Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 13 PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • SECTION 43 EVIDENCE ACT 1872
  • Section 227 and 228 of the Cr.P.C. 39.
  • Section 227 and Section 228 Cr.P.C,
  • Section 13(1)(e) of the PC Act, 1988
  • section 13(1)(e) {old section 5(1)(e)}
  • Section 227 Cr.P.C
  • Section 13(2) read with 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
  • Sections 109 IPC read with 13(2) read with 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
  • Sections 227 or 228 Cr.P.C.,
  • Sections 13(2) read with 13(1)(e) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and under Sections 120-B and 109 of IPC.
  • u/s. 13(1)(e) of the P.C. Act-1988
  • Section 239 Cr.P.C,
  • s. 106 of the Evidence Act.
  • Section Officer, Criminal Section, Madras High Court. Page 41 of 42 P.VELMURUGAN, J
  • Section 173 Cr.P.C,
  • Section 239 Cr.P.C., in C.M.P.Nos.773, 1164, 1165 & 598 of 2016
  • Section 107 IPC punishable under Section 109 IPC
  • Section 120-B, Section 302 read with Sections 120-B/34, Section 201 IPC and Section 25 of the Arms Act
  • 691 ..Clause (e) of sub-section (1) of section 13 corresponds to clause (e) of sub-section (1) of section 5 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947
  • Section 2(c) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. A2
  • Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872
  • Section 109 IPC. Page 16 of 42 14. Investigation
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 13 PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • SECTION 43 EVIDENCE ACT 1872
  • Section 227 and 228 of the Cr.P.C. 39.
  • Section 227 and Section 228 Cr.P.C,
  • Section 13(1)(e) of the PC Act, 1988
  • section 13(1)(e) {old section 5(1)(e)}
  • Section 227 Cr.P.C
  • Section 13(2) read with 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
  • Sections 109 IPC read with 13(2) read with 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
  • Sections 227 or 228 Cr.P.C.,
  • Sections 13(2) read with 13(1)(e) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and under Sections 120-B and 109 of IPC.
  • u/s. 13(1)(e) of the P.C. Act-1988
  • Section 239 Cr.P.C,
  • s. 106 of the Evidence Act.
  • Section Officer, Criminal Section, Madras High Court. Page 41 of 42 P.VELMURUGAN, J
  • Section 173 Cr.P.C,
  • Section 239 Cr.P.C., in C.M.P.Nos.773, 1164, 1165 & 598 of 2016
  • Section 107 IPC punishable under Section 109 IPC
  • Section 120-B, Section 302 read with Sections 120-B/34, Section 201 IPC and Section 25 of the Arms Act
  • 691 ..Clause (e) of sub-section (1) of section 13 corresponds to clause (e) of sub-section (1) of section 5 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947
  • Section 2(c) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. A2
  • Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872
  • Section 109 IPC. Page 16 of 42 14. Investigation
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State v. P.Prabhu

    Crl.R.C.Nos.110 to 113 of 2018.

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

    RESERVED ON : 06.01.2025

    PRONOUNCED ON : 28.04.2025

    CORAM

    THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE P.VELMURUGAN Crl.R.C.(MD)Nos.110 to 113 of 2018

    ... Petitioner State represented by The Public Prosecutor High Court, Madras 600 104 [V and AC., Dindigul] Crime No.1 of 2012 Vs

    P.Prabhu ... Respondent in Crl.R.C(MD) No.110 of 2018/A4 I.Periasamy ... Respondent in Crl.R.C(MD) No.111 of 2018/A1 I.P.Senthilkumar ... Respondent in Crl.R.C(MD) No.112 of 2018/A3 P.Suseela ... Respondent in Crl.R.C(MD) No.113 of 2018/A2

    COMMON PRAYER: Criminal Revision Petitions filed under Sections 397 and 401 of Cr.P.C., to set aside the order of discharge passed by the Chief Judicial Magistrate cum Special Judge for Prevention of Corruption Act Cases, Dindigul in C.M.P.Nos.773, 1164, 1165 & 598 of 2016 in Special Case No.27 of 2014 [common order passed in C.M.P.Nos.1164, 598, 1165 and 773 of 2016 dated 28.04.2017].

    Page 1 of 42

    For Petitioner : Mr.J.Ravindran, AAG Assisted by

    Mr.S.Vinoth Kumar

    Government Advocate (Crl.Side) in all Crl.R.Cs

    For Respondent

    in Crl.R.C(MD)

    Nos.110 and 112 of 2018 : Mr.Arun Anbumani for Mr.L.Ramesh Kumar

    For Respondent

    in Crl.R.C(MD)

    Nos.111 and 113 of 2018: Mr.A.K.Sriram, Senior Advocate for Mr.K.Muthu Ganesa Pandian

    C O M M ON O R D E R

    The Criminal Revision Petitions have been filed to set aside the common order dated 28.04.2017 passed in C.M.P.Nos.773, 1164, 1165 & 598 of 2016 in Special Case No.27 of 2014 by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate cum Special Judge for Prevention of Corruption Act Cases, Dindigul.

