Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants are manufacturers of "vacuum circuit breakers" who classified their product under sub-heading 8535.00 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. A show cause notice was issued to re-classify the products under chapter heading 8537 for goods cleared during Oct. 1993 to Aug. 1994. The appellants contested the notice, and the adjudicating authority accepted their contention and set aside the proceedings. The department appealed; Commissioner (Appeals) reversed the original order holding that the products fall under 8537 based on a Board order issued under Section 37B of the Central Excise Act, 1944. The appellants appealed that decision to the Tribunal, resulting in the present opinion delivered by M.V. Ravindran, Member (J).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellants' vacuum circuit breakers cleared between October 1993 and August 1994 are classifiable under sub-heading 8535.00 or under chapter heading 8537.
  2. Whether the Board's order issued under Section 37B on 14-7-94 applies retrospectively to the period prior to its publication (i.e., to Oct. 1993 onward) or is effective only prospectively from date of publication.
  3. Whether the HSN Explanatory Notes for Chapters 85.35 and 85.37 support classification under 85.35 for the appellants' products.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The issue is covered by the Tribunal's decision in S & S Power Switchgear Ltd. v. CCE, Chennai-II (Tri.-Chen.).
  • HSN Notes of Chapters 85.35 and 85.37 indicate the products manufactured by them are classifiable under Chapter heading 85.35.
  • HSN Notes and the Central Excise Tariff are abridged and the HSN Notes should apply to Heading 85.35 of CETA, 1985.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Department (learned DR) relied on the Commissioner (Appeals) finding and on the Tribunal decision in Crompton Greaves Ltd. v. CCE, Aurangabad (Tri.).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S & S Power Switchgear Ltd. v. CCE, Chennai-II The Board's order under Section 37B is applicable prospectively from date of its publication; cannot raise demand for period prior to publication. The Tribunal's majority holding was followed; the Board order dated 14-7-94 was held not to apply retrospectively to Oct. 1993–Aug. 1994.
Crompton Greaves Ltd. v. CCE, Aurangabad Relied upon by the Department for classification support (as cited by learned DR). The court distinguished this precedent, noting it concerned classification of panels and not vacuum circuit breakers, and found the reliance incorrect.
HM Bags manufacturing Co. (supra) Supports the principle that a Section 37B order is applicable from date of publication (as cited in S & S Power Switchgear). Used by the Tribunal majority to support prospective application of the Board's Section 37B order; relied on by the court in affirming prospective application.
RN Polyasacks Held that a Section 37B order is applicable from the date of issue of the trade notice by the concerned Commissionerate and not from the date of the Board order (as cited in S & S Power Switchgear). Referenced by the Tribunal majority and considered in the court's reasoning about prospective application of the Board order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court observed that the Board's order invoked by Commissioner (Appeals) was issued on 14-7-94, while the dispute concerned clearances from Oct. 1993 to Aug. 1994. Relying on the majority decision in S & S Power Switchgear (which analysed the Board's exercise under Section 37B and related authorities such as HM Bags and RN Polyasacks), the court held that the Board's Section 37B order operates prospectively from its publication and cannot be applied to periods prior to that date. The court also examined HSN Explanatory Notes to Chapters 85.35 and 85.37 and observed that, read with those notes, the appellants' "vacuum circuit breakers" — which they cleared independently to purchasers — fall under Chapter sub-heading 8535. The court distinguished Crompton Greaves as dealing with panels rather than vacuum circuit breakers and therefore found the Department's reliance on it misplaced. Based on these conclusions, the court found the impugned order unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

Appeal allowed; impugned order set aside.

Consequences: The Tribunal set aside the Commissioner (Appeals) order and allowed the appellants' appeal, with consequential relief if any. The direct effect is restoration of the appellants' classification under sub-heading 8535 for the relevant period (Oct. 1993 to Aug. 1994) as the Board's Section 37B order of 14-7-94 was held not to apply retrospectively. The opinion does not announce any new precedent beyond applying the principles set out in the cited authorities.

    Jyoti Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, Vadodara

    [Order per : M.V. Ravindran, Member (J)]. - This appeal is directed against the order-in-appeal dated 30-7-2001, which reversed the order-in-original, which held that the classification of product under heading 8535.

    2. The relevant facts are arise for consideration are that the appellant are manufacturer of vacuum circuit breakers, which they classified under sub-heading 8535.00 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. Show cause notice was issued to the appellant for re-classification of the said products under chapter heading 8537 cleared during Oct. 93 to August, 94. The appellants resisted to the show cause notice on the ground that the classification list as filed was duly approved by the excise authorities and there is no fresh evidence for re-classification. The adjudicating authority has accepted the contention of the appellant and set aside the proceedings initiated by the show cause notice. On an appeal by the department, the Commissioner (Appeals) has set aside the order-in-original on the ground that the final products will fall under Chapter sub-heading No. 8537 as per the circular issued by Board in exercise of power under Section 37B of the Central Excise Act, 1944. Hence, this appeal.

