Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sub-section (2) of S. 441
  • sub-section (3) of S. 437,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sub-section (2) of S. 441
  • sub-section (3) of S. 437,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns the question of whether a Magistrate has the authority to proceed against an accused for violation of bail conditions imposed by the High Court or Sessions Court, or whether the Magistrate must refer the matter to the High Court for cancellation of bail. The third accused was granted bail by the High Court with conditions to report to the Investigating Officer every alternate day and to not leave the police station limits without prior permission. The first and second accused were granted bail by the Sessions Court with conditions to report twice weekly. All three executed bonds before the Magistrate and were released on bail.

The Investigating Officer filed a report before the Magistrate stating that all three accused violated the reporting conditions. The Magistrate sent a report to the High Court seeking cancellation of bail, believing only the High Court could cancel bail granted by it. The High Court issued notice to the third accused and heard submissions on whether the Magistrate can act independently or must refer bail cancellation to the High Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a Magistrate can proceed against an accused for violation of bail conditions imposed by the High Court or Sessions Court without referring the matter for cancellation of bail to the High Court or Sessions Court.
  2. The distinction between cancellation of bail bond under Section 446A of the Code of Criminal Procedure and cancellation of bail under Sections 437(5) or 439(2) of the Code.
  3. The procedural and substantive requirements for cancellation of bail bond and cancellation of bail.

Arguments of the Parties

Learned Public Prosecutor's Arguments

  • If the accused violates any condition of bail granted by the High Court or Sessions Court under Section 439 of the Code, only the High Court or Sessions Court can cancel bail.
  • The Magistrate has no power to cancel bail granted by the High Court or Sessions Court.
  • Relied on the Supreme Court decision in Gurcharan Singh v. State (Delhi Admn.) (1978) 1 SCC 118 to support the proposition that cancellation of bail granted by the High Court can only be done by the High Court.

Learned Counsel for Third Accused's Arguments

  • The third accused was unable to report to the Investigating Officer due to illness (viral hepatitis).
  • There was no wilful default or breach of bail conditions.
  • Bail should not be cancelled on this ground.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gurcharan Singh v. State (Delhi Admn.), (1978) 1 SCC 118, AIR 1978 SC 179 Only the High Court can cancel bail granted by it; a Court of Session cannot cancel bail granted by the High Court unless new circumstances arise. Supported the proposition that bail granted by the High Court or Sessions Court can only be cancelled by those courts and not by Magistrates.
Narendra K. Amin (Dr.) v. State of Gujarat, (2008) 13 SCC 584 Application for cancellation of bail must be filed before the Court granting bail if it is a Court of Session or the High Court. Reinforced the procedural requirement that cancellation applications lie before the granting Court.
Rajan v. State Of Kerala, 2006 (4) KLT 429 Forfeiture of bond occurs only if there is wilful default by the accused; absence due to reasons beyond control does not amount to forfeiture. Clarified that non-wilful breaches do not lead to automatic forfeiture and cancellation of bail bond.
State of Kerala v. Anil Kumar, 2005 (4) KLT SN 59 Innocent violation of bail conditions does not ipso facto lead to cancellation of bail; cancellation requires deliberate, contumacious, and unjustified breach. Supported the principle that cancellation of bail requires cogent reasons and wilful breach of conditions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the relevant provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure, namely Sections 437, 439, 441, and 446A. It noted that while the High Court or Sessions Court "direct" release of an accused on bail under Section 439, the Magistrate actually "releases" the accused after the accused executes a bail bond under Section 441. The bail bond incorporates all conditions imposed by the granting Court.

Section 446A provides for automatic cancellation of the bail bond upon forfeiture resulting from breach of any condition. This cancellation occurs regardless of whether the bail was granted by the Magistrate, Sessions Court, or High Court. The Magistrate is empowered to proceed against the accused for breach of bail bond conditions, including issuing non-bailable warrants and committing the accused to custody, without needing to seek cancellation of bail from the High Court or Sessions Court.

The Court distinguished between "cancellation of bail bond" under Section 446A and "cancellation of bail" under Sections 437(5) or 439(2). The latter is a discretionary order requiring cogent reasons and is often referred to as "cancellation of bail" in judicial practice, but the Code does not expressly use this term. The Magistrate's power to act arises from the automatic cancellation of the bond and the consequent forfeiture, not from cancellation of bail per se.

