AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 27 of the Workmen's Compensation Act (VIII of 1923)
  • S. 8 of the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  • Workmen's Compensation Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 27 of the Workmen's Compensation Act (VIII of 1923)
  • S. 8 of the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  • Workmen's Compensation Act

    Ikkassintakath Abdurahiman And Another Petitioners v. Nadakkavu Malikkal Beeran Koya

    (Delivered by Venkataramana Rao, J.)

    This is a reference under S. 27 of the Workmen's Compensation Act (VIII of 1923) made by the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation in the following circumstances. A workman by name Saban employed under the respondent died in or about July 1934. A claim for compensation was preferred by his mother Pathumma under the Act. A question was raised whether the employer was liable to pay compensation to her. The matter was carried to the High Court and by an order dated 1st September 1936, it was decided by Burn J. and Lakshmana Rao J. that the employer was liable to pay compensation to the said Pathumma. Thereupon the Commissioner by his order dated the 26th September 1936 decided that the only dependant of the deceased workman was the applicant Pathumma and he therefore alloted the entire compensation to her. The entire compensation referred to was a lump sum of Rs. 552 paid by the employer in pursuance of S. 8 of the Workmen's Compensation Act. The Act obliges every employer who is liable to pay compensation to deposit the amount which he is liable to pay under the Act with the Commissioner, in order that he may get full satisfaction of the claim. On such deposit being made, the Commissioner has to find out who the dependants are so that he may effect a distribution among them. Under Cl. 7 of S. 8, if the dependant happens to be a woman or a person under a legal disability, the Commissioner is enjoined to invest the compensation money for the benefit of the woman or of such person during his disability. It is therefore clear that once an allotment of compensation to a dependant or a distribution of compensation money among several dependants is made, the compensation so allotted or distributed becomes the property of the dependant and if the dependant dies, the said sum being his property will devolve on his or her heirs. The Commissioner in pursuance of Cl. 7 of S. 8 of the Act directed an immediate payment of Rs. 50 out of the said sum of Rs. 552 to Pathumma and ordered that the balance be invested on her behalf in the Post Office Savings Bank and paid to her at the rate of Rs. 21 a quarter in advance beginning from October 1936. Before she could receive any sum, the said Pathuma died and an application was put in by her sons who are admittedly her legal heirs claiming the said amount. This claim was resisted by the employer (the 1st respondent) who contended that as Pathumma died the compensation money was liable to be refunded to him. The Commissioner was inclined to the view that by operation of Cl. 4 of S. 8 and S. 9, the amount is liable to be refunded to the employer, but, however, as he was not quite sure about that view, he has made this reference under S. 27 of the Act.

    It seems to us that the view of the Commissioner is not sound. Under Cl. 4 of S. 8, the right of the employer to get a refund only arises when a workman dies without any dependant and the Commissioner at the time of the distribution knows that he has left no dependant within the meaning of the Act. But if the workman leaves a dependant and the claim of that dependant is recognised by the Commissioner as the person entitled to receive the compensation, any claim on the part of the employer for a refund can no longer arise under that clause. S. 9 also has no bearing on the facts of this particular case. The first part of that section provides that no lump sum or half monthly payment payable under the Act is capable of being alienated or subjected to attachment. This is for the purpose of securing the benefit which the Workmen's Compensation Act is intended to provide for the workman or the dependants of the workman. This part of the section has therefore no application to the present case. The other part of the section in S. 9 is that no lump sum or half yearly payment shall pass to any person other than the workman. This contemplates that the compensation is payable to a workman and cannot be claimed by any person by operation of law. Therefore, before that clause can come into operation, there must be an existing workman to whom it is payable and it has no application to a case where the workman died before the award of compensation. In the case of a workman who is alive and to whom the compensation is payable, the Act says that it must be paid to him and it should not go to any other person; for example, if he becomes an insolvent, his trustee in bankruptcy cannot claim the sum for the benefit of his creditors. This section therefore has no application to this case where the money has been allotted to Pathumma, the mother of the workman, who is a dependant under the Act. It has become her property; it has been recognised to be her property by the said compensation money being invested in the Post Office Savings Bank by the order dated 26th September 1936.

    We are therefore of the opinion that the sons of Pathumma are entitled to be paid the amount due and payable under the order dated 26th September 1936 and we answer the reference accordingly. We see no reason to make any order as to costs.

    Reference answered accordingly.

    N.R.R

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ikkassintakath Abdurahiman And Another Petitioners v. Nadakkavu Malikkal Beeran Koya
    (Dec 10, 1937)