Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980 (hereinafter referred
  • S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black-Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980,
  • S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black-Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1983,
  • S. 18-G and S. 25 of the Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 1951 (65 of 1951).
  • S. 5 of the Essential Commodities Act (hereinafter referred
  • ESSENTIAL COMMODITIES ACT 1955
  • provisions of the Central Cement Control Order
  • provisions of the Cement Control Order 1967
  • ESSENTIAL COMMODITIES ACT 1955
  • S. 3/7 of the Essential Commodities Act.
  • provisions of U.P Cement Control Order
  • S. 3 of the Essential Commodities Act,
  • S. 5 of the Essential Commodities Act,
  • S. 3/7 Essential Commodities Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980 (hereinafter referred
  • S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black-Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980,
  • S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black-Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1983,
  • S. 18-G and S. 25 of the Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 1951 (65 of 1951).
  • S. 5 of the Essential Commodities Act (hereinafter referred
  • ESSENTIAL COMMODITIES ACT 1955
  • provisions of the Central Cement Control Order
  • provisions of the Cement Control Order 1967
  • ESSENTIAL COMMODITIES ACT 1955
  • S. 3/7 of the Essential Commodities Act.
  • provisions of U.P Cement Control Order
  • S. 3 of the Essential Commodities Act,
  • S. 5 of the Essential Commodities Act,
  • S. 3/7 Essential Commodities Act.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Om Prakash Agarwal (the detenu), a retail dealer in non-levy cement licensed under the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973, was found by an inspection party on 4-7-1984 to be carrying on business at a premises other than that specified in his licence and committing several irregularities including improper maintenance of cash memos, stock registers, and absence of required display boards. Upon being asked for his licence, he fled without producing it. A report was lodged against him under S. 3/7 of the Essential Commodities Act. The detenu surrendered in court on 26-7-1984, but before securing bail, a detention order under S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980, was passed by the District Magistrate, Agra on 2-8-1984. The detenu's representation against detention was ultimately rejected by the Governor of Uttar Pradesh on 27-8-1984.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the detenu's continued detention under S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980, is valid given the nature of his business and the applicable legal framework.
  2. Whether the provisions of the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973, apply to the sale of non-levy cement after the Central Government's 1982 Notification partially decontrolled cement.
  3. Whether the State Government can enforce control over non-levy cement sales inconsistent with the Central Government's Cement Control Order, 1967 as amended.

Arguments of the Parties

Detenu's Arguments

  • The provisions of the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 and the U.P Essential Commodities (Display of Prices and Stock and Control of Supply and Distribution) Order, 1977 are not applicable to non-levy cement sales after 28-2-1982.
  • According to the 1982 Notification by the Central Government, 33.4% of cement production was decontrolled as non-levy cement, exempting it from regulatory provisions including the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973.
  • The State Government's imposition of restrictions on non-levy cement sales is inconsistent with and overridden by the Central Government's amended Cement Control Order, 1967.
  • No licence is required for sale of non-levy cement post-1982 Notification, and thus the detenu's actions do not amount to acting prejudicially to the maintenance of supplies of an essential commodity.
  • The factual allegations regarding irregularities at his shop are disputed but these are to be resolved in the criminal trial and are not determinative for this detention petition.

State's Arguments

  • The U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 remains applicable to cement sales in the State, including non-levy cement, as it was not amended to reflect the Central Government's 1982 Notification.
  • The control imposed by the State Order continues despite the Central Government's partial decontrol, and the detenu's violations justify detention under the Essential Commodities Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Munna Lal Agarwal v. District Magistrate, Aligarh (1984 EFR 188; 1984 All LJ 753) Definition and scope of "acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of supplies of commodities essential to the community" under S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black-Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980. The Court relied on this precedent to clarify that detention orders under S. 3(1) can only be passed when a person commits or instigates an offence punishable under the Essential Commodities Act or deals in an essential commodity with a view to making undue profit, thus framing the limits of lawful detention.
Shyam Sunder Prasad Bhadani v. State of Bihar (1984 E.F.R 200) Effect of Central Government's partial decontrol of cement and consequent invalidity of State controls inconsistent with such decontrol. The Court noted the distinction that Bihar had amended its Cement Control Order to align with the Central Government's Notification, unlike U.P. This precedent was used to illustrate the principle that State orders inconsistent with Central decontrol are impermissible but with the caveat of factual differences.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by interpreting S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980, emphasizing that detention orders under this section require that the person be acting prejudicially to the maintenance of supplies by either committing an offence under the Essential Commodities Act or dealing in an essential commodity to make undue profit. The Court examined the nature of the detenu’s business, focusing on the distinction between "levy" and "non-levy" cement introduced by the Central Government's 1982 Notification which partially decontrolled cement by exempting non-levy cement from regulatory control.

