Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 13-A of the Rent Restriction Act (III), 1949 (hereinafter referred to as, the Act).
  • 2002, Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • rules of procedure of Civil Procedure Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 13-A of the Rent Restriction Act (III), 1949 (hereinafter referred to as, the Act).
  • 2002, Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • rules of procedure of Civil Procedure Code
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Gurnam Singh, the petitioner-landlord, filed an ejectment application under Section 13-A of the Rent Restriction Act, 1949, seeking possession of a shop let out by his deceased father, Piara Singh. The tenant had been paying rent to Gurnam Singh after Piara Singh's death. The ejectment was sought on the ground of bona fide personal use to establish a hospital and laboratory for the petitioner’s unemployed son, Dr. Amrinderpal Singh. However, since Section 13-A does not apply to commercial properties, the petitioner sought to amend the application to proceed under Section 13 of the Act. The Rent Controller refused the amendment application, leading to this revision petition challenging that refusal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Rent Controller erred in refusing the petitioner’s application to amend the ejectment petition from Section 13-A to Section 13 of the Rent Restriction Act, 1949.
  2. Whether the provisions of Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 2002, restricting amendments after trial commencement, apply to proceedings before the Rent Controller under the Rent Act.
  3. Whether allowing the amendment at a late stage, after evidence closure, would amount to a de novo trial and cause injustice to the tenant.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner initially filed under Section 13-A but sought amendment to Section 13 due to the inapplicability of Section 13-A to commercial properties.
  • The amendment was necessary to overcome the tenant’s objection regarding maintainability and to avoid hypertechnicalities.
  • The law of amendment is liberal and aims to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and reduce litigation.
  • Evidence had been led to establish bona fide personal use, so no prejudice would be caused to the tenant by allowing the amendment.
  • Relied on the precedent of Rulia Ram Sharma v. Amar Pal Singh Bhalla to support entitlement as a specified landlord.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The tenant objected to maintainability of the ejectment application under Section 13-A as it does not apply to commercial property.
  • Raised preliminary objections including maintainability, estoppel, and res judicata against the amendment application.
  • Contended that the landlord remained silent for over two years and only filed the amendment application at the final stage, after evidence was closed.
  • Argued that allowing amendment after trial commencement violates the proviso added in 2002 to Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • Claimed that amendment at this stage would amount to a de novo trial causing prejudice.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pirgonda Hongonda Patil v. Kalgonda Shidgonda Patithin, ALR 1957 SUPREME COURT 363 Amendments should be allowed if they do not cause injustice and are necessary to determine real questions in controversy. The Court applied this principle to hold that amendment should be allowed unless it causes irreparable injury to the other party.
Croper v. Smith, 1884 (29) Ch D 700 Courts exist to decide rights, not to punish mistakes; amendments should be allowed if no injustice is caused. Supported the view that correction of pleadings is a right if it helps decide the real controversy without injustice.
Rulia Ram Sharma v. Amar Pal Singh Bhalla and others, 1991 (1) RCR (Rent) 280 (P&H) Entitlement of specified landlord who has stepped into the shoes of predecessor landlord. Distinguished by Rent Controller since petitioner was a specified landlord unlike in Rulia Ram case, supporting amendment.
Brij Lal v. Yash Pal, 1985 (1) RCR (Rent) 551 (P&H) Rent Controller proceedings are not bound by Civil Procedure Code procedural rules. Supported the Court’s view that Order 6 Rule 17 CPC restrictions do not ipso facto apply to Rent Controller proceedings.
Lal Chand and others v. Kishan Murari Goel and others, 1995 (1) RCR 274 Same as above regarding procedural flexibility in Rent Act proceedings. Reinforced the principle that Rent Controllers can devise their own procedure for just adjudication.
Harcharan Singh v. Ashok Kumar, 2003 (1) RCR (Rent) 696 Rent Controller is an officer persona designata, not a court; CPC does not fully apply. Used to justify procedural flexibility and allowance of amendment despite trial having commenced.
Inderjit Pal v. Shankar, 1985 (1) Rent Control Reporter 508 Rent Controller’s quasi-judicial nature and limited applicability of CPC. Supported the approach that Rent Controllers are not bound by CPC procedural rigour.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by recognizing that the petitioner-landlord initially filed under Section 13-A, which does not apply to commercial properties, necessitating amendment to Section 13. The tenant’s objection on maintainability was acknowledged. The Court noted that although Order 6 Rule 17 CPC restricts amendments after trial commencement, this procedural rule does not automatically bind Rent Controller proceedings under the Rent Act. The Rent Controller is an officer persona designata with procedural flexibility to ensure just adjudication.