The Court emphasized that a mere violation of bail conditions does not automatically result in cancellation of the bond unless the breach is wilful and leads to forfeiture. The Court cited precedents clarifying that innocent or unavoidable breaches do not lead to forfeiture or cancellation.

Applying this legal framework to the facts, the Court found that the Magistrate was correct in receiving a report about violations but erred in sending the matter to the High Court for cancellation of bail. Instead, the Magistrate should have independently examined whether the bail bond stood forfeited and proceeded accordingly under Section 446A.

Holding and Implications

The Court held that a Magistrate has the authority to proceed against an accused for violation of bail conditions imposed by the High Court or Sessions Court without referring the matter to those superior courts for cancellation of bail.

The Court clarified that cancellation of a bail bond under Section 446A of the Code occurs automatically upon forfeiture due to breach of conditions, and the Magistrate can act on this basis to issue warrants and take custody of the accused. It is not necessary for the Magistrate to seek cancellation of bail from the High Court or Sessions Court in such cases.

The Court also explained the distinction between cancellation of bail bond and cancellation of bail, emphasizing that the former is automatic on forfeiture while the latter requires express orders with cogent reasons.

In the present case, since there was no application for cancellation of bail before the High Court, the Magistrate was not powerless and should have proceeded in accordance with law under Section 446A. The opinion disposes of the matter on these grounds.

No new precedent was set beyond clarifying the Magistrate's powers in relation to bail bond forfeiture and cancellation.

    Mahesh v. State Of Kerala

    K. Hema, J.:— If an accused violates any condition imposed by the High Court or the Sessions Court in the order granting bail, can the Magistrate himself proceed against him for such violation, under the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure (‘the Code’, for short). Is it necessary for the Magistrate to address this Court to cancel bail?

    2. This Court granted bail to the third accused, as per order dated 04/08/2008 in BA 4368/2008, on condition that he shall report before the Investigating Officer, on every alternate day, between 10 a.m and 1 p.m, until further orders. Another condition was that he shall not leave the limits of the Police Station within which the crime is registered, except with the previous permission of the learned Magistrate. Bail was granted to 1st and 2nd accused by the Sessions Court as per order in Crl. MP 3251/07 dated 14/08/2007 on condition that they shall report before the Investigating Officer on every Monday and Thursday between 10 a.m and 11 a.m, until the final report is filed. AH the three accused executed the bond before the Magistrate Court and were released on bail.

    3. The Deputy Superintendent of Police, who is the present Investigating Officer filed a report before the Magistrate Court stating that all the three accused failed to report before Investigating Officer and violated the conditions imposed by the High Court and Sessions Court. The 1st and 2nd accused did not report before the Investigating Officer, after 04/09/2008 and 22/09/2008 respectively and 3rd accused, since 15/09/2008. Therefore, he requested the Magistrate Court to take necessary action in the matter. Learned Magistrate therefore sent a report to this Court to cancel bail, since according to him, bail granted by the High Court can be cancelled only by the High Court.

    4. Notice was issued to third accused by this Court, calling upon him to show cause why bail shall not be cancelled. He entered appearance through counsel and filed an affidavit stating that he was laid up etc. Heard both sides. Learned Public Prosecutor argued that as per the settled position of law, if the accused violates any condition imposed by the High Court or the Sessions Court while granting bail under S. 439 of the Code, bail can be cancelled only by the High Court or Sessions Court. The Magistrate has no power to cancel the bail and hence, bail granted to 3rd accused may be cancelled, it is submitted.

    5. Learned Public Prosecutor also relied upon a decision of the Supreme Court reported in Gurcharan Singh v. State (Delhi Admn.), (1978) 1 SCC 118 : AIR 1978 SC 179 in support of his arguments. The relevant portion of the above decision is extracted hereunder:

    “Under S. 439(2) of the new Code a High Court may commit a person released on bail under Chapter XXXM by any Court including the Court of Session to custody, if it thinks appropriate to do so. It must, however, be made clear that a Court of Session cannot cancel a bail which has already been granted by the High Court unless new circumstances arise during the progress of the trial after an accused person has been admitted to bail by the High Court”.

    6. In Narendra K. Amin (Dr.) v. State of Gujarat, (2008) 13 SCC 584 it was held that

    “under the scheme of the Code, the application for cancellation of bail can be filed before the Court granting the bail if it is a Court of Session or the High Court.”

