AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order VII, Rule 3 of tin Code of Civil Procedure,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order VII, Rule 3 of tin Code of Civil Procedure,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns two applications referred to a Full Bench by the learned Acting Chief Justice regarding the amendment of a plaint and decree in Suit No. 254 of 1952. The suit was instituted by the applicant against Ram Lal, Ganesh, and Smt. Saraswati for possession of a house purchased by the plaintiff from Panna Lal under a sale deed dated 8th June 1950. The suit was decreed in favor of the plaintiff, and subsequent appeals and a second appeal were dismissed. During execution of the decree, a discrepancy was found in the description of the northern and southern boundaries of the property as stated in the decree compared to the actual property. The plaintiff-decree-holder filed applications seeking correction of this mistake. The applications were contested, and a civil revision was filed, which was allowed on jurisdictional grounds but left the question of amendment to be decided by the High Court. The matter involved a conflict between two earlier judicial decisions, leading to the referral to the Full Bench for resolution.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the court has jurisdiction to amend a decree and plaint to correct a clerical or accidental mistake in the description of property boundaries under Sections 151 and 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  2. Whether such amendment can be allowed when the identity of the property is undisputed and the mistake is inadvertent.
  3. Whether the applications for amendment are maintainable despite the death of a defendant and non-substitution of legal representatives.
  4. The resolution of the apparent conflict between the decisions in Shujaatmand Khan v. Govind Behari and Ruhulghani v. Uma Shankar regarding the applicability of Sections 151 and 152 for amendment of decrees.

Arguments of the Parties

Contestant Judgment-Debtor's Arguments

  • The applications for amendment could only have been made in the Second Appeal (No. 1612 of 1958) and not in the Civil Revision (No. 753 of 1963).
  • The suit as against Smt. Saraswati abated upon her death due to non-substitution of her legal representatives, rendering the applications not maintainable.
  • Reliance on the decision of the Madras High Court in T.M Ramakrishnan alias Mannor Krishnan Chettiar v. Radhakrishnan to argue against amendment under Sections 151 and 152.

Applicant's Arguments

  • The applications could and ought to have been treated as filed in the Second Appeal, and the court should accept this prayer.
  • The decree was passed against Ganesh, who represented the estate of Smt. Saraswati, thus the applications are maintainable despite her death.
  • The mistake in the boundaries was clerical and inadvertent, originating in the sale deed and copied into the plaint and decree, and does not affect the identity of the property.
  • Reliance on the decision of a Division Bench in Aziz Ullah Khan v. Court of Wards, Shahjahanpur which permits correction of such mistakes under Sections 151 and 152 for the ends of justice.
  • Distinguished Shujaatmand Khan v. Govind Behari on facts, arguing it did not consider the direct decision in Aziz Ullah Khan.
  • Other High Court and Supreme Court decisions support the power to correct inadvertent or clerical mistakes in decrees and pleadings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Aziz Ullah Khan v. Court of Wards, Shahjahanpur (A.I.R 1932 Allahabad 587) Correction of accidental mistakes in plaint and decree under Sections 151 and 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure for ends of justice. The Court affirmed this decision as directly applicable and authoritative, adopting its reasoning to allow amendment of the plaint and decree.
Ruhulghani v. Uma Shankar (A.I.R 1934 Oudh 5) Correction of clerical mistakes in mortgage deeds and related documents under Sections 151 and 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Supported the view that inadvertent mistakes can be corrected; although it did not consider Aziz Ullah Khan, it reached the same conclusion independently.
Shujaatmand Khan v. Govind Behari (A.I.R 1934 Allahabad 100 2) Held that amendments under Section 152 cannot be allowed if it would alter the plaint and decree substantially, especially where changes are due to settlement operations rather than clerical mistakes. The Court distinguished this precedent on facts, noting it involved substantive changes and not clerical errors, thus not applicable here.
I.L Janakirama Iyer v. P.M Nilakanta Iyer (A.I.R 1962 S.C 633) Supreme Court held that inadvertent or clerical mistakes in decrees can be corrected by the High Court under Sections 151 and 152 even during pendency of appeal. Relied upon to support the principle that courts have inherent power to correct such mistakes for ends of justice.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the applications in light of the undisputed identity of the property subject to the suit and decree, noting that the mistake pertained only to the misdescription of northern and southern boundaries copied inadvertently from the sale deed into the plaint and decree. It emphasized that such a clerical or inadvertent mistake does not materially affect the suit or decree as the property itself is identifiable. The Court overruled the preliminary objections regarding maintainability, accepting the applicant's prayer to treat the applications as filed in the Second Appeal. It resolved the conflict between the precedents by distinguishing Shujaatmand Khan on facts and affirming the reasoning in Aziz Ullah Khan that empowers courts under Sections 151 and 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure to correct such mistakes for the ends of justice. The Court also noted supporting decisions from other High Courts and the Supreme Court, reinforcing the principle that inadvertent clerical errors can be amended even during appeal proceedings. Finally, the Court referred to the statutory requirement under Order VII, Rule 3, that the property description must be sufficient for identification, which was satisfied in this case.