The Court noted that the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973, which regulated cement sales in the State, had not been amended to reflect the Central Government's 1982 Notification. It analyzed the legal effect of this discrepancy, referencing the constitutional principle under Article 254 that Central laws prevail over inconsistent State laws.

While the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 was not inconsistent with the Central Government's Essential Commodities Act itself, it was inconsistent with the amended Cement Control Order, 1967 as amended by the 1982 Notification. This inconsistency rendered the State Order inoperative to the extent it sought to control non-levy cement. The Court observed that the State Government was aware of this legal position and had directed a moratorium on prosecutions against non-levy cement dealers pending clarification.

Given this legal framework, the Court concluded that the detenu’s detention under S. 3(1) could not be sustained because his dealings were in non-levy cement, which was not subject to control under the relevant Central Government order and thus not an essential commodity under the terms of the Essential Commodities Act for the purposes of detention.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the petition and ordered the detenu's release forthwith if not required in connection with any other case.

The direct effect of this decision is that detention under S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980, cannot be sustained against persons dealing in non-levy cement after the Central Government's 1982 Notification, where the State order regulating such sales is inconsistent with the Central order. No broader precedent beyond the parties is explicitly stated, but the ruling clarifies the supremacy of Central Government orders over inconsistent State controls in this context.

    Om Prakash Agarwal v. State Of U.P And Others

    A.S Srivastava, J.:— By this petition, under Art. 226 of the Constitution of India, Om Prakash Agarwal (hereinafter referred to as the detenu) questions the validity of his continued detention by an order dated 2-8-1984 of the District Magistrate, Agra, passed under S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980 (hereinafter referred to as the Act).

    2. The detenu, a resident of 4/108, Kutchery Ghat, Agra and a retail dealer in non-levy cement, is carrying on his business in premises No. 37/105, Nagla Padi, Saran Nagar, Agra, under a licence granted to him under the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 for carrying on this business at 86/6, New Agra. It was discovered in an inspection of the said two premises made by raiding party consisting of the Additional District Magistrate (Civil Supplies), District Supply Officer, Senior Marketing Inspector and two public witnesses. During the inspection it was also found that the detenu was not only carrying on his business at a premises other than the place mentioned in his licence but was committing several irregularities. For example, 39 original cash memos purported to have been issued to the purchasers and only one counter-foil were found in the shop. They were all loose. None of the 39 cash memos contained the names and addresses of the purchasers to whom they related. No stock register or sale register was available. Instead a rough copy was found in which stock of cement entered on that date was 890 bags. On physical verification the actual stock was 923 bags i.e 33 bags in excess of the stock. No Rate and Stock board was found displayed. The detenu when asked to produce his licence, he slipped away from the shop without producing it. Thus he was found carrying on his business by contravening the provisions of U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 and U.P Essential Commodities (Display of Prices and Stock and Control of Supply and Distribution) Order, 1977. Consequently the Senior Inspector of District Supply Office lodged a report on the same date with the Police for initiating proceedings against the detenu under S. 3/7 of the Essential Commodities Act. On 26-7-1964 the detenu surrendered in Court and before he could secure his release on the bail, the impugned order was passed by the District Magistrate, Agra, on 2-8-1984. On 3-8-1984, this order was served on the detenu also in jail. On 14-8-1984 a representation was made by the detenu to the State Govt. which was forwarded by the Superintendent, District Jail, to the district Magistrate where it was received on the same day at 8.45 P.M 15-8-1984 being a public holiday due to the Independence Day, this representation along with the comments of the District Magistrate was sent to the State Govt. on 16-8-1984. A copy of the representation was also sent to the Advisory Board (Detention) Lucknow, where it was received on 17-8-1984. The representation of the detenu was ultimately rejected by the Governor of Uttar Pradesh on 27-8-1984 which was communicated to the detenu on 1-9-1984.

