Ohio Case Commentaries

Visiting-Judge Assignment Irregularities Render Judgments Voidable, Not Void: Ohio Supreme Court Reaffirms Limits of Habeas in Lowe v. Smith

Date: Oct 9, 2025

Visiting-Judge Assignment Irregularities Render Judgments Voidable, Not Void: Ohio Supreme Court Reaffirms Limits of Habeas in Lowe v. Smith Case: Lowe v. Smith, Warden, Slip Opinion No....

Commutation Is Not a New Judgment: Ohio Supreme Court Confirms Governor’s Power to Substitute LWOP for Death Without Ex Post Facto Implications

Date: Oct 9, 2025

Commutation Is Not a New Judgment: Ohio Supreme Court Confirms Governor’s Power to Substitute LWOP for Death Without Ex Post Facto Implications Case: State ex rel. Hawkins v. Frederick, Slip Opinion...

Pleading Matters in Election Mandamus: Generic “Any Other Relief” Is Insufficient to Compel an R.C. 3503.24(B) Hearing or Alternative Remedies

Date: Oct 9, 2025

Pleading Matters in Election Mandamus: Generic “Any Other Relief” Is Insufficient to Compel an R.C. 3503.24(B) Hearing or Alternative Remedies Introduction In State ex rel. Hicks v. Adams County...

No Prohibition for Procedural Missteps Under R.C. 2981.03: Subject-Matter Jurisdiction vs. Exercise of Jurisdiction in Post-Sentence Property-Return Orders

Date: Oct 9, 2025

No Prohibition for Procedural Missteps Under R.C. 2981.03: Subject-Matter Jurisdiction vs. Exercise of Jurisdiction in Post-Sentence Property-Return Orders Introduction This commentary analyzes the...

No Pro Se Representation of Others and Heightened Gatekeeping of Extraordinary Writs: Commentary on the Supreme Court of Ohio’s October 1, 2025 Case Announcements

Date: Oct 2, 2025

No Pro Se Representation of Others and Heightened Gatekeeping of Extraordinary Writs: Commentary on the Supreme Court of Ohio’s October 1, 2025 Case Announcements Introduction On October 1, 2025, the...

Ohio Supreme Court Clarifies: A Pending Adoption Petition Does Not Divest Juvenile Courts of Their Continuing Jurisdiction under R.C. 2151.353 and 2151.417

Date: Oct 2, 2025

Ohio Supreme Court Clarifies: A Pending Adoption Petition Does Not Divest Juvenile Courts of Their Continuing Jurisdiction under R.C. 2151.353 and 2151.417 Introduction In State ex rel. T.B. v....

No Mandamus to Force Prosecution of Private‑Citizen Affidavits under R.C. 2935.09/.10: Commentary on State ex rel. Rankin v. State, 2025-Ohio-4483

Date: Oct 2, 2025

No Mandamus to Force Prosecution of Private‑Citizen Affidavits under R.C. 2935.09/.10 In-depth Commentary on State ex rel. Rankin v. State, 2025-Ohio-4483 (Supreme Court of Ohio) Introduction This...

Agencies Need Not Run New Database Queries: Ohio Supreme Court Clarifies “Creation of a New Record” Under the Public Records Act

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Agencies Need Not Run New Database Queries: Ohio Supreme Court Clarifies “Creation of a New Record” Under the Public Records Act Introduction In State ex rel. Huwig v. Department of Health,...

Posthumous Vacatur of 2005 Registration Suspensions: Ohio Supreme Court Clarifies that Attorney Registration Sanctions Do Not Survive a Lawyer’s Death

Date: Sep 30, 2025

Posthumous Vacatur of 2005 Registration Suspensions: Ohio Supreme Court Clarifies that Attorney Registration Sanctions Do Not Survive a Lawyer’s Death Introduction In an Administrative Actions entry...

Continuing Jurisdiction to Correct Jail‑Time Credit During Appeal: The Ohio Supreme Court’s Clarification in Krouskoupf v. Anderson

Date: Sep 27, 2025

Continuing Jurisdiction to Correct Jail‑Time Credit During Appeal: The Ohio Supreme Court’s Clarification in Krouskoupf v. Anderson Introduction In Krouskoupf v. Anderson, Slip Opinion No....

