Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 KER 31604
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 KER 31604
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges

    C.K. SAJAN v. STATE OF KERALA

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

    PRESENT

    THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJA VIJAYARAGHAVAN V

    THURSDAY, THE 23RD DAY OF MAY 2019 / 2ND JYAISHTA, 1941 Crl.MC.No. 4644 of 2016

    AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT IN CC NO.524/2015 OF THE JUDICIAL

    MAGISTRATE OF FIRST CLASS, MUVATTUPUZHA

    CRIME NO. 629/2015 OF MUVATTUPUZHA POLICE STATION, ERNAKULAM PETITIONER/1ST ACCUSED:

    C.K. SAJAN, S/O KURUVILA,

    AGED 43 YEARS,

    CHOONDAYIL, MEKKADAMBUKARA,

    VALAKOM, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT 682 316.

    BY ADV. SRI.PAUL K.VARGHESE

    RESPONDENTS/DE FACTO COMPLAINANT:

    1 STATE OF KERALA,

    REPRESENTED BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,

    HIGH COURT OF KERALA,

    ERNAKULAM PIN 682 031.

    2 K.J. BABY, S/O JOSEPH,

    AGED 65 YEARS,

    KAKKANAD HOUSE, MEKKADAMBUKARA,

    VALAKOM, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT 682 816.

    SRI. M. S. BREEZ SR. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR

    THIS CRIMINAL MISC. CASE HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 23.05.2019,

    THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY PASSED THE FOLLOWING:

    1

    2

    ORDER

    The petitioner claims to be a practicing lawyer. He has been arrayed as the 1staccused in C.C. No.524 of 2015 on the file of Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Muvattupuzha. He has approached this Court seeking to quash the pending criminal proceedings.

    2. Sans the details, the relevant facts need to be adverted to for considering the prayer sought for. The 2ndrespondent is the owner of a one room building situated at Mekkadambu Panchayat. For leasing it out to a mobile phone operator, he had to carry out certain modifications. On 11.03.2015 at about 3.20 p.m, while he was overseeing the work that was being carried on, the petitioner reached the spot. He is alleged to have picked up an altercation and abused him. He then spewed out the following sentence"

    "... ഞാൻ പെണ്ണൂകേസ്സിൽ പ്രതിയാപെന്്ന ലകേ ാടും റഞ്ഞിട്ട് എന്തായിടാ. നിനക്്ക എന്തുപെയ്യാൻ റ്റൂപെ"ടാ പൂറികേ"ാപെന, കേ$ണ്ടീ$ന്നാൽ നിപെ' കേ"ാകേ(യും ഞാൻ പെയ്യുപെ"ടാ..."

    3. The petitioner then took out his mobile phone and was found talking to some one. After sometime, one Rajesh arrived at the

    3

    spot. He had a conversation with the petitioner and thereafter, he approached the de facto complainant. Rajesh then attempted to deflate the tyres of the vehicle of the 2ndrespondent. When this was questioned, he was abused and the aforesaid Rajesh is alleged to have fisted the de facto complainant on his face. When the neighbours rushed to the spot, the 2ndaccused is alleged to have left the place in his bike. The 2ndrespondent states that he was removed to the hospital and had to undergo treatment. Stating these allegations, information was furnished on the strength of which, the subject crime was registered.

    4. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that as against the petitioner, the only allegation is that he had committed the offence under Section 294(b) of the IPC. According to the learned counsel, in the light of the principles laid down by a Division Bench of this Court in Dhanisha v. Rakhi N. Raj [2012 (2) KHC 111] and that of a learned Single Judge in

    Latheef v. State of Kerala [2014 (2) KHC 604], the proceedings as against the petitioner are liable to be quashed. He would urge that in order to attract the offence under Section 294(b), the alleged words must involve some lascivious elements arousing sexual thoughts or feelings or the words must have the effect of depraving persons and

    4

    defiling morals by sex appeal or lustful desires. According to the learned counsel, the alleged words uttered by the petitioner, without adding or subtracting anything, will not attract the offence alleged.

    5. Though notice was served on the 2ndrespondent, he did not care to enter appearance.

    6. Heard the learned Senior Public Prosecutor and I have perused the records.

    7. In Dhanisha (supra), a Division Bench of this Court after cataloging the long line of precedents had occasion to observe that the matter charged as obscene under Section 294(b) of the IPC should tend to deprave and corrupt those whose minds are open to immoral influence arousing lustful desire or must tend to sexually impure thoughts. It was held that there is nothing in Section 294 of the IPC to hold that the word "obscene" should have a different meaning than that is made applicable to Section 292 of the IPC. In Latheef (supra), a learned Single Judge of this Court had occasion to observe as follows in paragraph No. 5 of the report:

    "Abusive words or humiliating words or defamatory words will not as such amount to obscenity as defined under the law. Of course there is

    5

    no doubt that the words alleged to have been used by the revision petitioner are in fact abusive and humiliating. But to make it obscene, punishable under S.294(b) IPC it must satisfy the definition of obscenity. S.294 IPC does not define obscenity. Being a continuation of the subject dealt with under S.292 IPC the definition of obscenity under 292(1) IPC can be applied in a prosecution under S.294 IPC also. To make punishable, the alleged words must be in a sense lascivious, or it must appeal to the prurient interest, or will deprave and corrupt persons. In P. T. Chacko v. Nainan Chacko reported in 1967 KHC 231:

    1967 KLT 799 this Court held that, "the test of obscenity is whether the tendency of the matter charged as obscenity is to deprave and corrupt those whose minds are open to such immoral influences."