    3. The grounds on which the impugned order was passed by the District Magistrate, as specified in the order, are; that on 4-7-1984 the detenu was found carrying on business at premises other than the one permitted by his licence; that the inspection of his shop made on 4-7-1984 by a raiding party further revealed that no stock or sale register was maintained by him; that no stock board and rate board were displayed at his shop; that no proper cash memos were issued to the purchasers in respect of sales; that the stock of cement at the shop on 4-7-1984 was found to be in excess i.e even the rough stock book found at the shop was not correctly maintained. The detenu was, therefore, carrying his business in violation of the provisions of the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 and the U.P Essential Commodities (Display of Prices and Stock and Control of Supply and Distribution) Order, 1977 not only punishable under S. 3/7 of the Essential Commodities Act but also acting in a manner prejudicial to the maintenance of supplies of cement, a commodity essential to the community.

    4. The main ground on which the detenu has attacked his detention is that the provisions of U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 and U.P Essential Commodities (Display of Prices and Stock and Control of Supply and Distribution) Order, 1977 are not applicable to the sale of non-levy cement in the State. According to him, non-levy cement ceased to be the controlled commodity after 28-2-1982 i.e after the date on which Cement Control Order 1967 of the Central Govt. was amended by the Central Govt. by issuing a Notification No. S.O 105E dated 28-2-1982 (hereinafter referred to as 1982 Notification). By this Notification the Central Govt. introduced partial decontrol on cement with effect from 28-2-1982 under which 33.4 per cent of cement produced by a cement factory was decontrolled for free sale in the market as non-levy cement. Sale of non-levy cement was thus exempted from the Regulatory provisions of not only Central Cement Control Order, 1967 but also from U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 and the U.P Essential Commodities (Display of Prices and Stock, and Control of Supply and Distribution) Order 1977. The provisions of U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 imposing conditions on sale and distribution of non-levy cement by the State Govt. which are now inconsistent with the provisions of Cement Control Order, 1967 as amended by the 1982 Notification are illegal and inoperative. Therefore, no licence is now required under the provisions of U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 for sale of non-levy cement in the State after 1982 Notification. By this Notification the Central Govt. has lifted all restrictions on the sale and distribution of non-levy cement. Therefore, even the State Govt. is now left with no jurisdiction to impose such restriction on the sale of non-levy cement after 28-2-1982 under the provisions of U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 merely because they have not amended their Cement Control Order, 1973 to make it consistent with the Central Cement Control Order as amended. In fact the provisions of U.P Cement Control Order cannot over ride the Central Cement Control Order as amended by 1982 Notification. The detenu, therefore, did not act prejudicial to the maintenance of supply of a commodity essential to the community.

    5. The detenu has also challenged the correctness of the facts alleged to have been found at his shop by the inspecting party on 4-7-1984. It is not necessary to detail them because these controversies of facts will be resolved in the trial initiated against the detenu under S. 3/7 Essential Commodities Act. They cannot be resolved for the decision of this petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution. However, those relevant for the decision of this petition shall be mentioned at appropriate places.

    6. The impugned order of detention is placed under S. 3 of the Act. This section reads as under:

    “3. Power to make orders detaining certain persons: (1). The Central Government or the State Government or any officer of the Central Government, not below the rank of a Joint Secretary to that Government specially empowered for the purposes of this section by that Government, or any officer of a State Government, not below the rank of a Secretary to that Government specially empowered for the purposes of this section by that Government may, if satisfied, with respect to any person that with a view to preventing him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of supplies commodities essential to the community it is necessary so to do, make an order directing that such person be detained.

    Explanation:— For the purposes of this sub-section, the expression “acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of supplies of commodities essential to the community” means—

    (a) committing or instigating any person to commit any offence punishable under the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 (10 of 1955), or under any other law for the time being in force relating to the control of the production, supply or distribution of, or trade and commerce in any commodity essential to the community; or

    (b) dealing in any commodity:—

    (i) which is an essential commodity as defined in the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 (10 of 1955), or

    (ii) with respect to which provisions have been made in any such other law as is referred to in clause (a), with a view to making gain in any manner which may directly or indirectly defeat or tend to defeat the provisions of that Act or other law aforesaid.

