Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was recruited as a soldier in the Indian Army on 13 December 1982 at Varanasi after medical examination and declared fit. He underwent training at Jat Regiment Centre, Bareilly and trade training at Remount Veterinary Group (R.V.G), Meerut, and was repeatedly examined and placed in medical category A during most of his service.

Over time, due to physical problems attributed to the stress and strain of military service (including long route marches, horse riding, carrying equipment and night training), the petitioner was placed in lower medical categories: temporarily in category C (six months in 1989), then upgraded to category B temporarily for six months and finally placed in category B permanently in 1990. He was discharged from service by an order dated 31-3-1990 passed by respondent No. 2 (Centre Commanding Officer).

A Medical Board had assessed disability at 20% and recommended disability pension, but respondent No. 4 (Chief Controller of Defence Accounts (Pensions), Allahabad) rejected the claim on 4-9-1990 and the appellate authority likewise did not accept the claim. The petitioner filed this writ petition seeking certiorari to quash the orders dated 31-3-1990 and 4-5-1990 (annexures I and II) and the order dated 3-12-1991 (annexure V), and a writ of mandamus directing reinstatement or, in the alternative, grant of disability pension and payment of salary from the date of discharge.

The respondents controverted the petition. During argument the petitioner confined the claim to grant of disability pension and relied on a Punjab High Court judgment (Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 16728 of 1990, delivered 17 January 1992) granting disability pension for 20% disability.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to disability pension where a Medical Board assessed disability at 20% and recommended pension on grounds of disability attributable to or aggravated by military service.
  2. Whether the respondents correctly applied the disability pension rules (including the criteria in R.173 of S. IV Disability Pensionary Awards and the rules in Appendix II and R.7 of Appendix II) in rejecting the petitioner's claim.
  3. Whether the impugned discharge and related orders (including orders of 31-3-1990, 4-5-1990 and 3-12-1991) should be quashed insofar as they affected the petitioner's entitlement to disability pension.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner argued he should be granted disability pension because the Medical Board assessed 20% disability and recommended pension as attributable to or aggravated by military service.
  • The petition challenged the interpretation and application of disability pension rules by the authorities, contending that those authorities had interpreted the pension rules wrongly.
  • The petitioner's counsel relied on a Punjab High Court judgment (Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 16728 of 1990, dated 17 January 1992) in which disability pension was granted for 20% disability.

Respondents' Position

  • The respondents controverted the petition and denied the petitioner's claim (the opinion records that the respondents controverted and denied the claim but provides no detailed exposition of their legal arguments).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Punjab High Court, Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 16728 of 1990 (delivered 17 January 1992) Cited as an instance where disability pensionary benefit was granted for 20% disability. Recorded as relied upon by the petitioner's counsel. The court noted the reliance but grounded its decision primarily on the statutory and administrative pension rules set out in the opinion (R.173 of S.IV, Appendix II and R.7 of Appendix II) rather than solely on this precedent.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed entitlement under the applicable disability pension rules and applied those rules to the facts admitted or alleged in the petition:

  1. The court quoted R.173 of S. IV (Disability Pensionary Awards) stating that "a disability pension may be granted to an individual who is invalided from service on account of a disability which is attributable to or aggravated by military service and is assessed at 20 per cent or over." This established the threshold and the linkage required between disability and service.
  2. The court referred to Appendix II (rules for entitlement) which includes:
    • Requirement that invaliding from service is a necessary condition for grant of disability pension and that an individual placed permanently in a medical category other than 'A' and discharged for lack of suitable alternative employment will be treated as invalided from service.
    • That disablement or death shall be accepted as due to military service if attributable to military service or if it existed before or arose during service and has been and remains aggravated thereby.
    • There must be a causal connection between disablement and military service, and all evidence (direct and circumstantial) must be taken into account with the benefit of reasonable doubt given to the claimant (liberally in field service cases).
  3. The court specifically applied R.7 of Appendix II relating to diseases:
    • Cases where conditions of military service determine or contribute to onset, or influence subsequent course, fall for acceptance on the basis of aggravation.
    • A disease leading to discharge will ordinarily be deemed to have arisen in service if no note of it was made at the time of acceptance for military service; an exception exists only if medical opinion states the disease could not have been detected at recruitment.
    • If accepted as having arisen in service, it must be established that conditions of service determined or contributed to onset, and that those conditions were due to duty in military service.
  4. Applying these rules to the facts, the court noted:
    • No note of the petitioner's disorder was made at the time of acceptance into service.
    • The respondents did not contend that the disorder could not have been detected at recruitment.
    • Given those facts and the Medical Board's assessment (20%), it was difficult to accept the respondents' refusal to grant pension as consistent with the rules.
  5. The court emphasized regulatory protections favoring the claimant: all evidence must be weighed and the benefit of reasonable doubt is to be given to the claimant, particularly in field service cases.
  6. The court also articulated a policy view reflected in the opinion: pension is not mere bounty but a right, and under Article 41 of the Constitution the State has duties to provide public assistance to disabled persons. The court used this to underline the nature of entitlement to pension.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The writ petition is allowed. The impugned orders are set aside and the respondents are directed to pay the petitioner the disability pension.

