where contractors fail to pay wages, in which event the Principal may be liable under Section 21 of the Contract Labour Act to step in.
  • The respondents maintained that the work is of casual nature and not continuous or integral to generation of electricity as alleged by the petitioners, and that contract labourers do not perform the same work as regular employees of the principal employer.
  • They also contested the Union's status and the authority of the deponent (alleging the Union was not registered and that Dwarika Singh was not duly elected as General Secretary).
  • The respondents stated that wages are fixed under the Minimum Wages Act read with Rule 25 of the Rules, and the dispute has been raised before labour authorities under the Rules.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
(1985) 1 SCC 630 : AIR 1985 SC 409 The opinion records that the parties cited this authority; the specific principle relied upon in argument is not detailed in the judgment. The court noted the case was placed before it and considered it, but refrained from expressing any opinion on its applicability because the core issues were disputed questions of fact suitable for labour/industrial forum determination.
1989 FIR 50 Cited by the parties; the judgment does not specify the precise rule or holding invoked from this citation. The court acknowledged consideration of this citation but did not apply or decide on its merits for the same reason of factual dispute and availability of alternative remedy.
1991 FIR 63 Cited by the parties; the judgment does not specify the exact principle drawn from it. The court recorded that it considered this authority but declined to express an opinion on its applicability, leaving factual questions to the industrial forum.
1992 FLR 39 (including Dena Nath v. National Fertilizers Ltd.) Parties cited this decision as directly on point; the petitioners contended it overlooked Section 1(5) of the Contract Labour Act. The court noted the citation (including Dena Nath) and the petitioners' objection, but expressly refrained from deciding the point and left such issues to the Labour Court/industrial forum.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded on the following lines (limited to matters expressly stated in the opinion):

  1. Commonality and factual disputes: The Court observed that common questions of fact and law are involved across the writ petitions and that the core disputed questions (whether persons are employees of the principal employer or contractors; whether their work is continuous or casual) are factual in nature.
  2. Availability of alternative remedy: Emphasising that the industrial laws (labour laws) constitute a self-contained code, the Court held that the petitioners have an adequate and efficacious alternative remedy before labour/industrial tribunals which are constituted to examine such factual and evidence-intensive disputes. The Court noted that the existence of an alternative remedy under industrial law normally weighs against invoking extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 where factual disputes are involved.
  3. Precedential material: The Court heard and considered authorities cited by the parties (including the cases listed in the table). However, without expressing any opinion on the merits of those authorities or on whether they apply to the present facts, the Court concluded that those issues should be determined by the labour forum in the first instance.
  4. Practical considerations: The Court observed the practical difficulty of adjudicating the matter under Article 226 given the number of workers (a few hundred) engaged in diverse activities and capacities, and the multifarious nature of their work—some identical to regular employees and some not—making a fact-specific inquiry necessary which better suits the industrial forum.
  5. Remedial availability under labour law: The Court pointed out that statutory remedies already exist (for example, remedies before the Chief Labour Commissioner for breaches by a contractor) and that such mechanisms should be availed of and are appropriate for resolution of the dispute.
  6. Declination to decide merits: Given the above, the Court declined to decide on the underlying factual claims (including the applicability of Section 1(5) of the Contract Labour Act and whether the contested authorities are binding) and left those matters to the labour court/industrial tribunal.

The Court explicitly stated that any observations in its judgment would not affect the merits of the case before the appropriate forum or prejudice the rights of any party.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petitions were dismissed. The Court's core ruling was that the petitions fail on the ground of availability of an alternative efficacious remedy before labour/industrial authorities; accordingly, the writ jurisdiction under Article 226 should not be invoked in the present factual context.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petitioners are directed to pursue their grievances before the appropriate labour/industrial forum (Labour Court/Industrial Court) which has the jurisdiction to examine disputed questions of fact and to receive evidence. The Court noted that some members had already initiated proceedings in the labour court, and that forum is the appropriate place for the contested factual inquiries.
  • Procedural direction to the State Government: The Court expressed that if the State Government is approached by concerned workmen or any registered Union (if permissible under law), the State Government should refer the matter to the appropriate authority within two months from receipt of such representation.
  • Interim orders: Any stay order that may have been in place stands vacated, as recorded by the Court.
  • On precedent: The Court refrained from laying down any new principle of law in the contested factual areas and expressly avoided pronouncing on the applicability of authorities cited; it recorded that its observations would not affect the merits of the case. Thus, no new binding precedent was announced on the central factual/legal issues; those remain to be decided by the industrial forum.

Disposition

DISMISSED. The writ petitions are dismissed on the ground of the availability of an alternative efficacious remedy before the authorities constituted under industrial law. Stay, if any, is vacated.