The Court relied on established precedents emphasizing that amendments should be allowed to prevent injustice and to decide real controversies, provided the other party is not unfairly prejudiced. It distinguished the petitioner’s case from Rulia Ram Sharma, affirming petitioner’s status as a specified landlord. The Court observed that the petitioner had led evidence supporting bona fide personal use, and no prejudice would arise to the tenant by allowing amendment. To balance equities, the Court imposed a cost on the petitioner for the delay and error in the initial filing.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is allowed. The impugned order refusing amendment is set aside, and the petitioner is permitted to amend the ejectment petition to proceed under Section 13 of the Rent Restriction Act, 1949. The amended petition is allowed to be taken on record.

To compensate the tenant for the delay and inconvenience caused by the petitioner’s initial mistake, a cost of Rs. 10,000/- is imposed in favor of the tenant. Upon deposit of the cost, the tenant will have the opportunity to file a reply and lead evidence regarding the amended petition.

This decision directly affects the parties by allowing the amendment and continuing the ejectment proceedings under the correct legal provision. No new precedent is established beyond reaffirming the procedural flexibility of Rent Controllers and the principles governing amendments in such proceedings.

    Gurnam Singh Petitioner v. Roshan Lal

    Kanwaljit Singh Ahluwalia, J. — Gurnam Singh petitioner has filed the present revision petition with a prayer that impugned order dated 05.02.2008 passed by the Rent Controller, Baba Bakala, Amritsar, whereby the application to amend the ejectment application has been refused, be set aside and amendment as prayed for be allowed.

    2. Gurnam Singh petitioner-landlord instituted an application for ejectment of tenant under Section 13-A of the Rent Restriction Act (III), 1949 (hereinafter referred to as, ‘the Act’). The demised premises was a shop. The shop was let out by Piara Singh, father of the petitioner. After the death of Piara Singh, tenant has been paying the rent to the petitioner. Therefore, petitioner had stepped into the shoes of his father, Piara Singh, as landlord.

    3. Petitioner retired as Chief Engineer, Public Health from the State of Punjab on 31st March, 2004. Application seeking ejectment of the tenant was filed on the ground that premises are required for the bonafide personal use and occupation, for establishing hospital and laboratory for his unemployed son Dr. Amrinderpal Singh, who after having passed his M.B.B.S degree, has further obtained a diploma in Radio Diagnostics.

    4. Admittedly, the ejectment application was filed under Section 13-A of the Act and Section 13-A is not applicable to commercial buildings. Therefore, another application was filed seeking amendment in the petition, with a prayer that petition be tried under Section 13 of the Act instead of Section 13-A of the Act. It was stated in the application that since an objection has been raised by the tenant that Section 13-A of the Act is not applicable to the commercial buildings and the petition is not legally maintainable, therefore, to overcome this objection, amendment has been sought. It was further prayed that the hypertechnicalities should not stand in the way and law of amendment being very liberal with an object to avoid multiplicity of proceedings, in order to reduce litigation, prayer of amendment be granted.

    5. A perusal of the impugned order shows that reply to the application for amendment was filed by the tenant before the Rent Controller, in which preliminary objection regarding maintainability, estoppel, resjudicata were raised. It was stated therein that an objection was raised in the written statement that ejectment application under Section 13-A of the Act is not maintainable, as Section 13-A is not attracted in case of commercial property. It was stated that landlord remained silent for more than two years and when case has reached at the final stage, an application has been filed.

    6. The Rent Controller declined the application for amendment and vide impugned order held that Gurnam Singh landlord had filed the application under Section 13-A of the Act from the demised premises, which is a shop and application was filed by the respondent-tenant seeking permission to contest the petition. While allowing the application to contest, it was observed by the Rent Controller that specified landlord is entitled to the possession of residential or scheduled building for his own occupation. It is stated that after the passing of the order granting permission to contest on 20th September, 2005, tenant filed written statement, in which an objection was taken that ejectment application under Section 13-A of the Act is not maintainable.

    7. Issues were framed on 8th November, 2005. Landlord closed his evidence on 13th March, 2007. Thereafter, tenant closed his evidence on 18th September, 2007, except for tendering of documents. The documents were tendered on 6th November, 2007. Then case was fixed for rebuttal and arguments and the application for amendment was filed on 15th January, 2008. Counsel for the respondent has stated that since evidence of the parties has been concluded, by allowing the amendment, it will amount to de-novo trial. It has been further urged that in the present case, trial has commenced.

    8. A perusal of the impugned order further reveals that during course of arguments, petitioner-landlord has placed reliance upon “Rulia Ram Sharma v. Amar Pal Singh Bhalla and others”, 1991 (1) RCR (Rent) 280 (P&H).

