Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of English Workmen's Compensation Act of 1906. The English Act
  • section affects the present case.Sub-section (2) of s. 3
  • English Workmen's Compensation Act of 1925,
  • sections of the Workmen's Compensation Act,
  • s. 2(d)(ii) of the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  • Section 306 of the Indian-Succession Act
  • English Workmen's Compensation Act (1906),
  • Workmen's Compensation Act, 1906,
  • Workmen's Compensation Act,
  • s. 306, Succession Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of English Workmen's Compensation Act of 1906. The English Act
  • section affects the present case.Sub-section (2) of s. 3
  • English Workmen's Compensation Act of 1925,
  • sections of the Workmen's Compensation Act,
  • s. 2(d)(ii) of the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  • Section 306 of the Indian-Succession Act
  • English Workmen's Compensation Act (1906),
  • Workmen's Compensation Act, 1906,
  • Workmen's Compensation Act,
  • s. 306, Succession Act.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Judgment (Derbyshire, C.J.; Mukherjea, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant appealed against an order of the Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation, Bengal, who declined to award any compensation for the death of a workman.

Relevant factual timeline (as stated in the opinion):

  • On 5 October 1934, Hari Charan De, head engine-driver at Kelvin Jute Mills, was injured at work.
  • He died on 13 October 1934.
  • The only person who could claim to be a dependant within the meaning of the Act was his widowed daughter, Kalo Mani Datta. She had a son (the appellant), who at the time of the workman's death was aged five (now seven) and lived with his mother in the deceased's house.
  • On 24 November 1934 the employers deposited Rs. 3,500 with the Commissioner under s.8(1) of the Workmen's Compensation Act.
  • On 29 November 1934 Kalo Mani Datta (the dependant) died, leaving the appellant surviving her.
  • On 25 April 1935 the Commissioner heard the appellant's application (through his uncle) for the compensation. The Commissioner rejected the application on the ground that no dependant existed at the date of the inquiry (25 April 1935) and ordered repayment of the deposit to the employers under s.8(4).

The appellant's primary contention was that the right to compensation vested in his mother on the death of the workman and that, after her death, that right passed to him under the Succession Act upon his obtaining the requisite succession documentation. The employers contended that if no dependant existed at the time the Commissioner made his inquiry, the money was repayable to them.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Does a right to compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act vest in the dependant(s) actually existing at the time of the workman's death, or does no right arise until the Commissioner completes his inquiry and makes an award?
  2. If a dependant who existed at the workman's death dies before any claim is made or before the Commissioner's inquiry is completed, does the right to compensation pass to that dependant's heirs or legal representatives?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The right to compensation vested in the appellant's mother (the dependant) on the death of the workman.
  • After the mother's death, the vested right passed to the appellant under the Succession Act (upon obtaining a succession certificate), entitling him to the compensation money deposited with the Commissioner.

Employers' (Respondent's) Arguments

  • If no dependant exists at the time the Commissioner makes his inquiry, the Commissioner must repay the deposited compensation to the employer under s.8(4).
  • Implicitly, the employers' position was that dependants acquire no enforceable right to compensation until the Commissioner has completed his enquiry and made distribution (i.e., the right only crystallises on the Commissioner's order).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
United Collieries, Limited v. Simpson (House of Lords; under English Workmen's Compensation Act, 1906) Whether the right of a dependant under the Workmen's Compensation Act vests on the workman's death and whether that right passes to the legal representatives of a sole dependant who dies before making a claim. The Court regarded the majority decision in United Collieries as supportive of the view that the right vests on the workman's death and is transmissible to legal representatives; Derbyshire, C.J. adopted reasoning of Lord Loreburn to support transmissibility of the dependant's right as property.
Bhupendra Narayan Sinha v. Chandramoni Gupta Affirmation that the doctrine actio personalis moritur cum persona is not part of Indian law (relevance to devolution of rights on death). Mukherjea, J. relied on this authority to support the proposition that statutory rights do devolve on legal representatives under s.306 of the Indian Succession Act and are not lost on the death of the person entitled.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis is grounded on textual interpretation of the Workmen's Compensation Act (notably ss. 2(1)(d), 3, 4 and 8) and analogy to the English authority discussed above.