    7. Learned counsel for 3rd accused contended that the 3rd accused was unable to report before the Investigating Officer, since he was laid up due to viral hepatitis. The 3rd accused filed an affidavit before this Court and also produced a medical certificate and contended that there was no wilful default or breach of any condition imposed, while granting bail and hence, bail may not be cancelled.

    8. On hearing both sides and on going through report of learned Magistrate and report of the Investigating Officer (which was filed before Magistrate Court), I find that the only request made by Investigating Officer is to take “necessary action” in the matter, since accused violated conditions imposed by the High Court and the Sessions Court in the bail order. To find out what the Magistrate can do in such a situation, firstly, a reading of S. 437 and S. 439 of the Code is essential. The relevant portion from the above provisions read as follows:

    “437. When bail may be taken in case of non-bailable offence.— (1) When any person accused of, or suspected of, the commission of any non-bailable offence is arrested or detained without warrant by an officer in charge of a Police Station or appears or is brought before a Court other than the High Court or Court of Session, he may be released on bail, but—

    (i) such person shall not be so released if there appear reasonable grounds for believing that he has been guilty of an offence punishable with death or imprisonment for life;

    (ii) xxx”

    9. S. 439 of the Code reads as follows:

    “439. Special powers of High Court or Court of Session regarding bail.— (1) A High Court or Court of Session may direct—

    (a) that any person accused of an offence and in custody be released on bail, and if the offence is of the nature specified in sub-section (3) of S. 437, may impose any condition which it considers necessary for the purposes mentioned in that sub-section;

    (b) that any condition imposed by a Magistrate when releasing any person on bail be set aside or modified:

    Provided that the High Court or the Court of Session shall, before granting bail to a person who is accused of an offence which is triable exclusively by the Court of Session or which, though not so triable, is punishable with imprisonment for life, give notice of the application for bail to the Public Prosecutor unless it is, for reasons to be recorded in writing, of opinion that it is not practicable to give such notice.

    (2) A High Court of Court of Session may direct that any person who has been released on bail under this Chapter be arrested and commit him to custody.”

    10. On a comparison of the provisions contained in S. 437 and S. 439 of the Code, I note that there is some difference in the nature of the powers exercisable by the Magistrate Court and High Court and the Sessions Court, while granting bail to an accused. Under S. 437 of the Code, the Magistrate may by himself release the accused on bail, but, as per S. 439, the High Court or the Sessions Court can only “direct” that the accused be released on bail. The expression used in S. 437 is “may be released on bail whereas, in S. 439 of the Code what is stated is, “direct that any person accused of an offence and in custody be released on bail.”

    11. Thus, it is clear that if the High Court or Sessions Court grants bail to an accused under S. 439 of the Code, it is the Magistrate who actually “releases” him on bail. The High Court or the Sessions Court only “directs” that the accused be released on bail, but the Magistrate “releases” him on bail, under direction from the Superior Courts. However, before he is released on bail under direction from the Superior Courts, the accused is bound to comply with an inevitable legal formality which is contained in S. 441 of the Code, S. 441 of the Code reads as follows:

    “S. 441. Bond of accused and sureties.— (1) Before any person is released on bail or released on his own bond, a bond for such sum of money as the Police Officer or Court, as the case may be, thinks sufficient shall be executed by such person, and, when he is released on bail, by one or more sufficient sureties conditioned that such person shall attend at the time and place mentioned in the bond, and shall continue so to attend until otherwise directed by the Police Officer or Court, as the case may be.

    (2) Where any condition is imposed for the release of any person on bail, the bond shall also contain that condition.

    (3) If the case so requires, the bond shall also bind the person released on bail to appear when called upon at the High Court, Court of Session or other Court to answer the charge.

    (4) For the purpose of determining whether the sureties are fit or sufficient, the Court may accept affidavits in proof of the facts contained therein relating to the sufficiency or fitness of the sureties, or, if it considers necessary, may either hold used an inquiry itself or cause an inquiry to be made by a Magistrate subordinate to the Court, as to such sufficiency or fitness.”

