AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was appointed as Reader in the Department of Psychology at Aligarh Muslim University in January 1983. Following complaints regarding admission to the Ph.D. course in Psychology, a charge-sheet was served on the petitioner in September 1986. An enquiry was conducted, and the Executive Council of the University dismissed the petitioner from service by an order dated 20-5-89. The petitioner filed an appeal to the Visitor of the University, who forwarded it back to the Executive Council for decision. The Executive Council dismissed the appeal on 2-11-92. The petitioner challenged these orders before the Court, seeking quashing of the dismissal and related orders, and a direction to treat him as in continuous service with consequential benefits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Executive Council, having dismissed the petitioner from service, was competent to hear and decide the petitioner's appeal against its own order.
  2. Whether the principle of natural justice and rule against bias was violated by allowing the Executive Council to decide the appeal.
  3. The scope of the Visitor's supervisory and appellate jurisdiction under sub-section 6 of Section 13 of the Aligarh Muslim University Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Executive Council acted as both the punishing authority and appellate authority, which is contrary to natural justice.
  • The appeal was effectively from "Caesar to Caesar," creating an inherent bias and unfairness.
  • The Executive Council was not competent to decide the appeal as it had already expressed its opinion by dismissing the petitioner initially.
  • The Visitor, having supervisory and appellate powers under the statute, should have decided the appeal to ensure fairness.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The statutes empower the Visitor to refer appeals to the Executive Council for disposal.
  • By statute, the Executive Council was authorized to hear the appeal, and there was no statutory bar on this arrangement.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ashok Kumar Yadav v. State of Haryana Principle that no person can be a judge in their own cause; reasonable likelihood of bias disqualifies decision maker. The Court applied this principle to hold that the Executive Council was disqualified from hearing the appeal due to its prior involvement and pre-judgment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the facts and statutory provisions, focusing on the principle of natural justice and the prohibition against bias. It found that the Executive Council, which had dismissed the petitioner from service, was the same authority that heard and rejected the appeal, creating a conflict of interest and a reasonable apprehension of bias. The Court emphasized that it is not necessary to prove actual bias; the likelihood or appearance of bias suffices to vitiate a decision. The Court also referred to sub-section 6 of Section 13 of the Aligarh Muslim University Act, which vests the Visitor with supervisory and appellate authority, indicating that the Visitor was the appropriate forum for deciding the appeal. The Court rejected the respondents’ argument that the Executive Council was competent under the statute to hear the appeal, noting that the Visitor could have decided the appeal and that necessity did not justify the Executive Council’s involvement. The Court concluded that the Executive Council was disqualified from deciding the appeal due to its prior involvement and pre-judgment of the matter.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition was allowed. The Court set aside the Executive Council’s order dated 2-11-92 dismissing the petitioner’s appeal. The Court directed the Respondent No. 1 to send the appeal record to the Visitor for decision on merits within one month of service of a certified copy of the order. The Court refrained from making any order as to costs.

The direct effect of this decision is that the Executive Council’s appellate decision was declared invalid and the appeal must be decided afresh by the Visitor. No new precedent was established beyond the application of established principles of natural justice and statutory interpretation of the University Act.

    Dr. Bishambhar Dayal Gupta v. Aligarh Muslim University Through Vice-Chancellor And Others

    V.N Khare and N.B Asthana, JJ.:— We have heard learned counsel for the petitioner and Shri Dilip Gupta, who appeared for the respondents. Learned counsel have agreed that this petition may be decided at the admission stage without calling for counter affidavit and rejoinder affidavit. We, accordingly, proceed in the matter to decide the same finally at the admission stage.

    2. The facts in so far as they are relevant for the purposes of deciding this writ petition are not in dispute.

    3. The petitioner was appointed as Reader in the Department of Psychology in Aligarh Muslim University (for short the University) in January, 1983. In connection with some complaints made by Miss Sunita Tandon and Miss Sunil Chauhan regarding their admission to Ph.D course in Psychology a charge-sheet dated 17/18th September, 1986 was served upon the petitioner. He filed reply. Shri M.K Vasudevan was appointed Enquiry Officer vide order dated 5-5-87 passed by the Vice Chancellor of the University. The Enquiry Officer submitted his report upon which the Executive Council issued a show cause notice dated 5-4-89 to the petitioner. The Executive Council vide its resolution dated 16/17-5-89 communicated to the petitioner by the Registrar of the University on 20-5-89 dismissed the petitioner from service. The petitioner filed an appeal on 9-8-89 to the visitor of the University. The appellate authority without deciding the appeal itself sent it to the Executive Council of the University with the direction to decide that appeal. The Executive Council vide resolution dated 2-11-92 dismissed the petitioner's appeal. Aggrieved by this order the petitioner has come to this Court with the prayer that orders dated 20-5-89 (Annexure-10 to the writ petition), order dated 6-3-92 (Annexure-13 to the writ petition) and the order dated 2-11-92 (Annexure-14 to the writ petition) be quashed and the respondents be directed by a writ of mandamus to treat the petitioner in continuous service with all consequential benefits.