Key points of the reasoning (Derbyshire, C.J. and Mukherjea, J.):

  • Statutory source of liability: Sections 3 and 4 make an employer liable and fix the amount payable when personal injury results in death; the statute contemplates a class of persons — the dependants — as the persons entitled to compensation.
  • Nature and timing of the right: The judges construed the Act as creating, upon the workman's death, a right in each member of the class of dependants to claim compensation. That right arises at the time of the workman's death rather than only upon the making of a claim or the conclusion of the Commissioner's enquiry.
  • Role of the Commissioner: Section 8 (and especially ss.8(4) and 8(5)) provides for custody, publication of notice, enquiry and distribution by the Commissioner; these provisions secure safe custody and equitable apportionment, but do not operate to extinguish or prevent the vesting of the dependants' rights at the time of the workman's death. The Commissioner has discretion to apportion and may, in his discretion, allot the compensation to one dependant to the exclusion of others, but he may not deprive the whole class of dependants of the compensation where a dependant did exist at the time of death.
  • Transmissibility of the right: The Court held that where a dependant (who existed at the workman's death) subsequently dies before the Commissioner's enquiry is completed, the dependant's vested right passes to his or her heirs or legal representatives pursuant to the principles embodied in the Succession Act (s.306) and general rules of devolution; hence, legal representatives can claim the compensation on behalf of the deceased dependant.
  • Analogical support from English law: The Chief Justice drew on Lord Loreburn's reasoning in United Collieries to support the proposition that the right is transmissible as property; both judges noted that the English Act of 1925 later altered the English position expressly (by preventing the legal representative of a dependant from claiming if the dependant died before claim or award), but the Indian Act contains no corresponding provision.
  • Practical and purposive considerations: The Court observed that construing the right to depend upon the timing of the Commissioner's enquiry (or the dependant's death during delay) would yield unjust and arbitrary results and frustrate the object of the Act — e.g., dependants might be left uncompensated due to delays for reasons beyond their control.
  • Conclusion on Commissioner's order: Given the above, the Commissioner was wrong to order repayment to the employers without first being satisfied that no dependant within s.2 (or heir/legal representative of such dependant dying after the workman) existed as of the date of inquiry.

Mukherjea, J. added emphasis on:

  • The statutory devolution rule in s.306 of the Indian Succession Act and the rejection of any general rule that statutory rights of this nature die with the person.
  • The interpretation that "in existence" for the purpose of s.8 means "in existence at the time of the workman's death."
  • The practical consequence that the Commissioner must investigate whether the sole dependant at the time of the workman's death (here, the appellant's mother) was indeed a dependant within s.2(d)(ii).

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: APPEAL ALLOWED; CASE REMANDED TO THE COMMISSIONER.

Direct consequences and instructions from the Court (as expressly stated in the opinion):

  • The Commissioner was in error in ordering repayment of the deposited compensation to the employers without first satisfying himself that no dependant under s.2, or no heir or legal representative of such a dependant who had died since the workman's death, existed at the date of the inquiry.
  • The matter is remitted to the Commissioner for further enquiry and determination on the lines indicated by the Court — specifically, to investigate whether the appellant's mother was a dependant within s.2(d)(ii) of the Workmen's Compensation Act and to determine entitlement in light of any heirs or legal representatives of such dependant.
  • The question of whether the appellant is the legal representative of the deceased dependant cannot be decided by the Commissioner without proper proof (e.g., letters of administration) as required by law.
  • Costs: The appellant is awarded the costs of this appeal in this Court. The costs of the first hearing before the Commissioner are to abide the result of the further hearing by the Commissioner. The hearing fee in this Court is assessed at five gold mohurs.

Broader implication articulated in the opinion (limited to what the Court itself stated): by interpreting the Act to vest the right in dependants at the workman's death and to allow transmission of that right to legal representatives where the dependant has died after the workman, the Court rejected the narrower construction that would make entitlement depend on the timing of the Commissioner's inquiry. The Court also noted that the English legislature later changed the English law (Workmen's Compensation Act 1925) to prevent such transmissibility, but that no similar provision exists in the Indian Act.

Appeal allowed, case remanded.

End of summary — based exclusively on the provided opinion text.

    Pashu Pati Datta v. Kelvin Jute Mills

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Derbyshire, C.J:— The appellant appeals from a decision by the Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation, Bengal, whereby the Commissioner declined to award the appellant any sum of compensation in respect of the death of a workman killed by an accident arising out of and in the course of his employment.

    The facts are as follows. On October 5, 1934, one Hari Charan De, the head engine-driver in the Kelvin Jute Mills, was injured at his work. He died on October 13, 1934. The only person who could claim to be dependant upon the deceased within the meaning of the Act was one Kalo Mani Datta. She was the daughter of the deceased, but a widow. She had one son, the appellant, now aged seven years, then aged five years, who lived with her in the house of her father, the deceased workman.