    (2) …………………….”

    7. The expression “acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of supplies of commodities essential to the community” in S. 3(1) above has been considered by a Division Bench of this Court in Munna Lal Agarwal v. District Magistrate, Aligarh 1984 EFR 188 : (1984 All LJ 753) and it has been held therein that:

    “The expression “acting in any manner prejudicial to the maintenance of supplies of commodities essential to the community” used in S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black-Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980, covers within its ambit only such activities as have been specified in cls. (a) or (b) of the Explanation appended to the said sub-section, and no other activity. Accordingly only such activities which result in committing or instigating any person to commit any offence punishable under the Essential Commodities Act or under any other law for the time being in force relating to control of the production, or supply or distribution of, or trade and commerce in, any commodity essential to the community or dealing in any commodity which is an essential commodity as defined in Essential Commodities Act, 1955, or with respect to which provisions have been made in any such other law, with a view to making gain in any manner which may directly or indirectly defeat or tend to defeat the provisions of the Essential Commodities Act or other such law, alone can be considered to be activities to prevent which an order for detention under S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black-Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1983, can be passed.”

    8. In other words, an order of detention under this Section can be passed only when he—

    either commits an offence punishable under (a) Essential Commodities Act or (b) under any other law relating to the control of production, supply or distribution of any commodity essential to the community, or, deals in any commodity which is ‘essential commodity’ (as defined in the Essential Commodities Act) or deals in a commodity the production, supply or distribution of which is controlled by any other law with a view to make undue profit commonly known as profit made by sale in black market.

    9. It, therefore, follows that an order of detention under this Section can be passed only against a person who has either (1) committed an offence punishable under the Essential Commodities Act or under any other law relating to the control of production, supply or distribution of any commodity essential to the community or (2) he must be dealing in an “essential commodity” as defined in the Essential Commodities Act or in a commodity essential to the community the production, supply or distribution of which is controlled by any other law with a view to make undue profit. An order of detention which does not fulfil any of the above two conditions cannot be said to be covered by S. 3(1) of the Act and is accordingly vitiated.

    10. We shall now examine whether the case of the detenu in this case falls in any one of the two categories, mentioned above. Admittedly, on the date on which the order of detention was passed, the detenu was dealing in cement which was “non-levy” cement under the Cement Control Order, 1967. This distinction between “levy cement” and “non-levy” cement was introduced in the Cement Control Order, 1967 by Order No. S.O 105(E) dated 28-2-1982 issued by the Ministry of Industry (Department of Industrial Development) of the Government of India. Prior to this there was no such distinction. It was by this Order that the Central Govt. amended the Cement Control Order, 1967. By these amendments “cement” was classified into two categories viz. “levy cement” and “non-levy cement”. It is not that these two categories were cement of different qualities because this amendment has not changed the definition of “cement” as contained in S. 2(a) of the Cement Control Order, 1967. The categorisation was made with regard to installed capacity of the cement plant. “Levy cement” was defined with regard to the installed capacity of the plant as may be defined by the Central Govt. (not being more than 66.6%) to which only the cement Control Order 1967 was applicable from the date of Notification i.e from 28-2-1982. The remaining part has been categorised as “non-levy” cement to which the Cement Control Order, 1967 ceased to apply from that date. In order words, non-levy cement is that cement which was released by the Central Govt. from its control exercised under the Cement Control Order, 1967 w.e.f 28-2-1982.

    11. The preamble of the Cement Control Order, 1967 indicates that one of the objects of this Order is to secure availability of cement at fair price. Cl. 10(1) of the Cement Control Order, 1967 reads as under:—

    “The maximum price at which cement may be sold by a dealer (whether wholesale or retail) shall be such as may be fixed by the State Government and no dealer (whether wholesale or retail) shall sell cement exceeding such maximum price.”

    12. Under cl. (1-A) of the Cement Control Order, 1967, this order applied only to “levy cement” and not to “non-levy cement”. Evidently, therefore, the sale of “non-levy” cement became free of the price control imposed by cl. (10) of the Cement Control Order, 1967 with effect from 28-2-1982. That is, on the date of the order of detention, the sale of non-levy cement was not subject to the price control as provided in cl. (10)(1) of that order. Therefore, no maximum price can be fixed by the State Govt. for sale of non-levy cement either whole-sale or retail.

