Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 1031
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • [No specific Act or Article mentioned], The methods to be adopted for disposal of public property must be fair and transparent providing an opportunity to all the interested persons to participate in the process.
  • Section 28, [No specific Act or Article mentioned]
  • Article 14 of the Constitution
  • Article 136 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Article 142 of the Constitution
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 1031
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • [No specific Act or Article mentioned], The methods to be adopted for disposal of public property must be fair and transparent providing an opportunity to all the interested persons to participate in the process.
  • Section 28, [No specific Act or Article mentioned]
  • Article 14 of the Constitution
  • Article 136 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Article 142 of the Constitution
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Bihar State Housing Board (appellant) issued an advertisement on 10-5-2008 inviting applications for allotment of a 43,000 sq ft plot in Lohia Nagar Housing Colony, Patna, intended for a health centre. The respondent, Radha Ballabh Health Care & Research Institute (P) Ltd., was the sole applicant and paid the prescribed earnest money. No allotment followed.

Between 2009 and 2015 several writ petitions and contempt proceedings were filed in the Patna High Court. Ultimately, by orders dated 10-5-2013 and 9-1-2014, the High Court directed the Board to allot two alternative plots (G-5 and G-6 measuring 24,000 sq ft) to the respondent on the “same terms and conditions” of the original advertisement, subject to updated price.

The Board demanded Rs 10.58 crore on 13-3-2014. The respondent, after written protests, accepted the demand, paid Rs 41 lakh on 2-4-2014, and later paid the 20% upfront amount of Rs 2,11,98,400. A formal allotment letter (11-12-2014) and a written agreement (12-3-2015) ensued, creating a concluded contract.

Subsequently, the respondent filed another writ petition challenging the fixation of price as “market rate” instead of “updated cost”. On 19-9-2016 a Single Judge quashed the price fixation and ordered recomputation; a Division Bench dismissed the Board’s letters-patent appeal on 21-11-2017. The Board has now succeeded before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after accepting the allotment price and executing an agreement, the respondent was estopped from challenging the price fixed by the Bihar State Housing Board.
  2. Whether the High Court erred in directing the Board to charge only a proportionate “updated cost” instead of the market price determined by the Board.
  3. Incidental issue: the legality of allotting public land without a fresh advertisement and the effect of such illegality once the respondent has constructed a running hospital.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The price was fixed on a rational basis pursuant to earlier Board decisions (Office Order 2-3-2001 and meeting dated 13-6-2013).
  • The respondent, having thrice accepted the payment schedule and having paid substantial sums, is estopped from disputing the price.
  • The High Court exceeded its jurisdiction by substituting its own price for a commercial decision of the Board.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The advertisement contemplated only “up to date cost/price”, not market price; hence the Board could not charge market rate.
  • The 13-6-2013 decision related only to resale by allottees, not initial allotment, and Office Order 2-3-2001 concerned reserve price in auctions, which were inapplicable.
  • The High Court correctly relied on the Board’s own calculation method (Annexure H) and found the Board’s fixation arbitrary.

Table of Precedents Cited

PrecedentRule or Principle Cited ForApplication by the Court
Akhil Bhartiya Upbhokta Congress v. State of M.P., (2011) 5 SCC 29 Allotment of public land without advertisement is arbitrary and violates Article 14. Used to show that the initial allotment of plots without advertisement was contrary to settled law, though cancellation was deemed impractical at this stage.
Institute of Law v. Neeraj Sharma, (2015) 1 SCC 720 Allotment without public notice and transparent criteria is invalid. Reinforced the above principle on transparency in disposal of public property.
Meerut Development Authority v. Association of Management Studies, (2009) 6 SCC 171 Tender is merely an invitation; disposal of public property must be fair and transparent. Cited to emphasise the limited rights of applicants and the necessity of open processes.
U.P. Housing & Development Board v. Ramesh Chandra Agarwal, (2019) 6 SCC 554 No vested right to allotment; authorities cannot be compelled to contract at a specified price. Relied upon to negate the respondent’s claim of entitlement to a particular price.
Style (Dress Land) v. State (UT of Chandigarh), (1999) 7 SCC 89 Allotting authority is entitled to interest on delayed payments even during pendency of stay. Basis for awarding interest, albeit waived for a specific period under Article 142.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Illegality of Allotment Without Advertisement: Relying on Akhil Bhartiya Upbhokta Congress and related cases, the Court observed that disposing of public property without public notice breaches Article 14. Nonetheless, since the respondent’s hospital is already operational, cancelling the allotment would be against public interest.

