Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Das, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This application challenges an order of the learned Sessions Judge of Shahabad dated 22nd September, 1921, which directed the petitioners to be committed to the Court of Sessions by the discharging Magistrate (or his successor).

The underlying occurrence took place on the afternoon of 14th April (year not specified in the opinion). In that occurrence, Sumiran and Balgobind received comparatively slight injuries, while Sheodahin (brother of Sumiran and Balgobind) suffered injuries which the medical evidence showed were contusions on both sides of his head and which caused his death on the afternoon of 15th April.

Sumiran is said to have lodged an information before the Writer Head Constable at about 7 P.M. on the evening of the occurrence; according to the record of that visit (the "Sanha"), the Writer Head Constable refused to take action because the offence described was non-cognizable. The Sanha did not allege serious injuries to Sheodahin nor that the complainant and his brothers were taking cattle to the pound.

At trial before a Magistrate of Sassaram, by an order dated 26th June, 1924, the learned Magistrate discharged the petitioners under Section 253 of the Code (presumably the Code of Criminal Procedure), having found the Sanha to be the true representation of the information and having rejected the prosecution evidence. The complainant (Sumiran) then moved the Sessions Judge of Shahabad, who directed the petitioners to be committed to the Court of Sessions. The present opinion is an appellate review of that direction.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Sessions Judge was justified in directing the discharging Magistrate to commit the petitioners to the Court of Sessions despite the Magistrate's discharge under Section 253.
  2. Whether the magistrate's factual findings (particularly that the Sanha correctly represented the information and that there was no case of culpable homicide) were perverse or wrong such as to permit the Sessions Judge to substitute his view.
  3. Whether there was any case to be tried under Section 304 read with Section 149, or under Section 147, of the Indian Penal Code.
  4. Whether there was any evidence on the record connecting the petitioners with the serious injuries to Sheodahin sufficient to mandate committal for trial under Section 325 of the Indian Penal Code.

Arguments of the Parties

Prosecution / Complainant (as presented at trial)

  • The prosecution's case in Court was that "Twenty or twenty two heads of cattle of village Baluahi were eating the crops stored in the khalihan of Sumiran Singh, Sheodahin and Balgobind, and Sumiran, Sheodahin and Balgobind started driving the cattle to the pound." The petitioners then came, rescued the cattle, and assaulted them; in that assault all three (Sumiran, Sheodahin and Balgobind) received injuries, and Sheodahin died the following day from those injuries.
  • The prosecution relied on the Head Constable (who proved the Sanha) and other evidence linking the petitioners to the violent occurrence that resulted in Sheodahin's death.

Defence / Petitioners

  • The defence theory (as described in the opinion) was that Sheodahin received the wounds by a fall from a tree rather than by assault.
  • Sumiran (complainant) had earlier given evidence that he went to the Writer Head Constable to have his information recorded but the constable refused; the Head Constable contradicted this, and the Magistrate accepted the Head Constable's version.

Learned Government Advocate (as represented in the opinion)

  • The learned Government Advocate contended that, at any rate, there was a case under Section 325 to be tried and that a committal was required to avoid a gross miscarriage of justice given that Sheodahin died from injuries inflicted on him.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by examining the factual findings of the Magistrate, the discrepancies between the Sanha (station diary entry) and the narrative presented at trial, and whether the Sessions Judge was entitled to direct committal despite the Magistrate's discharge.

Key points of the court's step-by-step reasoning as recorded in the opinion:

  • The Magistrate found the Sanha (station diary entry) to be the correct representation of the information given to the Writer Head Constable. Sumiran's contrary assertion (that the constable refused to take his statement) was disbelieved by the Magistrate, and the appellate judge found no basis to disturb that credibility finding.
  • The case presented at trial was materially different from the version (Sanha) recorded at the thana: the Sanha did not mention serious injuries to Sheodahin nor that the complainant and his brothers were taking cattle to the pound, whereas the trial case alleged a larger incident involving many cattle and multiple assailants. The Magistrate treated that discrepancy as significant and treated many aspects of the prosecution evidence as fabricated or modified to "get up a case."
  • The Magistrate considered whether there was a case of culpable homicide triable by the Court (S. 304 read with S. 149) and concluded there was nothing to show injuries were inflicted with intent to cause death or with knowledge that they were likely to cause death; accordingly there was no case of culpable homicide to be committed for trial.
  • Having reached that view, the Magistrate then tried the case himself on lesser charges and concluded the injuries were received "in the heat of the fight" and proved fatal afterwards; on the merits he rejected the prosecution evidence as unworthy of credit and discharged the petitioners under Section 253 of the Code.
  • The Sessions Judge, acting on the complainant's application, entertained doubt about the correctness of the station diary entry (Sanha) and directed committal. The appellate judge emphasized that a Sessions Judge considering whether to order committal after a Magistrate's discharge must determine whether the Magistrate's finding was not merely different but perverse — i.e., whether no reasonable tribunal could have reached it on the materials.
  • The appellate judge found that the Sessions Judge did not find the Magistrate's conclusion to be perverse and that, on the record, the Magistrate's findings could not be meaningfully characterized as perverse. Merely taking a different view did not justify the Sessions Judge's course.
  • The appellate judge expressly rejected the defence's fall-from-tree explanation for how Sheodahin sustained his injuries, finding that theory improbable or untenable; despite this, the court emphasized that even if Sheodahin's death was from injuries inflicted, the prosecution still had to establish a case under Section 325 against the petitioners specifically.
  • After reading all the evidence, the appellate judge concluded there was no evidence connecting the petitioners (or any of them) with the serious injuries to Sheodahin. Given the lack of connection on the record, there was no basis to commit the petitioners for trial under Section 325.

