AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Forest (Conservation) Act, 1890
  • FC Act
  • MMRD Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Forest (Conservation) Act, 1890
  • FC Act
  • MMRD Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This order resolves a large batch of Interim Applications (IAs) filed in the long-pending public interest litigation concerning forest conservation. Each IA was brought by a private company or government entity seeking permission to divert specified areas of forest land for mining, transmission lines, salt works, or other industrial projects. The Central Empowered Committee (CEC) and, in several instances, the Forest Advisory Committee (FAC) had already examined the individual proposals and submitted reports recommending conditional approvals.

The court, acting as the final overseer of forest-related clearances under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, reviewed the CEC/FAC reports, recorded the applicants’ acceptance of proposed safeguards, and issued directions to the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF), the Director-General of Forests, and other authorities to take final decisions within prescribed time frames. Where earlier Supreme Court orders dated 25-4-2008 and 2-5-2008 were relevant, the court extended their benefit to similarly situated applicants. In a separate dispute involving M/s BALCO, the matter was remitted to the High Court with a request for expedited disposal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether diversion of specific parcels of forest land should be permitted for mining, transmission lines, salt works, or other industrial uses, and if so, under what conditions.
  2. Whether applicants who had carried out mining operations without requisite clearances could continue operations upon payment of penalties in line with earlier Supreme Court orders of 25-4-2008 and 2-5-2008.
  3. Whether additional penalties were warranted where seals placed by the Forest Department had been broken by certain applicants.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
(2011) 15 SCC 658 (Order dated 25-4-2008) Earlier Supreme Court order regulating temporary working permission for mining leases and prescribing compliance conditions. Several IAs (e.g., those filed by M/s K.N. Ram & Co. and M/s Bonai Industrial Co. Ltd.) were disposed of “in terms of” this order.
(2011) 15 SCC 653 (Order dated 2-5-2008) Supreme Court order granting conditional continuation of mining operations upon payment of specified penalties. The court extended the “benefit” of this order to multiple applicants, subject to payment of penalty and, in some cases, an additional ₹1 lakh for breaking official seals.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Rather than conducting a merits-based environmental assessment itself, the court relied on the expert findings of the CEC and FAC. The key analytical steps were:

  • Delegated Technical Review: For each IA, the court noted that the CEC (and sometimes the FAC) had already evaluated the proposal and set out environmental safeguards such as payment of Net Present Value (NPV), compensatory afforestation, and restrictions on mineral sale.
  • Applicant Consent: The court recorded that every applicant expressly accepted the additional conditions recommended by the CEC/FAC, thereby eliminating contested factual issues.
  • Conditional Clearance Framework: Taking the above into account, the court authorized the MoEF or the Director-General of Forests to issue final approvals within specified time limits, but only after verifying compliance with all recommended conditions, environmental clearances, and payment of NPV or penalties.
  • Enforcement Measures: Where applicants had operated illegally or broken official seals, the court imposed additional financial penalties (₹1 lakh) to reinforce deterrence and directed deposit of the amount with the State-level committee.
  • Judicial Comity: In the BALCO land-regularisation dispute, because a connected writ petition was pending in the High Court of Chhattisgarh, the Supreme Court refrained from deciding the merits and instead requested the High Court to conclude the matter within three months, preserving hierarchical judicial processes.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF: All listed Interim Applications were disposed of with directions summarised below.

  • MoEF, FAC, and the Director-General of Forests must render final decisions on the requested forest-land diversions within the time frames set by the court and subject to conditions recommended by the CEC/FAC.
  • Applicants who had already undertaken unauthorised mining activities may continue operations only after paying the penalties fixed by earlier Supreme Court orders (and an additional ₹1 lakh in cases of seal-breaking).
  • The High Court of Chhattisgarh was directed to decide BALCO’s pending writ petition within three months.

Implications are primarily case-specific: approvals or rejections will now hinge on compliance with the CEC/FAC conditions and timely administrative action by MoEF. No new legal doctrine was created; the order reinforces the Supreme Court’s supervisory role in forest-land diversion while deferring technical evaluations to expert bodies.

    T.N Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union Of India And Others

    Order

    IAs Nos. 2164, 2167, 2169, 2170, 2239, 2319, 2304-05, 2306-07, 2293-94, 2298, 2329-2330, 2351, 2344-45 and 2129

    1. The applicant M/s Hindalco has sought for diversion of 106.76 ha of forest land for the renewal of the Kesarsada mining lease in its favour.

    2. The Director General of Forests is directed to take a decision in this matter having regard to the report submitted by CEC in the matter, within eight weeks. Application as regards the applicant is disposed of.

    IAs Nos. 2304-05

    3. The applicant M/s Ispat Godawari Ltd. in District Rajgaon, Chhattisgarh has sought for diversion of 110 ha of forest land for the mining of iron ore in its favour. CEC has considered the application and has made the following additional recommendations. FAC has also made certain recommendations.