    13. This was the position on the date of detention of the detenu under the Cement Control Order, 1967. But on that date another order viz. the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973, made under S. 3 of the Essential Commodities Act, was in force. This Order was not amended by the State in 1982 following the amendment made by the Central Govt. in Cement Control Order, 1967. According to the learned Addl. Govt. Advocate, the control in the sale of cement imposed by the U.P State Cement Control Order 1973 continued to apply to cement which has been declared “non-levy” under the Cement Control Order, 1967 and has been released from all the restrictions imposed by that order.

    14. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the detenu that after lifting of control on the sale of “non-levy” cement by the Central Govt., the State of U.P is left with no authority to interfere with the sale of the same and enforce the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973. In support of this submission the learned counsel referred to a decision of the Patna High Court reported in Shyam Sunder Prasad Bhadani v. State of Bihar 1984 E.F.R 200 in which it has been held that:—

    “the new provisions brought in by amendment and discussed above indicates that non levy cement has been completely released from the restriction and control applicable earlier to the total production of cement. Only the levy cement is now affected them. The power to earmark levy cement out of the total production lies with the Central Government. The District Magistrate or the Food Commissioner or the State of Bihar does not have any authority to interfere with same. The effect of seizing stock of non-levy cement and selling the same at the controlled price to disturb the proportion fixed in this regard by the Central Government. This is not permissible. As observed above the law as it stands now does not permit any control of price of non-levy cement.”

    15. It may, however, be pointed out that the above observations do not have a direct application to this case. Unlike our State, Bihar Govt. has also amended the Bihar Cement Control Order, 1972 in the line similar to the Central Govt. Cement Control Order, 1967 by introduction of definitions of “levy cement” and “non-levy cement” in Cl. (2) of their Order. This is amply clear from the following remarks contained in Shyam Sunder Bhadani's case;

    “…………The Bihar Cement Control Order, 1972 was also amended in similar line by introduction of the definitions of levy cement and non-levy cement in Clause 2. By a new Clause 8(a) the District Magistrate has been empowered to fix the price per bag of levy cement and the amended clause 9 requires a person desirous of purchasing levy cement to obtain a permit. The original Clause 12 prohibiting the sale of cement at a higher price than fixed has been amended by substituting levy cement in place of cement.”

    16. In our State, no such amendment has yet been made i.e “levy-cement” has not yet been substituted for “cement” for the purposes of restrictions imposed by the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973. Therefore, the question that needs examination is whether the restrictions contained in the Cement Control Order, 1973 will continue to affect sales of “non-levy” cement despite its sale being decontrolled under the Cement Control Order, 1967. In other words whether a dealer of “non-levy” cement in U.P still needs a licence under the Cement Control Order, 1973 and whether a breach of any term or condition of the licence would mean contravention of that order.

    17. The Cement Control Order, 1973 has been made by the State of U.P in the exercise of powers under S. 3 of the Act delegated to it by the Order No. S.O 1844 dated June 18, 1966 issued by the Govt. of India. Ministry of Commerce in the exercise of powers under S. 5 of the Essential Commodities Act (hereinafter referred to as the Delegation Order) for imposing a control on the production, supply and distribution of cement in the State. This delegation of power made by the Govt. of India is not an absolute one. It provides in Clause (a)(iii) of the Delegation Order:

    “that no order shall be issued in pursuance of the powers hereby delegated if it is inconsistent with any order issued by the Central Government under the said Act.”

