Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • PROBATION OF OFFENDERS ACT 1958
  • SECTION 4 PROBATION OF OFFENDERS ACT
  • Section 323 of I.P.C Under Section 325 of IPC R.I.
  • section 313 of the Cr.P.C.
  • section 374 (2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short CrPC)
  • sections 147, 148, 294, 352/149 and 323/34 of the IPC.
  • provision of section 437(A) of Cr.P.C. Sd/- (Sachin Singh Rajput) Judge Ashish
  • Section 325 / 34 of I.P.C R.I.
  • provisions of the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 (20 of 1958), or the Children Act, 1960 (60 of 1960
  • Section 4 of Probation of offender Act and section 360 CrPC.
  • Section 360 Cr.P.C.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Acts
  • PROBATION OF OFFENDERS ACT 1958
  • SECTION 4 PROBATION OF OFFENDERS ACT
  • Section 323 of I.P.C Under Section 325 of IPC R.I.
  • section 313 of the Cr.P.C.
  • section 374 (2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short CrPC)
  • sections 147, 148, 294, 352/149 and 323/34 of the IPC.
  • provision of section 437(A) of Cr.P.C. Sd/- (Sachin Singh Rajput) Judge Ashish
  • Section 325 / 34 of I.P.C R.I.
  • provisions of the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 (20 of 1958), or the Children Act, 1960 (60 of 1960
  • Section 4 of Probation of offender Act and section 360 CrPC.
  • Section 360 Cr.P.C.

    KORBIHA and 4 ORS v. STATE OF CG

    2024:CGHC:26801

    Reserved on : 13/03/2024 Pronounced on : 23/07/2024

    NAFR

    HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR

    Cr.A.No. 749 of 2007

    1. Korbiha, S/o. Maniram Suryavanshi, aged about 50 years

    2. Deonarayan, S/o. Puran Suryavanshi, aged about 20 years

    3. Tula Ram, S/o. Puran Suryavanshi, aged about 28 years

    4. Melaram, S/o. Puran Suryavanshi aged about 30 years

    5. Bhanupratap, S/o. Puran Lal Suryavanshi, aged about 25 years

    ---- Appellants

    Versus State of Chhattisgarh Through : P.S. : Pamgarh, District - Janjgir-Champa(C.G.)

    --- Respondent

    ____________________________________________________________ For the Appellants : Shri Pushpendra Kumar Patel, Advocate. For State/ Respondent : Ms. Upasana Mehta, Dy.G.A. along with Shri G.L.Uike, P.L.

    ________________________________________________________

    Hon'ble Shri Justice Sachin Singh Rajput CAV Judgment

    1. The appeal under section 374 (2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short CrPC) has been filed by the appellants, challenging the validity, correctness, judicial propriety of the judgment dated 25/08/2017 passed by the Session Judge, Janjjgir-Champa, (C.G.) in Session case No. 21/2007 by which the appellants have been convicted and sentenced as quoted below:

    Conviction Sentence
    (Appellant – Korbiha) Under Section 323 of I.P.C Under Section 325 of IPC R.I. for 03 months R.I. for two years and Rs.500 fine. (in default, three months addtiona R.I.)
    (Appellant - Deonarayan, Tularam, Bhanupratap) Under Section 325 / 34 of I.P.C R.I. for 02 years to each appellants and fine of Rs. 500/- in default of fine 03 months additional R.I.
    All the sentences to run concurrently

    1

    -2-

    2. Case of the prosecution, in brief, is that on 30.07.2006, Sunau PW/2, Shiv Kumar PW/1, Melaram PW/3 were bringing their cattle from Kanji House. On the way they met Tula Ram A/3, Bhanupratap Suryawanshi A/5, Deonaryan A/2, Puran Singh (acquitted accused), Melaram A/4 and Korbihar A/1. They asked them not to take their cattle's on the way of their field. However, the cow went into the field upon which all of them filthily abused and assaulted them by stick and club resulted into injuries upon the person of Sunau PW/2, Shiv Kumar PW/1, Melaram PW/3 and Sunau PW/2 sustained fracture. The FIR vide Ex.P/1 was lodged upon which crime was registered against the appellant. Injured were medically examined. Dr. K.K.Dahire (PW/4) in his report Ex. P/2 to Ex.P/4 confirmed the injuries and fracture. Investigating Officer prepared spot map vide Ex.P/6. Sticks (Lathi) and club were seized from the appellants vide Ex.P/7 to Ex.P/12. Statements of the witnesses were recorded. The appellants / accused were arrested and after due investigation, the charge- sheet was filed before the JMFC, Janjgir. The case was committed to sessions court.