Note: This summary has been prepared strictly from the contents of the provided judgment and does not add or infer facts or legal conclusions beyond those expressly contained in the opinion.

    Zila Contractors Workers Union Sonbhadra v. General Manager, Annapara Tapiya Pariyojna-A

    S.R Misra, J.:— As common questions of fact and law are involved in these writ petitions, they are being disposed of by this common judgment.

    2. In all these writ petitions,. Zila Contractors Workers Union Son-bhadra are the petitioners and a prayer for a writ of mandamus has been made for commanding the respondents not to discontinue or deny duly to the workers, shown in Annexute 1 to the writ petitions, on the change of Contractors Writ Petition no 29990 of 1991 is being treated as the leading case.

    3. Counter and rejoinder affidavits have been filed and with the consent of the learned counsel for the parties, the writ petitions are being finally disposed of at the admission stage in accordance with the High Court Rules. The brief facts are that the petitioner is an Union of workers registered under the Trade Unions Act, 1926 (however, these are the facts of writ petition no. 29990/1991, but as already stated, the facts are common in all the petitions). Annexure 1 contains names of 140 workers, who are members of the Union and have been working with the respondent no. 1 in Marry Go Round and Track Hopper Workshops and Maintenance Department. They do the work of maintenance of engines, railway lines and coal wagons etc., U.P State Electricity Board is a corporation of Govt-of U.P established for generation and supply of electricity. Respondent no. 1 generates electricity and the capacity of its Annapara unit is 630 M.W per day. Diesel enginees, wagons and railway line for bringing coal from Colliery, are maintained and repaired by the petitioners in the workship.

    4. The parliament enacted the Contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970 to regulate the employment of contract labour in certain establishments. It also provides for matters connected with abolition of employment. It applies to every establishment in which 20 or more workers are employed on any day of the preceding 12 months as contract labour.

    5. Section 1(5) of the aforesaid Act is relevant which provides that the Act shall not apply to establishments in which work only of intermittent nature or casual nature is performed. The explanation to section 1(5) provides that work performed by an establishment shall not be deemed to be of an intermittent nature if it was performed for more than 120 days in the preceding 12 months or if it is of a seasonal character and is performed for more than 60 days in a year.

    6. The petitioners further allege that the work which they perform, such as supply of coal from colliary to the project, maintancnce of railway line, diesel engines wagons Marry Go Round and Track Hopper System, is continuous in nature and the work goes on round the clock throughout the year. It Is not of intermittent or casual nature but is continuous and essential in its nature. It is integral part of generation of electricity.

    7. The petitioners further allege that the contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Rules, 1976 framed by the U.P Government also applies to the establishments of U.P State Electricity Board where contract labour is employed. The contract labour is mostly employed at the projects where the work of setting up of power stations is being done. The work on these projects is being done both by the department as well as by the employees of the contractors Section 7 of the Act provides for registration of covered establishments with the officers appointed by the State Government in exercise of powers conferred under section 6 of the Act. The State Government has already notified such officers vide notification dated 3-11-1977. As per provisions of sections 11 and 12 of the Act, no contractor to whom the Act, applies, shall undertake or execute any work through contract labour except under and in accordance with the licence issued in that behalf by the Licensing Officer. Sections 10 to 21 of the Act provide for facilities which are to be provided to the contract labour by the contractors. Sections 22 to 27 of the Act provide for penalties for violation of the provisions of the Act by various parties. In paragraph 12 of the writ petition, it has been alleged that no licence can be issued by the competent authority under the Contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970 for work which is of contlnuoua and permanent nature bat the officers of the respondent nos. 1 to 3, in collusion with respondent nos. 4 and 3, Issue licence for employment of contract labours with a view to victimise the workers and to Indulge in unfair labour practice to deny the workman of their rightful does and regularisation/pemsanency of service. They either change the contractor or get the work done by the workers of some contractor after changing the name of contractor from year to year. The modus operand! is that name of the contractor of earlier year is changed in the next year and workers are deprived of the benefits of a regular employee and equal pay for equal work and other allowances etc. No contract labour can be engaged on work of regular nature and the members of the petitioner's Union have been working against the permanent and regular Jobs.

    8. The petitioner allege that the Corporation being State Government Undertaking, would be model employer and it should treat its workmen accordingly but with a view to give lesser pay and to deprive the workmen from other facilities, and to victimise them it has been iadulging in unfair labour practice. On the demand being raised by the petitloner-Union, the officers of the respondent no. I became annoyed and decided to discontinue the services of members of the petitioner Union w.e.f 14-10-1991. The petitioner Union also raised demand for regularising the services of members before the Deputy Labour Commissioner, Piprl which has been registered as G.B Case No. 19 of 1991. Various other pleas have been taken in the writ petitions and it is not necessary to narrate them at this stage.

