B.P. Colabawalla, J.:— By this Commercial Appeal, the Appellant takes exception to the order passed by the learned Single Judge dated 24 April, 2018 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 243 of 2017, whereby the learned Single Judge granted leave to the Appellant to defend the suit on the condition that the Appellant deposits a sum of Rs. 50 crores in this court within a period of six weeks from 24 April, 2018. The Appellant before us was the original Defendant in the Summary Suit whereas the Respondent herein was the Plaintiff. For the sake of convenience, we shall refer to the parties as they were arrayed before the Trial Court.
2. The brief facts giving rise to the present controversy are as follows:—
(a) Between 17 August 2007 and 31 March 2008, various purchase orders were placed by the Plaintiff on the Defendant. The purchase orders contain a term permitting the Plaintiff to cancel or modify the purchase orders on a notice of two days without any liability, any time before opening the Letter of Credit in connection therewith for any reason. Thereafter, by an agreement, termed as a Logistics Agreement dated 5 February 2010, the Plaintiff agreed to import and source telecom products and provide end-to-end distribution thereof to the channel partners appointed by the Defendant. There were also some amendments to the Logistics Agreement in the form of Addendums dated 17 September 2010, 13 January 2011 and 2 July 2011 respectively.
(b) In the meanwhile, on 15 April 2010, another Agreement was entered into between the Plaintiff and the Defendant titled as a Product Purchase Agreement for purchase of wireless telecom equipments and related accessories by the Plaintiff from the Defendant. This Agreement provided for payment by irrevocable, transferable, straight divisible Letters of Credit or standby Letters of Credit (for short, “SBLCs”). In order to secure the Plaintiff against wrongful encashment of the SBLCs issued from time to time, the Defendant also executed a demand promissory note dated 5 October 2010 by which it promised to pay to the Plaintiff an amount of Rs. 101.98 crores. In addition thereto, the Plaintiff was also secured by a guarantee executed by the Defendant's sister concern and alter-ego - M/s. Olive Telecommunication Pvt. Ltd. Pursuant to all this, the Plaintiff placed purchase orders on the Defendant under the Logistics Agreement (as amended), as well as under the Product Purchase Agreement.
(c) In respect of each of these purchase orders, the Plaintiff opened the corresponding SBLC in favour of the Defendant and its bankers. Thereafter, the Plaintiff made full and prompt payment to the Defendant in respect of the handsets received by it under the Product Purchase Agreement. However, the Defendant failed to deliver the goods under the Logistics Agreement Purchase Orders and therefore, according to the Plaintiff, the Defendant was not entitled to any payment in respect thereof.
(d) Nevertheless, according to the Plaintiff, the Defendant acting through its bankers, wrongfully invoked and encashed the SBLCs opened by the Plaintiff in favour of the Defendant. Be that as it may, on 18 November 2011, the Defendant accepted and acknowledged that invocation of SBLCs would be wrongful since the telecom goods as per the said orders had not been despatched/delivered to the Plaintiff. The Defendant further acknowledged that if the payment under the said SBLCs were made, it would result in having paid Rs. 48 crores without receiving the telecom goods of an equivalent value that was ordered by the Plaintiff.
(e) Be that as it may, on 28 and 29 December 2011, the SBLCs given by the Plaintiff were encashed. The fact of the matter is that the Defendant has admitted that this encashment was without corresponding receipts of goods against it. It is in these circumstances, a balance reconciliation statement for the year ending 31 March 2012 was accordingly signed by the Defendant acknowledging and admitting a sum of Rs. 34.6 crores as due and payable by the Defendant to the Plaintiff. A further reconciliation statement was signed by the Defendant on 31 March 2013 for the year ending 2013 admitting and acknowledging its liability to pay a sum of Rs. 54 crores to the Plaintiff. As on 31 March 2014, a third balance reconciliation statement was signed by the Defendant for the year ending 31 March, 2014 acknowledging and admitting its liability to pay to the Plaintiff a sum of Rs. 54 crores. Despite all this, no payment was made and hence the above mentioned commercial Summary Suit was filed for recovery of the said sum.
(f) In its application for leave to defend, the Defendant did not deny the balance reconciliation statements signed by it. Its defence broadly before the learned Single Judge was that under the cancelled Purchase Orders, the Defendant had suffered a loss and this loss the Defendant was entitled to adjust against the dues payable to the Plaintiff. This was basically the main defense taken before the learned Single Judge.
(g) The learned Single Judge, on perusal of the material placed before him, came to the conclusion that the Purchase Orders that were cancelled were not by the Plaintiff but by M/s. Tata Tele Services Ltd. Furthermore, the learned Single Judge held that in any event, any claims arising from the cancellation of these Purchase Orders was very much a part of the matter discussed by the parties in their meeting on 11 August 2011. These minutes acknowledged the total compensation agreed upon as full and final settlement of the Defendant's claim and the balance amount due and payable in respect of these claims. What is important to note, and which even the learned Single Judge took notice of, was that the balance reconciliation statements referred to earlier, were signed by the Defendant well after this meeting that took place on 11 August 2011. The learned Single Judge also took note of the fact that these reconciliation statements not only contained an unequivocal confirmation and acknowledgment of liability but also an implied promise to pay the sum as stated therein by the Defendant to the Plaintiff. It is in these circumstances that the learned single Judge, after giving credit of an amount of Rs. 3.74 crores to the Defendant, ordered that the Defendant shall be entitled to conditional leave to defend the Suit on them depositing in this Court a sum of Rs. 50 crores within six weeks from the date of the passing of the order. It is this order that is challenged before us in the present Appeal.