    3. The appellants and acquitted accused Puran were charge for an offense punishable under sections 147, 148, 294, 352/149 and 323/34 of the IPC. The appellants denied the charges and claimed to be tried. The accused Puran took a defense that he was not present at the scene of occurrence and he was present at NTPC Seepat.

    4. In order to establish its case, prosecution has examined as many as 09 witnesses. The statement of the appellants under section 313 of the Cr.P.C. were recorded in which they pleaded false implication. Two defense witnesses Sanatan Pradhan DW/1 and Jodhram DW/2 were examined.

    5. The learned trial court after appreciating the evidence available on record

    -3-

    convicted the appellants as stated above, however acquitted the accused Puran by the impugned judgment giving the benefit of doubt.

    6. The impugned judgment is assailed before this court in this appeal.

    7. Learned Counsel for the appellants submitted that there was a counter case where no blame was put on the appellants. He further submitted that the incident occurred on provocation therefore the case under section 325 of IPC would not be made out and at the most it would fall under the ambit of section 335 of the IPC. The injured witnesses Shivkumar (PW/1), Sunau (PW/2) and Melaram (PW/3) particularly PW/2 Sunau have improved their statement in the court contrary to what they have stated in their 161 CrPC statement. He further submitted that the learned trial court has not appreciated the evidence to its proper prospective and erroneously convicted the appellant by the impugned judgment which requires to be set aside by this Court.

    8. The FIR though lodged within a short spam of time but in the recital of FIR and the statement of witnesses before the court there is a vast contradiction and omission, therefore benefit of doubt should have been extended to the appellants. Alternatively, he submitted that the appellants are first offender, they were granted bail by the learned trial court and after their conviction, this court also suspended the sentence imposed upon them and they have never misused the liberty granted to them. The appellants are rustic villagers and offense was committed in the year 2006 and they face long drawn litigation. During this period it is not brought on record that they are involved in any other criminal activity. Therefore in the event the appeal is dismissed, the appellants shall be extended the benefit of Probation of Offenders Act, 1958, to buttress his submission he placed reliance on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Tarak Nath Keshari v. State of West Bengal decided on 10/05/2023 in Criminal Appeal No.1444 of 2023, judgment of the High Court of

    -4-

    Punjab and Haryana in the case of Hanumat singh v. State of Haryana and ors, in CRR No.2347 of 2005 decided on 29/07/2022 and judgment in the case of Sunil v. State of Haryana in CRR No.1123-2022 (O&M) decided on 01/06/2022 and judgments of this Court in the case of Bhagat Ram v. State of Madhya Pradesh (Criminal Appeal No.2960 of 1998) decided on 15/02/2023 and Parmeshwar and ors v. State of Chhattisgarh in criminal appeal No.269/2002 decided on 21/06/2023.

    9. Per contra, learned Counsel for the State submitted that the statement of Shiv Kumar (PW/1), Sunau (PW/2) and Melaram (PW/3) is uncontroverted and inspire confidence. Even, if some contradiction and omission is made, it would not render their statement untrustworthy and incredible. The presence of the appellants is established on the scene of occurrence and they were not present on the spot. The oral testimony of the witnesses is duly corroborated by Dr.K.K.Dahire (PW/4) and Dr. R. Jeetpure (PW/8) radiologist who found certain injuries on the person of the injured and also found fracture on the Parietal bone of Sunau (PW/2). The finding of conviction recorded by the learned trial court is based upon proper appreciation of evidence which does not require any interference by this Court. She further submitted that looking to the overt act, the benefit of Probation of Offender Act 1958 cannot be extended to the appellants.

