Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 13(1) and (2) of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973
  • Section 13 of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973 (for short 'the Act')
  • Section 13(2)(1) of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949 (the provisions
  • provisions of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973),
  • SECTION 114 TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • Clause 1 of Sub-section 2 of the Section 13
  • Clause (i) of Sub-section (2) of Section 113
  • Section 114 of T.P. Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of Section 13(1) and (2) of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973
  • Section 13 of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973 (for short 'the Act')
  • Section 13(2)(1) of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949 (the provisions
  • provisions of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973),
  • SECTION 114 TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • Clause 1 of Sub-section 2 of the Section 13
  • Clause (i) of Sub-section (2) of Section 113
  • Section 114 of T.P. Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner (tenant) challenges two orders: the Rent Controller's order dated 26.4.2003 and the Appellate Authority's order dated 5.6.2003, by which an order of ejectment was made against the petitioner for failure to tender assessed provisional rent, interest and costs.

The respondent (landlord) sought ejectment inter alia for non-payment of rent for the period 1.1.2002 to 31.7.2002 and on the ground that the premises were required for bona fide personal use. On 13.11.2002 the learned Rent Controller provisionally assessed arrears at Rs. 35,000 (Rs. 5,000 per month), interest Rs. 935 and costs Rs. 875, and directed that payment facts would be considered at final disposal.

The Rent Controller adjourned for arguments on the tenant's application for leave to defend and for payment of arrears. The tenant tendered Rs. 15,725 on 28.11.2002 as arrears for 1.6.2002 to 30.11.2002 at Rs. 2,400 per month, plus Rs. 450 interest and Rs. 875 costs, stating that rent for some months was paid by cheques and June 2002 was paid in cash and deposited under protest with a right of counterclaim.

On 22.4.2003 the tenant applied to recall the provisional assessment order of 13.11.2002, contending that assessment was made without enquiry, recorded evidence or even filing of a written statement. The Rent Controller on 26.4.2003 held that because the assessed amount had not been paid within the prescribed time, the petitioner was liable to be ejected. A separate order of 26.4.2003 dismissed the tenant's objection to clubbing petitions under Section 13 and Section 13-A of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973; the landlord withdrew the Section 13-A petition on 22.4.2003 and eviction followed on 26.4.2003 for non-payment of provisional rent.

The petitioner appealed against the eviction order; the appeal was dismissed on the ground that ejectment must follow failure to comply with provisional assessment. The petitioner then filed the present revision petition, which is the subject of this opinion.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an order of ejectment can follow solely for non-payment of rent provisionally assessed by the Rent Controller, even where the tenant has not yet been given an opportunity to file a written statement or to lead evidence on the question of arrears (i.e., whether failure to deposit provisional rent entails immediate eviction without further opportunity to the tenant).
  2. Whether the orders dated 26.4.2003 (Rent Controller) and 5.6.2003 (Appellate Authority) are legally sustainable where ejectment was ordered before allowing the tenant to contest the petition on the merits.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Tenant's) Arguments

  • The tenant tendered payments on 28.11.2002 (Rs. 15,725, plus interest and costs) and asserted that rent for the months in question had been paid, mostly by cheques at Rs. 2,400 per month, and that June 2002 was paid in cash; the June payment was deposited under protest with a right of counterclaim.
  • The tenant applied on 22.4.2003 to recall the provisional assessment order dated 13.11.2002 on the ground that the Rent Controller assessed rent without enquiry, without recording evidence and even before permitting filing of a written statement.
  • The tenant objected to clubbing petitions under Section 13 and 13-A of the Act (this objection was dismissed by the Rent Controller in a separate order).

Respondent's (Landlord's) Arguments

  • The respondent relied upon Conclusion No. 4 of the Supreme Court judgment in Rakesh Wadhawan v. Jagdamba Industrial Corporation to contend that if the tenant fails to comply with an order of assessment of rent, "nothing remains to be done" and an order of eviction shall follow.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rakesh Wadhawan v. Jagdamba Industrial Corporation (Hon'ble Supreme Court) Interpretation of provisional/interim assessment by Rent Controller: (a) a Controller may pass a provisional assessment of arrears, interest and costs which the tenant should tender on the first date of hearing; (b) such provisional order is subject to final adjudication after enquiry; (c) consequences where deposit equals, is less than, or exceeds final amount; and (d) principle that tenants should be protected from being compelled to succumb to inflated claims without opportunity. The Court held that the lower authorities misapplied the judgment when treating Conclusion No. 4 in isolation. The present court interpreted the Supreme Court's conclusions (4, 5 and 6) harmoniously to mean that failure to deposit provisional rent does not automatically entitle immediate eviction without giving the tenant reasonable opportunity to contest and lead evidence; eviction may follow only after final adjudication or after giving opportunity to make up any deficiency where final adjudication finds a lesser amount.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the record and found the Rent Controller's order of eviction (26.4.2003) and the Appellate Authority's affirmance (5.6.2003) to suffer from patent illegality and irregularity because they were made before the tenant was permitted to file a written statement or to lead evidence.