    2. The case of the prosecution is that A1, who is the respondent in Crl.R.C(MD) No.111 of 2018 was a Member of the Legislative Assembly and became the Minister for Revenue and Prisons Department, Government of Tamil Nadu during the period from

    Page 2 of 42

    13.05.2006 to 31.03.2010. A2 is the wife, A3 and A4 are sons of A1, respectively. During his position as Minister, he had accumulated properties and pecuniary resources which are disproportionate to his known sources of income. After a detailed investigation, the Investigating agency found that the accused No.1 after acquiring considerable properties and pecuniary resources derived through unknown sources, converted the same in the form of properties and securities in his name and his family members viz. A2 to A4 with their knowledge and consent. Further, the accused did not have sufficient means and sources of income to acquire those properties and pecuniary resources. Hence, a case was registered in Crime No.1 of 2012 against the accused persons, by the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Agency, Dindigul for the offences under Sections 13(2) read with 13(1)(e) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and under Sections 120-B and 109 of IPC.

    3. After completion of investigation, the Investigating Officer filed a charge sheet dated 24.08.2012 along with statements I to VII

    Page 3 of 42

    against all the accused for the check period 13.05.2006 to 31.03.2010 before the learned Special Judge, Special Court for Prevention of Corruption Act Cases, Madurai and the same was taken on file in C.C.No.1 of 2013 and subsequently transferred to the Chief Judicial Magistrate cum Special Judge for Prevention of Corruption Act Caes, Dindigul and same was taken on file in Special CC.No.27 of 2014. Pending CC, the respondents have filed the petitions under Section 239 Cr.P.C., in C.M.P.Nos.773, 1164, 1165 & 598 of 2016 to discharge them from the charges levelled against them. The learned Special Judge, vide common order dated 28.04.2017, discharged the accused/respondents herein by allowing the petitions filed by them. Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner/State has filed this Criminal Revision Petitions.

    4. Learned Additional Advocate General appearing for the petitioner submitted that A1 became the Minister for Law and Revenue, Government of Tamil Nadu on 13.05.2006 and continued up to 13.02.2007 and then, he was the Minister for Revenue and Prisons from 13.02.2007 to 27.09.2007 and then, he was the Minister for Revenue and

    Page 4 of 42

    Housing from 27.09.2007 to 14.05.2011. The accused No.1, during his position as a Minister, the check period was determined between 13.05.2006 and 31.03.2010. The value of assets stood to the credit of A1 and his family members who are A2 to A4 at the beginning of the check period as on 13.05.2006 is Rs.1,17,61,390.65/-. The value of assets stood to the credit of A1 and his family members at the end of check period as on 31.03.2010 is Rs.3,26,04,988.21/-. Hence, the assets acquired by the accused persons during the abovesaid check period were arrived at Rs.2,08,43,597.56/-. Likely, savings of A1 and his family members were arrived at Rs.7,08,445.40/- The assets disproportionate to known sources of income of the accused persons is Rs.2,01,35,152.16/-. Since A1 as a public servant, during the period between 13.05.2006 and 31.03.2010, was in possession of pecuniary resources, movable and immovable properties in his name and also in the name of his family members viz., A2 to A4, which were disproportionate to their known resources of income. Hence, A1 committed the offence under Section 13(2) read with 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. In the course of same transaction, A2 to A4, who abetted A1 by

    Page 5 of 42

    intentionally allowing A1 to acquire a substantial portion of his assets in their names and by holding those assets on behalf of A1 and hence, they committed offence under Sections 109 IPC read with 13(2) read with 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act.

    5. Learned Additional Advocate General appearing for the petitioner/State further submitted that without appreciating the materials available on record and without considering the value of the documentary evidence, the learned Special Judge passed the impugned order. Though the income tax returns may be a material document, the same cannot be the ground to hold that it is a conclusive document. The respondents have placed much reliance on the Income Tax Returns filed by them. Mere filing of Income Tax Returns before the Income Tax Authority would not prove that they had earned that income from the sources mentioned by them. The Special Court ignored the materials and the counter placed by the prosecution. Mere filing of Income Tax Returns before the Income Tax Authority cannot be put to hold that the respondents had earned the income from the lawful sources. Further, the

    Page 6 of 42

    Income Tax Returns filed by the respondents herein are found to have been accepted summarily and the Income Tax Authority did not make any probe as to whether the respondents had actually derived the income as shown in their Income Tax Return Statement. The Special Court simply reproduced the submission of the counsel for the respondents/accused. Hence, the common order passed by the trial court discharging the respondents/A1 to A4 is liable to be dismissed.

    6. Learned Senior counsel appearing for the respondents/A1 and A2 submitted that the Respondent in Crl.R.C(MD) No.111 of 2018/A1 has been elected as a Member of the Legislative Assembly for six times and held the office of the Minister for various Departments in the Government of Tamil Nadu. Apart from the salary and pension derived by the respondent (A1), he inherited ancestral agricultural lands and derived income therefrom since 1972. A1 filed the Income Tax Returns by disclosing all his personal income, ancestral properties and agricultural income derived therefrom and purchase of properties from his personal income and the income derived from ancestral properties.

