Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from convictions and sentences imposed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Shahjahanpur, on three appellants: Badshah Singh, Khunni Singh and Kunwar Singh. Badshah Singh was convicted under section 307, Indian Penal Code (I.P.C.), sentenced to seven years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 200 (or one year further R.I. in default). Khunni Singh was convicted under section 323, I.P.C., sentenced to one year R.I. and Rs. 50 fine (or three months R.I. in default). Kunwar Singh was convicted under sections 323/109, I.P.C., and sentenced to six months R.I.

The incident occurred at about 8 a.m. on 12-8-1954 in a plot of land outside village Areli (P.S. Nigohi, Shahjahanpur). The prosecution's account is that Dular (P.W.1) and his nephew Raja Ram (P.W.3) were ploughing when Badshah Singh approached and attempted to prevent them — each side claimed possession of the field. The prosecution alleged that Khunni and Kunwar were with Badshah, that Khunni struck Raja Ram with a lathi, and that Badshah shot at Dular with a pistol at Kunwar's instigation.

Defences included: Khunni and Kunwar pleaded alibi; Badshah denied firing and claimed he had been assaulted. The appellants did not lodge a counter report, and Badshah did not get medically examined. The defence additionally claimed that Badshah and Kunwar were prevented from lodging a report at the police station because they were placed under arrest, but no evidence was led to support that claim and no questions were put to police witnesses on that plea.

Prosecution witnesses included the two victims (Dular and Raja Ram) and an eyewitness Hira Lal (P.W.4). Defence witnesses included Sita Ram (D.W.3) and two witnesses (Atjar/Atraj Singh and Hulas Singh) regarding possession. Medical examination by Dr. S.R. Khanna (midnight between 12th–13th August 1954) recorded multiple small, round gunshot wounds on Dular's left buttock (five pellets removed; firing from very close range; injury characterized as simple) and a simple abrasion on Raja Ram consistent with a lathi blow.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Badshah Singh's act of firing a pistol at very close range, resulting in superficial injuries, constituted the offence of attempted murder punishable under section 307, I.P.C., or at most an offence under section 324, I.P.C.
  2. Which party was the aggressor — i.e., who had cultivatory possession of the disputed plot — since that determination affected the assessment of who was the attacker and who the victim.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The principal argument advanced for the appellants was that because the injuries inflicted on Dular were superficial, Badshah Singh could not be guilty of attempted murder under section 307, I.P.C.; at most the offence would be under section 324, I.P.C.
  • Defences pleaded included alibi for Khunni and Kunwar; Badshah denied firing and asserted he had been assaulted. A further defence asserted they were prevented from lodging a police report because they were placed under arrest, but no supporting evidence was led on this point.
  • The counsel also argued that if the ammunition was defective and that explained the superficial injury, the defence should be credited and that the prosecution should have produced an expert to explain the condition of the ammunition (noting, however, the firearm was not recovered).

Prosecution's Position

  • The prosecution relied on the testimony of the two victims (Dular and Raja Ram) and an eyewitness Hira Lal to establish that Badshah fired a pistol at Dular at very close range and that Khunni had struck Raja Ram.
  • The prosecution produced medical evidence from Dr. S.R. Khanna showing multiple small, round pellets removed from Dular's buttock and an opinion that the firearm was fired from very close range.
  • The prosecution pointed to absence of any counter-report lodged by the appellants and the fact that Badshah did not get his own injuries examined, to support the credibility of the prosecution account.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Emperor v. Vasudeo Balwant Gogte, ILR 56 Bom 434 : AIR 1932 Bom 279 Establishes that firing at point blank range may constitute attempted murder under S.307, I.P.C., even if the bullets fail to take effect due to defective ammunition or intervening material; effect of act (i.e., actual injury) does not alone determine liability under S.307. The court relied on this precedent to support the conclusion that Badshah Singh's act of firing at very close range brought his conduct within the mischief of S.307, I.P.C., despite the injuries being medically simple.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in distinct steps, each tied to factual findings in the record and statutory interpretation:

  1. Credibility and possession: The learned Sessions Judge accepted the prosecution's eyewitness testimony (including the two victims) and rejected defence testimony and the Khasra extract produced by the defence Lekhpal (Atjar/Atraj Singh). Reasons noted in the opinion for rejecting the defence evidence included his relationship to Badshah and strained relations with Dular. The judge found possession of the disputed plot lay with Dular.
  2. Medical and circumstantial facts: The medical evidence established multiple small, round gunshot pellets in Dular's left buttock, five pellets removed, and a medical opinion that the firearm had been fired from a very close range; Raja Ram's injury was consistent with a lathi blow.
  3. Elements of S.307, I.P.C.: The court set out the legal elements required for liability under section 307 — (1) that the accused did an act, and (2) that the act was done with such intent or knowledge and under circumstances that if death had been caused by that act, the accused would be guilty of murder. The court noted that the section looks to the nature of the act and the requisite intention/knowledge rather than the gravity of the injury as the primary determinant of guilt.
  4. Application to the facts: Given the proved fact that Badshah fired a pistol at Dular from a very close range, the court considered that Badshah must be deemed to have acted with at least the knowledge that the shot could prove fatal. The court observed that superficial injuries could result from a defect in ammunition, which would not negate the nature of the act itself.
  5. Burden as to defective ammunition: The court addressed the defence contention that defective ammunition had been purposely used or that the prosecution should have produced an expert. It noted that the firearm was not recovered and that there was no evidence to suggest Badshah had intentionally used defective ammunition. The opinion states that the onus of proving such a defence lay on the defence, and that this onus had not been discharged.
  6. Reliance on precedent: The court cited the Bombay High Court decision in Emperor v. Vasudeo Balwant Gogte where point-blank firing that failed to cause fatality due to defect or interposition nevertheless attracted conviction under S.307. This precedent was applied to support the legal proposition that the nature of the act and the accused's knowledge are the decisive factors under S.307.
  7. Conclusion on convictions: On these bases — credibility findings, medical evidence of point-blank firing, absence of supporting evidence for the defence theory of defective ammunition, and applicable precedent — the court concluded that Badshah's act fell within section 307, I.P.C. The court therefore affirmed his conviction under section 307. The court also maintained the convictions and sentences of Khunni and Kunwar as recorded by the Sessions Judge.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The appeal is dismissed; the convictions and sentences of the appellants are maintained.

Direct effects on the parties:

  • Badshah Singh's conviction under section 307, I.P.C. is affirmed and his sentence (seven years R.I. and fine of Rs. 200, with default imprisonment as ordered) is upheld. The court refused to reduce his sentence.
  • Khunni Singh's conviction under section 323, I.P.C. (one year R.I. and Rs. 50 fine, or three months R.I. in default) and Kunwar Singh's conviction under sections 323/109, I.P.C. (six months R.I.) are upheld. Khunni Singh and Kunwar Singh, who are on bail, were ordered to surrender and serve their sentences.

Broader implications: The opinion applies established principles (including a cited precedent) to the facts but does not articulate any new rule of law beyond the application of section 307, I.P.C., to point-blank firing resulting in non-fatal injury. The decision reaffirms that the physical result of the act (i.e., superficial injury) does not, by itself, exclude liability under section 307 where the nature of the act and the requisite knowledge/intention are proved.


This summary is strictly limited to information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer material beyond that text.

    Badshah Singh And Others v. The State .