    4. It was urged that the decision forum of appeal and the authority who had passed the order of dismissal are the same. The appeal is from Caeser to Caeser, which is against all canons of natural justice and fair play. The Executive Council had earlier dismissed the petitioner from service and its decision to reject the appeal was in law biased. The Executive Council was not competent to decide the appeal against its own order. The argument has substance. Admittedly, the petitioner was dismissed from service w.e.f 15-7-86 by the Executive Council. The Executive Council is the punishing authority in the present case. Under sub-section 6 of Section 13 of Aligarh Muslim University Act” the Visitor may by order in writing annul any proceeding of the University which is not in conformity with this Act, the Statutes or the Ordinances”. Thus the Visitor has supervisory as well as the appellate authority under the Act and the correctness of the decision of Executive Council can only be tested by the Visitor of the University. In the present case the Executive Council had dismissed the petitioner's appeal. It is a fundamental rule that a person cannot be judge in a cause where he is interested. In the instant case the Executive Council of the University must be interested that the order passed by it dismissing the petitioner from service is maintained. The Executive Council had expressed its mind, while dismissing the petitioner from service. In the circumstances, it was not expected that the petitioner would get a fair deal from the Executive Council, which had dismissed him earlier.

    5. The Executive Council while disposing of appeal was likely to be biased because the appeal was filed against its own order. It is immaterial whether the Executive Council was, in fact, biased or not while disposing of the appeal. The Executive Council had already pre-judged the merits of the case while dismissing the petitioner from service and as such it was disqualified from hearing and deciding the appeal. It had pre-conceived opinion on the merits of the case. The decision of appeal by the Executive Council was vitiated on account of its prior involvement in the decision of the enquiry, which resulted in the dismissal of the petitioner. It is one of the fundamental principles of our jurisprudence that no man can be a judge in his own cause and if there is a reasonable likelihood of bias, it is in accordance with natural justice and common sense that the justice likely to be so biased should be incapacitated from sitting. The question is not whether the judge is actually biased or in fact decides partially but whether there is any real likelihood of bias What is objectionable in such a case is not that the decision is actually tainted with bias but the circumstances are such as to create a reasonable apprehension in the mind of others that there is likelihood of bias affecting the decision. The basic principle underlining this rule is that justice must not only be done but also must appear to be done. It is also important to note that this rule is not confined to the cases where judicial power stricto sensu is exercised. It is appropriately extended to all cases where an independent mind has to be applied to arrive at a fair and just decision. The standard applied by the authorities exercising the judicial powers are being increasingly applied to administrative bodies, so that the instrumentality of the State should discharge their functions in a fair and just manner. (Ashok Kumar Yadav v. State of Haryana.1

    6. It is a common experience that once a decision has been taken, there is a tendency to uphold it and an appeal decided by the same authority may not really serve any fruitful purpose. The authority who embarks upon the post decisional hearing would naturally proceed with a closed mind and there is hardly any chance of getting a proper consideration of the appeal at such a post decisional opportunity. This is an instance of an appeal from one's own order to oneself. The executive Council had already prejudged the facts while dismissing the petitioner on the basis of the enquiry report. It was disqualified from hearing the appeal against its own order.

    7. It was, however, urged on behalf of the respondents that statutes of the university empower the Visitor to refer the appeal to the Executive Council of the university for disposal. This has no doubt been provided in the statute but in the instant case this would not help the respondents at all. Had there been no other authority capable of hearing the appeal then it could have been argued that by way of necessity there is no option for the Executive Council but to hear the appeal. This is not the case here. The Visitor of the university could have very well decided the appeal.

    8. For the reasons given above, we are satisfied that the Executive Council was not competent to hear and decide the appeal of the petitioner.

    9. In view of the above the writ petition is allowed. We set aside the order dated 2-11-92 passed by the Executive Council dismissing the petitioner's appeal. Respondent No. 1 is directed to send the record/memo appeal if possible, within a period of one month from the date a certified copy of this order is served upon the Registrar of the University to the Visitor for decision of appeal on merits.

    10. In the circumstances, we refrain from making any order as to costs.

    11. Writ petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dr. Bishambhar Dayal Gupta v. Aligarh Muslim University Through Vice-Chancellor And Others
    (Feb 26, 1993)