    12. As per S. 441(1) of the Code, before any person is released on bail, he shall execute a abond that such person shall attend at the time and place mentioned in the bond and continue to attend, until otherwise directed by the Court. Sub-section (2) of S. 441 provides that where any condition is imposed for the release of any person on bail, the bond shall also contain that condition. S. 441 does not make any difference between the bond to be executed on the order of the Magistrate or the superior Courts. Whether it be on the basis of an order passed by the Magistrate Court under S. 437 or by the Sessions Court or High Court under S. 439 of the Code, the nature of bail bond to be executed is the same under S. 441 and it must be in accordance with the terms and conditions imposed in the bail order by respective Court.

    13. Once the bail bond is executed by the accused and he is released on bail, if he violates any condition of the bail bond, the consequences under S. 446A of the Code shall follow. S. 446A reads as follows:

    “S. 446A. Cancellation of bond and bail bond. Without prejudice to the provisions of S. 446, where a bond under this Code is for appearance of a person in a case and it is forfeited for breach of a condition—

    (a) the bond executed by such person as well as the bond, if any, executed by one or more of his sureties in that case shall stand cancelled; and

    (b) thereafter no such person shall be released only on his own bond in that case, if the Police Officer or the Court, as the case may be, for appearance before whom the bond was executed, is satisfied that there was no sufficient cause for the failure of the person bound by the bond to comply with its condition: Provided that subject to any other provision of this Code he may be released in that case upon the execution of a fresh personal bond for such sum of money and bond by one or more of such sureties as the Police Officer or the Court, as the case may be, thinks sufficient.”

    14. S. 446A deals with cancellation of bail bond. A joint reading of S. 439, S. 441, and 446A of the Code, shows that when a person is granted bail by the High Court or Sessions Court, he shall be released on bail only after execution of a bail bond, as provided under S. 441 of the Code. If any condition is imposed by the High Court or the Sessions Court, such condition, shall also be incorporated in the bail bond. If any of such condition is violated by the accused and thereby, such bond is forfeited by any person or persons, who executed the bail bond, the bond shall stand cancelled, by virtue of S. 446A of the Code.

    15. The cancellation of bail bond under S. 446A of the Code is an automatic eventuality and it occurs, on account of breach of condition in the bail order and consequent forfeiture of the bail bond. S. 446A of the Code does not make any difference in the case of bail bond executed on the strength of bail order passed by the Magistrate Court or by the High Court or Sessions Court. It applies equally to the bail bond executed either on the basis of an order passed under S. 437 or under S. 439 of the Code and the consequence under S. 446A is the same to such bond.

    16. If bail bond stands cancelled under S. 446A of the Code, as a consequence of violation of condition in the bail order, the Magistrate is bound to proceed against the accused to procure his presence in Court and also for forfeiture of bond. For this purpose, non-bailable warrant may be issued against him. If the accused is arrested and produced in Court, the Magistrate may also commit him to custody, subject to the provision in S. 446A(b) of the Code. Therefore, it follows that, if any condition in the bail order issued by the Superior Court is violated, the Magistrate himself can independently proceed against the accused for procuring his presence or to proceed against him for forfeiture of bond. It may not be necessary for him to address the High Court or Sessions Court to cancel bail. S. 446A is not controlled by S. 437(5) or 439(2) of the Code.

    17. S. 446A of the Code deals with “cancellation of bail bond”, whereas, S. 437(5) or 439(2) is invoked for “cancellation of bail”. There is a difference between “cancellation of bail bond”, and “cancellation of bail.” “Cancellation of bail bond” takes place automatically under S. 446A of the Code whereas, “cancellation of bail” is often ordered under S. 437(5) or 439(2) of the Code, under exceptional circumstances. In fact there is no provision in the Code which, in express terms, deals with powers of the Court to “cancel bail”. Neither in S. 437(5) nor in 439(2) of the Code, the expression “cancellation of bail” is seen used.

    18. Going by the language of the Code, what is contemplated under S. 437(5) and S. 439(2) of the Code, is only issuance of a direction to arrest and commit the accused to custody. But, such power is often referred to by the Bench and the Bar as “cancellation of bail” and the said expression “cancellation of bail” is crystallised by its usage, in various judicial pronouncements. However, before issuing a direction to arrest and commit to custody under S. 437(5) or 439(2) of the Code, it is necessary for the Court concerned to cancel the bail and this may be the reason why reference is made in the precedents, as “cancellation of bail”.