The court analyzed the Supreme Court's decision in Rakesh Wadhawan and extracted its central teachings: the provisional assessment made by a Controller is a prima facie, interim assessment based on pleadings and such material available at that stage; it should give way to final adjudication after enquiry if there is a dispute. The Supreme Court recognized three possible outcomes at final adjudication (provisional = final, provisional > final, provisional < final) and prescribed different consequences for each.

The court emphasized that reading Conclusion No. 4 (which states that on failure of the tenant to comply "nothing remains to be done and an order for eviction shall follow") in isolation would undermine the requirement in Section 13(2) of the Haryana Act that the Controller must give the tenant a reasonable opportunity of showing cause against an application for eviction. The opinion reasoned that the Supreme Court intended to afford tenants protection from unscrupulous or exaggerated landlord claims and did not intend that an interim or provisional order should operate as an automatic final order leading to eviction without further opportunity to contest.

By harmoniously construing Conclusion Nos. 4, 5 and 6 of the Supreme Court judgment together with Section 13(2) of the Haryana Act, the court concluded:

  • A failure to deposit provisional rent, by itself, will not automatically result in an eviction order.
  • An eviction order may only be passed after the conclusion of the trial and after giving the tenant the opportunities to file a written statement and to lead evidence as required under Section 13(2) of the Act.
  • If the final adjudication upholds the provisional assessment, the tenant who failed to deposit remains disentitled to further opportunity; if the final adjudication determines a lesser amount, the tenant must be afforded an opportunity to make up the deficiency; if the deposit was in excess, the excess must be refunded.

Applying these principles to the facts, the court found that the eviction in the present case was ordered prematurely — before written statement and evidence — and therefore could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The Civil Revision is allowed. The impugned orders of ejectment dated 26.4.2003 (Rent Controller) and 5.6.2003 (Appellate Authority) are set aside, and the matter is remanded to the learned Rent Controller for decision on merits after providing the tenant opportunities to file a reply and to lead evidence on issues arising out of the pleadings.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: the eviction orders are quashed; the eviction cannot be executed on the basis of the provisional assessment without a trial on the merits and without giving the tenant reasonable opportunity to contest and lead evidence. The Rent Controller must reopen/decide the petition on merits after permitting the tenant to file reply and adduce evidence.
  • No broader binding principle beyond the court's interpretation of the Supreme Court's decision was announced; the court applied and harmonised existing Supreme Court principles to the facts of this case rather than laying down a novel rule.

    Rajinder Lal v. Gopal Krishan

    1. The challenge in the present revision petition is to the order dated 5.6.2003, passed by the learned Appellate Authority and the order dated 26.4.2003 passed by the learned Rent Controller, whereby an order of ejectment was passed against the petitioner on account of failure to tender assessed provisional rent, interest and costs.

    2. The respondent sought the ejectment of the petitioner, inter alia on the ground of non-payment of rent for the period 1.1.2002 to 31.7.2002 and also that the premises in question are required for bona fide personal use. On 13.11.2002, the learned Rent Controller has assessed provisional rent at Rs. 35OOO/- (Rs. 5000/- p.m.), costs Rs. 875/- and interest Rs. 935/-. It was also ordered that the fact of payment of rent as stated in para No. 3 will be seen at the final disposal of the case.

    3. The learned Rent Controller adjourned the case for arguments on the application for leave to defend and also for payment of arrears of rent. The tenant tendered a sum of Rs. 15,725/- on 28.11.2002 as arrears of rent for the period 1.6.2002 to 30.11.2002 @ Rs. 2400/- per month and an amount of Rs. 450/- interest and Rs. 875/- as costs. The learned Rent Controller noticed the stand of the tenant that he has paid rent for the months in question except June, vide cheques @ Rs. 2400/- P.M. The tenant made tender and further give a statement that rent for the month of June, 2002, was paid in cash and he is depositing the said rent under protest with right of counter claim in this petition.

