Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 17 of the United Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947
  • Section 7A of the United Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947
  • Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947
  • Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act
  • Rule 4 of the Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 17 of the United Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947
  • Section 7A of the United Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947
  • Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947
  • Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act
  • Rule 4 of the Rules
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

On 18-5-1950 a decree for ejectment of tenant Nand Lal from shop No. CK25/8, mohalla Kaghzi Tola, Banaras was obtained by the landlord Krishna Chaitanya Goswami from the Court of the II Additional Civil Judge, Banaras. On that day the petitioner Jang Bahadur applied to the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer (ARCEO) for allotment of the shop in his favour. No allotment order was made then. The landlord claimed the shop had fallen vacant on 29-5-1950 and, claiming to have given notice of vacancy, nominated opposite party No. 4, Faujdar Rai, as tenant under Rule 4 of the Rules framed under Section 17 of the United Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947.

The ARCEO initially directed the landlord not to let out the shop without his order and on 3-8-1950 held that Faujdar Rai, who had occupied the shop meanwhile, was an unauthorised occupier liable to ejectment. On 12-8-1950 the ARCEO passed an allotment order in favour of Jang Bahadur. Faujdar Rai sought reversal before the Additional District Magistrate (ADM), which resulted in a stay; subsequent presentation and procedural steps led to the ADM on 6-12-1950 setting aside the ARCEO's allotment to Jang Bahadur and directing allotment to Faujdar Rai.

The petitioner moved the District Magistrate (DM) to vacate the ADM's order; the DM on 25-4-1951 refused to entertain the application as appeal/revision and directed that review, if desired, be presented to the ADM. Separate ejectment proceedings under Section 7A (UP Temporary Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947) initiated by the ARCEO against Faujdar Rai were terminated after the ADM's order. Jang Bahadur filed the present writ petition challenging the competence of the DM and ADM to pass the orders dated 25-4-1951 and 6-12-1950 and seeking certiorari to quash those orders and to stop their enforcement.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the District Magistrate and the Additional District Magistrate had competence (jurisdiction) to pass the orders dated 25-4-1951 and 6-12-1950 which set aside the allotment made by the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer.
  2. Whether the order of allotment passed by the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer on 12-8-1950 in favour of Jang Bahadur was lawful.
  3. Whether the Additional District Magistrate could review or correct an order passed by the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer where both officers exercised powers delegated by the District Magistrate under the United Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (Jang Bahadur)

  • The Additional District Magistrate had no jurisdiction to pass the order of 6-12-1950 because the matter was being dealt with by the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer acting as District Magistrate under the United Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947, and the ADM could not exercise appellate or revisional powers against orders passed by the ARCEO in that capacity.
  • Challenged the competence of the District Magistrate and the Additional District Magistrate to pass the orders dated 25-4-1951 and 6-12-1950 and sought quashing of those orders by writ of certiorari and an injunction against their enforcement.

Landlord / Opposite Party Arguments

  • The landlord contended the shop had fallen vacant on 29-5-1950 and that he had given notice of vacancy to the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer on 1-6-1950, sending the letter under a certificate of posting; he relied on that certificate to show he had notified vacancy and therefore had the right to nominate his tenant (Faujdar Rai) under the rules.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R.N. Seth v. Girja Shankar Srivastava, AIR 1952 All 819 Proposition that the District Magistrate or Additional District Magistrate could not appropriate appellate or revisional powers in respect of orders passed by an officer to whom he had delegated authority under the Act. The court observed that the R.N. Seth case related to a District Magistrate purporting to revise the order of his delegate; it distinguished the present case on its facts, noting that if two officers exercise the same power one cannot revise the other, but where jurisdiction is concurrent it may be possible for one to review the order of another.
Shri Chandra Bhan v. Rent Control Eviction Officer, Agra, AIR 1954 All 6 Addressed whether a valid allotment order can be reviewed either by the officer who makes it or by a higher executive authority (left open). The court noted that another Bench left the question open and that it was unnecessary for that Bench to express an opinion on whether a valid allotment order can be reviewed; the present court likewise found it unnecessary to decide the question for the purposes of the writ application.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first examined the petition on merits rather than disposing of it on procedural grounds. It found the petitioner's first application (18-5-1950) premature because the shop was not then vacant; the petitioner's subsequent application (11-7-1950) was also served after Faujdar Rai had occupied the shop.