    Page 7 of 42

    The properties were purchased out of the income derived from the ancestral agricultural properties. Pursuant to the family arrangement of sharing the income from the agricultural ancestral properties, 50% share of the income was held by the respondent/A1 and 35% share of income was given to the respondent/A3 and 15% share of income was given to the respondent/A4. When the respondents/A3 & A4 became an independent Income Tax Assessee on and from 01.04.2005 and 01.04.2006 respectively filed their respective Income Tax Returns in their names. A3 and A4 had independent sources of income from their ancestral properties. A1 had income from his ancestral properties for a long period. One property was purchased in the name of A2 from the lawful known sources of income of A1 as gift and the other three properties were purchased by A3, out of his independent known sources of income. All the said four properties were borne out by registered documents, banking transactions and IT Returns. Though A1 to A4 had separate accounts, income and IT Returns in their respective names, income of A1 to A4 were shown as joint income by the Investigating Agency. Suppressing the independent sources of income, the

    Page 8 of 42

    investigating agency clubbed the income, cash on hand and expenditure of A2 to A4 with the income of the first accused.

    7. He further submitted that the independent capital of accused 1, 3 and 4 was wrongly included in Item Nos.62,63 and 64 in the Statement-I and the same reflected in the independent assets acquired by them, prior to the check period. Property in Item No.55 shown in Statement-II was purchased by A2 from the gift amount received from A1 through his lawful sources of income and hence, there is no possession of disproportionate asset by A2, during the check period. Except the said Item No.55 in Statement-II, all other movable and immovable assets were acquired and purchased prior to the check period. He further submitted that except Items 62,63,64 and 65 in Statement-II held by A1 during the check period, all other items belonging to A1 were purchased prior to check period dated 13.05.2006 and no property was purchased in the name of A1 and A4 during the check period. Items mentioned in Statement-I are ancestral properties of A1, A3 and A4 and the same were inherited by A3 and A4, when they were minors and those

    Page 9 of 42

    properties were managed by A1. Item No.1 in Statement-III, monthly salary and pension was wrongly shown as Rs.10,56,502/-. A1 and A3 had jointly obtained loan of Rs.7,00,000/- in their names and repaid the same at Rs.3,50,000/- each as their respective share of loan and the same has not been considered in item No.5 of Statement-IV.

    8. Learned counsel for the respondents further submitted that A1 had source of monthly income as a Minister of State, monthly pension and 50% share of income from agricultural lands, bank interest etc., All the income, purchase of Item No.55 in Statement -II and gift in favour of his wife/A2 were disclosed in the IT Returns filed by A1. The Income Tax Authorities have also passed assessment orders. A2 has also become an Income Tax Assessee for the said property. Apart from Item No.55, all the movable and immovable properties mentioned in Statement -II were purchased by A1 and A2 within their known sources of income, whereas the Investigating Agency stated that all the items found in Statement-II were acquired by A1 on behalf of A2 to A4, despite they have independent and separate income derived by them.,

    Page 10 of 42

    Except items 62 to 65 all other items in Statement-II were purchased, prior to check period dated 13.05.2006 and no property was purchased in the name of A1 during the check period. The gift of money, gold and articles given by the A2's relatives at the time of marriage, birth of children and other functions are not the assets of A1. Except A1 and A2 are the parents of A3 and A4, no other material is available to prove the commission of the alleged offences. The trial court rightly found that the prosecution had omitted the sources of income of the respondents through agriculture. The trial court rightly held that the clubbing of properties of A1 with the properties of A2 to A4 is impermissible. Hence, the trial court allowed the discharge petitions filed by the respondents herein.

    9. Learned counsel for the respondents/A3 and A4 submitted that the respondents (A3 and A4) had known sources of income for a long period prior to the check period. A1 who is the father of A3 and A4 had acquired several properties in his name from the income derived from the ancestral agricultural lands, since 1972. On 31.03.2005, there was a

    Page 11 of 42

    family arrangement for division of proportionate shares of income from the ancestral properties and the properties purchased in their name out of the income from their ancestral properties and the properties of A3 and A4 were maintained by A1. Since A3 and A4 became independent by division of shares of proportionate income from the agricultural properties and properties purchased in their respective names, they registered them as an independent Income Tax Assessees from 01.04.2005. All the independent income and independent known sources of income of respective respondents were disclosed in IT Returns filed by them. Though the respondents/A3 and A4 had separate and independent income derived by them from their known sources of income, the Investigating Officer wrongly arrived the value of assets at Rs.3,26,04,988/-. All the accounts for independent income and expenditure of A3 and A4 were clubbed together with the income of A1. The respondents (A3 and A4) have disclosed all known sources of their income and filed their IT Returns. Neither recovery of money nor undisclosed wealth was found out from the respondents herein. There is no evidence available against the respondents/A3 and A4 for being in

    Page 12 of 42

    possession of disproportionate assets. The trial court rightly rejected the petitioner's petition and discharged the respondents from their charges levelled against them. Hence, he prayed for the dismissal of this criminal revision petitions.