    10.I have heard the learned counsel for the parties, considered their rival submission and also perused the record with utmost circumspection.

    11. The incident said to have occurred on 30/07/2006 at about 04:00PM. FIR vide Ex.P/1 was lodged on the same day at about 05:30PM. In FIR the name of the appellants and the acquitted co-accused Puran Singh Suryawanshi is metioned. The recital of the FIR also indicates the happening of the incident. PW/1 Shiv Kumar, in his statement before the court has vividly described the

    -5-

    happening of the incident and deposed that he knows the appellants present in the Court. He along with Melaram, Bhagbali, Sunau had gone to Kanjhi House to release their cattle and thereafter they were coming back. On the way the appellants met them and asked not to take their cattle. The appellants were armed with lathi and tangi and thereafter, he was assaulted and sustained injuries on his head, he was subjected to lengthy cross-examination. He has stated in his Police statement Ex.D/1, that he has informed to Police that appellants were armed with lathi and tangi, however tangi is not mentioned. He is unable to explained as to why the tangi word is not mentioned in the Ex.D/1. PW/2 Sunau corborates the statement of PW/1 Shivkumar. He also deposed in the same line and also stated that the appellants and acquitted co-accused were armed with lathi and tangi and cohere he was assaulted him with tangi on his forehead, Pooran assaulted him with lathi on his back and he fell unconscious. He went to to Police Station and lodged a report Ex.P/1. He was categorically subjected to lengthy cross-examination. In his cross-examination, he stated that in his Police report Ex.P/1 fact with record assault Pooran by Lathi that he feel unconscious is not mentioned. If it is not mention he is not able to depose reason for it. He has further stated he has 12 stitches on his head and sustained injuries on his back as a result of assault by lathi. He admit that the injuries not sustained only one place. He admit that they were facing case on the report of Bhanupratap and stated that the first report was lodged by him.

    12. Melaram (PW/3) also supports the case of the prosecution and also deposed against the appellants marked as Ex.D/1. The injuries sustained by the injured were found by Dr.K.K.Dahire (PW/4) who medically examined Shivkumar, Melaram and Sunau and found following injuries on the person of the above appellants:

    Shiv Kumar (PW/1)

    -6-

    Cut of 7x2.5x2cms on left parietal bone (report vide Ex.P/2),

    Melaram (PW/2)

    Abrasion of 0.5x0.5cm on right hand finger (report vide Ex.P/3),

    Sunau (PW/3)

    Cut of 3x3x3 cm frontal bone(report vide Ex.P/4), He further stated that as per radiologist report there was fractured on the left parietal bone of Sonau.

    13. PW/5 Bhagbali is an independent witness, he also deposed the happening of the incident, and proves the presence of the appellant on the scene of occurrence and stated that A/1 assaulted sonau with Tangi which stuck in his head. Melaram, Bhanupratap, Tularam assaulted Shivkumar with lathi, thereafter Shivkumar and Sunau fell unconscious and they were taken to house of Sarpanch and lodged the report. Though they were subjected to call the material to this witnesses remained firmed.

    14. PW/8 Dr. R.Jeetpure stated that on conducting X-ray of Sunau PW/2 he found fracture on left parietal bone and was advise to conduct CT-scan and gave it's report Ex.P/21.

    15.PW/6 Thakur Prasad Rathore and PW/9 Anand Kumar witness to the investigation and supported the case of prosecution.

    16.The learned trial court relied upon the statement of the injured witnesses and also found that minor contradiction could not fatal to the prosecution. The oral statement of injured witnesses also find corroboration from the medical evidence. Thereafter convicted the appellants as stated above. Counsel for the appellants vehemently argued that there is a contradiction and omission in the statement of the witnesses. However, the fact remains that these witnesses categorically deposed with regard to specific overtact by the appellants. It make some contradiction with regard to word tangi not mentioned in the FIR.

