Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 482 of Cr. P.C read with sections 401 and 397 of Cr. P.C
  • PREVENTION OF DAMAGE TO PUBLIC PROPERTY ACT 1984
  • Indian Penal Code under section 11 and section 12
  • section 11 and section 12 of IPC. Section 12
  • sections 143/448/354/427/436, IPC
  • sections 147/448/353/427/436 IPC.
  • sections 147/448/353/427 of IPC
  • section 147/448/353/427 of IPC
  • section 227 of Cr. P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 482 of Cr. P.C read with sections 401 and 397 of Cr. P.C
  • PREVENTION OF DAMAGE TO PUBLIC PROPERTY ACT 1984
  • Indian Penal Code under section 11 and section 12
  • section 11 and section 12 of IPC. Section 12
  • sections 143/448/354/427/436, IPC
  • sections 147/448/353/427/436 IPC.
  • sections 147/448/353/427 of IPC
  • section 147/448/353/427 of IPC
  • section 227 of Cr. P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

An FIR was filed on 28.9.2010 by the Secretary of the Kachamari Gaon Panchayat alleging that certain persons created an unruly situation, ransacked articles of the Gaon Panchayat office, and set them on fire, protesting a defective beneficiary list under the Chief Minister's Anna Suraksha Achani. The Superintendent of Police, Nagaon, intervened to control the situation. Based on the FIR, a police case under sections 143/448/354/427/436 IPC was registered, and an investigation ensued. A charge sheet was filed on 28.11.2010 against the petitioners. Subsequently, the Additional Sessions Judge, Nagaon, framed charges on 3.5.2013 under sections 147/448/353/427/436 IPC against the petitioners. The petitioners challenged this charge framing under section 436 IPC via a revision petition under section 482 of Cr.P.C. read with sections 401 and 397 Cr.P.C.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the charge under section 436 IPC was rightly framed against the petitioners based on the materials on record?
  2. Whether the learned Sessions Judge erred in not exercising jurisdiction under section 227 Cr.P.C. to discharge the petitioners from the charge under section 436 IPC?
  3. Whether the destruction of government property alleged falls within the ambit of mischief under sections 425 and 436 IPC or is covered exclusively under the Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, 1984?
  4. Whether the committal order passed by the learned Magistrate is sustainable given that the offences under sections 147/448/353/427 IPC are not triable by Sessions Court?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The charge under section 436 IPC should not have been framed as the materials at best disclose offences under sections 147/448/353/427 IPC, but not under section 436 IPC.
  • The learned Sessions Judge failed to exercise jurisdiction under section 227 Cr.P.C. to discharge the petitioners from the section 436 IPC charge.
  • Destruction of government property is specifically addressed under the Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, 1984, which is a special statute, thus excluding the applicability of section 436 IPC under the principle of "General Special bus Nondergaf."
  • Translated witness statements were submitted to support the contention that the accused only damaged articles like doors and windows and did not intend to destroy the building itself.

State's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the State's legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. Prafulla Kr. Samal, (1979) 3 SCC 4 Establishing that the court has power to sift and weigh evidence at the charge framing stage to determine if a prima facie case exists. Supported the proposition that the court must find if grave suspicion exists before framing charges and cannot act as a mere post office for prosecution.
CBI v. K. Narayan Rao, (2012) 9 SCC 512 Reinforced the principle that the court must ascertain the existence of a prima facie case before framing charges. Used to affirm the requirement of grave suspicion for framing charges under section 436 IPC.
Sajjan Kr., (2010) 9 SCC 368 Held that if two views are possible, one amounting to mere suspicion and the other grave suspicion, the accused is entitled to discharge under section 227 Cr.P.C. Applied to conclude that the charge under section 436 IPC was not supported by sufficient materials to exclude mere suspicion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the essential ingredients of section 436 IPC, which requires mischief by fire or explosive substance intending or knowing it likely to cause destruction of a building ordinarily used as a place of worship, human dwelling, or custody of property. The court noted that 'mischief' under section 425 IPC requires wrongful loss or damage to 'person' or 'public' as defined in sections 11 and 12 IPC. The court reasoned that government buildings may not fall within these definitions, thus complicating the applicability of section 436 IPC to the present facts.

The court found that the accused damaged government property by breaking and burning articles like doors and windows but did not cause or intend to cause destruction of the building itself. The accused removed articles from inside the building before setting them on fire, indicating no intention to destroy the building structure. The court rejected the petitioners’ argument that the Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, 1984, excludes the application of IPC, noting the Act is in addition to, not in derogation of, IPC provisions.

Further, the court emphasized the duty under section 227 Cr.P.C. to evaluate materials on record to determine if a prima facie case exists. It held that the learned Sessions Judge failed to apply this mind in framing the charge under section 436 IPC, as the materials did not disclose the essential ingredients of that offence. The court applied legal precedents to affirm that where two views exist, and one is mere suspicion, the accused is entitled to discharge.

