Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 115, Civil Procedure Code, or Article 227 of the Constitution of India
  • Order XXIII, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code. The Civil Procedure Code
  • SECTION 9 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Order XXIII Rule 1(2) the provisions of Order XXIII Rule 1(3)
  • SECTION 17 PROVINCIAL SMALL CAUSE COURTS ACT
  • SECTION 80 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Order XXIII, Rule 1(2), Civil Procedure Code,
  • Order XXXIII, Rule 15, Civil Procedure Code,
  • Order VII, Rule 11(d), Civil Procedure Code,
  • Order XXIII, Rule 2, Civil Procedure Code.
  • Order XXIII, Rule I, Civil Procedure Code,
  • Order XXIII, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code,
  • Order XXIII, Rule 1, and this Rule
  • CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • claim.3. Order XXIII, Rule 2,
  • Order XXIII, Rule 1(2)(a)
  • Order XXIII Rule 1(2)
  • Order XXIII, Rule 2(3),
  • Order XXXIII, Rule 15,
  • Rule 1(2)(b)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 115, Civil Procedure Code, or Article 227 of the Constitution of India
  • Order XXIII, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code. The Civil Procedure Code
  • SECTION 9 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Order XXIII Rule 1(2) the provisions of Order XXIII Rule 1(3)
  • SECTION 17 PROVINCIAL SMALL CAUSE COURTS ACT
  • SECTION 80 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • Order XXIII, Rule 1(2), Civil Procedure Code,
  • Order XXXIII, Rule 15, Civil Procedure Code,
  • Order VII, Rule 11(d), Civil Procedure Code,
  • Order XXIII, Rule 2, Civil Procedure Code.
  • Order XXIII, Rule I, Civil Procedure Code,
  • Order XXIII, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code,
  • Order XXIII, Rule 1, and this Rule
  • CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • claim.3. Order XXIII, Rule 2,
  • Order XXIII, Rule 1(2)(a)
  • Order XXIII Rule 1(2)
  • Order XXIII, Rule 2(3),
  • Order XXXIII, Rule 15,
  • Rule 1(2)(b)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Bishan Narain, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 15 January 1949 the plaintiffs (Mela and Ganda) instituted a suit seeking a declaration that certain revenue entries were wrong and that they were the owners and in possession of the disputed land. That suit was withdrawn under Order XXIII, Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC). On 30 November 1949 the trial Court allowed withdrawal with liberty to institute a fresh suit, but ordered that the plaintiffs pay costs to defendant No. 1 (counsel's fee assessed at Rs. 10/-) and directed that the plaintiffs would not have the right to file a fresh suit without first paying those costs.

