Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • rule 9 clause (4) , rule 11 clause (9) and rule 19
  • sub - clause (2) of rule 3
  • clause (2) of rule 3
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • rule 9 clause (4) , rule 11 clause (9) and rule 19
  • sub - clause (2) of rule 3
  • clause (2) of rule 3
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Both the petitioner and the 4th respondent are medical graduates who later obtained diplomas in gynaecology and obstetrics and joined government medical service. The petitioner joined government service in May 1983; the 4th respondent joined in 1984. Both applied for admission to the postgraduate M.D. course in gynaecology and obstetrics and sat a common entrance examination.

In the entrance examination the petitioner scored 158 out of 200 marks and, with 3 additional marks for her diploma qualification, had a total of 161. The 4th respondent scored 153 and, with 3 diploma marks, had a total of 156. Despite the petitioner having a higher total score, the selection committee selected the 4th respondent for admission and rejected the petitioner.

The selection committee treated the petitioner as an "in-service candidate" under sub-clause (2) of rule 3 of G.O. Ms. No. 549 (M & H Department dated 6-9-1983 and amendments), and considered her against the 15% of seats reserved for in-service candidates; the 4th respondent was treated as a general candidate and considered against a general seat because the 4th respondent had not put in a minimum of two years' service.

The petitioner challenged the selection committee's action by filing this writ petition. The court admitted the petition on 4 March 1986 and by interim orders forbade the 4th respondent from taking admission in the medical college pending decision.

Relevant regulatory provision referred to in the opinion: sub-clause (2) of rule 3 of G.O. Ms. No. 549 provides that 15% of seats in clinical subjects and 30% in non-clinical subjects are reserved for in-service candidates; the explanation defines an in-service candidate as one who has put in a minimum of two years of service in the respective service.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner, although an in-service candidate within the meaning of sub-clause (2) of rule 3 of G.O. Ms. No. 549, has a right to be considered for admission against the general (open) seats.
  2. Whether that right (if any) is lost or excluded by reason of her being classified as an in-service candidate (i.e., whether an in-service candidate may be considered only for the seats reserved for in-service candidates and not for general seats).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that although she qualifies as an in-service candidate under sub-clause (2) of rule 3, her entitlement to be considered against the general seats cannot be taken away by the reservation scheme for in-service candidates.
  • She argued that if she had been considered against the general seats (as she should be entitled to), she would have been preferred for admission over the 4th respondent because she had higher total marks.

Respondent-State and 4th Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondents contended that an in-service candidate can be considered for admission only against the seats reserved for in-service candidates and not against the general seats.
  • The learned government pleader argued the reservation scheme contemplates special treatment for in-service candidates (including leave and salary arrangements after selection) and that if in-service candidates were selected through the general quota it would create administrative difficulties in running the service and granting leave. He relied on certain rules (rule 9 clause (4), rule 11 clause (9), and rule 19) that relate to benefits and administrative provisions for in-service candidates.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka (quoted) That education is a fundamental public function and where the state provides education that opportunity is a right which must be made available to all on equal terms. The court invoked this principle to emphasize the importance of equal access to education and to support the conclusion that the State cannot deny admission to the petitioner who obtained higher marks, unless she is truly ineligible to compete for general seats.
Bolling v. Sharpe (quoted) That the right to education falls within the protection of the due process concept of liberty (i.e., protection under constitutional notions of liberty). The court used this authority to underline that constitutional protections (due process/liberty) cover educational opportunity, reinforcing that reservation rules cannot unduly deprive a candidate of the right to pursue higher studies.
Raghuramulu v. The State of A.P. (earlier judgment of this court) That a reservation should be understood as not taking away the right of a candidate to compete for the general seats. The court relied on this precedent to hold that the reservation for in-service candidates does not exclude an in-service candidate from competing for general seats and therefore supports the petitioner's entitlement to be considered on the general list.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through the following analytical steps, confined to the reasoning set out in the opinion:

  1. The court began by stressing the constitutional and social importance of education and its protection under Articles 14 and 21, drawing on quotations and principles from Brown v. Board of Education and Bolling v. Sharpe to frame education as a right that must be made available on equal terms and as within the protection of due process/liberty.
  2. It observed the factual matrix: the petitioner had higher total marks than the 4th respondent but was treated as an in-service candidate and considered only for the reserved (15%) in-service seats; the 4th respondent was considered against the general quota.
  3. The court examined the scheme in G.O. Ms. No. 549 (and its amendments) and concluded that the reservation provisions are intended to withdraw a specified number of seats from general competition as a guarantee to secure a minimum number of seats for the beneficiaries of reservation. However, the court found nothing in that scheme that expressly barred an in-service candidate from competing for the remaining general seats.
  4. The court relied on precedent (Raghuramulu v. State of A.P.) holding that reservation does not take away a candidate's right to compete for general seats, and applied that principle to the present facts to conclude the petitioner retained the right to compete on general seats.
  5. The court considered the respondent-state's administrative argument (as advanced by the government pleader) that permitting in-service candidates to be selected through the general quota would create difficulties in running the service and in granting leave, and that certain rules (rule 9(4), rule 11(9), rule 19) envisage special benefits and leave arrangements for in-service candidates. The court held that these administrative considerations do not answer the constitutional question and that no evidentiary facts were placed before the court to show that allowing the petitioner to compete for a general seat would produce serious detrimental effects on service administration.
  6. The court emphasized that the right of a government servant to improve professional skills by further study is a citizen's right and is not lost merely by reason of joining government service. It held the State could not, consistently with Articles 14 and 21, deny a senior government servant the right to compete for general seats while allowing a junior to avail that right.
  7. On these bases the court concluded that the selection committee's interpretation of sub-clause (2) of rule 3 — to treat an in-service candidate as eligible only for reserved in-service seats and thereby excluding her from general competition — was incorrect and resulted in denial of equality to the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court allowed the writ petition, set aside the admission of the 4th respondent, and directed respondents Nos. 1 to 3 to admit the petitioner into the M.D. course in gynaecology and obstetrics. The order expressly records: "The writ petition is accordingly allowed. No costs. Advocate's fee Rs. 500/-."

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The 4th respondent's admission was set aside and the petitioner was ordered to be admitted to the M.D. (gynaecology & obstetrics) course. The petition was allowed without costs, and an advocate's fee of Rs. 500 was noted.
  • Broader implications: The opinion applies and reiterates the principle (following earlier authority) that reservation for a category (here, in-service candidates) does not by itself bar those beneficiaries from competing for general seats. The opinion does not explicitly state that it establishes a new precedent beyond applying existing authorities; it grounds the decision on constitutional protections (Articles 14 and 21), the purpose of reservation, and prior judicial authority.

    Dr. P. Indira Devi v. Selection Committee Constituted For Selection Of Candidates For P.C Medical Courses In The S.V University For The Year 1985-86 Repre Sented By Its Chairman Director Of Medical Education, Hyderabad And Others .

    (1) The petitioner and the 4th respondent are both medical graduates and applicants for admission into post - graduate m. D. , course of gynaecology and obstetrics. After they passed their m. B. B. S. , examinations at different times both the petitioner and the 4th respondent obtained diplomas in gynaecology and obstetrics. Later both joined government service. While the petitioner joined in the government medical department in may, '83 the 4th respondent joined the same department much later in 1984. While working in the medical department both applied for admission into post - graduate m. D. Course in gynaecology and obstetrics. They sat for common - entrance examination. While the petitioner secured in that examination 158 marks out of a total of 200 marks with 3 marks added for her diploma qualification taking the total to'161', the 4th respondent secured '153' marks in the entrance examination to which they added '3' marks taking the total to '156'. Thus, the total marks the 4th respondent secured are lower to the total marks secured by the petitioner. Yet the selection committee selected the 4th respondent for admission into m. D. , course of gynaecology and obstetrics while rejecting the petitioner to the same course. It may be mentioned that the selection committee considered the case of the petitioner for admission against the 15% of the medical seats reserved for in - service candidates while the case of the 4th respondent for admission was considered against the general seats. This was done by the selection committee on the basis that the petitioner was an in - service candidate within the meaning of g. O. Ms. No. 549 m and h department dt. 6 - 9 - '83 as amended from time to time. sub - clause (2) of rule 3 of the above g. O. Says that 15% of scats in clinical subjects, i. E. , in medicine, surgery, obstetrics and gynatcoloy groups and 30% of seats in non - clinical subjects or in each group are reserved for in - service candidates, the reservation of in - service candidates shall be applicable in each category. The explanation to the said sub - clause says that an in - service candidate is one who has put in a minimum of two years service on duty in the respective service.