    10. Learned counsel for the respondents further submitted that when there is no dispute regarding the Income Tax Returns, agricultural income was not properly accounted for by the prosecution. When the IT Returns were scrutinized by the officers periodically and order was passed by the competent quasi-judicial authority, the same cannot be brushed aside. The trial Court rightly found that no property was acquired by the respondents during the check period and items 10,12 and 15 mentioned in the Statement-I are ancestral properties of the respondents and the same were inherited by A3 and A4, which continued under the management of A1. Further, during the check period, A4 had sufficient rental income from Item No.15 and he had salary income for a sum of Rs.3,00,000/- from the year 2007 to 2011. The item 72 in Statement-II was acquired through agricultural income of 15% from his

    Page 13 of 42

    ancestral properties and the same has been reflected in his IT Returns. Accepting the same, the Income Tax Authorities have also passed the assessment orders. The prosecution has wrongly included the capital accounts, which is in the liability side of the balance sheet, after taking the assets on the assets side of the balance sheet and further omitted the agricultural income which was scrutinized by competent quasi-judicial authorities.

    11. Heard the learned Additional Advocate General assisted by the learned Government Advocate (Crl.Side) appearing for the petitioner, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondents/A1 and A2 and the learned counsel appearing for the respondents/A3 and A4 and perused the materials available on record.

    12. The specific case of the prosecution as per the charge sheet filed before the Special Court is that A1 was the Minister for Revenue and Prison Department, Government of Tamil Nadu between 13.05.2006 and 31.03.2010. He contested the Assembly Election during 2006 and

    Page 14 of 42

    was elected in the Athur Assembly Constituency and sworn in as a Minister. He completed his five years tenure. When he again contested in the same Athur Assembly Constituency in the Assembly Elections held in 2011, he was elected as M.L.A and continued as such, and he is a public servant as defined under Section 2(c) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. A2 is the wife of A1. A3 and A4 are the sons of A1 and A2. A1 hails from an agricultural family and A2's parents are not sound enough to extend any financial assistance to A1. A3 is a Law Graduate and contested the Assembly Elections held during 2011 from the Palani Assembly Constituency and he was defeated. A3 submitted his IT Returns from 2007-2008 onwards. A4 is also a B.Com Graduate living with his parents and now working as Manager in Alamelu Ammal Mills India Private Limited, Ottupatti near Batlagundu, Dindigul. For the purpose of this case, the check period was fixed between 13.05.2006 and 31.03.2010. The value of assets stood to the credit of A1 and his family members at the beginning of the check period as on 13.05.2006 was Rs.1,17,61,390.65/-. The value of assets stood to the credit of A1 and his family members at the end of the check period as on 31.03.2010 was

    Page 15 of 42

    Rs.3,26,04,988.21/-. Hence, the assets acquired by A1 and his family members during the said check period were arrived at Rs.2,08,43,597.56/-. The income of A1 and his family members during the check period was Rs.1,07,52,621/-. The expenditure incurred by A1 and his family members was Rs.1,00,44,175.60/-. Hence, the savings of A1 and his family members were Rs.7,08,445.40p. The assets disproportionate to the known sources of income of A1 and his family members is Rs.2,01,35,152.16p. Hence, the value of disproportionate assets is 187.25% and for which A1 and is family members were unable to account for satisfactorily to the said acquisition of assets.

    13. A2 to A4 during the check period, facilitated A1 within the meaning of Section 107 IPC punishable under Section 109 IPC to acquire assets in their names which were disproportionate to their known sources of income of A1 and thereby, A1 to A4 have committed the offence punishable under Section 13(2) read with 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and also read with Section 109 IPC.

    Page 16 of 42

    14. Investigation disclosed that A1, after acquiring considerable properties and pecuniary resources derived through unknown sources, also converted the same in the form of properties and securities in the name of his family members with their knowledge and consent. By letter dated 20.06.2012, A1 was called upon to account for the quantum of properties and pecuniary resources held by him in his name. A1 has given his explanation on 02.07.2012. The Investigating Officer after considering the explanation offered by A1 and also the statement recorded by the Investigating Officer during investigation, came to the conclusion that A1 was not able to account for his income satisfactorily for the abovesaid quantum of properties which were found to be disproportionate and A1 did not have sufficient means and sources of income to acquire those properties and pecuniary resources. Hence, the Investigating Officer laid a charge sheet against the accused persons. After obtaining necessary sanction from the competent authority, the Investigating Agency laid the charge sheet before the Special Court namely, Chief Judicial Magistrate-cum-Special Court for the Prevention of Corruption Act Cases, Dindigul and the same was taken on file in

    Page 17 of 42

    Special Case No.27 of 2014. Pending case, the accused have filed the petitions separately under Section 239 Cr.P.C., to discharge them from the case. The trial Court after hearing the parties, allowed the petitions and discharged them from the charges levelled against them. Aggrieved by the same, the State has preferred these Criminal Revision Petitions.