On the landlord's case, he asserted vacancy on 29-5-1950 and relied on a letter sent on 1-6-1950 under a certificate of posting. The ARCEO had held that the notice of vacancy had not been received. By contrast, the Additional District Magistrate, in reviewing the ARCEO's order, concluded the letter must have been received on 2 or 3-6-1950 and suggested it was likely misplaced in the ARCEO's office. The opinion notes that the ARCEO produced no other letter under the certificate of posting to indicate the certificate related to some other matter.

Because no allotment was made by the ARCEO within one month of the receipt of the notice of vacancy, the landlord had the right to nominate his own tenant and to send that nomination to the ARCEO. The landlord did nominate Faujdar Rai. The ARCEO was then bound either to allot the shop immediately to some other person for reasons recorded in writing or to allot in accordance with the landlord's nomination. The ARCEO failed to make a timely allotment and did not pass any allotment order until 12-8-1950, and the ARCEO's orders of 3-8-1950 and 12-8-1950 were, on the merits, contrary to law.

The Additional District Magistrate's order of 6-12-1950 setting aside the ARCEO's allotment and directing allotment to Faujdar Rai was characterized by the court as a correction of the ARCEO's error — essentially an order that should have been passed by the ARCEO itself. Although the court accepted the general proposition that a District Magistrate or Additional District Magistrate cannot appropriate appellate or revisional powers against orders of an officer exercising delegated authority, it found that in the present case both the Additional District Magistrate and the ARCEO were persons to whom the District Magistrate had delegated authority and they in practice exercised concurrent powers. In those circumstances the ADM's review of the ARCEO's order was treated as permissible correction of an incorrect exercise of the statutory duty.

The court discussed authorities (R.N. Seth and Shri Chandra Bhan) and distinguished them on facts. R.N. Seth dealt with a District Magistrate purporting to revise his delegate's order; the present case involved concurrent exercise of delegated powers. Shri Chandra Bhan had left open whether a valid allotment order can be reviewed; the present court considered it unnecessary to resolve that broader question because, on the merits, the ADM's order corrected an unlawful allotment and thus was just and proper.

Finally the court exercised its discretion under Article 226 of the Constitution and declined to interfere with the ADM's order even if technical objections to the ADM's jurisdiction might exist. The court noted that Faujdar Rai had been in possession of the shop for about three and a half years and that the ARCEO was not entitled to make the allotment in favour of Jang Bahadur; accordingly it held that the writ petition should fail.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The writ petition is dismissed.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The order of the Additional District Magistrate dated 6-12-1950, which set aside the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer's allotment to Jang Bahadur and directed allotment to Faujdar Rai, is upheld on the merits as a correct and valid order in the circumstances of this case.
  • The court declined to quash the District Magistrate's order dated 25-4-1951 and the Additional District Magistrate's order dated 6-12-1950, and refused to exercise Article 226 to interfere with the ADM's order.
  • Costs were awarded: Rs. 80/- to the first three opposite parties (represented by Standing Counsel) and Rs. 51/- to opposite party No. 4 (Faujdar Rai).
  • No broader change in legal principle or new precedent was announced by this opinion; the decision resolves the dispute between the parties by upholding the ADM's correction of the ARCEO's earlier orders in the particular facts of this case.

The opinion bears the concluding notation "H.G.P" and the succinct dispositional statement: "Petition dismissed."