Holding and Implications

Applications allowed.

The Court allowed both applications for amendment of the plaint and decree to correct the misdescription of the northern and southern boundaries of the property. The parties were directed to bear their own costs. The decision directly effects the parties by permitting correction of the decree and plaint to reflect the accurate boundaries without altering the identity of the property. No new precedent was established beyond affirming existing principles permitting correction of clerical mistakes under Sections 151 and 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

    Ganesh v. Sri Ram Lala Ji Mahraj Birajman Mandir And Others

    Kirty, J.:— Those two applications having been referred to a Full Bench by the learned Acting Chief Justice by an order dated 28-7-1972 have come up before us. Application No. 3303 of 1970 was filed on 14-5-1970 under Sec. 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The other application filed on 23-3-1965 is under Secs. 151 and 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Before the learned Acting Chief Justice a contention was raised that Secs. 151 and 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure were not applicable. In support of his contention reliance was placed on Shujaatmand Khan v. Govind Behari A.I.R 1934 Allahabad 100 2.. On behalf of the applicant, however, reliance was placed on Ruhulghani v. Uma Shankar A.I.R 1934 Oudh 5.. In view of the apparent conflict between the decisions in these two cases reference to a Full Bench was made by the learned Acting Chief Justice.

    2. Suit No. 254 of 1952 was instituted by the applicant against Ram Lal, Ganesh and Smt. Saraswati, inter alia, for possession of a house described at the foot of the plaint. The house, which was the subject-matter of the suit, was purchased by the plaintiff from Panna Lal under a ??? deed dated 8th June, 1950. Panna Lal entered appearance but did not ??? the suit. In his written statement he admitted having sold the suit property to the plaintiff and further pleaded that the other defendants were in occupation of the house as tenants. The suit was, however, contested by Ganesh and Smt. Saraswati. It was pleaded by them that the were not in possession of the property a tenants but in their own right as owners. Amongst other pleas, a plea of ??? possession was also taken. It was, however, no where stated in the written statement that the subject-matter of the suit was not the same property which was ??? by Panna Lal to the plaintiff under the sale deed dated 8-6-1950. The trial court framed a number of issues which ??? answered in plaintiff's favour. The suit accordingly was decreed on 27-5-1957 for possession of the house in suit. An at peal against the decree of the trial court was preferred by Ganesh. It appears that during the pendency of the suit in the trial court Smt. Saraswati, who was the ??? the of Ganesh, died. No application was filed by the plaintiff for substituting the name of the legal representatives of Smt. Saraswati in her place. The appeal filed by Ganesh was dismissed by the learned Additional Civil Judge, Jhansi on 15-10-1958. Thereafter Ganesh filed a Second Appeal (S.A No. 1612 of 1958) in this Court. This Second Appeal was dismissed by learned Single Judge under Order ??? Rule 11, C.P.C on 27-1-1969. There after the plaintiff-decree-holder execute the decree. A warrant for delivery ??? possession was issued and when the ??? went to deliver possession it was found ??? that the description of the northern an southern boundaries of the property, a mentioned in the decree, did not tall with the actual northern and ??? boundaries of the house on the spot. The ??? under the circumstances returnel ??? warrant unexecuted along with a ??? mentioning therein the discrepancy, the discrepancy, however, was only this; The boundary which was shown as the ??? boundary in fact was the southern ??? of the house’. Similarly the ??? boundary as shown in the decree as actually the northern boundary. In ??? plaint the property in suit was ??? as house No. 125 situate in Mohallah ???. The boundaries of the ??? in suit, were also mentioned in the plaint. It, however, appears that neither ??? the trial court nor in the appellate court nor even in the Second Appeal in his Court was it ever alleged by Ganesh ??? the house in suit was not the same as the house conveyed to the plaintiff by Panna Lal under the sale deed dated 8-6-1950. That is to say, there never existed any dispute between the parties concerned ??? regard to the identity of the house which was the subject-matter of the suit. The execution application, however, was ??? by the executing court in view of the report submitted by the Amin. Thereafter the plaintiff-decree-holder filed in application in the court of the learned Additional Civil Judge, Jhansi for the ??? of the, decree with a view to ??? the mistake in or misdescription of the ??? and southern boundaries ???. This application was contested, but the learned Judge allowed the application. In his order dated 11-5-1963 if was noted that there was no dispute about the property involved and its identity. Against this order Civil Revision No. 753 of 1963 was filed by Ganesh. During the pendency of this revision the decree-holder-opposite party filed application No. 622 of 1965 on 23-3-1965. The revision was allowed by D.S Mathur, J. on 24-3-1965 solely on the ground that the learned Additional Civil Judge, Jhansi had no jurisdiction to amend the decree in view of the fact that Second Appeal No. 1612 of 1958 was dismissed by this Court. The learned Judge in his judgment allowing the revision, however, observed as follows:

    “The proper remedy available to the plaintiff-opposite party was to apply to the High Court for amendment of the decree. Such an application has since been made but it shall be disposed of separately.

    The revision is hereby allowed and the order dated 11-5-1963 is set aside. The application for amendment of the decree shall stand rejected though similar application made before the High Court shall be considered in due course.”

    3. It may here be also mentioned that on 24-3-1965 the learned Judge also passed the following order on Civil Misc. Application No. 622 of 1965:—

    “The application cannot be deemed to have been made in Civil Revision No. 753 of 1963. It shall be registered separately as a Miscellaneous case.

    ……………………………”

    4. The application, however, could not come up for hearing, on account of the death of Ganesh and the consequent substitution proceedings. In application No. 622 of 1965 it was prayed that an order for the amendment of the decree passed by the trial court and affirmed by the lower appellate court in First Appeal and by this Court in Second Appeal be corrected by giving the northern boundary as southern boundary and southern boundary as northern boundary of the house in dispute. In application No. 3303 of 1970, which was field on 14-5-1970, it was prayed that the boundaries as given in para 7 of the plaint be ordered to be amended by deleting the word and substituting the word in its place and similarly the word be deleted and substituted by the word in its place.

    5. As already mentioned, at no material point of time was there any dispute between the parties in regard to the identity of the house, which was the subject-matter of the suit and of the decree. It appears, however, that in the sale deed in question this very mistake in regard to the description of the northern and southern boundaries occurred and that in the plaint due to inadvertance the boundaries as given in the sale deed had been copied out. Under the circumstances it seems to us that the misdescription or mistake in the boundaries did not in any way materially affect the suit or the decree passed thereunder. The identity of the subject-matter of the suit being not in dispute no difficulty could have arisen in delivering the suit property to the decree-holder in execution of the decree. Since however two applications are before us in which prayers have been made for the amendment of the plaint as also of the decree and since the matter has been referred to this Bench it is necessary for us to consider the applications on merit and to give our decision.

    6. Sri S.P Kumar, learned counsel for the contesting judgment-debtor raised two preliminary objections. One was that the present applications, if at all, could only have been made in Second Appeal No. 1612 of 1958 and not in Civil Revision No. 753 of 1963. The other was that Smt. Saraswati, one of the defendants, having died during the pendency of the suit and her legal representatives not having been substituted, the suit as against her abated and that, therefore, also the two applications were not legally entertain-able and deserved to be dismissed. In our opinion there is no substance in these two objections. The learned counsel himself submitted that these applications could be and ought to have been made in the aforesaid Second Appeal. The learned counsel for the applicant made an oral prayer to us that if need be the applications may be treated as applications filed in the said Second Appeal. We see no objection to accepting this prayer. In regard to the second objection the learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the decree of the trial court was passed against Ganesh, who occupied a dual capacity he was a defendant in his own right and, on the death of Smt. Saraswati, he being one of the legal representative, if not the sole representative, must be deemed to have represented the estate, if any, of Smt. Sarasvrati. Even if we proceed on the basis that the suit as against Smt. Saraswati had abated, the two applications cannot be held to be affected in any way as to their maintainability. In the decree ??? Saraswati was not shown as a judgment debtor. Obviously, therefore, if the amendment prayed for is allowed, it cannot ??? said that there will be any alteration the decree which will in any way ??? affect the legal representatives ??? Smt. Saraswati, if any. In regard to the first preliminary objection we may further mention that from the judgment Mathur, J. dated 24-3-1965 allowing Revision No. 753 of 1963 and the order of the learned Judge of the same date passed ??? Civil Misc. Application No. 622 of ??? it is clear that the learned Judge did ??? give any decision on the question whether the decree could or could not be ??? as prayed by the decree-holder. In fact the learned Judge expressly left this question to be dealt with by the High Court inasmuch as, in his view, such an application could only be appropriately considered and decided by the High Court We, therefore, over-rule the preliminary objections.