    -7-

    However, from the injury sustained and other evidence available, this contradiction may not be fatal to the prosecution. It's not a case that there was assault only one injured person, three persons were assaulted by total six accused persons and five of them are before this court. Looking to the medical evidence, the injuries which are sustained by the injured person can be said to have been caused by the arms which were kept by the appellants. After thoughtful consideration and assessment of the evidence, I do not find any informative in the judgment of the trial court convicting the appellants for offense under section 325 IPC of the Sunau ram sustained a fractured on left parietal bone which is a vital part of the body. Apart from this the other injured person were also sustained injuries. Learned counsel for the appellants has to convinced this court that the grievous hurt was caused by appellant No.1 Korbiha and the roll of their person cannot be said to be attributed with the aid of Section 34 IPC. Material available on record this contention is liable to be rejected. Every appellants involved in committing the aforesaid offense. Therefore finding this contention is under guilt. Hence sentence may be reduced on given benefit of provision Probation of Offender Act. 17.This leads to second submission with regard to reduction of sentence, it is brought to the notice of the court, the appellants were granted bail by trial court and they never remain in detention through out the trial during pendency of this appeal.

    18.It is brought to the notice of this court that the appellant has no criminal antecedent during this period and the appellants does not misused the liberty during bail.

    19.Now the question arises for consideration is whether sentence awarded to appellant by trial Court can be reduced to period already undergone or what

    -8-

    would be adequate sentence to be imposed in facts and circumstances of the case. Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Deo Narain Mandal Vs. State of UP

    reported in (2004) 7 SCC 257 observed in paragraph 8 as under:

    "8.This brings us to the next question in regard to the reduction of sentence made by the High Court. In criminal cases awarding of sentence is not a mere formality. Where the statute has given the court a choice of sentence with maximum and minimum limit presented then an element of discretion is vested with the court. This discretion can not be exercised arbitrarily or whimsically. It will have to be exercised taking into consideration the gravity of offence, the manner in which it is committed, the age, the sex of the accused, in other words, the sentence to be awarded will have to be considered in the background of the fact of each case and the court while doing so should bear in mind the principle of proportionality. The sentence awarded should be neither excessively harsh nor ridiculously low."

    20. Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of State of MP Vs. Ghanshyam Singh reported in (2003) 8 SCC 13 held as under:-

    "13. Criminal law adheres in general to the principle of proportionality in prescribing liability according to the culpability of each kind of criminal conduct. It ordinarily allows some significant discretion to the Judge in arriving at a sentence in each case, presumably to permit sentences that reflect more subtle considerations of culpability that are raised by the special facts of each case. Judges, in essence, affirm that punishment ought always to fit the crime; yet in practice sentences are determined largely by other considerations. Sometimes it is the correctional needs of the perpetrator that are offered to justify a sentence, sometimes the desirability of keeping him

    -9-

    out of circulation, and sometimes even the tragic results of his crime. Inevitably these considerations cause a departure from just desert as the basis of punishment and create cases of apparent injustice that are serious and widespread.

    14. Proportion between crime and punishment is a goal respected in principle, and in spite of errant notions, it remains a strong influence in the determination of sentences. The practice of punishing all serious crimes with equal severity is now unknown in civilized societies, but such a radical departure from the principle of proportionality has disappeared from the law only in recent times. Even now for a single grave infraction drastic sentences are imposed. Anything less than a penalty of greatest severity for any serious crime is thought then to be a measure of toleration that is unwarranted and unwise. But in fact, quite apart from those considerations that make punishment unjustifiable when it is out of proportion to the crime, uniformly disproportionate punishment has some very undesirable practical consequences.

    15. After giving due consideration to the facts and circumstances of each case, for deciding just and appropriate sentence to be awarded for an offence, the aggravating and mitigating factors and circumstances in which a crime has been committed are to be delicately balanced on the basis of really relevant circumstances in a dispassionate manner by the Court. Such act of balancing is indeed a difficult task. It has been very aptly indicated in Dennis Councle McGautha v. State of Callifornia that no formula of a foolproof nature is possible that would provide a reasonable criterion in determining a just and appropriate punishment in the infinite variety of circumstances that may affect the gravity of the

    -10-

    crime. In the absence of any foolproof formula which may provide any basis for reasonable criteria to correctly assess various circumstances germane to the consideration of gravity of crime, the discretionary judgment in the facts of each case, is the only way in which such judgment may be equitably distinguished."

