Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Section 350A of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • provisions of Section 350A of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • judgment.8. Section 15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 540 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.4.
  • Section 350A of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • section 540 of the Code of Criminal Procedure;
  • Section 147, 452 and 323, I.P.C,
  • Sections 452 and 323, I.P.C
  • Section 16 of the Code
  • Section 147, I.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Section 350A of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
  • provisions of Section 350A of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • judgment.8. Section 15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • Section 540 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.4.
  • Section 350A of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • section 540 of the Code of Criminal Procedure;
  • Section 147, 452 and 323, I.P.C,
  • Sections 452 and 323, I.P.C
  • Section 16 of the Code
  • Section 147, I.P.C
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of Opinion: Bhargava, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

Jairam and Satyaram, who are brothers, were convicted by the Bench Magistrates of Bhogaon (district Mainpuri) for offences under Sections 147, 452 and 323 of the Indian Penal Code and were sentenced to different terms of imprisonment and fines. On appeal, the Assistant Sessions Judge of Mainpuri set aside the conviction under Section 147, I.P.C., but upheld convictions under Sections 452 and 323, I.P.C. The applicants filed the present revision.

The trial was conducted before a Bench of Magistrates at Bhogaon whose membership changed on multiple dates between January and August 1950. The case record and order-sheets show hearings and adjournments on multiple dates (including 21 Jan 1950; 15 Mar 1950; 5 Apr 1950; 20 & 25 Apr 1950; 10 & 17 May 1950; 1 Jun 1950; 14 & 29 Jun 1950; 13 & 19 Jul 1950; 27 Jul 1950; 31 Jul 1950; judgment delivered 17 Aug 1950).

The judgment challenged in this revision was delivered on 17 August 1950 by Dr. Janki Prasad Misra and Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh. The crux of the challenge is that Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh was not present on the Bench throughout the proceedings, and therefore, under Section 350A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the judgment is said to be invalid.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the judgment delivered by a Bench of Magistrates is invalid because one of the magistrates who joined in delivering judgment (Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh) was not present on the Bench throughout the proceedings, in light of Section 350A of the Code of Criminal Procedure?
  2. Whether the presence of a magistrate on "material dates" when evidence was recorded suffices to validate a judgment under the exception in Section 350A, or whether the magistrates must have been present throughout all proceedings (beyond the mere recording of evidence)?

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants' Arguments

  • The Bench Magistrate who delivered the judgment (Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh) was not present on the Bench throughout the proceedings; therefore, relying on Section 350A CrPC, the judgment is invalid and should be set aside.
  • The applicants' counsel specifically relied upon the language of Section 350A of the Code of Criminal Procedure to support invalidity where a magistrate who joined in judgment had not been present throughout the proceedings.

Respondent / Government Advocate's Arguments

  • The Government Advocate's brief contended that Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh was present on the material dates on which the evidence in the case was recorded; implicitly arguing that presence on those material dates suffices to validate the judgment.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a statutory and factual analysis focused on Section 350A of the Code of Criminal Procedure and the trial record (order-sheets). Key steps in the court's reasoning were:

  1. Statutory framework: The court noted that provincial government notifications and rules (under Sections 15 and 16 CrPC) permitted constitution of Benches of two or more magistrates and that, by rule, two magistrates could form a quorum for the Bhogaon Bench.
  2. Interpretation of Section 350A CrPC: Section 350A declares that no order or judgment of a Bench shall be invalid solely because of a change in the constitution of the Bench provided the Bench that passed the order or judgment was duly constituted and "the Magistrates constituting the same have been present on the Bench throughout the proceedings." The court emphasized that the protection afforded by Section 350A applies only when those magistrates were present throughout.
  3. Meaning of "proceedings": The court rejected the contention that "proceedings" should be restricted to the recording of evidence. Citing the dictionary meaning and practical implications, the court held that "proceedings" include all acts, measures, or steps taken in the further progress of the case—orders, adjournments, directions, issuing of process, excusing an accused, directing production of documents, etc. Therefore, presence throughout all such steps is required for Section 350A protection.
  4. Factual application to the record: The order-sheets showed multiple changes in bench composition on different dates. While Dr. Janki Prasad Misra was present throughout the proceedings, Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh was absent on several dates when orders or other proceedings (not limited to recording evidence) were taken—such as adjournments awaiting commission returns, excusing an accused's absence, directing summoning of the injury register under Section 540 CrPC, and allowing time for defence witnesses. The court concluded that Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh did not satisfy the requirement of presence throughout all proceedings.
  5. Effect of noncompliance: Because the magistrates who delivered judgment were not present throughout the proceedings, the case did not fall within the exception of Section 350A and the general rule (that the Bench which recorded proceedings should pronounce judgment) was violated. Consequently, the judgment was not protected by Section 350A and was invalid.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision is allowed and the judgment delivered by the Bench (Dr. Janki Prasad Misra and Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh) is held to be invalid because the magistrates who delivered judgment were not present on the Bench throughout the proceedings; accordingly, the convictions and sentences imposed upon the applicants are set aside.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The applicants (Jairam and Satyaram) are acquitted.
  • No retrial was ordered, having regard to the petty nature of the offence and the time elapsed since the incident (20 September 1949).
  • Any fine paid by the applicants will be refunded.
  • The bail bonds executed by the applicants are cancelled.

The opinion does not discuss broader legal or binding precedential implications beyond its application of Section 350A to the facts of this case; its effect is stated in direct terms as to the parties and their convictions.

Disposition: Revision allowed.

    Jai Ram v. State

    Bhargava, J.:— This is an application in revision filed on behalf of Jairam and Satyaram, who are own brothers and were convicted by the Bench Magistrates of Bhogaon, in the district of Mainpuri, for offences punishable under Section 147, 452 and 323, I.P.C, and each of them was sentenced to different terms of imprisonment and fine. On appeal, the Assistant Sessions Judge of Mainpuri set aside the conviction of the applicants under Section 147, I.P.C but upheld their conviction under Sections 452 and 323, I.P.C The applicants have now come up to this Court in revision.

    2. On behalf of the applicants, the first point urged in this revision is that the Bench Magistrate, who delivered the judgment, were not present on the Bench throughout the proceedings. A reference to the order sheets bears out this contention of the applicants' learned counsel. The case was transferred to the Bench Magistrates on the 21st January, 1950. When this case was taken up by the Bench Magistrates on the 15th March, 1950 the Magistrates present on that date were Dr. Janki Prasad Misra and Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh. On that date the statement of certain witnesses were recorded and the other witnesses being absent the case was adjourned to the 5th April, 1950. On the last mentioned date only the Magistrate Dr. Janki Prasad Misra was present and Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh, Magistrate was absent. The order-sheet of this date goes to show that as the quarum was not complete the case was adjourned. The order-sheet also goes to show that the quorum prescribed for this Bench was of two magistrates. The case was then adjourned to April 20, 1950 and the case had to be adjourned to the 25th of April 1950 for want of a quorum. On the 25th April, 1950 all the three magistrates who constituted the Bench namely Dr. Janki Prasad Misra, Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh and Chaudhri Bijai Singh were present. Certain witnesses were produced and cross-examined and the case was adjourned for the recording of further evidence to the 10th May, 1950. On the order-sheet, against the date 25th April, 1950, there is a note showing that the accused persons did not claim a de novo trial, apparently in view of the fact that the constitution of the Bench had been changed. On the 10th May, 1950 the case had to be adjourned for want of quorum to the 17th May, 1950. On the last mentioned date again the case had to be adjourned for want of quorum. But it is to be noted that on this date Satyaram accused was absent and his absence was excused by an order made by Dr. Janki Prasad Misra who was present on the bench.