    15. Admittedly, during the relevant point of time, A1 was the public servant. A2 is the wife of A1. A3 and A4 are the sons of A1. The Investigating Officer collected the materials and affirmed the opinion that there is suspected disproportionate assets held by the accused. Once the Investigating Officer sent the letter dated 20.06.2012 and called for explanation from A1 annexing the statements 1 to 4, compounding the details of assets of income and expenditure, the same was acknowledged by A1 and he offered his explanation on 02.07.2012. The investigating agency was not satisfied with the accounts of the assets and quantum of properties held in the name of A1 and his family members, and came to the conclusion that assets found in the name of A1 and his family members were disproportionate to known sources of income. The Investigating Officer considering the same, held that A1 has not

    Page 18 of 42

    satisfactorily accounted for the assets which were disproportionate to his known sources of income. On a perusal of the materials, it is clear that A1 was given sufficient opportunity to offer his explanation. During the check period between 13.05.2006 to 31.03.2010, the accused being the public servant, abused his official position for obtaining pecuniary advantage, thereby attracting Section 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. In this context, it becomes essential to advert to Section 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, which defines criminal misconduct by a public servant.

    " Section: 13: Criminal misconduct by a public servant:-

    (1)....

    (a) ...

    (e) if he or any person on his behalf, is in possession or has, at any time during the period of his office, been in possession for which the public servant cannot satisfactorily account of pecuniary resources or property disproportionate to his known sources of income."

    Page 19 of 42

    Explanation: For the purpose of this section,

    "known sources of income" means income received from any lawful source and such receipt has been intimated in accordance with the provisions of any law,rules or orders for the time being applicable to a public servant.

    As per explanation to Section 13(1)(e) of PC Act, receipt of any known source of income has to be intimated in accordance with the provisions of law. As a public servant, A1 is accountable for his income and assets and liabilities.

    16. The principal contention advanced by the learned senior counsel for the respondents is that the methodology adopted by the prosecution in establishing the allegation of disproportionate assets is fundamentally flawed. It is contended that the inclusion of properties standing in the names of A2 to A4 within the fold of A1's assets is legally untenable. It is submitted that A1 cannot be held liable for properties owned by individuals over whom he exercises no ownership or control, particularly when such properties were acquired from their independent and legitimate sources of income. The Investigating Officer,

    Page 20 of 42

    without any cogent evidence demonstrating that the properties standing in the names of A2 to A4 were procured out of the income of A1, improperly attributed the said properties to A1. The Trial Court, upon a detailed appreciation of the evidence, also recorded a finding that the prosecution, in an attempt to artificially inflate the expenses and exaggerate the extent of disproportionate assets, unjustifiably clubbed the properties of A2 to A4 with those of A1. In this context, it is apposite to refer to the meaning of the expression "known sources of income," as elucidated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in C.S.D. Swami v. State of Andhra Pradesh [AIR 1960 SC 7], wherein it was observed as follows:

    (1) C.S.D.Swami -Vs- State reported in AIR 1960 SC 7

    Now, the expression " known sources of income " must have reference to sources known to the prosecution on a thorough investigation of the case. It was not, and it could not be, contended that " known sources of income " means sources known to the accused. The prosecution cannot, in the very nature of things, be expected to know the affairs of an accused person. Those will be matters " specially within the knowledge" of the accused, within the

    Page 21 of 42

    meaning of s. 106 of the Evidence Act. The prosecution can only lead evidence, as it has done in the instant case, to show that the accused was known to earn his living by service under the Government during the material period.

    (2) State of Maharastra -Vs- Wasudeo Ramachandra Kaidalwar reported in 1981 (3) SCC 199

    "The provisions of section 5(3) have been subject of judicial interpretation. First the expression "known sources of income" in the context of s.5(3) meant

    "sources known to the prosecution"."

    (3) State of M.P. v. Awadh Kishore Gupta reported in (2004)

    1 SCC 691

    ..Clause (e) of sub-section (1) of section 13 corresponds to clause (e) of sub-section (1) of section 5 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 (referred to as 'Old Act'). But there has been drastical amendments. Under the new clause, the earlier concept of "known sources of income" has undergone a radical change. As per the explanation appended, the prosecution is relieved of the burden of investigating into

    Page 22 of 42

    "source of income" of an accused to a large extent, as it is stated in the explanation that

    "known sources of income" mean income received from any lawful source, the receipt of which has been intimated in accordance with the provisions of any law, rules orders for the time being applicable to a public servant. The expression "known sources of income" has reference to sources known to the prosecution after thorough investigation of the case. It is not, and cannot be contended that "known sources of income" means sources known to the accused. The prosecution cannot, in the very nature of things, be expected to know the affairs of an accused person. Those will be matters

    "specially within the knowledge" of the accused, within the meaning of Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (in short the 'Evidence Act'). The phrase "known sources of income" in section 13(1)(e) {old section 5(1)(e)} has clearly the emphasis on the word "income". It would be primary to observe that qua the public servant, the income would be what is attached to his office or post, commonly known as

    Page 23 of 42

    remuneration or salary. The term "income" by itself, is elastic and has a wide connotation. Whatever comes in or is received, is income. But, however, wide the import and connotation of the term "income", it is incapable of being understood as meaning receipt having no nexus to one's labour, or expertise, or property, or

    investment, and having further a source which may or may not yield a regular revenue. These essential characteristics are vital in understanding the term "income". Therefore, it can be said that, though "income" is receipt in the hand of its recipient, every receipt would not partake into the character of income. Qua the public servant, whatever return he gets of his service, will be the primary item of his income. Other incomes which can conceivably are income qua the public servant, will be in the regular receipt from (a) his property, or (b) his investment. A receipt from windfall, or gains of graft, crime, or immoral secretions by persons primafacie would not be receipt from the

    "known sources of income"of a public servant.