    3. The learned Advocate submits that issue is now squarely covered by the decision of the Tribunal in the case of S & S Power Switchgear Ltd. v. CCE, Chennai-II as reported in (Tri.-Chen.). It is also his submission that HSN Notes of Chapter 85.35 and 85.37 make it very clear that products manufactured by them shall be classifiable under chapter heading 85.35. It is his submissions that since the HSN Notes and Central Excise Tarrif are abridged the notes of the HSN would clearly apply to the Heading 85.35 of CETA, 1985.

    4. The learned DR, on the other hand, reiterate the finding of the Commissioner (Appeals) and relies upon the decision of the Tribunal in the case of Crompton Greaves Ltd. v. CCE, Aurangabad reported in (Tri.).

    5. Considered the submission made by both sides and perused the case records. It is not in dispute that the appellants are manufacturer of “vacuum circuit breakers” and classified the same under chapter sub-heading 8535.00. The reliance placed by the Commissioner (Appeals) on the order of the Board issued under Section 37B, reads as under : -

    “(3)  heading No. 85.35 of the Tariff deals with electrical apparatus for switching or protecting electrical circuits (for example switches, fuses, lightening arresters, voltage limiters, surge suppressors, plugs, junction boxes), for a voltage exceeding 1000 volts. Heading No. 85.37 of the Tariff deals with boards panels (including numerical controls panels), consoles, desks, cabinets and other bases, equipped with two or more apparatus of heading no. 85.35 or 85.36 for electric control or the distribution of electricity, including those incorporating instruments of apparatus of Chapter 90, other than switching apparatus of heading no. 85.17. Keeping in view the process of manufacture, composition of circuit breakers, its end use and HSN Explanatory Notes etc, the Board is of the view that the circuit breakers as mentioned in the list enclosed are classifiable under Chapter 85.37 of the Tariff.”

    6. We find that the above reproduced order of the Board was issued on 14-7-94 while the question in dispute in the present case is for the period of Oct, 93 to August, 94. We find strong force in the contention of the learned Advocate that as the Board’s order was issued on 14-7-94 it would not period prior to the order. We find that in an identical issue and in respect of the same order of Board was in dispute in the case of S&S Power Switchgear (supra), wherein the majority order held as under :-

    “I have considered the submissions made by both the sides and gone through the order recorded by learned Member (T) and Member (J). I find that learned Member (T) Shri S.S. Sekhon has thoroughly analysed the whole issue and has recorded a very detailed order supported by various judgments as cited by him under para 3. I have also perused the various classification lists and it is observed that in the classification list the assessee has clearly described the goods as HT circuit breakers. Further the matter was taken to the Central Board by the Indian Electrical and Electronic Manufacturers Association who had represented that there is no uniformity in the classification of circuit breakers above 1000 volts for the purpose of levy of Central Excise duty under Schedule to Tariff Act, 1985 (henceforth. referred to as Tariff). The association had furnished a list of such HV and MV circuit breakers manufactured in India and it was pointed out by the Association that the Central Excise Officers in different Commissionerate have been classifying such circuit breakers under Headings 9535 and 8537 of the Tariff. In order to ensure uniformity in classification of this product, the Board examined the classification of circuit breakers and issued an order in exercise of the power conferred under Section 37B of the CE Act, 1944 for the purpose of ensuring uniformity in classification of the product and levy of duty, vide order No. 32/8/94-CX., issued from file No. 151/6/94-CX.4, dated 14-7-94. The list enclosed with the Board’s order as noted above, covers circuit breakers manufactured by the appellants also. Since there was confusion in the minds of the trader as well as the Revenue, whether the product in question viz. circuit breakers would fall under Tariff Heading 8535 or under 8537 or the Tariff and since there was no uniformity in the classification of circuit breakers as admitted by the Board while issue the Section 37B order, the order issued by the Board will be applicable prospectively i.e. from the date of its publication. In view of the order recorded by learned Member (T) in para 3(d) at page 7 and in view of the judgment in the case of HM Bags manufacturing Co. reported in (SC) the order issued by the Board under Section 37B will be applicable from the date of its publication. Therefore, no demand of duty can be raised for a period prior to the date of publication of such order. Learned Member (T) has also relied upon the judgment of the Tribunal in the case of RN Polyasacks reported in in which it has been held that the Section 37B order issued by the Central Board will be applicable from the date of issue of the trade notice by the concerned Commissionerate and not from the date of issue of the order by the Board. While rendering the above judgment the Tribunal had followed the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of HM Bags Manufacturing Co. (supra).”

    7. It can be seen from the above reproduced paragraph that majority decision in the case of S & S Power Switchgear (supra) has held that Board’s order under Section 37B would be applicable only prospectively. It is also seen from records that the products of the appellant would get covered under Chapter Sub-heading No. 8535,  if read with the HOS Explanatory Notes to Chapter Headings 85.35 and  85.37,  as  appellants  clear their product “Vacuum  Circuit Breakers” independently to their purchasers.

    8. Reliance placed by the learned DR in the case of Crompton Greaves (supra) is not correct inasmuch as the said order of the Tribunal was in respect of classification of the panels and not of “vacuum circuit breakers”.

    9. Accordingly, we find that impugned order is liable to be set aside and respectfully following the majority order in the case of S & S Power Switchgear (supra), we set aside the impugned order and allow the appeal with consequential relief, if any.

    (Dictated and pronounced in the Court)

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jyoti Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, Vadodara
    (Dec 19, 2006)