    4. On 22.4.2003, tenant filed an application for recall of the order dated 13.11.2002, inter alia, on the ground that the learned trial Court has assessed the rent without making any enquiry in question nor evidence was recorded and even without filing of the written statement. The learned Rent Controller vide order dated 26.4.2003 found that since the amount assessed has not been paid within the time prescribed, therefore, the petitioner is liable to be ejected from the demised premises. It may be noticed that vide separate order on 26.4.2003, the learned Rent Controller dismissed another application filed by the petitioner, wherein an objection was raised that the petition under Section 13 of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973 (for short 'the Act') for eviction on the ground of non-payment of arrears of rent and the petition under Section 13-A of the Act to seek eviction for the bona fide personal requirement, cannot be clubbed. The landlord suffered a statement on 22.4.2003 withdrawing the petition under Section 13-A of the Act seeking ejectment was the arrears of rent, the order of eviction was passed on 26.4.2003 as the petitioner has not paid assessed provisional rent.

    5. Aggrieved against the order of eviction on account of non-payment of provisional arrears of rent within 15 days, the petitioner filed an appeal but the same was dismissed as it was held that the ejectment order has necessarily to follow on the failure of the tenant to comply with the order of provisional assessment of arrears of rent, interest and costs. Still, aggrieved, the petitioner is in revision petition.

    6. After going through the record of the case, I am of the opinion that the order passed by the learned Rent Controller and the order in appeal suffer from patent illegality and irregularity causing manifest injustice to the petitioner. The findings recorded are not based upon correct appreciation of the ruling of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rakesh Wadhawan v. Jagdamba Industrial Corporation .

    7. An order of ejectment has been passed against the petitioner even before a written statement was permitted to be taken on record and without recording any evidence. In my view, the order of ejectment passed simply on account of failure to deposit arrears of rent, interest and costs within time prescribed, is complete negation of justice. In the present case, the landlord has filed petition under Sections 13 and 13-A of the Act. The tenant has moved an application for grant of leave to contest the petition but even before such application could be taken up for hearing, the order of ejectment has been passed, even as the petition for bona fide requirement was withdrawn.

    8. The issue involved in the present revision petition is whether on account of nonpayment of provisional rent assessed, in terms of an order assessing such rent, interest and costs, within the time prescribed, the ejectment has to follow, even without giving any opportunity to the tenant to lead evidence in support of his plea in respect of the rent due.

    9. Learned Counsel for the respondent has relied upon conclusion No. (4) of the aforesaid judgment to contend that if the tenant fails to comply with the order of assessment of rent, nothing remains to be done and an order of eviction shall follow. After going through the judgment in detail, I am of the opinion that the inference sought to be raised by the learned Counsel for the respondent is not the one which can be arrived at from the reading of the entire judgment and reading the other conclusions along with conclusion No. 4.

    10. In the aforesaid judgment, the question examined by the Hon'bie Supreme Court was as "what is the amount which the tenant should tender and what is the course to be followed if there be any genuine dispute between the amount claimed and alleged to be due by the landlord and the amount which the tenant admits and alleged to be due." The Court found that some State legislations provide for an interim or provisional order being passed by the court or the Rent Controller resolving the dispute "momentarily" by a judicial order with which order the tenant should comply and failing which the tenant may suffer adverse consequences. The Court was conscious of the fact that a landlord may claim arrears at a highly inflated rate of rent or may claim rent alleging it to be arrears though the same had already stood paid and for which the landlord chose not to issue receipts for payment, or there may be a bona fide dispute as to the rate at which the rent was paid or is payable. The court found that the manner in which Section 13(2)(1) of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949 (the provisions of which are parimateria with the provisions of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973), have been interpreted in some of the decisions of the Court, if allowed to prevail, the consequence would be that the tenant shall have to succumb to the pressure of the landlord by conceding and making the payment or tender as dictated by the landlord along with interest and costs, else he inescapably suffers the risk of eviction. The Court observed to the following effect:-

    Yet the manner in which section 13(2)(i) with the proviso has been interpreted by the Punjab High Court, if allowed to prevail, the consequence would be that the tenants shall have to succumb to the pressure of the landlord by conceding and making the payment or tender as dictated by the landlord along with interest and costs; else he inescapably suffers the risk of eviction. If he raises a dispute in defence even if bona fide, and howsoever believed to be true, he must suffer eviction if on trial for any reason including any fortuitous circumstances, he fails in substantiating his plea though he very much believed, and genuinely, that he would be able to do so. A tenant forcefully raising a plea in his defence stands to lose and suffer for his failure to substantiate his defence. On the contrary, if the landlord has made a false or exaggerated claim, submitted to by the tenant by making a deposit with interest and costs, and the landlord fails in substantiating his claim of arrears, he does not stand to lose anything. Thus, there are no holds barred for the landlord while the tenant is subject to strict discipline. This could not have been the intendment of an enactment which as its Preamble speaks, is meant to restrict the eviction of tenants from urban premises.