    21. While determining the quantum of punishment various factors needs to be consider. Nature and gravity of offence, penalty provided for the offence, manner of commission of offence, proportionality between crime & punishment, character of the offender, age and sex of the offender, antecedents if any, possibility of reforms, impact of crime on society etc are some of the relevant consideration in determining the quantum of punishment. Court has to strike a balance between crime and punishment. Possibility of reform is an important mitigating factor while imposing appropriate sentence. Undue sympathy should not be given only because of long drawn pendency of criminal proceedings. In light of the above broad principles the facts of the instant case is examined. The appellants during pendency of this appeal were enlarged on bail. Nothing has been brought to the notice to this court that they have misused the liberty granted to them. It has also not brought on record by state respondent that during this period they were involved in any other crime or previous criminal antecedents. Possibility of reform cannot be ruled out. However, looking to the entire facts circumstances and mitigating factors as stated above 2 years sentence imposed under Section 325 / 34 of IPC appears to be a bit harsh. In order to strike balance between crime and punishment ends of justice will be met if the sentence of 2 years imposed is reduced reasonably. Hence, the sentence of 2 years RI imposed by the learned trial court is reduced to RI of 6 months. However, the sentence imposed under Section 323 of IPC and fine amount is not disturbed.

    22. Now this Court has to consider whether in the given facts and circumstances of the case benefit of Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 can be extended to the appellants

    -11-

    or not.

    23. For considering this issue it is expedient for this Court to extract Section 4 of the Probation of Offenders Act and Section 360 of CrPC as under :-

    Section 4 Power of court to release certain offenders on probation of good conduct.—

    (1) When any person is found guilty of having committed an offence not punishable with death or imprisonment for life and the court by which the person is found guilty is of opinion that, having regard to the circumstances of the case including the nature of the offence and the character of the offender, it is expedient to release him on probation of good conduct, then, notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, the court may, instead of sentencing him at once to any punishment direct that he be released on his entering into a bond, with or without sureties, to appear and receive sentence when called upon during such period, not exceeding three years, as the court may direct, and in the meantime to keep the peace and be of good behaviour: Provided that the court shall not direct such release of an offender unless it is satisfied that the offender or his surety, if any, has a fixed place of abode or regular occupation in the place over which the court exercises jurisdiction or in which the 8 offender is likely to live during the period for which he enters into the bond.

    (2) Before making any order under sub-section (1), the court shall take into consideration the report, if any, of the probation officer concerned in relation to the case.

    (3) When an order under sub-section (1) is made, the court may, if it is of opinion that in the interests of the offender and of the public it is expedient so to do, in addition pass a supervision order directing that the offender shall remain under the supervision of a probation officer named in the order during such period, not being less than one year, as may be specified therein, and may in such supervision order, impose such conditions as it deems necessary for the due supervision of the offender.

    (4) The court making a supervision order under sub-section (3) shall require the offender, before he is released, to enter into a bond, with or without sureties, to observe the conditions specified in such order and such additional conditions with respect to residence, abstention from intoxicants or any other matter as the

    -12-

    court may, having regard to the particular circumstances, consider fit to impose for preventing a repetition of the same offence or a commission of other offences by the offender.

    (5) The court making a supervision order under sub-section (3) shall explain to the offender the terms and conditions of the order and shall forthwith furnish one copy of the supervision order to each of the offenders, the sureties, if any, and the probation officer concerned.