County Auditors Have No Discretion to Withhold Listing of Voter‑Approved Bond Levies While Bonds Remain Outstanding (State ex rel. Springfield City School Dist. Bd. of Edn. v. Hamilton, 2025-Ohio-4427)

Date: Sep 27, 2025

County Auditors Have No Discretion to Withhold Listing of Voter‑Approved Bond Levies While Bonds Remain Outstanding Case: State ex rel. Springfield City School District Board of Education v....

Mandamus Is Not a Shortcut Around Nonfinal Custody Orders: State ex rel. Conomy v. Fuller (2025-Ohio-4411)

Date: Sep 26, 2025

Mandamus Is Not a Shortcut Around Nonfinal Custody Orders: State ex rel. Conomy v. Fuller Introduction In State ex rel. Conomy v. Fuller, 2025-Ohio-4411, the Supreme Court of Ohio reaffirmed core...

In Reopened Appeals, Appellants Must Brief Deficiency and Prejudice: No Presumption of Ineffective Assistance Under App.R. 26(B)

Date: Sep 26, 2025

In Reopened Appeals, Appellants Must Brief Deficiency and Prejudice: No Presumption of Ineffective Assistance Under App.R. 26(B) Introduction In State v. Clark, Slip Opinion No. 2025-Ohio-4410, the...

Noncompliance with R.C. 2969.25(C) Is Not an Affirmative Defense; Institutional‑Cashier Certification of Inmate Account Statements Is Mandatory for Fee-Waiver Requests

Date: Sep 25, 2025

Noncompliance with R.C. 2969.25(C) Is Not an Affirmative Defense; Institutional‑Cashier Certification of Inmate Account Statements Is Mandatory for Fee-Waiver Requests Introduction This commentary...

No Committee, No Replacement: Strict Pre-Filing Committee-of-Five Designation Required to Fill Nonpartisan Candidate Vacancies under R.C. 3513.31(F)

Date: Sep 11, 2025

No Committee, No Replacement: Strict Pre-Filing Committee-of-Five Designation Required to Fill Nonpartisan Candidate Vacancies under R.C. 3513.31(F) Introduction In State ex rel. Vermilion Campaign...

Ohio Supreme Court mandates facility‑specific “rate for direct care costs” drives 60% allocation to nursing‑home quality pool under R.C. 5165.26(E)

Date: Sep 4, 2025

Facility‑Specific “Rate for Direct Care Costs,” Not Group “Price,” Controls the 60% Quality‑Pool Allocation: A Textualist Course Correction in Medicaid Nursing‑Home Payments Case Overview Decision:...

Quo Warranto Is the Exclusive Vehicle to Remove a Committee-Appointed Township Trustee; Probate Judge’s Duty to Appoint under R.C. 503.24 Arises Only When a Vacancy Exists

Date: Aug 31, 2025

Quo Warranto Is the Exclusive Vehicle to Remove a Committee-Appointed Township Trustee; Probate Judge’s Duty to Appoint under R.C. 503.24 Arises Only When a Vacancy Exists Case: State ex rel....

Immediate Applicability of H.B. 265’s Public-Records Mandamus Prerequisites: Ohio Supreme Court Mandates Dismissal Without Pre‑Suit Complaint Affirmation

Date: Aug 31, 2025

Immediate Applicability of H.B. 265’s Public-Records Mandamus Prerequisites: Ohio Supreme Court Mandates Dismissal Without Pre‑Suit Complaint Affirmation Case: State ex rel. Jordan v. Dept. of...

Nonbypassable Transmission Riders Under R.C. 4928.05: Ohio Supreme Court Affirms PUCO’s Discretion and Demands Particularized Harm for Discovery Challenges

Date: Aug 31, 2025

Nonbypassable Transmission Riders Under R.C. 4928.05: Ohio Supreme Court Affirms PUCO’s Discretion and Demands Particularized Harm for Discovery Challenges Introduction In In re Application of Ohio...

Implicit Compliance with Adm.Code 4121-3-34(D)(3)(i): Hearing Officers Need Not Itemize Every Psychological Restriction in PTD Orders

Date: Aug 31, 2025

Implicit Compliance with Adm.Code 4121-3-34(D)(3)(i): Hearing Officers Need Not Itemize Every Psychological Restriction in PTD Orders Introduction In State ex rel. Urban v. Wano Expiditing, Inc.,...