Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2007 INSC 822
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2007 INSC 822
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Food Corporation of India (FCI) introduced a Voluntary Retirement Scheme (VRS) on 29-6-2002. The respondent, an FCI employee, applied for voluntary retirement on 13-9-2004. He withdrew that application on 27-9-2004, i.e., before any decision was taken by FCI. Nevertheless, FCI accepted the retirement on 9-11-2004.

The respondent challenged the acceptance order before the Punjab and Haryana High Court, which quashed the retirement relying on its earlier judgment in Gurcharan Singh v. FCI. FCI appealed to the Supreme Court. Three appeals raising the same legal question were heard together and disposed of by this common order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Clause VIII(d) of FCI’s VRS, an employee who has applied for voluntary retirement can withdraw that offer before it is accepted by the Corporation.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Food Corporation of India)

  • Clause VIII(d) explicitly states that once an employee submits a VRS application, it is “final” and cannot be withdrawn.
  • Relied on the three-Judge Bench decision in Bank of India v. O.P. Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721 to argue that an employee is barred from revoking the VRS request after submission.

Respondent (Employee)

  • Cited State Bank of Patiala v. Romesh Chander Kanoji (2004) 2 SCC 651, another three-Judge Bench ruling, to contend that even where the scheme forbids withdrawal, the employee may still revoke the offer before the employer accepts it.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gurcharan Singh v. FCI (Punjab & Haryana High Court) An employee’s VRS offer cannot be enforced if withdrawn before acceptance. Relied upon by the High Court; Supreme Court found its reasoning consistent with later Supreme Court jurisprudence.
Bank of India v. O.P. Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721 Distinguished between schemes that allow limited withdrawal and those that do not; in schemes expressly allowing withdrawal for a fixed period, revocation must occur within that period. FCI invoked this case, but the Court distinguished it because the scheme discussed there differed from the FCI scheme and was clarified in a later case.
State Bank of Patiala v. Romesh Chander Kanoji (2004) 2 SCC 651 Even when a VRS prohibits withdrawal, the employee may withdraw the offer any time before acceptance. Treated as the governing authority; applied to hold that the respondent’s withdrawal, made prior to acceptance, was effective.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court compared the two leading precedents cited. In O.P. Swarnakar, the State Bank of India’s scheme expressly allowed withdrawal within 15 days, making the offer irrevocable thereafter. Conversely, other nationalised-bank schemes, and by analogy the FCI scheme, merely stated that withdrawal was “not open” but gave the management up to three months to decide. The later decision in Romesh Chander Kanoji clarified that, for such schemes, an employee retains the right to withdraw the offer until the employer’s acceptance is communicated.

Applying this clarification, the Court found Clause VIII(d) did not render the respondent’s revocation ineffective because FCI had not yet accepted the offer. Acceptance occurred on 9-11-2004, well after the withdrawal on 27-9-2004 and still within the three-month decision window. Therefore, the employee’s revocation was valid, and FCI could not act upon the original offer.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS DISMISSED. The Supreme Court upheld the High Court’s decision quashing FCI’s acceptance of the respondent’s voluntary-retirement offer.

Implications: The ruling confirms that, under schemes similar to FCI’s, an employee may withdraw a voluntary-retirement application any time before the employer formally accepts it, despite clauses purporting to bar withdrawal. The decision maintains consistency with existing Supreme Court precedent but does not announce a new legal principle beyond applying Romesh Chander Kanoji.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Food Corporation Of India And Others v. Ramesh Kumar .

    Order

    1. Heard learned counsel for the parties in all these appeals. All the three cases involve similar question of law, therefore, we dispose them of by the common order. The facts given in the case of CA No. 1611 of 2006 are taken into consideration.

    2. The respondent, an employee of Food Corporation of India applied on 13-9-2006 for voluntary retirement in pursuance of the scheme of voluntary retirement floated by them on 29-6-2002. He revoked his offer and had withdrawn the same on 27-9-2004 but despite withdrawal, his offer for voluntary retirement was accepted on 9-11-2004. This order of retirement dated 9-11-2004 was challenged by the respondent by filing a writ petition before the Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court. The Division Bench relying upon the earlier judgment given under Gurcharan Singh v. FCI allowed the respondent's request and quashed the order dated 9-11-2004. Hence the present appeal by Food Corporation of India.