    Section 360. Order to release on probation of good conduct or after admonition. (1) When any person not under twenty- one years of age is convicted of an offence punishable with fine only or with imprisonment for a term of seven years or less, or when any person under twenty- one years of age or any woman is convicted of an offence not punishable with death or imprisonment for life, and no previous conviction is proved against the offender, if it appears to the Court before which he is convicted, regard being had to the age, character or antecedents of the offender, and to the circumstances in which the offence was committed, that it is expedient that the offender should be released on probation of good conduct, the Court may, instead of sentencing him at once to any punishment, direct that he be released on his entering into a bond with or without sureties, to appear and receive sentence when called 9 upon during such period (not exceeding three years) as the Court may direct and in the meantime to keep the peace and be of good behaviour: Provided that where any first offender is convicted by a Magistrate of the second class not specially empowered by the High Court, and the Magistrate is of opinion that the powers conferred by this section should be exercised, he shall record his opinion to that effect, and submit the proceedings to a Magistrate of the first class, forwarding the accused to, or taking bail for his appearance before, such Magistrate, who shall dispose of the case in the manner provided by sub- section (2).

    (2) Where proceedings are submitted to a Magistrate of the first class as provided by sub- section (1), such Magistrate may thereupon pass such sentence or make such order as he might have passed or made if the case had originally been heard by him, and, if he thinks further inquiry or additional evidence on any point to be necessary, he may make such inquiry or take such evidence himself or direct such inquiry or evidence to be made or taken.

    (3) In any case in which a person is convicted of theft, theft in a building,

    -13-

    dishonest misappropriation, cheating or any offence under the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860 ), punishable with not more than two years' imprisonment or any offence punishable with fine only and no previous conviction is proved against him, the Court before which he is so convicted may, if it thinks fit, having regard to the age, character, antecedents or physical or mental condition of the offender and to the trivial nature of the offence or any extenuating circumstances under which the offence was committed, instead of sentencing him to any punishment, release him after due admonition.

    (4) An order under this section may be made by any Appellate Court or by the High Court or Court of Session when exercising its powers of revision.

    (5) When an order has been made under this section in respect of any offender, the High Court or Court of Session may, on appeal when there is a right of appeal to such Court, or when exercising its powers of revision, set aside such order, and in lieu thereof pass sentence on such offender according to law:

    Provided that the High Court or Court of Session shall not under this sub- section inflict a greater punishment than might have been inflicted by the Court by which the offender was convicted.

    (6) The provisions of sections 121, 124 and 373 shall, so far as may be, apply in the case of sureties offered in pursuance of the provisions of this section.

    (7) The Court, before directing the release of an offender under sub- section (1), shall be satisfied that an offender or his surety (if any) has a fixed place of abode or regular occupation in the place for which the Court acts or in which the offender is likely to live during the period named for the observance of the conditions.

    (8) If the Court which convicted the offender, or a Court which could have dealt with the offender in respect of his original offence, is satisfied that the offender has failed to observe any of the conditions of his recognizance, it may issue a warrant for his apprehension.

    (9) An offender, when apprehended on any such warrant, shall be brought forthwith before the Court issuing the warrant, and such Court may either remand him in custody until the case is heard or admit him to bail with a sufficient surety conditioned on his appearing for sentence and such Court may,

    -14-

    after hearing the case, pass sentence.

    (10) Nothing in this section shall affect the provisions of the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 (20 of 1958), or the Children Act, 1960 (60 of 1960 ), or any other law for the time being in force for the treatment, training or rehabilitation of youthful offenders.

    24. Sections 4 and 360 CrPC has come up for consideration before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Ratan Lal vs. State of Punjab 1965 (1) Criminal Law Jeneral 360, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held in paragraph-4 as under:-

    "This Act is a milestone in the progress of the modern liberal trend of reform in the field of penology. It is the result of the recognition of the doctrine that the object of criminal law is more to reform the individual offender than to punish him. The Act distinguishes offenders below 21 years of age and those 677 above that age and offenders who are guilty of committing an offence punishable with death or imprisonment for life and those who are guilty of a lesser offence. While in the case of offenders who are above the age of 21 years, absolute discretion is given to the court to release them after admonition or on probation of good conduct, in the case of offenders below the age of 21 11 years an injunction is issued to the court not to sentence them to imprisonment unless it is satisfied that having regard to the circumstances of the case, including the nature of the offence and the character of the offenders, it is not desirable to deal with them under SS 3 and 4 of the Act.