    Page 24 of 42

    In the present case, it is undisputed that a notice was issued to the first accused, providing him with an opportunity to explain the disproportionate assets. The first accused did submit an explanation in response. However, this explanation was deemed unsatisfactory. The issue of whether the properties in question were acquired by the first accused or are independent properties of the respondents is a matter that can only be resolved through a comprehensive evaluation of the evidence during the trial, and not at the stage of discharge. Given that the explanation provided was insufficient, the case was allowed to proceed.

    17. It is settled proposition of law that at the time of framing charges, the Court has to see the final report filed by the prosecution and the materials viz. statement of witnesses and also documents collected by the prosecution during investigation and if the same prima facie reveals that there is sufficient materials to proceed with the case further and the Court has to frame charges against the accused. Further at the time of framing charges, the Court has to look into the materials produced by the prosecution and not the defence taken by the accused or the documents

    Page 25 of 42

    relied upon by the accused. Further the Court cannot go into probative value of the materials produced by the prosecution and validity and veracity of the same cannot be examined at the stage of framing charges, which can only be done during trial.

    18. However, the Special Court wrongly came to the conclusion without any evidence on record that the respondents/A1 to A4 would have earned more income than that shown in the documents produced by the Investigating Officer and that the Special Court has not followed the principles laid down by the Honourable Supreme Court of India in

    "Superintendent and Remembrance of legal affairs, West Bengal-Vs- Anilkumar Bhunja" (1979 SCC (Crl) 1038).

    19. In the present case, it is seen from the order passed by the learned Special Court, while discharging the accused, that the learned Judge extensively discussed the income of the accused and found that there was no disproportionate income in relation to the known sources of income. From the abovesaid decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, at

    Page 26 of 42

    the stage of framing charges, if the materials placed before the trial Court, lead the Court to form an opinion regarding the existence of factual ingredients constituting the alleged offence, it may testify the framing of charges against the accused in respect of commission of offence.

    20. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Madhyapradesh Vs. Mohanalal Soni reported in 2001 MLJ Crl. 60,

    held that at the stage of framing of charge, the Court has to prima facie consider whether there is sufficient materials available for proceedings against the accused and the Court is not required to appreciate the evidence to conclude whether the materials produced by the prosecution are sufficient to convict the accused. If the Court is satisfied that prima case is made out for proceeding further, then charges have to be framed. Further, in the case of State (NCT of Delhi) Vs. Shiv Charan Bansal And Others reported in (2020) 2 SCC 290 in paras 38, 39 and 40, it is held as follows:

    Page 27 of 42

    38. At the stage of framing charges under Section 227 and Section 228 Cr.P.C, the Court is required to consider whether there was sufficient material on record to frame charges against Shiv Charan Bansal, Shailendra Singh, Lalit Mann and Rajbir Singh. The prosecution alleged that the offences under Section 120-B, Section 302 read with Sections 120-B/34, Section 201 IPC and Section 25 of the Arms Act ought to have been framed.

    I. Scope of Section 227 and 228 of the Cr.P.C.

    39. The Court while considering the question of framing charges under Section 227 Cr.P.C has the power to sift and weigh the evidence for the limited purpose of finding out whether or not a prima facie case has been made out against the accused. The test to determine prima facie case would depend upon the facts of each case. If the material placed before the court discloses grave suspicion against the accused, which has not been properly explained, the court will be fully justified in framing charges and proceeding with the trial. The probative value of the evidence brought on record cannot be gone into at the stage of framing charges. The Court is required to evaluate the material and documents on record with a

    Page 28 of 42

    view to find out if the facts emerging therefrom taken at their face value disclose the ingredients constituting the alleged offence. At this stage, there cannot be a roving enquiry into the pros and cons of the matter, the evidence is not to be weighed as if a trial is being conducted. Reliance is placed on the Judgment of this Court in State Of Bihar v. Ramesh Singh . Singh1 where it has been held that at the stage of framing charges under Sections 227 or 228 Cr.P.C., if there is a strong suspicion which leads the Court to think that there is ground for presuming that the accused had committed the offence, then the Court should proceed with the trial.

    40. In a recent Judgment delivered in Dipakbhai Jagdishchandra Patel v. State of Gujarat and Another decided on 24.04.2019, this Court has laid down the law relating to framing of charges and discharge, and held that all that is required is that the court must be satisfied with the material available, that a case is made out for the accused to stand trial. A strong suspicion is sufficient for framing charges, which must be founded on some material. The material must be such which can be translated into evidence at the stage of trial. The veracity and effect

    Page 29 of 42

    of the evidence which the prosecutor proposes to adduce are not to be meticulously judged at this stage, nor is any weight to be attached to the probable defence of the accused at the stage of framing charges. The court is not to consider whether there is sufficient ground for conviction of the accused, or whether the trial is sure to end in the conviction.''