    (2) The selection committee interpreted the above sub - clause (2) of rule 3 not only as providing for a reservation of the in - service candidate, but also as denying the right of in - service candidate to be considered for the general seats. As the petitioner has put in a minimum of 2 years of service the selection committee treated the petitioner as an in - service candidate and the 4th respondent was treated by the selection committee as a general candidate because the 4th respondent though in government service had not put - in a minimum of 2 years service.

    (3) The petitioner having been aggrieved by the decision of the selection committee made in favour of the 4th respondent for admission into m. D. Gynaecology and obstetrics has filed this writ petition challenging the action of the selection committee constituted by the government. This court admitted the writ petition on 4th march, '86 and by interim orders had forbidden the 4th respondent from taking admission in the medical college. The argument of the petitioner is that although she is an in - service candidate within the meaning of the above sub - clause (2) of rule 3 of the selection rules, her right to be considered against the general seats cannot be taken away by the reservation provided under the said rule for the in - service candidates. According to the petitioner's case she ought to have been considered against the general seats. If it is so considered, there is no doubt the petitioner - would have been preferred for admission into the m. D. , gynaecology and obstetrics to the 4th respondent. But the contention of the respondent - state and the 4th respondent is that an in - service candidate can be considered for admission into the post - graduate courses only against the seats reserved for the in - service candidates and the case of such a candidate cannot be considered against the general seats.

    (4) Now, the point for consideration is, whether the petitioner has a right to be considered against rthe general seats notwithstanding the fact that she is an in - service candidate, and whether such a right, if any, is lost by reason of her being an in - service candidate.

    (5) The importance of general or professional education to the awakening of human mind cannot be too much emphasised. In a democratic polity where roan's ultimate salvation depends upon his own thought and deed, education that equips and furnishes man's mind with vision and concept becomes an indispensable ingridient of his up - bringing. Barthruhari extolled the virtues of education. One of the most powerful reasons that had operated to retard the growth of our nation is the denial in the past of the fight of the majority to education. To - day when the state expends huge amounts of monies and resources for the spread of education the right of every citizen to receive that education on equal terms becomesprotected by articles 14 and 21 of the constitution. In brown vs. Board of education of topektf chief justice warren writing about the primary education in america observed :

    "today, education is perhaps the most important function of state and local governments. It is required in the performance of our most basis public responsibilities, even service in the armed forces. It is the'very foundation of good citizenship. Today it is a principal instrument in awakening the child to cultural values, in preparing him for later professional training, and in helping him to adjust normally to his environment. Such an opportunity, where the state has undertaken to provide it, is a right which must be made available to all on equal terms."

    In bollingd vs. Sharpe the same learned judge rules that the right to education falls within the protection of due prdcess concept of liberty. A modern nation that fosters mediocracy and promotes inefficiency cannot long survive the international competition. Constitutionally speaking the state should riot be the pation of the less efficient. It follows therefore that in the facts arid "circumstances of this case, where the petitioner has secured higher number of marks the state cannot be allowed to deny her admission to the m. D. , course unless the petitioner is held to be not entitled to compere along with the 4th respondent to the general seats. Normally where there are greater number of applications chasing fewer number. Of seats for any professional educational course run by the state the distribution of such seats among competing candidates must be based upon merit only. First in order of merit should not be the next in order of admission. To - day we worship at the alter of efficiency that sustains our complex industralised social order.