The plaintiffs instituted a fresh suit on 3 December 1949. On 3 February 1950 the defendants filed written statements and objected to the competency of the fresh suit on the ground that the required costs of the earlier suit had not been paid prior to institution. A preliminary issue was framed; the plaintiffs sought and were granted permission to deposit the costs and deposited the amount on 4 February 1950. Both lower Courts dismissed the fresh suit as not competent because the costs had not been paid before institution. The plaintiffs appealed to this Court by way of second appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the legal effect of non-observance of conditions (specifically payment of costs) imposed by a Court when allowing withdrawal of a suit with liberty to institute a fresh suit under Order XXIII, Rule 1(2), CPC?
  2. Does failure to pay costs required by the withdrawal-order before instituting the fresh suit deprive the Civil Court of jurisdiction to entertain the fresh suit (i.e., render the fresh suit void or incompetent), or does it amount to an irregularity remediable by subsequent deposit or procedural steps (e.g., rejection of the plaint or stay until payment)?
  3. What is the proper procedural remedy if the condition precedent (payment of costs) is not fulfilled before institution — dismissal of the suit, rejection of the plaint, or a stay until compliance — and what are the consequences for limitation?
  4. Whether the High Court has power under Section 115 CPC or Article 227 of the Constitution to amend terms imposed under Order XXIII, Rule 1(2), so as to cure non-compliance?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Purna Chandra Chatterjee v. Narendra Nath Chowdhury, I.L.R. 52 Cal. 894 Observation that a suit withdrawn with leave should be regarded as never brought; it does not save limitation nor give a fresh cause of action. Used to show that Order XXIII leave does not affect inherent jurisdiction and does not create a fresh cause of action or fresh limitation period.
Ohene Moore v. Akesseh Tayee, A.I.R. 1935 P.C. 5 Principle that statutory appeals exist only by statute and jurisdiction is subject to statutory conditions. Court distinguished this principle as inapplicable to Order XXIII, Rule 1(2) because no similar statutory condition is imposed there to oust jurisdiction.
Rachehu Singh v. The Secretary of State for India in Council, I.L.R. 25 All. 137 Non-compliance with certain statutory provisions (section 80) leads to rejection of plaint, not dismissal of suit. Adopted to support that failure to comply with conditions should lead to rejection or stay, not dismissal which would bar a fresh suit.
Abdul Aziz Molla v. Ebrahim Molla, I.L.R. 31 Cal. 965 Holding that a suit filed without compliance is not void ab initio and subsequent payment cures the irregularity; suggestion to stay till payment. Cited as authority supporting the view that non-payment is a curable irregularity and that stay until payment is appropriate (subject to limitation issues).
Gopi Lal v. Naggu Lal, 10 I.C. 6 Calcutta High Court view similar to Abdul Aziz Molla. Referenced as consistent authority favouring stay/rejection rather than voidness or dismissal.
Sajjad Hossain v. Ram Lal Shahu, 15 I.C. 159 Calcutta High Court view aligned with above. Used as part of a cluster of Calcutta decisions adopting a curative approach.
Amir Hushen v. Abdul Bari Khan, A.I.R. 1943 Cal. 860 Calcutta High Court decision supporting curative approach. Adduced in support of treating non-payment as curable irregularity.
Jadu Teli v. Mahboob Raza Khan, A.I.R. 1933 All. 810 Allahabad High Court adopted view that cure by deposit is possible and overruled Rachhpal Singh. Relied on to show that earlier strict view had been rejected by Allahabad High Court and to support curative approach.
Rachhpal Singh v. Sheo Rattan Singh, A.I.R. 1929 All. 692 Earlier decision holding strict compliance required (later overruled by Allahabad High Court). Noted by the Court as overruled in part; the Court rejects strict application of this authority to bar fresh suit by dismissal.
Dindayal Rai v. Indrasan Rai, A.I.R. 1926 Patna 472 Patna High Court view that supports curative approach. Used as additional authority consistent with the view that deposit cures defect.
Narsingh v. Nathuji, A.I.R. 1929 Nag. 135 Nagpur High Court similar view. Referenced as supporting authorities from other High Courts holding non-payment is curable.
Shidramappa Mutappa Biradar v. Mallappa Ramchandrappa Biradar, A.I.R. 1931 Bom. 257 Bombay decision (Baker, J.) following Rachhpal Singh: strict adherence to conditions; second suit dismissed if instituted without fulfilling conditions. Cited by respondent; court distinguished it as relying on a view later overruled and as not decisive for present case.
Ramakrishna Timmappa Shetti v. Hanumant Patgavi, A.I.R. 1950 Bom. 113 Bombay decision which left open the effect of payment after institution. Noted but held not to assist present case because it did not decide the key question.
Ma San Myint v. U. Ton Sein, A.I.R. 1939 Rang. 378 Held suit filed before payment void ab initio, relying on De Souza v. Coles (Letters Patent context). Cited and distinguished: Court held De Souza and the Rangoon decision relate to Letters Patent/original jurisdiction and are inapplicable to Order XXIII situations.
De Souza v. Coles, 1866 3 M.H.C.R. 384 Construction of Clause 10 of Letters Patent; jurisdiction on original side dependent on prior leave. Distinguished: principle not applicable because Order XXIII does not create or oust jurisdiction in the same manner.
Gollapudi Seshayya v. Nadendla Subbayya, A.I.R. 1924 Mad. 870 Held Court has no jurisdiction to entertain fresh suit if costs were not paid prior to its institution (relied on Rule 2(3)). Court disagreed: Rule 2(3) cannot operate once leave is granted under Rule 1(2); thus Gollapudi is not determinative here.
Abdul Rahman Syed Lal v. Aminabi Syed Lal, A.I.R. 1943 Bom. 409 Under Order XXXIII, Rule 15 — payment of costs of a pauper application is not a condition precedent to instituting an ordinary suit and can be waived; if unpaid court may reject plaint or stay but not dismiss. Used by analogy: the terms in previous suit resemble Order XXXIII, Rule 15 and support rejection/stay rather than dismissal.
Ramakrishna Nadar v. Ponnayya Thirumalai Vandaya Thevar, A.I.R. 1936 Mad. 24 Similar view to the above Bombay decisions on pauper applications. Cited as further authority aligning with the position that costs are not a condition precedent to an ordinary suit and remedies are rejection/stay.
Sham Sundar Lal v. Kunwar, I.L.R. 58 All. 191 F.B. Held suit not competent unless costs were paid before institution; relied on Ohene Moore. Court noted the decision but rejected its applicability, distinguishing Ohene Moore's principle and Order XXIII's different character.
Jeun Muchi v. Budhiram Muchi, I.L.R. 32 Cal. 339 Under section 17 Provincial Small Cause Courts Act — an application imperfect for lack of security is to be treated as pending until security is deposited; perfected on date of deposit. Adopted as persuasive analogy: where payment/security is made after presentation, the remedy is to treat the application/plaint as perfected on the date of deposit rather than to penalize earlier diligence.
V.M. Assan Mohamed Sahib v. M.E. Rahim Sahib, I.L.R. 48 Mad. 579 F.B. Supports the same principle as Jeun Muchi re deposit/curing of defects. Cited as consistent authority to support the Court's curative approach.
Mohan Lal v. Firm Muni Ram Nand Lal, A.I.R. 1946 Lah. 62 Similar view following Tara Chand line of authorities regarding post-presentation cure. Used to bolster the proposition that deposit cures the defect and the plaint can be treated as perfected on deposit.
Tara Chand Hira Chand Porwal v. Durappa Tavanappa Patrayali, A.I.R. 1943 Bom. 237 Authority in the line that an application may be perfected by subsequent compliance and should not be penalized. Referenced as part of supporting authorities for the court's position on curing procedural defects by subsequent compliance.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by identifying the narrow legal question: the effect of non-observance of conditions (here, payment of costs) imposed when a suit is withdrawn with liberty to institute a fresh suit under Order XXIII, Rule 1(2), CPC.