    3. When the case was taken up on the next date of hearing, namely, the 1st June, 1950, it appears from the order-sheet that the constitution of the bench was again changed and the bench so constituted was described as “Jadid Bench”. The bench magistrates present on that date were Dr. Janki Prasad Misra and Chaudhri Bijai Singh, On this date also a note has been made on the order-sheet on behalf of the accused persons stating that they did not want to claim a de novo trial. On the 14th June, 1950 again the quorum was not complete and only Dr. Janki Prasad Misra was present and an order adjorning the case awaiting the receipt of the report regarding an examination of the medical witness was passed. On the next date of hearing i.e on the 29th June, 1950 the Bench Magistrate present were Dr. Janki Prasad Misra and Chaudhri Bijai Singh and the case had to be adjourned again as the report about the examination of the medical witness was not received. On the same date an order was made by the Bench directing the summoning of the injury register from the hospital under Section 540 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

    4. When the case was taken up next on the 13th July, 1950 it appears that all the three Bench Magistrates were present. On this date again a note was made on the order sheet on behalf of the accused persons that they did not want to claim a de novo trial. The case had to be adjourned as the report about the examination of the medical witness had not been received. On the 19th July, 1950 which was the next date of hearing the bench magistrates present were Dr. Janki Prasad Misra and Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh. On this date the case was adjourned for the recording of the defence evidence to the next date of hearing viz., the 2-7th July, 1950. On the last mentioned date the Bench magistrates present were Dr. Janki Prasad Misra and Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh. After the hearing, the case was adjourned to the next date viz., the 31st July, 1950 for delivery of judgment. Judgment was not delivered on the 31st July as the quorum was not complete. The judgment was delivered on the 17th August, 1950 by Dr. Janki Prasad Misra and Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh Learned counsel for the appellant has contended that as Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh who had delivered the judgment along with Dr. Janki Prasad Misra was not present on the Bench throughout the proceedings the judgment is invalid, and as such it should be set aside.

    5. Learned counsel holding the brief of the Government Advocate has urged that Ch. Sheoraj Singh was present on the material dates on which the evidence in the case was recorded.

    6. Learned counsel for the applicants has relied upon the provisions contained in Section 350A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which is in these terms:

    “No order or judgment of a Bench of Magistrates shall be invalid by reason only of a change having occurred in the constitution of the Bench in any case in which the Bench by which such order or judgment is passed is duly constituted and the Magistrates constituting the same have been present on the Bench throughout the proceedings.”

    7. The section deals with the effect of the change in the constitution of a Bench of Magistrate upon the order or judgment of the Bench and lays down when the change shall not invalidate the order or judgment.

    8. Section 15 of the Code of Criminal Procedure empowers the Provincial Government to constitute Benches of two or more Magistrates. The notification of the Provincial Government constituting the Bench at Bhogaon is not before me; but it appears from the record that the said Bench consisted of three Magistrates, viz., Dr. Janki Prasad Misra, Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh and Chaudhry Bijai Singh; and under the rules framed under Section 16 of the Code two Magistrates could constitute a Bench for trial of cases transferred to the Bench. In other words, two Magistrates could form a quorum.

    9. It is not contended that there was any change in the constitution of the Bhogaon Bench, although it has been pointed out that there were frequent changes in the constitution of the Bench, before which the trial of this case had commenced. That Bench consisted of two Magistrates, viz., Dr. Janki Prasad Misra and Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh; and the said Bench recorded part of the evidence in the case. On two subsequent dates at different intervals the Bench which took up this case was constituted of all the three Magistrates. These changes invited on each occasion a statement from the accused persons that they did not want to claim a de novo trial. The Bench which consisted of Dr. Janki Prasad Misra, Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh and Chaudhri Bijai Singh, recorded further evidence in the case. The constitution of the Bench was again changed and the Bench so constituted as described as Jadid or new Bench. This Bench consisted of Dr. Janki Prasad Misra and Chaudhri Bijai Singh. When this Bench was constituted it was again stated on behalf of the accused persons that they did not want to claim a de novo trial.