Direct consequences ordered by the court:

  • The respondents are directed to pay the petitioner the disability pension as per law.
  • The petitioner is entitled to arrears of pension with interest at the rate of 12 percent; payment of arrears with interest is to be made within three months from the date of production of a certified copy of the order before the authorities concerned.
  • There will be no order as to costs.

Broader implications noted by the court:

  • The court reiterated that pensionary benefits are a right earned by service and are to be treated accordingly rather than as charity.
  • The court's determination was based on application of the disability pension rules (R.173 of S.IV, Appendix II and R.7) to the factual record and the Medical Board assessment; the opinion does not purport to establish a new legal precedent beyond applying those rules to these facts.

Disposition: Petition allowed.

    Anil Kumar Mishra v. Union Of India And Others

    1. By this writ petition, the petitioner has made a prayer in the nature of certiorari quashing the orders dated 31-3-1990; 4-5-1990 (annexures I and II to the writ petition) passed by respondent No. 4 and the order dated 3-12-1991 (annexure V to the writ petition) passed by the respondent No. 1. The petitioner has also prayed that a writ in the nature of mandamus be issued directing the respondent No. 2 to reinstate the petitioner in service and to pay the salary from the date of the discharge on 31-3-1990 or in the alternative direct the respondents to grant the disabi lity pension to the petitioner in accordance with law.

    2. The petitioner's grievance is that he had been recruited as soldier in the Indian Army on 13th December, 1982 at Varanasi after being thoroughly examined by the Medical Board and after completing all the necessary formalities, he was declared successful.

    3. He has not been given the disability pension assessed 20% by the Medical Board which occurred during the period of service. Resume of facts leading to the writ petition are as under:—

    4. The petitioner joined as soldierin the Army on 13th December 1982 at Varanasi. Thereafter the petitioner reported for training in Jat Regiment Centre, Bareilly. There also the petitioner was examined by the competent medical officers and was declared fit and was put in category A. After the above training in Jat Regiment, Bareilly, the petitioner was transferred for Trade Training at Remount Veterinary Groups, Meerut (here in after referred to as R.V.C) in the year 1983. He was found fit there by the Medical Board. It is further alleged that after the completion of the above training, the petitioner was posted at Hempur, district Nainital on 2nd June, 1984. The petitioner remained medically fit and was placed continuously in medical category A. It is alleged that Hempur is a hilly area and due to stress and strain in Military Service and nature of duties such as long route marches covering about 20 miles a day, severebattle in training involving horse riding at faster speed for a long distance, with all the personal arm and equipments and night training including sleep less night etc., the petitioner developed some minor physical problem and then he was placed in low medical category B in September 1985. A review was held in March 1986 and the petitioner was upgraded to medical category A. Thereafter the petitioner was transferred from Hempur, district Nainital to R.V.G Saharanpur on 30th April, 1987 where he was again medically examined by the Medical Board and was declared fit to category A. Itis also averred in the petition that the petitioner was technically tested in horse-riding in which he was declared successful and certificate of technical proficiency was issued on 19th December, 1987 to the petitioner mentioning that the petitioner had physical efficiency to discharge tr\e duty. The case of the petitioner is that he performed all typesof his duties during this period at different places wherever he was posted till 1988 and remained in medical category A. However, at the last due to stress and strain of the Military service, as mentioned earlier, he developed some physical trouble and, therefore, the medical authorities placed the petitioner in low medical category C temporarily for six months in the year 1989. The petitioner had improved his health and his medical category was upgraded to category B temporarily for six months and thereafter the petitioner was placed in category, B permanently during the year of 1990. It is alleged by the petitioner that he was discharged from service on the basis of the report of the Medical Board placing him in category B, permanently vide order dated 31-3-1990 passed by the respondent No. 2 Centre Commanding Officer. The petitioner has described the order of discharge as illegal, arbitrary and against the rule as the persons placed in category B permanently cannot be discharged from service because they are deemed to be fit for performing all types of duties except conducting battle duties in war front. The petitioner was also not given sheltered post in alternative and, therefore, he has described the action of respondents not fair. He has further averred that the persons similarly situ ated are in service and he had been discriminated; peti doner's further grievance is that the Medical Board recommended that since he is in category B, he be given disability pension as it had been caused and aggravated due to Military Service but despite that recommendation, the respondent No. 4, the Chief Controller of Defence Accounts (Pensions), Allahabad rejected the claim of the petitioner on 4-9-1990. Later on, appeal was filed but the appellate authority has not accepted the claim of the petitioner. Under these circumstances, the petitioner has moved this Court to quash the impugned orders.