The Court analysed the relevant statutory scheme. It observed that Order XXIII, Rule 1(2) authorises a Court to allow withdrawal on such terms as it thinks fit, but the CPC does not itself prescribe the consequences of failing to comply with such terms. The Court emphasised that Order XXIII does not confer or take away the inherent jurisdiction of Civil Courts to entertain suits (jurisdiction is vested by section 9 CPC), and therefore the question is whether non-compliance with judicially imposed terms operates to divest the Civil Court of jurisdiction.

The Court concluded that the terms imposed when leave is granted are binding on the parties, but they are not statutory conditions precedent which, if not performed, deprive the Court of jurisdiction to entertain the fresh suit. Hence, mere non-payment of costs before institution amounts to an irregularity in procedure rather than to a jurisdictional defect rendering the suit void ab initio.

As to consequences and remedies, the Court explained that where a condition imposed is not complied with, the proper course is to treat the defect as one for which the plaint may be rejected under Order VII, Rule 11(d), CPC, or for the proceedings to be stayed until compliance, rather than dismissing the suit which would operate as a bar to fresh litigation. The Court relied on authorities holding that non-compliance with analogous statutory requirements (for example section 80 CPC) leads to rejection of the plaint rather than dismissal; it also cited multiple decisions that held subsequent deposit of costs cures the irregularity and that the Court may treat the plaint or application as perfected on the date of deposit.

The Court further reasoned that the High Court has ample power under Section 115 CPC or Article 227 of the Constitution to amend or relax the terms imposed under Order XXIII, Rule 1(2), either suo motu or on application, before or after institution of the fresh suit, in the interests of justice. That remedial jurisdiction supports a non-jurisdictional characterization of the condition.