2. Estoppel Against Challenging Price: The respondent accepted the Board’s price on three separate occasions (letters dated 21-3-2014, 2-4-2014, and payment of 20% in January 2015) and executed a formal agreement on 12-3-2015. Having thus consented, it was estopped from later disputing the price.

3. High Court’s Error: The High Court’s distinction between “updated cost” and “market price” was termed irrelevant because the respondent had already consented to the Board’s demand. Moreover, price fixation is a commercial decision of the State-instrumentality, not ordinarily open to judicial substitution absent arbitrariness, which was not demonstrated.

4. Equitable Adjustment of Interest: Applying Style (Dress Land), the Court held the Board entitled to interest on delayed payments but, exercising Article 142 powers, waived interest for the period between the writ filing and the present judgment if the respondent clears the remaining consideration within six months.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; High Court orders dated 19-9-2016 and 21-11-2017 are set aside.

Consequences: the respondent must pay the balance sale consideration within six months; interest for the litigation period is waived, but interest will otherwise apply to delayed payments. The decision reinforces that once a party unconditionally accepts contractual terms with a public body, it cannot subsequently challenge the agreed price, and it underscores judicial reluctance to rewrite commercial terms fixed by State agencies.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Bihar State Housing Board And Others v. Radha Ballabh Health Care And Research Institute Private Limited .

    Hemant Gupta, J.— Leave granted. The challenge in the present appeal is to an order passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature at Patna on 21-11-2017 2017 SCC OnLine Pat 1833, 2018 AIR CC 1929, whereby, the letters patent appeal against an order passed by the learned Single Bench on 19-9-2016 2016 SCC OnLine Pat 10108 was dismissed.

    2. The appellant published an advertisement on 10-5-2008 inviting applications for allotment of plot for health centre in Lohia Nagar Housing Colony, Patna measuring 43,000 sq ft at the price of Rs 1,71,89,057. Rs 1,00,000 was the earnest money. The respondent applied for such plot along with the amount of earnest money. It was mentioned in the advertisement that upon receipt of more than one application, allotment shall be made by draw of lots and that the Chairman-cum-Managing Director of the appellant has the power to cancel allotment without assigning any reason. The respondent herein was the sole applicant for seeking allotment of plot advertised for health centre but no such plot was allotted to the respondent, may be for the reason that the respondent being the sole applicant.

    3. The respondent filed writ petition before the High Court in the year 2009 challenging the action of the appellant in not accepting the application of the respondent for the reason that it had not submitted the documents of recognition from the State Government. In view of the stand taken, the High Court directed 2011 SCC OnLine Pat 1577 the appellant to take a decision on the application of the respondent within a period of one month. Subsequently, contempt petition was filed wherein the Court was informed 2012 SCC OnLine Pat 1729 that the request of the respondent for allotment of plot was not accepted. The respondent was given liberty to challenge the decision of the appellant by way of a fresh writ petition.

    4. The respondent again filed writ petition before the High Court contending that the respondent approached the Managing Director of the appellant, who agreed to the proposal of allotment of alternative plots for construction of hospital in lieu of original plot offered, though with much less area than the plot advertised earlier. The respondent submitted the technical and financial proposal also stating that the plot, which was advertised, was of an area of 43,000 sq ft for a consideration of Rs 1,71,89,057, thus, there should be proportionate reduction of price on account of lesser area being offered. The respondent sought allotment on the terms and conditions of the advertisement itself. The two plots offered as alternative to the earlier plot, were Plots Nos. G-5 and G-6 measuring an area of 10,000 sq ft and 14,000 sq ft respectively situated near Rajendra Nagar Overbridge in Patna. However, the Board took a decision to allot the aforesaid plots on the basis of Swiss Challenge Method. The said decision was communicated to the respondent on 14-12-2011.