    7. It has already been ??? that the reason why the applications wen referred to a Full Bench by the ???. Acting Chief Justice is the conflict in the decisions of this Court and the Oudh Chief Court in the two cases which have already been noted hereinabove. During the hearing of these applications before us the learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the matter was directly ??? with by a Division Bench of this Court in Aziz Ullah Khan v. Court of Wards, Shahjahanpur A.I.R 1932 Allahabad 587.. Learned counsel further submitted that Shujaatmand Khan's case is clearly distinguishable. He further submitted that in Shujaatmand Khan's case earlier decision of this Court in Aziz Ullah Khan's case was neither referred to nor considered. It was urged that on the point involved in the applications before us there being a direct decision of this Court which has so far neither been overruled nor even distinguished in any later case the applications should be allowed and this Bench should affirm the view taken ??? the Division Bench in Aziz Ullah Khan's case.

    8. On examination the two cases of his Court, namely, Aziz Ullah Khan's ??? and Shujaatmand Khan's case we ??? that the former case is directly in point, whereas the latter case is clearly ??? on facts.

    9. In Aziz Ullah Khan's case the suit was filed on the basis of a mortgage. In he mortgage deed itself by an accidental ??? the mortgaged property was described ??? being situated in Mauza “Nagla ??? Nawadiya” whereas the correct name of the village was “Nawadiya ??? Nagla”. This mistake was repeated a the plaint, the preliminary decree, the ??? decree, execution application and the ??? certificate. The mistake was ??? in mutation proceedings in the revenue court, and because of this mistake in the ??? of the mortgaged property the ??? application was rejected by the ??? court. Thereupon the decree-??? applied for the amendment of the ??? under Sec. 152 of the Code of Civil ???. This application was opposed ??? the ground that no such amendment ??? be made under Sec. 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure. In support of this sub-mission that such amendment could be permitted under Sec. 152 of the Civil Procedure Code reliance was placed by the ??? counsel concerned on two earlier ??? of this Court. Referring to ??? cases the Division Bench observed ??? held as follows:—

    “For the opposite party we have been ??? to a ruling of this Court in Sheo Balak Pathak…Applicant v. Sukhdei…Opposite Party . A.I.R 1914 Allahabad 61. in which the, court ordered the amendment of the proceedings starting from the plaint right down to the decree.

    10. We have also been referred to an ??? decision of a Bench of this Court (of which one of us was a member) in Sarju Kumar Mukerji v. Sheikh Enayat Husain C.R No. 148 of 1929 dated 11-7-1930.. The facts of that case were very similar to he facts of the case before us and the court ordered the correction of the documents in question, namely, the plaint, the decree and other documents. We see no reason why these decisions of this Court should not be followed as they are in accordance with the ordinary meaning of the language in Sec. 152. It has further been argued that the court below purports to act under Sec. 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure only and that Section can only apply in terms to the amendment of the decrees and not to the amendments of the plaint, the sale certificate and the dakhalnama. This contention no doubt is correct but the power of the court to make corrections necessary for the ends of justice is not confined only to powers exercisable under Sec. 152. Extensive powers may be exercised also under Secs. 151 and 152. We consider that this is eminently a case in which the accidental slip should be corrected as the correction is necessary for the ends of justice”.