    On November 24, 1934, the employers, pursuant to s. 8(1) of the Act, deposited with the Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation, the sum of Rs. 3,500 in respect of their obligations under the Act. On November 29, 1934, Kalo Mani Datta died leaving the appellant surviving her. On April 25, 1935, the Commissioner heard the application of the appellant (through his uncle) for an award to be made in his favour of the compensation, viz., Rs. 3,500. The Commissioner rejected this application on the ground that no dependant within the meaning of the Act then (i.e, on April 25, 1935) existed. Accordingly he ordered the compensation money to be repaid to the employers under s. 8(4) of the Act.

    The relevant provisions of the Act are as follows:—

    Under s. 2(1)(d) a “dependant” includes a widowed daughter “if wholly or in part dependant on the earnings of the workman at the time of his death.” (The child of such widowed daughter is not a defendant within the section.)

    Section 3(1) provides that—

    If personal injury is caused to a workman by accident arising out of and in the course of his employment, his employer shall be liable to pay compensation in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter.

    There is a proviso, but neither that nor the rest of the section affects the present case.

    Sub-section (2) of s. 3 deals with the case of contraction of occupational diseases. Sub-section (3) gives the Governor-General in Council power to add to the schedule of occupational diseases.

    Section 4(1) provides that “subject to the provisions of this Act the amount of compensation shall be as follows, namely:—

    A. Where death results from the injury…….

    Then follow provisions specifying how the amount of compensation is to be ascertained.

    Section 8(1) provides that—

    No payment of compensation in respect of a workman whose injury has resulted in death * * * * * * shall lie made otherwise than by deposit with the Commissioner * *

    Sub-section (4):—

    On the deposit of any money under sub-s. (1) as compensation in respect of a deceased workman the Commissioner shall deduct therefrom the actual cost of the workman's funeral expenses, to an amount not exceeding twenty-five rupees and pay the same to the person by whom such expenses were incurred, and shall, if he thinks necessary, cause notice to be published or to be served on each dependant in such manner as he thinks fit, calling upon the dependants to appear before him on such date as he may fix for determining the distribution of the compensation. If the Commissioner is satisfied, after any enquiry which he may deem necessary, that no dependant exists, he shall repay the balance of the money to the employer by whom it was paid * * *

    Sub-section (5):—

    Compensation deposited in respect of a deceased workman shall, subject to any deduction made under sub-s. (4), be apportioned among the dependants of the deceased workman or any of them in such proportion as the Commissioner thinks fit, or may, in the discretion of the Commissioner, be allotted to any one dependant.

    Sub-section (6):—

    Where any compensation deposited with the Commissioner is payable to any person, the Commissioner shall, if the person to whom the compensation is payable is not a woman or a person under a legal disability, and may, in other cases, pay the money to the person entitled thereto.

    The appellant contends that the right to compensation vested in his mother on the deceased workman's death and that after his mother's death and upon his obtaining a Succession Certificate that right passed to him under the Succession Act and so he is entitled to the compensation money. On the other hand, the employers contend that if no dependant exists at the time when the Commissioner makes the enquiry the money is repayable to them.

    A somewhat similar case arose under the English Workmen's Compensation Act (1906), viz., United Collieries, Limited v. Simpson where a workman whilst in the employment of a colliery company was knocked down by a wagon in the course of his employment on July 9, 1907. He died of his injuries on July 14th. His mother, alleged to have been dependant upon him, died on October 16, 1907, without making any claim upon the appellants. Her executrix made a claim on December 10, 1907, under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1906, as representative of the mother. The House of Lords found some difficulty in coming to a decision, but the majority held (Lord Dunedin dissenting) that the right of the dependant of the deceased workman passed to the executor of a sole dependant who had died without having made a claim.

    I think the reasoning of Lord Loreburn (p. 389) is applicable here. In discussing the English Act of 1906 he says:—

    Paragraph 5 of the schedule requires payment in the case of death “unless otherwise ordered or hereinafter provided” into the county Court to be dealt with in discretion “for the benefit of the persons entitled thereto under thus Act.” This is, no doubt, in order to relieve the employer and ensure a proper custody, distribution, and application of the money, especially where there are minors or several dependants, or where there are persons for whom the county Court judge thinks it advisable to take precautions.

    The eighth paragraph also contemplates payment to a dependant. And though the ninth reserves a power to vary the apportionment, neither it nor any other paragraph proceeds upon any other view than that there is a definite right on the part of dependants as a class to the money, subject to a parental power of the Court in dividing and applying it for their advantage.