    21. At the time of considering the petition under Section 239 Cr.P.C, the Court has to see the materials which have been brought on record by the prosecution. At the time of framing charges, the Court has to accept the case of the prosecution and the materials produced by the prosecution as true. The Court has to give an opportunity to the prosecution to substantiate the charges by examining the witnesses and by marking the documents. After giving opportunity, if the prosecution is not able to substantiate the materials, the accused are entitled for acquittal. Therefore, at the stage of framing of charges, the Court cannot interpret the materials collected by the Investigating Agency in its own way and it has to allow the prosecution to lead the evidence to substantiate the charges levelled against the accused. The Hon'ble

    Page 30 of 42

    Supreme Court laid down the principle that the trial Court is barred from looking into any materials including the documents produced by the defence available in the report filed by the prosecution under Section 173 Cr.P.C., at the stage of framing charges and should not testify the veracity of the documents which are premature and prior to trial.

    22. The Special Court failed to consider the following principles laid down by the Honourable Supreme Court of India in

    "State of Maharashtra-Vs-Somnath Thapa" (AIR 1996 SC Page

    1744).

    "It is apparent that at the stage of framing the charges, probative value of the materials on record cannot be gone into and the material brought on records by the prosecution has to be accepted as true at that stage".

    23. The Speical Court went wrong in discharging the respondents/A1 to A4 against law and contrary to the following dictum issued by the Honourable Supreme Court of India in

    Page 31 of 42

    (i) "State of Tamil Nadu-Vs-Narayanan and another" (2000 SAR (Crl) Page 100 (SC)).

    "It appears that the Court went on elaborate examination of statements recorded during investigation and formed an opinion after scanning and shaping of the same which was not warranted under law".

    (ii) In "State of Madhya Pradesh-Vs-Mohanalal Soni" (2001 MLJ Crl.60).

    "At the stage of framing of charges, the Court has to prima-facie consider whether there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused. The Court if not required to appreciate the evidence to conclude whether the materials produced are sufficient or not to convict the accused. If the Court is satisfied that prima facie case is made out for proceeding further, then charges have to be framed".

    24. Further, the actual assets possessed in the names of respondents/A2 to A4 and the income derived in their names during the check period were fully and duly taken into consideration by the

    Page 32 of 42

    Investigating Officer while assessing the proportionality of the assets and the trial Court failed to consider the following principles laid down in

    "P.Nallammal & Others-Vs-State of Tamil Nadu" (1999 SAR 804).

    "Legislative intent is manifest that abettors of all the difference offences u/s. 13(1)(e) of the P.C. Act-1988 should also be dealt along with the public servant in the same trial held by the Special Judge".

    25. Once the prosecution finds that the family members of the public servant abetted the public servant to acquire disproportionate assets, all of them should be tried together. In this regard, the Hon'ble Supreme Court stated supra, held that if a non-public servant has abetted any of the offences which the public servant commits, such non-public servant is also liable to be tried along with the public servant.

    26. Further, it is settled proposition of law that, mere filing of Income Tax Returns before the Income Tax Authorities cannot be a basis to put to hold that the respondents earned the income from the lawful

    Page 33 of 42

    sources. If the Income Tax Returns filed by the respondents herein, are found to have been accepted summarily, the Income Tax Authority did not make any probe as to whether the respondents had actually derived the income as shown in the Income Tax Returns. In this regard, it is useful to refer the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of State of Tamil Nadu vs. N.Suresh Rajan and Others reported in

    (2014) 11 SCC 709 and the relevant portion is extracted hereunder:

    "The property in the name of an income tax assessee itself cannot be aground to hold that it actually belongs to such an assessee. In case this proposition is accepted, in our opinion, it will lead to disastrous consequences. It will give opportunity to the corrupt public servants to amass property in the name of known persons, pay income tax on their behalf and then be out from the mischief of law." Mere filing of Income Tax Returns may not be the sole ground to discharge the respondents that they have accounted for the known sources of income.

    Page 34 of 42

    27. Further, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in its judgment in the case of State of Karnataka Vs. J.Jayalalitha reported in (2017) 6 SCC 263

    has held as follows:

    "190. The decision is to convey that though the IT returns and the orders passed in the IT proceedings in the instant case recorded the income of the accused concerned as disclosed in their returns, in view of the charge levelled against them, such returns and the orders in the IT proceedings would not by themselves establish that such income had been from lawful source as contemplated in the Explanation to Section 13(1)(e) of the PC Act, 1988 and that independent evidence would be required to account for the same.