    9. The Rent Controller distinguished the judgment of Rulia Ram (supra) on the ground that as in the case of Rulia Ram, he was not held to be specified landlord as he had retired from service when he was not owner of the demised premises.

    10. Counsel appearing for the respondent has laid much emphasis on the fact that in 2002, Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure has been amended and a proviso has been added that no application for amendment shall be allowed after the trial has commenced, unless court comes to the conclusion that inspite of due diligence the party could not have raised the matter before the commencement of the trial.

    11. There is no doubt in the contention made by the counsel for the respondent. But it has been held in various judgments that technical rules of procedure of Civil Procedure Code are not applicable to proceedings under the Rent Act and Rent Controller can device his own procedure for the just adjudication of the case. It has been further held that in rent proceedings, Rent Controller, to find out the truth, can device appropriate procedure. Rent Controller cannot be held bound by the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure. Therefore, provisions of Code of Civil Procedure would not apply ipso-facto on the Rent Controller. Reference can be made to Brij Lal v. Yash Pal, 1985 (1) RCR (Rent) 551 (P&H), Lal Chand and others v. Kishan Murari Goel and others, 1995 (1) RCR 274 (Harcharan Singh…Petitioner v. Ashok Kumar…, 2003 (1) RCR (Rent) 696. It is now well settled that Rent Controller is not a Court. He is an officer persona designata, specially authorized to adjudicate upon disputes relating to urban property concerning ejectment and determination of fair rent of urban properties. Reference can be made to Inderjit Pal v. Shankar, 1985 (1) Rent Control Reporter 508. Therefore, the Court of Controller is not, for all practicable purposes, a Court, nor the Code of Civil Procedure in entirety applies with all vigour and strength.

    12. It was held in “Pirgonda Hongonda Patil v. Kalgonda Shidgonda Patithin”, ALR 1957 SUPREME COURT 363, as under :

    “All amendments ought to be allowed which satisfy the two Conditions (a) of not working injustice to the other side, and (b) of being necessary for the purpose of determining the real questions in controversy between the parties…. but I refrain from citing further authorities, as, in my opinion, they all lay down precisely the same doctrine. That doctrine, as I understand it, is that amendment should be refused only where the other party cannot be placed in the same position as if the pleading had been originally correct, but the amendment would cause him an injury which could not be compensated in costs. It is merely a particular case of this general rule that where a plaintiff seeks to amend by setting up afresh claim in respect of a cause of action which since the institution of the suit had become barred by limitation, the amendment must be refused; to allow it would be to cause the defendant an injury which could not be compensated in costs by depriving him of a good defence to the claim. The ultimate test therefore still remains the same can the amendment be allowed without injustice to the other side, or can it not?”

    In “Croper v. Smith ”, 1884 (29) Ch D 700, it was stated by Bowen, L.J as under :

    “I think it is a well-established principle that the object of courts is to decide the rights of the parties and not to punish them for mistakes they make in the conduct of their cases by deciding otherwise than in accordance with their rights… I know of no kind of error or mistake which if not fraudulent or intended to overreach, the Court ought not to correct, if it can be done without injustice to the other party. Courts do not exist of the sake of discipline, but for the sake of deciding matters in controversy, and I do not regard such amendment as a matter of favour or grace. It seems to me that as soon as it appears that the way in which a party has framed his case will not lead to a decision of the real matter in controversy; it is as much a matter of right on his part to have it corrected, if it can be done without injustice as anything else in the case is a matter of right.”

    13. Guided by these parameters, the prayer of the petitioner to amend the petition can be allowed.

    14. The courts have further held that there is one panacea, which heals every sour in litigation and that is cost. Admittedly, in the present case, there was a mistake and error on the part of the landlord. For correction of this mistake, landlord can be burdened with the cost. Since from the very beginning, it has been the case of the landlord that the shop in question is required for personal necessity to settle his son, for establishing his hospital and laboratory and he has led evidence on this score, no prejudice therefore, will be caused to the tenant.

    Accordingly, the present revision petition is accepted, impugned order is set aside and application filed by the landlord for the amendment is allowed. He is permitted to amend the petition and amended petition (Annexure P-3) is allowed to be taken on record. However, since due to the mistake and error on the part of the landlord, tenants have suffered, to balance the equities, a cost of Rs. 10,000/- is awarded in favour of the tenant. On deposit of the cost, the same shall be disbursed to the tenant. Tenant will have adequate opportunity to file reply to the amended petition and to lead evidence in support of the pleadings made in the written statement to be filed to the amended petition.

    Accordingly, the present revision petition is allowed in above terms.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gurnam Singh Petitioner v. Roshan Lal
    (Nov 11, 2008)