    (6) Now, the petitioner as a citizen has a right to compete to all the medical seats in a state medical college unless some of those seats are reasonably and constitutionally excluded from being competed by the petitioner. The admission to these medical colleges is governed by the scheme enunciated by the government in g. O. Ms. No. 549 mandh department, dated 6 - 9 - 1983 and its subsequent amendments. Under that scheme certain seats are reserved for candidates belonging to the scheduled castes, scheduled tribes, backward castes and in - service candidates. The remaining seats are thrown open for general competition. In the scheme enunciated under the g. O. Ms. No. 549, i find no barrier preventing the petitioner from competing to the general seats. The fact that the petitioner had an advantage under the scheme of reservation made for the in - service candidates would not, in my opinion, take away the right of the petitioner to compete to the general seats. The reservation is intended to withdraw certain number of seats from the general competition so that it would operate as a guarantee to secure a minimum number of seats for those for whose benefit such a reservation has been made. Such a provision for reservation cannot be interpreted as taking away the right of the petitioner to compete to the general seats. One of the earliest judgments of this court reported in raghuramulu,. Vs. The state of a. P. Rules that the reservation should be understood as not taking away the right of the candidate to compete to the general seats. I, therefore, hold that the petitioner has a right to compete for the general seats and that right is not taken away by sub - clause (2) of rule 3, which provided for reservation for the in - service candidates.

    (7) But it is very ably argued by sri khadri, the learned government pleader, that the petitioner's right to compete to the general seats is taken away by the scheme of reservation enunciated in g. O. Ms. No. 549 for the in - service candidates. His argument is that the scheme of reservation provided for the in - service candidates envisages that they should be granted leave after they are selected and that if many in - service candidates are selected through the general quota the running of the service would not only become difficult but the government may not also be in a position to grant them leave for prosecuting their studies. He referred to rule 9 clause (4) , rule 11 clause (9) and rule 19 of the above rules. It is true that these rules contemplate conferment of certain benefits for an in - service candidate both in the matter of his selection against the reserved quota and also in the matter of grant of leave and payment of salary after admission to the post - graduate course. But these rules do not answer the constitutional question, whether state can take away the right of an in - service candidate to improve his professional skills by studying further. I think that right is too precious to be allowed to be scuttled by the state. It would. At be just to reject the claim of an in - service candidate to imprive his professional skills merely on the ground that he is an in - service candidate. The right of an in - service candidate to be considered against the general quota is a right which belongs to the gvernment employee as a citizen and it is not lost merely by reason of his joining government service the exercise of this right by an in - service candidate is not shown to me to produce any serious detrimental effects on the running of the medical department. It is not as if that every in - service candidate is selected in the general quota. By granting absence of leave for purposes of study to those few in - service candidates, who are selected in the general quota, the running of the medical department cannot be expected to be impeded. In any case no such evidenciary facts have been produced before. At all events the artificial definition of an in - service candidate which is now adopted by the government in the above mentioned g. O. , does not prevent the government servants, who have put - in less than two years of service from being selected through the genera! quota. I, therefore, hold that the government cannot deny the right of a senior government servant to prosecute higher studies in order to better his medical skills, while conferring hat right on a junior government servant. The government cannot consistently with its obligation under articles 14 and 21 of the constitution take away the right of an in - service candidate to compete for the general seats. The right to pursue ones own happiness is inalienable and undeniable and the government cannot add extraordinary burdens or place extraordinary hurdles on that pursuit. Furthering ones own professional qualifications while being in government service is not an extraordinary nor an unusual thing. I am, therefore, of the view that the right of the petitioner to compete for the general seat is not taken away by the fact that she is an in - service candidate. Accordingly, i hold that the selection committee illegally denied the petitioner's right to equality.

    (8) I accordingly set aside the admission made of the 4th respondent and direct respondents nos. 1 to 3 to admit the petitioner into m. D. , gynaecology and obstetries. The writ petition is accordingly allowed. No costs. Advocate's fee rs. 500/ -.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dr. P. Indira Devi v. Selection Committee ...
    (Apr 9, 1986)