    If there is this right, when does it arise or become vested? The statute evidently treats it as arising because of the workman's death. It seems to follow that it arises on the workman's death, unless some other event is fixed.

    At page 390 he remarks:—

    I observed that in Lord M'Laren's opinion if the claim is made within the statutory period, and the dependant dies before an award has been made; the right to an award of compensation has vested in the dependant, and a right to follow out the proceedings in the arbitration passes to the legal personal representatives. But if the claim has not been made, his Lordship thinks that the employer's liability is terminated by the death of the dependant. That opinion is entitled to the greatest respect, but I cannot agree. I cannot see why the claim instead of the death is to be regarded as the signal for the right to compensation vesting. And even if it were 60, the Act does not require that the dependant himself should make the claim, and I do not see why that right to make the claim should not pass to the executor.

    It seems to me, therefore, that, as the person represented by the respondent was the only dependant, her representatives may properly claim all that she was entitled to, the right being transmissible as property.

    Applying a similar process of examination and reasoning to the Indian Act, my own view is that ss. 3 and 4 make the employers liable to pay compensation upon the death of the workman and fix the amount which has to be paid. Section 8(5) gives a right to the dependants of the deceased workman as a class, but not individually, to that compensation money. The Commissioner may apportion the compensation money amongst such members of the class as he thinks proper, even to the extent of allotting the money to one dependant only. It does not give the Commissioner the right to deprive the whole of the class of dependants of the compensation money. In my view, therefore, upon the death of the workman, each member of the class acquires a right to claim compensation and that right vests in him. That dependant may thereafter be divested of that right or find it of no value because the Commissioner decides to award the compensation amongst other members of the class.

    Here the only person in the class of dependants at the death of the workman was the applicant's mother. Consequently, the right to the compensation money vested in her. It was not competent, in my view, for the Commissioner to divest her of that right. Therefore it remained vested in her to the time of her death. Upon her death, the right passed to her heirs or legal representatives subject to the conditions of the Succession Act being complied with.

    In my view “dependant” in s. 8 includes the heirs or legal representatives of the dependant as defined by s. 2 where the dependant has died since the death of the workman.

    It is noteworthy that in the English Workmen's Compensation Act of 1925, which replaced the Act of 1906, it is provided in s. 2(3):—

    Where a dependant dies before a claim under this Act is made, or if a claim has been made, before an agreement or award has been arrived at or made, the legal personal representative of the dependant shall have no right to payment of compensation, and the amount of compensation shall be calculated and apportioned as if that dependant had died before the workman.

    This was obviously intended to alter the law as laid down in United Collieries, Limited v. Simpson. There is no corresponding provision in the Indian Act.

    If the conclusion at which I have arrived is wrong the position would be that the right to compensation would depend upon the accident of the time when the Commissioner made his inquiry or when the dependant die. If the Commissioner were delayed in making his inquiry through some cause such as a heavy list or some other unavoidable delay, dependants might the uncompensated after suffering privations through the loss of the workman upon whom they were dependant. I cannot think that such is the position under the Act.

    I am of the opinion, therefore, that the Commissioner was wrong in law in the award he made, and that before ordering the return of the compensation money to the employers he should have satisfied himself that no dependant within s. 2, or heir or legal representative of such dependant, who has died since the death of the workman, existed at the date of the inquiry.

    The matter will go back to the Commissioner for him to deal with it upon the lines indicated above.

    The appellant will have the costs of this appeal here, but the cost of the first hearing will be left to abide the result of the further hearing by the Commissioner. The hearing fee, in this Court, is assessed at five gold mohurs.

    Mukherjea, J.:— I agree with my Lord the Chief Justice in the judgment that, has just now been delivered, and I would desire only to add a few words.

    The point in controversy in this appeal is, as to whether, on the death of a workman through some accident arising in course of his employment, a right to the compensation, payable by the employer under the Workmen's Compensation Act, does vest in his dependant or dependants actually existing at the time of his death; and if such dependant dies before any claim to such compensation is made or investigated, does the right pass on to his heirs or legal representatives?

    The second part of the question does not really present any difficulty. The doctrine “Actio personalis moritur cum persona” does not form part of the law of this country: see Bhupendra Narayan Sinha v. Chandramoni Gupta. Section 306 of the Indian-Succession Act embodies the statutory provision as regards devolution of rights and habihties of the deceased upon his legal representatives. The right to demand compensation payable under a statute is certainly not founded on tort, and does not come within any of the exceptions that are mentioned in s. 306, Succession Act. It is really not disputed on behalf of the respondent that if the right accrued in favour of the appellant's mother during her lifetime it would devolve on her legal representatives at her death. What is disputed is that any right could accrue in favour of a defendant at all till the enquiry is finished by the Commissioner and the distribution order made. The answer to this question has got to be found in the relevant sections of the Workmen's Compensation Act, relating to payment and distribution of the compensation.