The Court considered and distinguished cases taking a contrary view (including some Bombay and Rangoon decisions and decisions based on Letters Patent principles). It held those authorities either to be based on a different statutory context (e.g., original jurisdiction under Letters Patent) or to have been overruled or distinguishable on facts and principle.

Applying this analysis to the facts, the Court observed that the plaintiffs had in fact deposited the costs on 4 February 1950. The Court concluded that the defect (non-payment before institution) had been cured by deposit, and that the lower Courts were wrong to have dismissed the suit; at most the plaint could have been rejected or proceedings stayed until compliance, which would have permitted a fresh suit (or treated the plaint as perfected on deposit) without barring the plaintiffs' rights under limitation rules.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed. The orders of both lower Courts dismissing the suit are set aside and the case is remanded to the trial Court for decision on merits in accordance with law. (The judgment records: "Appeal accepted.")

Specific directions given by the Court (direct consequences for the parties):

  • No order as to costs of these appellate proceedings.
  • The parties are directed to appear before the trial Court on 1 November 1954.
  • Court-fee paid on this appeal is to be refunded.

Implications of the decision (as articulated by the Court):

  • Non-payment of costs ordered as a term of withdrawal under Order XXIII, Rule 1(2), CPC, is an irregularity in procedure and does not divest a Civil Court of jurisdiction to try the fresh suit.
  • Where such a condition is not complied with prior to institution, the appropriate remedies are rejection of the plaint on presentation or a stay of proceedings until compliance (subject to consideration of limitation under Order XXIII, Rule 2), not dismissal which would bar a fresh cause of action.
  • Subsequent deposit of the costs cures the procedural defect and the Court may, where appropriate, treat the plaint as perfected on the date of deposit.
  • The High Court has power under Section 115 CPC or Article 227 to amend or relax terms imposed under Order XXIII, Rule 1(2), in the interests of justice.

The opinion does not purport to lay down or frame a novel statutory rule altering Order XXIII; it applies existing principles and authorities to conclude that dismissal was incorrect and that the procedural defect was curable.

    Mela v. Labhu

    Bishan Narain, J.:— This second appeal raises a question as to the effect of non-observance of the conditions under which a suit is allowed to be withdrawn with liberty to bring a fresh suit.

    2. Mela and Ganda instituted a suit on the 15th January, 1949 for a declaration that the entries in the revenue papers are wrong and that in fact the plaintiffs are the owners and are as such in possession of the disputed land and the defendants have no rights therein. This suit was however, withdrawn under Order XXIII, Rule I, Civil Procedure Code, and the trial Court on the 30th November, 1949 passed an order granting permission to the plaintiffs to withdraw the suit and they were allowed to institute a fresh suit in respect of the same subject-matter. The plaintiffs were, however, ordered to pay costs of the suit to defendant No. 1 and counsel's fee was assessed at Rs. 10/-, but it was ordered that the plaintiffs will not have the right of filing a fresh suit without first paying the costs of the present suit. The plaintiffs after three days instituted the present suit on 3rd December, 1949. The next date fixed in the case was 3rd February, 1950 when the defendants filed their written statements and objected to the competency of the suit on the ground that the costs of the previous suit had not been paid. A preliminary issue was framed by the trial Court on the same day and at about the same time the plaintiffs made a written application for permission to deposit the costs of the suit and this permission was granted and the amount was deposited the next day. All these above facts are admitted by the parties to be correct, and the learned counsel for the defendants respondents has also admitted that if the suit had been filed on the 4th of February 1950 softer deposit of the costs, no objection like the present one could have been raised on any ground whatsoever. Both the lower Courts have dismissed the suit on the ground that the present suit was not competent inasmuch as the costs had not been paid in accordance with the order dated the 30th November, 1949 before institution of the present suit, and the plaintiffs have come to this Court in second appeal, and I have heard Mr. Shamair Chand, the learned counsel for the appellants, in support of it. Order XXIII, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code, reads as far as it is relevant in the present case, as follows—

    “23. (1) At any time after the institution of a suit the plaintiff may, as against all or any of the defendants, withdraw his suit or abandon part of his claim.