    1. This is an appeal by three men, Badshah Singh, Khunni Singh & Kunwar Singh, against the judgment and order of the learned Additional Sessions Judge of Shahjahanpur. He convicted and sentenced Badshah Singh to seven years' R.I and a fine of Rs. 200/-, or further rigorous imprisonment for one year in default of payment of fine, under S. 307. I.P.C Khunni Singh to one year's R.I and Rs. 50/- fine, or further rigorous imprisonment for three months in default of payment of fine, under S. 323, I.P.C and Kunwar Singh to six months' R.I under Ss. 323/109, I.P.C Khunni Singh and Kunwar Singh are uncles of Badshah Singh. One other tried along with the appellant, Munshi Singh, was acquitted mainly on the ground that the two main witnesses in this case were inimical to him. The prosecution of the appellants was based upon an incident which, it is common ground, did take place at about 8 a.m on 12-8-1954 in a plot of land outside village Areli within police station Nigohi in the district of Shahjahanpur. It is common ground that Dular P.W 1 and his nephew Raja Ram P.W 3 were ploughing the field when the appellant Badshah Singh came up and tried to prevent them from doing so. Each party claimed to have been in possession of the field and accused the other of aggression.

    2. According to the prosecution, Khunni Singh and Kunwar Singh appellants were also with Dadshah Singh and, when Dular refused to accede to the protests of Badshah Singh, Khunni Singh gave Raja Ram a lathi blow and Badshah Singh shot at Dular with a pistol at the instigation of Kunwar Singh.

    3. Khunni Singh and Kunwar Singh pleaded alibi and Badshah Singh denied having fired at Dular and pleaded that when he protested he was assaulted by Dular and his companions. No counter report was lodged by any of the appellants, nor did Badshah Singh get himself medically examined. The defence of Badshah Singh and Kunwar Singh was that when subsequently the latter came to know of the incident from the former both of them went to the police station to lodge a report but were prevented from doing so because they were placed under arrest there.

    4. No defence was however led in support of this latter plea, nor was any question put relating to that plea to Head Constable Babu Ram P.W 2, who registered the report lodged by Dular at P.S Nigohi at 12-20 o'clock on the day of the occurrence, or to S.I Hari Bhajan P.W 6, Station Officer of the police station, who investigated the case.

    5. The prosecution produced three eye-witnesses, the two victims Dular P.W 1 and Raja Ram P.W 3, and Hira Lal P.W 4 who was scraping grass close to the field of occurrence, while the defence produced one witness Sita Ram D.W 3 in support of the counter version. The defence also produced two other witnesses Atjar Singh and Hulas Singh in support of the defence plea that the disputed field had been in possession of Badshah Singh.

    6. The injuries of Dular and Raja Ram were examined by Dr. S.R Khanna, Medical Officer in charge of the District hospital at Shahjahanpur, in the midnight between the 12th and 13th August 1954. He found the following injuries on Dular:

    7. A large number of small and round gunshot wounds, each 1/10″ × 1/10″ × skin deep, spread in an area of 6″ × 3½″ on the left buttock.

    8. He found blackening present on some wounds. Screening showed four small and round radio opaque shadows in outer and upper part of the left thigh resembling gunshots. The doctor took out 5 pellets from the wound. In the opinion of the doctor the firearm had been fired from a very close range. In the opinion of the doctor, the injury caused to Dular was a simple one. On the person of Raja Ram the doctor found one abrasion — ¾″ × 1/6″ on the front part of the phalanx of the left thumb, the injury being simple and appearing to have been caused with a blunt weapon like a lathi.

    9. The injuries were stated before the doctor to have been caused at about 8 a.m on 12-8-1954 which, in his opinion, was probable. The learned Sessions Judge relied upon the testimony of the prosecution witnesses & rejected that of the defence witnesses, including the Khasra extract produced by the defence witness Atraj Singh, the village Lekhpal.

    10. The crucial question no doubt was as to which party was the aggressor, and for that purpose it was necessary to find as to who actually had been in cultivatory possession of the disputed plot. The learned Sessions Judge discarded the testimony of the Lekhpal who was produced as a defence witness on the ground that he was related to Badshah Singh and the relations between him and Dular had been strained.

    11. It is noteworthy that the entry with regard to possession in favour of Badshah Singh was only in the remarks column and those entries do not appear ever to have been verified by any superior officer. Nor was the Zamindar produced on whose behalf Badshah Singh purported to have been in possession, and no rent receipts were produced either. Support for the prosecution version with regard to possession was, on the contrary, found in the statement of one of the defence witnesses himself. The learned Sessions Judge appears therefore to have been right about his finding relating to possession of the disputed plot having been with Dular. The learned counsel appearing for the appellants did not urge that the learned Sessions Judge was wrong in rejecting the testimony of the defence witness about the counter-version of the incident. The learned Judge seems to have been right also in relying upon the testimony of the eye-witnesses produced by the prosecution with regard to the details of the occurrence.

