Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from a reference made by the Chief Inspector of Stamps, United Provinces, under section 61 of the Stamp Act. The reference concerns two instruments filed as evidence in suits Nos. 11 of 1944 and 31 of 1944 before the court of the Munsif, Shahganj, Jaunpur, exercising the powers of a Judge, Small Cause Court. The question was whether these two instruments, dated 29th March 1939 and 30th December 1940 respectively, were promissory notes or mere agreements. Both instruments were executed by the respective parties—Ram Avadh Singh and Raja Ram Singh—and bore one-anna revenue stamps. The Inspector of Stamps contended that the instruments were not promissory notes but acknowledgments of debt coupled with agreements to pay interest, deeming them unstamped and liable for stamp duty and penalty. The trial court disagreed, holding them to be promissory notes based on their description. The Chief Inspector of Stamps referred the matter for determination.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the two instruments executed by Ram Avadh Singh and Raja Ram Singh qualify as promissory notes under section 4 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
  2. If not promissory notes, whether they should be treated as agreements subject to stamp duty and penalty under the Stamp Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Inspector of Stamps' Arguments

  • The instruments do not contain any unconditional undertaking to pay money.
  • They are acknowledgments of debt coupled with agreements to pay interest.
  • As such, the instruments are not promissory notes and were not properly stamped.
  • Stamp duty and penalty should be imposed on the parties concerned.

Court Below's Position

  • The instruments are described as "pronotes" and should be treated as promissory notes.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ratan Singh v. Pirbhu Dayal Instrument lacking an unconditional undertaking to pay does not qualify as a promissory note under section 4 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. Used as authoritative support to hold that the instruments in question are not promissory notes due to absence of an express undertaking to pay.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the terms of the two instruments rather than relying on their descriptive labels as "pronotes." Referring to the definition of a "promissory note" under section 4 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, the court emphasized that such an instrument must contain an unconditional undertaking by the maker to pay a certain sum of money. The instruments under scrutiny only contained acknowledgments of debt coupled with agreements to pay interest, without any express or unconditional promise to pay. The court further cited illustration (c) to section 4 of the Act, which clarifies that a mere acknowledgment of debt (e.g., "Mr. B, I.O.U Rs. 1,000") does not constitute a promissory note. The precedent in Ratan Singh v. Pirbhu Dayal reinforced this interpretation. Consequently, the court concluded that the instruments are agreements rather than promissory notes.

Holding and Implications

The court accepted the reference and held that the instruments are not promissory notes but agreements.

Accordingly, the court declared that a stamp duty of twelve annas and a penalty of Rs. 7-8 is payable in respect of each instrument by the respective parties, Ram Avadh Singh and Raja Ram Singh. This decision directly affects the parties by imposing the stamp duty and penalty but does not establish any new precedent beyond the interpretation of the instruments under the existing law.

    Bachan Singh v. Ram Avadh

    P.L Bhargava, J.:— This is a reference by the Chief Inspector of Stamps, United Provinces, under section 61 of the Stamp Act. The question raised in this reference is whether the two instruments filed in suits Nos. 11 of 1944 and 31 of 1944 in the court of the Munsif, Shahganj, Jaunpur, exercising the powers of a Judge, Small Cause Court, were promissory notes or agreements. The first instrument is dated the 29th of March, 1939. It was executed by Ram Avadh. Singh and is to the effect:

    “It had borrowed a sum of Rs. 42 … bearing interest at the rate of annas four per cent, from Bechan Singh … on the 29th of March, 1939, and have, therefore, executed this pronote on this 29th day of March, 1939, so that it may serve as evidence and be of use when needed.”

    The second instrument is dated the 30th of December, 1940. It was executed by Raja Ram Singh and it recites:

    “I of my own free will and accord approached Mahajan Ranbir Singh … and borrowed from him the sum of Rs. 100 … bearing interest at the rate of annas eight per cent, per mensem for the purpose of purchasing bullock. I have, therefore, executed these few presents by way of a promissory note so that it may serve as evidence and be of use when needed.”

    Each instrument bears a one-anna revenue stamp.

    The Inspector of Stamps and Registration, who examined the records of the cases in which these instruments were filed, was of opinion that the instruments were not promissory notes as they did not contain any undertaking to pay the money and each of them only contained an acknowledgment of debt coupled with an agreement to pay interest at the stipulated rate. He, therefore, treated them as unstamped and reported that the persons concerned should be asked to pay the stamp duty and penalty provided by law. The court concerned did not accept the report and held that, in view of the fact that the documents were described as “pronotes”, they must be treated as promissory notes.

    In this reference the Chief Inspector of Stamps has again pointed, out that the instruments are not promissory notes but they are acknowledgments of debt coupled with agreement to pay interest.

    The term “promissory note” has been defined in section 4 of the Negotiable Instruments Act as follows:

    “A ‘promissory note’ is an instrument in writing (not being a bank-note or a currency note) containing an unconditional undertaking, signed by the maker, to pay a certain sum of money only to, or to the order of, a certain person, or to the bearer of the instrument.”

    It is true that the instruments are styled as “pronotes”, but that is merely the description of the instruments; and, in order to find out whether the instruments are promissory notes or not, we must examine their terms. The terms of the instruments have been set out above and we do not find therein any conditional or unconditional undertaking by the maker to pay the amounts mentioned therein.

    In our opinion, there must be an express undertaking to pay the amount mentioned in the instrument before it can be held to be a promissory note, as defined in section 4 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. A mere implied undertaking by the use of the word ‘debt’ or ‘pronote’ is not sufficient. This is also made clear by illustration (c) appended to section 4 of the Act, it reads:

    “(C) Mr. B, I.O.U Rs. 1,000.”

    This does not amount to a promissory note within the meaning of the term as used in section 4 of the Act.

    In Ratan Singh…Defendant v. Pirbhu Dayal…Plaintiff . the instrument under consideration was in more or less similar terms and, in the absence of any unconditional undertaking to pay the amount mentioned therein, it was held that the instrument could not be considered as a promissory note.

    We, therefore, accept the reference and hold that the instruments, in question are not promissory notes, but they are agreements. Accordingly, we declare that a stamp duty of twelve annas and a penalty of Rs. 7-8 is payable in respect of each of the instruments by Ram Avadh Singh in one case and Raja Ram Singh in the other case.

    Reference accented.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bachan Singh v. Ram Avadh
    (Nov 15, 1948)