Consequently, the court set aside the charge under section 436 IPC, held that the accused are liable to be tried only under sections 147/448/353/427 IPC, and quashed the committal order as these offences are not triable by Sessions Court. The case was directed to be transferred to the Chief Judicial Magistrate for trial.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is allowed in part.

The court quashed the charge framed under section 436 IPC against the petitioners, holding that the materials did not disclose a prima facie case for that offence. The accused are to be tried only for offences under sections 147, 448, 353, and 427 IPC, which are not triable by Sessions Court. Accordingly, the committal order is quashed, and the trial is to proceed before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Nagaon. No new precedent was set; the decision applies the settled principle that charges must be framed only when a prima facie case of grave suspicion exists.

    Pankaj Borah And Ors. v. State Of Assam .

    1. This is an application under section 482 of Cr. P.C read with sections 401 and 397 of Cr. P.C praying for quashing of the charge framed under section 436, IPC against the present petitioners.

    2. There was an FIR filed by the Secretary of the Kachamari Gaon Panchayat on 28.9.2010, before the Office-in-Charge of Haibargaon Town Out-Post alleging that some persons created unruly situation and ransacked the articles of the office of the Gaon Panchayat and set it on fire claiming that list of beneficiaries prepared under the Chief Minister's Anna Suraksha Achani, was defective. The Superintendent of Police, Nagaon, himself had to go to the spot to bring the situation under control. Accordingly, necessary action by way of investigation in the matter was prayed for.

    3. On the basis of the said FIR vide Haibargaoh TOP GD Entry No. 1137 dated 28.9.2010, Nagaon PS case No. 1653/2010 under sections 143/448/354/427/436, IPC was registered and police started investigation. Subsequently, a charge sheet was submitted by the police vide Charge Sheet No. 706/10 on 28.11.2010 against the present petitioners. Thereafter, the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Nagaon, by an order dated 3.5.2013 drew up charges against the present petitioners under sections 147/448/353/427/436 IPC. The said order dated 3.5.2013 is under challenge in this revision petition.

    4. I have heard Mr. T.J Mahanta, learned counsel for the petitioners and Mr. B.B Gogoi, learned Public Prosecutor for the State.

    5. According to the petitioners, charge under section 436, IPC should not have been framed against them. In view of the materials available on record, the learned Sessions Judge committed error in not exercising jurisdiction under section 227 of Cr. P.C for discharging the petitioners from section 436, IPC. Learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that the materials available on record, may, at best make out a case under sections 147/448/353/427 of IPC but not under section 436 of IPC. To support his argument, learned counsel for the petitioners submitted translated copies of statements of witnesses recorded by the police under the provisions of section 161 of Cr. PC. According to the learned counsel for destroying government properties, there is specific provision in the Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, 1984.

    6. During investigation, as many as seven witnesses were recorded by the police. All of them deposed before the police that the present petitioners apart from creating unruly situation and destroying public properties, broke down the doors and windows and set them on fire by taking it outside the building. Later on, police came and seized the door panes, burned tables, almirahs and other articles from the place of occurrence. The names of the petitioners were disclosed by all those witnesses. The Common material emanating from the statements of the witnesses is that the accused persons came forming an unlawful assembly, created not like situation, trespassed into the office of the Gaon Panchayat and ultimately broke down the door panes, windows, etc., and set them on fire taking it outside the building.

    7. Now the question arises whether on the basis of the said materials, a charge under section 436, IPC can be drawn up against the present petitioners?

    8. For a ready reference, section 436, IPC is quoted herein below:

    “436. Mischief by fire or explosive substance with intent to destroy house, etc. — Whoever commits mischief by fire or any explosive substance, intending to cause, or knowing it to be likely that he will thereby cause, the destruction of any building which is ordinarily use as a place of worship or as a human dwelling or as a place for the custody of property, shall be punished with imprisonment for life or with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine.”

    It appears from a bare perusal of section 436, IPC that the essential ingredients of the said section are:

    (i) Commission of mischief,

    (ii) by fire or any explosive substances,

    (iii) intending to cause or knowing that it is likely to cause destruction of the building,

    (iv) which is ordinarily used as a place of worship or as a human dwelling or as a place for the custody of property.

    9. The first ingredient of section 436, IPC is ‘mischief’.

    ‘Mischief has been defined under section 425 of IPC and the same is also quoted herein below:

    “Mischief — Whoever with intent to cause, or knowing that he is likely to cause, wrongful loss or damage to the public or to any person, causes the destruction of any property, or any such change in any property or in the situation thereof as destroys or diminishes its value or utility, or affects it injuriously, commits “mischief”.

    Thus, to make out an offence of mischief, one has to cause or know that it is likely to cause wrongful loss or damage to ‘public’ or to any ‘person’,

    (emphasis supplied)

    Now both the words ‘person’ and ‘public’ have been defined in the Indian Penal Code under section 11 and section 12 respectively, which are quoted below.