    191. Though considerable exchanges had been made in course of the arguments, centring around Section 43 of the Evidence Act, 1872, we are of the comprehension that those need not be expatiated in details. Suffice it to state that even assuming that the income tax returns, the proceedings in connection therewith and the decisions rendered therein are relevant and admissible in evidence as well, nothing as such,

    Page 35 of 42

    turns thereon definitively as those do not furnish any guarantee or authentication of the lawfulness of the source(s) of income, the pith of the charge levelled against the respondents. It is the plea of the defence that the income tax returns and orders, while proved by the accused persons had not been objected to by the prosecution and further it (prosecution) as well had called in evidence the income tax returns/orders and thus, it cannot object to the admissibility of the records produced by the defence. To reiterate, even if such returns and orders are admissible, the probative value would depend on the nature of the information furnished, the findings recorded in the orders and having a bearing on the charge levelled. In any view of the matter, however, such returns and orders would not ipso facto either conclusively prove or disprove the charge and can at best be pieces of evidence which have to be evaluated along with the other materials on record. Noticeably, none of the respondents has been examined on oath in the case in hand. Further, the income tax returns relied upon by the defence as well as the orders passed in the proceedings

    Page 36 of 42

    pertaining thereto have been filed/passed after the charge-sheet had been submitted. Significantly, there is a charge of conspiracy and abetment against the accused persons. In the overall perspective therefore neither the income tax returns nor the orders passed in the proceedings relatable thereto, either definitively attest the lawfulness of the sources of income of the accused persons or are of any avail to them to satisfactorily account the disproportionateness of their pecuniary resources and properties as mandated by Section 13(1)(e) of the Act.

    192. A Constitution Bench of this Court in Iqbal Singh Marwah v. Meenakshi Marwah [Iqbal Singh Marwah v. Meenakshi Marwah, (2005) 4 SCC 370 : 2005 SCC (Cri) 1101] in this context had ruled that there is neither any statutory provision nor any legal principle that the findings recorded in one proceeding may be treated as final or binding on the other as both the cases have to be decided on the basis of the evidence adduced therein.

    ......

    Page 37 of 42

    196. This Court ruled that the fact that the accused, other than the two Ministers, had been assessed to income tax and had paid income tax could not have been relied upon to discharge the accused persons in view of the allegation made by the prosecution that there was no separate income to amass such huge property. It was underlined that the property in the name of the income tax assessee itself cannot be a ground to hold that it actually belongs to such an assessee and that if this proposition was accepted, it would lead to disastrous consequences. This Court reflected that in such an eventuality it will give opportunities to the corrupt public servant to amass property in the name of known person, pay income tax on their behalf and then be out from the mischief of law.

    28. As far as the false case that has been foisted against the accused with mala-fide intention on the ground of political vendetta is concerned, once the Investigating Officer fixed the check period and conducted the investigation and collected the materials and has given an opportunity to A1/the public servant, and after getting an explanation and

    Page 38 of 42

    not being satisfied with the explanation, obtained sanction for prosecution from the competent authority, and filed the charge sheet. At this stage, the Court has to see the materials produced by the prosecution as to whether prima-facie materials are available to proceed with the case further or not. Therefore, at this stage, the allegation of mala-fide against the informant are of known consequences and cannot by itself be the basis for discharging the accused.

    29. On a reading of the materials produced by the petitioner and also the grounds taken by the petitioner and the impugned order passed by the trial Court, this Court finds that the trial Court traversed beyond the scope of Section 239 Cr.P.C., and went to the extent of conducting roving enquiry and also evaluating the probative value of the materials and interpreted the documents in its own way and discharged the respondents which is perverse. As discussed above and on a reading of the entire records, this Court finds that, prima facie materials are available to frame the charges and proceed with the case further.

    Page 39 of 42

    30. There is no quarrel with the proposition of law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the decisions relied upon by the learned Senior Counsel for the respondents/accused, but the facts of those cases are distinguishable, which are not applicable to the facts of the present case on hand, rather the decisions relied upon by the prosecution are squarely applicable to the present case.

    31. The Special Court without framing of charges and giving opportunity to the prosecution to substantiate their charge, simply discharged the respondents/accused on the ground of technicality and also interpreted the facts in its own way, which warrants interference. In this case, the learned Special Judge failed to consider the case of the prosecution and materials produced along with the charge sheet under Section 173 Cr.P.C, and proposition of law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court and traversed beyond the scope of Section 239 Cr.P.C., by discharging the respondents herein/accused. Hence, the impugned order passed by the Special Court is perverse and the same is liable to be set aside.

    Page 40 of 42

    32. Accordingly, the Criminal Revision Petitions are allowed. The Special Court is directed to frame charges and proceed with the case in accordance with law. Further since the check period is between 2006 and 2010 and considering the scope and object of constitution of the Special Court for dealing the cases of MP and MLAs, the Special Court is directed to dispose of the case within a period of six months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order by conducting trial on day to day basis.

    28.04.2025

    mfa Index:Yes/No

    Speaking Order: Yes/No Neutral Citation: Yes/No To

    1. The Chief Judicial Magistrate cum Special Judge for Prevention of Corruption Act Cases,

    Dindigul.

    2. The Public Prosecutor, High Court, Chennai. Copy to:

    1. The Section Officer, ER Section, Madras High Court.

    2. The Section Officer, Criminal Section, Madras High Court.

    Page 41 of 42

    P.VELMURUGAN, J

    mfa

    Pre-delivery order made in Crl.R.C.(MD)Nos.110 to 113 of 2018

    28.04.2025

    Page 42 of 42

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State v. P.Prabhu
    (Apr 28, 2025)