    10. In view of the provisions of Section 350A of the Code of Criminal Procedure these changes in the constitution of the Bench would not have been material if the Magistrates constituting the Bench, which started the trial of the case, had been present on the Bench throughout the proceedings. If we take the first Bench, that is the Bench before which the evidence was first recorded, Dr. Janki Prasad Misra and Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh should have been present on the Bench throughout the proceedings; if we take the second Bench, all the three Magistrates should have been present throughout the proceedings; and if we take the third Bench, or Jadid Bench, Dr. Janki Prasad Misra and Chaudhri Bijai Singh should have been present throughout the proceeding. But, we find from the record that only one Magistrate, namely, Dr. Janki Prasad Misra was present throughout the proceedings and the other two Magistrates, or even Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh, who joined Dr. Janki Prasad Misra in delivering the judgment in the case, were not present throughout the proceedings.

    11. The argument of the learned counsel holding the brief of the Government Advocate that Dr. Janki Prasad Misra and Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh were present on all the material dates on which evidence was recorded, has, in my opinion, got no force. In order to save the order or the judgment of the Bench from being invalid the Magistrates constituting the Bench ought to have been present on the Bench throughout the proceedings. The dictionary meaning of the word ‘proceedings’ is the course of procedure in an action at law; and an act, measure or step in a course of business or conduct. Hence, the expression ‘proceedings’ with reference to a case, would imply taking of steps in connection with the further progress of the case. When a case is listed for hearing and the case is taken up by the court and an order is made in the case, it would be proceedings in the case. It is not possible to confine the word ‘proceedings’ to the recording of evidence only. On a particular date of hearing, on which evidence has to be recorded, a witness may be absent inspite of sufficient service and an order may be made directing the issue of a proclamation or warrant against the witness or witnesses who are absent. That would be a proceeding in the suit, even though no evidence is recorded on that date. Similarly, on any particular date the accused might be absent owing to illness or otherwise and an order may be made either dispensing with the presence of the accused or for the issue of a warrant for securing their presence. In either case, proceedings will have to be recorded in the case.

    12. In the present case, we find that part of the evidence was recorded on the first date of hearing and some part was recorded on a subsequent date of hearing. During the interval, on some days the case had to be adjourned awaiting the return of the report of the commission which had been issued to Sitapur for the recording of the statement of the medical witness; on one date, the court dispensed with the presence of one of the accused person who was absent; on another date the Bench directed the summoning of a document under section 540 of the Code of Criminal Procedure; and on another date time was allowed for the production of defence witnesses. On all these dates, although no evidence was recorded, some proceedings were taken in the case. On all the dates on which the proceedings were taken in the case the Magistrates constituting the Bench, which started the trial of the case and which delivered the judgment in the case, should have been present. Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh who was one of the members of the Bench, which started the trial of the case and of the Bench which delivered judgment in the case, was not present on some of the dates on which proceedings were recorded in this case. It appears from the record that whoever was present on a particular date of hearing proceeded to hear the case; and the only precaution taken was that at least two Magistrates were present and there was quorum.

    13. According to the general rule of law the Bench which recorded proceedings in the case and recorded evidence should have pronounced judgment in the case and if this general rule was not observed, the judgment delivered by a Bench could have been saved from being declared invalid if the provisions of Section 350A of the Code of Criminal Procedure were complied with. In the present case the general rule was violated and the case does not fall within the exeception mentioned in Section 350A of the Code, inasmuch as the Magistrates constituting the Bench which delivered the judgment, were not present throughout the proceedings.

    14. The judgment which is being challenged in this revision, as already stated, was delivered by Dr. Janki Prasad Misra and Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh. It is true that a Bench so constituted had commenced the trial of this case, but as pointed out above there were frequent changes in the personal of the Bench and that Chaudhri Sheoraj Singh was not present on the Bench throughout the proceedings. The judgment delivered is, therefore, not protected by Section 350A of the Code of Criminal Procedure and must be held to be invalid. The judgment being invalid the applicant's conviction must be set aside. The revision is, therefore, allowed; and the conviction of and the sentences imposed upon the applicants are set aside. Having regard to the petty nature of the offence and the time which has elapsed since the incident took place on the 20th September, 1949 I do not order a retrial in this case. The applicants are acquitted. Fine, if paid by them, will be refunded. The bail bonds executed by them are cancelled.

    15. Revision allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jai Ram v. State
    (Feb 26, 1952)