Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Docket Number 10628 Attorney(S) Messrs. Raysor, Moss Lide, for appellant, cite: Amendment of Constitution regulated: Art. XVI Const. 1895. Senate Journal must be looked to: 100 S.C. 173 Failure of journal to show negative votes is fatal: 131 N.C. 657, 43 S.E. 3; Modified in 143 N.C. 110, 55 S.E. 442; also see: 200 S.W. 997, (Ark.); 33 Ark. 17. Messrs. John S. Bowman, Nathans Sinkler, for respondents, cite: Case at 131 N.C. 657 was overruled in 143 N.C. 110. There was substantial compliance by the Legislature: 12 S.C. 289; 145 Fed. Rep. 765; 93 N.E. 244; 43 S.E. 3 See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. THOMPSON v. LIVINGSTON, MAYOR. June 2, 1921. The opinion of the Court was delivered by MR. JUSTICE COTHRAN. For the reasons assigned by his Honor, Judge Bowman, it is the judgment of this Court that the judgment of the Circuit Court be affirmed.