H.G.P

    Jang Bahadur v. Dist. Magistrate

    1. On 18-5-1950 a decree for ejectment of one Nand Lal tenant from shop No. CK25/8 mohalla Kaghzi Tola, Banaras was obtained by the landlord Krishna Chaitanya Goswami from the court of the II Additional Civil Judge, Banaras. On that very day the petitioner Jang Bahadur presented an application to the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer for allotment of that shop in his favour. No order of allotment was passed on that application and on the 11th July 1950 the landlord sent an application dated 3rd July 1950 to the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer, Banaras nominating opposite party No. 4 Faujdar Rai, as tenant of the shop under Rule 4 of the Rules framed under Section 17 of the United Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947 and requesting the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer to pass an order of allotment in favour of Faujdar Rai. On the 11th July 1950 the petitioner Jang Bahadur also made another application in the prescribed form requesting that the shop be allotted to him as it had actually fallen vacant. There were various other persons also who wanted allotment of that shop in their favour. The Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer first passed an order directing the landlord not to let out the shop to any one without his order and then on the 3rd August 1950 held that Faujdar Rai, who had occupied the shop in the meantime, was an unauthorised occupier and was liable to be ejected from the shop. The Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer came to this view after holding that the vacancy had not been intimated to him by a letter alleged to have been sent by the landlord on 5-7-1950 and consequently no right had accrued to the landlord to nominate a tenant of his own choice under the rules.

    2. On 12-8-1950 the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer passed an order of allotment in favour of Jang Bahadur. On the same day Faujdar Rai moved the Additional District Magistrate seeking reversal of the order of the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer making the allotment in favour of Jang Bahadur. The Additional District Magistrate stayed operation of the order of the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer. On 1-9-1950 the landlord applied to the Additional District Magistrate asking for the stay of the order passed by the Rent Control and Eviction Officer directing possession to be given to Jang Bahadur.

    3. On 25-10-1950 the Additional District Magistrate dismissed the application of Faujdar Rai for reversing the order of the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer on the ground that application had been presented directly to him and had not been received by him on transfer from the District Magistrate. Thereupon on 26-10-1950 Faujdar moved an application before the District Magistrate. This application was entertained by the District Magistrate who delegated his authority to the Additional District Magistrate and sent the application to him for disposal. The Additional District Magistrate after hearing parties passed an order on the 6th December 1950 setting aside the order of allotment passed in favour of Jang Bahadur and directed that the shop in question be allotted to Paujdar Rai.

    4. On 8-12-1950 the petitioner moved the District Magistrate to vacate the order of the Additional District Magistrate dated 6-12-1950. This application was rejected by the District Magistrate on 25-4-1951 with an order that he could not entertain an appeal or revision and if a review of the order of the Additional Magistrate was sought the application should be presented direct before the Additional District Magistrate.

    5. While these proceedings were going on before the Additional District Magistrate and the District Magistrate the Assist. Rent Control and Eviction Officer had also started proceedings under Section 7A of the United Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947 for ejectment of Faujdar Rai from the shop in question. These proceedings also terminated after the order of the Additional District Magistrate dated 6-12-1950. This writ petition has been presented by Jang Bahadur challenging the competence of the District Magistrate and the Additional District Magistrate to pass the orders dated 25-4-1951 and 6-12-1950 and the validity of those orders with a request that these orders be quashed by issue of a writ of certiorari and the enforcement of those order be stopped.

    6. I consider that in this case the claim of the petitioner may first be properly examined on merits. The petitioner first applied on 18-5-1950 for allotment of the shop in his favour. On that date admittedly the shop was not vacant and the application for allotment was, therefore, premature. His next application was presented on 11-7-1950 and it appears that even on that date the shop was no longer vacant as it had been occupied by Faujdar Rai.

    7. The landlord contended that the shop had actually fallen vacant on 29-5-1950 and he gave notice of the vacancy to the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer on the 1st June. He sent the letter under a certificate of posting. During the proceedings before the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer, the landlord produced that certificate of posting which mentioned that the certificate related to a letter sent by the landlord to the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer and related to shop No. CK25/8. The Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer held that letter intimating vacancy had not been received by him.

    8. But the learned Additional District Magistrate in reviewing the order of the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer came to the view that the letter had really been sent and must have been received by the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer on 2 or 3-6-1950. It also appears that on merits the view taken by the learned Additional District Magistrate is more sound. The likelihood is that the letter was received in the office of the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer and was probably misplaced there.

    9. The suggestion that the certificate of posting related to some other matter seems to have no force as the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer was not able to produce any other letter from the landlord which might have been sent under that certificate and which may have related to some other matter. In these circumstances no allotment was made by the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer within one month of the receipt of the notice of vacancy. The landlord had a right to nominate his own tenant and to send that nomination to the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer. This the landlord did. Thereupon it was incumbent on the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer either to make an allotment in favour of some other person forthwith for reasons to be recorded in writing or to make allotment in accordance with the wishes of the landlord.