Holding and Implications

The application is allowed and the order of the learned Sessions Judge directing committal is set aside.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The petitioners' discharge by the Magistrate (under Section 253) stands; they are not to be committed to the Court of Sessions on the record as it stands.
  • The court found no case to be tried under Section 304 read with Section 149, nor under Section 147, nor sufficient evidence to connect the petitioners with serious injuries so as to require committal under Section 325 of the Indian Penal Code.

The opinion does not discuss any broader legal implications or purport to lay down a new precedent; the decision concerns the direct effect on these parties and reverses the Sessions Judge's direction to commit.

Disposition: Application allowed; order of the Sessions Judge set aside. Reference answered.

    Ritbhanjan Rai And Others v. King Emperor .

    Das, J.:— This application is directed against the order of the learned Sessions Judge of Shahabad, dated the 22nd September, 1921, by which he has directed the petitioners to be committed to the Court of Sessions by the discharging Magistrate, or if he is transferred by his successor.

    2. The petitioners were tried by a Magistrate of Sassaram in respect of an occurrence which took place on the afternoon of the 14th of April last. By his order dated the 26th June, 1924, the learned Magistrate discharged the petitioners under S. 253 of the Code.

    3. The complainant thereupon moved the Sessions Judge of Shahabad with the result that the petitioners have now been directed to be committed to the Court of Sessions.

    4. It is not open to doubt that in the course of the occurrence which took place, Sumiran and Balgobind received certain injuries which were more or less slight. It is the case of the prosecution that serious injuries were inflicted on Sheodahin, the brother of Sumiran and Balgobind, which caused his death. Sheodahin undoubtedly died in the afternoon of the 15th April, and the medical evidence shows that there were two contusions on both sides of his head which were the cause of his death.

    5. The defence theory is that he received these wounds by a fall from a tree. The medical Officer stated in his evidence that a contusion on one tide of the head could have been caused by a fall from a tree. On being pressed further, he stated that contusions on both sides of the head could be caused by a fall from a tree bub that the idea was far fetched. I understand his evidence to be that it is possible but highly improbable that the injuries on both sides of the head could have been caused by a fall from a tree.

    6. Now in respect of the occurrence, Sumiran is alleged to have lodged an information before the Writer Head Constable at 7 P.M that evening. He is alleged to have reported that the petitioners were taking his cattle to the pound from a purti land when he went and remonstrated. On that there was an altercation and he was assaulted. As the offence disclosed in the information was of a non-cognizable nature, the constable refused to take any action. It is to be noted that there was no suggestion in the Sanha that serious injuries were inflicted on Sheodahin, or that the Complainant and his brother were taking the cattle to the pound.

    7. The case made by the prosecution at the trial was, however, a different one. That case is as follows;

    “Twenty or twenty two heads of cattle of village Baluahi were eating the crops stored in the khalihan of Sumiran Singh, Sheodahin and Balgobind, and Sumiran, Sheodahin and Balgobind started driving the cattle to the pound.” Thereupon the petitioners came and rescued the cattle and began to assault them in the course of which they all received injuries from the effect of which Sheodahin died the next day.

    8. It will be noticed that the case presented in Court was radically different from the one alleged to have been stated to the Writer Head Constable, and it was impossible for the Court to convict the petitioners if it found that the information was correctly recorded by the Writer Head Constable.

    9. The Sanha was proved by the Head Constable who was very properly called as a witness on behalf of the prosecution. Sumiran in his evidence admitted that he went to the Wirter Head Constable to have his information recorded; but he states that the constable refused to take down his statement. In this he was contradicted by the Writer Head Constable and the Court had to consider which of the rival versions was true. On a consideration of the evidence, the Magistrate came to the conclusion that the evidence of Sumiran on this point was untrue, and I have no doubt whatever that this is the only conclusion at which he could have arrived.

    10. Now if the prosecution case be true, a serious offence had been committed by the petitioners. It is the evidence of Sumiran that he went to the Writer Head Constable to have his information recorded but that the refused to record his statement. No attempt was made to have Sheodahin conveyed to the hospital and the complaint was not filed in Court till the 16th of April, the occurrence having taken place on the 14th of April. The internal evidence furnished by the complainant, however shows that it was drawn up on the afternoon of the 15th of April.