    5. The said writ petition was decided on 10-5-2013 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 1584 holding that the advertisement cannot be given a go-by adopting a method of allotment other than what was described in the advertisement. As such, the Swiss Challenge Method cannot be applied in the case of the respondent. However, change of plot was not interfered with in view of the fact that the respondent agreed for the offered plots. The appellant was directed to consider issuing an allotment letter in favour of the respondent in terms of the advertisement but with respect to Plots Nos. G-5 and G-6 in place of the original plot, as mentioned in the advertisement, on the same terms and conditions with proportionate cost reduction on account of the area of the plots having been reduced. The High Court passed the following order: (Radha Ballabh Health Care case 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 1584, SCC OnLine Pat para 8)

    “8. In view of the reasons and discussions made above, the decision of the Board to allot Plots Nos. G-5 and G-6 in favour of the petitioner vide Office Order No. 160 of 2009 as contained in Memo No. 10792 dated 9-12-2011 (Annexure 16) as also Letter No. 10871 dated 14-12-2011 (Annexure 17) on the basis of Swiss Challenge Method is hereby quashed. The respondent Board is directed to consider the letter dated 3rd of January, 2012, written by the petitioner to the respondent Board and on considering the same, issue allotment letter in terms of the advertisement, as contained in Annexure 1 with respect to Plots Nos. G-5 and G-6 in lieu of the original plot as mentioned in the advertisement on the same terms and conditions with proportionate cost on account of the area of the plots being reduced.”

    6. Such order was modified 2014 SCC OnLine Pat 8292 at the instance of the appellant on 9-1-2014 that in view of the condition in the advertisement that if the allotment letter is issued after 31-5-2008, the price of the allotted plot will be on the updated rates as on the date of allotment. The Court held as under: (Bihar State Housing Board case 2014 SCC OnLine Pat 8292, SCC OnLine Pat paras 4-6)

    “4. It is submitted that advertisement states that if the allotment letter is issued after 31-5-2008 the price of the allotted plot would be on updated rate as on the date of allotment as per the terms of advertisement contained in Annexure 1 to the writ application.
    5. The order dated 10-5-2013 passed in Radha Ballabh Health Care & Research Institute (P) Ltd. v. Bihar State Housing Board 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 1584 is clarified to the above extent.
    6. After such clarification it goes without saying that the Board upon considering the letter dated 3-1-2012 written by the petitioner is to issue the allotment letter, and as such, the same be issued within a period of two months from today.”

    7. It is thereafter on 14-2-2014, the respondent was called upon to deposit up to date price of Rs 13,09,95,041. The said price was not deposited by the respondent, instead the respondent replied vide letter dated 19-2-2014 that the said demand is contrary to the direction issued by the High Court and requested the Board to calculate the updated price as per the terms and conditions.

    8. On 13-3-2014, the appellant revised price to Rs 10,58,91,736 and raised demand for payment of such amount to be deposited by 31-3-2014. In response to such communication, the respondent on 21-3-2014 communicated its acceptance. The said communication reads as under:

    “With reference to your Letter No. 1902 dated 13-3-2014 directing us to deposit Rs 10,58,91,736 for Plots Nos. GC-5, GC-6, Kankarbagh, Patna allotted to Radha Ballabh Health Care & Research Institute Pvt. Ltd.
    We need to inform you that the Board may measure the exact area of the land to be delivered before the representatives of both sides and thereafter hand over the vacant possession of the land erecting boundary wall, the cost of which shall be borne by us.
    The amount (money), directed to be deposited for the said plot is against the directions of the Hon'ble High Court, Patna. We have raised this issue of price in our Letter dt. 19-2-2014, however, subject to our right and without prejudice, we are ready to take the land (Plots Nos. GC-5 & GC-6) under protest.
    We propose the following payment plan.
    We will deposit a token advance of Rs 40 lakhs at the outset. Once we get vacant possession of the land, with boundary wall erected (the cost of which will be borne by us) we will deposit up to 20% of the total cost (subject to final measurement of the land).
    The remaining amount will be paid in four quarterly instalments per annum in three years. Once again we would emphasise that if we do not get the vacant possession of the land within two (2) months of token advance deposit, the Housing Board shall be held responsible and will have to bear bank interest levied on us by the bank/borrower.
    Kindly approve our proposal at the earliest and let us know your bank with account number, so that we can proceed with the payment process.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    9. Again, the appellant sought the consent of the respondent on 1-4-2014 seeking advance payment of Rs 40,00,000 and that the balance payment of Rs 8,47,93,330 was payable in 12 quarterly instalments in three years. The communication of the appellant reads as under:

    “Reference: Yours Letter No.-zero dated 21-3-2014.
    Sir,
    Review is made of your letter regarding aforesaid subject. In course of review for the payment, following payment list is prepared:
    (a) Total price on the date 31-3-2014 - Rs (Illegible)
    (b) Advance payment - Rs 40,00,000
    (c) Earlier deposited earnest amount-Rs 1,00,000
    (d) 20% of total amount-Rs 2,11,98,400
    (e) Deducted advance payment and earnest amount-Rs 41,00,000
    (f) Rest preliminary amount to be deposited prior to deed of agreement - Rs 1,70,98,400
    (g) Rest amount of the price-Rs 8,47,93,330
    (h) Amount of instalment payable in 12 quarterly instalments in three years-
    (i) Normal with interest @14%-Rs 87,74,750
    (ii) By delay with interest @18%-Rs 92,98,962
    So if you are willing for the allotment in question, please give your consent on aforementioned schedule, otherwise it shall be deemed that you are not willing for the allotment.”

    10. The respondent communicated on 2-4-2014 accepting the payment schedule under protest subject to final measurements of the plot. Such communication reads as under:

    “Ref.: Housing Board's Letter No. 2445 dated 1-4-2014
    Dear Sir,
    Received the Board's aforesaid letter regarding the payment schedule for Plots Nos. GC-5 and GC-6, Kankarbagh, Patna.
    As stated earlier and in the light of our letter dt. 21-3-2014, we accept the payment schedule, under protest subject to the final measurement of the plots.
    We are enclosing herewith two banker's cheques of Rs 40,00,000 (Rupees forty lakhs),
    1. Banker's Cheque No. 021879 for Rs 20,00,000 (Rupees twenty lakhs) and
    2. Banker Cheque No. 021880 of Rs 20,00,000 (Rupees twenty lakhs) drawn at Patna dated 2-4-2014 as advance payment.
    Please ensure the possession of plot/land, with boundary wall erected (at our cost) at its earliest.”

    11. It is thereafter, a formal letter of allotment was issued on 11-12-2014 acknowledging that Rs 41 lakhs stand deposited and that 20% of the interim price of the land amounting to Rs 2,11,98,400 be paid within thirty days. Such amount was paid by the respondent. It is thereafter, an agreement was executed on 12-3-2015 between the appellant and the respondent. Thus, a concluded contract came into existence with deposit of the amount demanded by the appellant and paid by the respondent.

    12. After accepting the allotment on the price as per the communication referred to above, the respondent filed a writ petition disputing the allotment price. The learned Single Bench allowed the writ petition on the basis that proportionate price of the plot advertised in Lohia Nagar alone can be claimed by the appellant.