3. In this factual background, Mr. Bagla, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Appellant (original Defendant), canvassed only three points before us for our consideration. They are as under:—
(i) that in the present case, the Suit was clearly barred by the law of limitation as it was filed beyond the period of three years from the date of the last balance reconciliation statement. On this aspect, it was the contention of learned counsel that the last balance reconciliation statement was dated 31 March 2014 and therefore, the limitation expired on or before 30 March 2017. Though the present Suit was lodged on 22 March 2017, the same was not properly verified as per the provisions of the Commercial Courts Act read with Order 6 Rule 15A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. This verification was done only on 20 April 2017. Since the verification was done (as required by law) only on 20 April 2017, and which was beyond the period of limitation, the Suit was therefore barred under the law of limitation, was the contention of Mr. Bagla;
(ii) that the plaint has been verified by a person not authorized to do so viz. Mr. Vishal Shah who has not only signed the plaint but also verified the same;
(iii) that the Suit was also bad for non-joinder of necessary parties.
4. On these three contentions, the learned counsel for the Appellant submitted that all this raises serious triable issues which would entitle the Defendant (the Appellant before us) to unconditional leave to defend the present Suit. He therefore submitted that the learned Single Judge has gone completely wrong in passing a conditional order and hence was required to be set aside by us in Appeal.
5. We have heard the learned counsel at great length and have also perused the papers and proceedings in the present appeal. We find absolutely no merit in the contentions raised by the learned counsel appearing for the Appellant.
6. As far as first issue regarding limitation is concerned, it is not in dispute that the Suit was lodged on 22 March 2017. It is also not in dispute that the period of limitation, even according to the learned counsel for the Appellant, was to expire on or before 30 March, 2017. We fail to see how the learned counsel can therefore submit that the Suit is barred by the law of limitation. The limitation stops on the day when the Suit is lodged in this Court. Merely because the Suit was to be verified in a particular manner as provided under the commercial Courts Act read with Order 6 Rule 15A of the CPC (and which was admittedly done on 20 April, 2017) would not affect the stoppage of time for filing the suit. In fact, Order 6 Rule 15A sub-rule (4) clearly states that where a pleading is not verified in the manner provided under sub-rule (1), the party shall not be permitted to rely upon such pleading as evidence or any of the matters set out therein. In other words, the legislature has clearly set out what consequences would follow if the pleadings were not verified in the manner as set out thereunder. In our opinion, this defect, if at all, is a curable defect and is certainly not one that would affect limitation. This being the case, we find this argument to be wholly unmeritorious and therefore stands rejected.
7. As far as the issue of the authority of Mr. Vishal Shah in filing the suit is concerned, we find that the plaint (as lodged in this Court) has been signed and verified by one Mr. Vishal Shah who is the authorized signatory of the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff Company, through its Director Mr. Ajit Ponkshe has executed a general power of attorney dated 26 June 2013 authorizing Mr. Vishal shah, Head Legal and company Secretary of the Plaintiff, to do and perform all the acts and things as mentioned in the power of attorney. Clause 7 of this power of attorney clearly stipulates that Mr. Vishal Shah shall have the power to institute, for and on behalf of the Plaintiff company, suits or proceedings against any party with which the Plaintiff has business transactions and recover, for and on behalf of the Plaintiff, the amount due. For this purpose, Mr. Shah has been empowered to appoint one or more Solicitors, Chartered Accountants, Advocates, Assessors etc. On a reading of this Power of Attorney, it can hardly be argued before us that the plaint as filed in this Court suffers from any infirmity on this count or that the said plaint has been signed by a person who is not authorized to institute the Suit against the Defendant. We must also mention that in the application for leave to defend that was filed by the Defendant before the learned Single Judge, though a detailed narration has been given with reference to the merits of the matter, the authority of Mr. Vishal Shah to file the present Suit for and on behalf of the Plaintiff, has not been questioned. Therefore, on this count also, we cannot countenance this argument on behalf of the Defendant (Appellant before us).
8. This now only leaves us to deal with the argument of the Defendant that the plaint suffers from non-joinder of necessary parties and therefore the Defendant would be entitled to unconditional leave to defend the Suit. On going through the plaint, we find that the Suit has been filed on the basis of a written contract viz. the Product Purchase Agreement and the Logistics Agreement as well as on the basis of the balance reconciliation statements signed by the Defendant wherein they admit and acknowledge their liability in writing and which were issued under the aforesaid Agreements. The Product Purchase Agreement as well as the Logistics Agreement are entered into between the Plaintiff and the Defendant only. This being the case and considering that this has been filed as a Summary Suit to recover dues of the Plaintiff under the aforesaid two agreements, read with the balance reconciliation statements duly signed by the Defendant, we do not think that the Suit suffers from any non-joinder of necessary parties which would entitle the Defendant to unconditional leave to defend the Suit. We must mention here that even this contention has not been raised in its application for leave to defend and neither was it argued before the learned Single Judge. This being the case, in any event we do not think that it would be fair to let the Appellant raise this contention for the first time in Appeal before us.
9. In the circumstances mentioned above, we find that the learned Single Judge has considered the matter in its correct perspective and has thereafter come to a correct finding that conditional leave to defend the Suit ought to be granted to the Defendant by directing them to deposit a sum of Rs. 50 crores in this Court. This being the case, we find absolutely no infirmity in the impugned order passed by the learned Single Judge.
10. In view of the foregoing discussion, we find no merit in this appeal. It is accordingly dismissed. However, in the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.