    (2) Where the Court is satisfied—

    (a) that a suit must fail by reason of some formal defect, or

    (b) * * * * * *

    it may, on such terms as it thinks fit, grant the plaintiff permission to withdraw from such suit or abandon such part of a claim with liberty to institute a fresh suit in respect of the subject-matter of such suit or such part of it claim.”

    3. Order XXIII, Rule 2, lays down that the plaintiff shall be bound by the law of limitation in the same manner as the first suit had not been instituted on permission granted under Order XXIII, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code. The Civil Procedure Code does not deal at and place with the consequences of the withdrawal of a suit excepting under Order XXIII, Rule 1, and this Rule does not specifically lay down that if a suit is withdrawn with liberty to file a fresh suit, then the fresh suit will not be competent unless the terms on which the suit is allowed to be withdrawn are performed previously, and it is obvious that this could not have been provided in the statute because the terms need not necessarily lay down any condition precedent which must be fulfilled before a fresh suit can be filed. It is, however, clear from the wording of Order XXIII, Rule 1(2) that the terms on which the plaintiff is allowed to withdraw the suit must be complied with. If the Court allowing withdrawal of the first suit merely orders that the costs are to be paid, then there is no doubt in my mind that the fresh suit can be filed leaving the defendants to realise their costs in accordance with law. Therefore there is no want of inherent jurisdiction in the Courts to entertain the fresh suit. When a suit is allowed to be withdrawn with leave to bring a fresh suit under Order XXIII, Civil Procedure Code, it should be regarded as never brought. It is available for no purpose. It does not save or give a fresh start to limitation, nor does it afford a fresh cause of action (vide observation of Suhrawardy, J. in Purna Chandra Chatterjee v. Narendra Nath Chowdhury . I.L.R 52 Cal. 894 at p. 909.). Civil Courts entertain a suit under section 9, Civil Procedure Code. Therefore, Order XXIII, Rule 1, does not affect the jurisdiction of Civil Courts to entertain a suit, and it neither confers nor takes away any jurisdiction vested in them. Order XXIII does not even lay down that the jurisdiction vested in law will not be exercised unless certain statutory conditions are fulfilled. It is true that the conditions imposed by the Court allowing the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit are binding on the parties, but the statute does not provide consequences which must follow if those conditions are not fulfilled and one must look to some other provision of law for that purpose. If the legislature intended to bar a fresh suit in case the conditions imposed by Court under Order XXIII, Rule 1(2) are not fulfilled, it could have done so particularly when it proceeds to provide in sub-clause (3) that if a suit is withdrawn without permission, then a fresh suit in respect of the same subject-matter is barred. I may here state that in my opinion a suit withdrawn with permission subject to a condition precedent can never amount to a withdrawal of a suit without permission even if the terms imposed by the Court are not fulfilled. Once an order is passed under Order XXIII Rule 1(2) the provisions of Order XXIII Rule 1(3) can never become applicable to that case. It cannot therefore be said that a Court entertaining the fresh suit gets its jurisdiction from the order passed under Order XXIII Rule 1(2) and therefore it cannot try it unless the statutory condition subject to which jurisdiction is conferred on the Court must be previously fulfilled. The principles applicable to cases where Courts have no jurisdiction unless the statutory conditions an fulfilled are not applicable to cases like the present one and therefore decisions under section 80, Civil Procedure Code, or under Clauses of Letters Patent giving jurisdiction to High Courts on the original side are not applicable at this stage I may refer to the decision by their Lordships of the Privy Council in Ohene Moore v. Akesseh Tayee . A.I.R 1935 P.C 5., wherein it was observed—

    “It is to be remembered that all appeals in this country and elsewhere exist merely by statute and unless the statutory conditions are fulfilled no jurisdiction is given to any Court of Justice to entertain them”.