    10. The Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer did not forthwith make allotment in favour of any person. In fact he passed no order of allotment until 12-8-1950 though on 3-8-1950 he held that the occupation by Faujdar Rai was unauthorised. Clearly the order of allotment passed on 12-8-1950 was not in accordance with law.

    11. When on receipt of the nomination of the landlord on 11-7-1950, the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer did not forthwith make an order in favour of any other person he was bound under law to pass an order of allotment in favour of the landlord's nominee Pauzdar Rai, and in not making such an order he neglected to carry out his duties enjoined by the statute. The order of the Additional District Magistrate dated the 6th December 1950 was therefore merely a correction of the error which had been committed by Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer inasmuch as he passed an order that should have been passed under the law by the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer. On merits, therefore it is clear that the order of the Additional District Magistrate which is being challenged by this writ application is really a correct and valid order under the law and is eminently just and proper.

    12. The contention of learned counsel for the petitioner is that the Additional District Magistrate had no jurisdiction to pass the order of 6-12-1950 as the matter was being dealt with by the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer acting as District Magistrate under the United Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947 and the Additional District Magistrate could not exercise any powers of appeal or revision against the orders passed by the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer in his capacity as District Magistrate under that Act.

    13. The proposition that the District Magistrate or the Additional District Magistrate could not appropriate to himself the powers of appellate or revisional authority in respect of the orders passed by the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer must be accepted. But it appears that in this case what the Additional District Magistrate did was not to exercise any powers of appeal or revision. The Additional District Magistrate as well as the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer were both persons to whom the District Magistrate had delegated his authority under the United Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act and they exercised concurrent powers. It was in these circumstances that the Additional District Magistrate reviewed the order of the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer. Learned counsel urged the Additional District Magistrate had no such powers of review and for this proposition relied on a decision of a division Bench of this Court in — ‘R.N Seth v. Girja Shankar Srivastava’, AIR 1952 All 819 (A).

    14. It, however, appears that case related to an order which was passed by the District Magistrate purporting to revise the order of an officer to whom he had delegated his authority under the United Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act. The District Magistrate did not purport to review the order. It is obivious that if two officers exercise the same power one cannot revise the order of another. But if the jurisdiction is concurrent, it may be possible for one to review the order of another. The question whether the District Magistrate could review an order passed by the Rent Control and Eviction Officer who exercised powers under delegation from him came up before another Bench in ‘Shri Chandra Bhan v. Rent Control Eviction Officer, Agra’, AIR 1954 All 6 (B), but the learned Judges left this question open and said that it was unnecessary for them to express an opinion on the question whether a valid allotment order can be reviewed either by the officer who makes it or by a higher executive authority.

    15. In this case before me also, it appears to be unnecessary to decide this question for the purposes of this writ application. I have already expressed my opinion above that the orders which were passed by the Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer on the 3rd August and 12th August 1950 were against law and incorrect orders and they were corrected by the Additional District Magistrate by this order dated the 6th December 1950. Further, the order of the 6th December 1950 was the just and proper order which should have been passed in the circumstances of this case.

    16. In, these circumstances it does not appear to be necessary to exercise the discretionary powers under Article 226 of the Constitution in this case to interfere with that order even if technical grounds may exist indicating that the Additional District Magistrate could not have passed that order. Faujdar Rai is already in possession of the shop and the orders passed in favour of the petitioner dated 3 & 12-8-1950 were never given effect to. Faujdar Rai has thus been in possession of this shop for about three and a half years already and according to law he was the person who should have been in possession. The Assistant Rent Control and Eviction Officer was not entitled to make an order of allotment in favour of Jang Bahadur. Consequently I do not think that this is a proper case where I should go into the validity of the order of 6-12-1950 and set it aside on some technical or legal ground. The writ petition must, therefore, fail and is dismissed with costs. The costs of the first three opposite parties who were represented by the learned Standing Counsel are fixed at Rs. 80/- and of opposite party No. 4 at Rs. 51.

    H.G.P

    17. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jang Bahadur v. Dist. Magistrate
    (Jan 4, 1954)