    4. The additional conditions imposed by CEC are as under:

    (a) The mineral extracted from the mine will be exclusively for captive consumption/sale. No sale of mineral will be permissible.
    (b) The forest area approved under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1890 and the forest area included in the mining lease approved under the MMRD Act will be identical. The NPV will be payable for the entire forest area included in the mining lease approved under the MMDR Act and
    (c) The forest land will be handed over and allowed to be used for mining only after the environmental clearance is first accorded.

    The said conditions are acceptable to the applicant.

    5. Subject to the fulfilment of the above additional conditions, in addition to other stipulated conditions, MoEF may grant permission.

    6. The application as regards the applicant is disposed of accordingly.

    7. The applicant, M/s Pushp Steel and Mining (P) Ltd. sought for diversion of 66 ha of forest land in Kanker District for iron ore mining lease in its favour.

    8. Subject to the fulfilment of the additional conditions as in the case of M/s Ispat Godavari Ltd.'s application noted above, MoEF may grant permission. Application as regards the applicant is disposed of accordingly.

    IA No. 2378

    9. List on 7-11-2008 with connected matter.

    10. The Secretary, Ministry of Coal may give his views within four weeks.

    IAs Nos. 2293-94 and 2298

    11. FAC is given four weeks' time to take an appropriate decision.

    12. Adjourned by five weeks.

    13. The applicant, Mpsmcl in Sidhi District, Madhya Pradesh sought permission for mining of coal at Amelia (north coal block). Secretary, Ministry of Coal, may file his views within four weeks.

    14. List on 7-11-2008.

    IAs Nos. 2306-07

    15. The applicant, M/s Bhilai Steel Plant seeks permission for diversion of 883.22 ha of forest land for Rowghat iron ore mining project in its favour.

    16. CEC has filed its report. FAC has made certain recommendations. The applicant has to fulfil the recommendations made by FAC and also with an additional condition that the NPV for the forest area will be payable as per the rate applicable for area falling in a wildlife sanctuary. The conditions imposed by the CEC are acceptable to the applicant. Having regard to this fact, the MoEF may take a decision within a reasonable period. The applications as regards the applicant are disposed of accordingly.

    17. The applicant, M/s Madras Cements in Krishna District of Andhra Pradesh seeks permission for diversion of 160 ha of forest land for limestone mining in its favour.

    18. CEC has studied the project and has made certain observations. The suggestions/observations are acceptable to the applicant. The project may be reviewed by the MoEF in the light of the observations made by CEC in this regard. The application as regards the applicant is disposed of accordingly.

    19. The applicant, M/s Orissa Manganese and Minerals (P) Ltd. in Singhbhum (West) District of Jharkhand seeks permission for diversion of 141.447 ha of forest land for iron ore mining in its favour.

    20. CEC has studied the project and has made certain observations. The suggestions/observations are acceptable to the applicant. The project may be reviewed by the MoEF in the light of the observations made by CEC in this regard. The application as regards the applicant is disposed of accordingly.

    21. The applicant M/s JSW in District Bellary, Karnataka seeks permission for diversion of 200.73 ha of forest land for iron ore mining in its favour.

    22. CEC has examined the project and has suggested that it may be reviewed by MoEF in view of suggestions made by CEC. The applicant accepts the suggestions made by CEC. MoEF may give its decision keeping in view the suggestions made by CEC and after the report of the Lok Ayukt, Karnataka regarding Bellary-Hospat mining is received.

    23. The application as against the applicant is disposed of accordingly.

    24. Application In re: M/s V.M Salgaocar Brothers (P) Ltd. No orders.

    25. The applicant, M/s Orissa Mining Corporation in Keonjhar District of Orissa seeks diversion of 117.9648 ha of forest land (fresh area 76.7206 ha and broken up forest land 41.2442 ha) (out of 216.3617 ha of forest land proposed) in Gandhamardan Block A in its favour for first renewal of mining lease.

    26. CEC has examined the same and has laid down the following conditions:

    “(a) The Wildlife Institute of India should prepare a Wildlife Management Plan for the area which should be implemented at the project cost. The diversion of forest land for mining should be considered only if with appropriate remedial measures the adverse impact of mining on wildlife conservation and protection is found to be containable within reasonable limits;
    (b) Approval under the FC Act should be restricted to 117.9648 ha of forest area. The possession of the balance forest area should be taken over by the Forest Department. Before grant of the formal approval under the FC Act, the mining lease granted under the MMRD Act should be revised so that the total forest area included in the mining lease and the forest area approved under the FC Act are identical;
    (c) Compensatory afforestation charges should be payable for the entire forest area after deducting the forest area legally broken up during the validity of the mining lease;
    (d) For carrying out the mining operations between 1993 to 1997 in violation of the FC Act, an amount equal to the NPV payable in the present case should be imposed as a penalty on the user agency; and
    (e) The approval under the FC Act should be granted only after the environmental clearance for the project is accorded.”