    13. The High Court has sought the basis of fixation of price of the plot during the proceedings before it. The proportionate price claimed by the appellant was found to be arbitrary. The High Court, vide order dated 19-9-2016 2016 SCC OnLine Pat 10108, issued the following directions: (Radha Ballabh Health Care case 2016 SCC OnLine Pat 10108, SCC OnLine Pat paras 20-22)

    “20. … In my considered view, only that procedure could have been followed for updation of price of allotment.
    21. Thus, it is held that the Board has acted in arbitrary manner in fixing the price of the plots concerned due to which the petitioner has been fastened with a liability to pay a price several times higher than which could have been charged. It has also to be kept in mind that due to the delay caused by the Board, the allotment could not be finalized on the date fixed.
    22. Accordingly, this writ petition is allowed. The price fixed by the Board is quashed and set aside. The Board is directed to recalculate the cost of the plots of the petitioner in accordance with the procedure adopted under Annexure H appended with the counter affidavit within a period of three months from the date of receipt/production of a copy of this order and return the excess amount, if any, having been paid by the petitioner in terms of the calculation done by the Board. If the same is not done within the aforesaid period of three months, the petitioner would be entitled for interest @14% p.a. on the said amount to be calculated from the date of expiry of the aforesaid period of three months till the date of final payment.”

    14. In terms of the directions of the High Court, the appellant has paid back a sum of Rs 3,31,94,435.53.

    15. It is the said order 2016 SCC OnLine Pat 10108 of the learned Single Judge, which was affirmed in the letters patent appeal, on the ground that the Board could only claim up to date rate and not the market rate as claimed in the letter of allotment.

    16. The respondent in the counter-affidavit in the present appeal has referred to the decision taken by the appellant in its 193rd meeting dated 10-2-2000 on the basis of which office order was issued on 2-3-2001 to fix reserve price for the purpose of auction of the plots/houses/flats. The decision is as under:

    “(i) The auction price of such plots/houses/flats, having taken within one last preceding year.
    (ii) The updated price of the commercial rate fixed by the Board.
    (iii) The rate prescribed by the Collector for the purpose of registration.
    In addition to this the Managing Director of the Bihar State Housing Board was authorised to have discretion keeping the place, time and circumstances.”

    17. It is also pointed out that on 13-6-2013, the market value was determined for calculation of premium for Financial Year 2013-2014 and that on the basis of such calculation, the price of the plot allotted has been fixed.

    18. Mr Ranjit Kumar, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant, argued that the decision of the appellant is based upon rational basis in terms of the decision of the Board taken earlier. It is argued that after accepting the offer of allotment and paying initial amount, the respondent is estopped to dispute the allotment price.

    19. The argument of Mr Neeraj Kishan Kaul, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent, is that the advertisement inviting applications for allotment of plot contemplated charging of up to date cost/price which is not the same as market price, therefore, the appellant cannot charge market price of the plot. It was argued that the decision of 13-6-2013 is in respect of sale of the plot by the allottee to third person so as to pay 50% of the market value to the appellant. Therefore, such decision has rightly not been accepted by the High Court. It is also argued that office order dated 2-3-2001 deals with fixation of reserve price in the event of decision of the Board to auction the plot. Therefore, the High Court has rightly fixed price of the plot on the basis of calculations given by the appellant alone. Thus, the order of the High Court does not warrant any interference in an appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution of India.

    20. We find that the entire approach of the High Court is erroneous and not sustainable. Plots Nos. G-5 and G-6 located in Rajinder Nagar Overbridge were never advertised. The allotment of the alternative plots was made by the appellant in lieu of the plot advertised in Lohia Nagar, Kankarbagh, Patna measuring 43,000 sq ft. The location and the size of the alternative plots are different.

    21. Firstly, we need to examine as to whether, the appellant could allot plots without advertisement. This Court in a judgment in Akhil Bhartiya Upbhokta Congress v. State of M.P. (2011) 5 SCC 29 deprecated the practice of allotment of plots dehors an invitation or advertisement by the State or its instrumentalities. The Court held as under:

    “66. We may add that there cannot be any policy, much less, a rational policy of allotting land on the basis of applications made by individuals, bodies, organisations or institutions dehors an invitation or advertisement by the State or its agency/instrumentality. By entertaining applications made by individuals, organisations or institutions for allotment of land or for grant of any other type of largesse the State cannot exclude other eligible persons from lodging competing claim. Any allotment of land or grant of other form of largesse by the State or its agencies/instrumentalities by treating the exercise as a private venture is liable to be treated as arbitrary, discriminatory and an act of favouritism and/or nepotism violating the soul of the equality clause embodied in Article 14 of the Constitution.
    67. This, however, does not mean that the State can never allot land to the institutions/organisations engaged in educational, cultural, social or philanthropic activities or are rendering service to the society except by way of auction. Nevertheless, it is necessary to observe that once a piece of land is earmarked or identified for allotment to institutions/organisations engaged in any such activity, the actual exercise of allotment must be done in a manner consistent with the doctrine of equality. The competent authority should, as a matter of course, issue an advertisement incorporating therein the conditions of eligibility so as to enable all similarly situated eligible persons, institutions/organisations to participate in the process of allotment, whether by way of auction or otherwise. In a given case the Government may allot land at a fixed price but in that case also allotment must be preceded by a wholesome exercise consistent with Article 14 of the Constitution.”

    22. In another judgment in Institute of Law v. Neeraj Sharma (2015) 1 SCC 720, this Court upheld the order Civil Writ Petition No. 6916 of 2004 2006 SCC OnLine P&H 539 of the High Court setting aside allotment of land in favour of the appellant institute without giving any public notice and in the absence of a transparent policy and any objective criteria.

    23. Further, in Meerut Development Authority v. Assn. of Management Studies (2009) 6 SCC 171, this Court held that a tender is an offer. It is an invitation to seek communication to convey acceptance. This Court held as under:

    “26. A tender is an offer. It is something which invites and is communicated to notify acceptance. Broadly stated it must be unconditional; must be in the proper form, the person by whom tender is made must be able to and willing to perform his obligations. The terms of the invitation to tender cannot be open to judicial scrutiny because the invitation to tender is in the realm of contract. However, a limited judicial review may be available in cases where it is established that the terms of the invitation to tender were so tailor-made to suit the convenience of any particular person with a view to eliminate all others from participating in the bidding process.
    27. The bidders participating in the tender process have no other right except the right to equality and fair treatment in the matter of evaluation of competitive bids offered by interested persons in response to notice inviting tenders in a transparent manner and free from hidden agenda. One cannot challenge the terms and conditions of the tender except on the abovestated ground, the reason being the terms of the invitation to tender are in the realm of the contract. No bidder is entitled as a matter of right to insist the authority inviting tenders to enter into further negotiations unless the terms and conditions of notice so provided for such negotiations.
    28. It is so well settled in law and needs no restatement at our hands that disposal of the public property by the State or its instrumentalities partakes the character of a trust. The methods to be adopted for disposal of public property must be fair and transparent providing an opportunity to all the interested persons to participate in the process.”

    24. Therefore, the respondent does not get any right of allotment of a plot merely because it has applied for allotment earlier. The response to an advertisement does not lead to any obligation on the appellant to allot any plot. Admittedly, there was no allotment in pursuance of the offer submitted by the respondent. Mere fact that the respondent had applied for allotment of a plot does not confer any legal or equitable right to seek allotment of any plot.

    25. The appellant was more than indulgent in allotting two plots of 24,000 sq ft without any advertisement advertising such plots merely on the basis of the fact that the respondent had applied for allotment at an earlier stage in respect of another plot. The public property could not be disposed of without any advertisement and without giving opportunity to eligible persons to apply and seek consideration of allotment of public property in a transparent and non-discriminatory manner.

    26. Therefore, the very allotment of two plots, on the basis of direction given by the High Court to consider the claim of the respondent, is against the public interest. However, the fact remains that after allotment, the respondent has constructed hospital which is operational, therefore, it is too late in the day to cancel the allotment of the plot allotted to the respondent.