    4. In mf opinion this decision has no application to the present case because no such statutory condition has been enacted in Order XXIII Rule 1(2) which must be fulfilled before Court gets jurisdiction to entertain the fresh suit. Another aspect of the matter is that this Court has ample power under section 115, Civil Procedure Code, or Article 227 of the Constitution of India to amend the terms imposed under Order XXIII Rule 1(2) whether a High Court calls for the record suo motu or otherwise before or after the institution of the fresh suit in the interests of justice. If this be so the fresh suit filed without fulfilling the conditions imposed by the Court when granting leave must be considered to be validly instituted if the terms are amended by the High Court subsequently removing the conditions precedent imposed. This result could never be achieved in cases like the case reported in Ohene Moore v. Akesseh Tayee.

    5. Therefore, if a suit is filed without payment of costs when liberty to file it has been given under Order XXIII, Rule 1(2), then in my opinion it merely amounts to an irregularity in the initial procedure which does not effect the inherent jurisdiction and competence of the Court to entertain a suit. If that be so, the non-payment of costs in a case where such payment has been made condition precedent for filing a fresh suit merely has a consequence of the suit being barred by law in terms of Order XXIII, Rule 1(2), Civil Procedure Code, and all that a Court can do is to apply Order VII, Rule 11(d), Civil Procedure Code, and reject the plaint. It is not clear to me however how the Court can dismiss a suit under such circumstances as distinct front rejecting a plaint. It has been laid down in Rachehu Singh v. The Secretary of State for India in Council . I.L.R 25 All. 137. that non-compliance with the provisions of section 80, Civil Procedure Code, involves rejection of the plaint and not dismissal of the suit. If the plaint is rejected then a fresh suit can always be tiled after fulfilling the required conditions. I am therefore of the opinion that in such circumstances the Court should exercise its discretion and stay the proceedings till the plaintiff fulfils the required conditions instead of rejecting the plaint immediately. Of course if the plaintiff fails to fulfil the conditions within a reasonable time, then the Court must reject the plaint leaving it open to the plaintiff to file a fresh suit within limitation it so advised after fulfilling the conditions, but the Court cannot dismiss the suit which would bar a fresh suit. It was held in a case similar to the present one in Abdul Aziz Molla v. Ebrahim Molla . I.L.R 31 Cal. 965., that such a suit is not void ab initio and that subsequent payment of costs will cure the irregularity in filing the suit and it was suggested in that judgment that the suit should be stayed till costs are paid subject of course to any question of limitation that the defendant might raise as contemplated under Order XXIII, Rule 2, Civil Procedure Code. A similar view was taken in the Calcutta High Court in cases reported as Gopi Lal v. Naggu Lal . 10 I.C 6., Sajjad Hossain v. Ram Lal Shahu . 15 I.C 159. and Amir Hushen v. Abdul Bari Khan . A.I.R 1943 Cal. 860.. The Allahabad High Court in Jadu Teli v. Mahboob Raza Khan . A.I.R 1933 All. 810., has also taken the same view after overruling Rachhpal Singh v. Sheo Rattan Singh . A.I.R 1929 All. 692., that if the non-payment of costs before the institution of the suit is considered to be a defect as to make the suit premature, then the plaintiff can file another suit after he has made the deposit. It was further observed in that case that in any case the Court can certainly treat the plaint as having been filed on the day on which deposit was made. The Patna and the Nagpur High Courts have also taken a similar view, vide Dindayal Rai v. Indrasan Rai . A.I.R 1926 Patna 472., and Narsingh v. Nathuji . A.I.R 1929 Nag. 135..

    6. The learned counsel for the respondents, Mr. K.C Nayar, has drawn my attention to two Bombay cases in which, according to him, opposite view has been taken. In Shidramappa Mutappa Biradar v. Mallappa Ramchandrappa, Biradar . A.I.R 1931 Bom. 257., Baker, J. following Rachhpal Singh v. Sheo Ratan Singh, expressed himself in these terms—

    “There is no reason why if the permission to file a second suit had been granted subject to a condition, the plaintiff should not be held strictly to that condition and his second suit dismissed if he attempts to file it without having fulfilled the condition on which he secured permission”