    12. Of these three witnesses two were the victims themselves. It is also to be borne in mind that Badshah Singh never got his injuries examined and no counter-report of the incident was lodged.

    13. The main argument of the learned counsel for the appellants however was that, regard being had to the nature of the injury caused to Dular, Badshah Singh could not be said to have committed the offence punishable under S. 307. I.P.C According to him, the utmost that could be said was that Badshah Singh was guilty under S. 324, I.P.C

    14. For liability under S. 307 the prosecution has to prove the following facts: (1) that the accused did an act, and (2) that the act was done with such intention or knowledge and under such circumstances that if he by that act caused death he would be guilty of murder. If hurt is caused by such act, the offender becomes liable to transportation for life, otherwise the maximum term of imprisonment prescribed is 10 years. It would thus appear that the section itself does not take into consideration the effect of the act of the accused except as a measure of sentence to be imposed upon him.

    15. That being so, it cannot be argued that Badshah Singh should not be held guilty of the offence of attempted murder simply because the injuries caused to Dular were of a superficial nature. What is to be seen is whether the act of Badshah Singh was of the nature contemplated by the section. The idea underlying the offence punishable under that section seems to be that by his act the accused should be deemed to have done all that was necessary to commit the offence of murder, the commission of that offence having been prevented by some event unknown to the accused and beyond his control.

    16. In the present case the facts disclosed are that Badshah Singh fired a pistol at Dular, and that he did so from a very close range. These facts are, in my opinion, sufficient to bring Badshah Singh's act within the mischief of S. 307, I.P.C since in view of those facts he would be deemed to have fired the pistol at Dular with at least the knowledge that the shot would prove fatal. If the injuries actually caused to Dular were only superficial, that may have been the result of some defect in the ammunition.

    17. The argument of the learned counsel for the appellants was that Badshah Singh should be credited with having purposely used defective ammunition. He went on to argue that the prosecution should have produced an expert. He has however not taken into account the fact that the firearm was not recovered from the possession of Badshah Singh. On the other hand, there is nothing in the prosecution evidence from which it could even remotely be held, or even a doubt could arise, that Badshah Singh had purposively used defective ammunition.

    18. In fact, the onus of proving the defence put forward by the learned counsel for the appellants would appear to have lain clearly on the defence. In a similar case reported as Emperor v. Vasudeo Balwant Gogte…(Original Accused)*, ILR 56 Bom 434 : (AIR 1932 Bom 279) (A), in which the accused fired two shots from a revolver at point blank range at Sir Ernest Hotson, the Acting Governor of Bombay, but the bullets failed to take effect owing to some defect in the ammunition or to the intervention of a leather wallet and folded currency notes in his pocket, the Bombay High Court held that the accused was still guilty of the offence under S. 307, I.P.C

    19. I am therefore clearly of the opinion that facts proved by the prosecution clearly brought the act of Badshah Singh appellant within the mischief of S. 307, I.P.C, and that the burden of proving the aforesaid defence of defective ammunition having knowingly been used lay on the defence and the same had not been discharged. Badshah Singh was therefore rightly convicted under S. 307, I.P.C

    20. The learned counsel also made a plea for reduction of the sentence of Badshah Singh; but to that submission also it does not seem to be possible to accede. From his point of view he had done his worst, and if the result was not more serious the credit of it could not go to him. There is no reason therefore to reduce the sentence passed on Badshah Singh. In the result, the appeal is dismissed and the convictions and sentences of the appellants are maintained. Khunni Singh and Kunwar Singh who are on bail shall surrender and serve out their sentences.

    K.S.B

    21. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Badshah Singh And Others v. The State .
    (Mar 4, 1958)