    27. The question raised before the High Court was whether the appellant is entitled to updated price or the market price. We find that such discussion by the High Court is totally irrelevant inasmuch as the respondent has accepted the price on three occasions; firstly, on 21-3-2014, then on 2-4-2014 whereby, the respondent remitted a sum of Rs 40 lakhs by two cheques as well. The respondent has accepted the payment schedule but subject to final measurements of plots. It is thereafter the letter of allotment was issued on 11-12-2014. Thirdly, the respondent remitted another sum of Rs 1,71,00,000 vide three separate cheques in January 2015 so as to complete 20% of the interim price of letter of allotment dated 11-12-2014. It is thereafter an agreement was executed on 12-3-2015 unequivocally and categorically accepting the offer of the appellant. It was not open to the respondent to dispute the price of allotment offered by the appellant. The respondent is estopped to dispute the allotment price in these circumstances.

    28. Recently, in a judgment of this Court in U.P. Housing & Development Board v. Ramesh Chandra Agarwal (2019) 6 SCC 554, the appeal was allowed against an order passed 2018 SCC OnLine NCDRC 1172 by the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission for allotment of a plot for the reason that the complainant had applied for allotment of a plot way back in 1982. It was held that there was no contractual entitlement for allotment of a flat at a specified price. The Court held as under: (U.P. Housing & Development Board case (2019) 6 SCC 554)

    “13. The appellant is governed by the terms and conditions advertised in its Registration Booklet and by the 1979 Rules. Clause 5 of the Registration Booklet indicates that mere registration does not confer a right for allotment. Rule 15 makes a provision to the effect that the Board is not bound to allot a house or plot to every registered holder. Rule 30 indicates that after the Board advertises the availability of a scheme in the newspaper, every registered applicant is at liberty to submit a consent letter for participation in the draw of lots. Mere registration does not oblige the authority to include every registered applicant in the draw of lots. The applicant must show readiness and willingness to participate in a draw of lots in respect of a specified scheme. This is evident from Rule 30(2). A set of priorities is provided in Rule 30(5). In view of the clear position in the brochure and the 1979 Rules, the respondent had no vested right to seek an allotment. As a registered applicant, the respondent was at liberty to seek to participate in the draw of lots by indicating his consent to the appellant. After paying an initial sum of Rs 500 in 1982 and a further sum of Rs 500 in 1985, the respondent did not pursue any remedies until 1993 when he moved the District Forum. The order of the District Forum gave liberty to the respondent to seek allotment at the current market value under any of the schemes of the appellant. Ncdrc was manifestly in error in issuing a direction to the appellant to make an allotment to the respondent for a total sum of Rs 2,50,000 in any of the flats available in the Mandola Vihar Yojna, Ghaziabad. There is no rational basis or justification for the amount of Rs 2,50,000 which has been fixed by Ncdrc. This direction proceeds purely on the basis of the ipse dixit of the forum. The appellant, as a public authority, could not have been compelled to enter into a contract with the respondent. There was no contractual entitlement of the respondent to the allotment of a flat much less for an allotment at a specified price. In its effort to render justice, Ncdrc has adopted a view which is contrary to the basic principles of contract governing the law on the subject.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    29. The appellant as State is required to act fairly in fixation of price for allotment of a plot. The order of the High Court to direct the appellant to charge the price proportionate to the price advertised earlier has no legal basis. It is a commercial decision taken by the appellant fixing the price of the plot. In the matter of fixation of price, the Board has a right to fix such price, more so, when such price was accepted by the respondent on three different occasions as mentioned above.

    30. The action of the respondent to dispute the allotment price after accepting the price is neither fair nor reasonable and cannot be accepted.

    31. In terms of judgment of this Court in Style (Dress Land) v. State (UT of Chandigarh) (1999) 7 SCC 89, the appellant is entitled to the allotment price along with interest on the delayed payment even if there is stay by the Court. But, keeping in view the cause of allotment of plot i.e. hospital, we order, in exercise of our jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution, that the interest for the period from the date of filing of the writ petition before the High Court till the date of order of this Court shall not be charged from the respondent provided the respondent pays the entire balance sale consideration in terms of the condition of allotment within six months from today.

    32. In view of the above, we find that the order 2017 SCC OnLine Pat 1833, 2018 AIR CC 1929 of the High Court is not sustainable in law, thus, the order is set aside. The appeal is accordingly allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bihar State Housing ... v. Radha Ballabh Health...
    (Sep 13, 2019)