    19. To cancel the bail under S. 437(5) or 439(2) of the Code very cogent and overwhelming reasons are also to be stated. The Court shall not cancel bail in a routine manner, under S. 437(5) or 439(2) of the Code, as per law. This is the settled position of law. But, the position under S. 446A of the Code is totally different. If the Magistrate Court is satisfied that there is breach of condition of bail bond and thereby, forfeiture of the bond, the bond automatically stands cancelled under S. 446A of the Code.

    20. However, a mere violation of condition in the bail order will not lead to automatic cancellation of bail bond under S. 446A of the Code. Apart from violation of condition in the bail order, the Court must also be satisfied that the bond is forfeited then alone, bail bond would stand cancelled and the accused can be proceeded against. It is the forfeiture of the bail bond which is crucial under S. 446A of the Code. If the breach of condition is not wilful and is due to reasons beyond his control, it cannot be said that there is forfeiture of bond; The question is dealt with in Rajan v. State Of Kerala, 2006 (4) KLT 429 and it is held thus:

    “A bond for appearance can be said to be forfeited, only if there is a wilful default on the part of the accused in not appearing before the Court. It is needless to say that an accused can be absent in Court due to various reasons on a particular occasion. When the counsel flies an application, it follows that the accused was vigilant and he had taken steps to instruct his counsel to file an application. Such an accused cannot be said to have forfeited the bond by reason of any wilful default. It is only in Cases where there is wilful default on the part of the accused to appear in Court, forfeiture of bond will follow and penalty will incur.”

    21. In State of Kerala v. Anil Kumar, 2005 (4) KLT SN 59, referring to cancellation of bail, this Court held thus: “an innocent violation of any condition imposed by the Court will not ipso facto lead to cancellation of bail under S. 439(2) Cr.PC The crucial and vital question is whether there has been deliberate, contumacious and unjustified infraction of the conditions imposed by the Court”. It is needless to say that if the Court cannot cancel bail, if violation of condition is not wilful or deliberate, it is only reasonable to hold that such violation (which is not wilful or intentional) shall also not lead to an automatic cancellation of bail bond under S. 446A of the Code.

    22. It must also be borne in mind that whether bail bond stands cancelled under S. 446A or bail is cancelled under S. 437(5) or 439(2), the consequences which the accused may face are more or less the same. He may be arrested and committed to jail. Therefore, the Courts shall be extremely cautious and careful while proceeding against an accused on the ground that bail bond stands cancelled.

    23. To sum up, I hold that if the Magistrate comes across with instances of violation of condition of bail or if a report is filed by the Investigating Officer before the Magistrate Court, pointing out violation of condition of bail granted by the Superior Courts without there being any request for “cancellation of bail”, nothing prevents the Magistrate from proceeding against the accused, under appropriate provisions of law, as indicated above. Nothing in the Code prohibits the Magistrate from proceeding against the accused, if the bail bond executed on the strength of the order issued by the High Court or Sessions Court stands cancelled under S. 446A of the Code. It is not even necessary for the Magistrate to address the High Court or the Sessions Court to cancel bail. However, if mere is an application for cancellation of bail granted by the High Court or Sessions Court, the position will be different and the Magistrate Court will have to proceed, as per the settled legal position.

    24. Now coming to the facts, I find that the High Court passed a bail order in favour of 3rd accused and he executed bail bond under S. 441 of the Code before Magistrate Court, Thereafter, he was released on bail by the Magistrate Court. If there is any violation of condition in the bail order, there may be breach of bail bond and forfeiture of bond.

    25. Therefore, instead of sending a report to this Court, learned Magistrate ought to have considered whether there is automatic cancellation of bail bond under S. 446A of the Code and proceeded in accordance with law, especially since there is no request from the Investigating Officer to cancel the bail.

    26. Since there is no application for cancellation of bail, it is unnecessary for this Court to proceed under S. 439(2) of the Code. The Investigating Officer has only sought for “necessary action” to be taken by the Magistrate Court. Learned Magistrate is not powerless to proceed against the accused who breaches a condition of bail imposed by the Superior Courts and there is automatic cancellation of bond under S. 446A of the Code.

    27. In the above circumstances, learned Magistrate shall proceed in accordance with law, as indicated in this order.

    28. The matter is disposed of accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mahesh v. State Of Kerala
    (Aug 3, 2009)