    Section 3 of the Act lays down that:—

    If personal injury is caused to a workman by accident arising out of and in the course of his employment, his employer shall be liable to pay compensation in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter.

    Section 4 lays down the rules for determination of the amount of compensation, s. 8(1) then says, where the injury has resulted in death, no payment of compensation shall be made otherwise than by deposit with the Commissioner. Under cl. (4) of that section, the Commissioner after he receives the deposit has got to give notice on each dependant, and if he is satisfied on enquiry that no dependant exists he has to refund the money to the employer. In case dependants exist, the money may be distributed amongst them in such manner as the Commissioner thinks proper, and may in his discretion be allotted to one dependant only to the exclusion of the rest. Mr. Banerji on behalf of the respondent contends that these provisions make it perfectly clear that the dependant or dependants do not acquire any right in the compensation till the order is passed by the Commissioner after enquiry under cl. (5) of s. 8, and if there is no dependant actually living at the time when the award is made, there is no other course open to the Commissioner but to refund the money to the employer. This contention, in my opinion, is not tenable. It is true that s. 3, which imposes the liability upon the employer to pay compensation, does not specify the person or persons to whom it is payable, but s. 8 makes it clear that nobody has any right to it except the dependants, and this is the case, whether the compensation is paid direct or through the Commissioner. In certain cases the compensation has to be deposited with the Commissioner, and this is for ensuring its safe custody and equitable distribution, particularly when there are more dependants than one, but, though the Commissioner has got the entire discretion in the matter and can allot the entire amount to one dependant, he cannot deprive the sole dependant of any portion of the compensation, nor can give any portion of the same to one who is not a dependant.

    The right therefore accrues to the dependants as a class, subject to the Commissioner's rights of distribution in such way as he thinks proper, and in case of a sole dependant it vests absolutely and it is a right which has been given to the dependants because of the workman's death, it must be deemed to accrue at the time of his death, there being no grounds of postponing it to a further date. A duty to refund the compensation arises only when there is no dependant “in existence” and this must mean “in existence” at the time of the workman's death. To put any other interpretation would be to frustrate the object of the Act, and place the right to compensation on an uncertain contingency. The enquiry before the Commissioner may be delayed for various reasons, and people who really depended upon the earnings of the deceased workman might die before or pending the enquiry and even just before the Commissioner makes the award. To say that the Commissioner is bound to refund the money to the employer under such circumstances would be to put an extremely narrow and unjust construction upon the section, which is not borne out by the purpose of the Act or the actual words used. As my Lord the Chief Justice pointed out in his judgment, the House of Lords in England took a similar view in United Collieries, Limited v. Simpson upon the provisions of English Workmen's Compensation Act of 1906. The English Act also provided for payment of the compensation into the county Court, which could deal with it in its discretion, and divide it in such manner as it thought best among the dependants of the deceased workman. It is true that there was no provision for refund of the money to the employer in the English Act of 1906, but that is really not very important as on total absence of any dependant the money could not really be retained by the county Court and would have to be returned to the employer in exercise of its inherent powers. Mr. Banerji for the respondent lays stress on the fact, that in the English Act of 1925, an express provision was inserted in s. 2, cl. (3), under which the legal representative of a dependant had no right to the compensation payable to the latter; but here again it is significant to note that the Indian Act was amended on various occasions even after 1925, but the Indian legislature did not think it proper to introduce any provision like the one mentioned above. It may be said indeed that to hold, that the dependants' right to compensation is a vested right which passes to his legal representative would be to put an additional burden upon the employer, the effect of which might be to enrich strangers and persons totally outside the scope of the Act, but the result would be exactly the same if the dependant dies the very day after receiving the compensation. For all these reasons, I agree that the appeal should be allowed, and the case remanded to the Commissioner for investigation, as to whether the appellants' mother was really a de-, pendant within the meaning of s. 2(d)(ii) of the Workmen's Compensation Act. Of course the question as to whether the appellant is the legal representative of the deceased dependant cannot be gone into before the Commissioner. It must be established by letters of administration or such other proof as the law provides for establishing such rights.

    Appeal allowed, case remanded.
    S.M

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pashu Pati Datta v. Kelvin Jute Mills
    (May 5, 1937)