    In Sangeetha Lakshmana v. State Of Kerala reported in 2008 (1) KHC 812: 2008 (2) KLT 745: 2008 (1) KLD 339 this Court held thus, "in order to satisfy the test of obscenity, the words alleged to have been uttered must be capable of arousing sexually impure thoughts in the minds of its hearers." Thus it is quite clear that, to make obscene the alleged words must involve some lascivious elements arousing sexual thoughts or feelings or the words must have the effect of depraving persons, and defiling morals by sex appeal or lustful desires. ………..."

    8. In the case on hand, from the prosecution charge, the allegation attributed to the petitioner is that he had committed the

    6

    offence under Section 294(b) of the IPC. The de facto complainant was assaulted by the 2ndaccused after he had come to the spot later in point of time. As held in Latheef (supra), abusive words or humiliating words or defamatory words will not as such amount to obscenity as defined under the law. To make the words obscene punishable under Section 294(b) of the IPC, it must satisfy the definition of obscenity. To satisfy the test of obscenity, the words alleged to have been uttered must be capable of arousing sexually impure thoughts in the minds of its hearers. Furthermore, the sequence of allegations in the final report clearly show that the petitioner herein, who is a lawyer by profession, was roped in when he questioned the act of the de facto complainant in putting up constructions without securing permission from the local authority.

    9. In Preeti Gupta and Another v. State of Jharkhand and another [2010 (7) SCC 667], the Hon'ble Supreme Court while summarizing the principles, where inherent power can and should be exercised to quash the criminal proceedings, had occasion to observe as follows in paragraph Nos. 18 and 19 of the report.

    "18. This Court had occasion to examine the legal position in a large number of cases. In R.P Kapur v. State Of Punjab ., 1960 KHC 689: AIR 1960 SC 866: 1960

    7

    (3) SCR 388: 1960 CriLJ 1239, this Court summarized some categories of cases where inherent power can and should be exercised to quash the proceedings:

    (i) where it manifestly appears that there is a legal bar against the institution or continuance of the proceedings;

    (ii) where the allegations in the first information report or complaint taken at their face value and accepted in their entirety do not constitute the offence alleged;

    (iii) where the allegations constitute an offence, but there is no legal evidence adduced or the evidence adduced clearly or manifestly fails to prove the charge.

    19. This Court in State of Karnataka v. L. Muniswamy and Others, 1977 KHC 581: 1977 (2) SCC 699: 1977 SCC (Cri) 404: AIR 1977 SC 1489: 1977 (3) SCR 113: 1977 CriLJ 1125 observed that the wholesome power under S.482 CrPC entitles the High Court to quash a proceeding when it comes to the conclusion that allowing the proceeding to continue would be an abuse of the process of the Court or that the ends of justice require that the proceeding ought to be quashed. The High Courts have been invested with inherent powers, both in civil and criminal matters, to achieve a salutary public purpose. A Court proceeding ought not to be permitted to degenerate into a weapon of harassment or persecution. In this case, the Court observed that ends of justice are higher than the ends of mere law though justice must be administered according to laws made by the legislature. This case has been followed in a large number of subsequent cases of

    8

    this Court and other Courts."

    10. Having considered the facts and circumstances, the nature of allegations against the petitioner and the sequence of events, it appears that the initiation of criminal proceedings against him is with intent to vex and spite him. A criminal proceeding ought not be permitted to degenerate into a weapon of harassment or persecution. In that view of the matter, I am inclined to hold that the continuance of proceedings against the petitioner is a clear abuse of process and the same is liable to be quashed.

    In the result, this petition is allowed. Annexure-III charge and all further proceedings pursuant thereto against the petitioner now pending as C.C. No.524 of 2015 on the file of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Muvattupuzha are quashed.

    SD/-

    RAJA VIJAYARAGHAVAN V.,

    avs

    JUDGE

    //TRUE COPY// P.A. TO JUDGE

    9

    APPENDIX

    PETITIONER'S/S EXHIBITS:

    ANNEXURE I A TRUE COPY OF THE FIR NO 629/15 OF MUVATTUPUZHA POLICE STATION DATED 11-03-

    2015

    ANNEXURE II A TRUE COPY OF THE STATEMENT GIVEN BY THE

    2ND RESPONDENT BEFORE THE POLICE DATED 12- 03-2015

    ANNEXURE III A TRUE COPY OF THE CHARGE IN CRIME NO

    629/15 OF THE MUVATTUPUZHA POLICE STATION

    DATED 31-03-2015. RESPONDENT'S/S EXHIBITS:

    NIL

    avs //TRUE COPY// P.A TO JUDGE

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    C.K. SAJAN v. STATE OF KERALA
    (May 23, 2019)