    27. The MoEF may take an appropriate decision having regard to the recommendations made by CEC. The application as regards the applicant is disposed of accordingly.

    28. The applicant M/s K.N Ram and Co. in Keonjhar District of Orissa seeks temporary working permission (TWP) over already broken up forest area of 27.10 ha in Roida mining lease of 74.867 ha in its favour.

    29. The application as regards the applicant is disposed of in terms of the orders passed by this Court on 25-4-2008 (2011) 15 SCC 658 and 2-5-2008 (2011) 15 SCC 653.

    IAs Nos. 2329-30

    30. The application filed by M/s Bonai Industrial Co. Ltd. in Nadidihi iron and manganese mining lease area is also disposed of in terms of the orders passed by this Court on 25-4-2008 (2011) 15 SCC 658 and 2-5-2008 (2011) 15 SCC 653.

    31. IAs Nos. 2329-30 are disposed of accordingly.

    32. M/s Jaypee Power Grid Ltd., Sholtu within the jurisdiction of Kinnaur, Rampur, Tehog, Rajgarh and Nahan Forest Divisions in Kinnaur, Shimla and Sirmour Districts of Himachal Pradesh seeks permission for diversion of 322.6538 ha of forest land for 400 kV DC Karcham Wangtoo-Abdullapur transmission line in its favour.

    33. CEC had made certain observations after considering the project. The suggestions made by CEC are acceptable to the applicant. MoEF may take a decision after considering the observations made by CEC. The application as regards the applicant is disposed of accordingly.

    IAs Nos. 2344-45 and 2351

    34. The applicant M/s Adani Chemicals Ltd. in Kutch District of Gujarat has made this application for reconsideration of diversion of 1850 ha (approved area of 1840 ha) of forest land for high purity salt works in its favour for development of Mundra Special Economic Zone and also for reconsideration of diversion of one consolidated patch in Survey No. 169/36 admeasuring 168.41 ha of forest land for the salt washery desalination plant and container depot near Dhrub Village in Kutch District of Gujarat.

    35. CEC has examined the project and has submitted its report. Meanwhile, as regards the proposed land use, the State Government may furnish a fresh proposal to FAC within a reasonable time. FAC may take an appropriate decision at the earliest.

    36. The applications as regards the applicant are disposed of accordingly.

    IAs Nos. 208-09, 1692, 1989-90 and 2219-20 in WP (C) No. 202 of 1995

    37. The benefit of the order passed by this Court on 2-5-2008 (2011) 15 SCC 653 shall be applicable to these applicants also, subject to payment of penalty as in other cases. The applications are disposed of accordingly.

    IAs Nos. 1950-51 and 2105-07

    38. These applicants are also entitled to avail the benefit of the order passed by this Court on 2-5-2008 (2011) 15 SCC 653 and it is to be noticed that they have broken the seal put by the forest department. CEC has suggested an additional penalty of a sum of rupees one lakh on these applicants for this act.

    39. The applicants are allowed to operate subject to payment of penalty and additional amount of rupees one lakh to be deposited with the State Level Committee. The applications are disposed of accordingly.

    IA No. 2211, WP (C) No. 469 of 2005

    40. In this application, certain allegations have been made and indicated that M/s Balco is in possession of about 1897 ha of government land out of which about 1751 acres is recorded as jungle in the revenue records.

    41. Learned counsel appearing for the State of Chhattisgarh states that the lease was granted in favour of M/s Balco to an extent of 388 acres but this was disputed by learned counsel appearing for M/s Balco.

    42. We are told that M/s Balco has filed a writ petition bearing No. 5328 of 1996 before the High Court, Chhattisgarh for regularisation of the alleged lease/allotment in their favour by the Government. We are told that the writ petition is being adjourned from time to time.

    43. As this matter is pending before the High Court, we request the High Court to dispose of the writ petition pending before it and pass final orders at the earliest within a period of three months from today.

    44. Post this matter after the decision of the High Court.

    IAs Nos. 1424-25

    45. The applicant to file its response to the report filed by CEC within four weeks.

    46. List on 17-10-2008 for directions.

    IAs Nos. 2289-90

    47. CEC has filed its report after examining the project and has laid down certain conditions. The conditions are acceptable to the applicant. Subject to fulfilment of the conditions laid down by CEC, the project is approved.

    48. The applications are disposed of accordingly.

    IAs Nos. 170-75 in WP (C) No. 460 of 2004

    49. List on 17-10-2008.

    Rest of the matters on board today

    50. List on 7-11-2008.

    Court Masters

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    T.N Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union Of India And Others
    (Oct 3, 2008)