    11. The said question was sought to be resolved by two means. Firstly, by placing meaningful interpretation as would enable the legislative intention being effected and secondly by devising such procedure without altering the structure as would enable the substantial law being meaningfully implemented. After considering various judgments and the provisions of Section 114 of the Transfer of Property Act, the Court came to the following conclusion:-

    The question which stares us is: whether in enacting section 13(2)(i) and proviso thereto can we assume that the Legislature intended to place the tenants in a situation worse than that is would have been under the principles deducible from Section 114 of T.P. Act and even if this provision would not have been there? We cannot attribute such misplaced wisdom to the Legislature without being uncharitable to it. We are definitely of the opinion that by engrafting section 13(2)(i) and proviso in the body of the Act the Legislature intended to confer on the tenants a protection, larger and more beneficial than what it would have been if the provision was not enacted.

    12. The Court held that proviso to Clause 1 of Sub-section 2 of the Section 13 must be read as obliging the Controller to assess by means of passing an order, the arrears of rent, interest and cost of litigation, which the tenant shall pay and tender on the first date of hearing of the main petition following the date of such assessment by the Controller, Such order is based on an opinion formed prima facie by perusal of the pleadings and such order "shall have to give way" to a final order to be made on further enquiry to be held later in the event of there being dispute between the parties calling for such determination. The Court opined to the following effect:-

    What follows from the above said discussion is that the proviso to Clause (i) of Sub-section (2) of Section 113 must be read as obliging the Controller to assess, by means of passing an order, the arrears of rent, the interest and the cost of the litigation - all the three which the tenant shall pay or tender on the first date hearing of the main petition following the date of such assessment by Controller. Such order based on an opinion formed prima facie by perusal of the pleadings and such other material as may be available before the Controller on that day would be in interim or provisional order which shall have to give way to a final order to be made on further enquiry to be held later in the event of there being a dispute between the parties calling for such determination.

    13. The Hon'ble Supreme Court while summarising held that it will be for the tenant to pay or tender the amount provisionally assessed by the Controller on the first date of hearing of application of ejectment. On compliance, the controller has to proceed to adjudicate upon the controversy raised for decision by a reference to the pleadings of the parties and by holding a summary enquiry for the purpose and such adjudication shall be provisional and subject to later final adjudication". The Court has foreseen three situations which may arise i.e. (i) the rent ultimately found to be due and payable was the same as under the provisional order; (ii) is less than what was determined by the provisional order; or (iii) more than what is held to be due and payable by the provisional order. It was held that in first situation, the proceedings would be terminated. In the second, the Rent Controller may direct the amount deposited in excess by the tenant to be refunded to him and in the third situation, the tenant should be provided one opportunity and a reasonable time for depositing the amount of deficit failing which, he shall be liable to be evicted. The consequences of the tenant not depositing the rent assessed provisionally, was not the issue arising in the said case.

    14. The Rent Controller can pass an order of eviction only after giving the tenant a reasonable opportunity of showing cause against the application. The relevant provisions of Section 13(1) and (2) of the Haryana Urban (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973 read as under:-

    Eviction of Tenants:- (1) A tenant in possession of a building or a rented land shall not be evicted therefrom except in accordance with the provisions of this section.

    (2) A landlord who seeks to evict his tenant shall apply to the Controller, for direction in that behalf. If the Controller, after giving the tenant a reasonable opportunity of showing cause against the application, is satisfied-

    (i) that the tenant has not paid or tendered the rent due from him in respect of the building or rented land within fifteen days after the expiry of the time fixed in the agreement of tenancy with his landlord or in the absence of any such agreement, by the last day of the month next following that for which the rent is payable:

    Provided that if the tenant, within a period of fifteen days of the first hearing of the application for ejectment after due service, pays or tenders the arrears of rent and interest, to be calculated by the Controller, at eight per centum per annum on such arrears together with such costs of the application, if any, as may be allowed by the Controller, the tenant shall be deemed to have duly paid or tendered the rent within the time aforesaid;

    Provided further that the landlord shall not be entitled to claim arrears of rent for a period exceeding three years immediately preceding the date of application under the provisions of this Act.