    11. “Person”. — The word “person” includes any Company or Association or body of persons, whether incorporated or not.

    12. “Public” The word “public” includes any class of the public, or any community.

    10. The other important ingredient of section 436, IPC is to cause destruction of a building. This part of section 436, IPC, namely, causing or intending to cause destruction of building and that too, by fire or explosive substance, if read together with the word ‘mischief’ mentioned at the first part of section 436, it becomes necessary to read the said section along with sections 11 and 12 of the IPC. This shows that the building damaged or intended to be damaged should belong to a ‘person’ or public within the meaning of section 11 and section 12 of IPC. Section 12 is the only plural form of ‘person’ and thus to constitute an offence of mischief within the meaning of section 436 of IPC, building damaged or intended to be damaged must be one of ‘person’ or ‘public’. Obviously, government building may not come within the scope of sections 11 and 12 and so consequently not within the scope of section 436 of LPC. This being the position, it is difficult to hold that by burning the door panes of government office and that too, taking them out of the office premises, can be understood to be an attempt to destroy the building. Moreover, the building in question does not belong to either any person or public within the meaning of sections 11 and 12 of IPC.

    11. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that there is a special law for the purpose of dealing with an offence involving destruction of public properties. The said Act namely, Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, 1984 provides offence as well as punishment for causing destruction of the government building and/or private properties. Since there is a special statute covering this aspect, general law prescribed under the Indian Penal Code shall not be applicable in view of well established maxim, i.e, “General Special bus Nondergaf. But a perusal of the principle of the said Act shows that the section is in addition to but not in derogation of the other provisions of law. So, existence of the said Act may not ipso facto result in non-application of the IPC. So, this submission of the learned counsel is not acceptable.

    12. In the case in hand, the charge sheet and materials annexed thereto show that the accused persons damaged public properties including building of the Government. The court while framing charge under section 227, is duty bound to evaluate materials and documents on record to find out if the facts emerging from the materials taken at its face value, discloses essential ingredients of a particular section. It is settled law that court has power to sift and Weigh the evidence for limited purpose and to ascertain it as to whether a prima facie case for grave suspicion which is fully explained, is made out and in doing so, the court cannot act ‘merely as post office or mouth piece of the prosecution’. It is also settled law that even if two views are possible such that one of them is mere suspicion but not grave suspicion as to the guilt of the accused, the accused is entitled to be discharged under section 227 of Cr. PC. This would amount to an opinion that there is not sufficient ground for presuming that the accused has committed offence under the said section of law. Although these are established question of law, yet if any reference is necessary, support can be had from the cases of Union of India v. Prafulla Kr. Samal, (1979) 3 SCC 4 (para 10) and CBI v. K. Narayan Rao, (2012) 9 SCC 512. Even in the case of Sajjan Kr., (2010) 9 SCC 368 (para 21), the hon'ble Supreme Court held that if two views are possible that one of them is of mere suspicion and not of grave suspicion, the accused is entitled to the benefit of section 227 of Cr. PC.

    13. Applying the above propositions of law, it is clear that the impugned order of framing charge under section 436 of IPC against the accused petitioners was passed without considering this aspect of the matter. It cannot be denied that the scope of application of section 436, IPC is not beyond doubt under the facts of the case. Learned trial court has not applied his mind as to whether destruction of public premises in the manner and method suggested by materials available on record, can at all make out an offence under section 436, IPC. None of the witnesses have stated that the accused persons caused or intended to cause mischief so as to destroy the building by setting fire or by explosive substance. The building remained intact and the accused persons destroyed the door panes, other articles like tables, chairs, etc., by taking them outside of the building. Had the accused persons intended to damage the building by setting fire, there was no question of taking out of the articles from inside and they could have done the same by putting fire on the articles while they remained inside the premises.

    14. The materials available on record, makes out a case of damage of government property. Obviously, any property belong to any ‘person’ and/or ‘public’ have not been damaged and as such, it could not be said to be a ‘mischief’ within the meaning of section 425 of IPC. It is necessary to mention herein that section 425, IPC is a pre-condition for completion of an offence under section 436 of IPC. When an offence as defined under section 425, IPC is performed by setting fire and/or by explosive substance and that too, with respect to a building causing or intending to destroy the same, then and then only the question of committing an offence under section 436 of IPC arises.

    15. In view of the discussions made here-in-above, I am constrained to hold that the learned Addl. Sessions Judge, Nagaon, committed error in framing charge under section 436 of IPC against the present petitioners, as such the said charge is hereby set aside.

    16. Consequent to above, the accused persons shall be liable to be tried for the other offences, namely, offence under section 147/448/353/427 of IPC only. Incidentally, none of these sections are triable by Sessions and as such the committal order passed by the learned Magistrate is also liable to be quashed. Accordingly, the case will be transferred to the Court of learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Nagaon, for holding trial.

    17. With the above observations and directions the revision petition is allowed impart.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pankaj Borah And Ors. v. State Of Assam .
    (Sep 10, 2013)