    7. The facts in that case were that the plaintiffs after withdrawing their first suit on terms filed a second suit without fulfilling the conditions and withdrew it and then filed a third suit without paying costs of the first and the second suits and under these circumstances the learned Judge relied on Rachhpal Singh v. ??? Ratan Singh which it will be observed has been overruled by the Allahabad High Court in Jadu Teli v. Mahboob Raza Khan. It is correct that the plaintiff must fulfil conditions imposed on him under Order XXIII, Rule 1(2), but failure to do so entails at the most rejection of the plaint and not dismissal of the suit. In Ramakrishna Timmappa Shetti v. Hanumant Patgavi . A.I.R 1950 Bom. 113., this question was left open by observations—

    “We do not wish to express any opinion as to the effect of the payment of costs after the institution of the suit”.

    8. And therefore this decision is of no assistance in the present case and it cannot be said that the view of the Bombay High Court is opposed to the view I have taken above. In Ma San Myint v. U. Ton Sein . A.I.R 1939 Rang. 378. a Single Judge of that Court held in circumstances similar to those in the present case that if the suit is filed before payment of costs, then the second suit is void ab initio. For this conclusion Ba U.J has relied on De Souza v. Coles . 1866 3 M.H.C.R 384., but that decision relates to construction of Clause 10 of Letters Patent from which it is obvious that the Courts on the original side had no jurisdiction at all the entertain the suit unless leave is previously obtained for entertainment of such a suit, and as I have already stated that principle has no application to a case like the present one. The learned counsel for the respondents has drawn my attention to a single Bench decision in Gollapudi Seshayya v. Nadendla Subbayya . A.I.R 1924 Mad 870., where it was held that the Court has no jurisdiction to entertain a fresh suit if costs are not paid prior to its institution and in that case reliance was placed on Order XXIII, Rule 2(3), which precludes a Court from entertaining a second suit when no permission has been granted. With due respect to the learned Judge I am of the opinion as stated above that Order XXIII Rule 2(3) can never come into operation once leave to file a fresh suit is granted although certain conditions have been imposed by the Court while granting the necessary leave. I am therefore of the opinion that the cases cited by the learned counsel for the respondents are of no assistance to him.

    9. I am fortified in my view by the consideration that leave to wish-draw a suit is to be granted by the Court under Order XXIII, Rule 1(2)(a) on ground of some formal defect or under Rule 1(2)(b) on some sufficient grounds which have been construed by the Courts as on grounds of the same nature as specified in sub-clause (a), vide observations of Mookerjee, J. in Kharda Co. Ltd. v. Durga Charan Chandra . 5 I.C 187.. Thus the leave is to be granted on grounds of formal defect or on analogous grounds. In such circumstances it would be extremely inequitable that the plaintiff should lose valuable rights or claim by merely filing a suit without complying with the conditions which in the very nature of things cannot bear any proportion to the stake involved in the litigation. In the present case the costs have been assessed to be Rs. 20/-, while the suit involved a claim relating to 3 kanals 10 marlas of land. It appears to me to be extremely inequitable that in such circumstances plaintiff should be precluded from asserting his claim to this area of land. I can visualize cases where costs to be paid before institution of the suit may not amount to more than a few hundreds of rupees while the claim involved may extend to lacs. The object of all rules of procedure is to advance justice and mitigate hardship. After all Courts of law are not meant for enforcing discipline but their aim is to do substantial justice between the parties and therefore construction should be placed on a statute if at all possible which advances this aim.

    10. A similar provision is found in Order XXXIII, Rule 15, Civil Procedure Code, which reads—

    “An order refusing to allow the applicant to sue as a pauper shall be a bar to any subsequent application of the like nature by him in respect of the same right to sue; but the applicant shall be at liberty to institute a suit in the ordinary manner in respect of such right, provided that he first pays the costs (if any) incurred by the State and by the opposite party in opposing his application for leave to sue as a pauper.”