    15. If the interpretation sought to be raised by the respondent on the basis of the reading of the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court is to be accepted, that will negate the grant of reasonable opportunity contemplated to the tenant in terms of Section 13(2) of the Act. Without any written statement, document or evidence, an order of ejectment would be passed against the tenant merely because an ad-interim order has not been complied with. The said interpretation would in fact mean the interim order to be the final order itself. The background in which the Hon'ble Supreme Court has passed the order, leave no manner of doubt that it wanted to provide protection to the tenant from eviction on account of non-payment of arrears of rent, if there is a bona fide' dispute as the tenant is not entitled to any other opportunity after the determination of the said lis. The judgment contemplates providing protection to the tenant against the unscrupulous landlords.

    16. The conclusion No. 4 as drawn by the Hon'ble Supreme Court cannot be read in isolation. The same has to be read in view of the discussion in the preceding paragraphs and in conjunction with the Conclusion Nos. 5 and 6. Conclusion Nos. 4, 5 and 6 read as under:-

    4. On the failure of the tenant to comply, nothing remains to be done and an order for eviction shall follow. If the tenant makes compliance, the inquiry1 shall continue for finally adjudicating upon the dispute as to the arrears of rent in the light of the contending pleas raised by the landlord and the tenant before the Controller.

    (5) If the final adjudication by the Controller be at variance with his interim or provisional order passed under the proviso, one of the following two orders may be made depending on the facts situation of a given case. If the amount deposited by the tenant is found to be in excess, the Controller may direct a refund. If on the other hand, the amount deposited by the tenant is found to be short or deficient, the Controller may pass a conditional order directing tenant to place the landlord in possession of the premises by giving a reasonable time to the tenant to place the landlord in possession of the premises by giving a reasonable time to the tenant for paying or tendering the deficit amount/failing which alone he shall be liable to be evicted. Compliance shall save him from eviction.

    (6) While exercising discretion for affording the tenant an opportunity of making good the deficit, one of the relevant factors to be taken into consideration by the Controller would be, whether the tenant has paid or tendered with substantial regularity the rent falling due month by month during the pendency of the proceedings.

    17. The Supreme Court has provided another opportunity to the tenant to tender arrears of rent after determination of question relating to rent with a view to avoid hardship to the tenant. The conclusion No. 4 to the effect that nothing remains to be done and order of eviction shall follow has to be interpreted keeping in view the provisions of Section 13(2) of the Act, which contemplates that an order of eviction can be passed after giving reasonable opportunity of show cause against the application. Still further, Conclusion No. 5, contemplated that if the amount deposited by the tenant is short or deficient, the Rent Controller may pass a conditional order directing the tenant to place landlord in possession of the premises qua the rent provisionally assessed by the Rent Controller. Still further Conclusion No. 6 contemplates an opportunity to the tenant to make good the deficiency.

    18. After harmoniously construing Conclusion Nos. 4, 5 and 6, I am of the opinion that the failure to deposit provisional rent assessed will not entail passing of the eviction order. The eviction order can be passed only after conclusion of the trial after giving opportunities or hearing to the parties as required under Section 13(2) of the Act. If, however, the final order of the Rent Controller is in terms of the provisional rent assessed, the tenant is not entitled to any other opportunity to tender rent as he has failed to comply with the order of provisional assessment of rent. But in case, in the final order passed by the Rent Controller, rent determined is less than the order of provisional assessment of rent, the tenant would be entitled to another opportunity to make up the deficiency in respect of such arrears of rent. However, if the amount tendered is in excess, the tenant is entitled to refund. The above conclusion alone would be in tune with the principles of law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. It is preposterous to say' that on failure of payment of provisional rent i.e. ad-interim order, the eviction order shall follow without giving a reasonable opportunity to the tenant to controvert the stand of the landlord on the basis of evidence led that such provisional rent was not correctly assessed.

    19. Therefore, the order of eviction passed by the learned Rent Controller and affirmed by the learned Appellate Authority without giving any opportunity to contest the petition by filing written statement and to lead evidence cannot be sustained.

    20. Consequently, impugned orders are set aside. The matter is remanded to the learned Rent Controller to decide the petition for eviction on merits after providing opportunities to the tenant to file reply and after granting opportunities to lead evidence on the issues arising out of the pleadings of the parties.

    21. Civil Revision stands allowed in the above terms.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajinder Lal v. Gopal Krishan
    (Mar 31, 2006)