    5. The respondents controverted the allegations and denied the claim of the petitioner in tpto.

    6. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties. The learned counsel for the petitioner has, however, during the course of arguments, confined his claim regarding the grant of disability pension only and submitted that the authorities concerned have interpreted the disability pension rules wrongly. The learned counsel for the petitioner has further relied on a judgment of Punjab High Court delivered on 17th January, 1992 in Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 16728 of 1990 granting disability pensionary benefit to the petitioner, whose disability was 20 percent.

    7. After hearing the learned counsel for the parties, I am on the view that the petitioner is entitled for getting the disabi lity pension. The petitioner was at first placed in category A later on in category B due to hyper tension and thereafter he was discharged. At the time of recruitment at all stages, he was medically declared fit and as such no other inference can be drawn that he suffered mental illness during the course of his duties when he was in service. I would like to quote R. 173 of S. IV Disability Pensionary Awards:—

    173. Unless otherwise specifically provided, a disability pension may be granted to an individual who is invalided from service on account of a disability which is attributable to or aggravated by military service and is assessed at 20 per cent or over.

    The question whether a disability is attributable to or aggravated by military service for the purpose of disability pensionary awards.”

    8. Reference would be made to Appendix II pertaining the rules for entitlement of disability pension which run as under:—

    “1. With effect from 1st April, 1940, in supersession of all previous orders on the subject, the entitlement “to disability and family pension, children's allowance and death gratuities will be governed by following rules. Invaliding from service is a necessary condition for the grant of a disability pension. An individual who at the time of his release under the Release Regulations is in a lower medical category than that in which he was recruited will be treated as invalided from service. JCOs/ORs¼NCs (E) who are placed permanently in a Medical category other than ‘A’ and are discharged because no alternative employment suitable to their low medical category can be provided as well as those who having been retained in alternative employment but are discharged before the completion of their engagement will be deemed to have invalided out of service.

    2. Disablement or death shall be accepted as due to military service provided it is

    (a) the disablement is due to a wound, injury or disease which—

    (i) is attributable to military service; or

    (ii) existed before or arose during military service and has been and remains aggravated thereby,

    xxxxxx

    3. There must be a causal connection between disablement or death and military service for attributability or aggravation to be conceded.

    (4) In deciding on the issue of entitlement all the evidence, both direct and circumstantial, will be taken into account and the benefit of reasonable doubt will be given to the claimant. This benefit will be given to the claimant. This benefit will be given more liberally to the claimant in field service cases.”

    9. In respect of diseases, the following rules will be observed as provided by R. 7 of Appendix II. “7. In respect of diseases, the following rules will be observed;

    (a) Cases, in which it is established that conditions of military service did determine or contribute to the onset of disease but influenced the subsequent course of the disease, will fall for acceptance, on the basis of aggravation.

    (b) A disease which has led to an individual's discharge or death will ordinarily be deemed to have arisen in service if no note of it was made at the time of the individual's acceptance for military service. However, if medical opinion holds, for reasons to be stated, that the disease could not have been detected on medical examination prior to acceptance for service the disease will not be deemed to have arisen during service.

    (c) if a disease is accepted as having arisen in service, it must also be established that the conditions of military service determined or contributed to the on-set of the (sic) and that the conditions were due to the circumstances of duty in military service.

    (d)x x x x x x x x x x x x x

    10. A perusal of the above provisions wou Id show that the disease which leads to an individual's discharge is ordinari ly deemed to have arisen in service if no note of it was made at the time the individual's acceptance for service in the Armed Forces. In the present case, no such note was made at the time of acceptance of the petitioner for service. It is also not the case of the respondents that the disorder could not have been detected on medical examination at the time of recruitment in the army. Under such circumstances, it is very difficult to accept that the petitioner is not entitled to get 20 per cent, disability pension and according to the rules, as mentioned above, the petitioner is entitled to get the same in accordance with law. Action of the respondents in not doing the needful cannot be sustained as arbitrary and against pension rules. Now the concept of the pension has been changed as it is not mere a bounty but it is a right to property. It is not a charity to be given by the Government as the employee has earned it by virtue of putting the best period of his life in the service of society. Under Article 41 of Constitution of India, the State is under duty to provide public assistance to disabled persons.

    11. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The impugned orders are set aside and the respondents are directed to pay the petitioner the disability pension. The petitioner will be entitled to the payment of arrears of pension with interest at the rate of 12 percent, which is payable within three months from the date of production of a certified copy of this order before the authorities concerned. In the circumstances of the case, there will be no order as to costs.

    12. Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Anil Kumar Mishra v. Union Of India And Others
    (Dec 8, 1995)