    9. On behalf of the respondents, it has been denied that the petitioners are performing permanent job. According to them, it is the Contractors who engage labourers for specified period and the respondents have no say in the matter of their employment. In case the contractors do not pay them the wages then alone the respondents come into play as it is their liability/responsibility to pay the wages under section 21 of the Act. The wages so have been fixed under the Minimum Wages Act read with Rule 25 of the Rules. In para 11 of the counter affidavit, it has been asserted that the petitioner Union is not a registered one and Dwarika Singh, who has filed the affidavit and writ petition is not the General Secretary, duly elected, of the Union the respondents have denied the averments made in the writ petition and they have specifically denied that the persons mentioned in Annexure 1 are working with the answering respondents. It has also been denied that the work discharged by the persons mentioned in Annexure 1 is of continuous nature. On the other hand, the work is of casual nature. It has also been denied that the work is integral part of generation of electricity. In para 23 of the Counter Affidavit, it has been asserted that contract labourers are not the workers of principal empleyer nor they are performing the same work which regular workers do perform. The petitioner Union has also raised dispute before Labour Commissioner Kanpur under Rule 25(2)(v)(a)(b) of the Rules in this regard.

    10. I have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and have also gone through the record of the case and considered the case laws cited by them; such as, (1985) 1 SCC 630 : AIR 1985 SC 409, 1989 FIR 50, 1991 FIR 63, and 1992 FLR 39 etc. However, without expressing any opinion on merits of the case and on the points as to whether the petitioners are entitled to the reliefs claimed and whether the contention of the respondents that they are not the employees of Principal but of contractors, and, whether the duty being discharged by them is of casual or permanent nature, I am of the view that the aforesaid points can only be gone into in a regular forum and since they are disputed questions of fact, the petitioner Union can approach the labour or the Industrial court under the Industrial law, which Is self contained code. Thus, the petitioner Union has an adequate alternative remedy where all these questions can be looked into.

    11. It is true that alternative remedy of an Industrial dispute is not a complete bar to the exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India but at the same time, the same is dependent upon the facts and circumstances of each Case, The industrial laws are self contained laws and It is created to afford a pregmetic and comprehensive remedy to the litigants for settlement of their disputes where questions of facts can be gone into and evidence may be adduced St is desirable that such Tribunals, which are self contained, should be allowed to strike the roots and in the normal circumstances, the moment, the question of fact is involved, exercise of jutisdiction under Article 226 may not be invoked on account of alternative appropriate remedy.

    12. It is admitted to the learned counsel for the petitioner that out of the three writ petitions, members of Union of one of the Unions have already approached the labour court and the matter is pending consideration. However, learned counsel for the petitioner urged that the case laws, which are directly on the point, including the decision of Hon'ble the Supreme Court in Dena Nath v. National Fertilizers Ltd., 1992 FLR 39, as well as a decision of this Hon'ble Court, clearly overlooked section 1(S) of the Act and, thus, these decisions will have no application to the facts of the present case.

    13. Since I am taking the view that the petitioner Union has an alternative remedy of approaching the Industrial Court where questions of fact can also be examined, I refrain myself from expressing any opinion on this aspect of the case as well and I leave St to the Labour Court to consider the same.

    14. Thus, it is clear from the allegations in the writ petition and counter allegations in the Counter affidavit that it is not possible for this court, under Art. 226, to embark into an enquiry where it concerns a few hundred workers working in various capacities, engaged in multifarious activities, doing or not doing identical work to that of the employees of U.P State Electricity Board. The question as to whether they should be treated workmen employed by U.P State Electricity Board and not by the Contractors is a question of fact and there is self contained forum crested in other statutes designed for such like questions and therefore, I am not inclined to interfere under Article 226 of the Constitution on account of availability of alternative remedy.

    15. From a perusal of the Act, St is quite clear that where a breach is committed by a Contractor, the remedy is already provided for equal remuneration and other reliefs, where the Chief Labour Commissioner is the appropriate authority. It is not necessary to deal this matter at greater length in view of what has been stated above that all these questions are those of facts and they are to be considered by an authority having exclusive jurisdiction to go into these aspects of the matter. On receipt of the case, the competent court will record a finding in the light of the pleadings of the parties and any observation made in this judgment will not affect the merit of the case and will not prejudice the right of any party. Accordingly the writ petitions fail and they are dismissed on the ground of alternative efficacious remedy of approaching the authority constituted under the Industrial Law. It appears to be desireable that if the State Government is approached by concerned workmen or any other registered Union, if permissible under the law, the State Government will refer the matter to the appropriate authority within a period of two months from the receipt of such prayer. Stay order, if any, stands vacated.

    16. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Zila Contractors Workers Union Sonbhadra v. General Manager, Annapara Tapiya Pariyojna-A
    (Feb 16, 1993)