    11. Aziz Ullah Khan's case, therefore, is an authority for the proposition that such accidental mistakes, as had occurred in that case, can be corrected by the court, apart from the powers exercisable under Sec. 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure, under the powers exercisable under Secs. 151 and 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure, if such correction is necessary for the ends of justice. Respectfully we agree with the view expressed by the learned Judges in Aziz Ullah Khan's case and affirm that view. A Division Bench of the Oudh Chief Court in Ruhulghani's case also held that clerical mistakes occurring due to inadvertent in a mortgage deed giving rise to re-petition of the same mistake in the plaint and the decree can be corrected in exercise of powers under Secs. 151 and 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure. This case was also a case of incorrect description or misdescription of an itsm of the mortgaged property. Although in this case Aziz Ullah Khan's case was not referred to or considered, the learned Judge independently of it came to the same view as had been taken earlier by the Bench of this Court in Aziz Ullah Khan's case. Reference, however, was made to Shujaatmand Khan's case, but it was distinguished. Shujaatmand Khan's case was not a case of some accidental or inadvertant mistake committed by the parties. What had happened was that a mortgage deed was executed on 16th December, 1897 hypothecating eight zemindari properties. Another mortgage deed was executed in 1905 in respect of the same eight properties and also a house. In 1914 a mortgage by conditional sale was executed in respect of the eight zamindari properties and also the house besides a grove. The description of the zamindari shares and the boundaries of each item of the properties of the mortgage deed of 1914 were precisely the same as in the two earlier mortgages. Meanwhile, however, there was a Settlement in 1901, as a result of which the proportionate shares of the mortgagors in the Mahals were changed. After the passing of a preliminary decree in the suit filed on the basis of the 1914 mortgage an application under Sec. 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure was filed alleging that there had been a misdescription of the mortgaged shares in the mortgage deed of 1914. A prayer was made for an amendment of the plaint and the preliminary decree. The High Court held that the amendment which was sought would completely alter the plaint and the decree and also the deed on which the plaint was based. In the circumstances the learned Judges were of the view that there was in reality no clerical mistake which could be corrected under Sec. 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure. It will thus be seen that Shujaatmand Khan's case is clearly distinguishable on facts. There it was as a result of Settlement operations that certain changes came about in regard to the shares of the mortgagors in the Mahal. It was not a case of any clerical mistake or accidental misdescription of property due to acts or omissions of parties as in the instant case.

    12. The learned counsel for the contesting judgment-debtor urged before us on the basis of reported decisions of other Courts that in the circumstances of the case the amendments prayed for could not be legally ordered either under Sec. 151 or 152. He relied on the decision of the Madras High Court in T.M Ramakrishnan alias Mannor Krishnan Chettiar v. Radhakrishnan A.I.R 1948 Madras 13.. The learned counsel for the applicant, however, pointed out the in a later case of Appat Krishna Poduya v. Lakshmi Nathiar A.I.R 1950 Madras 751. the Madras High Court itself took a different view. The learned counsel also pointed out that the view taken by this Court in Aziz Ullaf Khan's case has been followed by other High Court. He referred to in this connection a decision of the Patna High Court in Jagarnath Prasad Bhagat v. Jamuna Prasad Singh A.I.R 1934 Patna 403.. The learned counsel for the judgment-debtor also referred to the decision of the Rajasthar High Court in Kistoormall v. ??? Mohammad A.I.R 1958 Rajasthan 276.. We, however, do not consider it necessary to discuss these cases as, in our opinion in the circumstances of the case for the ends of justice, corrections can be made or permitted to be made in the plaint as well as the decree, as was held in Aziz Ullah Khan's case by a Division Bench of this Court and in Ruhul ghani's case by the Oudh Chief Court Besides, we may mention that the Supreme Court in I.L Janakirama Iyer v. P.M Nilakanta Iyer A.I.R 1962 S.C 633. has held that inadverten or clerical mistakes in the decree can be corrected by the High Court under Secs. 151 and 152 of the Code of Civil Procedure even during the pendency of an appeal ??? the Supreme Court. We are thus of opinion that under the circumstances of the instant case the two applications could by legally entertained and deserve to ??? allowed.

    13. Before parting with the case ??? may also refer to Order VII, Rule 3 of tin Code of Civil Procedure, which provides:—

    “Where the subject-matter of the ??? is immoveable property, the plaint shall contain a description of the property sufficient to identify it, and, in case such property can be identified by boundaries or lumbers in a record of Settlement or ???, the plaint shall specify such or numbers.”

    14. It will thus be seen that what the law requires is that the description of the property in suit given in the plaint must be sufficient to identify the property. If independently of the, boundaries the property can be sufficiently identified, then any error or misdescription in the boundaries cannot affect either the suit or the decree massed in the suit. In the instant case, is already mentioned, no dispute at any rime was raised that the suit property and the property inrespect of which the decree was passed is not identifiable on the spot or it is a property different from the property which was purchased by the plaintiff from Panna Lal and for the delivery of which the suit was filed. In the circumstances, in our opinion, ends of justice require that the two applications should be allowed and the amendments prayed for be made.

    15. In the result, both the applications are allowed. Let amendments be made as prayed. The parties shall bear their own costs.

    Applications allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ganesh v. Sri Ram Lala Ji Mahraj Birajman Mandir And Others
    (Nov 15, 1972)