    11. Now I cannot believe that, if the police refused to help Sumiran in the matter, Sumiran would not have rushed to the Court at the earliest possible opportunity and laid his case before the Court; but he waited till the 16th of April and when he did file his complaint in Court, he made no allegation whatever against the police and suppressed the fact that he had gone to the Head Constable be have his information recorded. The facts speak for themselves and it is not necessary for me to pursue the subject.

    12. These being the circumstances, the Magistrate had to consider whether there was a case to go to the Jury, or whether he was not competent to try the case himself. He examined the evidence and came to the conclusion that “there is nothing to show that the injuries were inflicted with intent to came death or knowing it likely that they will cause death”. Although the point is disputed by the learned Government Advocate, I take the view that the finding of the Magistrate amounted to a finding to the effect that there was no case of culpable homicide to be tried by the Court. That bring his finding, he tried the case himself to see whether any of the petitioners could be convicted of an offence under S. 325 I.P.C On this his finding is that “the injuries were received in the heat of the fight and proved fatal afterwards”. Having accepted that the Sanha correctly represented the information given by Sumiram, the Magistrate rejected the whole of the prosecution evidence and discharged the petitioner under Section 253 of the Code.

    13. When the matter went up to the learned Sessions Judge at the instance not of the Crown but of Sumiram, the learned Sessions Judge thought that there was much to be said on behalf of the complain in that the entry in the Station diary was not a correct entry.

    14. Now it seems to me that this was a vital point in the case was the entry in the station diary a true entry or a false entry. In dealing with this point the learned Magistrate, referred to two circumstances which in his view were important: first that there was no allegation by Sumiran either in his petition of complaint or in his statement on solemn affirmation that the Writer Head Constable refused to take down his statement; and secondly that Sheodabin was not taken to the thana.

    15. Now these are matters not discussed in the Judgment of the learned Sessions Judge. I apprehend that, in considering whether the petitioners should be directed to be committed to the Court of Sessions notwithstanding they had been discharged by the Magistrate, the Sessions Judge had to consider whether it was open to the Magistrate to come to the conclusion to which he did come on the materials before him. That a different view could be taken on the evidence would nos justify the learned Sessions Judge to tike the course which he has taken; he must come to the conclusion that the finding of the Magistrate is not only wrong but perverse. In my opinion, on the materials in the record the learned Sessions Judge could not have come to the conclusion that the finding of the Magistrate on this point was a perverse finding nor do I think that the learned Sessions Judge has come to that conclusion. The finding of the learned Sessions Judge on this point is somewhat halting; but as I read the Judgment, he does not even say that the finding of she Magistrate is wrong although he does throw some doubt on that finding. In my opinion there is no case: to be tried either under S. 304 read with S. 149, or under S. 147 of the Indian Penal Code.

    16. But the learned Government Advocate contended before me that at any rate there is a case under S. 325 to be tried.

    17. There is no doubt that Sheodahia has died from injuries inflicted on him. I have read the evidence myself and I altogether reject the theory that Sheodahin could have received these injuries by a fall from a tree. But still the prosecution has to establish a case under S. 325 against the petitioners or some of them. The learned Magistrate examined the prosecution evidence and rejected it as Unworthy of credit. His finding on this point is as follows:—

    “It is clear that true circumstances of the occurrence have been suppressed and false and fictitious circumstances have been set forth in order to get up a case. All the eleven accused persons are given their respective parts, three assault one man, three assault another and five assault another. None are left to stand idle. But I do not understand how in the heat of fight persons injured can see things so minutely and in detail ani why when so many persons used their lathis so few injuries were received. This shows that much less number of men were engaged in the occurrence than what is alleged by the prosecution and this is another proof that the circumstances of the occurrence have been changed.”

    18. It was, in my opinion, open to the learned Magistrate, on the materials before him, to reject the evidence, having regard to the fact that the prosecution had undoubtedly made a false cue on many points.

    19. It is, however, contended by the learned Government Advocate that Sheodahin laving died from the injuries admittedly inflicted on him by the petitioners, there would be a gross miscarriage of justice if the petitioners are not directed to be committed to the Court of Sessions to be charged for an offence under S. 325, or at any rate if further inquiry into the matter be not ordered.

    20. Now in dealing with this point, it has to be remembered that charges under S. 304 read with S. 149 and S. 147 have wholly failed. I have myself read all the evidence in the case and there is no doubt whatever that there is no case under S. 304 to be tried. That being so the only question is, is there any evidence on the record to connect the petitioners or any of them with the serious injuries inflicted on Sheodahin? As I have said I have read ill the evidence in the case and in my opinion there is no evidence whatever to connect the petitioners or any of them with those injuries. That being so, obviously none of the petitioners could be convicted of an offence under S. 325 I.P.C The application must be allowed and the order of the learned Sessions Judge must be set aside.

    21. Reference answered.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ritbhanjan Rai And Others v. King Emperor .
    (Nov 26, 1924)