    11. I am not called upon to construe this provision of law, but I am of the opinion that decisions under Order XXXIII, Rule 15, are revelant for the decision of the question involved in the present case. It will be observed that there is a marked distinction in the language of the first part of the Rule and the latter part. Dismissal of a pauper application is to be a bar to a similar application, but it is not provided in terms that non-payment of the costs of pauper application is to be a bar to an ordinary suit. It was laid down in Abdul Rahman Syed Lal v. Aminabi Syed Lal . A.I.R 1943 Bom. 409. that under Rule 15 the payment of costs of a pauper application directed to be paid is not a condition precedent to the institution of an ordinary suit and can be waived, and it was further laid down that the costs, however, must be paid and if they are not paid and the matter is brought to the notice of the Court, then the Court should reject the plaint on presentation, or subsequently stay the suit pending their payment but the Court is not bound to dismiss the suit. The order of the Court in the previous suit by the present appellants is almost in the same terms as a second portion of Order XXXIII, Rule 15, and therefore the construction placed thereon is helpful in deciding the present appeal. A similar view was taken in Ramakrishna Nadar v. Ponnayya Thirumalai Vandaya Thevar . A.I.R 1936 Mad. 24.. I am conscious of the fact that a different view was taken in Sham Sundar Lal v. ??? Kunwar . I.L.R 58 All. 191 F.B., where it has been laid down that the suit was not competent unless the costs were paid before its institution and their Lordships of the Allahabad High Court based their decision on the case reported in Ohene Moore v. Akesseh Tayee, but with due respect to the Judges of the Allahabad High Court I am of the opinion that the principles laid down in Ohene Moore v. Akesseh Tayee as stated above, have no application to Order XXIII Rule 1(2), Civil Procedure Code Moreover, it is not open to Courts of law to amend the conditions laid down under Order XXXIII, Rule 15, Civil Procedure Code, but the High Court can always amend the conditions laid down under Order XXIII, Rule 1(2), and for this reason also I am of the opinion that the strict interpretation which found favour with the Allahabad High Court cannot be applied to the present case.

    12. Another similar provision is to be found in section 17 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act the revelant portion of which reads as follows—

    “Provided that an application for an order to set aside a decree passed ex-parte or for a review of Judgment shall, at the time of presenting his application, either deposit in the Court the amount due from him under the decree or in pursuance of the judgment, or give such security for the performance of the decree or compliance with the judgment as the Court may, on a previous application made by him in this behalf, have directed.”

    13. Thus, this section contemplates that costs must be paid or security must he given at the time of presenting the application, and it was held in Jeun Muchi v. Budhiram Muchi . I.L.R 32 Cal. 339., that when the applicant did not comply with all the formalities required under this section even then it just be considered that the application was pending on the day when the security was actually deposited and the application therefore might well be treated as having been perfected on that day; the position of the applicant ought not to be worse than what it would have been, if he had presented the application along with security subsequently and to hold otherwise would lead to the conclusion that the petitioner ought to be punished for his diligence in presenting the application earlier than he need have done under the law. The underlined passage fully applies to the facts of the present case. A similar view was taken in V.M Assan Mohamed Sahib v. M.E Rahim Sahib . I.L.R 48 Mad. 579 F.B., and Mohan Lal v. Firm Muni Ram Nand Lal . A.I.R 1946 Lah. 62. which follows Tara Chand Hira Chand Porwal v. Durappa Tavanappa Patrayali . A.I.R 1943 Bom. 237., which is also to the same effect.

    14. For the reasons given above, I am of the opinion that the lower Courts were wrong in dismissing the present suit and that at best the plaint could have been rejected. The consequance of the rejection of the plaint, however, would have been that a fresh suit could have been filed on the 4th of February 1950 and therefore in the circumstances the Courts would have been well-advised to have stayed the proceedings till the defect in the filing of the suit was cured. The costs were deposited on the 4th February, 1950 and therefore no defect exists in the present suit at the present time.

    15. I therefore accept this appeal, set aside the orders of both the Courts and remand the case to the trial Court for decision on merits in accordance with law. There will be no order as to costs of these proceedings. The parties have been directed to appear before the trial Court on 1st November, 1954. Court-fee paid on this appeal be refunded.

    16. Appeal accepted.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mela v. Labhu
    (Sep 30, 1954)