    18. Therefore, any order of the State Govt. made in the exercise of delegated powers of the Central Govt. under S. 3 of the Essential Commodities Act cannot be inconsistent with the orders issued by the Central Govt. under that Act. The reason for the above provision is not far to seek. S. 3 of the Essential Commodities Act confers power on the Central Govt. to make an order for the control of all kinds of prices viz. ex-factory, wholesale or retail of any essential commodity and for the control of its production, supply and distribution whenever it (the Central Govt.) is of the opinion that it is “necessary or expedient” to do so. If in the exercise of this power the Central Govt. makes an order for the control of the production, supply and distribution with respect to a part of the installed capacity of commodity manufactured by a plant (in this case “levy cement”) and expressly releases the remaining part of the installed capacity of that plant (in this case non-levy cement”), the State Govt. in the exercise of its powers delegated under S. 5 of the Essential Commodities Act, will not be empowered to make an order inconsistent with the order issued by the Central Govt. in respect of the same commodity. It is this fact which has been emphasised by cl. (a)(iii) of the Delegation Order. It is, therefore, evident that the State Govt. is not empowered to issue any Order in the exercise of its delegated powers which is inconsistent with any Order issued by the Central Govt. under the Essential Commodities Act and if such an order issued, it would be beyond its competence. But in this case the provisions of U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 is not inconsistent with any order made by the Central Govt. under S. 5 of the Essential Commodities Act but is inconsistent with the provisions of the Cement Control Order 1967 as amended by the 1982 Notification which was made by the Central Govt. in the exercise of its powers under S. 18-G and S. 25 of the Industries (Development and Regulation) Act, 1951 (65 of 1951). Therefore, U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 does not seem to be hit by cl. (a)(iii) of the Delegation Order. Still we cannot close our eyes to the fact that where only levy cement is subject to control under the Cement Control Order, 1967 with effect from 28-2-1982 and non-levy cement is free from any control, U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 has placed non-levy cement under control. In other words, it has the effect of destroying the provisions of the Central Cement Control Order vis-a-vis non-levy cement and to that extent it is repugnant to the Cement Control Order, 1967 as amended by the 1982 Notification. Both the Cement Control Order, 1967 and the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 are orders issued in exercise of the powers conferred by a statute. Therefore, they for all practical purposes have the same effect as if enacted in that statute and inconsistency between them will attract the application of Art. 254 of the Constitution of India. Such repugnancy is therefore hit by Art. 254 of the Constitution of India and, even if not hit by this Article, it cannot be permitted to hold the field if the State of U.P does not see the wisdom of making suitable amendments in the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 as the State of Bihar has done with respect to their Bihar Cement Control Order, 1972. In other words, the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 would remain inoperative to the extent it is sought to be applied with non-levy cement. That is the law as it stands now after 28-2-1982 does not permit control of non-levy cement in a manner which is not consistent with the Cement Control Order, 1967 issued by the Central Govt. It cannot be disputed that this does not mean that a retail dealer in levy cement (which of course is also cement as defined in the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973) should be given a free hand in indulging in activities enabling him to make undue gain. It is not within our competence to suggest here the ways and means for achieving this object. Annexure ‘12’ of the petition shows that the State Govt. is already aware of the above situation and is thinking on these lines. This annexure is a copy of Confidential D.O No. 7632/29-0-124.Cement dated 25-10-1982 of the Commissioner and Secretary, Khadya Ratha Rasad Anubhag-2 of the State Govt. After pointing out the situation created by the amendment of Cement Control Order, 1967 by 1982 Notification, it has by its para 7 issued a direction to all the District Magistrates that no prosecution be initiated against the dealers of non-levy cement in their districts till the position in this regard is got after consultation with the Govt. of India, clarified. The words *(…….) further indicate that all the previous orders issued in respect of sale of cement in the State were also amended along with the issue of this letter. In that event, it appears strange that the District Magistrate, Agra has fallen back on the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 without noticing para 7 of this Annexure which speaks of an amendment of the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 made prior to the issue of this letter. This part of the letter indicates that the enforcement of the provision regarding sale of cement in the State contained in the various Cement Control Order prior to this letter of 25-10-1982 were at least put off in respect of “non-levy” cement.

    19. If the order of detention is examined in the light of above discussions it would appear that it cannot be said that the detenu was dealing in “non-levy” cement in contravention of the provisions of the U.P Cement Control Order, 1973 even though he holds a licence for this business granted to him under this Order because the law as it now stands after the amendment of the Cement Control Order, 1967 with effect from 28-2-1982 does not permit control of “non-levy” cement. The case of the detenu is, therefore, not covered by S. 3(1) of the Prevention of Black Marketing and Maintenance of Supplies of Essential Commodities Act, 1980 and his continued detention under this section cannot he upheld.

    20. The petition is accordingly allowed.

    21. The detenu shall be set free forthwith if not required in connection with any other case.

    22. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Om Prakash Agarwal v. State Of U.P And Others
    (Nov 30, 1984)