    25. The Hon'ble Supreme Court considering the provisions of Section 4 of the Probation of Offenders Act and Section 360 CrPC in the case of Ved Prakash vs. State of Haryana (1981) 1 SCC 447 has held as under;-

    "We must emphasise that sentencing an accused person is a sensitive exercise of discretion and not a routine or mechanical prescription acting on hunch. The Trial Court should have collected materials necessary to help award a just punishment in the circumstances. The social background and the personal factors of the crime-doer are very relevant although in practice Criminal Courts have hardly paid attention to the social milieu or the personal circumstances of the offender. Even if Section 360 Cr.P.C. is not attracted, it is the duty of the sentencing Court

    -15-

    to be activist enough to collect such facts as have a bearing on punishment with a rehabilitating slant. The absence of suck materials in the present case has left us with little assistance even from the counsel. Indeed members of the bar also do not pay sufficient attention to these legislative provisions which relate to dealing with an offender in such manner that he becomes a non-offender. We emphasise this because the legislations which relate to amelioration in punishment have been regarded as 'Minor Acts' and, therefore, of little consequence. This is a totally wrong approach and even if the Bar does not help, the Bench must fulfill the humanising mission of sentencing implicit in such enactments as the Probation of offenders Act. In the present case, the offender is a young person and his antecedents have no blemish. His life is not unsettled or restless and the report indicates that he is an agriculturist, pursuing a peaceful vocation. His parents are alive and he has a wife and children to maintain. These are stabilizing factors in life. A long period of litigation and the little period of imprisonment suffered? will surely serve as a deterrent. We are mindful of the fact that a firearm has been used by the appellant and we cannot sleep over the gravity of the 12 offence. Nevertheless, the report of the Probation officer states that the appellant is not given to any bad habits or stresses of poverty. A land dispute led to the crime and that does not survive any longer".

    26. Again the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Maharastra vs. Jagmohan Singh Kuldeep Singh and other (2004) 7 SCC 659 has held in paragraph-27 as under:-

    The learned counsel appearing for the accused

    submitted that the incident is of the year 1990. The parties are educated and neighbours. The learned

    counsel, therefore, prayed that benefit of Probation of Offenders Act, 958 may be granted to the accused.

    The prayer made on behalf of the accused seems to

    be reasonable. The incident is more than 10 years

    old. The dispute was between the neighbours over a

    trivial issue of cleaning of drainage. The incident took place in a fit of anger. All the parties are educated and also distantly related. The incident is not such as to direct the accused to undergo sentence of

    -16-

    imprisonment. In our opinion, it is a fit case in which the accused should be released on Probation by directing them to execute a bond of one year for good behaviour.

    27. From the record, it is not in dispute that the incident took place in the year 2006 and since then they have been facing the trial i.e. for last 18 years and regularly appearing before the trial Court even after granting bail by this Court. No past criminal antecedents against them is brought on record by the prosecution during pendency of the appeal. Therefore, instead of sending the appellants to jail, they shall get the benefit of Section 4 of Probation of offender Act and section 360 CrPC. Appellants shall file one surety to the tune of Rs. 10,000/- each coupled with personal bond to the effect within three months from the date of receipt of the copy of order before the concerned trial Court, they shall not commit any offence, shall observe good behaviour and shall maintain peace during the period of one year and if there is breach of any of the conditions, they will be subjected to undergo the sentence as awarded this judgment.

    28. Accordingly, the appeal is partly allowed. The appellants need not to surrender before the concerned trial Court to serve out the remaining sentence, if they are not required in any other case.

    29. It is reported that appellants are in bail during pendency of the appeal their bail bond shall be kept alive for six months as per provision of section 437(A) of Cr.P.C. Sd/-

    (Sachin Singh Rajput) Judge

    Ashish

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    KORBIHA and 4 ORS v. STATE OF CG
    (Jul 23, 2024)