    3. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. The short question before us is when the applicant has made the application for withdrawal before it could be accepted, can Food Corporation of India still enforce the offer of voluntary retirement upon the incumbent. The learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that as per Clause VIII(d) of the terms of the scheme which clearly stipulates that the incumbent once makes a request for voluntary retirement, he will be prevented from withdrawing the same that means that once he has given offer for voluntary retirement and when the withdrawal is totally prevented he has no right to withdraw his offer. For better appreciation of Clause VIII(d), it reads as under:

    “Once an employee submits his application for voluntary retirement under this scheme to the competent authority, it shall be treated as final and it is not open to the employee to withdraw the same. The competent authority within notice period (3 months) shall take a decision to accept or reject the request and shall communicate the same to the official concerned.”

    4. Learned counsel submitted that in view of this once the respondent has given an offer for voluntary retirement on 13-9-2004, he cannot revoke the same on 27-9-2004 and in that support learned counsel invited our attention to the decision of this Court in Bank of India v. O.P Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721. As against this learned counsel for respondent invited our attention to the decision in State Bank of Patiala v. Romesh Chander Kanoji (2004) 2 SCC 651. Both these decisions are of three-Judge Bench and in the earlier decision given in O.P Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721 Hon'ble Justice Sinha was a party and he was also a party in the subsequent decision in State Bank of Patiala v. Romesh Chander Kanoji (2004) 2 SCC 651.

    5. We have gone through both the decisions cited by the learned counsel for the parties. In O.P Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721 two schemes were taken into consideration, namely, one of State Bank of India Scheme (for short “SBIVRS”) and the other of nationalised banks. There was a stipulation in SBIVRS that the person who offers for voluntary retirement can only revoke the same within 15 days, whereas in other bank's scheme the provision was different, and is identical to the one in the case before us.

    6. In O.P Swarnakar (2003) 2 SCC 721 a distinction was made between the two schemes. So far as the scheme of State Bank of India i.e SBIVRS is concerned there the condition of 15 days was mentioned i.e that incumbent can revoke the offer within 15 days. If the person fails to do so the offer is complete. But so far as other cases of other banks are concerned it is stipulated only that once the incumbent gives an offer of voluntary retirement he will not be permitted to revoke it. Therefore, there was a distinction between the schemes which has been properly explained by the subsequent decision in para 6 in State Bank of Patiala v. Romesh Chander Kanoji (2004) 2 SCC 651 as follows:

    “6. It is evident from above that in the case of SBIVRS, where there is a specific provision for withdrawal, the employee must exercise his option within the time specified; and in case of nationalised banks where there was no provision to withdraw (and in fact the Scheme forbade withdrawal), the withdrawal must be effected prior to acceptance by the Bank. Therefore, in terms of the ratio laid down by this Court, the employee is ensured under SBIVRS the right of withdrawal within the specified period.”

    7. Therefore, now the position stands settled that in case of a VRS Scheme of State Bank of India where 15 days' time-limit for revocation has been laid down in case the incumbent withdraws his offer within 15 days then the offer given by the incumbent cannot be treated against him and it will be deemed that he has revoked his offer. In case of other banks there is a condition that once the offer has been given it shall not be permitted to be revoked but in view of the above decision the incumbent can still withdraw the offer if it has not been accepted by the management.

    8. Now adverting to the present Scheme of Food Corporation, Para 8 clearly stipulates that the incumbent has no right to revoke the same and the Management will decide the same within three months. That means the Management still has three months' time to consider and decide whether to act upon the offer given by the incumbent or not. But if the incumbent revokes his offer before the Corporation accepts it then in that case, the revocation of the offer is complete and the Corporation cannot act upon that offer. In the present case there is one more additional factor which is that the Management has to take a decision within three months. Therefore, once the revocation is made by the incumbent before three months then in that case the Corporation cannot act upon the offer of voluntary retirement unless it is accepted prior to its withdrawal. In the present case, it is clear that the incumbent had given an offer for voluntary retirement on 13-9-2004 and he revoked his offer on 27-9-2004 but the same was accepted on 9-11-2004 i.e after the revocation of his offer. In view of the law laid down by this Court in State Bank of Patiala (2004) 2 SCC 651 the incumbent has already revoked his offer before it could be accepted. Therefore, in this view of the matter, the approach of the High Court appears to be correct and does not require any interference. The revocation made by the incumbent on 27-9-2004 of his offer of retirement cannot be acted upon as he has revoked it before the Corporation could act upon it. Hence, we are of the opinion, that the view taken by the High Court is correct. Consequently, all the three appeals are dismissed but without any order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Food Corporation Of India And Others v. Ramesh Kumar .
    (Aug 8, 2007)